Look I’m starting off by saying this is my opinion…
Every full open world PVP MMO sucks and the reason I think it does is: Players don’t value their lives…
Let me use an example here. If you have ever played a role play server of a popular game (maybe red dead redemption, GTA V etc.) then the concept of valuing your life isn’t new to you.
For everyone who hasn’t let me give a quick run down. Valuing your life in playing a game means you don’t do stupid things that can get you killed because… well… you don’t want to die. In a role play setting it is easy to follow along because you CHOOSE to do so. You simply follow the rules of that server. This leads to open world pvp in a meaningful way. You don’t ignore the gun to your head, you don’t rush a group of 10 people by yourself, you don’t do things that would get your character likely killed.. value.. your.. life..
Pvp mmos try to implement this system through various means.. whether that is ‘you lose all your items on death’ or a karma system that gives you corruption for killing/attacking first they all try to implement value your life through rewards/punishments for doing certain actions, and in large part this punishment is performed on your character when you die…
So if they all have mechanics to simulate Valuing your life why do they not work? Well, it’s simple.. because a singular life doesn’t mean anything in an mmo… these penalties are not penalties.. if you get killed while ganking a group of players you don’t really lose anything. Nothing happens to you, there are no consequences. You respawn and can keep playing the game.
Even for karma system games you get a slap on the wrist at most..
I think open world pvp mmos give too much leeway to bandits and ruffians.. it makes no sense that you have these civilized, beautiful mmo worlds with large cities, kings, empires.. yet the law does not apply to the player.. oh you killed a bunch of people? Yeah you can go to the same town as everyone else, you won’t get arrested…
You are in a griefing guild? Well your guild can bank and trade the same as any other guild.. you have no restrictions..
You charge into a fight and gank a bunch of players? Well your singular life in that mmo isnt valuable so you feel no reason not to risk…
This is my point right here.. pvp mmo systems have no real balance to just a slaughter house. It makes pvp hollow and a gank fest rather than something meaningful you do as part of a conflict, robbery, mugging etc… there are no real punishments on disregarding the value of your life so you can get away with doing awful things and even just suiciding yourself over and over with no real problem…
Some solutions I think that would work:
law/bounty systems (can’t go into cities, get arrested and imprisoned for real life days etc.)
actual meaningful deaths (not just losing your stuff, maybe not being able to log in for a couple hours.. if you were the first to attack/do something bad maybe the penalty is 2x worse)
large groups of bandits, pvpers etc. wouldn’t be able to interact with lawful cities etc. and have to get by not being able to use the same banking systems and what not..
I’m just tired of poorly designed, weak willed open world pvp systems that don’t give any sort of punishment to bad players, gankers, and most of all no value to life..