r/morningsomewhere • u/LinkDude80 • 5h ago
Discussion The existence of the "non-canon" James Bond Film "Never Say Never Again" is part of the reason that Sony has the film rights to Spider-Man
The 1983 Bond film Never Say Never Again got a brief mention on yesterday's episode and I wanted to write this up because the complicated legal history around James Bond and Spider-Man is my favorite example of weird copyright disputes and unexpected knock-on effects in Hollywood.
In 1955, Ian Fleming sold the film rights to his first James Bond novel, Casino Royale, to producer Gregory Ratoff. That project stalled, but the growing popularity of the character prompted Fleming to sell the remaining book rights to producer Harry Saltzman who partnered with Albert R. "Cubby" Broccoli to create company Eon Productions. The pair signed a distribution deal with United Artists and produced the famous series of James Bond films we know today.
In 1961, Fleming, running out of ideas for his Bond novels, decided to adapt an unproduced screenplay titled Thunderball into a novel without the consent of cowriters Kevin McClory or Jack Whittingham. McClory and Whittingham sued, with the resulting settlement granting Fleming the rights to the Thunderball novel and McClory the film rights. The eventual 1965 film version of Thunderball includes elements from both the novel and the screenplay, with Eon Productions making a deal with McClory which credited him as producer with an agreement that he would not make another adaptation of Thunderball for 10 years.
In 1967, Casino Royale was adapted separately from the main franchise and without the involvement of Eon Productions, as a parody of the popular Bond franchise.
In 1983 McClory's screenplay would be adapted again into Never Say Never Again, which competed directly with the Roger Moore Bond film Octopussy.
The rights situation was complicated further when Columbia Pictures purchased McClory's screenplay and the film rights to 1967s Casino Royale while MGM acquired the rights to the rest of the Bond franchise.
Meanwhile, starting in the late 1970s Marvel Comics, was looking to adapt its popular Spider-Man series into a film. The film languished in development hell for over a decade with rights bouncing through a series of lawsuits, bankruptcies, and acquisitions between Cannon Films, Carolco Pictures, and 21st Century Film Corporation which ultimately resulted in both MGM and Sony, who now owned Columbia Pictures, owning various pieces of the film and distribution rights to Spider-Man.
The legal situation in the late 1990s was such that both MGM and Sony could both claim that they had the film rights to both Spider-Man and James Bond, with both threatening to produce competing films in the respective franchises. The issue was finally resolved in a landmark 1999 settlement in which Sony agreed to exchange the rights to the remaining James Bond material for MGMs ownership of the rights to Spider-Man.
Tl;Dr: The rights for James Bond and Spider-Man were both split up and acquired by competing studios who had to spend decades fighting it out in court until they decided to swap James Bond and Spider-Man with one another and let everyone move on with their franchises.