r/mixingmastering • u/[deleted] • Feb 28 '24
Discussion A warning for anyone seeking advice online
My Warning
I’ve learned that asking for advice online can sometimes actually cause more harm than good. Take all advice online with a grain of salt!
Background
A few days ago I came to this group to ask for some advice. I asked if anyone knew any techniques to make soft singing sound louder over a loud mix, or if doing so was impossible. I mentioned:
-I was mixing a loud jazz song, but the singer sang softly, and she was a bit shy.
-We recorded in an apartment with thin walls, so we were concerned about annoying the neighbors.
-I was quite happy with the current performance, it was just a little on the soft side.
-I was already playing with EQ (specifically, lowering frequencies that would be drowned out by the loud band in a live environment), reverb, delay, exciter, and compression.
-I would continue to adjust those settings in an attempt to fix the problem.
The general consensus from the group was that it would be impossible to fix this in the mix, and I had no choice but to re-record louder singing. I took this at face value. I thought that by opening the question to a group of my peers, I had been educated and enlightened. So, the next day I asked the singer if she could sing louder. She said, "Sorry, no, I'm just a soft singer." I hit a low point of despair, thinking I was going to have to abandon the song I loved.
Then I realized that the main problem was that I was mistakenly taking the advice from the group as 100% expert knowledge. Normally I wouldn't have asked anyone for advice while working on a specific project and just plowed ahead working with what I had. I often enjoy embracing the challenges of making good mixes from flawed recordings. In hindsight, I probably shouldn't have come to the group for advice, and I definitely should not have taken the response as hard truth.
Why Online Forums Are Not Ideal For Getting Advice
Online forums are not like sitting in a room full of peers. In that real-world situation, I would have openly asked the group my question. I likely would have unintentionally left out some details, but my peers would ask for clarification about the missing details, and everyone would listen to those details. Then everyone would, one by one, make suggestions about the issue. As the conversation proceeded, the result would ideally be some agreed-upon advice. However, my experience felt more like walking into a party, shouting out my question, and then sitting there while every person in the room would walk up to me, give their two cents, then leave. Not the most efficient way to get advice.
About Me
Before I continue, I should describe where I’m coming from. I have a diploma in audio engineering and over 25 years of experience in recording and mixing as a hobby. I have continued educating myself in audio engineering by reading books and speaking with fellow audio engineers. I have collaborated with and recorded other musicians many times. I have successfully worked with many flawed recordings and made good mixes. I have worked with all types of musicians with different personalities. I too am a musician and have played in a few bands and released multiple albums. I also have a degree in linguistics and psychology, if that's somehow relevant.
Disclaimer
Before I start listing off some examples of bad replies, I want to say that this is not meant to be an attack on the users. Attacking each other won’t fix anything. I’m merely trying to point out flaws in the system. Perhaps as commenters, we can all look at these examples as things to be mindful of before we give advice. I don’t expect every reply to be perfect. I understand that everyone is human. When interacting online you’re dealing with the anonymous public, and you have no idea who’s on the other end. I myself am definitely guilty of writing stupid comments after I’ve been into the whiskey. I sincerely appreciate all the users who were genuinely trying to be helpful. If nobody replied to each other’s posts then the system would be even more broken than it currently is.
Problematic Responses
Here are some examples of things advice seekers should watch out for.
Arrogance
I’m the type who believes that I will always be a student. The more I learn, the more I realize I have more to learn. We can never know everything about mixing. Asking our peers for advice is not a weakness, but a strength. Every song is different and can be a learning experience. However, many replies had an arrogant know-it-all tone to them. Generally, it seemed like many of these users felt the need to reply with something, anything, regardless of how useful or accurate it was. I’m not sure why. As usual, some users felt the need to express that they felt my post was somehow a waste of their time. Ultimately, these replies were actually wasting everybody’s time.
2) Discouragement
Many users lacked a sense of encouraging fellowship. Some users were basically stating:
-This definitely cannot be fixed during the mixing stage.
-This is a tracking issue, you’re in the wrong forum.
-You can’t record in an apartment.
3) Incorrect Assumptions
It seemed that many users didn't bother to carefully read my post. It also seemed that they didn’t bother to read what others had already suggested, and didn’t attempt to build on those conversations. Furthermore, almost nobody asked for more details or clarification before giving their advice. Here are some examples:
-Many users made assumptions about the relationship dynamic between myself and the singer. They didn’t realize that the singer and I are friends who are collaborating on a hobby project together. Therefore, getting a different singer isn’t in the cards. I was surprised at how many users suggested this. From my experience getting a singer is not like picking out a case of beer. I’ve always had to cooperate with whoever was willing to perform for me. When it comes to how they perform, the ball has pretty much always been in their court. I myself am a terrible singer and not a singing coach. I have learned that many artists are defensive when using this approach, myself included. I feel like most musicians would understand this. Also, recording again isn’t always a possible option, for many different reasons.
-Many replies assumed that both myself and the performer are wildly inexperienced and uneducated. Some very basic advice included:
-Turn up the volume.
-Record again.
-Use a reference track.
-Ask her to sing differently.
-Some users assumed that the singer wasn't even close to singing it correctly. They thought I was trying to work a miracle by “making a whisper sound like a scream”. The reality is she sang pretty loud on the performance, just not quite loud enough for my taste. I had already mentioned in the post that I was happy with the performance. Surprisingly, nobody used the phrase “without hearing the mix myself…” before giving their advice.
-Some responded as if I hadn't tried anything at all before asking for advice. I had mentioned in the original post that I was already playing with several advanced methods. That should have been a clear hint that I was well past the “turn up the volume” approach.
-Most replies seemed to assume that I had unlimited resources available to me. That works well in theory, but how many of us actually have that privilege? If you only have a crappy guitar to record with, you can’t just go out and buy a Gibson. You use the crappy guitar and fix it in the mix. Remind yourself it will probably add some unique character to the track. I know this process well. The project I was asking about is a hobby project with a budget of $0. We’re not prepared to start driving to the city to rent studio space. We can’t hire another singer. This is exactly why I was asking if I could fix it in the mix.
Helpful Responses
There were a few helpful responses that were buried beneath the other comments. For those individuals I’m grateful. One user gave specific EQ settings, which came in handy. Some nice people gave nothing more than words of encouragement, which is helpful in its own way. My favorite reply was, “Mix the song around the performance you have.” I love this because that experimental approach has always been my philosophy. All recordings start organically, and we have very little control over what the natural world produces. I believe the best way to approach a mix is to have loose expectations about the outcome. Do you think the Beatles knew exactly how their songs were going to turn out from the start?
If I were to give some suggestions to someone else with this issue, I would have replied:
If you find have to rerecord, try recording while having the singer wear isolation (drummer) headphones so she has to sing loudly enough to hear her own voice. I’ve used this trick myself.
Find a reference track of a band that is loud but has a soft singer. Some examples (which show my age) might be:
-Smashing Pumpkins’ "Today"
-Garbage’s "Only Happy When It Rains"
-Silversun Pickups’ "Panic Switch"
Conclusion
In the end, I was able to fix the issue in the mix, with a result I’m totally happy with. This is proof that the general consensus (most “upvoted” reply) was false, and the system is flawed. I think the “upvote” method is an enemy of logical conversation. It makes what’s popular more valuable than what’s true. Obviously, I won’t be relying on groups like this for any more advice. For anyone seeking advice like I was, I would suggest finding a mentor, or a small “committee” of advisors. Get in touch with someone whose advice you can trust, and have a one-on-one dialogue with them.
Final remarks
That wraps up my rant. To summarize once again, if you are searching for advice online, avoid taking it at face value. This applies to YouTube channels and the like too.
Now bring on the “downvotes” and replies...