r/mixingmastering • • Mar 06 '25 Helpful

Discussion Last Words of Reddit Advice from a Retiring Engineer

931 Upvotes

Long story short, after a 15+ year run of working pretty much exclusively on other people's music in a formal/professional capacity, I've recently decided to go in the total opposite direction and instead focus on my own personal creative endeavors. I'll probably still continue to be selectively involved with projects here and there when people reach out to me and it feels worthwhile, but I'm not going to pursue or focus on the provision of my services to others anymore. As potentially difficult and frustrating as it might be, I'm going to finally take on myself as a client, in a sort of ongoing, collaborative, exclusive management type role. Even if doomed to failure, it's still *maybe* the best thing I can do with my time and energy. Only one way to find out. Wish me luck.

As part of this change, I am disconnecting from "the internet" as a whole, particularly Reddit, where I've spent a ton of time and energy over the last 6+ years. I thought it would be nice to bid farewell somewhere, and I figured, what better place to do that than here on this subreddit, the last stronghold of respectable discourse that is r/mixingmastering. There are other audio/music/production/engineering subreddits that I won't mention because this subreddit is, to put it simply, the best in every way by a significant margin. I've never once seen u/Atopix give bad advice, make a poor judgement call, or lose patience. You guys are in good hands here.

Anyways, I'm more recently of the belief that it's pointless to try to give others advice, but I'll have one last go of it here. I most likely won't be responding to comments, so it's up to you guys to make of this what you will. Try these ideas, or challenge them, or prove me wrong -- all of those things are fine. I honestly don't care anymore. I'm just so done with the internet lol. More on that to come. Also note that in order to cover everything I want to touch on within a timely manner of one sitting, I'm not going to provide a super in-depth explanation for every point. I started to do that with the first one, and then realized this would just be a full-blown novel. Please understand. Here we go. In no particular order;

NUMBER ONE. Be mindful of where you get your ideas/advice/information from. Consume *way* less music production content from YouTube, social media, and the internet as a whole. Or better yet, avoid it altogether. The collective average quality of information on the internet has gotten progressively and severely much worse in recent years with the advent of content creation emerging as a predominant craft/industry in and of itself. The resulting collective brainrot has been a crazy phenomenon to witness. Some of you haven't been at this too long, but even just in the few years leading up to the covid era, it wasn't like this at all. Just avoid content consumption as much as you can. Even just the secondhand effect of being on Reddit a lot has been enough to inspire me to go offline.

But... I will add, that if you have a super specific technical question, use Google, or ChatGPT, or use YouTube like a search engine. Like, "What version of ____ software is compatible with OS version ______?" That's good for ChatGPT. For super niche OS / software installation / bug fix / DAW editing tool things, you can sometimes find a YouTube video with like 100 views that is the exact answer, with someone doing a nice walkthrough. But *definitely* break the habit of turning to the internet for every single thought that enters your mind, and avoid infotainment content creators like the plague.

NUMBER TWO. Get the bulk of your inspiration/information from things like;

  • Shuggie Otis

  • Tape Op (free magazine that rules)

  • Interviews with creative thinkers (including artists, authors, directors, actors, et cetera)

  • Books (Mixing Audio by Roey Izhaki is my personal go-to recommendation)

  • Other mediums of art (movies, novels, visual art)

  • Life experiences

  • Cover other songs

  • Learning an instrument / about music (crazy that this even needs to be said)

NUMBER THREE. Use references / have a solid, collective, irrefutable foundation of what you believe is good. Make a reference playlist, and know how it sounds so well that you can use it to assess different monitoring environments and compare your in-progress works to it. Continue to update it over the years. Know what the absolute best sound possible actually is *to you*. (This point is particularly relevant to mixing / mastering.)

NUMBER FOUR. Your monitoring should be both as accurate and as highly familiarized as possible. Your reference playlist, on your monitoring, should ideally sound *perfect* to you. This is a prerequisite for having a clear, informed target to aim at. Otherwise, you are aiming in the dark. If that combination doesn't sound perfectly right to you, adjust all of the different variables until it does. Room, monitoring devices, placement, treatment, calibration. Get it dialed in until it sounds as right to you as possible. If you're in a situation where you can't effectively optimize those variables, then just consider your speakers as an alternate monitoring source, and use open-back headphones as your more accurate reference. I've tried pretty much every popular headphone model there is, and while my personal preference are calibrated HD800S, I generally recommend ATH-R70x as the best out-of-the-box performance for the price. No matter what headphones you use, r/oratory1990 is an absolutely incredible resource. (Again, this point is particularly relevant to mixing / mastering.)

NUMBER FIVE. Beyond monitoring being accurate/familiar enough, gear doesn't matter all that much. There, I said it. Just use what you have available. I cannot stress this enough. I've seen people spend their entire lives just gradually swapping out pieces of gear with new purchases and never actually making anything. Give me a piece of shit broken guitar with 1 string and a single RadioShack microphone, and I will come up with something that my mom will like. Trust. Thump that mic on your palm and low-pass it; kick. Pitch that guitar down an octave; bass. Make beatbox sounds into the mic; beatbox sounds. Nice. Record multiple tracks of single note stuff on guitar and put crazy effects on it; fucking *cool*. (Not too many though -- 2 to 3 is already plenty. More on that later.) Seriously, you have a freaking single piece of software on your computer that will let you do literally anything sonically imaginable, and you're worried about theoretical comparisons between spec measurements? Are you kidding me? Just make some gotdamn music.

NUMBER SIX. Understand that making fully realized commercial-grade music consists of multiple, chronological (for the most part), interconnected stages. While there can be *some* overlap, the later stages generally cannot exist without the earlier stages. Coincidentally though, those later stages are where many beginner engineers these days tend to place a massively disproportionate amount of their attention. (You can thank the collective phenomenon of infotainment brainrot content for that.) But as much as you want it to, it just don't work like that, babygurl. You can't effectively work on the interior design of a house and arrange the furniture before the foundation is completed, the walls are up, et cetera. Those stages for music are;

  • Composition. I.e., lyrics (if there are any), melody, chord progression / underlying harmonic pattern, song form / structure. So far, this just exists as a performable idea, and/or on paper.

  • Arrangement. I.e., exactly what notes different instruments are playing and at what times. So far, this still just exists as a performable idea, and/or on paper.

  • Production. I.e., exactly *how* the performance of the song and/or arrangement elements are captured, programmed, created, or otherwise turned into a tangible recording. The end result of this stage are the cleaned up, edited, and organized multitracks.

  • Mixing. I.e., shaping the beginning-to-end sonic presentation and trajectory of the production's listening experience.

  • Mastering. I.e., a trusted second set of ears providing 1) Experience, capability, and taste. 2) Accurate and fully familiarized monitoring. 3) A greater degree of objectivity.

Tracing our steps backwards from the end, it is generally true that a "good" (let's say, commercial-grade) end result, i.e. master, can only be *reliably and consistently* achieved under certain, predictable conditions. (*Can your cat run across your MIDI keyboard, your grandma accidentally move some faders around while trying to send an email from your laptop, and your buddy-who-knows-a-guy's mastering engineer, aka 15 year old cousin, slap Ozone on that masterpiece and make something that sounds commercial-grade? It's theoretically not *impossible*, sure. A bunch of monkeys in a room with typewriters will eventually recreate Shakespeare word-for-word *eventually*, if they live infinitely long and never run out of paper or ink.*) But otherwise, generally, for the vast majority of the time, aside from very special and unlikely exceptions... A good final end result can only result from a good mastering engineer *and* a good mix of a good production of a good arrangement of a good composition. How do we get a good mix? You guessed it. We need a good mix engineer *and* a good production of a good arrangement of a good composition. Every time someone posts, "Why does _____ sound so good???" well, that is the answer, every time.

What can you do? This goes back to point #2 about learning. Cover other songs. Learn how *music* works. Learn how to play/recreate/program/transcribe individual parts from songs that consist of a bunch of good parts added together. It's literally just LEGO. Learn how to sit down with the instructions (which are right in front of you within every piece of music that exists) and look at how the pieces go together. If you can't figure it out, get help. No, not on YouTube. Find a real, live, experienced, capable person, and ask them to help you. We used to call this "music lessons". You can still do this in 2025 -- people will accept your money in exchange for teaching you how to do things. If you want to get good, you should seriously consider this approach. If your time has any value at all, which it does, you will save tons of time by addressing your weakest points, learning more quickly and efficiently, and improving as a whole, as opposed to just... spending your time consuming brainrot.

You can disagree with me about those 5 stages of music and about the value of learning directly via music lessons, and I know people will. Internet people *hate* being told that getting good results is going to require tons of practice, furthering their understanding, lots of hard work, and anything other than ‧₊˚❀ anyone can do anything ❀༉‧₊˚ -- that it's not just some industry secret "instant Justin Bieber" EQ/compression vocal chain settings being gatekept from them. Or that their abilities don't just level up automatically after hitting a certain number of hours spent watching YouTube. Seriously, that attitude makes me sick, and its prevalence is a huge part of why I'm going offline. People like that just simply cannot be helped, and they account for a huge percentage of those actively taking part in online discussions. I want to say more, but I won't. Take my advice or don't. I truly don't care -- I'm not checking back in to argue with people after I post this. I'm literally just giving away a chunk of my lifetime of insight, knowing fully well that some people will get upset about it. Tough titties, I guess. That's showbiz, baby.

Man, I really got carried away with point #6. This is a really big one, to be honest. Probably the biggest. If you can wrap your head around those 5 stages, and address whatever your weakest link is, that is where you will find the greatest improvement. I promise. And I'm willing to bet that for most of you, your weakest link is almost definitely within the first 3 stages, but instead of realizing/accepting that, you're struggling trying to figure out stage 4, mixing. Tale as old as time. If your mix sucks, it's almost definitely because your production and/or arrangement sucks. That's the elephant in the room, and it cannot be fixed with mix tips, mix feedback, or "better" mix techniques. I know this is r/mixingmastering and not r/compositionarrangementproduction, but the internet as a whole *really* needs to hear that. Anyways, so as not to end on a crazy rant voicing my frustration against the entirety of the internet, I'll give you a little more insight on those stages, and then call it a day. Keep in mind that this is not comprehensive at all. Just some quick tidbits that come to mind before going to bed.

NUMBER SEVEN. Composition (continued). To learn about this, just cover songs. That's the easiest way. It is honestly not very difficult.

NUMBER EIGHT. Arranging/arrangement (continued). To learn about this, learn an instrument, or better yet, multiple instruments. For more advanced readers that can already play multiple instruments, take a drastically reductive approach. When you have nearly infinite tracks, the natural tendency is to want to add nearly infinite things. Do the opposite. Great commercial-grade arrangements have very few things happening at once. It is not musically dense *at all*, and that's why it sounds good. That's why the mix sounds good. That's why the master sounds good. I hope you're starting to get it. Here are a few principles within this topic that I like to use to explain it;

  • Pie graph theory. No matter how many or how few slices you have, a pie graph will always represent a total of 100%. The same is true of audio in terms of how much headroom you have. You want the biggest most badass kick ever? Just have a kick and literally nothing else. Boom, 100%. That kick is literally the biggest kick sonically possible. Wait, you want a bass too? Okay, now each one is 50%. Adding vocals? Now the kick is 33.3%, the bass is 33.3%, and the vocal is 33.3%. The more things you add, the smaller everything gets. Don't you love how basic and easy to understand that is? That's how it works. Don't slap a whole bunch of unnecessary, noodling, dense, overplayed ideas into your arrangement, and it will sound way better.

  • Single piano roll test. Do this. Take all of your instruments, vocals, and harmony parts, and convert them to MIDI data. I don't care how you do it, just do it. Now dump all of those MIDI parts onto one MIDI/instrument track, preferably with something simple, like a piano. Play it all back together. Does it still sound like music? Does it sound like a cohesive piano piece, albeit with maybe one or two extra hands at times? Can you still detect the main melody? Or... does it sound like shit? If it sounds like shit, your arrangement sucks. Get rid of stuff until it sounds like music.

NUMBER NINE. Production (continued). This one also isn't that hard. It just takes a lot of necessary trial and error to find your own sound and unique style. Try doing one thing 10 different ways. There are just an infinite variety of ways to do things that I can't even begin to get into it. It's getting late and I'm tired. Sorry. I'll just do a few;

  • For both vocals and instruments, crank up your monitoring volume, and play/sing *quietly* for a huge sound. Playing/singing loudly sounds really quiet in a recording, and conversely, playing/singing quietly sounds really big in a recording. Try it. Record the same song twice. The first time, do everything super loudly. Then, record the song again, but play everything super quietly. Mix and finish both versions of the song. You'll see what I mean. One will sound like shit, and the other will sound amazing. Maybe you can prove me wrong -- who knows. At the very least, I tricked you into having a cool B-side version of that song. Joke's on you.

  • Hire musicians and singers. Seriously. I've always been not that good at drums. I befriended a really good drummer, and he ended up being my most indispensable shortcut to productions that were *wayyyy* better than what I would have ever been able to do without him. This goes for other instrumentalists, vocalists, and producers as well. Make friends and make stuff with them. I guess this is one for the beginners. Whoops.

  • Figure out your sound before you hit record. I don't know who needs to hear this, but you can monitor things through plugins that are already added and shaping things. This should be obvious, but it makes all the difference between someone who is a good producer / recordist / YouTube type beat maker and a bad one. Seriously, get it dialed in to the point that your performance of the part, and the sound are complimentary of each other and one in the same. After you add a new part, it should already sound pretty much fully mixed. When it comes time to mix my own productions, there's truly almost zero mixing left to do. Conversely, if I mix someone else's song and the arrangement/production are not thoroughly thought out and don't already have a vibe? Oh lawd, I gotta charge this boi quadruple. I mean, to be fair, mix engineers that began as producers can help people out really effectively when that extra help is needed, but we'll get to that...

NUMBER TEN. Mixing (continued). Sure, practice, but understanding those first 3 stages is a huge plus. It's pretty necessary in my opinion. There's no substitute for that depth of insight and understanding that you can bring to a mix. I'm seriously getting so tired, so I'll do my best to avoid the cliches and give you just a few less common quickies;

  • Fix your monitoring. Seriously. You can make the most incredible sounding mix in the world, but if your monitoring is whack, it's only going to sound good sitting in *your* chair, in *your* room, in front of *your* speakers. And, surprise, it'll sound like shit everywhere else. (This cliche is necessary. People are always like, "Yeah, I know, but I can't." Go back and read my main point #4 about monitoring again if you have to.)

  • All of the different processing that you can possibly imagine really just falls into two categories; gain, and time. Compression and all dynamic processing, saturation, split band processing, EQ, any combination of that stuff = gain. All of the most advanced techniques in the world within those categories just add up to essentially making something relatively louder / closer, or softer / more distant. I don't care what you're doing to the thing. Are you bringing it up or down? More or less noticeable in a certain frequency range? Tone is just gain applied unevenly. Panning is just the difference in gain between the left and right speaker. Time accounts for pretty much everything else; reverb, delay, modulation-based effects. *I guess* that maybe certain dynamic processing, like really tight gating or super heavy compression, can give the impression of a "time" effect. But honestly, just simplify things. Don't overcomplicate them. You straight up don't ever need M/S EQ, or "advanced mixing technique" meme stuff like that unless there's a really serious problem that could have easily been avoided in the first place, and that's a hill that I'm willing to die on. Yeah, I went through that phase too and thought I was really cool and smart, and my mixes from that period probably sounded like shit.

  • The big three. Make your main drum/beat/whatever elements (I'll just call this "drums", but really it's kick + snare), bass, and vocal sound good together. Those are the three most important things to get right. Your mix should sound really, really good with just those three. If it doesn't, adding in more tracks will not make it sound good if it doesn't already. In fact, it should be *easy* to make your mix sound amazing with just those 3 things. Remember the "pie graph theory"? As you add more stuff, it's only going to get more difficult to maintain a good mix, so be careful about fitting other stuff around those 3. Make those 3 slices big, and the other slices as small as you can get away with, without the client complaining. Kidding. Kind of. See, mixing is easy! The composition/arrangement/production just has to not suck. You'll get there.

NUMBER ELEVEN. Mastering (continued). Mastering is easy too! Anyone can do it! If you have something that you plan to release and you want it to sound good, send it to a good mastering engineer. All you need is an internet connection. See what I mean? This is literally the easiest step. Oh, *you* want to become a mastering engineer? Alright, fine;

  • Is your monitoring basically as perfect as possible? Start there. Okay, good. Now you just need to be able to hear the small differences between things, be able to identify exactly what those differences are, and adjust those differences as you see fit, based on your taste, and the collective context of the best sounding stuff in existence. That's it. It's honestly not that hard once you've developed the capability to do it. Developing the capability to do it is the hard part. When you see an Olympic athlete do a bunch of crazy ass flips, they make it look super easy, don't they? Well, it *is* kind of easy for them, relative to someone who hasn't been training for decades to do that one super specific thing. So yeah, you could *probably* do it at a commercial-grade level with about ~10 years of rigorous training and really good monitoring. If you're offended by that, how do you feel when you watch the Olympics?

NUMBER TWELVE. For the internet people I ranted about. Read "As a Man Thinketh" and change the way you think about things. It's free -- just type "as a man thinketh filetype:pdf" exactly like that on Google. "Bro is suggesting self help books," yeah, I realize how corny that is. Literally just don't read it, or do. I don't care. Life is hard, but there's a lot more within your control than you realize.

That's all, folks. I covered a tiny percentage of a very very broad topic, but it's after midnight here, and it's time for bed. There's way way way more that I'd love to yap about, but this is all I could muster in one sitting. And if you're one of those people that are mad/offended after reading this, thanks for helping me to decide to stop using the internet. In a weird way, I appreciate you. Sorry for giving you a hard time, but I hope it helps. To everyone else who appreciated this, please defend me against the hordes of naysayers since I'm not going to bother defending myself. These kinds of disputes usually just come down to reading comprehension, so you should be fine just copying/pasting stuff. That being said, there's no winning and you'll get downvoted anyways, but as they say; live by the sword, die by the sword.

I'll be off Reddit from now on, and the internet as a whole for the most part, but I'm not hard to find. I wasn't too clever or creative when I made my Reddit handle, so if any of you internet sleuths are bored and want to find me, have at it. Feel free to reach out. I'll still be out here in the world, existing and whatnot. I may be done with the internet, but human connection is always a wonderful thing. I genuinely hope the amount of good music being made in the world increases ever so slightly after posting this. Peace out, pimps. <3


r/mixingmastering • • Jan 07 '25

Video Mix engineers Andrew Scheps and Fab Dupont talk about mixing on headphones

833 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Jan 05 '26 Bravo

Discussion I built a website to test your EQ skills!

539 Upvotes

EQtrainer.app

Simple, free EQ training website with a clean UI

It can take a long time to develop an ear for EQ naturally just from mixing, so tools like these are really helpful. (also a great way to humble a cocky producer friend)

I posted this once in another sub (so sorry if you've seen it) and got a lot of great feedback and feature requests. There are a bunch of new updates - more tracks, a cellphone speaker mode, difficulty tiers, and a daily challenge mode with wordle-style score sharing.

Hope you guys find it useful!


r/mixingmastering • • Jul 14 '25

Discussion Just a friendly PSA that the answer to 85% of your questions that read like "why don't my mixes sound good" is actually really simple: Because you can't actually hear (in great enough detail) what you're listening to yet.

496 Upvotes

People love to talk about tips and tricks, flashy eq moves, envelope filters, compressor setting, etc until the cows come home. The reason this is what youtube obsessed over is usually quite simple: they want engagement, or they want to sell you something, or both.

"I can fix your problem with this quick tip" = views

"you cant actually hear what the fuck youre listening to in great enough detail yet to be really great at this for at LEAST 2-3 years of doing this almost daily" = no views, doesn't provide opportunity for instant gradification.

Your ears change SO DAMN MUCH as you do this. I'm in year 15 and I remember thinking stuff I was putting out in year 2 sounded pretty good..it objectively sounded like pure shit. Why? I literally had not developed my ears even CLOSE to good enough to actually be able to hear a problem, diagnose that problem, and fix it.

On a mixing level, I don't set myself up to fail anymore, because I can ACTUALLY HEAR what i'm working on via good ole fashion time on task. My ears no longer trick me into thinking "yea that snare sounds pretty good!" simply because it sounds recognizable as a snare drum and not a trash can lid, my ears now go "nope, that snare is not right for the song yet" in about 2 seconds flat, then I make a change, re-diagnose, and go from there.

None of it has shit to do with plug ins or tips and tricks. The basics will get you literally to the damn moon and back in this industry if you have developed a killer ear. It just takes hours and hours and hours of time..the one resource nobody really wants to spend.


r/mixingmastering • • Dec 25 '21

Article Mixing tips for the inexperienced

475 Upvotes

I spent a whole lotta years making records - if you listen to American pop music from the 80s to mid 2000s, you've almost certainly heard my work as arranger, sound designer and mixer. I retired a while back but now getting back into it for fun. Reading posts here for a couple months, I see that some things haven't changed and young producers are fighting the same battles as every generation before. So I thought I'd share some greybeard wisdom lol.

Not in any particular order.

Yes you absolutely should learn an instrument and some theory. It will improve your music more than you can imagine. Seriously, trying to be a producer without knowing any of the fundamentals of music is like wanting to be a race car driver without knowing how to drive. FYI many old-school producers say they 'don't know any theory'. All but 1 of them are lying lol.

Lighten up on the fx. New mixers tend to add reverb, delay, chorus etc too heavy and much too early in the mixing process. You generally should not reach for any fx until your tracks are bussed and sub-bussed and all your relative levels are solid.  If you don't know what these terms mean, go look them up, it's not complicated and you need to know.

Busses and automation: learn how to use them. Your mixes will happen much faster. Generally automation should happen towards the end of the process because large-scale revision on automation data is not fun.

Vary your listening levels constantly. Your mix will sound vastly different at different volume levels. Use this Fletcher-Munson Effect (look it up) to your advantage - some issues will only be noticeable at the extremes. Getting it sounding good at all volume levels is the key to creating mixes that sound good on a wide range of audio devices. Listen at every level from barely audible to loud, with VERY RARE listens at very high volume. You only get one set of ears and they're very fragile. Cherish and protect them.

In the beginning, choose 1 eq, 1 compressor, 1 limiter, 1 reverb etc. Doesn't even matter which ones you choose at this point. Learn them inside out. This will give you a rock-solid base for understanding what processors do and all the choices and subtleties involved in using them. You can't even begin to make an informed choice between 3 compressors until you truly know at least one of them. Switching between plugins will actually slow your progression early on.

Don't worry too much about gain staging. Most of what you read about it dates from the analog era, whereas modern digital gear renders it mostly superfluous. As long as your meters never go red you're OK. Unless you're doing classical/orchestral but that's a whole different world.

If you're tracking a band, spend all the time needed to isolate everything you can. This alone can shave hours off your mix time.

Recording heavy guitars? Include a clean DI track. Mixing a little of this into the overdriven amp track will add clarity and definition with 0 additional processing.

Eq rule #1: never boost if you can accomplish the same result by cutting somewhere else.

Take frequent breaks when mixing. Your ears experience fatigue effects after 45 minutes to an hour of concentrated listening. 5 minutes of quiet will recalibrate them.

If you have an fx stack on your Master Bus check occasionally that none of your plugins are overloading the inputs of the next plugin in line. If they are, you just found the source of that mysterious trash noise you're hearing.

Solo mode is not your friend. Use it to track down issues when necessary. But if you do your sound design in Solo you're just adding massive unnecessary workload because Solo tells you zip about how that instrument sounds in the context of the music.

Whenever possible perform all doubles. Copypasting and the inevitable processing to make it sound slightly less shitty is never worth it.

Want some massively thick guitar chords? Double the guitar with a B3 through an overdriven Leslie/rotary sim but don't play full chords, just root & 5th. Mix under the guitar. Voila, massive 80s-era rythm guitar.

And finally, the toughest one. Not every track is a keeper. Keep perspective and realize that not every idea you have is viable. Don't waste time polishing something that's just never gonna shine. The typical professional songwriter tosses approximately 85% of what they write, long before it's even a finished song.

I hope my ramblings make the journey more enjoyable and successful for as many of you as possible!

Xposted to r/mixingmastering and r/musicproduction


r/mixingmastering • • Apr 14 '24

Wiki Article -14 LUFS IS QUIET: A primer on all things loudness

440 Upvotes

If you are relatively new to making music then you'll probably be familiar with this story.

You stumbled your way around mixing something that sounds more or less like music (not before having watched countless youtube tutorials in which you learned many terrible rules of thumb). And at the end of this process you are left wondering: How loud should my music be in order to release it?

You want a number. WHAT'S THE NUMBER you cry at the sky in a Shakespearean pose while holding a human skull in your hand to accentuate the drama.

And I'm here to tell you that's the wrong question to ask, but by now you already looked up an answer to your question and you've been given a number: -14 LUFS.

You breathe a sigh of relief, you've been given a number in no uncertain terms. You know numbers, they are specific, there is no room for interpretation. Numbers are a warm safe blanket in which you can curl underneath of.

Mixing is much more complex and hard than you thought it would be, so you want ALL the numbers, all the settings being told to you right now so that your misery can end. You just wanted to make a stupid song and instead it feels like you are now sitting at a NASA control center staring at countless knobs and buttons and graphs and numbers that make little sense to you, and you get the feeling that if you screw this up the whole thing is going to be ruined. The stakes are high, you need the freaking numbers.

Yet now you submitted your -14 LUFS master to streaming platforms, ready to bask in all the glory of your first musical publication, and maybe you had the loudness normalization disabled, or you gave it a listen on Spotify's web player which has no support for loudness normalization. You are in shock: Compared to all the other pop hits your track is quiet AF. You panic.

You feel betrayed by the number, you thought the blanket was supposed to be safe. How could this be, even Spotify themselves recommend mastering to -14 LUFSi.

The cold truth

Here is the cold truth: -14 LUFS is quiet. Most commercial releases of rock, pop, hip hop, edm, are louder than that and they have been louder than that for over 20 years of digital audio, long before streaming platforms came into the picture.

The Examples

Let's start with some hand-picked examples from different eras, different genres, ordered by quietest to loudest.

LUFSi = LUFS integrated, meaning measured across the full lenght of the music, which is how streaming platforms measure the loudness of songs.

  • Jain - Makeba (Album Version, 2015) = -13.2 LUFSi

  • R.E.M. - At My Most Beautiful (1998) = -12.2 LUFSi

  • Massive Attack - Pray for Rain (2010) = -11.4 LUFSi

  • Peter Gabriel - Growing Up (2002) = -10.5 LUFSi

  • Gorillaz - Clint Eastwood (2001) = -10.1 LUFSi

  • Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross - In Motion (2010) = -10.0 LUFSi

  • Zero 7 - Mr. McGee (2009) = -9.8 LUFSi

  • If The World Should End in Fire (2003) = -9.1 LUFSi

  • Taylor Swift - Last Christmas (2007) = -8.6 LUFSi

  • Madonna - Ghosttown (2015) = -8.6 LUFSi

  • Björk - Hunter (1997) = -8.6 LUFSi

  • Red Hot Chili Peppers - Black Summer (2022) = -8.1 LUFSi

  • The Black Keys - Lonely Boy = -7.97 LUFSi

  • Junun - Junun (2015) = -7.9 LUFSi

  • Coldplay - My Universe (2021) = -7.8 LUFSi

  • Wolfmother - Back Round (2009) = -7.7 LUFSi

  • Taylor Swift - New Romantics (2014) = -7.6 LUFSi

  • Paul McCartney - Fine Line (2005) = -7.5 LUFSi

  • Taylor Swift - You Need To Calm Down (2019) = -7.4 LUFSi

  • Doja Cat - Woman (2021) = -7.4 LUFSi

  • Ariana Grande - Positions (2021) = -7.3 LUFSi

  • Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross - Immigrant Song (2012) = -6.7 LUFSi

  • Radiohead - Bloom (2011) = -6.4 LUFSi

  • Dua Lipa - Levitating (2020) = -5.7 LUFSi

Billboard Year-End Charts Hot 100 Songs of 2023

  1. Last Night - Morgan Wallen = -8.2 LUFSi

  2. Flowers - Miley Cyrus = -7.2 LUFSi

  3. Kill Bill - SZA = -7.4 LUFSi

  4. Anti-Hero - Taylor Swift = -8.6 LUFSi

  5. Creepin' - Metro Boomin, The Weeknd & 21 Savage = -6.9 LUFSi

  6. Calm Down - Rema & Selena Gomez = -7.9 LUFSi

  7. Die For You - The Weeknd & Ariana Grande = -8.0 LUFSi

  8. Fast Car - Luke Combs = -8.6 LUFSi

  9. Snooze - SZA = -9.4 LUFSi

  10. I'm Good (Blue) - David Guetta & Bebe Rexha = -6.5 LUFSi

So are masters at -14 LUFSi or quieter BAD?

NO. There is nothing inherently good or bad about either quiet or loud, it all depends on what you are going for, how much you care about dynamics, what's generally expected of the kind of music you are working on and whether that matters to you at all.

For example, by far most of classical music is below -14 LUFSi. Because they care about dynamics more than anyone else. Classical music is the best example of the greatest dynamics in music ever. Dynamics are 100% baked into the composition and completely present in the performance as well.

Some examples:

Complete Mozart Trios (Trio of piano, violin and cello) Album • Daniel Barenboim, Kian Soltani & Michael Barenboim • 2019

Tracks range from -22.51 LUFSi to -17.22 LUFSi.

Beethoven: Symphony No. 9 in D Minor, Op. 125 "Choral" (Full symphony orchestra with sections of vocal soloists and choir) Album • Wiener Philharmoniker & Andris Nelsons • 2019

Tracks range from -28.74 LUFSi to -14.87 LUFSi.

Mozart: Symphonies Nos. 38-41 (Full symphony orchestra) Album • Scottish Chamber Orchestra & Sir Charles Mackerras • 2008

Tracks range from -22.22 LUFSi to -13.53 LUFSi.

On My New Piano (Solo piano) Album • Daniel Barenboim • 2016

Tracks range from -30.75 LUFSi to -19.66 LUFSi.

Loudness normalization is for THE LISTENER

Before loudness normalization was adopted, you would put together a playlist on your streaming platform (or prior to that on your iPod or computer with mp3s), and there would often be some variation in level from song to song, especially if you had some older songs mixed in with some more modern ones, those jumps in level could be somewhat annoying.

Here comes loudness normalization. Taking a standard from European broadcasting, streaming platforms settled on the LUFS unit to normalize all tracks in a playlist by default, so that there are no big jumps in level from song to song. That's it! That's the entire reason why streaming platforms adopted LUFS and why now LUFS are a thing for music.

LUFS were invented in 2011, long after digital audio was a reality since the 80s. And again, they weren't made for music but for TV broadcasts (so that the people making commercials wouldn't crank up their levels to stand out).

And here we are now with people obsessing over the right LUFS just to publish a few songs.

There are NO penalties

One of the biggest culprits in the obsession with LUFS, is a little website called "loudness penalty" (not even gonna link to it, that evil URL is banned from this sub), in which you can upload a song and it would turn it down in the same way the different platforms would.

An innocent, good natured idea by mastering engineer Ian Shepherd, which backfired completely by leading inexperienced people to start panicking about the potential negative implications of incurring into a penalty due to having a master louder than -14 LUFSi.

Nothing wrong happens to your loud master, the platforms DO NOT apply dynamic range reduction (ie: compression). THEY DO NOT CHANGE YOUR SIGNAL.

The only thing they do, is what we described above, they adjust volume (which again, changes nothing to the signal) for the listener's convenience.

Why does my mix sound QUIETER when normalized?

One very important aspect of this happens when comparing your amateur production, to a professional production, level-matched: all the shortcomings of your mix are exposed. Not just the mix, but your production, your recording, your arrangement, your performance.

It all adds up to something that is perceived as standing out over your mix.

The second important aspect is that there can be a big difference between trying to achieve loudness at the end of your mix, vs maximizing the loudness of your mix from the ground up.

Integrated LUFS is a fairly accurate way to measure perceived loudness, as in perceived by humans. I don't know if you've noticed, but human hearing is far from being an objective sound level meter. Like all our senses (and the senses of all living things), they have evolved to maximize the chances of our survival, not for scientific measurements.

LUFS are pretty good at getting close to how we humans perceive loudness, but it's not perfect. That means that two different tracks could be at the same integrated LUFS and one of them is perceived to be bit louder than the other. Things like distortion, saturation, harmonic exciters, baked into a mix from the ground up, can help maximize a track for loudness (if that matters to you).

If it's all going to end up normalized to -14 LUFS eventually, shouldn't you just do it yourself?

If you've read everything here so far, you already know that LUFS are a relatively new thing, that digital audio in music has been around for much longer and that the music industry doesn't care at all about LUFS. And that absolutely nothing wrong happens to your mix when turned down due to loudness normalization.

That said, let's entertain this question, because it does come up.

The first incorrect assumption is that ALL streaming platforms normalize to -14 LUFSi. Apple Music, for instance, normalizes to -16 LUFSi. And of course, any platform could decide to change their normalization target at any time.

YouTube Music (both the apps and the music.youtube.com website) doesn't do loudness normalization at all.

The Spotify web player and third party players, don't do loudness normalization. So in all these places (plus any digital downloads like in Bandcamp), your -14 LUFSi master of a modern genre, would be comparatively much quieter than the rest.

SO, HOW LOUD THEN?

As loud or as quiet as you want! Some recommendations:

  1. Forget about LUFS and meters, and waveforms. It's completely normal for tracks in an album or EP to all measure different LUFS, and streaming platforms will respect the volume relationship between tracks when playing a full album/EP.

  2. Study professional references to hear how loud music similar to what you are mixing is.

  3. Learn to understand and judge loudness with nothing but your ears.

  4. Set a fixed monitoring level using a loud reference as the benchmark for what's the loudest you can tolerate, this includes all the gain stages that make up your monitoring's final level.

  5. If you are going to use a streaming platform, make sure to disable loudness normalization and set the volume to 100%.

The more time you spend listening to music with those fixed variables in place, the sooner digital audio loudness will just click for you without needing to look at numbers.

TLDR

  • -14 LUFSi is quiet for modern genres, it has been since the late 90s, long before the LUFS unit was invented.

  • All of modern music is louder than -14 LUFSi, often louder than -10 LUFSi.

  • There are NO penalties for having a master louder than -14 LUFSi. Nothing bad is happening to your music.

  • Loudness normalization is for the LISTENER. So don't worry about it.

  • The mixes which you perceive as louder than yours when normalized, is likely a reaction to overall better mixes, better productions made by far more experienced people.

The long long coming (and requested) wiki article is finally here: https://www.reddit.com/r/mixingmastering/wiki/-14-lufs-is-quiet


r/mixingmastering • • Aug 31 '24

Video Bob Clearmountain, the guy who practically invented mixing as a standalone profession

395 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Jul 11 '25

Video A British University hired 8 very well-known mix engineers to mix the same rock/metal song so we all could learn from them!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
376 Upvotes

This project in the UK called the Heaviness In Metal Music Production project received government funding to explore what makes music “heavy.” So they hired Andrew Scheps, Nolly Getgood, Jens Bogren, Buster Odeholm, Fredrick Nordstrom, Dave Otero, Mike Exeter, and Josh Middleton all to mix the same song in their own way and then they each did a mix walkthrough to teach us their ways! You can download the songs and also the tracks to mix them yourself!

I thought it was so cool, that I made a video about it on my tiny YouTube channel, where I listen to each of the mixes and talk about what I’m hearing. If you’re into rock and metal, I think you will really enjoy it! Cheers!


r/mixingmastering • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion Gates are so underutilized and underrated

373 Upvotes

So I've recently discovered the power of gates for things besides the basic uses most people think of when they think of a gate. I realized that the way our ears work is such, that we will fill in gaps in an audio source like we fill in the details of a silhouette on paper. This is insanely useful information, because it opened up a massive, gamechanging mixing technique for me that I think is just too powerful not to share.

Basically what i do, is i set the gate to cut off much of the decay of certain sounds, maybe I have a top sound that has a lot of release and decay and overlapping harmonics, so I'll set a gate on it, then experiment with the theshold. The idea is that, especially if you have other sounds playing at the same time, is that your brain will be occupied with the other sounds playing, and as long as the gating isn't super choppy or artificial feeling(meaning you need to dial in attack and release extremely precisely), all the user will experience is a cleaner sound, you are basically sacrificing a certain amount of granular detail in your sound to give more space for other things. The human ear is so amazing when it comes to perception vs reality, I've come to find that the best mixes are a well crafted illusion to a certain extent, utilizing tricks of the ear to benefit the listener.

It also has a really cool side effect of being able to really accentuate a groove, really make something just snap in a certain way by giving it a slight choppy and human feel.


r/mixingmastering • • Aug 14 '25

Question I have a client that might have made up a genre in their head and doesn't realize it?

354 Upvotes

Please somebody correct me if I'm wrong. This is also very much not a client bashing post, just not sure if I'm crazy or uninformed or what.

I've been working with this client for almost a year now. He produces music that's a mix of trap and metal but refers to it as "boink" (specifically "hard-level boink.") Whenever he's giving me revision notes, he says things like "This could be a little brighter for hard-level boink" Or "it needs more kick, check a hard-level boink reference and you'll see what I mean."

But that's the thing. I *don't* know what he means.

I googled it recently just to look for artists or reference tracks and the only things that came up were AI feeding me stuff about Dark Souls attacks, the definition of Onomatopoeia, and instagram posts that he made where he used the phrase himself. I told him a couple mixes ago that I'd never heard of "hard-level boink" and google had nothing to show me either and he looked at me like I told him the moon was made of melted down XLR cables.

Has anyone heard of the genre Boink, hard-level or otherwise, and have some reference songs or artists to recommend? At this point I'm somewhere between thinking I don't know enough, he's pranking me, or there's a weird Twilight Zone-esque mishap going on.

Edit: For those asking, when I ask for references, he mostly sends me Marilyn Manson or MGK. So your guess is as good as mine.


r/mixingmastering • • Jul 31 '22

Discussion The 4 Styles of Compression

343 Upvotes

I teach mixing lessons professionally. Here’s a question my students ask all the time:

“I’m super overwhelmed when it comes to compression. What exactly should I be focusing on? What does compression even sound like?”

Let’s simplify it, shall we?

There’s only four main “sounds” you can create with it. The Four Styles of Compression, if you will.

These four different combinations of settings are:

  1. Consistency

  2. Punch

  3. Thickness

  4. Groove

We’ll get to what those settings are in a moment. What does each Style do?

Consistency

Consistency compression (AKA leveling compression) is probably the most commonly used style out there. And yet, this style doesn’t SOUND like anything - if it’s changing the tone, you’re probably doing it wrong. It’s all about leveling out a performance so that no rogue notes stick out or are lost in a mix. You won’t hear it in solo, but you’ll definitely hear it in context of a mix. Think of it as a more advanced volume fader. If you can’t seem to get a good volume balance in your mix, your instruments probably need more of this style.

Try Consistency style on vocals, bass, and any other dynamic performances that you’re fighting within the mix.

Settings:

  • Attack - fast

  • Release - slow

  • Threshold - high

  • Ratio - set to taste

  • Makeup gain - half of whatever your gain reduction is (that way you’re turning down the loud notes and up the quiet notes by the same amount!)

Punch

Punchy compression does the opposite of what you’d expect. Think compression is all about lowering the dynamic range? Think again. Punch style raises it. And it sounds damn good too.

Punch style raises the level of the initial peak in a sound, and lowers the level of the sustain of that sound. But more importantly, it makes stuff hit harder and sound more upfront. It breathes life into an instrument that feels a little… flat.

Try Punch style on drums, vocals, or any instrument that needs a little more “umph” in it.

Settings:

  • Attack - slow

  • Release - slow

  • Threshold - low

  • Ratio - set to taste

  • Makeup gain - turn up until your RMS or LUFS level is the same as before

Thickness

Thickness compression is basically the exact opposite of punchy compression. Instead of pushing the peaks and sustain further apart, it squeezes them closer together. And it’s all about making stuff LOUD. It gives a sound more girth and more body. If a sound is feeling kind of weak, this sends it to the weight room with a protein shake and a head full of unearned confidence.

(A quick note: saturation and limiting can also create the same effect. Experiment to find the sound you like)

Try Thickness style on drums, especially on overheads or room mic. Also works on anything that isn’t already thick. Looking at you, electric guitars and other sausage sounds.

Settings:

  • Attack - fast

  • Release - fast

  • Threshold - high

  • Ratio - set to taste

  • Makeup gain - turn up until your peak level is the same as before

Groove

Groove compression is maybe the least often used, but it’s my personal favorite. Groove style is all about the subconscious. If done well, it can near-telepathically influence the listener to start tapping their toe or bobbing their head. It creates more bounce in a sound that isn’t always obvious to the ear, but for some reason causes the body to respond. This is done by creating subtle “pumping” in the compressor that’s timed to the sweet spot of the tempo of a song.

Try it on drums (seeing a pattern here?), rhythm instruments, or busses to glue several instruments together. It excels in giving instruments a shared sense of movement.

Settings:

  • Attack - slow

  • Release - fast

  • Threshold - low

  • Ratio - set to taste

  • Makeup gain - turn up until your peak level is the same

------------------

That’s about wraps it up. Focus on these four styles in a mix and lose the overwhelm.

Want to learn more? I teach private mixing lessons, and I’ve got a few open spots left for this month. DM me if you’re interested.

EDIT: For clarity, here are your typical attack/release time ranges.

  • Fast Attack: 0.01ms - 2ms

  • Slow Attack: 10ms - ∞

  • Fast Release: 20ms - 100ms

  • Slow Release: 250ms - ∞


r/mixingmastering • • Nov 17 '25

Video I hired five pros to mix my death metal song as an experiment

303 Upvotes

I play in a death metal band and I've always DIYed my recording. I had pros mix my earlier albums but as I gained confidence i also handled mixing the last 2 records. I had a couple of top pros here: Jens Bogren (opeth) Dave Otero (archspire, cattle decap) Dan Swano (dissection, dawn) Greg Chandler (chtheilist, ashenspire) Damian Herring (horrendous, voidceremony, blood incantation)

https://youtu.be/oQYRc7ypW3s

It was interesting how differently everyone treated the buzzsaw guitars and vocal effects. As a pure left hand path clone I thought swanos mix won handily in that aspect aspect

I often see people asking for multitracks to practice mixing with so I got relapse records' approval to also release the multitracks for free! https://theweebdungeon.bandcamp.com/album/feast-of-the-deceased-multitracks

Hope yall find this comparison as interesting as it was for me


r/mixingmastering • • Mar 18 '23

Video Michael Brauer on how he couldn't hear differences in compression when he started up

301 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Jan 19 '21

Wiki Article Re-thinking your own mastering

281 Upvotes

Note: This article is not directed at people who arrived at their own personal workflow after years of having tried different things. It's meant mainly for people who are still fairly new to mixing and in need of guidance

I've always had a bit of a problem with the name of this subreddit: "mixingmastering", like it's one thing. Contributing to the misconceptions there are about mastering.

But I'm also glad mastering is one of the core topics here, because it gives us the opportunity to set the record straight, to give mastering its rightful place.

Mastering is perhaps the most misunderstood aspect of music production. I've recently talked about the importance of professional mastering which is about the role mastering has had in the recording industry for decades, and why it's now more relevant than ever in this age of bedroom production.

And it's indeed with the rise of bedroom production in the early 2000s, and the heavy marketing campaigns by companies like iZotope that the understanding of mastering shifted and twisted and it's a bit of a mess.

It went from being a quality assurance process conducted by a specialist in the different playback mediums and formats, to being this thing you had to do yourself. And that thing often involved slapping some "mastering" plugins on your mixes.

Today you'd be hard pressed to find a bedroom producer who doesn't think (even a little bit) that mastering = Ozone.

The problem with thinking of mastering as a separate stage from your mixing

This idea that you have to take your finished mix to a later stage in which you'll change it, and tweak it and make it loud is problematic.

It makes people adopt a workflow in which they'll rush a quick/unfinished mix into a later stage in which they'll try to make it work by piling some processing on it. Mastering becomes this safety net which leads you to have a questionable work ethic.

Especially if you are mixing a single, this practice doesn't make sense.

If you are happy with your mix, why do you want to change it? If you would change anything about it, then that means you are not done mixing.

Mixing as your ONLY stage

Mixing should be all you think about. Whatever "mastering" processing you like adding later, you can have it on your master bus while you mix. You should have your final limiter while you mix. You can also add them later to your mix session, the timing of this comes down to personal preference but the key is that you shouldn't think of your master bus processing as a separate stage. It's still mixing.

What is coming out of the speakers/headphones while you are mixing should be the final product, all that will ever be.

When you know there is no later, you'll work harder on the individual elements of the mix to get the sound that you want. And by "there is no later" I don't mean that you should mix everything from start to finish in one sitting. Take breaks, take a few days, a few weeks, that's entirely up to you. Taking breaks is definitely a good thing, it clears your ears, gives you some perspective.

You should forget mastering is a thing. Referring to your own "mixing and mastering" when talking of your mixing is silly, it doesn't make sense.

You want your mix to sound loud and punchy and exciting and competitive with commercial releases? You can achieve all that in the mix.

Let's leave the word "mastering" mainly for that process made by professional mastering engineers.

Understanding the limits of your limiter

Mixing into a limiter requires you to understand how your limiter affects what is sent to it, because that will be the lens through which you'll "see" everything.

Practice by taking a few professional mixes, commercial releases (here are suggestions of where to buy and download some), which will be already limited, and put them through your limiter, and listen to what happens when you lower the threshold.

Practice with some of your individual recordings, pushing the gain to see how loud you can make it before it starts to sound too compressed. You can then export that limited version, put it next to the original track and lower the volume to match the original version. Now you can compare back and forth between the two to hear the difference.

While you are mixing, try bypassing your master bus limiter every now and then to hear the difference and make sure the limiter is not doing anything you don't like.

One thing to always be careful of, is the low end. Especially in bass heavy music like hip hop, pop, EDM, electronic music, where it's common to have a deep bass and/or kick. A typical problem is having an exaggerated bass, which is louder in the deep lows than your monitoring is capable of revealing and that will hit your limiter first and that can create an unwanted ducking effect.

We have an article about how to better understand your low end: https://www.reddit.com/r/mixingmastering/wiki/lowend

I recommend that to start with, you pick a limiter that is as transparent as possible, doesn't impart color or flavor to the mix. Generally speaking that means to avoid outboard limiter emulations. You can always get to those later, but I find it's simpler to understand what a limiter is doing when it's just putting a ceiling on the peaks and is otherwise getting out of the way.

Some great options:

Some FREE options:

Your master bus as a sacred temple

This is another suggestion in approach. It's not the "right" way to do things, it's not a rule, there are no such things.

The idea is to think of your master bus (also called mix bus) as a sacred temple. What is allowed in this sacred temple? Definitely a transparent limiter is allowed.

You can only have things there that are absolutely essential.

Sausage Fattener? NO, it will anger the Gods.

The idea is to avoid this notion of top-down mixing, to re-direct your efforts into your individual channels and group buses. If you want Sausage Fattener, you have plenty of other places where you should consider using it before even thinking about putting it on the mix bus. Same thing with EQ, same thing with compression.

There are countless places on your mix to try processing on. The master bus should be the last place you consider. If you tried making the most out of individual track and bus processing and you still feel you need a little something on the mix bus, then that's perfectly fine. The master bus Gods will know your intentions are pure and noble and will let you even use the Sausage Fattener there.

Mastering plugins can be used anywhere and anything can be used for mastering

This is another big confusing topic for people. "Plugins for mastering" is largely a marketing idea. Processing is processing and you can use it wherever you want.

I regularly use some Ozone modules on individual elements in my mixes. You can technically put Sausage Fattener or Decaptitator on your master bus if it gets you the results that you want.

There are some plugins that are designed with mastering tasks in mind, but you can use anything anywhere. Processing will process any signal. Break free from marketing brainwashing.

What about mixing E.Ps and albums?

This is the one case where thinking of your own mastering does make sense. Because you want all your individual mixes to sound cohesive and at the same level.

There is nothing wrong with having a dedicated stage to work in all your individual mixes as one thing.

Having said that, you can still mix in such a way that you get masters that are very close to each other, or even all the way there in terms of tone and level.

If you are mixing an album, you can finish your first song, down to the final loudness. If many elements in that mix stay the same throughout the album (ie: drums, guitars, vocals) you can save your session as a template to use as your starting point for the next mix.

Then you can also use your previous mix as a reference and you'll know right away if your current mix is sitting well next to your previous mix.

If the big picture of the sound of your album is on your mind from the beginning you'll be able to shape your sound in such a way that no professional mastering engineer would be able to with their limited options of having to deal with just a stereo mix.

Should you leave 6 dB of headroom going into your master bus?

No, that's [insert curse that most offends you]. There is no need to do that and this article goes in depth as to why: https://theproaudiofiles.com/6-db-headroom-mastering-myth-explained/

If you are hitting compressors or limiters too hard, you are hitting them too hard and you'll be able to tell with your ears.

-14 LUFS is NOT a mastering target. Forget about LUFS!

It's just a number. Streaming services that have normalization, will normalize using whatever system they use with the goal being that every song will sound about as loud as every other song.

If we all mastered our tracks to -14 LUFS then we would have no need for normalization. But no one does that.

Learn to understand loudness with your ears so that you don't have to rely on your eyes and meters. Grab a few references and using your ears, determine how loud they are between each other. Whichever level you like the most, you can now have a point of reference for the loudness of your mix.

Many mastering engineers don't pay much attention (if any) to LUFS, which was originally used only in broadcasting. For decades countless amazing albums have been released without ever checking on LUFS, either because it was not a thing in music production or because it didn't exist yet (it was first introduced in 2010).

The bottom line

When it comes to your own mixes that you want to release, let's stop thinking in terms of "mastering". It's more productive to just think of mixing.

And if you already have any other way of working which gets you the results that you want, then that's perfect too. But if you are struggling or still learning, it's worth to re-consider how you think of your mastering and give this idea a try.

I've added this as a new article to our wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/mixingmastering/wiki/rethinking-mastering


r/mixingmastering • • Mar 30 '25

Discussion There’s an INSANE amount of miss-information on this sub

271 Upvotes

I love this sub it’s been very helpful to me in the past but now that I’ve been doing this full time for a few years now, I’ve noticed an insane amount of mis information and black and white thinking that just doesn’t work all the time on this sub. Just now I got into an argument with someone about cutting frequencies you can’t hear. In the past I’ve seen people spout the same YouTube bs tutorial info that was written by “producers, and engineers” who have never set foot in a studio in their life. Sometimes this sub feels like the blind leading the blind and something needs to be done about it. Idk if mods could like mark certain people with verified studio experience and credits


r/mixingmastering • • Nov 30 '23

Video Mix engineer Tony Maserati on working for free

269 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Nov 30 '25

Discussion People who claim to hear the difference between 44.1khz, 48khz, and 96khz: Please explain why and how?

260 Upvotes

This is not a "you all are experiencing placebo" post. I'm genuinely curious who has experienced being able to tell the difference? Do you have to have an ideal setup to be able to achieve those results? Or what? I personally cant tell any difference. I appreciate the input.

To those that can, what is the main difference?

To those that are claiming you can't, what is your reasoning? Etc.


r/mixingmastering • • Feb 07 '25

Article The 6 dB of headroom for mastering is a bunch of horseshit! Stop following rules! Learn how stuff actually works!!! and stop watching random youtubers who spread all this misinformation

Thumbnail
theproaudiofiles.com
249 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Mar 27 '26

Video Chris Lord-Alge rates typical internet mixing advice from 0 to 10

Thumbnail
youtube.com
237 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Feb 13 '21

News RIP Rupert Neve

Thumbnail
rupertneve.com
232 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Dec 16 '19

Discussion CMD+S x20

Post image
229 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • May 14 '21

Discussion Tip: the quieter you’re listening, the easier it is to dial in transients

222 Upvotes

Transient smearing increases with reflections so unless you’re in a completely ideal monitoring environment then mixing at extremely low volume should be an essential part of your toolkit and workflow. Loudness bias and the way we perceive sound can also make mix errors seem more forgivable at higher volumes.

Bring your volume control down literally whisper quiet until all you can hear are the transients and it will become clear as day whether your compressors are hitting too fast or too slow, your synth attacks are too hard or soft, guitars are too plucky or washy etc. At this level you are essentially hearing an inharmonic bed of percussive sounds and you need to make sure that bed is well balanced and nothing is jumping out (unless it’s supposed to be)

I find this especially revealing with kick drums in a fuller mix. At a higher volume everything can sound like it’s gelling well and the kick is sat in there nicely. However, lower the volume and suddenly the high end and attack of the kick jump forward to a completely unacceptable level

Be careful to choose the best way to lower your volume. Cheaper monitor controllers sometimes suffer from image problems at very low gain settings. You might need to drag down your master fader instead if you think this is an issue.

Hope some people find this useful!


r/mixingmastering • • Jan 19 '21

Oh she’s pretty.

Post image
222 Upvotes

r/mixingmastering • • Oct 19 '20

Article The importance of professional mastering in the age of bedroom production

220 Upvotes

To understand why professional mastering is more important now than it has ever been, we first need to understand how music was made before.

Until around the late 90s, if you wanted to record music and have it released, you pretty much had to go through the record industry system: Sign with a label and they would pay to have your music recorded in a studio.

In the studio, the people working there would be either professional engineers or assistents and interns learning from these professionals. So by the time you got to the mastering stage, you had to go through the following:

  • Professionals handling the recording and mixing

  • Studios with serious equipment (monitoring, processing, microphones, preamps, converters)

  • Good acoustics! (spaces designed for recording and monitoring)

The average final mix was pretty good. The professional mastering engineers (which have historically been a different person than the recording and mixing engineers) where mostly there to make albums, get a bunch of final mixes and tweak things to minimize the differences between each mix and prepare it for CD.

Starting in the early 2000s, with the coming of affordable interfaces like the original Mbox, the financial requirements for recording your own music was significantly lowered. This enabled the democratization of production: A lot more people being able to record their music, meaning that artists who would previously be passed by record labels could now maybe find their own niche audiences online. (Of course, this also enabled anyone to record, regardless of talent or skill.)

The studio system naturally acted as a quality assurance funnel. In order to get your music released, it had to go through a professional system and that pretty much guaranteed a minimum level of quality in the recording and mixing. That is no longer the case.

Anyone has access to the minimally required tools, and thus the funnel has been removed almost completely. People who have no idea what they are doing, can still record their music and release it. This is where we are today.

People are more often than not, working in very imperfect acoustical spaces (ie: bedrooms, living rooms, basements, etc), with imperfect monitoring (affordable nearfield monitors, affordable pro headphones). That means that they can't accurately hear what is happening in the entire frequency spectrum.

That brings us to professional mastering.

Professional mastering and why it's more important than ever

Professional mastering engineers listen on full range monitors in a controlled environment.

If you are working with just nearfield monitors, or inaccurate headphones (ie: most headphones by far, anything below $1000 usd to put it in simple terms) you simply cannot know what your mixes exactly sound like. Some of the monitors used in professional mastering studios cost $30k usd a pair and more.

So just monitoring wise, if you don't have that kind of full range monitoring (monitoring which not only covers the full 20hz to 20kHz spectrum, but reproduces it accurately) in a very controlled space (acoustically designed for this purpose), you physically cannot hear what a professional mastering engineer can hear.

It's the same reason that in filmmaking, the colorists, the people doing color correction and color grading (which is kind of like the mastering for video) is done on $40k usd reference monitors (screens). Because you need to know exactly what the image is. And yet editors and directors generally use much cheaper displays for their day to day work, and make decisions on them. But before releasing it, and for the final touches, they need to see what exactly is there.

There is just no comparison of what a pair of Bowers & Wilkins Nautilus 802 extended with subwoofers can tell you compared to some Yamahas HS8. The difference is going to be night and day.

The number one problem: Bass

Talk to any mastering engineer and they will tell you that the thing people most often get wrong, is the low end (ie: the bass and the kick).

This is because the low end is hard to understand and hear correctly on affordable nearfield monitors and headphones. What this often means is that people have an exaggerated sub low end (below 50hz) that sounds good on their monitoring, but which will sound completely overdone on more accurate loudspeakers or high end headphones. Because they are lacking a true representation of what is happening below 50hz.

So the importance of mastering goes well beyond how happy you are with what you can hear.

A fresh perspective

By the time you are done with your mix or album, you probably have spent days, weeks, maybe even months mixing. All objectivity is out the window.

A mastering engineer is going to be hearing it with completely fresh ears for the first time. Anything that is off, is going to be immediately obvious to them in a way it would be impossible for you (unless you stepped away from your mixes for weeks).

Their ears are likely going to be more trained than yours, at the very least for the specific task of mastering.

A good mastering engineer can give you feedback

If your mix has a problem, fixing it in mastering is sometimes not possible or less than ideal because you are limited to a stereo mix, any processing you apply is going to affect the entire mix. But a mastering engineer can point you to the problems and help you address it in the mix session, so that it can result in a better master.

Their ability to hear very well what is going on with your mix, enables them to give you excellent feedback if there is any technical shortcoming in the mix.

Q: Does this mean I must always send my stuff to professional mastering?

NO. If your intended release is kind of casual: just on Soundcloud or YouTube. Or maybe it's important to you but you can't really afford a professional, then it's okay to release something yourself to the best of your ability. There are enough tests you can conduct and ways to ensure your mixes are alright enough for release. We will have an article about this soon.

But if you can afford it, and you intend to have a serious release. Then taking it to professional mastering is a way to not only ensure your release will be as good as possible, but also a way to show commitment to your art by subjecting it to a serious quality assurance process.

Q: Will professional mastering improve my mix?

Sometimes, yes. But mastering is fundamentally NOT about making things sound better, it's certainly not about making them sound worse either. It's just about producing the master, sometimes that entails correcting problems (or suggesting corrections for you to do in the mix), sometimes they can make overall sonic enhancements but the goal is to produce a good and correct master for the intended playback format/service. You shouldn't expect mastering to be the thing that turns a less than satisfactory mix into a streaming sensation. Contrary to popular belief mastering is not the stage where your mix is made to sound "professional".

If you are not happy with your mix, then it's not ready for mastering. You should send something for mastering when you feel it's either perfect as it is, or at least as good as you can make it.

You should aim for your mix to be so finished that the mastering engineer will feel they have nothing to do to it other than giving it its final loudness level. More often than not, they will still do other things to it. But that's a good way to think of your final mixes in relation to mastering.

The role of mastering

At its most basic, mastering is the process of producing the master. The role of mastering is to make sure there aren't any problems with the mix, highlight the best aspects of it and prepare the signal for its intended delivery format. These days it's mostly streaming services, but it could also be vinyl, CD or even cassette tape (which has had a resurgance lately).

Here is renowned mastering engineer Bob Katz (who wrote the book on mastering) describing mastering in his words: https://youtu.be/uCiNSSa2oT8?t=362

Some professional mastering engineers also take on restoration or re-mastering projects. Re-releases of back catalogs of artists are pretty common, and they tend to be re-mastered from the final mixes for each release.

When the material is old and hasn't been re-released in a while, the effort also involves some kind of restoration (noise reduction, cleanup, etc). Here are some remastering projects:

Q: Is AI-based online mastering a valid alternative?

NO. Automated online mastering services (or iZotope Ozone master assistant) are little more than glorified processing presets.

If you like what those processing chains do to your mixes, that's okay and it's okay to use them. That still doesn't make those services a replacement for professional mastering provided by a good mastering engineer.

None of those services can identify geniune problems in the mix and address them. None of those services can understand the emotion and vibe that the music is trying to convey.

For more on this last subject, here is a video of legendary mastering engineer Bernie Grundman talking about the emotional experience in mastering: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8a9W_FG1St0

So just because you may like what any of those services does to your mixes, it doesn't mean you are getting a suitable professional master.

What to look for in a mastering engineer

This is something that is undoubtly going to make a few people mad (considering how many of them are out there), but it needs to be said since it's by far the easiest way to separate the wheat from the chaff. If you want to find a good mastering engineer, avoid everyone who is offering both mixing and mastering (especially those who offer mastering as if it's like adding fries to your burger).

ANYONE CAN GIVE YOU A LOUD FILE, including the aforementioned ai online mastering services. Any mixing engineer can give you a loud file. In fact 99 times out of a 100, that's exactly what any of the "mixing and mastering" people will be giving you: The exact same thing anyone can give you, whether they advertise it as such or not. Like we have established, there is more to professional mastering than just making a mix loud or with some random processing that may make it sound better.

There are exceptions, professional engineers who are legitimately good mastering engineers, who can also mix and they offer these services separately (ie: not mastering what they mix). But it's not at all common.

Until you are experienced enough to identify them, I recommend you look for people who are dedicated exclusively (or at the very least mostly) to mastering. That already tells you that they have have invested more time to specialize in mastering and thus they are more likely to know the nuts and bolts of mastering, than the people who "do" everything.

Look for people who have a purpose built room (it can even be in their home, nothing wrong with that, quite a few legit mastering engineers have built a serious mastering studio at their place).

Look for people who have full range monitoring (covering the full 20hz-20kHz range). If they achieve that by having a subwoofer, that's okay. Whatever they have, make sure it's better than what you have.

In fact, these days there are even some professionals doing Grammy-winning masters on headphones (with top of the line headphones and DACs though), completely in the box. You can hear about the most prominent of them here: https://themasteringshow.com/episode-50/ and here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9somtZ1FZTI (he sometimes hangs out in our sub!)

Is analog processing something to look for in a mastering engineer?

As the just mentioned gentleman has proven, it's entirely possible to do perfect masters 100% in the DAW. But unless it's him, or someone like him with a proven track record, looking for a mastering engineer with some outboard gear can serve as another filter in your quest.

Most of the "mixing and mastering" guys are unlikely to have any outboard gear. On the other hand, by far most professional mastering engineers have at least some outboard processing.

Where to find them professional mastering?

I recommend looking up what mastering engineers there are in your area. You can start by googling it, which is likely to mostly show you the most established ones (which in turn might be the most expensive ones). If there is an online hangout of audio professionals in your country, it's very much worth perusing it.

You should definitely check the Gearslutz mastering forum, which is one of the most prominent professional hangout.

You can also check our subreddit's listing of people offering mastering. You'll find some professionals, as well as some less experienced people giving mastering a try (whom are likely to be a lot more affordable)

How much does it cost?

As it tends to be the case with most of these things, it can vary a lot.

You should expect professional rates to start around $40-50 USD per track, that goes to around $100-150 USD per track in average. And of course you should expect to pay much more for some of the biggest names in mastering, like Bob Ludwig, Bob Katz, Bernie Grundman, etc.

Most people tend to have discounts on EPs and albums.

As a reference this is what some top mastering houses charge for their services:

I don't particularly recommend using these online services because despite the fact that they have excellent studios and great engineers, the experience in this online version is rather cold and transactional. You'll get a very good master, but the experience is unlikely to be memorable or at all personalized.

You can get equivalent services for less money, dealing directly with the engineer and it's more likely to be an overall better experience.

If you need recommendations, feel free to PM me and I'll send you a list of some of my favorites (in a range of different prices).

How to prepare your mixes for mastering

You are likely to have heard stuff like making sure your mixes are peaking at -6dB or lower. Yet when it comes to working 100% in the box (like most of us are these days), that's complete bullshit. Here is why: https://theproaudiofiles.com/6-db-headroom-mastering-myth-explained/

General considerations are:

  • Make sure your mixes aren't clipping.

  • Export at the bit depth and sample rate your mix session is at.

  • DON'T dither.

  • Bypass any mix bus limiter that is not a fundamental part of the sound of your mix. But also send them a version with that limiting if you had any, especially if it's the version you have been listening to the most.

That's about it really. If the mastering engineer in question has more specific requirements, they are sure to tell you (or have it described on their website).

Summary

Most people mixing at home are working on nearfield monitors and headphones which don't give you an accurate representation of the full range of audible sound, that means that you can never fully know what your mixes sound like exactly.

Professional mastering is a key quality assurance process that will ensure your material is truly ready for release. So if you are happy with your mixes and you can afford it, it's worth giving professional mastering a try.

NOTE: I've added this article to our wiki. And I'll soon have another article on how to approach your own mastering for those who can't yet afford a professional.