r/mrballen • • Jul 27 '24

Discussion Please stop fictionalizing people's experiences, especially victims'

77 Upvotes

There is only one thing about Mr. B's storytelling that that I have beef with, and the more I hear it the less I want to listen to the next story. -That is creating a 'POV' narrative that literally cannot exist, either because the person died before ever speaking to anyone else ever again, or they were a killer and never gave so many details about their acts or their inner thoughts.

Most recent example -the one about Shelly, killed in her bed. He described her thinking about her social life becoming too much and how she wanted to break up with her boyfriend. -Yeah it turned out she HAD talked to her mom about that sometime before, and sure it sets up suspense about whether it was Nathan who killed her. But nobody has the right to make up her LAST THOUGHTS ON EARTH like that, just for entertainment. And just imagine you're Nathan and hearing that! For all anyone knows, she decided to stay with Nathan after talking to her mom and before being killed.

But that's just one of many examples. Frankly it's not only distasteful, it's a cheap way to literally trick an audience. If keep wishing he would stop doing it, but I suppose his overwhelming amount of 100% approving fans far outweighs any disapproval.


r/mrballen • • Feb 11 '23

Why did MrBallen accept a Draftkings Sponsorship?

1 Upvotes

Was anyone else kinda disappointed to see mrballen do a silly Billy Mays-ish style ad for draftkings in the middle of covering a really tragic story? it just seemed rather tasteless to put a goofy ad for a scummy gambling app right in the middle of such a serious story like that. It would have been a bit better if the ad was placed at the beginning or the end of the video but I'm still surprised that he decided to promote this app to his fans. the video in question is "You might want to think twice about skydiving (*DISTRESSING CONTENT*)"


r/mrballen • • Oct 12 '24

Podcast Discussion Once I noticed, I can't unnotice it

4 Upvotes

I am a huge fan of true crime, and I usually already know the stories he releases, but I enjoy the narrated story-like presentation, and it's a nice change from the highly detailed gory style of podcast I listen to.

BUT! It really irritates me how often the word "totally" is used.

"totally crazy" "totally ruined" "totally overwhelmed" "totally dark"

It has become so irritating because I now can't unnotice it!

Also, "all of the sudden" gets me irked too

I just had to say this. I really like MrBallens podcast (and youtube videos) but I just had to get this off my chest!!


r/mrballen • • Mar 16 '23

Ask Ballen I hate that he moved his podcast to Amazon behind a paywall. I understand everyone needs to make money, but his YT channel and sponsorships seems more than adequate income. Why can’t the podcast be streamed on a free platform like Apple or Spotify? So disappointing.

0 Upvotes

edit Guys, I love MrBallen and don’t blame him for getting money, I’m just expressing my opinion to open a conversation about it. A majority of the YouTubers who do podcasts, hell, even non-YouTuber podcasts, you can stream for free. Ballen has 7.35 million followers on YT, a merch line, and a fair amount of sponsors. It would be foolish to say he doesn’t have a pretty income. The paywall just sucks and I’m sure he had a reason for it but I’m just expressing my thoughts as a fan. Which… is exactly what this subreddit is for. But for real, no harm, no foul. I love Mr Ballen and hate the like button forever.


r/mrballen • • Nov 20 '25

Ask Ballen Annoyed

0 Upvotes

I think like many others I came to Reddit to see what was going on with missed episodes of the Mr. Ballen podcast(s). I’ve been a dedicated listener and supporter since day one and it has been great to watch him grow. HOWEVER, it is frustrating and concerning to stop getting episodes and to get constant re-runs without anything being said. It doesn’t seem normal… every other podcast I listen to who has moved away from Wondery has made several announcements on their final episodes with Wondery about the move. Did I miss something? Even going on his website I had to dig to get to a news article by the Hollywood Reporter to see that he moved to Sirius.
The lack of communication with his very committed and supportive audience is frustrating. Is this guy okay?


r/mrballen • • Oct 14 '23

Discussion I’m just gunna say it…

0 Upvotes

…I love Mr. Ballen. HOWEVER…his excessive use of the word “BUT” or maybe the way he says it? It drives me nuts. Am I the only one who has noticed this?


r/mrballen • • Jul 24 '26

Discussion Can’t believe Mr Ballen is selling out with fake stories

Post image
3 Upvotes

Alright so listening to this story it’s the usual as expected from John until I start catching on to the fact that the premise of this story is ripped out of Urban legend. When a couple are in their car and one of them leaves but doesn’t come back while the person in the car starts hearing scratching and tapping on the roof. Instead of someone hanging above the car they’ve replaced it with a crazy woman on top of the car eating her husbands head proceeding to get away from police being shot at point blank range along with the husbands body never being found. What makes this even worse is this image they shared which doesn’t remotely make sense, it’s 1970s and there is a random camera in the middle of nowhere getting everything in shot, a car in the image that’s certainly not from the 60s or 70s while the “woman” idk looks like ai chose to create a wizard instead standing at a height over 7ft. And just a little cherry on top this couple were said to be coming back from a casino but during this time period there was only 1 casino is all of Malaysia.


r/mrballen • • Jan 12 '26

Discussion Neck wound?

2 Upvotes

Sorry if this is old news…I’ve been listening to MrBallen for years, and a couple months ago I noticed the large wound on MrBallen’s neck during a video. Didn’t think anything of it until watching the newest video today and noticed it’s still not healed. Not trying to be nosy or pry, just wondering if he’s addressed it or if anyone knows what happened. Hoping everything is good and that it’s not medical related.


r/mrballen • • Feb 05 '23

A curse upon MrBallen's house for using BetterHelp as a sponsor!

1 Upvotes

r/mrballen • • Jan 03 '23

FYI Dudleytown video is full of crock

0 Upvotes

http://cornwallhistoricalsociety.blogspot.com/2014/09/the-truth-about-dudleytown.html

Once again Mrballen makes a super heavy supernatural-biased video without explaining any of the context behind the lives of the normal people who live there. Sounds like the whole Dudleytown "insanity" was just a load of crock. I found this page in 2 seconds so I'm assuming u/johnballen416 did also and just decided to not mention it ^^


r/mrballen • • Oct 13 '21

Memes / jokes Dylatov Pass? Didn't they have spelling classes in the Navy?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/mrballen • • Mar 31 '24

Discussion Today’s video..

15 Upvotes

Anyone else find today’s video extremely underwhelming? The first story was so short that it seemed tacked on just to make the overall video longer (and really wasn’t very strange, dark, or mysterious as much as sad). And the second story, having only one real photo included (of the doctor), felt like a medical mysteries podcast episode.

Also, and this is more of an observation about all his videos in general lately, it seems like he’s been adding all the extra little details to the story that he couldn’t possibly know— the scene-setting details that he adds for the podcats— and I really kind of hate it. For an audio presentation, it’s more “acceptable,” as you’re having to use your imagination and picture everything yourself, so, while they may not be factual, they can help a little bit. But for the YT videos, I just think they have no place. I don’t find the stories to now be non-credible, per se, but they’re feeling a lot less “real” now.


r/mrballen • • Mar 03 '22

Story Suggestions The dyatlov pass incident story suggestion

0 Upvotes

I hope you can do a story about the dyatlov incident. Nine hikers were found under strange circumstances and with unexplainable injuries. Nobody knows how they dead and how they ended up with these weird injuries.Wikipedia page about this case


r/mrballen • • Sep 28 '22

Story Suggestions TikTok credit: Faunalia

21 Upvotes

r/mrballen • • Jan 14 '24

Discussion Annoying

0 Upvotes

I can't be the only one who is annoyed by the seagull lung interruptions with the ad for the sponsor


r/mrballen • • Nov 07 '25

Discussion Why?!

0 Upvotes

Erm.. I've had a look k over the sub and there's nothing... Ehhhh...

Why is nobody taking about the fact there was no podcast tonight??


r/mrballen • • Aug 09 '22

Ask Ballen Ballen, you’re really stretching these stories nowadays and there isn’t even necessarily a twist: Spoiler

0 Upvotes

r/mrballen • • Sep 06 '26

Real Mr.Ballen Reply So..... Anybody else notice the missing wedding ring???

1 Upvotes

Just watched his most recent video and couldn't help but notice the missing wedding ring. No, I wasn't looking for it, but I always notice it because he talks with his hands. Anyway.... I just wondered what was up🤔😊


r/mrballen • • Aug 24 '26

Like Button So today, what we're going to do to the Like button...

1 Upvotes

Is nothing. Absolutely. Nothing.

And That, will send it into it's next panic.

Edit: Has anyone ever seen the sitcom Comunity? Specifically Ken Jeong's character? Maybe Im reading too far into it, but thats what I thought we were doing in the "Gay" comment 😅 It's from the show. Yall chill, plz.


r/mrballen • • Mar 08 '25

Discussion Again, tired of recycled stories

18 Upvotes

Took me about 30 seconds before realizing today’s first story was about Fred Smith, founder of FedEx. Two weeks ago it was the Menhaz kid. I’ve heard the recent stories tons of times other places and I have a chip on my shoulder about it. Strange, dark, and mysterious content is not all I watch. It’s a small fraction of what I consume. I don’t understand why they’re choosing stories that have been told numerous times before. I’d rather have less shock factor because it’s a less hard- hitting story than none at all because I’ve heard it 3 times before it gets to MrBallen. Just frustrating.


r/mrballen • • Apr 20 '26

Discussion Does anyone else find the four uploads a week a total disappointment?

21 Upvotes

I was very excited three months ago when he announced he would be uploading up to four times a week. However the excitement has worn out by this point for me. I cannot speak to the book or the tours, and I understand that John is putting most of his personal effort into those projects, which I find is a good way to branch out.

The videos that he has been pushing out now have been a total disappointment, though. Foremost is the fact that none of these uploads are new videos. They’re all from some random podcasts he used to do before, but which he has now abandoned. For me, they are technically new since I haven’t heard them before. But now, a couple of months in, I can say they’re all the same basically in terms of plot. There’s just a lot of yapping about random backstories, possible suspects, and, of course, the slow reveal at the end. I can easily believe they’re from the podcast since they are so drawn out, as you would guess in a true crime podcast.

Another thing that weirds me out is that he has a massive team behind the scenes now:
Host & Executive Producer:  MrBallen
Head of Writing:  Evan Allen
Producers:  Jeremy Bohn & Cole Locascio
Production Supervision:  Samantha Collins
Research & Fact-Checking:  Shelly Xu, Camille Callahan, & Evan Beamer
Research & Fact-Checking Supervision:  Steve Annear
Video Editor:  Jordan Stidham
Thumbnails by:  Jessica Clogston-Kiner & Robin Vane
Production Support:  Antonio Manata & DeLaynna Corley

Do you need this many people to recycle already used content? I am aware that there is one new video a week, the same as before. And that is okay, even one new video per week is good. But he promised to go: “old school”. And this isn’t going to be old school at all with the recycled content and a massive team pouring hours to produce a single new video.


r/mrballen • • Jan 28 '25

Art/ Original Content I lied to you guys about the hat

0 Upvotes

Sorry @Less_Veterinarian_95 for lying to you


r/mrballen • • May 12 '22

Russian Invasion of Ukraine is Strange Dark and Mysterious

2 Upvotes

It would be awesome to hear you tell some of the stories. Im sure you could get access to details of Ukrainian heroes and Russian villains. Use maps and pictures to show whats going on.


r/mrballen • • Jan 09 '25

Discussion Change name of podcast?

2 Upvotes

Do you think he should just rename the "Mr. Ballen Podcast" to "Mr. Ballen: True Crime?"

Just for some truth in advertising. In general, his main podcast isn't all that "strange, dark and mysterious". It is just another true crime podcast but with Mr. Ballen's story telling flair.

I actually like Medical Mysteries more as they are "strange, dark, and mysterious" stories like some of his old YouTube content.

Thoughts?


r/mrballen • • Mar 31 '26

Discussion I’ve been so disappointed lately

8 Upvotes

I don’t know how I can put it nicely or not sound rude but episodes lately have just been so disappointing. There really is nothing interesting about true crime stories where a husband kills his wife. There’s no suspense. You absolutely know who did it right off the bat. There’s nothing mysterious about it. True crime is only interesting if it has some sort of strange element to it or if there’s a true reveal at the end. I really don’t understand why Mr. Ballen is allowing his show to become substandard. It’s like the episode is stretched out with a lot of filler in insignificant details and then you have so many ads that it’s even more frustrating. I really wish that he would go back to telling shorter stories but more of them if they’re more interesting. Like the places you can’t go but people who went there anyway. Trying to stretch out one boring story just isn’t good for anyone. It really is disappointing to me because this was my favorite podcast, but I’m quickly losing interest. Please go back to actually telling strange, dark and mysterious stories.!!