r/moraldilemmas • • Apr 11 '25

Personal Is saving a drowning person a foolish idea unless you are trained to do it ?

2.2k Upvotes

Last summer, I was at a lake beach with my wife and daughter. It was very crowded and I was near the shore. However, I heard this older men yell for help (with raised hand) and noticed he was drifting further into the deep lake (still standing up but water was near his mouth). I quickly swam toward him, bypassing all the people and pulled him to shore by his hand. He was very thankfully and his family (which was on the beach) was in shock. It all happened so quickly, I was the only one to react. I am not the best swimmer too, but I can manage. That day, I was sure I just did the right thing. However, my family/friends believed I took too much of a risk and did something foolish. I had no idea that a drowning person can actually pull you under and often that seems to be the case. I only found this out after this event. I am wondering what is the morality here ? How can we just not try even if we are not trained ? Then again, my young daughter was there on the beach that day and I also feel like I did not think of that. I am morally confused here.


r/moraldilemmas • • Aug 22 '25

Personal Is it wrong of me to not want to donate my part of my liver to my cousin?

1.8k Upvotes

I (24,F) have a cousin named Tom (30,M). He was diagnosed with a rare disorder a few years ago that has caused him to go into liver failure. He needs a transplant, and the whole family is getting tested to see if any of us are a match.

Here is where my dilemma is. Tom is not a good person. He’s a racist asshole. Tom once punched our other cousin’s significant other solely because he was Asian. He has sexually assaulted multiple women, though he was only convicted of one. He made fun of my friend who had cancer because she was bald. Tom disgusts me.

I will probably go get tested to see if I am a match and will donate if I am. I don’t think I could let someone, even a bad person, suffer if I know I can fix it. However, I don’t know if I want to. Is that a bad thing?

Update: I ended up not getting tested. I decided to wait and see if someone else was a match. Turns out none of us are. We also learned that there is no way my cousin is his father’s biological son so that’s been really interesting.


r/moraldilemmas • • Dec 18 '25

Hypothetical Is it considered stealing? WWYD?

1.7k Upvotes

If you went into a fairly large department store and brought a large ticket item and a few smaller ticket items to the checkout, had the cashier ring them through, paid, chatted for a bit with the cashier then drove home only to realize that the cashier didn’t actually scan the large ticket item.. but removed all the security tags and checked that it was in proper condition before handing it to you.. would you go back and pay for it or not ?!

Edit to add : cost ~$200 item.

Edit #2: the total was never read out loud to me when going through the till. I didn’t intentionally distract anyone. We were simply chatting and it was a “tap your card whenever you’re ready” situation and I had done the mental math while shopping so I had a rough idea of the total cost that it would end up being. Honest mistake only realized once I got home.


r/moraldilemmas • • Jan 05 '26

Personal Do I tell someone they accidentally went against their religion?

1.6k Upvotes

My partner is muslim and he doesn't eat pork and is very strong about this belief. About 2 days ago he bought a meal deal and sent me a photo of it after he had eaten it, and he had eaten a pasta with chorizo in it. It was chicken and chorizo and the packaging emphasised the chicken part. (He doesnt mind if food isnt halal but draws the like at pork). His english isn't perfect and he doesnt realise what chorizo is. (Pls no comments that its his responsibility to check etc)

The second he sent me it my heart dropped for him, but I didnt say anything as he was at work and no good would come from telling him as he couldnt undo it and would spend the next few hours feeling sick. Initially I thought i wont tell him as it serves no purpose, but my worry is he will buy it again, so to tell him is preventing him doing it again. Its been on my mind non stop for 48 hours. I tried to tell him but the words wouldn't come out. I've thought of every possibility of how to tell him and the thought of how he might feeling knowing he ate it makes me so upset, but if I dont tell him and he does it again I will feel complicit.

He rarely buys food out but didnt have lunch that day, its unlikely to happen again but not impossible. I dont know if I should tell him, and if I do, how?


r/moraldilemmas • • Feb 03 '25

Relationship Advice Is it okay for me to sleep With my dead friends ex?

1.5k Upvotes

So this girl really wants us to hookup, but i am conflicted, because she used to be with a good friend of mine before he died a few years ago. Is it wrong of me if I did it?


r/moraldilemmas • • Oct 30 '25

Personal A girl asked me for my number. Was what I did next morally wrong?

1.4k Upvotes

Yesterday I was studying at a cafe in my college town when a girl approached me and said I was cute and she asked for my number. I was flattered by her approaching me, but I did not find her attractive unfortunately. However, I got nervous because that rarely happens to me so I just gave her my number anyway.

A few hours later, she texted me saying "Hey it's [name] from the cafe!" At this point I didn't know how to handle the situation and whether or not I should respond -- I was not interested in pursuing her romantically or even becoming friends with her. So I asked a few of my friends for advice:

The first two friends I asked told me the best thing I can do is either reply to her message and tell her that I'm not interested right off the bat, or just not respond at all. The other two friends I asked told me I should respond to her and be friendly / get into a brief convo then ease into a rejection message, and the message should be a "white lie" to soften the blow and make it seem like she couldn't have dated me anyway.

At first I was thinking of sending no reply, but then I felt like it would've made her feel bad/rejected so I went about the best way to hurt her feelings the least possible. What I ended up doing was listen to the latter two friends, and I responded to her saying "Hi it's [my name]!" and then she asked how I was doing and I responded to that and then she asked if I was free to call her sometime later. In response, I told her I was busy, then I told her "Also I didn't know if I was gonna be the one to tell you this, but I'm gay lol" which is not true and just a white lie to make it sound less like a rejection. Also, this whole text exchange lasted only 20 minutes.

After doing this, the first two friends I asked for advice told me that what I did was not morally right and that I should have been honest from the start. Their view is that it's more respectful to be transparent even if it stings a bit. My stance is that I was trying to be empathetic and protect her feelings, and that it wasn't serious enough to require complete honesty since we didn't know each other.

I feel deep down that what I did was right, even if it may have been unconventional. But now I'm wondering if lying about something like that crosses a moral line.

Was what I did morally wrong, or was it understandable in this situation?


r/moraldilemmas • • Nov 18 '24

Personal Found out my wife was cheating on me - Do I tell the 'other man's' wife about it?

1.2k Upvotes

Throwaway account, just in case. Me (male) and ex-wife (female) and I recently ended our relationship and marriage. When going through my things, I found conversations on a shared device that proved to me she was cheating on me and in a sexual relationship with another man for quite a bit of time while we were married (over 6 months). In these conversations, I also discovered that the man she was cheating on me with also has a wife, who does not know about their sexual encounters.

I do not personally know his wife, but I can't help but feel like it is the moral thing to try to figure out a way to contact her and let her know this information. Most of my friends have advised me to just move on and forget about it, but I feel like it is the right thing to do because I am not really seeking out revenge, but because if I was in his wife's situation, I would want to know. Also, I definitely feel like I would be ok with whatever she decides to do with this information, including staying with him - I feel like my moral obligation begins and ends with making sure she knows.

The main potential downsides is that this course of action does come with its dangers - for instance, if the 'other man' decides to come after me for ruining his life, etc.


r/moraldilemmas • • Jan 18 '25

Personal Should I tell my bsf’s boyfriend she is having an affair

1.2k Upvotes

My best friend has been in a 9 year relationship with her boyfriend and they are currently and have been long distance for the past few years. She is moving back to live with her boyfriend in 3 weeks and from what she has told me he is planning on proposing to her in the near future as he has booked the both of them a “surprise” three week holiday in about a month. Yesterday she told me she has been sleeping with one of our mutual friends for about 3 months now and although they are ‘casual’ (her words) she spends most of her time with him and they go on a lot of dates. The past few months she has been acting very unlike her usual self (going out a lot/ smoking/ not caring about work that much) but she has seemed so happy I just thought she was trying to enjoy her last few months in the country before she leaves. She told me she doesn’t plan on telling her almost fiance that she has been cheating on him and just says that she’s just going to have to live with this as a secret because once she goes back she knows there’s no way he could ever find out. I have felt genuinely sick to my stomach ever since she told me as I know her bf loves her so much, his parents even gave them their house to live in when she goes back. I don’t know how I can live with knowing she has betrayed him in such a way and has taken a ‘what he doesn’t know won’t hurt him’ stance on this and she honestly shows no sign of guilt whatsoever and is not planning on breaking up with him. I already feel guilty as a couple months ago i unknowingly covered up a lie for her to him about her location and he obviously needs to know, but I don’t know how and if I should be the one to tell him or if I should wait or just see how things play out and maybe their relationship would end anyways?


r/moraldilemmas • • Nov 02 '24

Abstract Question Harris voters, genuinely tell me why

1.2k Upvotes

I saw someone on this subreddit ask this about Trump and I would like to know the same for the other side. Without bashing Trump or republicans, why are you voting/in support of Kamala Harris?

For reference, I am in the US and ineligible to vote, so these posts are not being used to make a decision. If this were for decision making purposes, I would of course be reading candidates’ policies straight from them.


r/moraldilemmas • • Oct 31 '24 Take My Silver

Personal Ex demanded "no contact", then some money arrived

1.1k Upvotes

My wife divorced me a few years ago, moved on with some new guy and stopped all contact. Not long ago, she wrote out of the blue that her pet cat died and she was feeling sad. I replied that I felt bad for her, but I had some good news: a family member just announced they were getting married. She didn't reply.

A few days later I got a letter from a lawyer saying I was no longer to contact my ex under any circumstances, and that if I did it would result in legal consequences. It seemed really weird, since I hadn't heard from her in ages, until she initiated communication saying her cat had died, and I wrote my two line reply about being sorry and about the family wedding.

Anyway, whatever. If that's what she wants. No contact.

The very next day, by mindboggling coincidence, a letter arrived addressed to my ex. It was from a company she had worked with a few years ago saying they owed her roughly $850. They had tried to send it to the bank account they had on record, but were told that account was closed. So, if she would contact them with new bank account details they would send the payment.

I thought "screw it, she said no contact, so no contact it is", and ignored the letter. My attitude was that legal letter just cost her another $850.

Did I do the right thing, or should I risk "legal action" by contacting her again about this money she is owed?

UPDATE: Some folks are asking why I opened the letter. I live alone, and didn't even realise it was addressed to her until I had opened it.


r/moraldilemmas • • Dec 02 '23

Abstract Question Stray puppy followed us home from bar at 3am and we don’t want to give her up

1.1k Upvotes

And a week later we’ve decided to keep her. She’s an amazing, kind, gentle dog and we already love her. Over the passed week we’ve contacted multiple shelters to see if anyone reached out about this particular dog and left our info to be contacted. We also had her checked for a micro chip and she doesn’t have one.

Yesterday our neighbor came across a post on a lost dog Facebook page and it was definitely for this dog we have and another. We learned her actual name. And the last place the dog was seen is where she started to follow us from. She doesn’t respond to the name we learned. She’s barely potty trained, probably about 6-7 months old. We saw what the condition of the home is that she’s living in and it’s not great.

The neighbor that showed us this post just so happened to find the other dog included in the Facebook post. They reached out to the owner and said it was a weird exchange. The owner was unexcited on the phone and was unwilling to compensate $100 for the food and toys that the neighbor had bought claiming the toys were used. The owner said they filed a police report but also said it would be bad news for both parties if the police were involved. The owner doesn’t have any papers to prove the dogs are his and said the dogs are his 16yr old brothers. The dog we have also has a rash as well as scabs on her inner legs.

We personally have not reached out to the owner yet.

We feel like this dog would have a better quality of life with us. How do you lose a dog at 3am, have no micro chip, and not contact the shelters around at the very least. Why isn’t she potty trained yet and why doesn’t she respond to her old name?

The dilemma is basically this. After 72 hours from what we have read, we become responsible for the dog and we aren’t legally obligated to return her. We want to take her to the vet and get her micro chipped. But does that make us bad people? It seems like she’s been in a home that kinda wants her and kinda doesn’t care. But at the same time who are we to decide how they treat her. We’re sad to think she would be worse of but we also don’t know for sure that’s how it would be.


r/moraldilemmas • • Jun 12 '24

Abstract Question Should I tell my friends (other members) about the cult group we’re in or should I just keep it to myself and leave?

1.0k Upvotes

It’s recently been solidified to me that the group I’ve been with for 6 months now probably is as a cult. I've done extensive research (which they strongly advise against) and found strong evidence that it is a cult. I've decided to leave, but the problem is that I have friends in this group, and I'm not sure what to tell them when they reach out to me because they are so committed to this. I also don't want to come across as the villain or insane, so I'm not sure how to go about this. I want to leave without any issues and I'm scared they might even tell the cult leaders about this.

Here's some additional information;

I stumbled upon Shincheonji Church of Jesus (SCJ) while scrolling through TikTok, where I cams across an exposé shared by a former member sharing their experiences, and I noticed eerie similarities between their accounts and my own personal experience within the group I’d been in. I dove deeper into it and conducted my own research, and I realized that I was unknowingly following the teachings of Lee Man Hee, the leader of SCJ, who claims to be immortal. The thing is, SCJ's recruiting tactics were deceptive. They kept their true identity hidden and encouraged secrecy within the group, even from my family and friends. They’d frequently use the phrase the "spirit works through flesh" to create a divide among us, and outsiders, it was always "you vs. them.

Attendance was mandatory, with any absence met with incessant phone calls and guilt-tripping tactics to discourage me prioritising my personal life. They would also pressure us to recruit new individuals frequently. In terms of the level of danger I think I'm in I don't believe they pose a direct physical threat, the group overall seems pretty harmless. I don't think they'd go out of their way to harm me; at most, maybe repeatedly reach out to me via phone call, or if all efforts are exhausted, maybe try to come to visit my home to maybe talk. I’m just worried that my friends will continue to fall victim to SCJ's lies, sacrificing their time and energy for a group that ultimately isn’t being truthful about who they truly are and are seeking to control and exploit them.

New Edit: Thanks to everyone for your advice on how to deal with this and your genuine concern for my safety.

So here’s a little backstory for those wondering I found myself in this situation. 

Btw, I’m aware that Christianity isn’t look favourably upon here on reddit, but here’s the backstory I was invited to join this group by a mentor from a previous bible study. (Little did I know she was apart of this group as well. ) The group's teacher was incredibly vague when I first met them; all they said was that they offered bible studies that lasted anywhere from nine months to a year. Since they used a front name rather than simply telling us who they were, there was no mention of SCJ, but I'm sure they would have eventually disclosed their identity as time passed and they earned our trust. As I kept on going to these classes three times a week, nothing seemed off. The things they taught were fair and backed by scripture. Ironically, looking back, I recall one time where the leaders often warned us not to share what we had been learning with others, saying that we’d provide them with false information that could mislead them leading them to think that we were part of some kind of cult or something. So they told us that we should instead send these people to them directly. They even used Jesus as an example of someone who people might perceive as the leader of a cult. To further solidify their point, Still, I didn't give it much thought. I first became aware of the early warning signs when they strongly discouraged us from searching the internet and other Bible sources because it was "false truth" and we shouldn't rely on it. I had never heard that before, so it seemed quite odd to me.

The thing is, I didn't notice many of these things at first, but as I started to look closer, I began to see all of these red flags. But essentially, how I got this far was by simply taking them for their word because I felt as though they had an explanation for everything they said, and they had also established a place where I felt comfortable and had a sense of belonging while I looked to the Bible for answers and understanding. (These are literal characteristics this particular cult often seeks in their recruits, young people who lack a solid understanding of the Bible) So that’s how I was easily fooled and unknowingly was recruited by them.

 


r/moraldilemmas • • Dec 29 '23

Personal Should I tell my spouse’s affair partner’s wife?

963 Upvotes

Earlier this year it started off great with my wife cheating on me, lucky me. Her man of choice was not married at the time when it first started. When I got back from deployment, she came clean telling me it lasted until a day or two before I got back, late April. He met and eventually married his new wife a few weeks later.I recently found out she had oral sex with this guy two times during the summer while this guy was married. This woman he married has kids from prior relationships, and apparently she is already pregnant.

I told my wife to do the right thing, and tell her, which she said she was going to after the holidays. She then met up with the guy again for him to explain himself, and now she’s telling me it isn’t her place to tell her. Clearly she lacks some ethical integrity.

I just feel so bad for this woman, going on in that marriage with a scumbag of a husband. Should I try and find a way to tell her about this? But in doing so will probably hurt my ok relationship with my soon to be ex wife which is important for our kids sake. So, what do I do?

EDIT: I do not plan to stay with my wife, that was very unclear in my post apparently. Only still with her so we can figure things out while helping my financial situation.


r/moraldilemmas • • Aug 03 '24

Relationship Advice Wife slept with her friends husband before our relationship started should I tell the friend

961 Upvotes

Through our discussions about the affair my wife had recently my wife reveled to me that she slept with her best friend's husband when she was 17 (10 years ago). I knew she slept with a married man before we got married but I did not ask who it was with. She is still friends with this couple, though we don't live near each other. I told her that I do not feel comfortable with her being around this previous partner. She accepted that. I also told her I'm not comfortable being around the other betrayed friend. My wife didn't seem to understand why. But it is because I'm now complicit in their lie. I am now wondering if my wife has a moral compass and if I should ask her to confess to her friend and if she doesn't should I tell her.


r/moraldilemmas • • Jun 02 '25

Personal I found a jewelry box in our home of 11 years..

840 Upvotes

We moved into this home over 11 years ago. The people who owned the house before us never met us. They ran a multi-level marketing business in their home. When they left they gave us No forwarding address to send their mail to. They said they were moving to Florida is all I knew at the time. We received many letters and bills unpaid to our address with no where to send it. I sent the mail back to the sender. I found out through the years that there were other people who lived here too. Maybe they were a part of the multi level marketing business. One day a few months ago we were repairing an appliance. When my husband moved it away from the wall to unplug it we saw a jewelry box. I opened it. It has maybe about 5k in jewelry in it. I am not sure. Do I keep it or try to locate the owners. Although I am not really sure who the box belongs to.


r/moraldilemmas • • Oct 26 '24

Personal My mother is dying. Do I owe her reconciliation? If not, is it okay to not attend her funeral

792 Upvotes

My (M51) mother (F71) is nearing death. I went "no contact" with her several years ago. She is a narcissist who plays my emotions like an instrument. Her go-to move is making everything about herself. Since I was in my 30s, the main subject of our conversations was "poor me, give money." I've been generous in directly giving her a lot of money and paying down her debt. She is always the victim and claims that everyone is trying to take advantage of her.

She constantly lies, even about things that don't matter and are easily refuted. She has zero empathy and does not agree that her behavior is problematic. This has been the case my whole life. She neglected my sister and me as children, putting her wants ahead of our needs. There was always money for Tab (Diet Coke before there was Diet Coke) and cigarettes but little for anything beyond our minimum needs.

She suffered from postpartum depression and tried to kill me when I was an infant - a fact that I learned pretty recently. She clearly has mental health issues. She was abused as a child and developed a hatred of men—all men, including me. What happened to her was awful, and I've tried to look at her behavior through the lens of a hurt little girl. I didn't always handle this well and have been unkind at times. I love her. I don't think she loves anyone but herself. Every interaction since I became an adult has left me feeling hurt and undermind my self-esteem. I was resigned to our dysfunctional relationship, in part because of what "I owed" to my mother for raising me.

And then I married and had children. She always called my wife by the wrong name and sent the girls birthday and Christmas cards for the first few years of their lives, but then she stopped. While I brought the girls around and encouraged them to have a relationship with their grandmother, it didn't go well. She made connections with them and then pulled back. My children didn't understand why she didn't want them around; they were very hurt. She never asks about them. I decided that it stopped with me, and I wouldn't allow her to hurt my children. I ended communication and removed her from our lives.

I don't struggle with the question of whether I did the right thing. She is my mother, and I love her, but I won't tolerate the infliction of pain on my family and myself. I have more or less concluded that the answer is a messy "Yes, I set the necessary boundaries."

Now, my mother's death is imminent. She has been in a steady decline and suffered a major heart attack last night. My sister and aunts are pressuring me to reconnect with my mother using the "she won't always be around" line of guilt. I mourned the loss of her many years ago, and her physical passing will not change my life. I will be sharing the final costs with my sister.

I am thinking about whether the right thing to do is 1) speak to, if not reconcile with my mother, and 2) if I don't, is it okay not to attend her funeral - I feel it would be disingenuous to attend. I am comfortable with not speaking to my mother or attending her funeral. Still, I can't decide if those are moral choices. What do you think?

TL;DR: My estranged mother's death is imminent. I haven't spoken to her in years and don't want to now. Additionally, I have already mourned the loss and think attending her funeral will be disingenuous. Am I wrong?


r/moraldilemmas • • Dec 19 '25

Personal Should I give a donation back

721 Upvotes

I attended a church dinner with my 2 daughters (5 and 7) and their great aunt. My family doesnt attend church however, their Aunt does. She asked me to go along for a free meal and my husband didnt want to go and neither did my 9 year old son. We had a "girls night out" and walked to the the church. We ate dinner, cleaned up, we're super respectful as one should be. While getting ready to leave the Pastor came up to me and asked me if our family was in need of any help this christmas (its one week away) and I immediately started crying because of how stressed I've been. He pulled me aside and asked me how old my kids were and told me he would be right back. He walked down a hall way that had 2 tables full of gift bags and I thought maybe he was coming back with one for each of my kids. He instead came back with $250 in gift cards and I started crying all over again. I asked him if he was sure and thanked him over and over again and asked him for a hug. I explained to him then that we dont have anything for them right now and I wasn't sure how we were going to get presents for my kids. He said Merry Christmas and I asked him if I could hug him. I went to dinner just expecting a quick community meal and a night out of the house.

Fast forward the next day. My husband is telling me I need to return the gift cards because we dont attend church and he is very against church. He said if I use them I am not to put his name on any of them as he wants nothing to do with them.

Should I return the gift cards since our family doesnt usually attend church? He has me thinking im awful for even thinking about taking them.


r/moraldilemmas • • Sep 06 '26 Bravo

Personal I found a wallet full of cash and returned it.........

689 Upvotes

A days ago I found a wallet lying on the ground while I was walking home.

I picked it up. Looked inside to see if there was any identification. There was an ID, some cards and quite a bit of cash. Honestly enough cash that for a seconds I seriously considered keeping it.

Nobody was around. There were no cameras that I could see and realistically I probably could have taken the money and left the wallet somewhere.

I kept thinking about what it would feel like to lose that much money especially if the person needed it for something important.

I used the ID to find a way to contact the owner and eventually returned the wallet with everything inside.

They were incredibly relieved. Kept thanking me. I told them it was no deal but honestly it was a bigger temptation than I expected.

I’m not posting this because I think I did something. I just realized that doing the thing can be surprisingly difficult when nobody is watching.


r/moraldilemmas • • Nov 06 '25

Personal I found out my client is reselling my work to customers for significantly more money than I charged - should I keep this up?

632 Upvotes

Throwaway account, because I'm on NDA.

However, I work as a freelance tech consultant, and one of my most consistent clients pays me around $500 for each delivered presentation (google slides powerpoint). Usually, my work is directly with the tech company or entrepreneur, which I originally thought this person was.

However, I realized this individual works for a much larger organization that has some accolades and much better branding than me, and charge their clients around $2,500 for each delivered presentation.

It doesn't change my life much, as I still get work at my rate. However, I realized the company was using their branding and "expertise" on their website to justify their high cost, but what their customers are getting just comes directly from me.

It's possible they're editing the powerpoint before passing it on to their customers in which case they're probably adding value, but I don't know for certain.

Should I just forget about it? It seems a lot of the economy runs like this, such as companies buying from manufacturers for cheap and then reselling for 10x.

Or would it be unethical for me to keep working with this company when I know they are unnecessarily upcharging their customers (who could instead work with me directly for 20% of the price).

*edit - spelling error

* Information -- just for clarity, my moral dilemma is more related to my client's customers rather than how much I should charge. My client's customers are paying a premium price because the organization has great branding and promises their expertise, but I've learned they're just using my work under their "premium expertise" label instead of doing it themselves, despite me having way less expertise than them. How much I'm getting paid doesn't bother me in a moral sense. I'm more bothered by the idea that I'm contributing to an unethical business practice involving false advertising.


r/moraldilemmas • • Aug 27 '26

Personal I found out something horrible about one of my favorite regular customers, and I don’t know how I’m supposed to treat him now

613 Upvotes

I opened a small fast-casual pizza restaurant about two months ago. I’m deliberately leaving out the name, city and any identifying details.
Since opening, we’ve developed a few regular customers. One of them, who I’ll call Bill, is probably our most consistent.
Bill is an older guy, probably in his 60s, who gives off the vibe of a retired dude with a lot of time on his hands who enjoys wandering around downtown and getting to know the local businesses.
He’s incredibly friendly. He learned my name and the names of several employees. He loves our food and constantly tells other people about us. He goes into neighboring businesses and recommends us. He became such an enthusiastic supporter that we gave him one of our T-shirts, and he even offered to distribute coupons for us.
Basically, he was exactly the kind of regular you hope to have when you open a small business.
Then a couple weeks ago, he sat down with me and asked a strange question:
“What’s something that would prevent you from hiring someone?”
I assumed he was interested in working part-time and probably had some kind of criminal record.
I’ve hired people with felony convictions before. I don’t automatically believe that someone’s worst mistake should define the rest of their life, and I think circumstances matter.
While explaining this to him, I mentioned that during our initial hiring process I had encountered one applicant whose background involved a very serious offense against a young child. That was something I personally couldn’t overlook when deciding whom to employ.
As I’m explaining this, Bill slowly raises his hand and says:
“That’s what I have.”
I was floored.
He then disclosed that he himself had a conviction for a sexual offense involving a minor. He told me that he had gone through a rehabilitation program at a nearby facility and was doing well.
I don’t know the details of what happened, and I don’t want to know them. I don’t know when it happened, what his sentence was or what circumstances surrounded it. I’m intentionally not including anything here that could identify him.
I told him that I appreciated his honesty with me, but I couldn’t employ him. My staff includes people ranging from 17 years old into their 60s, and that was simply a boundary I wasn’t willing to cross.
He understood completely and thanked me for treating him respectfully.
But here’s where I’m struggling.
He’s continued coming into my restaurant, and I’ve continued treating him pretty much exactly as I did before. I serve him food, say hello and chat with him.
Yesterday he came in and specifically thanked me for continuing to treat him “like a human.” He told me that having somewhere he can come in, interact with people and feel welcomed has helped give him a sense of purpose.
It was a surprisingly sincere moment.
And I walked away from it feeling incredibly conflicted.
I believe in rehabilitation and second chances. I also believe that someone can do something horrible and still remain a human being. Treating someone with dignity isn’t necessarily the same as forgiving or condoning what they did.
But I also can’t pretend his past doesn’t disgust me.
I can’t un-know what he told me. Sometimes I’m standing there smiling and chatting with the same friendly regular I’ve known since opening, while simultaneously thinking about the fact that this person once did something I find morally reprehensible.
Part of me feels good that I’ve continued treating him like a human being. Another part of me feels uncomfortable that I’m being so friendly toward someone who did something I find almost impossible to forgive.
So I’m genuinely curious how other people would handle this.
Would you continue treating him warmly like any other regular? Would you remain polite but distance yourself? Would knowing his past permanently change your ability to interact with him?
More importantly, **is it possible to believe that what someone did is unforgivable while still believing that the person they are today deserves compassion and basic human dignity?**
I’m genuinely struggling with where that line is.

**Edit : this got way more attention than I thought it would. I appreciate these responses and, as expected, I spotted a few posts that just flat out say “fk pdfs”. Great - I agree - but the point here is what do you do when they’re right in front of you like Bill. They exist. They are in society. At some point down the line someone has to give them food or rent to them or change the oil in their car. I want to take a moral stand but there is no clear high ground here, as many of you pointed out.

Truly enjoying this input - thank you all


r/moraldilemmas • • Apr 01 '25

Personal Is it morally wrong for me to keep an expensive watch I didn’t buy?

550 Upvotes

So, about three years ago I ordered an expensive watch from Cartier for my wife’s birthday. I believe it was right around 5k. On the day it arrived, fedex (I think) showed up with a package. 5 minutes later, a different delivery driver showed up (DHL maybe) and gave me another package. Both return address labels were from the same warehouse in Texas. I figured one was the watch and one was the box or paperwork etc. I opened up the first box and inside was a piece of paper with all of the specs for the Cartier watch as well as a small cardboard box that had a man’s IWC watch inside. I was very confused because the one piece of paper clearly had all of the Cartier specs and had my name and shipping address. I opened the second box and it was filled with a fancy Cartier watch box, fancy Cartier paperwork (really expensive cardstock) a sort of watch purse and the Cartier watch I had ordered. Everything you would expect when ordering a watch.

I figured a mistake had been made and they accidentally sent me the wrong watch. I called Cartier and spoke to someone in customer service. They were very nice and said they would send me an email with details on how to return the watch. The retail price of the watch was 18k so I was obviously nervous. No email ever came. I waited a few days, called again, same thing. I got the person’s name and emailed them, the generic customer service email address, and the VP of marketing for both Cartier and IWC. I explained the situation in detail. I also expressed that for me to return the watch I would appreciate them sending someone from fedex or ups that could physically take possession of the watch and provide a signed receipt that I had given the watch back. No answer. I tried to reach out one more time via email. No response. It’s now been three years and the watch is sitting in my safe. I even have a friend that works for a high end jewelry store and he looked up the serial number and the watch has not been reported stolen. He also confirmed the watch is genuine.

So, is it morally wrong to wear or sell the watch?


r/moraldilemmas • • Nov 14 '24

Abstract Question Facebook family is missing their dog from 2 years ago

539 Upvotes

I unfortunately have been conflicted with a huge moral issue today. I saw on facebook that a family posted about loving and missing their puppy that went missing 2 years ago. Here's the problem: my family had that dog for 2 weeks. About 2 years ago my dog was barking at this stray dog so i put it in a kennel because i couldnt find a collar/name tag on her. The next day i called the vet, and she wasnt chipped either. my dad isnt huge on having more than 2 pets at a time, and we had 2 dogs at that time already. She was super friendly and i made so many found posters and "is this your dog" posts on facebook groups for missing animals in my area. After 2 weeks, we decided that she was too hyper (she was a puppy, we just couldnt do that) for our busy schedules and i decided to put "free to a good home, stray female puppy" on facebook and eventually got an answer. The dog is absolutely THRIVING because the couple that got her had 3 younger kids who have all the time in the world, and shes cleaned up and absolutely spoiled. DILEMMA: I dont know if its a good idea to tell these people what happened to their dog and ive had the worst time today thinking about it...on one hand they miss their dog, but on the other hand, they never saw/reached out and now the dog is safe and happy. i would really appreciate any advice given to me right now!


r/moraldilemmas • • Feb 28 '24

Personal Do I blow the whistle on a relapsed addict Nurse or let the chips fall where they may?

528 Upvotes

A person that I know works as a nurse in the Nicu unit. They are a recovering opioid addict

They have since fallen off the wagon and bad too.

Now I have reasons to believe that they are not actually getting high or drunk at work. But they are most likely having to do a maintenance dose so that they don’t go through withdrawal.

And on the days that they aren’t working, they get blackout drunk, and I don’t think that they are drinking at work because obviously their coworkers would smell it on them.

And finally, they told me that when there’s leftover medication’s, because the babies take such a small dose, that they pocket it and use it to keep themselves comfortable and functioning. Things like benzodiazepines and stuff like that. I don’t know if they mean they’re doing that in the bathroom at work or at home I didn’t even ask because I was so, to be honest, disgusted and alarmed.

I told them maybe they should take a break till they get themselves straightened out and back on track. And they said that’s not something they are able to do because they have financial responsibilities and child support.

I feel like I am in a moral dilemma. Nobody wants to be a snitch, but am I complicit if I don’t tell somebody? What do I do?

I mean, imagine if your baby was in the Nicu and an accident happened. I’m not even saying that the accident would be because of using drugs AT work, but that doesn’t matter.

If they tested the nurses that happened to be on shift if an accident like that occurred, and my friend came up positive for anything, the headline would be

NICU Nurse kills baby due to fentanyl addiction.

What do I do?


r/moraldilemmas • • Jul 04 '24

Personal My friend is seeing a married man - should I tell his wife?

516 Upvotes

My friend started seeing a guy a while ago go who is a lot older than us and he is also married! I told her all the reasons she shouldnt, for her sake personally and for the family’s sake aka the moral problem. She does know it’s wrong and isn’t like keen on that but is attached to him now. It’s been a few months and I’m feeling really bad for the wife - it’s so unfair she doesn’t know and can’t go and get w better husband really, or at least do whatever she pleases with the information. I spoke to my friend about it and obviously she doesn’t want me to do anything but will also not break it off with this guy. I thought sbout just telling the wife (who I don’t actually know personally) but I realised they would definitely know it was me now even if i did it anonymously. I don’t know the guy either and he would definitely be angry, understandably, which I don’t care about but for all i know he could be violent when angry and come and look for me - is that a realistic risk or am I over thinking this? And mainly, what should i do? I don’t want to lose my friendship but she is doing something I thoroughly disagree with anyway and my priority now seems to lie with the unfairness towards this poor wife.