r/modular • • Mar 07 '26

The Dark Side of r/Modular: Envy, Gatekeeping, and Downvotes or Why I Can’t Celebrate Anyone’s Gear in This Subreddit

0 Upvotes

This subreddit is so disgustingly eaten up by jealousy. Even when you wish someone all the best and say you’re happy for them, you get downvoted for it. Every second comment, sometimes it feels like three quarters of them, is aimed at putting the OP down in some way. People try to talk things down, point out flaws, or look for weaknesses just to make it harder for someone to simply share and enjoy their excitement.

And I’ve seen this happen over and over again in this sub. People post their gear, something they clearly worked hard for or saved up for, something they’re excited about. When I comment something positive like “Hey, that looks great, you clearly put a lot of effort into it, I hope you have a lot of fun with that module,” my comment regularly ends up with something like a 47% upvote ratio. That means the majority of people here can’t even tolerate someone being happy for someone else.

Think about that for a moment. People can’t even stand seeing someone else share in another person’s joy.

This subreddit is full of gatekeepers, self-appointed authorities, and pseudo-experts trying to show off how knowledgeable they are by tearing others down. But this kind of place is supposed to be about community. It should be a space for exchange, for curiosity, for new experiences, for pushing a scene forward together.

Instead, what often happens here is the exact opposite. People get discouraged from sharing their excitement because they know that the moment they post something, a wave of negativity will follow. Nitpicking, condescension, and attempts to diminish someone else’s enthusiasm.

And honestly, it feels like this comes from a very simple place. Some people here seem unable to feel joy for others because they themselves feel stuck. They’re not progressing, they’re not excited anymore, and instead of moving forward, they try to hold others back as well.

That’s not a community. That’s just a pile of bitterness gathering in one place.

And it’s honestly unpleasant to watch

So I‘m out…✌️


r/modular • • Jul 20 '24

Watching ’I dream of wires’. What did they do with the girls?

0 Upvotes

2 hrs in. So far less women interviewed than fingers on one hand. Come on guys, many of the pioneers were female. Pretty poor showing tbh.


r/modular • • Aug 18 '25

New space cat 16HP Eurorack blank panels only 8.5 Euros each :)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

https://www.etsy.com/shop/ForbiddenCircuits

For the haters/trolls: yes, my AI has crapped out some more slop that I have slapped on a blank to sell. Cue the outrage: “soulless, talentless, fraud, blah blah.” Please save your typing fingers - heard it all.

For everyone else: I use a cocktail of AI tools to create these images. I keep the price at rock-bottom so you can put something fun in your rack without emptying your wallet.

This is a new 16HP blank: a Giger-inspired space cat. Think cosmic nightmare… with whiskers.

Just 8.5 Euros plus postage - on sale on Etsy. Lots of love from Switzerland 🇨🇭


r/modular • • Apr 03 '24

Modular artists who are BIPOC?

6 Upvotes

Title says it all. I’m not a big dance music fan but if pickings are slim…

UPDATE: Thanks for all the responses, I'm super excited to dig into all these good people's work. I'm a BIPOC mixed race cis male that's in my first few months of messing with DAWless setups and modular via VCV Rack. i hope other BIPOC modular artists will take the opportunity to share their work here and we get to build each other up in the process.

Update 2: Pour on the reco’s! So many diverse artistries from so many different backgrounds I’m very happy to see it. I want to say something for people who are expressing a bit of cluelessness regarding why I’m interested in BIPOC artists and am not bringing a “all modular artists matter” mentality. Frankly, I am indeed mostly only interested in art that is made by people that have a similar lens on the world as I do. That lens is defined by our experiences. And it’s without stretching the imagination too far I think people can understand that a lot of white artists do not share the same experiences as artists of color.

Their access to equipment and funding, access to public performance platforms, and their challenges of just surviving in a white-dominated artist society fosters far more a connection between me and them and their art. I see white artists every day.

On Instagram, Reddit and YouTube I ONLY ever see white artists thanks to the algos which I won’t be arguing the inherent racist nature of programming here but I literally am only served white artists all day every day. I want to see BIPOC artists as well, because representation matters. Black, indigenous, Asian, SWANA, Latinx, queer, gay, and trans art and artists matter. And white artists matter too, but I’ve had my fill. BIPOC artists to the front please.


r/modular • • Aug 10 '23

My current setup

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/modular • • Jun 20 '24

Discussion IMO it’s pretty silly to claim “Modular Is Overrated”

3 Upvotes

It’s not mainstream enough to be deserving of a proper backlash, is it? It’s a way of organizing synth stuff, it’s a form factor, it’s a gear sub-culture, it’s a loose affiliation of various communities, but one thing it IS NOT is massively popular.

Secondly, to claim it’s overrated assumes ratings of gear are worth treating with the same level of scrutiny reserved for a science. Gear culture is not an objective ranking system, it’s a way for companies to get news and information out there, along with the cottage industry of artists and influencers who talk about it. It’s entertainment, its commerce, its basic human stuff, mostly it’s fun.

Finally, “it’s just an expensive hobby” is mostly true, and that’s one of my favorite things about modular. People just like the gear, the processes, the swapping of information, the constant stream of new stuff, the conversations around all of it. I’ve heard hype about gear, sure, but I’ve never once heard a modular person act superior in any way, usually the opposite. It’s just regular folks playing with electricity.

A hobby is good. Enjoying your life is good. Tools for making noises are good. People who take form factors seriously enough to rank them are cool, too, I suppose. Whatever works…


r/modular • • Aug 18 '23

Gear Pics Never owned a Maths. Abacus came in the mail today.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Any maths experts can provide some cool, interesting patch ideas, again I have zero experience with this module, aside from using it as an LFO.


r/modular • • Aug 01 '23

Discussion *sigh*

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/modular • • Feb 23 '25

Introducing Patchpal - your modular companion

0 Upvotes

I've been using r/modular as my inspiration and knowledge source for the last years. I guess like many modular enthusiasts, I love learning new modules, looking up information and watching YouTube videos about possibilities. Getting inspired. Making extensive patch notes on stickies. Like you probably know, however, this inspiration and knowledge will quickly fade.

This got me searching for a place to combine everything related to my modular. And I could not find it. This winter, I set out to build a personal storage for my modular manuals. I have been a product manager for years, but never developed an app myself so I need to learn a lot. Patchpal is my first app, built by and for modular enthusiasts. Currently I am building this app in my spare time, in evenings and weekends. And I think it is time to gather feedback on my ideas, and see if this app could solve other people's needs.

What is Patchpal?

Patchpal is your personal modular knowledge companion. At its core, it helps you:

- Import and store information about your modules from various sources (manuals, YouTube videos, Reddit posts, websites)

- Create a searchable knowledge base that's specific to your rack

- Take personal notes that become part of your personal knowledge base

- Keep all your modular knowledge in one accessible place

- Chat with an AI that understands your personal module setup and can reference all your stored information

The key idea is simple: instead of having information scattered across browser bookmarks, YouTube playlists, and sticky notes, Patchpal brings it all together. You can look through all related knowledge and easily check the sources. Then, the AI can then help you explore and understand this information in the context of your specific module setup.

The Road Ahead

Here's what I'm working on:

- Building a robust knowledge import system that can handle various sources and makes it easy to look through all knowledge that is related to your eurorack

- Creating an intuitive note-taking system that connects with your stored knowledge

- Refining the AI chat system to make interactions more natural and helpful

- Making the platform stable and reliable for more users

How You Can Help Shape Patchpal

Your input would mean a lot to me! I'd love to hear:

- What sources do you currently use to learn about your modules or keep notes?

- How do you currently keep track of all your modular knowledge?

- What kind of questions would you want to ask an AI that knows your rack?

About pricing: The app will need a sustainable model to cover AI costs. I'm thinking about this carefully and would love your thoughts on what would work for you.

Stay Connected

Want to join the journey?

- Visit patchpal.app and subscribe for the closed beta. I will invite you when it's ready.

- Follow me on Instagram: patchpal.app

I'm excited to build something that could help us all make better use of our modular knowledge. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!

--
Edit: Thanks for the discussion on the features of the app, and the clear opinions on AI since I posted yesterday. While I feel that the whole point behind the idea of the app - gathering information sources and notes for easy access for users - has not been understood correctly, I still value all the comments and want to thank everyone who subscribed for the beta.


r/modular • • Dec 28 '24

After a couple of weeks of looking at different modules and thinking what is the most sensible choice for my first purchase I finally pulled the trigger.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Had the M32 already, got the rest of this system used from the marketplace and really wanted to get some granular synthesis modules but dam, those modules are not cheap (Instruo Arbhar looks so cool). Decided for now I’ll just run a hybrid setup and usb all this audio into my iPad or iPhone for fx and sample based synth stuff.


r/modular • • Dec 16 '18

I need feedback.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/modular • • Apr 19 '25

Discussion I don't get it. Why is the one on the left $110 and the module on the right $245? Both American manufacturers.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/modular • • Apr 01 '25

Introducing Threetom Modular’s brand-spanking-new Hole Reaming Service™!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Tired of misaligned mounting holes on your Eurorack modules? Wishing that hole was just that tiny bit looser? . Here at Threetom we know all about the frustrations of holes being too tight for comfort. Luckily, there now is a solution to your plight: Introducing Threetom Modular’s brand-spanking-new Hole Reaming Service™!

Say goodbye to all that unnecessary friction! Our exclusive hole reaming service ensures that every screwing experience is smooth and satisfying. No more awkward angles or unwanted resistance—just a perfect fit every time. Whether you’re dealing with a tight squeeze or an awkward angle, our service will have you screwing with ease.

Do you want to play fast and loose, and loose fast? With our speedy service, your hole will be reamed before you know it!

Call now: 1-800-REAM-ME-NOW for expert assistance(*).

🎯 “Threetom Modular—reaming so smooth, you’ll forget it was ever tight!”

Real Testimonials from Satisfied Synth Enthusiasts:

🗣️ “I used to dread installing new modules—now I actually look forward to it. The moment that screw slid in effortlessly, I knew my life had changed. Thanks, Threetom—you didn’t just ream my hole, you reamed my heart.” — Chuck Laserhawk, Miami, FL

🗣️ “My case hasn’t felt this smooth since 1984. The reaming was fast, professional, and oddly relaxing.” — Crystal Thunderbolt, Ventura, CA

🗣️ “Finally, someone who understands my hole problems. I’m telling all my synth buddies about it!” — Randy Steel, Tulsa, OK

🗣️ “One word: WOW. I got reamed and now I’m a believer.” — Bambi Skylark, Reno, NV

(*) Only available for other brand modules. You won’t need it for Threetom gear—my holes are already perfect.


r/modular • • Mar 25 '25

Behringer eurorack modules are that bad?

2 Upvotes

In Modular Grid website all the Behringer modules are, usually, very bad rated. Wish to know, from these modules users, what they think about them. Thanks in advance.


r/modular • • Jan 01 '26

Beginner Ringing in the New Year with Behrenjour

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/modular • • Jul 16 '24

Gear Pics Fixed the knobs on the abacus

Post image
0 Upvotes

Finally I kan tweak.


r/modular • • Mar 29 '26

About a mostly-Behringer setup

Post image
4 Upvotes

For me at least, the Behringer stuff worked really well as a jumping off point. 4? years into Eurorack and I'm just at the finishing stages of an album which is more than 50% generated by modular. Example : https://youtu.be/Gofnn5OqIec

When I first, belatedly, came across the format I started by recreating the subtractive synth config I was familiar with. I got a Neutron at the same time. Gradually added bits. Made a couple (I'm familiar with electronics).

I haven't (yet) got any of the desktop synth in 4HP kind of things, except arguably I've gone a little the far side of that with a couple of kxmx Daisy Seed-based modules. Well, one is restrained, a dual Karplus-Strong style delay line...ok, I couldn't resist adding a wavefolder to its input that you have to menu-dive to adjust... The other one has about a dozen algorithms on it, homemade with much help from AI. About 50/50 useful/useless.

My setup is rather haphazard. I intend getting a Pam's at the first opportunity, but for now I've got an RD-6 drum machine which has 2 trigger outs (which I clock from Reaper). Plus a couple of midi2CVs (when I can be bothered playing with grids on a screen). Hardly an Oxi but it is surprising how much you can get out of minimal kit. Lacking a Euclidian module etc etc, I've coded quite a few things up as lv2 plugins.

I haven't the funds or energy to gripe about Behringer on any kind of moral grounds. I will gripe about some of their awful designs. Space FX - how could they get it so wrong? The Victor isn't quite as bad, but instead of it being the brilliant thing it could be, it's clunky and rather a pain to use.

My €0.02.


r/modular • • Aug 23 '24

Envisioning the Future of Eurorack

4 Upvotes

Note: If you are happy with modular's limitations, move on. This discussion is not for you. It's for people who want to solve problems and improve things.

Any makers here who are excited by these ideas?

I've used Ethernet cables in DIY electronics projects, and they have some great advantages over other types of cables. Why not use Ethernet cables instead of ribbon cables in Eurorack?

Ethernet cables, built for durability in demanding environments, are cheaper, more robust, and more reliable than fragile ribbon cables. They offer superior shielding and feature secure, easy-to-use RJ45 connectors that reduce the risk of accidental misconnections, which can fry boards. Ethernet cables also support Power over Ethernet (PoE) standards, allowing for power transmission alongside data. Their ability to carry more data at higher speeds opens up possibilities for transmitting complex or multiple signals through a single cable.

Pushing the idea opens up some exciting possibilities. Taking inspiration from Ethernet-connected loudspeakers with programmable cross-over frequencies....

Eurorack 2.0: Ethernet-Based Modular Synthesis

Core Concept

  • Replace traditional ribbon cables with Ethernet cables for inter-module connections (Doepfer A-180-9 already uses ethernet to join rack to rack.)

  • Implement a digital networking layer for module communication and control

Advantages of Ethernet Cables

  • More durable and reliable than ribbon cables

  • Superior shielding against interference

  • Secure RJ45 connectors reduce risk of misconnections

  • Support for Power over Ethernet (PoE) for combined power and data transmission

  • Higher data transmission capabilities

Virtual Patch System

  1. Central Hub:

    • Acts as the system's brain and network switch

    • Manages module registration and inter-module routing

    • Provides power distribution via PoE

  2. Module Registration:

    • Each module connects to the hub via Ethernet

    • Modules use a standardized protocol to register their capabilities

    • Modules expose their "API" - inputs, outputs, parameters, and functions

    • You can still have analog components like an analog filter, but each module would have a digital layer for routing and communication.

  3. Virtual Patching Interface:

    • Touchscreen or computer-based interface for patch management.

    • Drag-and-drop functionality for creating virtual connections between modules

    • Or a device like the Modulation Matrix on the Arturia MiniFreak.

    • Real-time visualization of signal flow and modulation

  4. Preset Management:

    • Save and recall entire system states, including all virtual patches and module settings

    • Cloud synchronization for sharing presets across different systems

  5. Advanced Routing Capabilities:

    • Route multiple signals through a single cable

    • Implement complex routing matrices without physical cable limitations

    • Enable feedback loops and conditional routing based on signal analysis

  6. Integration with DAWs:

    • Direct integration with digital audio workstations like Bitwig and Ableton over USB

    • Seamless transition between hardware and software environments

    • Remote control and automation of hardware modules from within the DAW

  7. Expandability:

    • Easy addition of new modules to the system

    • Software updates for modules to add new features or optimize performance

    • Potential for software-based virtual modules within the same ecosystem

Think of each module as a kind of IoT device that can expose an API when queried and can be fully remote controlled.

Challenges to Address

  • Ensuring low latency for real-time audio processing

  • Developing a standardized protocol for module communication

  • Balancing digital control with the hands-on appeal of traditional modular systems

  • Maintaining backwards compatibility with existing Eurorack modules

UPDATE:

FAQ: Ethernet-Based Eurorack Proposal

Q: Is this still Eurorack, or a completely new system?

A: We can figure that out later. It’s just a proposal to enhance Eurorack while maintaining its core appeal by expanding its capabilities. You could think of it as potentially "Eurorack 2.0" or a new standard inspired by Eurorack. I'd like to it be compatible with "classic" Eurorack modules, so I'm interested in building off that standard (voltage ranges, power, 1v/oct, etc.)

Q: Wouldn't this just be like a DAW with extra steps?

A: No, the goal is to maintain the analog sound path and tactile experience of Eurorack while adding digital control for routing and preset management. It's about combining the best of both worlds - the organic sound and immediacy of hardware with the flexibility of digital control.

Q3: How does this differ from using MIDI controllers with software?

A: MIDI is about notes and durations and controlling a devices parameters. But I think an additional protocol could make device discoverability, such as MQTT, routing and remote control (firmware updates) while maintaining audio signal path.

Q: Won't Ethernet cables be too bulky compared to ribbon cables?

A: This proposal is for replacing backside ribbon cables, not front panel patch cables. There are Ethernet cables as thin as 1.5mm and 6.0mm wide, which are actually smaller than many ribbon cables used in Eurorack.

Q: Aren't RJ45 connectors digital? How can they work with analog audio?

A: Ethernet cables are simply conductors that can carry any type of electrical signal, digital or analog. The proposal is to use them for power, control signals, and routing of analog audio, not to digitize the audio itself.

Q: Wouldn't this system lose the hands-on, immediate nature of Eurorack?

A: The goal is to enhance, not replace, the tactile experience. Knobs, sliders, and patch points would remain. The digital layer adds flexibility in routing and preset management without sacrificing the hands-on control.

Q: Is this compatible with existing Eurorack modules?

A: The system could be designed to be interoperable.

Q: Doesn't this add unnecessary complexity to a simple, working system?

A: While it does add a layer of complexity in terms of infrastructure, it aims to simplify many aspects of working with modular systems, such as complex routing, preset management, and integration with digital tools.


r/modular • • Aug 09 '23

T O P 5 F A V O R I T E M O D U L A R A N D W H Y ?

2 Upvotes

I enjoy discussing on this subject, and I am consistently learning something new, or sometimes finding out about a new modular.

  1. Startlab - Love it, if you take a good chunk of your day just messing around with it, and looking over Strymon Demos on Youtube, you soon will realize how much of a power house this modular is. Filter, Clean Delay, LFO, Karplus String Synth easter egg, Simmer, Quantize Pitch, etc and on top of an amazing reverb. Love to attenuate/modulate the Echo, and Feedback. I can go on, it is my top modular for my rig.

  2. Just Friends - Wow. I think on its own, it is already an incredible modular, however, with Teletype, man, you can just ouright make an EP right there. I love the Synth voice it provides, but I think the utilization of all six voices into a nearness modular just makes it much more powerful. On top of the aesthetic of the modular itself, Mannequins really made some very beautiful, and unique panels. If you already familiar with the such of Tides, or Maths, then you'll know how it works. These modulars are just confusing as hell if you're not familiar with how to utilize them, but all the less, it is my main voice for my rig, and just very much worth it. Sucks that it is so expensive along with the other modulars as well. Wish, mannequins whimsical raps were more consistent with their product release.

  3. Cosmotronic Delta - V (Function Gen) Think Maths, but in 10 HP - I loved Maths, I study that mofo for a good day, and it finally efin' clicked, just like every other Make Noise Modulars, so complex with their design, love it though. Anyways, found out about Delta - V with the input VCA, 10 HP. I was sold. It is a beautiful modular, too, definitely the name "Cosmotronic" reflects in the visual representation of these modulars. So, if you love Maths, please consider looking into this one if you're looking into downscaling.

  4. Triplatt from Intellijel - I know it is a utility, but I just want to appreciate Intellijel design and focus on Utilities, pretty much all my utility modulars are from Intellijel. Very clean design, and just so useful. I tend to attenuate my other modulars, and just mixing, and shaping sounds with these Intellijel modulars, and man, I would love to obtain more, but space, haha.

  5. Surprisingly.. Endless Processor! I was able to buy it recently, and at first, I was not feeling it until, I connected my modulars to a buff > Endless Processor > Mixer. Turned down the input volume, but the output Volume Max < LFO and just a beautiful pad will drone in and out from the mix. I was like fuck, that is just perfect. Need to download the latest firmware for sure, too.


r/modular • • Jul 16 '25

Oops, I did it again… Checked out the $40 Ripples clone.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I knew this would stir the pot - but I had to try it.

After what felt more like waiting for a hand-built Italian supercar than a Chinese mass product, my first Behringer test orders finally started showing up. And yep - here it is: Behringer Surges, an 8HP clone of Mutable Instruments’ Ripples v2.

First impression? Honestly, kind of surprised. The packaging is… actually decent. Gone are the glossy orange-white boxes - now it’s matte black, minimal, with a printed "greeting from Uncle Uli" thrown in. No more antistatic bag either - just a plain clear wrap. Nothing fancy, but a step up.

Then you look at the faceplate - and that’s where the praise ends. It feels like someone was bored in a university lecture and started sketching. Grey on grey, no contrast, no vibe. It works, but it doesn’t inspire.

Build-wise? Pretty much what you'd expect. No panel-mounted jacks or pots, and the patching feel is… let’s say: functional. Not great, not tragic. Just there. But let’s be real - you don’t make music with how a module feels, you make it with what it does.

So, what does it do? It sounds like Ripples. That’s it. Not more, not less - and honestly, that’s exactly the point. It nails the core job.

But here's where it gets interesting - because it’s Behringer. And few names cause more hand-wringing in this community. When a boutique brand puts out a Ripples clone for $200, no one blinks. Behringer does the same thing for $40? Suddenly we’re in a moral panic. Funny how that works.

And sure, you can argue about ethics - but let’s not ignore that a lot of boutique rebrands are just open-source builds with nicer panels. Nothing wrong with that, but let’s not pretend it’s something else. And it’s not like Emilie saw any of that $200 anyway - or am I wrong?

Important to remember: Ripples - like most of the Mutable lineup - was open-source from day one. This isn’t IP theft. It’s legit reuse. That might annoy some gear snobsters more than it actually affects anyone else. Same deal with the Batumi clone. Open-source as well - even if XAOC decided to quietly remove the GitHub repo later. Sure, modules like Abacus or Four Play are more in the gray zone - but let’s be honest: Behringer didn’t start that trend. They just scaled it.

And that’s the thing. Behringer does it at scale. And scale changes the game - for better and worse. It makes modular more affordable, more accessible, more widespread. But it also steps on some toes. Especially if you’ve paid top dollar for a boutique clone that’s now mirrored by a $40 version.

Is that unfair? Depends on your perspective. If you're pushing boundaries with fresh designs - Behringer's not coming for you. That niche is too small and too weird to bother with. But if your business model is reselling open-source clones with a fancy front panel… yeah, this might sting a bit.

So where do you stand? Is Behringer democratizing modular - or just steamrolling it? Or maybe it just hurts when your $200 boutique panel gets outed by a $40 anti-snobster special.

I’m honestly curious where the line is for you.


r/modular • • Feb 02 '23

Used ChatGPT to help understand patching my gear and found it much easier to understand vs YouTube tutorials. Asking questions and getting specific answers in real time is….. luxurious. Is this method considered cheating by this community? I looked briefly and saw no posts about this at all.

0 Upvotes

r/modular • • Oct 07 '25

I figured out how to paint all my panels black :)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/modular • • Dec 28 '25

WHAT DOES V/OCT MEAN?

1 Upvotes

Also where else can I learn about gates, what triggers mean and etc? I’m a noobie with minimal knowledge about vcos and lfos. What books can I read ? Or free online sources you guys like personally


r/modular • • Jul 11 '25

Look ma, Uli sent me to the Skies – and it’s kinda... Cloudalicious.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Picked this up just for fun. A Clouds clone for ~€100? Not much to think about.

Sure, it’s got the usual Behringer quirks – no panel-mounted jacks, they feel a bit cheap when patching. No built-in reverb like Typhoon or Microcell either. But honestly? The core functionality and sound quality are shockingly solid. Strip away all the extra firmware fluff from my ALA Typhoon, and what’s left here still delivers. For this price, it’s kinda wild. Used OG Clouds? Usually more than twice the price.

No frills. No polish. But it works. And it sounds good. I'll keep it.

(Please insert obligatory Behringer outrage below ⬇️)