r/mormondebate • • Oct 14 '18

Mormonism and Islam have the same progenitor (the Devil)

1 Upvotes
  1. Both Mohammed and Joseph Smith claim they had a secret vision

  2. Both went into a secret/hideaway place. In contrast, Jesus did miracles in public.

  3. Both claim that Christian scripture is corrupted.

  4. Both claim they have a new revealed scripture.

  5. Both claim to be the greatest and final prophet of God.

  6. Both start sleeping with multiple women and children.

  7. Both promise multiple wives and wealth (Mohammed gets 20% of all booty, Joseph Smith's Kirtland bank).

  8. Both have theological flaws in their scripture (muslims call it abrogation, mormons call it "ongoing revelation"). In contrast, Jesus fulfilled (perfected) the Law, and did not change it.

  9. Both claim sexual paradises in Heaven.

  10. Joseph Smith started an army and called himself the second Mohammed.


r/mormondebate • • Nov 25 '18

Moon: Is Adultery a Fundamental Doctrine of Mormonism?

1 Upvotes

"Thou shall not commit adultery" is a commandment that Jesus Christ never revoked.  When someone asked him what a person must do to gain eternal life, he reiterated it as one among other commandments that must be followed (Matthew 19:16-19).

     But in this world where licentiousness and immorality knows no limits, the sin of adultery has become a tricky concept to define.  For example, if a man marries a woman but does not consummate the marriage in sexual intercourse with her, does he commit adultery if he divorces her and marries another woman instead?

     For some, the easy answer seem to be no. If he gets to divorce her, then he is free to remarry. It's obvious, isn't it? How else can it be? Few would actually bother to open the scriptures, if only to find out what Jesus might have to say on the matter.

     The Pharisees also came unto him, tempting him, and saying unto him, Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause? And he answered and said unto them, Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female, And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh? Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.

     They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away? He saith unto them, Moses because of the hardness of your hearts suffered you to put away your wives: but from the beginning it was not so. And I say unto you, Whosoever shall put away his wife, except it be for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth ADULTERY: and whoso marrieth her which is put away doth commit ADULTERY. (Matthew 9:3-9).

 

So from Jesus, we see two ways a man can commit adultery:

  1. If he divorces his wife and marries another.

  2. If he marries a woman divorced from another marriage.

     In both cases, it is the act of remarrying that causes the sin. If we go back to the question we asked above, and using what Jesus has explained as a foundation, the answer is not that hard to see.  Even if a man does not consummate his marriage in sexual intercourse, he commits adultery by the act of remarrying.

     It doesn't matter even if the parties involved have been legally divorced.  Remarriage is adultery.   Moses may have allowed the Israelites to divorce their spouses, but what God has joined together, no man can put asunder.  Even a legal divorce does not justify it.

     To put it another way, this is one doctrine where what Moses loosed on earth is not loosed in Heaven. In the eyes of God, the man and woman has become one flesh. This was the social order in the beginning long before Moses was born.

     Having this doctrine on marriage set straight by Jesus, how is adultery a fundamental teaching of Mormonism?

     Well, the so-called "new and everlasting covenant" of Mormon polygamy as laid out in D&C 132 is really nothing more than remarriage without the divorce. One can read the entire chapter and not find any reference to what Jesus defined as adultery in Matthew 19 (and also in Mark 10). Instead, it has plenty of references to Old Testament polygamy. If Joseph Smith was restoring lost or corrupted gospel truth, he wasn't correcting the false ideas on marriage promoted by the sectarians of his era. He was instead adding and multiplying to the same sectarian errors by ignoring Jesus.

     Let us now look at what the LDS church teaches about divorce and remarriage in the context of Mormon polygamy:

     "Church leaders recognized that plural marriages could be particularly difficult for women. Divorce was therefore available to women who were unhappy in their marriages; remarriage was also readily available." ('Plural Marriage and Families in Early Utah,' Gospel Essay from LDS.org)

     Divorce and remarriage were readily available to Mormon polygamists who are not happy with it.  (Divorce was reported to be rampant among them. Joseph Smith's first polygamous marriage to Fanny Alger, the first known Mormon celestial marriage, abruptly ended in divorce.) In other words adultery, as defined by Jesus as remarriage, was readily available to these serial adulterers. Thus, the Mormon solution is not to end the sin and the misery it brings by ending the adulterous practice that cause it, but to double down, and have more of the same. The Mormon solution to the sin of adultery is adultery.

     Mormon apologists at Fairmormon would justify this absurd perversity even further:

     Some members of the Church remarried without obtaining a formal legal divorce. Was this adultery? Remarriage without a formal, legal divorce was the norm for the period, especially on the frontier and among the poor. These were the legal realities faced by nineteenth century Americans. (https://www.fairmormon.org/answers/Mormonism_and_polygamy/Divorce_in_the_19th_century#cite_ref-1)

Is remarriage adultery?  If you listen to Mormon apologists, it isn't... because, hey, it's the normal thing to do at that time!  And, come on, this was the wild, wild west.... everyone was fetchin' poor!!! 

     But we ask: if remarriage without a formal and legal divorce was indeed the norm, then none of the Mormon polygamists like Joseph Smith would've hidden themselves in secrecy as they practiced it in Kirtland and Nauvoo. They would have flaunted themselves in public just as Brigham Young did in Utah. After all, what is Mormon polygamy but a man remarrying himself to different women without divorcing any of his previous wives?

     By defending polygamy with such silly justification for remarriage, apparently none of these apologists, like Joseph Smith their prophet, ever read what Jesus had to say on the subject. Or maybe the have, but they didn't like what they found since it didn't suit their purposes. As the Lord himself would say, Isaiah did prophesy correctly of these false teachers:

     "This people draweth nigh unto me with their mouth, and honoureth me with their lips; but their heart is far from me. But in vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men." (Matthew 15:8-9)


r/mormondebate • • Apr 18 '16

An Earnest Plea to Latter-day Saints

0 Upvotes

r/mormondebate • • Sep 09 '12

Star: Ex-Mormons, even though you no longer practice Mormonism, do you still believe the Gospel of Jesus Christ, or the principals of Mormonism?

0 Upvotes

Also, have you joined other religions, or have you turned to atheism?

Edit: And why do you feel its your duty to spread your unbelief. Basically, you've left the church. Why can't you leave it alone?

Edit 2: A better question is why do you promote views that many Mormons find heretical?


r/mormondebate • • May 08 '12

Star: The Book of Mormon appears to be factually false, according to all the evidence we have from archeology, genetics, linguistics, paleontology and Biology.

0 Upvotes

r/mormondebate • • Oct 09 '17

Sun: Is the President of either one of the teachers or the deacons the oldest one? What are some requirements to be the president of either one(apart from being baptized and being worthy)?

0 Upvotes

Sun: What are the requirements to be a President of either the Deacons or the Teachers?


r/mormondebate • • May 28 '13

What is the most laughable teaching in the church in your opinion?

0 Upvotes

r/mormondebate • • Apr 11 '18

If Mormons ever needed to open their minds to what is going on it is now!

6 Upvotes

On June 18th, 2017, I wrote to President Dieter Uchtdorf, Second Counselor in the First Presidency of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints in the sincere hope he might take the time to respond to several specific concerns I had about the truth claims of the Mormon Church.

President Uchtdorf was my choice because I viewed him as one of a few General Authorities that might have the intelligence, courage, and humility to answer my questions.

I had a colleague remark to me that Elder Uchtdorf would not personally address my concerns and in all likelihood would never even see my letter. Rather I should expect a form letter response from an underling or a missive from my Stake President.

Sadly, and it would seem predictably, that is just what happened. I did receive a rather terse ‘form-letter’ riposte from his secretary who also copied my Stake President.

Considering the age and the tenure the ‘Brethren,’ have enjoyed, they must all be painfully aware of the many problems, contradictions and inconsistencies that exist vis-à-vis the truth claims of the LDS Church, as well as the myriad accusations of corruption, dishonesty, profligacy, and immorality leveled at its founder Joseph Smith.

As well, considering the Church’s historic lack of openness, I would suspect they are privy to inculpatory documents and materials locked away in the First Presidency’s vault, never to see the light of day.

Occasionally I have heard an intrepid member muse, “Do you think they, that is, the general authorities, believe the LDS Church is true, or are they victims of self-delusion, avarice, the affluent lifestyle the Church provides them, or is about ego and an exaggerated sense of self-importance. Is it the ‘fortune in men’s eyes,‘ that drives them?”

The late Grant Palmer, author of, An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins spoke about several meetings he had with a general authority, who told him straight up that the apostles all learn within a year or two of being called that the Church is a fraud.

Did this fellow know what he was talking about, was he telling the truth?

There is no way for me to know if this fellow’s statement was correct. Perhaps he was deluded, had an ax to grind; was lying or mad as a March hare. He certainly wouldn’t be the first GA to be guilty of any or all of these adjectives.

But, having read Grant’s books on Jesus, having communicated with him and being aware of his service to the least among us – inmates in the Utah prison system; I don’t doubt that Grant Palmer was telling the truth.

In contrast, to the cynical view this story suggests, as a child, I met Hugh B. Brown, a man my father knew well and revered, whom he described as a man of God, a man without guile.

Although Elder Brown served as an Apostle and member of the First Presidency, he confessed to moments of doubt, as shown by the following letter to a friend going through a faith crisis:

“I was really glad to get your letter of October 25th, and I appreciate your confidence. The revelation of your mental and spiritual struggle does not come as a surprise, that the waters of your usual placid soul had become somewhat, roiled and disturbed.

Would you be surprised if I should tell you that I, too, have had periods of perplexity, uncertainty, and doubt; that I, too, have known the darkness, fogginess, and chill of the valley which lies between illuminated peaks of faith and confidence, and that only the memory of the hilltops along the road over which I have come coupled with the somewhat misty vision of others still ahead has given me the courage to plod on when I was tempted to “chuck it all,” to wrap myself in the comfortless blanket of doubt and selfcommiseration and just quit the field.

Well, I have had that experience. But this I can say positively, that each peak which I have climbed has seemed higher and more inspiring than the last, due at least in part, I think, to the dark background of the valley through which I came. Sharp contrasts are sometimes most revealing.

In view of the above admission, you will not expect an argument or a brief on faith in God and immortality. However, and I hope it may be so, a relating of some personal experiences and observations may give you a fellow-feeling and bring comfort, courage, hope, and faith may renew in you the spirit of adventure, of zest for the quest of truth.”

I find Elder Brown’s honesty not only refreshing but stirringly human. If this good man said he believed it to be true, I don’t doubt he truly believed it.

Nonetheless, putting this question aside for the moment, all is not well in Zion.

I suspect that there have never been so many people abandoning the LDS Church since 1838.

In a recent article by Jana K. Riess, a writer on American religion entitled, “The Next Mormon Research,” she indicates proportionately why members are leaving the LDS Church.

Her work shows 6% of respondents said they left the Church after discovering Joseph Smith translated the Book of Mormon by looking at a “magic stone” in his hat. Another 3% because of DNA evidence shows no Hebrew nexus with the aboriginal peoples of North America; but one-third, over 30%, reported that they left because they could not trust the leadership of the Church to tell the truth. Clearly the Church’s current raison d’être, fails on several fronts. One being they view openness, honesty and dialogue as real and present dangers and they see free discussion as dissent and something that must be suppressed. Their fear is reflected in such Orwellian avowals as,” Not everything that is true is useful,” and” It’s wrong to criticize the leaders of the Church, even if the criticism is true.”

Gordon Hinckley once said, and with a straight face, “We have nothing to hide, our history is an open book.”

Well, I have taken him at his word and opened that book, and I am troubled by what I find on its pages.

In this letter, I pose what, from my perspective, are the most significant questions and fundamental problems relating to the historicity of Mormonism, the Church’s foundational claims and the Joseph Smith story.

I have have tried to be fair and balanced, presenting the most intelligible rebuttals and remedies that FairMormon, the leading LDS apologetic organization has published vis-à-vis my interrogatories. It is my hope that this methodology might help others, like myself, who are experiencing honest doubts to discover what is true and what is false.

I have never had, nor do I now have any agenda beyond a genuine search for knowledge, nor am I animated by any of the motivations that Mormons jump to when someone begins to question.

  1. Someone gave offense: No one hurt me, I love and respect my friends and family many of whom are committed members.

  2. A desire to sin: I am 71 years old, so it’s a little late for that!

  3. Never had a testimony in the first place: Wrong again, I would not have served in various callings, paid my tithing and attended the temple if I had never believed?

  4. Lazy, not reading the scriptures: I love the Bible, and I read it often; admittedly the Book of Mormon, not so much.

  5. Seduced by anti-Mormon literature: Hardly, it is easy to identify those who hate and those whose purpose is to destroy. I would not consider the work of Richard Bushman, Thomas Stuart Ferguson, Fawn Brodie, B. H. Roberts, Dan Vogel or Grant Palmer however anti-Mormon simply because they have the courage to question.

I wish the Church to be true for what an amazing and beautiful future it portends. To be forever together with loved ones, to walk with the Savior and grow, learn and progress forever.

But wishing does not make it so. No matter how appealing this ‘Plan of Salvation’ is, above all be must be real, a design formed by Deity and not merely the musing of a brilliantly creative ploughboy prophet.

There is a wonderful allegory in Book Seven of Plato’s The Republic often referred to as ‘Plato’s Cave.’ It tells the story of men held prisoner, chained and shackled such that they cannot look to their left, their right or most importantly behind themselves, rather they can only see forward at the wall directly in front.

Behind them is a blazing fire and between them and the fire a corridor along which men walk carrying statues, tools and other large objects. All that the prisoners can see however, is the shadows of the objects that are projected on the cave wall in front of them.

Some older prisoners, ‘the elders,’ have developed explanations as to what these shadows represent; what their meaning is.

One day, a prisoner is released. Now free to wander the cave, he sees the fire, and objects carried in front of it. This former prisoner comes to understand the origins of the shadows, and to his amazement, he sees that the shadows were often misinterpreted. He hurries back to share with his fellow prisoners the true meaning of the shadows, what the truth is. But rather than welcome and embrace this new knowledge, his former friends ridiculed him, particularly the elders, who even seek to take his life.

Finally, the freed prisoner is let out of the cave into the world beyond, a world filled with radiant sunshine where he can now see the fullness of reality illuminated by the brilliance of the sun.

You and I are like those prisoners. We see as it says in Corinthians, through a glass darkly. We live in a world where, like the prisoners, our knowledge is imperfect; a world of conjecture and illusion.

Some elders presume to know what the shadows mean, but they too are prisoners, and their shackles are as firmly in place as is our own. I don’t presume to be that prisoner freed from his chains who now longs to share the truth as only he can see it. I am a fellow prisoner, viewing the shapes and shadows on the wall, but seeking the truth by asking those questions that ‘the elders’ hope the prisoners dare not ask.

We will all leave the cave one day and will discover in that day, as we enter that new world filled with the dazzling brightness of truth that our lives have been spent wisely engaged in a correct and worthy cause, or that we have been credulous fools, desiring so much to feel good about our present and our future, to feel safe, that we had sadly become victims of an attractive fraud.

I hope that this letter and the research supporting it might provide greater clarity regarding the shadows that animate our actions and beliefs. I hope that at least it will show that there are alternative interpretations to those presented by the ‘elders.’

This study may well strengthen your testimony as you face the greatest problems with the current LDS narrative and come to more fully embrace the explanations and rationalizations proffered by the Church and her apologists as being altogether reasonable.

Or it might lead you to a place where you discover that perhaps your knowledge and the breath of your understanding based on what you have been taught is far less than perfect or complete. That there is more to the story.

In either case what a fascinating story it is.

But let me end this preface with a warning.

So, read on at your peril, because once the toothpaste is out of the tube, you will never get it back in again.

“… convince us of our errors of doctrine, if we have any, by reason, by logical argument, or by the word of God, and we will be ever grateful for the information, and you will have the pleasing reflection that you have been instruments in the hands of God for redeeming your fellow beings from the darkness which you may see enveloping their minds.”

Apostle Orson Pratt,

As you say, Orson. I have asked many questions in my ‘A Letter to an Apostle’ that as Orson says. ‘by reason and logic’ are difficult to reconcile.

I am not asking out of ignorance. I have diligently sought out, explored, researched and thoroughly investigated each of the concerns and difficulties that are at issue for me. I have sought out the most recent, reliable and comprehensive material related to each of my interrogatories. I have also endeavored to provide only facts and verifiable data rather than opinions and testimonies.

Most of the facts I quote as well as the commentaries I reference come from Church-friendly sources, LDS historical documents, Church newspapers and magazines, the Journal of Discourses, Lectures on Faith, the History of the Church. I have also gone to the letters of learned and even some not so learned Church leaders, and, of course, the Scriptures themselves.

The rest has been garnered from serious and often meticulous research conducted by many of the world’s leading scholars in several scientific disciplines and, of course, professional historians. You will not find reference to ‘The God Makers,’ or the many mean-spirited articles posted on the Internet by those whose obvious purpose is to mock and despoil.

When it comes to questions of a purely scientific nature, matters relating to archaeology, anthropology, paleontology or genetics, I have given greater credence to the considered opinions of non-Mormon scientists and researchers because these scholars have fewer biases and predispositions that might impede their willingness to go where the truth leads them.

At BYU and all other LDS owned post-secondary institutions, any criticism of the Church or its leaders or even, as a free American citizen espousing any view privately of which the ‘Brethren‘ disapproval, is forbidden and will result in the termination of the offending faculty member. Ruthie Robertson, a professor of political science discovered this was the case when she placed a post on her personal Facebook page supporting the LGBT community. BYU demanded she retract her statement and when she refused, she was summarily dismissed.

When a reporter asked the Church to comment on the state of academic freedom at BYU, they released the following statement: “All good LDS, including scholars, must accept the judgment of the Church’s General Authorities. If it is what the brethren want, then good LDS must say it is appropriate. This may be difficult for scholars, but obedience is an important concept “Mormon Brethren Silencing Scholars?”

Salt Lake Tribune , May 26, 1983, p. B4

Having taught at a large public university which placed a value on freedom of expression, and a commitment to pursue truth without fear of where it leads, I can only imagine how difficult it must be to teach at a place like BYU where authoritarian efforts to curtail free and independent thinking is a way of life.

Also, it is important to recognize that non-Mormon academics publish and are thereby subject to peer review. In contrast, it is rare that a paper on archeology or anthropology coming out of a school like BYU would even be accepted for publication by a prestigious scientific journal, let alone face the often-withering examination of one’s fellow scholars.

I must tell you: I had no intention of writing this book. I sought answers from many others including local priesthood leaders long before writing to President Uchtdorf.

The typical response to my questions was usually no response; instead, there would be a somewhat awkward and uncomfortable change of subject.

It soon became clear to me that faithful Mormons feel that if they were even to entertain a question concerning the Church’s official narrative; they would be somehow sucked into an abyss of disbelief resulting in an alarming disruption of their comfortable homeostasis.

I remember once asking a family member who happened to be a Mormon bishop how he deals with the fact that there is no archaeological evident supporting the Book of Mormon? You would have thought I asked him how often he had sex with his wife. The conversation went from archaeology to the color he planned to paint his kitchen in the “twinkling of an eye.”

So, absent any help from ward or stake priesthood leaders or Uchtdorf himself, I published this open letter on the Internet in 2017 in the faint hope that someone in the Church’s leadership might perhaps then respond to my concerns.

While I have yet to receive any direct response to this letter from any of the ‘Brethren,’ it seems to have gotten their attention as FairMormon immediately published a lengthy rebuttal to it. Their confutation can be found at:

https://www.fairmormon.org/answ…/Criticism_of_Mormonism/Onli ne_documents/A_Letter_to_an_Apostle/The_Letter

I can’t say FairMormon’s response to my on-line letter was of absolutely no value. Some of their explanations were interesting and a couple of their apologies sound and if not probable at least possible.

However, too often these anonymous defenders of the faith, lacking convincing answers, would proffer some defense or rationalization no matter how irrational or implausible rather than just saying, “we don’t know.”

FairMormon of course preaches to the choir; their raison d’etre is to justify all statements and actions taken by Church leaders past and present. You will never hear them say, ‘that was a mistake;’ or ‘President Nelson is no an expert in that area,’ rather they will dispense superficially plausible apologetic ‘snake oil,’ that will be eagerly swallowed by members who just crave a quick fix to dull their pesky cognitive dissonance.

After all, TBMs are not looking for a deep dive into truth, rather just enough conjectural adhesive to keep their shelves from altogether collapsing.

FairMormon searches for, interprets and favors only that information and just those data which confirm their pre-existing beliefs or hypotheses; their conclusions have been set before they have even given ear to any argument or evidence. This is called confirmation bias, and it is intellectually dishonest.

I have been around long enough and have studied history and human nature long enough to feel that well-meaning zealots seldom do anything to advance the cause of truth and often do much to harm it. Examples range from the Church’s sexually incursive and psychologically damaging youth interviews to the obscenity of the Mountain Meadows slaughter of more than 120 innocent men, women and children by true believing Mormons.

FairMormon’s efforts, follow their Mormon mindset that feelings trump facts. They prefer to speak about possibilities than probabilities.

So, instead of taking these apologists’ avowals as ‘Gospel,’ I have commented where I feel their responses to what I have written are misleading or lack credulity or plain old common sense. My standard is simple – what would a reasonable man or woman find more compelling and believable – the evidence, facts and first-hand statements I have uncovered and carefully cited in my research or the best arguments and renouncements, the Mormon Church, and her army of apologists can come up with?

To apply this standard, I have devised a rating system based on Occam’s Razor.

As you are no doubt aware, Occam’s Razor (also Ockham’s Razor) or sometimes the “Law of Parsimony,” is a philosophical problem-solving principle first attributed to William of Ockham (c. 1287–1347), an English Franciscan friar and scholastic philosopher.

His ‘law’ can be interpreted as‘ From among competing hypotheses, the one with the fewest assumptions should be selected.’ It is the most likely to be true or at least the most correct – until proven otherwise. It is the same principle taught in medical school, “when you hear hoof beats, think horses, not zebras!”

‘Occam’s Razor’ then is the test, and I have distilled it into the following rating scale to test the apologist’s efforts.

A: LOGICAL & CONVINCING The apologist has provided a logical and persuasive argument that a reasonable person would see as sensible. While possibly fallacious, the probabilities favor this explanation. The response or explanation provided is worthy of your thoughtful consideration.

C: FEEBLE BUT REASONABLE The apologist provides a somewhat weak response or argument, however there is enough here that it is worthy of your consideration. It is likely not to be the most obvious explanation of several competing explanations as Occam speaks to, but may still be correct. The apologist may assume facts not in evidence or unsubstantiated claims.

F: IRRATIONAL & UNCONVINCING The apologist's comments and rationalizations do not pass the 'Occam's Razor' test. From among the competing hypotheses, those offered by the apologist require many assumptions. Their arguments require a form of logical gymnastics, that a reasonable person would see as undue, or the apologist's explanations contain half-truths, unsubstantiated claims or a misinterpretation of facts.

The Mormon Church is an immensely wealthy, powerful and secretive corporation seeking to secure the time and acquire the treasure of sincere, honest people who are, more often than not, no match for the Church’s well-oiled PR machine. So, forgive me if I do not pull any punches in presenting facts and evidence that raise doubts about the Church’s narrative or the truthfulness of its past or present leadership.

I don’t believe it unfair to say truth has never been a core value for the Mormon leadership, and I am not just talking about Joseph Smith, Brigham Young and John Taylor who lied openly and repeatedly but many more recent, Prophets as well.

In an interview with Time Magazine in August 1997, then Mormon president Gordon B. Hinckley was asked,“ Is this the teaching of the church today, that God the Father was once a man like we are?” He unabashedly responded, “I don’t know that we teach it. I don’t know that we emphasize it. I haven’t heard it discussed for a long time in public discourse. I don’t know. I don’t know all the circumstances under which that statement was made. I understand the philosophical background behind it. But I don’t know a lot about it, and I don’t know that others know a lot about it.”

“I don’t know if we teach it?”

Could Gordon have missed what Joseph Smith said about it: “God himself was Once as we are now, and is an exalted man, and sits enthroned in yonder heavens! That is the great secret, and He was once a man like us; yea, that God himself, the Father of us all, dwelt on an earth, the same as Jesus Christ Himself did; and I will show it from the Bible.”

Or, what he himself had written a decade before this interview:

“The whole design of the gospel is to lead us, onward and upward to greater achievement, even, eventually, to godhood. This great possibility was enunciated by the Prophet Joseph Smith in the King Follett sermon and emphasized by President Lorenzo Snow. It is this grand and incomparable concept: As God now is, man may become!”

Teachings of Gordon B. Hinckley, p. 179; “Eternal Progression.

I have never been a fan of Boyd Packer; I found him a pompous ass full of hateful, inane and fatuous pronouncements.

As we are discussing truth and honesty let me provide one of his gems:

“I have a hard time with historians because they idolize the truth. The truth is not uplifting. It destroys. I could tell most of the secretaries in the church office building that they are ugly and fat. That would be the truth, but it would hurt and destroy them. Historians should tell only that part of the truth that is inspiring and uplifting.”

Boyd K. Packer, Faithful History: Essay on Writing Mormon History, p.103, fn.

But the likes of Boyd Packer are hardly representative of rank and file Latter-Day Saints.

As I said in my original letter to President Uchtdorf, I have always found that, with few exceptions, everyday Mormons, and I am not speaking of the leadership of the Church, are honest, kind and decent people. Therefore, I don’t doubt that the nameless apologists volunteering their time and talents to FairMormon are for the most part doing the best they can with what they have to defend their beliefs and the institution that has inculcated them.

But surely religious fervor, or a strong, “testimony” should not be our standard when searching to know what is true, the only arrow in our quiver. Romans Chapter 10, Verse 2 tells us, “For I can testify about them that they are zealous for God, but their zeal is not based on knowledge.”

I do not accept the Orwellian mantra hoisted on an already subdued people by the likes of Dallin Oaks that,“ Not everything that’s true is useful.”

Useful to whom and for what purpose?

Has Oaks even considered that the corollary to this puerile statement must also hold, “That not everything that is false is NOT useful!” I am told that Oaks was trained as a lawyer, not at BYU but at a highly ranked law school, the University of Chicago. Surely, he must have taken at least one class in classical logic or philosophy. Perhaps not or maybe he has just forgotten the Law of the Excluded Middle,’ espoused by Bertrand Russell. The law states that if ‘A is B’ is false, then ‘A is not B’ must be true.

If we accept that Oaks statement in the affirmative that, ‘A – Not everything that is true’ is ‘B – Useful,’ then the negative corollary,‘ Not everything that is false is not useful,’ must also be true. But then again, perhaps Oaks does in fact believe that.

There is no lack of examples in the Mormon experience where things that are known to be wholly untrue are nonetheless very useful.

Joseph Smith’s denials of his polygamous marriages, and the many lies he told the Saints and his wife. False statements? Certainly, but very useful – to him and his agenda!’

The many paintings hanging across the globe in Mormon chapels, visitor centers and temples and still reproduced in Church books and manuals, showing a young strong-chinned Joseph Smith studiously examining the ‘Reformed Egyptian‘ characters on the golden plates while his faithful scribe sits across from him writing down his ‘translation.’ A much more inspiring image than Smith bent over, with his hat in his lap and his head in his hat.

The Church has long known these images were not true representations of reality, but they remain because they are useful. So, I intend to call bullshit where I find it, whether it comes from Dallin Oaks, Russell Nelson, FairMormon or Joseph Smith.

With that said, in the words of that great dame Bette Davis, “Fasten your seat belts, this is going to be a bumpy night!”

Paul A. Douglas July 2017

I invite you to read: A Letter to an Apostle https://lettertoanapostle.org/


r/mormondebate • • Dec 01 '18

Moon: Is Being Single in the Mormon Church A Necessary Burden?

2 Upvotes

Is Being Single in the Mormon Church A Necessary Burden?

Two years ago, a young Mormon woman studying at Harvard wrote an email to Elder Dallin Oaks about her so-called "Trial of Singleness" that was "overtaking her." The Mormon website that published this story symphatized with her plight, confirming that many unmarried Mormon adults feel discouraged in a religious environment where "marriage is a big deal."

"Elder Oaks Gives Advice For Those Struggling Being Single"
http://www.ldsliving.com/Elder-Oaks-Gives-Advice-For-Those-Struggling-Being-Single/s/82617

     And what was Oaks advice? I won't quote what he said, because all he could say was leave the matter to God. Poor woman. What if God's will for her is to be single so she could serve God better in that capacity?

     Would she be able to hear God after Oaks and Mormon theology has conditioned her mind to believe that being married is the biggest spiritual deal of all?

     What has Jesus to say about being unmarried?

     In the previous debate topic where adultery as a fundamental Mormon doctrine was discussed, we cited Matthew 19:3-9 where Jesus defined what adultery was, and how his definition demolishes much of Mormon theology on marriage. His teaching shocked not only the Pharisees who weren't expecting that answer, it also shocked his apostles.

     The disciples said to him, “If this is the situation between a husband and wife, it is better not to marry.” (Matthew 19:10)

     And what did Jesus tell them? Did he say, "No, you are all very wrong! Marriage is essential to salvation!"? Unfortunately, for those like Oaks who believe that marriage is what salvation in God's kingdom is all about, they are terribly mistaken:

     Jesus replied, “Not everyone can accept this word, but only those to whom it has been given. For there are eunuchs who were born that way, and there are eunuchs who have been made eunuchs by others—and there are those who choose to live like eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom of heaven. The one who can accept this should accept it.” (Matthew 19:11-12)

     In responding to the idea that "it is better not to marry," Jesus affirms that not everyone can receive that concept. Actually it is not just a mere concept, it is a spiritual gift from God. This is why he emphasizes that "those who can accept it should accept it." Now, where in Mormon theology do we find the teaching that being single is something to be accepted from God "if one can accept it"? It doesn't exist.

     Jesus also mentions the word "eunuch" three times. This word too has no meaning in Mormon theology where the married status is deemed better than the unmarried. It is foreign to Mormonism. But this concept of a "eunuch for the kingdom of God" goes all the way back to the Old Testament:

...And let no eunuch complain,
“I am only a dry tree.”
For this is what the Lord says:
“To the eunuchs who keep my Sabbaths,
who choose what pleases me
and hold fast to my covenant—
To them I will give within my temple and its walls
a memorial and a name
better than sons and daughters;
I will give them an everlasting name
that will endure forever. (Isaiah 56:3-6)

     This teaching in Isaiah demolishes everything that Mormon temples stand for, ie, eternal marriage. Here, God consoles the eunuch who think himself to be no more than a fruitless "dry tree." He promises all the unmarried, that if they hold to God's covenant, they will receive a memorial and a name better than sons and daughters. It will be an everlasting name that will endure forever.

     And where will God give that? Within his temple and its walls.

     So we see, in the true temple that belongs to God, the unmarried man or woman who keeps God's covenant has nothing to worry or be sad about. They need not agonize about being single and not having children. God will reward them even in their single state. But inside false temples that don't belong to him, like the Mormon temples promoted by Oaks, who fervently believes he will be resurrected as a Mormon polygamist, the unmarried must struggle and suffer the mental anguish of being "dry trees."

     Jesus said "My yoke is easy, and my burden is light" (Matthew 11:30). If Jesus had talked to that young Mormon woman at Harvard, He would have better things to say than Oaks. He would have freed her from the false doctrine that's the root of her anguish. And most likely, he would have opened the scriptures to her just as He always did to his own disciples in the gospels. That's something Oaks could not do since Jesus does not teach any of the nonsense that Oaks believes in Mormon marriage.

     If you are unmarried, and you think and feel that being unmarried will enable you to follow Jesus better, then perhaps Jesus is calling you to follow him as a single person. Why reject that call? Why prefer the yoke of marriage if God is calling you through a different way?

     How many young Mormons, who would have been better off not marrying, sadly ended their marriages in divorce and remarriage? Not everyone is fit for the married life, and their children must suffer the tragic consequences. And as we have seen in the previous debate topic on adultery, the only Mormon solution to adultery and divorce is more adultery. The idea that a divorced person might be better off not remarrying is off their radar.

     Single Mormons who feel no inclination to marry should not. God may have other plans for them. The true gospel of Jesus has a message of redemption for both the married and unmarried. Being single is not a sin, and deserves no punishment. But in the false gospel that a false apostle like Oaks promotes, the single Mormon must carry an unnecessary burden of an imaginary sin.


r/mormondebate • • Nov 21 '13

Sun, I am the best debater on planet earth.

0 Upvotes

Hey everybody! I just wanted to let you all know (and prove it if anybody cares to challenge me) that I am the best debater in the world. I have never lost an argument nor can I ever lose an argument.

Don't believe me? Well let's see you prove me wrong! Exmo? Mo? Doesn't matter--your arguments will fail like wicked Nephite arrows against Samuel the Lamenite.


r/mormondebate • • Jul 09 '12

Moon: Isn't this being just a wee bit hypocritical?

5 Upvotes

This is a question directed at atheists. Also, I am not saying that all atheists follow this pattern of behavior.

Why is it that I find many atheists on the interwebs will complain about having other people's faiths "shoved down their throats", but then they will turn it right back around and bash on Mormons, and try to warn everyone not to join their "cult". It's like they're complaining about having other people tell them how to live, but then they go out and tell other people how they should live.


r/mormondebate • • Feb 05 '14

Star: Thomas Spencer Monson you are summon to Westminster Magistrates' Court. Failure to attend may result in a warrant being issues for your arrest.

3 Upvotes

I am sure most everyone has heard of this http://mormonthink.com/img/monson-summons1.jpg by now. I figured we could have some fun.

My goal for this thread:

Lets act out what would happen in an actual court of law for england. I am no lawyer nor am I all that familiar with English law, yet I think we could still have some fun. If you want to take a more practical approach to how think this will actually play out that is great. If you want to take a more sensationalist approach to how this might play out feel free as well.

The rules for the thread....

  1. Top level comment set the stage. You can jump in anywhere. If you want to imagine you are lawyer aiding Monson in their written or verbal response to Westminster Magistrates before march 14th thats fine. If you want to pretend the court is already in session and Thomas Spencer Monson has just take then stand thats fine. When setting the stage please try to include at least two possible characters. Others may jump in later, but set the stage for at least two so a back and forth can occur.

  2. Now that the stage is set responses must be in character. Please reference who you are before you go on your rant. Feel free to respond to your own top level post. Your top level post sets the stage with Monson being sworn in while on the witness stand. You are allowed to immediatly respond as the prosecution examining the witness. I recommend you don't play all the parts but if after a few hours nobody responds have at it. But I think it would be more fun if you only play one character.

  3. Have fun. Keep it light. Try to stay in character, but a little sarcasm is fine. If you want your thread to be more serious maybe include that in your stage setting. Also feel free to play devils advocate. ExMormons play the defence, Mormons play the prosecution. Try to get into the characters and really play it out. Anyway, I hope this is more fun than serious, but I am interested to see how people think it might actually play out as well.


Some sources to help everyone out...

http://mormonthink.com/img/monson-summons1.jpg (I already linked that one above)

Fraud act of 2006 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraud_Act_2006

Not sure if this will help. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prosecution

"You are a prosecution witness at Westminster Magistrates' Court" https://courttribunalfinder.service.gov.uk/courts/westminster-magistrates-court/leaflets/prosecution (there is a youtube video at the bottom that might help you get into character)

"You are a defence witness at Westminster Magistrates' Court" https://courttribunalfinder.service.gov.uk/courts/westminster-magistrates-court/leaflets/defence

Not sure if this will help http://www.justice.gov.uk/

Feel free to PM me if you have any sources that will help in our discussion and I will add it to the list.


typos in the title, dammit


r/mormondebate • • Jan 06 '15

Star: Can prayer and the answers that come from prayer be used to determine truth?

1 Upvotes

Throughout time and in most religions, prayer has been used as a means to communicate with the divine. Many people in many cultures and religions pray and insist they receive answers to their prayers. Even within religions, answers are communicated differently and those answers are often different. Even individuals can receive different answers to the same repeated prayer

If answers to prayers cannot be consistently replicated, how can anyone be certain that the answer contains truth?

In providing an answer, please be aware of and respect the no true scotsman fallacy. If you believe the fallacy itself is in error for this question, please address that as well.


r/mormondebate • • Apr 19 '12

I challenge the anti-mormons to prove they still understands basic LDS concepts.

0 Upvotes

I see that most of the anti-mormons on this board have become an incredible source of antagonism, of hostility, nay, abject hatred of the LDS church. I see such animosity that I can't help but wonder if they are fighting against that which they do not truly understand: they debate on history and books and stories and anecdotes but the Church was never about any of that.

I propose an experiment. I have selected a challenger and sent the password to this account that way he can say anything he wishes anonymously, in such a way that can never be called on it in the future and keep the reputation as an antagonist intact.

The challenge - explain what is GOOD about the LDS church, and what most people base their testimonies on. Explain why people continue to plod along in the face of people like you and your wisdom and knowledge. Explain why faith and hope are important to Mormons.

Speak as you believe that a Mormon would speak. My challenge is to express the gospel as one who has faith and hope would do so. Pretend that you are a true believing Mormon. Do you even understand what that means? You spend so much time fighting it and hating it that I can't help but think that your eyes are clouded with bias and that you are fighting against some imperfect ideal that the church can never measure up against. Can you even see the other side anymore?

Say nothing that would identity yourself.


r/mormondebate • • Feb 23 '15

The Mormon God is not very loving

6 Upvotes

Ok, the mormon God, contrary to popular belief, is definitely not a loving and/ or perfect God. (decided to add that in.) he is actually an extremely bad parent, the plan of salvation that he created is very bad, and his actions and/ or lack of actions, show that he is not loving.

God is an extremely bad parent, comparatively or realistically speaking. He decided to set literally impossible standards for his children. It has been explained that the people needed to go through that in order to receive bodies, and it has also been said that we need to be tested, however, the only reason why we would need to is because God made it so. He is literally all powerful, and the only reason why it would be necessary is. Disuse he made it so. He does not actually care about his children. He sent his oldest son to earth just so that he could experience all pain on earth and then be killed. He also sent all of his other children to earth with very little guidance, though the majority of it is also unlikely and untrustworthy. Almost all modern major religions are founded by people who literally no people alive today would have known and/ or known well. There has never been a person alive who met jesus, and there are also none who have met Joseph Smith or NY other people like that. All earth suffering is because he allows it to be so. It is all unnecessary and all originates with him, if the church is to be believed. He also is not willing to give to his children out of his literal infinite amount of supplies unless they prove they are "worthy". (of standards he set himself) Th else are all in addition to the fact that be did worse than disown 1/3 of all his children just because they disagreed with him on one thing, that would literally determine their eternal future. There are few, if any, parents alive today who would do something that unacceptable and barbaric. Next, the plan of salvation is obviously flawed, and a truly loving parent would not have made it necessary. If the. Burch is to be believed he literally sent all people to earth just to see if they would mess up. It is apparently because it was necessary in order to do this game like vet a body, and also grow spiritually, however, this is all because God would not allow us to do any of those things otherwise. He decided on a plan that would result in very very few of his. Children gaining true happiness. A truly loving person would have not wasted people's time and determined their eternal future off of a time in which they are uninformed. It would basically be the equivalent of putting people in a room for 3 years with almost no instructions, and withought their knowledge, after brainwashing them, and determining whether they get a part of a literally infinite supply of things, without knowing the requirements, or if they will be disowned. A loving person would not do this either.

The art wag that he is a nonloving God is that he has done next to nothing for people. He was not the one who created the Earth, he played almost no part in the plan of salvation, (mainly approved it) and he was not the main person who made it possible. All pain is because he allows it, and because he does kit act. The main logical explanation for this is that he is either lazy, or that he doesn't care. Causing Peolle pointless pain is never ok. It seems that this is God's main policy though. He is essentially a lazy prideful guy who sits in heaven and let's all other people do his work. He is not even the person who guides, that is the Holy Ghost who either will have ti suffer an eternity without a body, or who God will somehow give a body to. A truly loving God would not just be lazy in what he did, and would instead try taking an active part in what is happening. (which he does at a few points in history, however, it is mainly when he feels like destroying people or groups.)

Edit: posted case, changed a few things.


r/mormondebate • • Oct 28 '15

How I know that being a Mormon was the right choice for me

5 Upvotes

I know that by choosing to become a member of the church, my life has been blessed in so many different ways. Do you believe that your life can be better if you also join the church?


r/mormondebate • • Dec 01 '15

Can Anyone Provide One Example of a Family Affected by the Policy Prohibiting Baptism of Children Living with Parents Involved in a Same Gender Relationship?

5 Upvotes

I’ve waited to post this for a while to see if the media would find anyone directly affected by the new policy. I have not seen one example. There are three groups of people potentially affected by this policy.

(1) True believing grandparents that want their grandchildren, living with gay parents, to be baptized. Through badgering and bribes, these people will push their gay offspring to let their grandkids to be blessed, named and baptized. This would cause a huge trauma to the child and family. Naming and baptism of these children would activate a program of fellowship and activation for the rest of their lives. Bishops, YM/YW leaders, ward missionaries, full-time missionaries, EQ Presidents, and RS Presidents would be tasked, for the next 110 years, with finding, fellowshipping, and activating these children. If the kids become interested, it will cause tension in the home. If the kids are not interested, the Mormon activation effort will be a lifetime of hassle unless the person has their name removed from the Church Records. (2) Gay Parents with Children Aged 12 and Under. I would argue that there are a total of zero parents in this situation that, on their own, want their children to be baptized and raised in the LDS Church. The “gay identity” is very strong and no sane parent would want their child to be raised in a church where they are told the lifestyle of their parents is sinful and wrong. Any gay parent that really would want this is hoping to change the Church from the inside or is using their child for a purpose beyond the benefits the church can provide. (3) Children Aged 13 to 17 that Really Want to Join the Church. This group is most likely to be affected by the policy. Unless they have another agenda, a total of zero gay parents would approve of their minor child being baptized into the LDS church. If they are open-minded and are willing to let them join, the tension on the family of being taught one thing at church and another at home would not be good for family dynamics. As above, the baptism would unleash a wave of contact from church members to fellowship and retain the child. The new policy of making the child wait until they are of age seems prudent and legitimate.

I just don’t understand the big fuss. If this policy directly affects no one, why the angst and crying? In my opinion, the people that don’t like this policy simply don’t like that the LDS church classifies same sex relations as a sin. The claims of discrimination and harm to children are an attempt to get the Church to change their policy. It has nothing to do with children – there are no children affected.


r/mormondebate • • Jul 27 '20

What would you say is the origin of the races?

5 Upvotes

We've been made according to Gods likeness. We have similar physical characteristics. If He has a body he has a race. At least this is my deduction. But of he has one race, then he could not be the origin of races. How do we explain then the existence of many races if God has one race?

My deductions so far lead me to 2 possible alternatives:

  1. The secular explanation, scientifical consensus of adaptation depending on the conditions of the geographical zone where groups of people developed.

  2. God has many wives, and she might have one wife that is white, another that is black, amerindian, asian, Arab, Jewish, etc. So the origin of races would be explained in direct relations to Heavenly Mothers.

This is pure speculation. I acknowledge that, but interesting topic to discuss about nonetheless.

I expect mainly LDS opinions since my premise rests on the foundation of LDS theology, but theories from people of other faiths are also welcome.

Thank you.


r/mormondebate • • Oct 25 '18

Moon: Is Mormonism Müntzerism?

2 Upvotes

Is Mormonism Müntzerism?

Thomas Müntzer is virtually unknown among Mormons, except those who have to read, study, or publish literature related to the Protestant movement of the 16th century. The BYU Religious Studies Center published an article about him in 2004, and is accessible online.

     Müntzer is a folk hero of the Radical Reformation known as the Anabaptist movement, the left-wing of the 16th century Protestant Revolution. The Anabaptists were called as such because they "re-baptized" Christians who had already been baptized previously. This movement is very wide, and is sometimes judged by mainstream Christian writers as neither Catholic nor Protestant. The Donatists of the 4th-6th centuries were considered anabaptists, and their heresy of rebaptizing Christians was condemned at that time.

     Mormonism is anabaptist without question. Its own statistics reveal that fact. Its top-baptizing countries are all Catholic countries. It has no convincing power to change the minds of pagans in non-Christian lands. After almost 200 years of aggressive missionary work, some 85% members are still found only in the Western hemisphere where most inhabitants and culture are Christian.

     But back to Müntzer. He rejected "infant baptism" and taught "believer's baptism," ie, baptizing only those who are capable of believing the Christian faith. Not strangely, this anabaptist doctrine is explained in the Book of Mormon, an anachronism that makes it no older than the 16th century.

     He rejected the doctrine of the "Real Presence" in the Eucharistic elements of the bread and wine, and denied that these were the actual Body and Blood of Christ where the Lord's whole person and divinity resides. The Mormon ritual called the "Sacrament" is a rejection of that doctrine.

     Müntzer also held apocalyptic delusions, believing that their present social order was about to be overthrown, and an earthly theocracy established to abolish the rule of the Church and the secular princes. Likewise, Mormons believed that the 19th century was the "last days" and identified themselves as "latter-day saints" who must gather to Jackson county, Missouri as the place of refuge when the world is swallowed in apocalyptic destruction.

     Müntzer therefore believed in a social order where material goods are equally shared as in socialism and communism. Harmony, Pennsylvania was the site of a failed socialist experiment when Joseph and Emma settled there. The name Harmony itself is an obvious clue to that experiment. But where Harmony failed, Joseph was confident his United Order and Kirtland Safety Society would not.

     Müntzer was also an iconoclast, a destroyer of Christian icons and images. Smith's followers, in contrast, though not iconoclast in practice, somehow followed the same tendency. This is why Mormon worship halls and rooms are bland and totally devoid of Christian images and symbols. They look exactly as how a church would look after iconoclasts have done their destructive work.

     By working for social upheaval in order to establish a theocracy, both Müntzer and Smith became magnets for trouble and hostilities. Both attracted like-minded loonies, and both died violent deaths.

     Perhaps their greatest theological bond is in the idea that "all true parsons must have revelations." Where most Protestants planted themselves in "sola scriptura" or the "Bible alone" as the rule of faith, both Müntzer and Smith believed in the superiority of "personal revelations" or "inspiration" over the written word of God. This is why opening the Biblical scriptures to correct and reprove Mormon theological errors hardly convinces the Mormon mind. Its the spirit of Müntzer at work.

     Mormon scholars see in Müntzer as a type of Elijah, a forerunner to the coming of Joseph Smith and his so-called Restoration. But as Ecclesiastes said it: There is nothing new under the sun. Mormonism is not a restoration, but a rehash. It's nothing more than an improved version of a 16th century Christian heresy. Catholics have seen this movie before, and they know how it will end.


r/mormondebate • • Mar 12 '17

Star: Mormons should embrace polygamy again to attract more people to the faith.

2 Upvotes

I literally see no downside to this.


r/mormondebate • • Aug 04 '20

Calling All Ex-Mormons for UC Berkeley Study

11 Upvotes

UPDATE: Clarification of Requirements to Participate:

I realize I was unclear on some things, and I apologize. Thank you to everyone who has already completed the survey and to those of you asking questions and giving me feedback.

- Be POMO for a minimum of 6 months

- Both those who have officially resigned and those who haven't are welcome to participate.

Hello everyone,

My name is Emma Yataco. I'm a UC Berkeley Undergraduate Researcher currently studying the effects of conversion/de-conversion from the LDS Church.

As an ex-mo I am deeply curious about the effects of joining/leaving religion. For the past two years I have been studying conversion/de-conversion in the LDS Church and recently began looking at Kingdom Hall as well.

I want to invite you to participate in my study by first completing the Preliminary Screening Survey.

Here is a link to my research profile. https://hsp.berkeley.edu/haas-fellows/detail/3379

If you have any questions please feel free to contact me at [email protected] or feel free to send me a direct message.

Thank you!


r/mormondebate • • Jan 07 '14

Sun: Even though the LDS Church is True, you shouldn't have faith in it.

3 Upvotes

I have often heard, "While we don't have a perfect answer for X, we can proceed because of our knowledge that the Church is True." I am going to argue that even though the Church is True, an individual should not believe in it.

First let me define True--generally I mean that the major doctrines reflect the way the universe really is. A major doctrine would be something like, a powerful being who humans could understand as God exists, and he communicates with the LDS prophet. Another major doctrine would be that God requires humans to develop faith in something that is true but unprovable if they are to enter his kingdoms in the afterlife. Basically, by True I mean that the assertions that Church doctrine makes about the universe will all be vindicated in some way at some future time.

To see why one shouldn't believe in the Church, even though it is True, we should examine the experience of someone who belongs to The Bizarro Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

The doctrines of the BLDS Church are very similar to the LDS Church, but instead of believing in a resurrection, the BLDS Church believes in reincarnation onto other more advanced planets if people lived holy lives and onto more backward planets if people lived unholy lives. Obviously the BLDS Church is not True, and therefore has no priesthood power or divine counsel for their Prophet and Quorum of the 12 Apostles.

A person who is a member of BLDS Church and has been developing their understanding of and faith in the religion, comes across some discussion over reincarnation versus resurrection and becomes confused. This person thinks that resurrection makes sense, but they really have no way to determine which doctrine is true experientially. They can't talk to anyone who's been resurrected or reincarnated. They can't experience it themselves until they die.

Stuck in this conundrum, the BLDS member goes to their bishop and the bishop discusses with them how resurrection in the scriptures also refers to reincarnation because resurrection refers to one stage of a many stage reincarnation, and that the other stages simply weren't referred to very often because we really only need to focus on one stage at a time. The bishop explains that while we personally can't interact with any reincarnated beings, we do have the accounts of people who have, and the writers of the accounts were known to be honest.

The BLDS bishop encourages his flock-member to go back to the basics of the BLDS faith--read your scriptures, pray, focus on the blessings you get from the faith, and trust that you will get your own witness in the future regarding reincarnation.

The BLDS member goes and tries all these things, and does find some solace in their religious activity but the question still bothers them. They go back to the bishop in 6 months, and the bishop gives them a special blessing and encourages them to have a special fast. The BLDS member does these things, and feels better in some respects, but still the question nags.

In another meeting, the bishop says finally, "I know that this is an important question for you, but we cannot place requirements on the Lord. He will answer the question in his own due time when you are ready. Know this, the Church is True and it blesses your life. Continue on the path that you know to be True, and in time all things will make sense."

The BLDS person does just this--they acknowledge their discomfort with this point, but continue forward in faith. The BLDS person cannot recognize that their faith has been placed in something that is not true. The BLDS Church always has an answer to explain why the person should keep their faith in the false religion.

For the person in the BLDS Church and for anyone in a false Church that teaches having faith, that person is stuck on the false path they are on as long as they use the faith that their religion encourages. It is the methodology of using faith (relying on non-provable assertions) that while True in the case of the LDS Church, keeps people in false beliefs in the case of all other faith-based beliefs.

Thus, you should reject faith as conscientious objector. The methodology only gives the correct answer if you start with the right answer, and this causes humanity many problems.

One might argue, you shouldn't conscientiously object against God. We know he is just. We know he loving. We know he knows better than us. That is True, but it is also the exact same thing a believer in a false religion will say to justify their false beliefs.

If all humans took the position, "Faith is a flawed methodology to determine truth" the world would not have harmful faith based beliefs such as refusal to grant medical care and stoning of rape victims. In order for that to happen, everyone has to repudiate their faith, even I as a believer in the True Church.


r/mormondebate • • Jul 30 '25

Is Mormon faith properly basic?

3 Upvotes

r/mormondebate • • Oct 22 '18

Moon: Is God really offended with the nickname "Mormon"?

8 Upvotes

Pres. Russel M. Nelson, the current Mormon prophet, was quite emphatic in his General Conference talk about ditching the Mormon label. According to him, God is offended whenever Mormons identify themselves as Mormons.

     Yet consider how dangerous this era we live in:

     The US and Russia are now on the brink of direct conflict over Syria. The US just pulled out of the 1987 Intermediate-range Nuclear Forces Treaty that the Reagan signed with Soviet Russia. The threat of a global nuclear conflagration is even more acute now than it was during the 1962 Cuban missile crisis. As America bleeds heavily in blood and treasure over its eternal wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, surprisingly, God's most important message is not about calling for an end to the senseless waste, destruction, and bloodshed.

     No, it's about calling for an end to the Mormon nickname. Why? Because it is, as Nelson points out, a victory for Satan if the practice continues.

     Well, if God is so offended by this, why didn't he say so right at the beginning? He could have told Joseph Smith to call the Book of Mormon by another name, like the "Stick of Joseph" or something. That would have prevented this offensive label from reaching public consciousness. In 1830, the name Mormon already sounded weird. That's why it got tacked on to the book's believers. I don't know of any country in the world where this name actually sounds cool. Yet, God was tone-deaf in all of this.

What was God thinking when his two most recent prophets, Hinckley and Monson, embarked on such multi-million dollar projects like the "I'm a Mormon" ads and "Meet the Mormons" movie? And now he is venting his anger at the members of his church although he said nothing about it until Nelson became prophet.

     If this all sounds like God is straining at gnats while swallowing a camel, it is because he is. The God of Russell Nelson is not the God of the true Jesus Christ. Nelson's God is as vain and petty as Joseph Smith. He is that foolish christ who built a church that collapsed in a so-called "great apostasy" so that Smith can restore it. His shortsightedness and trivial concerns betray who he really is.

     How do we know this, aside from the fact that Christ's Church never fell in apostasy? In the New Testament, Jesus castigated the Pharisees for their pettiness and hypocrisy. They overly concerned themselves with so many silly minutiae in their rituals, yet neglected the more important moral issues of truth, justice, and mercy. They ignored what man has to do in order to correct his broken relationship with God and his fellowmen. In failing to address the weightier matters of God's Law, they teach for doctrines the commandments of men.

     The God of the true Jesus Christ has nothing to do with the Mormon nickname. He has nothing to do with all this Mormon trivialities. If Nelson's God is offended, let him be. He deserves it.


r/mormondebate • • Aug 30 '12

Aliens, Racism, Gold Tablets

0 Upvotes

Do you guys honestly believe in this stuff? Coming from an x-christian, atheist, Mormonism really seems like a cult to me. Do you understand this view? I'm really not trying to be a dick, but your religion just seems like the biggest hoax to me... Such a small group in such recent history... IN AMERICA... given the true religion. What about the rest of the world.

Help me understand.