r/movingtoNYC • • Aug 23 '26

Had a ridiculously hard time in NYC, so I’m leaving

1.1k Upvotes

I only lasted 7 months. I had lived in DC during my 20s and visited NYC a ton and always wanted to live here. It was always so fun, I’d go out and meet tons of interesting people and have adventures. I thought I’d enjoy the arts scene, the creativity, the weirdness of the city.

I moved here in March after spending most of last year in Mexico and pretty much hated it from the start. First off, living here is totally different from visiting - it’s so much harder. Everything simple is difficult, from ordering furniture (I live in a 4th floor walkup) to buying groceries (aside from the insane prices, there seems to always be a line) to my commute with work (it’s always packed, or the train isn’t running on time). Everything costs way more than I even realized. The free stuff always has crowds. A lot of the good paid stuff has crowds! It also just feels like a different city than it was when I was in my 20s - more homogeneous, more intense. I grew up in downtown Chicago so I’m not unfamiliar with big cities, but this is on a different level.

And I’ve had such a fucking hard time making friends. People meet once, or flake on drinks, or reschedule half a dozen times. I’ve tried talking to people at bars but they always seem to have other shit going on. I’ve also never been to a city where so many people just constantly had their heads in their phones.

I also think I’ve experienced culture shock because the atmosphere is so different from Mexico, where everything was way more laid back and easy, and people were really welcoming. It was much easier to make friends and a much calmer pace of life. I also miss nature and space and quiet and not feeling like everyone’s on top of each other all the damn time.

I think some of this is also my age. I’m in my mid 30s, and I just don’t find partying all night or going to the hottest restaurant particularly attractive anymore.

I’m sure if I stuck it out for a bit longer I could eventually make it work. But it’s just not worth it. I can’t for the life of me figure out why everyone’s paying such a damn premium to live here when life is also exponentially more difficult here than most other places you could choose to live.

I don’t regret it - living here has been a bucket list item for me for years. But I’m so ready to go.

I leave on Sunday. I’m actually going back to Mexico. I appreciate this subreddit - it helped a lot when I was figuring out my move. Just wanted to give my honest accounting for those thinking of doing the same.

ETA: Lol y’all are absolutely NUTS and the angry people commenting on this post are giving New Yorkers a bad name. I always loved New Yorkers - my mom is one, she was born here, lived her childhood here, grew up in the Hudson Valley and moved back for her 20s and early 30s. Every time I visited in my 20s I had great interactions with New Yorkers on the street or at bars. But since moving here I’ve experienced an incredible amount of rudeness and coldness. No, it’s definitely not all New Yorkers, but this post suggests it’s more New Yorkers than you’d think. For whoever sent me a Reddit cares notification, Jesus Christ get off Reddit and enjoy the city you love so much!.


r/movingtoNYC • • Aug 28 '26

You balling in NYC?

Post image
680 Upvotes

So at least 10k of y’all active users gotta be millionaires am i right ighttt


r/movingtoNYC • • Jun 06 '26

Not surprised that Bushwick is getting whole foods now. Last night walk around jefftown

Thumbnail
gallery
562 Upvotes

r/movingtoNYC • • Apr 29 '26

People say you need a high salary to live in NYC, yet service workers live in NYC. What is the disconnect here?

500 Upvotes

I just don’t understand why everyone says you need so much money to live in NYC (like 80K+) yet there are many areas full of service workers. Are we just completely ignoring those areas? Are we speaking about a quality of life that isn’t normal for most Americans? I can’t imagine that everyone is NYC is making tons of money and I also can’t imagine that everyone who isn’t are just living miserable lives so what’s going on?


r/movingtoNYC • • Oct 07 '26

Want to relocate to NYC over 50.

462 Upvotes

​

First let me say that I absolutely LOVE New York! The energy of the city, the people, the food, plays, parks, museums, fashion, small jazz clubs, corner bodegas… I could go on. There’s very little about the city that I don’t love. Only the cost of living has kept me away. Every single time I’ve visited I’ve had the most wonderful experiences. Recently I’ve wanted to move there more than ever. Tired of living in Texas. I’ve raised two sons who are now in their early 20s. My son recently started grad school at Columbia and I spent the week getting him settled into his apartment and walking all over Harlem, riding the subway and just falling in love with the vibe of the city all over again. I’m in my late 50s, my other son has special needs but I want to live in a vibrant walking city. I would have to find a new job or I can consult. I’ve been in Tech as a Sr. UX Designer all of my career. I love helping people and mentoring young people. I don’t need much to be happy, literally can find joy in anything. I have a few friends and family members that live in the city that are struggling. I would sell my home here and car after my son completes his degree in a year and a half before I would move. I still want to be sure he has some financial support before I leave my current job. I would also secure a new position before I leave. That’s just how I’m wired. I’m wondering if it’s late to move from Texas to NYC at this time in my life. I see a lot of 20-something’s moving. I take really great care of myself and I feel strong and so happy. I feel I would thrive there after spending most of my life in the South. I welcome any advice or comments. Sincerely, Ready for a midlife change

Update: Thank you for all of the wonderful and encouraging messages I’ve received on this post. It’s been overwhelming, in a really great way. I am planning and am so excited! My sister lived in NY for over 20 years. I visited very often while she lived there. I drove her there from Texas in her little Honda. So my love affair with the city goes back a ways. I lost my husband to a car accident when my sons were little so Texas seemed like a great place to raise them. I did consider moving to NY after his death but decided to stay put. Now that I’ve raised them it’s time to do what would make me happy. Thank you again to all of the beautiful people who responded with advice and comments. I’m overflowing with joy!❤️


r/movingtoNYC • • Sep 16 '25

A heads up: most “luxury” apartments in NYC aren’t worth the hype at all

435 Upvotes

If you’re planning to move to NYC, you’re bound to see a ton of listings labeled as “luxury” apartments. Just be careful. Most of the time, that word is pure marketing.

Here’s what “luxury” really usually means in NYC:

- A doorman, maybe a package room.

- A small gym with two treadmills and a bike.

- A rooftop or lounge that looks nice in photos but is often packed or barely used.

What it doesn’t mean: better construction. Most of these places have paper thin walls, super high rents, and appliances that break down like anywhere else. You’re basically paying thousands extra for branding and a fancy lobby.

If you’re moving here, please weigh whether those “amenities” are actually worth the premium. For a lot of people, a solid prewar building or a well maintained walk up will give you a better living experience without the unnecessary markup. I know I'm talking facts here so if I'm wrong, please tell me why.


r/movingtoNYC • • Oct 15 '26

People that say 200K isn't enough to live comfortably on. How???

374 Upvotes

The amount of times I've seen people's salary expectations for a comfortable life in the city > 300k is just crazy, and in my experience does not line up with reality at all.

Some stats:

  • Income of about 220K, wife is mostly SAHM with some part time work (Makes like 20K a year so 240K total)

  • I live in the most bougie Brooklyn neighborhood one block from Mccarren Park

  • Two small kids, one is public school with expensive after school care, one about to go to daycare

  • Small 2 bedroom (3150 rent)

  • Max out my retirement accounts, put about 1k in brokerage accounts every month

  • I'm DEFINITELY not rich, but middle class enough to where I don't really think about bills/medical expenses/random stuff

  • No debt of any kind

I definitely have some compromises though

  • No car (but don't need one)

  • Small apartment, kids share a bedroom. This is the one I really wish was different, but we want to stay in Greenpoint/WB and rents have gotten crazy so any comparable apt is like 1K more now.

  • On account of the kids, we don't go out to dinner often/never Uber. But we are cafe/pastry crazy so treat ourselves most days - get multiple cold brews a day

So all in all, I feel like I live a fairly cushy life supporting two kids/wife while what seems to be the BASELINE minimum salary required by folks here to not be miserable? Is my case unique and am I benefiting from a lowish rent/no car? Am I actually just miserable and I don't know any better?

EDIT:

There's a lot of comments here lol. Some additional context:

We moved into the apartment at the height of Covid - so definitely a covid deal. I was in Astoria before that.

I work at a healthcare institution and get free healthcare essentially, no deductibles/copays/lots of other benefits.

I forgot to mention the 529/TRUMP accounts that I also put money into

Williamsburg is not the most bougie, agreed lol. but definitely is bougie :)

On the no debt, i got super lucky that my parents paid fully for college (though zero other financial assistance otherwise).

I definitely could be saving more.

I guess what I was just trying to say is that I'm not miserable. I LOVE living in Brooklyn, love the city as a whole, and love raising kids here. Prior to kids I went out like crazy (although made less money at the time as well) I never WANT to leave but know realistically we probably will in a few years because I want the kids to have more access to sports/programs that don't cost a million dollars.


r/movingtoNYC • • Mar 27 '26

Genuinely how are all these transplants affording to move here?

329 Upvotes

I get people who work in finance, consulting, etc. they are most likely earning salaries that can cover it. But I feel like a lot of people moving here work jobs like entry level roles in fields like marketing, PR etc. those definitely do not pay enough to afford rent etc.

I keep seeing statistics showing that you need to make $150k+ to live here. I don’t get it?


r/movingtoNYC • • Jun 21 '26

Did NYC always attract affluent transplants or is this more of a recent phenomenon?

321 Upvotes

When I was growing up, the stereotype was that people moved to NYC with a couple suitcases, a modest job, multiple roommates, and just figured things out as they went. The appeal was that NYC was where you went to build a career, not necessarily because you were already successful.

Nowadays, when I browse apartment groups, IG, and even this sub, it sometimes feels like a lot of transplants are already coming from relatively affluent backgrounds. I see people in their 20s willing to pay $3k+ for a room, signing leases quickly, working remote jobs with strong salaries, or having family support as a safety net.

Maybe that's just the internet skewing my perception, but...has NYC always attracted a disproportionately affluent transplant crowd or has that become more common over the last 10–20 years as housing costs have increased?

I always see a bunch of affluent kids from California or New Jersey moving here but rarely do you ever come across a middle class Joe from Oklahoma to start a new life in Manhattan.

Does the average transplant today seem different from the average transplant in the 2000s or early 2010s? Or is this something people have always said about NYC newcomers? Just curious.


r/movingtoNYC • • Jul 17 '26

I'm curious to hear from people who moved to NYC and then realized NYC is not for them

294 Upvotes

Did you stay? Move back? Why didn't you like it?


r/movingtoNYC • • Oct 01 '26

What is it like living here?

Post image
263 Upvotes

Midtown / close to
billionaires row & central park south


r/movingtoNYC • • Sep 23 '26

Is it worth moving to NYC at age 30?

261 Upvotes

I’m 29 and am stuck in Chicago for 1 more year. Great opportunity to put money aside because New York is expensive I make about 200k-250k a year.

I fell in love with New York back in 2017 and I’ve been going there every other year to visit ever since. And every time is the same. I can’t stop thinking about living there. There’s something just different and special about it. Im single no responsibilities like kids, a house , nothing.

For ppl who have pulled the trigger and just moved there. Is it worth it at age 30? Only thing holding me back is that I didn’t start making money till I was 27 and I’m way behind on investing..

I’d look into possibly Brooklyn or west village. Are there places that are nice and still in the city but less expensive?

Any advice would be great. I can feel it in my veins I need to live in NYC for a few years or else I’ll re


r/movingtoNYC • • Feb 14 '26 Heartwarming

To the people asking if they should move here..

258 Upvotes

some might find what I’m about to say super corny but….If you have the funds and/or have the type of job where you can easily get hired I say just do it. Try it for a year and if it’s not right, you can always leave, no shame in that. There’s always people on the NYCapartments sub looking for roommates. Yes you will see roaches, yes there’s garbage on the streets, yes you may get lonely sometimes, yes the subway will push you to your limit on certain days BUT when you have one of those perfect New York days… it will all be worth it. You will have access to some of the most amazing food, art, and culture in the world and unparalleled walkability (coming from a place that is nearly 100% car-dependent, this has changed my life). There is a potential adventure around every corner. JUST DO IT.

signed,

a random internet person who moved here 11 years ago on a semi whim.


r/movingtoNYC • • Aug 10 '26

People here getting upset when someone mentions they want to move somewhere “safe” is so dumb. Some parts of NYC are safer than other places and that’s OK.

246 Upvotes

Jeez, people here get so upset when out of towners put words like safe, not sketchy, etc in their description. Even as a guy whos lived here for my whole adulthood, there are places in NYC that i dont feel safe in. So lets not act like its such a big deal when someone wanting to move here mentions that they want to live somewhere SAFE. There are undesirable parts of NYC that would be FOUL to recommend someone to move there. Stop the act.


r/movingtoNYC • • Mar 06 '26

is it crazy to move to NYC for a receptionist role?

226 Upvotes

I (24F) graduated college about two years ago and spent a year abroad. When I came back, I lived with extended family in NYC while applying for jobs (full-time, part-time, seasonal), but I couldn’t land anything. Eventually I had to move back in with my parents in a rural area.

Recently, a temp agency reached out about a receptionist job in NYC paying $20/hr. If I take it, I’d stay with extended family again, so I wouldn’t have to worry about rent.

My family is very protective and doesn’t really want me to move away again, but honestly I feel like I’m wasting my 20s staying here. I don’t have any debt, and if I took the job I could probably save up to around $10k.

The issue is that it’s not the kind of job I was hoping for. I’d really like to work in marketing, and I had also been considering going to grad school partly to delay unemployment.

Now I’m wondering if it makes more sense to take this job and keep looking for better opportunities while working.

Does taking the receptionist job sound like a smart move, even if it’s not in my field?


r/movingtoNYC • • Aug 20 '25

Does anyone else notice how social circles in NYC are still very separated despite the diversity?

226 Upvotes

As cliche as it may sound...one of the things I love about New York = its racial/cultural diversity

You can walk down a single block and hear 20 different languages. But at the same time, I’ve noticed that when it comes to actual friend groups, people often stick with their own background.

Transplants usually hang out with other transplants. Asians tend to stick with other Asians. Same with Latinos, same with other groups. Even within work, school, or hobbies, it feels like people gravitate back to what’s familiar.

I’m not saying it’s necessarily bad since it’s obviously human nature to seek comfort and commonality. But I thought living here would mean more mixing across different cultures and identities, especially since NYC is known for being so diverse.

Is this just me projecting or is it actually a common experience?


r/movingtoNYC • • Mar 11 '26

NYC MOVER HERE — These are 7 factors that can make your move more expensive.

211 Upvotes

I own a moving company in NYC and after doing thousands of moves around the city I’ve noticed the same mistakes over and over that end up costing people more money than necessary.

Here are a few things that make a move more expensive than it needs to be:

  1. Not reserving the elevator If you’re moving in or out of a building with an elevator, reserve it with management. Waiting for elevators can add a lot of time.

  2. No parking for the moving truck If movers have to park far away, every trip takes longer. In NYC a short hallway walk vs. half a block can make a big difference.

  3. Underestimating how much stuff you have A one bedroom that isn’t packed ahead of time can easily turn into a 6–7 hour job.

  4. Last minute packing Movers can pack, but it slows the process down. Packing beforehand usually saves hours.

  5. Walk-up buildings Stairs are the biggest factor in NYC moves. A 4th floor walk-up can take twice as long as an elevator building.

  6. Moving at the end of the month The last few days of the month are the busiest days for movers in NYC. Prices and availability are usually tighter.

  7. Not labeling boxes When boxes aren’t labeled, everything slows down during unloading.

Just sharing some insight from the moving side of things. Happy to answer any questions about moving in NYC.


r/movingtoNYC • • Oct 16 '26

I visited NYC and now want to move there. Want to make sure I'm not romanticizing it. What's the reality?

208 Upvotes

I've lived all over the USA and multiple countries, but this was my first time in NYC. Big fan of the architecture, people, diversity (Chinatown right next to Little Italy!), accents and 2nd languages being spoken everywhere. My time here was the most fun I've had in years.

I'm in a high-paying field (big tech) where I could afford a comfortable life here. However, I want to lucid about the potential downsides that you don't see as a tourist. I came during pretty ideal weather (early October), and I believe the weather can actually be quite bad for a lot of the year. I've heard about problems with rats, garbage, etc.

If you had to sell me on not moving here, what would you tell me? Vice versa, what may I have missed that would make moving to NY even more appealing? Thanks in advance for the info.


r/movingtoNYC • • Aug 20 '26

WA to NY

Post image
200 Upvotes

Curious about living in new York - are there any servers or bartenders on this thread? How is rent and income, decent studios for 2k-2.3k monthly and working 40-50 hours a week?


r/movingtoNYC • • Jan 31 '26

Suburban guy dating a NYC girl. Is there a sane middle ground or am I cooked?

199 Upvotes

I'm about to turn 35 and currently have a girlfriend living in Queens. I'm from Jersey.

I’m very suburban coded. I’m used to space, quiet, and not paying luxury prices for things that used to be normal. I don’t really care about the arts, nightlife, or “being close to amazing food” (I eat like a raccoon with a routine and I’m fine with that).

My girlfriend, on the other hand, currently lives in Queens and wants to move into the city or Williamsburg. I’m in NJ and...I do not want that, at least not in the romanticized “tiny apartment + high rent + vibes” type of way.

The appeal of NYC for me would be more practical such as career proximity / density and convenience.

So I'd like to ask: is there a meet-in-the-middle version of this that doesn’t involve a shoebox apartment?

Are there neighborhoods (Queens/outer Brooklyn? NJ near PATH?) where a suburban-brained person could live with a city-brained partner and not resent it 6 months in?

Or would you say this is just a fundamental lifestyle mismatch and one of us is going to be unhappy no matter what?

Would appreciate honest answers from people who’ve navigated this exact dynamic.

Thanks.


r/movingtoNYC • • Jun 10 '26

Moving to NYC with nothing but belief in myself

198 Upvotes

I’m 25 and moving to NYC has been my dream for years.
For a long time it was just something I talked about, but over the last 2–3 years I’ve really started turning my life around. I went back to school and finished my associate’s degree, and I recently landed a job in Manhattan making $66k plus commission. This was actually my first week, and so far I can genuinely see myself staying with this company for a while (God willing).

I currently live in Connecticut, but I’m originally from Long Island. Every time I spend time in the city, it feels like home in a way nowhere else does. I love the energy, the people, the neighborhoods, and the feeling that something is always happening.

I know what the logical advice is going to be: stay put, get settled into the new job, build savings, improve my credit, and then move. The problem is that I’m tired of waiting. Part of me feels like I’ve already spent years waiting and preparing, and now I just want to take the leap and make the dream happen. Most of all, I BELIEVE in myself.

Here’s my situation:
25 years old
New job in Manhattan
$66k base salary + commission
About $3,000 in savings (Willing to relentlessly put more)
Credit is pretty rough
Open to roommates
Is it realistic to make a move to Brooklyn within the next 1–2 months, or am I underestimating how much money and stability I’ll need first?
Looking for honest advice from people who have actually made the move from a similar position.


r/movingtoNYC • • May 28 '26

things i wish i knew about apartment hunting before moving to nyc

193 Upvotes

moved here a few years ago and wasted the first few weeks doing it completely wrong, so figured i'd write down what i actually learned in case it helps someone about to make the jump.

the biggest thing: the great apartments rarely make it to streeteasy. the actual deals are lease takeovers and lease breaks - someone leaving early who needs to hand off their place fast.

by the time something hits a listing site its usually overpriced or at least market-priced (which days days feels overpriced anyways) - took me way too long to figure that out.

stuff that would've saved me time:

- get all your paperwork ready before you start touring. pay stubs, bank statements, ID, guarantor info if you need one. if you find a half decent deal it will be gone in hours. you have to be able to say yes on the spot and have everything you need to apply.

- look into rent stabilized buildings. landlord can only raise by a small % set each year (2-3% lately) so you're protected long term. rough rule: built before 1974 with 6+ units is usually stabilized

- double check if a place is rent controlled/stabilized before signing. i've had multiple friends whose landlords never told them and just raised the rent however they wanted year over year, which is illegal. you can look the building up yourself at https://amirentstabilized.com/

- lease takeovers are underrated. someone hands off their lease, often furnished, and you skip the guarantor/credit hurdle that screws over anyone without 2 years of us income history. i made a map of all takeovers (free, no login, updated daily) here: https://leaseswap.nyc/takeovers

- summer is peak demand and peak prices. you can get a noticeably better deal in winter, so if youre moving in the summer it can be worth doing a short sublet and signing a real lease once it cools down

- a few channels to skip: facebook group posts for apartments are like 90% scams in my experience. renthop has almost no original inventory and more scams than you'd expect, basically skippable. facebook marketplace is actually decent but more for finding roommates than apartments

- budget for the upfront cost being brutal. first month + deposit (and sometimes more) can mean 3x rent before you even move in. and this is actually way better than it was a year ago where you'd also have to account for broker fee

lmk if i missed anything!


r/movingtoNYC • • Oct 15 '26

Should I quit my current job to move to NYC?

187 Upvotes

I have a super comfy six figure job in a low cost of living area. We own our home, a nice little 3BR 2BA place I lucked into when my uncle was moving to Montana. I am married to the love of my life and we have two amazing kids, a dog, a cat and everybody actually gets along. We have chickens and grow our own tomatoes. My parents are close, my in-laws are actually awesome, everybody helps out. Wife (Susan) is also professionally satisfied, works remotely as a consultant, but for a firm that gives her time and space to be present for her own needs. We are living the dream.

But I am feeling the itch. I have been talking to Susan about uprooting everything. I have found a 1BR unit in a tenement building at the bottom of the gowanus canal for twice my current monthly paycheck. It seems steep but ever since I saw Macaulay Culkin interact with Donald Trump in Home Alone 2 I always knew that my dream was to live there. "A one bedroom is not enough space for our family" is a common Susan lament in our household, but in a pinch I figure we can just throw some pillows on the fire escape and the kids can sleep under the light-polluted sky when I am feeling frisky. We have looked into local schools and while our kids are not varianced into a school per se, it is a junkyard, and I feel like working there would teach them valuable life experience. I don't have a job lined up but I just figure since I would be so close to Time Square that relying on divine inspiration and serendipity would be a solid choice. The stars will align. What all do you think? Joseph Campbell said 'Jump' and I am inclined to agree.

/s

It feels like every other post is like this. Maybe this is a meta complaint, and every tenth post is something equally dripping with sarcasm.


r/movingtoNYC • • 12d ago Mindblown

I moved to NYC 6 months ago and I am miserable

184 Upvotes

Let me start this off by stating that prior to me moving I was visiting NYC every month because I thoroughly enjoyed it that much. I really thought I was in love with New York. Now since moving here I have been miserable. I can't make friends. I'm an introvert, neurodivergent and have social anxiety so going out alone and trying to make friends is very hard for me. Ive tried online chatting as well and it has gotten me nowhere but people who want to text about surface level shit and never make plans. (I real life can't do surface level.) 

 When I do go out alone, I guess I don't give off "come talk to me" vibes and not a soul speaks to me. I haven't found the best job yet. So financially I can't afford to just keep going out alone and doing random things in hopes of maybe meeting someone. I feel so alone here, and I want to enjoy what this place could offer. I will also add that I have been seeing someone since being here and It's been kind of rocky and we don't even do much. Maybe that's causing some of the sadness? I realize moving was my decision and only I am in charge of my happiness. maybe I just romanticized this place too much? Maybe I just have to be patient? I would love advice from someone on ways to maybe start to enjoy it better. Or give financially friendly solutions on how to make my time better. I've looked into taking random classes those are all 60$ plus. 

Also, before anyone adds "just go home". Yes, I know that and eventually will go home if all else fails. But where I was living at home, I was miserable for other reasons. So going "home" would put me right back into a box I took so long to finally get out of. I am naturally a homebody and always have been, but I guess I thought moving to New York would help that. I was wrong I barely leave unless it's for work. and I don't want it to be like that anymore. 


r/movingtoNYC • • Jun 29 '26

For the people moving

180 Upvotes

I would say New York is an amazing place. Im blessed to have grown up calling it home. But if you move to a place you should be mindful and not expect things to be tailored to you. For example someone moved into a neighborhood in bk which is known to be noisy and now almost every night there is a noise complaint. When yall walk you don’t have to take up the whole side walk , you don’t have to move like a snail either. Or even in the subways it’s a side to go up AND down you don’t have to all rush. it’s common curtsey and city speed. I would say it’s nice seeing people fall in love with the city. And make it their home. But just please be considerate it’s kinda annoying and it’s just ruining the vibe of things