r/modclub • • Jul 05 '15

/r/modtalk is shutting moderators out of the conversation

4 Upvotes

In light of the recent events, mainly this thread showing us that the admins communicated in there, /r/modtalk is not accepting any applications at all, effectively silencing the voices of their fellow moderators who want to participate in the conversation.

In responses to PMs from several individuals, the stock response is:

"In the past two days we got somewhere between 400-500 applications were usually we get one or two per day at most. It will take a while before we have sorted through everything.

You can send a message to /r/modtalk_advisory but just be aware that it will take a long time."

The mod responded with:

I already sent a message on Friday. Sorry to be annoying, but could you clarify what "a long time" is? Days/weeks/months? I can't imagine that it really takes an impossibly long time to verify that someone is a mod and add them to the approved submitters list - if you dedicate one person at a time to do it in shifts it could be done in a day, tops.

Right now you are actively preventing other mods from joining the conversation, doubly so by shutting down applications.

By this point, I was also growing frustrated and sent the following message. I figured that they really must be overwhelmed by people wanting and and figured that sharing my concerns as well as offering to help them out and make things easier for everyone would be a great way of going about it.

Exchange 1

The next response was a polite "fuck off" which I wasn't very appreciative of.

Exchange 2

It feels like /r/modtalk is either a clique or they've got something going on with the admins. While it's great that they may one day share information here, it's completely unacceptable to actively leave other moderators out of the conversation.


r/modclub • • Jul 03 '15

I am disappointed in all the mods of the subreddits that went dark "caving in" today so easily. Here's why.

4 Upvotes

So a bunch of the subreddits that went dark are coming back online, and I'm disappointed with their reasons for doing so.

We the users, get that the blackouts weren't going to last forever, and that the moderators finally got the admins to talk to them. That's great. But what we're hearing is y'all weren't given any specifics on what was actually changing, and instead were told to expect changes in three to six months. That's just not acceptable. Even if it takes that long to get new mod tools or new admin personnel, that doesn't change the fact that some things need to happen RIGHT NOW before you turn your subreddits back on. Like, resignations.

Of course, everyone wants different things, but simply being told "We hear you, and we'll work on it" just gives the admins more time to do nothing and continue to abuse their power, like they've done for years already. It gives them time to replace your subreddits, as well, which might be in the cards.

I can't speak for all other users, but for me, I implore all moderators to keep their subreddits dark until at the very least:

  1. Someone at Reddit responsible for the firing of Victoria and/or bungling the aftermath of AMA handling resigns.

  2. Reddit releases Victoria from any NDAs, non-competes, or any other restrictive instruments.

  3. Reddit provides a PUBLIC timeline of what they are doing to address moderator concerns over the next X months, including agreed upon penalties if they miss certain milestones (e.g. subreddits going dark again, more resignations, etc.).

Please, moderators, don't let us down by letting the administrators of Reddit off the hook.


r/modclub • • May 28 '14

Hey everyone, I am a moderator of /r/abolish and I am looking for people who feel strongly about abolishing the death penalty to help.

0 Upvotes

We need help populating our wiki and sub with content related to abolishing the death penalty in any way. We call our wiki the "Abolitionist Handbook".

We want to use the wiki to bring new activist up to speed on what is going on with this issue, organizations related to this issue, how they can get involved, etc.

We want to use our sub to

  • bring abolition to the top of the political agenda.

  • unite all the scattered abolitionist groups and activist to one place on the web.

  • educate Redditors on this issue and bring them up to speed.

  • encourage subscribers to create art (videos,poetry,stories,images,etc) that advokates for the abolition of the death penalty.)

  • be a hub of abolitionist news, discussion, and activism

Also, much more in the future. If you think you may be able to help in any way let me know.


r/modclub • • Jun 09 '14

what do you think of my subreddit?

0 Upvotes

i recently added a couple of mods and they made some great improvements to my subreddit /r/razorbacks. what i want yall to do is be as nit-picky as you can in finding things we can still improve. what do you like? what do you dislike? just looking for some feedback from an unbiased group.


r/modclub • • Nov 09 '16

With everybody introducing their subs I'd thought I'd share mine - /r/Trumpablefaces

0 Upvotes

I created this way back. I didn't expect Trump to win so I thought the sub would die out. It's a light-hearted sub about Photoshopping and drawing Trump to make funny pictures

/r/trumpablefaces


r/modclub • • Jun 30 '15

Ban Bargaining

0 Upvotes

The Ban Bargain is a technique to temporarily ban users, to stop them from complaining about being banned, and to curb their unwanted behaviour. If a user makes a comment worthy of a temporary ban but not a permanent ban, initially give the user a permanent ban. The user will then beg to be unbanned in modmail. Tell them you are willing to shorten their ban, if they are willing to never do whatever they were banned for again. They will happily agree, and think they were given a second chance, when in reality you were only going to temporarily ban them, anyways. Make sure to temp-ban them for long enough that they will remember the ban next time they go to make the same type of comment, but not for so long that they completely forget about the subreddit.


r/modclub • • Jul 27 '16

Call for Reddit to roll out 2FA for all users immediately

Thumbnail
change.org
0 Upvotes

r/modclub • • Nov 05 '15

What are some tips for promoting a (NSFW) porn subreddit? NSFW

1 Upvotes

r/modclub • • Nov 10 '17

Reddit is now using an autoresponder when you mail about spam.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/modclub • • Feb 06 '15

I'm drunk, who wants to mod /r/blackpeoplegifs

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/modclub • • Nov 12 '21

r/California is an anti-COVID-19-misinformation zone

4 Upvotes

I am so tired of users commenting with COVID-19 misinformation and FUD that every COVID-19 post to r/California gets this comment sticker at the top.


r/California is an anti-COVID-19-misinformation zone

All users who are commenting in r/California and spouting r/NoNewNornal and r/Conspiracy misinformation will have their comments deleted and will be reported to reddit admins.

For any users who also want to report misinformation to the admins: https://old.reddit.com/report



r/modclub • • Oct 24 '12

I moderate a midsized subreddit. AMA

0 Upvotes

I moderate /r/calvinandhobbes and have since about march. Ask Me Anything!


r/modclub • • Oct 15 '19

Researching moderating - please take my quick surveys

0 Upvotes

Hi, hope this is ok to post. As someone trying to help other mods, and write guides, etc I'm doing a bit of research.

I have a couple of quick surveys and I'd really appreciate your input:

This one is for mods and it's about the help you've needed as a mod: https://forms.gle/JJMNqgjfhKLMhMm67

This one is for everyone and it's about what makes a good mod: https://forms.gle/2fNiFTxpVuHc7WZu8

Thank you for your time :)


r/modclub • • May 24 '26

Rant/vent A member reported me to a su*c*de watch list

1 Upvotes

I wanted to tell someone about this ridiculous harassment that happened to me today.

This one person, not even sure if they were a member, they had very low community activity. They were giving bad advice and blatant misinformation. I commented from my personal account, that the OP should ask in a different sub where there’s more experienced people that could better help them. I didn’t engage with the troll directly, didn’t call them out or anything, but they sought me out anyway. I offered OP direct links to help and tried to stay out of it. The troll wouldn’t stop, I removed the troll’s comments, and gave them a violation because one of their comments broke our no personal attack rule.

I thought the matter was done, I come back to a report in the queue and the troll wouldn’t stop. I had to lock the whole thread. The troll kept editing their deleted comments, trying to dunk on me or something. So I locked and removed the post and told OP to repost or post in the other more appropriate sub, because the people in the comments couldn’t be civil. Mind you 7 hours have passed since I last commented on the thread.

Within seconds of the troll’s last comment and the post removal, I get several notifications. “A concerned redditor reached out to us about you.” With a bunch of resources for crisis help lines, because they were concerned I was a danger to myself.

Seriously, you report me to reddit cares because you couldn’t handle being wrong and having your comments removed. (In case it wasn’t obvious, I’ve never posted anything that would give anyone the idea that I would be a danger to myself.)

I permanently banned the troll almost instantly. I told them why too, using Reddit resources that are actually important to harass a mod would not be tolerated.

It’s just so ridiculous. I’ve gotten the standard death threats and name calling before. But this was a new one for me.

Edit: guess I have to ban the troll from another sub I mod. He went there and is still bad mouthing me.


r/modclub • • Feb 06 '24

Is it possible to take over a sub that was banned being unmoderated?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi there, I wanted to create a sub but then found out it was banned due to lack of moderators. Is there anything I can do to take over this sub since I’m willing to be a moderator now?


r/modclub • • Jan 03 '12

Just setup an unofficial Reddit Blog, what do you suggest me to cover on this site?

0 Upvotes

My Reddit addiction is hitting a new level. Spending hours and hours wasn't enough for me. So I just setup an 'unofficial' reddit blog. It's been set up 24hrs back. However I have filled it with the type of posts that would be mostly appearing here... i.e noteworthy Links or discussions etc and some handy tutorials for newbies.

I would appreciate, If you could suggest what else should I include in my posts or what else should I cover on this blog....

blog: http://sifarat.me/


r/modclub • • Dec 10 '16

A moderator of /r/totallynotchristians here

0 Upvotes

This subreddit got set up a few days ago as a result of a passing joke in /r/atheism. It quickly reached 100 subscribers. I've tried to get the basics in place. Feedback welcome.

Personally my interests are boardgames, philosophy and politics.

EDIT: https://www.reddit.com/r/TotallyNotChristians/


r/modclub • • Feb 23 '22

Looking for German speaking moderators

0 Upvotes

Hey, I am looking for German speaking and working(!) moderators that would be interested to participate in my sociologic study for my PhD Thesis. If there is anyone, I can give you more information on the details. Basically it is about having some interviews and kind of "observe" your work in a digital ethnographic way.


r/modclub • • Nov 06 '22

Miscellaneous Pro Tip for those using post flair: Have a flair for ‘Miscellaneous’

0 Upvotes

I’m always surprised at how so many subreddits don’t have a Miscellaneous flair.


r/modclub • • Oct 01 '18

My first ban. Feel a tiny bit bad about it, because in theory Discordianism is a free-for-all, but this seemed like obvious crap.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/modclub • • May 01 '13

/r/IAmA is looking for new moderators. Follow the link to apply; applications in this post will not be considered.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/modclub • • Oct 16 '12

hi everyone im robotanna

4 Upvotes

hi im robotanna my favorite hobbies are destroying the patriarchy and reading /r/SubredditDrama

here is a complete list of subreddits i moderate:

it is good to meet you all and im glad to be in this cool club!!


r/modclub • • Dec 01 '11

My reaction to getting added.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/modclub • • Dec 08 '15

Kitteh Is Pleased!!

0 Upvotes

Well, you can't imagine my satisfaction upon finding out that she is so pleased.

As long as kitteh is pleased, I know I'm going to have a good day