r/mobileweb • u/mjmayank product • Dec 03 '19
Mweb Release Notes - 12/3
Some bug fixes / improvements that went out over the last couple weeks
Upvoting a comment on a single comment thread no longer causes the page to jump to the top
Close button on post pages takes you back to where you were, rather than the community page
Avatars are now consistent across comments, comment box, and profile page
Comment bar no longer shows your username
When clicking into a comment thread, the page no longer jumps awkwardly
You can now change your avatar by going to your user profile page and clicking 'Edit Profile'
New sign up and log in flow
19
u/HotDiggityDiction Dec 04 '19
What's the ETA on giving us an old.mobile option for those of us that don't like this unnecessary, unintuitive redesign?
Also, why is the Sort by x button so small, with it usually being displayed below a banner ad, it's really annoying.
-19
u/mjmayank product Dec 04 '19
We won’t be creating an old mobile option. We’ll work on making the current version better.
We’ll fix the size of this button.
13
u/Myheartisred Dec 05 '19
We won’t be creating an old mobile option.
And I think I know why; that way, the huge (eventual) difference, not in UI and design changes but in actual lacking features that support core functionalities like a time indicator for post headers! that will have been added under the guise of a "redesign" won't be as immediately noticeable.
I see you have yet to respond to my comment here where I lay this out in detail.
-16
u/mjmayank product Dec 05 '19
Why would we want you to not notice that we’re adding new features? Isn’t it good that we’re adding new features?
I also wish we’d added these features sooner but I can’t change the past.
17
u/Myheartisred Dec 05 '19
Why would we want you to not notice that we’re adding new features?
Because in none of your updates it is mentioned that the lacking time of post headers has been added? I wouldn't call that a new feature, more a core lacking functionality that should have been there all along. Do you honestly want to tell me that mobile web on Reddit didn't have a time indication up until now?
I'd appreciate a response to my earlier comment that I linked to, as well. Thank you in advance.
19
u/assassinate_December Dec 05 '19
New "features"...
I shouldn't have had to click a button to open an entirely new page just to see this single comment. Just make threaded comments work/display as they did before, please. This is really clunky.
7
u/Myheartisred Dec 05 '19 edited Dec 06 '19
You just proved my point by (I think deliberately) evading mentioning it.
Edit: reworded things slightly.
9
Dec 06 '19
Adding features is fine, as long as they are customizable. Right now, I can't see the replies to your comment without loading a separate window, which is burdensome.
And its not even a long thread to justify it. I end up skipping a lot of good discussions because I don't want to load a separate window.
Right now, the avatars function seems like a placeholder, because the real avatars don't even load half the time.
6
u/Aichmalotizo Dec 09 '19
No, we didn't want new features, your redesign sucks, your excuses are shit, and nobody here fucking likes you anymore. All your goodwill is gone. Congrats mang
8
40
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 04 '19
If you are truly working to improve new mobile reddit then when are you getting rid of avatars, removing the pop up frame things when we open a post, eliminating the wasteful new headers, getting rid of those ugly "read more" buttons, putting the collapse comment arrow back, fixing comment indentation, and increasing comment density?
Because all of that needs to be fixed.
34
u/magikarp89 Dec 04 '19
But the old mobile version IS better. That is the version we like and want. We don't want avatars showing, we don't want a new page to read expanded threads, we were all happy with it as it was and it only needed a few minor tweaks if that.
Reddit web has provided an "old layout" option, so there is NO justification for you to refuse to give us the old mobile option other than sheer pettiness. It must be clear to you by now that this is what the majority WANTS.
25
u/HotDiggityDiction Dec 04 '19
Why will you not be creating an old mobile option? There's no reason for there to not be one, avatars do nothing for the end user experience aside from take up valuable screen space, anonymity is one of the trademarks of online forum posting. The show replies button taking you to a new instance still discourages more discussion or deeper reading, which was drew me to reddit usage in the first place, and forcing people to log in to continue viewing a thread is the same thing that drives people to not use things like pinterest or quora, if you make someone have to create an account to see non-nsfw content, they're more likely to NOT do so.
5
u/caboosetp Dec 06 '19 edited Dec 06 '19
Not a reddit developer but I am a web developer.
Maintaining two front ends for the same API can be an expensive nightmare. You need to code and test things twice. Also, some changes to the backend lend themselves better to one front end rather than the other. This means you need to check that all the changes are compatible with both.
It's more work, it costs more money, it takes more time, and it restricts what you're able to do.
11
u/TheVeryNicestPerson Dec 06 '19
And that's fair, they shouldn't introduce an old mobile option. They should just revert all the changes and get rid of the redesign.
7
u/HotDiggityDiction Dec 06 '19
I can understand that, but what I don't agree with is web developers changing things for the sake of change, rather than because someone wanted it. Look at youtube, no one asked for them to change it's layout 30+ times, and yet they have. The same is with this mobile redesign, no one asked for a new mobile format, and yet they did, because the facebook format sells, for whatever reason, even though facebook is an ugly site.
22
18
u/rhen_var Dec 04 '19
Why won’t there be an old mobile choice? I’ve asked you this probably a dozen times and you’ve ignored me every time.
11
u/Senyu Dec 05 '19
The old version is superior in nearly every way. Its function, composition, and design all perform better than what I'm now being forced to see on mobile.
I'm sure you all mean well on uplifting reddit's design into something new (aside from being paid for it most likely), so please genuinely look at the feedback you're getting reassess. There are inherent flaws to this current design, and the choice to ignore these issues will make feedback more vitriol over time.
Ya'll have a chance to do something decent that the community would appreciate, so please stop wearing blinders on these critical issues regarding the current mobile web UX.
10
u/PhreddPewter Dec 05 '19
If you really wanted to improve it you would revert most of the changes this new version has put in place and focus on issues like submitting comments regularly doing nothing until you refresh the screen, at which point the post may or may not have worked.
Or tall images not fully displaying unless you go to the image host or view it in a new tab even if the host is Reddit!
The new login flow and NSFW handling are nothing short of hostile.
Every time a new tweak gets released you guys seem to fix two things and completely dick up five! I don't need more than half my screen taken up by a description of a sub I've been a member of for three years and yelling at me that I've JOINED it.
8
u/Dalek-SEC Dec 06 '19
But you're just making it all worse while you stick your fingers in your ears and go "LALALALALA YOU'RE WRONG, WE'RE RIGHT."
The least you could do is actually reply to people who are telling you what you're doing wrong. It just makes you look spineless.
4
u/duffercoat Dec 06 '19
Is it possible to have a 'simple' view mode that cuts down the excessive features for more content (e.g. hiding avatars) at least? I've been giving the new mobile a chance hoping to adapt to it, but its just not happening. It just feel bloated and awkward now.
4
u/Aichmalotizo Dec 09 '19
You can't fix trash mate. This redesign, is trash. Ditch it, go back to the drawing board, and come up with something that isn't a hot pile of vomit on my phone screen.
3
u/metanoia29 Dec 09 '19
So do you guys just block out any comment where we tell you that the old design was better? Not a single person here has voiced their thanks for things like unnecessary white space, avatars, having to visit new pages for a comment thread after 4 levels, invisible collapse buttons, and more.
I'd assume your role at Reddit is only as a PR man, because the only thing you ever post here is ignorant PR-speak.
1
1
6
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 05 '19
Why did you add a blue indicator next to our username in the comments? This recreates the exact same problem you just solved by removing usernames from the comment box! Please remove this icon next to our username in the comments immediately.
Since you seem to fail to understand what removing the name from the comment box was about, let me spell it out for you: there should be no way to tell what my username is from looking at the screen. I want to be able to show someone the comments on a post and be able to scroll through them without that person being able to tell what my username is.
-4
u/mjmayank product Dec 05 '19
That indicator has always been there. It's not new.
5
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 05 '19
Really? I don't remember it being there previously on the mobile site.
I guess I could be wrong about the icon being new, but I would still request that it be removed for the above reason.
5
Dec 07 '19
The green icon next to usernames has not always been there. There has been an icon next to an OP's comment, but never on any individual's username on the mobile browser. Stop gaslighting us.
2
9
u/Sagasujin Dec 04 '19
Thank you for finally letting me at least somewhat get rid of my avatar by setting it to a blank white image. At least now I'm less annoying to myself and hopefully I can inspire others to make life easier on the neuro diverse. For everyone else reading this, would you consider setting your avatar to a blank white image so that I can maybe eventually look at reddit without causing a headache.
7
u/Sagasujin Dec 04 '19
And darn, my new white avatar isn't showing. Nvm then. Back to desktop mode I go.
4
u/twentyonesighs Dec 04 '19
Just to let you know. I do see it. All white.
4
u/Sagasujin Dec 04 '19
Yay at least something is working for someone.
3
u/PnDaPocket87 Dec 04 '19
Just an FYI that I'm with you and I've changed my profile to the white page as well.
Totallt up to you but I would maybe suggest making this suggestion it's own post.
I think this community at the very least will jump aboard and hopefully it can spread.
At any rate thanks again for coming up with this.
3
-9
u/mjmayank product Dec 04 '19
There's a bug where when you reply it doesn't show your avatar right away. If you refresh you should see it though (I see it). We'll fix this bug.
27
13
u/PhreddPewter Dec 05 '19
The community has responded with a resounding 'We do not want avatars'.
They are distracting, they precious screen real estate, they use additional data and they are problematic for people with certain sensory issues.
They need to be removed or allowed to be completely disabled.
6
Dec 06 '19
It's rather confusing to see avatars on mobile and then go back to the classic desktop design on pc and have nice, clean threads.
4
u/OnlyForF1 Dec 13 '19
/u/mjmayank, The mobile web version has stopped remembering my choice to use the (old Reddit) desktop version of Reddit instead. It feels like I need to re-enable the desktop version every day.
2
u/IntrepidDreams Dec 17 '19
It apparently only lasts 1 day now. You can ask /u/mjmayank why, but odds are he won't reply.
https://www.reddit.com/r/bugs/comments/eaodsq/comment/fb2soit?context=1
-2
u/mjmayank product Dec 17 '19
There is currently no way to get back to mobile web after clicking that, and we noticed a lot of users were getting lost on old reddit desktop. The old setting meant that now they were stuck there for an entire year. Maybe we could make it so logged out users save the setting for longer, since they know what they are doing.
6
u/Sagasujin Dec 17 '19
... There's a link for "mobile website" right at the bottom of the page on desktop mode.
I have circled the correct button on a picture in case you can't find it readily
4
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 27 '19
There is currently no way to get back to mobile web after clicking that
That's not true.
I'm looking at the full page on my phone right now, there is a link to reddit mobile at the bottom.
2
u/Sagasujin Dec 15 '19
That's been going on for me since the beginning of December. I've posted about it and gotten nowhere. The devs won't even acknowledge this problem.
1
u/IntrepidDreams Dec 17 '19
It's not a bug, it's a feature!
No, seriously. They think you aren't capable of making a decision on your own.
https://www.reddit.com/r/bugs/comments/eaodsq/comment/fb2soit?context=1
4
u/StopLinkingToImgur Dec 03 '19
You did something somewhat competent for once. Wow.
8
u/StopLinkingToImgur Dec 03 '19
I retract my statement. My avatar is still the default, even though I changed it.
7
-3
u/mjmayank product Dec 04 '19
If your profile is marked as NSFW then we don't display your avatar. I agree that it's unclear as to why your avatar isn't being displayed however. We can figure out a solution to this.
18
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 04 '19
So what is to stop someone from putting a NSFW avatar on their profile that is not marked as NSFW and causing family friendly subreddits to be filled up with explicit pictures? Because your new avatar system is definitely going to end in r/aww being full of dicks and gore.
8
Dec 05 '19
Instead of not their displaying avatar, now there's an annoying red circle that highlights a potentially NSFW user.. this is the opposite of an improvement. Before, I could scroll through hundreds of comments without any indicator of the users other history. even the multicolored snoos were better for anonymity. Did you not read any of the comments regarding accessibility?
3
Dec 06 '19
Having red "18+" avatars makes me feel like I am reading porn related stuff when in public.
17
u/PnDaPocket87 Dec 04 '19
Please - wasn't there supposed to be a fix (reversion) about working to eliminate or reduce the occurrence of the "more replies" for logged in users at least?
It's getting intolerable.
10
u/HeterosexualMail Dec 05 '19
for logged in users at least
Please fix this for all users. When I visit reddit on a mobile device I can often be on different devices or even just a different mobile browser and I have no desire to log into reddit.
6
u/PnDaPocket87 Dec 05 '19
I'm with you 100%. They had made this "for logged in users" bs statement in one of the previous bs feedback posts which is what I was referencing.
But I agree - which is why when they say "we want to improve mobile web not drive users to the app" it makes them look really bad considering they're on record on this sub as saying they want to make updates for logged in users but not all.
17
u/HeterosexualMail Dec 05 '19
Still too much clicking required. This update will not bring me back to reddit on my mobile device. I've stopped visiting on mobile since the redesign was launched. Reddit is no longer a part of my mobile habits. This is all because of the poor UX of reading comments.
Will this be addressed or not? I left a detailed comment about why it is poor UX here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/mobileweb/comments/dwzhlz/mweb_release_notes_1115_feedback_thread/f7moltv/
Will the team engage more with this community and find out what the issues are? I know you might feel like you've fixed a bunch of things, but it has not addressed the core UX complains we have that were not present in the old design.
9
u/HeterosexualMail Dec 05 '19
/u/mjmayank can we get an idea about whether or not you're going to tackle this issue soon? It was the second most upvoted feedback in the initial post-release thread yet there has been no communication from the team about whether or not you'll fix it. It's horrible UX and is causing me to refuse to use the mobile reddit site, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.
16
u/ProntoPupSalesman Dec 04 '19
I have a problem with the see replies function now. I browse Reddit on private on my phone so it's a pain in the ass to log in all the time so I usually stay logged out. Now it won't let me see more comments unless I log in, is there anyway to fix this?
5
u/abiostudent3 Dec 05 '19
Same. Plus it keeps logging me out whenever I come back to a page I've left open.
(That might just be from the wrong adguard settings, though.)
31
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 04 '19 edited Dec 04 '19
Are you seriously forcing people to create accounts if they want to read reddit comments? That's a fucking terrible idea that should be undone immediately.
Of all the changes you have made, this one is far and away the worst and has the potential to kill the site by driving away new users.
You incompetent clowns.
13
u/waidt99 Dec 04 '19
I think the excessive amount of see replies button is back for me.
It's also very annoying to be taken to a new page for one additional reply. Just let them chain down like before.
12
Dec 04 '19 edited Mar 29 '22
While this is great, you should have just gotten rid of the whole darn update
12
u/im29andsuckatlife Dec 05 '19
Mobile site now forces you to have the app to view NSFW content. Im not talking about porn. I mean anything. I enjoy the wtf subreddit and now I can't because it says I need the app to verify my age. That's straight untrue, an app doesn't do that any more than someone clicking a box to say yes. I do not like the direction this site is going
2
u/caboosetp Dec 06 '19
If this was true, I'd he upset. However I'm not running into this issue. Even not logged in on incognito it just had the normal nsfw prompt.
Is this change only rolled out to some people or is there something else wonky going on here?
5
u/im29andsuckatlife Dec 06 '19
It appears to be intermittent? Because I just tried it again and it is not there. However, for about 2 hours last night any time I checked something it required the app. I also now get 403 errors when trying to see a gif on mobile site.
2
u/caboosetp Dec 06 '19
Have you tried clearing the browser cache? I had some bugs pop up last night before I did.
10
u/Lion12341 Dec 04 '19
There's still the problem of the new update being complete bollocks. Is there any plans for a solution or do we have to stick to https://i.reddit.com/ or the desktop site?
10
u/MadOmnipotentSelf Dec 05 '19
(Reposting from the previous thread in the hope of getting an answer)
In the 7 Nov release notes post, you said that you would fix the "read more" buttons:
We heard your feedback regarding the recent testing that we did. You all said that it required more tapping to read conversations, and the read more button was annoying. We are updating the new comments page redesign so that the shorter conversations and "read more" button changes don't apply to logged in users. These updates should be releasing next week.
Are you able to say anything about how this is progressing?
(I don't see why this should be limited to logged in users, but at this point any improvement would be welcome.)
3
10
u/PmTitsForJokes Dec 05 '19
Can you fix the see more replies bullshit like we've asked over and over and over? Why would anyone want to load a whole new page to see one comment. Not everyone has unlimited data. I barely browse on mobile anymore because of this shitshow.
10
8
8
u/mindwarp42 Dec 09 '19
(takes a look at mweb for the first time in probably a week, sees that it has gotten uglier and worse, still hurts my head as my eyes STILL jump all over the place thanks to the accessibility issues brought up multiple times by neurodiverse users haven't been addressed)
You know mweb Reddit devs, if you wanted to make this look like a social media site knockoff, congrats. Guess what. You drove this social media hater to Twitter, as I mentioned over there. I would have posting/reading over here a lot in my most read subreddits due to stuff in my fandoms that is going on right now. Instead, I'm elsewhere, because I I cannot use this design because it literally, not figuratively, hurts me. Migraines due to sensory overload/eye strain are not fun. So, bye, Reddit, using you on a regular basis.
7
u/sf4096 Dec 17 '19
Gentlemen, I am about to give up reddit on mobile with all the changes the devs made.
Devs: You have won! You successfully drove me away from reddit mobile.
Devs: You have lost! As I am not going to use reddit crappy app. It is utter garbage and it should not exists.
Please explain to me why a website needs an app? Seriously?
I can't have incognito/private browsing in the app. I can't open new tabs.
It is absurd that you need to be logged in to view comments on second level. It is absurd that you need to use the app for NSFW content. This exact content I am certainly not going to use app for.
What was the reason for "read more" button? What was the reason for "more from $subreddit" in comment section? All these are anti-features.
Fuck you for trying to force me to use your shitty app. You are supposed to be developing mobile version of a website and not forcing people to use your crappy app.
Now to the solutions: can anyone point me to the firefox extension I can use to revert the changes these idiots did?
2
u/Extroverted_Recluse Dec 27 '19
Please explain to me why a website needs an app? Seriously?
Apps harvest more of your personal data from your phone than webpages, and reddit can use that to make $$$ by either targeting advertisements at a more granular level, or just outright selling your data.
Anyone who claims it's about improving the user experience is lying to you.
6
u/SevenTom Dec 04 '19
Anyone else getting a '403 Forbidden' screen when trying to view gifs?
I also seem to sporadically get a blank black page when opening some posts which keeps causing me the need to refresh the page.
6
6
Dec 05 '19
Why is there now a green marker on my username next to all my comments? Please stop adding unnecessary changes.
6
u/Budget-Welcome Dec 27 '19
👏👏👏I 👏 will 👏 never👏use👏your👏shitty👏fucking👏app👏stop👏asking👏👏👏
I will never look into this account again, but thanks for making me use it to view more comments.
5
u/graepphone Dec 15 '19
How bad must a design be when the only way to complain is to find this out of the way sub.
It's incredible that every decision you make just ends up with a worse product. You think you'd at least hit 50/50
4
u/Zuzubar Dec 13 '19
The developers of this mobile UI are a bunch of failures. Everybody involved should be embarrased. Get your act together. Listen to your users. Do the right thing.
4
Dec 16 '19
suddenly I cant see my followed subs. Suddenly on some pages I cant see NSFW content without the app. I can see the followed subs drop down before I log in, but the second I do its not there. Yall destroying the mobile site. Keep up the good work
3
u/caboosetp Dec 06 '19
It's only showing up in single comment threads for some reason, but I really like where the comment replies are starting father left. It looks like the avatars overlap vertically a little bit. This is great because the fourth comment down is now a little less than a quarter of the way across my screen instead of halfway. If this change could be applied everywhere I'd be very happy.
I know many people in this thread are hating on avatars, but I like them. They help me spot who is commenting in multiple places easier.
I just realized that my settings for "open a link in a new page" doesn't apply to mobile. I don't remember if it did before, but I've trained myself to hold down and tap open in new tab, so I assume it wasn't. If this could be added to mobile that would be great. I like opening multiple pages before I actually go and read through them.
2
u/HelicopteroDeAtaque Dec 28 '19
How the hell do you access the subreddits you're subbed to as well as /all and /popular?
0
Dec 04 '19
[deleted]
18
u/Hairy_S_TrueMan Dec 04 '19
Posted a top level comment on this second issue before seeing your reply. It's 3 months old at this point.
0
Dec 04 '19
[deleted]
19
u/Representative_Panda Dec 04 '19
Have the last three months taught you nothing, I thought that answer was a very clear and resounding"yes".
19
u/Hairy_S_TrueMan Dec 04 '19
Have you been looking at a solution to the 3 month old permalink context bug? #1 threat to my reddit flow.