r/metroidvania • • Feb 01 '26

Discussion I LOVE RUNBACKS

0 Upvotes

I love it every time a boss defeats me and I reappear at the bonfire far, far away, surrounded by dozens of enemies I've already defeated between my character and the boss. So I run back, dodging each one of them. What a pleasant feeling, running and dodging, sometimes jumping or rolling! It's thrilling to repeat it every time the boss finishes me off! In Silksong, the path back to the final judge! Delicious!!

The Stakes of Marika are poorly designed! Why didn't they just simplify everything to a bonfire? Bad design, Mike Saki!

Games would definitely be better with more runbacks, and if the recovery vials were like in Bloodborne! I love farming those things!

Damn, how I enjoy runbacks!


r/metroidvania • • Dec 29 '24

Discussion Thoughts on Nine Sols, as a vet Metroidvania and Soulsborne gamer

3 Upvotes

The combat and movement in Nine Sols is extremely crisp. I never once experienced any annoying mechanic that I couldn't directly blame on my own actions.

The boss fights were extremely well done. Each boss fight felt unique (to the other bosses in the game) and was extremely fun. When boss fights are really fun, repeated failures just become a part of an enjoyable journey.

Regarding general combat and movement, I'd rank Nine Sols in the Top 4 metroidvania-like games that I've ever played. Regarding boss fights, this game has the funnest boss fights in any metroidvania that I have ever played.

Here is where I get critical...

The dialogue felt excessive and wasn't captivating to me. I felt the story could be told in a more succinct and meaningful way. After what seemed like an hour of reading insignificant dialogue between Yi and Shaunsaun (sp), I decided that I had read enough and promptly commensed to button smashing to get through the endless walls of text with Shaunsaun. The dialogue with Shaunsaun is not something I expect in a game like Nine Sols, it felt out of place. It is something I would expect in a game like Animal Crossing or My Time in Portia.

I've read a lot of praise for the artwork in Nine Sols, but after playing through the game, I can't say that I share the same opinion. Character artwork felt bland, lacked detail and personality. The environment artwork was marginally better than the character artwork, but I can't say that it breaks into my top 20 metroidvanias, artwork wise.

I enjoyed the musical score quite a bit. The team did a phenomenal job on the music.

The fanbase of the game is... weird, to put it politely. The game's story and artwork style appears to be a magnet for the mentally ill. Some of the themes in the game, were questionable, at best.

Ultimately, Nine Sols is a very fun and challenging game that I would recommend to any Metroidvania gamer. It has easily broken into the top 5 metroidvania games that I've ever played.


r/metroidvania • • Dec 01 '25

Discussion My hot take on Silksong, Hollow Knight, and the future of the MV genre

13 Upvotes

Silksong! It's a good game. I know, it's shocking to find someone with this view, but bear with me. Now, I've previously expressed the thought that the original Hollow Knight is somewhat overrated, and I still believe that. It's a really great game, sure, but I think many people essentially put it in god tier, far higher than any mere mortal videogame. And this has essentially caused a bit of a revolution in the MV genre, hasn't it? We had the dim dark past of MV's before Hollow Knight, and now we have the glorious present where nearly every MV is inspired by Hollow Knight in some way. Because HK was so beloved, people naturally asked why. The answer was obvious: the movement, the combat, the openness, the charms, the map, the bosses, the bread-crumb lore, the platforming, the art style, etc. So on came games taking these elements directly from Hollow Knight. You play Super Metroid, for example, and you have a big character with a beam gun and a very floaty jump, but in Hollow Knight you're small, with a very quick melée weapon, and very tight jump controls, which enable dance-like very hard bosses and pogo-heavy platforming gauntlets. So, games have made small characters with quick melée attacks and easy air control, and they've made very hard bosses and pogo-heavy platforming gauntlets. Even the art style has been copied, even specific boss attacks, even the appearance of the character (I can name several MV's with some very HK-like avatars). All of this, I think, is meant to capture the magic of Hollow Knight.

But that obvious answer to what makes HK so great was, well, wrong. What makes it great is the quality of the experience. The mechanics are fine, and yeah, HK has some Souls-like ideas that made for some very fairly challenging bosses in a way not really seen before in MV's, which have more often been DPS races than elegant dances, but this comes with excellent storytelling, excellent music, excellent art, an excellent setting, excellent gameplay tuning, excellent atmosphere, and so on. You can't just take those elements, copy them, and say hey look, my game is great because it shares these elements with Hollow Knight! That's just not where greatness comes from. Team Cherry understood what makes a game great, and they made that happen with the set of mechanics they wanted to use; if they had wanted different mechanics, it probably would have turned out just as good (if not better) because the mechanics aren't why the game is so great.

Enter Silksong. Silksong kinda destroys what Hollow Knight built, in a sense. Hornet? Not as small. The pogo, not there by default and you have the option to not even have it at all. That precise air control now comes with running momentum. The charm system is replaced by Tools, which work very differently -- I mean, you have a whole ranged arsenal now! Gone is the super-quick horizontal dash that was so important for HK. If Hollow Knight spawned the HK-like subgenre, the actual sequel Silksong is not a Hollow-Knight-like. That's pretty crazy to think about, isn't it? I mean, obviously there are still many similarities, but many of the specific elements that were repeatedly imitated with "homages" (yeah, right) to Hollow Knight are not part of the game. And the stuff people complained about? Corpse runs, the fact that you have to buy maps and equip the Compass and that it only updates at benches, the insane difficulty? All still there. It's like Team Cherry listened to what everyone was saying and just... Captain America-ed out, "no, we don't think we will".

So I think Silksong, in being a really great game, exposes that lie, that what made Hollow Knight great was the mechanics. Silksong is great for the same reasons Hollow Knight was great, the fact that the developers are really good at what they do. You can't copy Silksong. There's nothing there to copy. There's nothing so special about the mechanics of Silksong that hasn't been done dozens of times in other games already. If you want to make a game like Silksong, then you need tons and tons of quality. And it's not just that. Team Cherry spent seven long years working on this, and it shows. There'll be no such thing as a "Silksong-like". Instead, I think we may see more of an understanding about the amount of effort and hard work (and talent) that it takes to make a game of this scale and quality (because Silksong, in addition to being a really great game, is MASSIVELY HUGE). Hopefully devs are fully aware that they're not going to make the next Hollow Knight by copying mechanics, and that actually making something like this is really, really hard. I personally also enjoy playing smaller games that didn't take 7 years to make, so I hope that devs can realize their dreams of making great games that fit their desired scope, whether small or large. But my real hope here is that the era of HK ripoffs is done for good, because ripping off Silksong would be pointless without the massive amounts of quality behind it.

Anyway, that's all I have to say about that. Feel free to agree or disagree!


r/metroidvania • • Nov 30 '24

Discussion Nine Sols isn’t an MV. It’s a soulslike masquerading as one

0 Upvotes

So I’m about 12 hours into Nine Sols and mostly spite playing it for the story at this point. It on the surface very much looks like an MV and I’ve seen many in this community talking about it. But it’s not, it’s a Soulslike.

It’s super linear with maybe one or two options at most on where to go. You rarely find areas that require an ability you acquire later to get to. While it rewards some exploration the main focus is definitely on the combat instead. It’s got a high degree of difficulty, the resting mechanic, and an extreme over-reliance on parrying. Oh and the map sucks.


r/metroidvania • • Oct 20 '26

Discussion Belmont's curse is… ok

0 Upvotes

Yay, my turn to make a post. Finished it at 99.4% (only missing xp statues) in 15 hours and just wanted to rant/share my opinion

For me the game is an ok, slightly better than average MV with a Castlevania wrapping and Konami price tag

The combat is very simple and doesn't change much throughout the game. Enemy variety is rather low and most bosses can be face rolled unless you are limiting yourself

Platforming and secrets are primarily built around whip hooks making it rather repetitive towards the end of the game. Getting from point A to B is rather slow and fast travel requires a slightly over the top amount of loading screens. Having said that the controls themselves felt rather smooth and responsive

Exploration is decent, there's a good deal of optional backtracking for stat boosts, relics and weapon. The map after the first few bosses gets rather open, but it is essentially split into 2 parts that are connectedby a single line passage, which makes sense narrative, yet still feels somewhat off

For the even more subjective details. Art is amazing, sound track is meh (bordering on being annoying in some locations), custom game settings are great to see. Quality of life in swapping every part of the build on the fly without requiring to stare at the mirror is also appreciated

Overall a solid 7/10 slightly overpriced experience


r/metroidvania • • Apr 18 '25

Discussion Playing Hollow Knight for the first time in 2025. Dropping it after 15 hours.

2 Upvotes

The reason I’m quitting isn't because the game is too hard. I love tough platforming and challenging bosses. Dying a hundred times is fine by me.

The problem is the long treks back to your place of death. Sometimes it takes up to 5 minutes just to get back there. It's exhausting. What’s the point of mastering difficult fights if I have to repeat the same 5 minutes run dozens of time just to try again? How is that fun?

I’m 35 years old. I’ve got a family and kids. And this game seriously expects me to spend 5 to 10 minutes per attempt, over and over, just to get another shot? I’d rather spend that time with my family — or play a game that respects my time with better quality-of-life design.

Any recommendations for other highly-rated metroidvanias that don’t suffer from this kind of punishing backtracking?


r/metroidvania • • Oct 21 '23

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: I don't like pixel graphics in new games.

2 Upvotes

At least when compared to good hand-drawn style graphics. I know that's setting the bar high, but I really find heavily pixelated graphics to be harsh on the eyes.

Games like Rogue Legacy 2 and Ender Lilies, for example, just looks so incredibly refreshing after playing Death's Gambit and Dead Cells. I feel like I have 20/20 vision again, instead of incredibly blurry vision.

When the pixel density is higher, it's not that bad. But some pixel art games are just so unpleasant to look at after a while.


r/metroidvania • • Jan 22 '26

Discussion Hollow knightification has been a disaster for the metroidvania genre as a whole.

0 Upvotes

I wish they were classified as a different genre as the staples of good metroidvanias (rpg elements, exploration, no corpse runs, focus on multiple combat styles instead of just melee and lively word) are not found in hollowknightlikes. So annoying to play a new metroidvania release and in 10 mins it turns out to be hollowslop. Tiny oval shape character sprite in "dead world" with no normal map and tRiNkEts. Even the melee combat is so shallow for my taste, (no flashy combos, no different melee weapons with drastically different playstyle). I am tired bros. Can we get a good metroidvania like Blasphemous, Afterimage or Bloodstained anymore.


r/metroidvania • • Mar 03 '25

Discussion 9 Sols, i ran out of love.

0 Upvotes

Anyone else kinda get through about half of it and just kind of felt like: meh?

  1. The story is so verbose and so much of the convo isn't actually anything of consequence. I really wonder if they'd gone like Tunic/HLD and just had next to no convo how much more mysterious and intriguing it'd be.

  2. I finally got fed up of the slog of getting to the 3rd stage of the lady ethereal fight over and over that i called quits. I'm getting tired of "git gud". It's a laboured premise that game modifiers don't really satiate. There's a world in which git gud mode isn't the de facto base game and where players aren't demeaned into story mode because they don't want to fight a boss for 4 hours.

It's a shame cos all the previous bosses were pretty fun in my opinion, but i gather they're all insane from here on out so... Nah. I'll read a book instead


r/metroidvania • • Mar 30 '25

Discussion New Metroid Prime Trailer Was Really Underwhelming

0 Upvotes

Let me start off by saying I am a massive Metroid Prime fan. I have played the original games like ten times each. I want this franchise to succeed. I’m not trying to be a hater in any way.

With that being said I am super conflicted after seeing this last trailer. The music,character designs and plot all look amazing. I am super excited for a new soundtrack, weapons, suits etc.

However, the graphics looked terrible for this being a brand new Metroid game. I think some parts of Metroid Prime Remastered looks better which says a lot. The gameplay looks super underwhelming as well. It packs no punch or uniqueness to it. Feels like they are ripping 20 year old gameplay and pasting it in a new Prime title. I like the gameplay from the Prime trilogy but I think it needs a major overhaul to stay relevant/ fun in today’s ever changing competitive gaming world. If the gameplay is flat it will be really hard to enjoy this game for me. I like the idea of physic powers but I feel like it will be a dumbed down version of the Wii controls and not have much depth.

Also, what was with that trailer? It felt so calm and not hype what so ever with a boring monologue in the background. Kind of disappointed.

Overall, I’m super excited for this game. I really want it to succeed and for it to sell well. I think if they tweak a few things it will be one of the greatest they have ever made. Hopefully all goes well 🤞

What were your thoughts on the trailer?


r/metroidvania • • Oct 08 '25

Image You're not

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/metroidvania • • Oct 31 '25

Discussion Silksong is about as forgiving (most of the time) as the first game.

17 Upvotes

I never found Silksong to be as punishing as people made it out to be and it’s not because I’m skilled (I really am not).

The reason for that relies entirely on one feature: the healing system.

Healing in Silksong is so much more versatile and forgiving than the first game that you can basically heal after any attack in almost every boss fight, being able to heal midair makes for so many healing windows that HK just didn’t have at all. The first game made it so the player had to be so careful as to when and where we could charge up a heal and not get hit while at it whereas in Silksong you really don’t have to think about it as much.

Also, you heal for 3 masks straight up to account for the double damage and Multibinder extends it to 4. For that, I also don’t think double damage was that huge of deal, you can heal so much faster and more efficiently that it’s perfectly accounted for in my opinion.


r/metroidvania • • Jan 12 '26

Discussion Ori games better than Hollow Knight? Hot take or not?

10 Upvotes

Is it a hot take to think the Ori games are better than Hollow Knight in almost every way including art style? I don't understand how Hollow knight gets more hype than Ori games. Thoughts?


r/metroidvania • • Nov 25 '25

Discussion [Weekly Vote] The Best Metroidvania Games of all Time: What's the Best Retro Metroidvania game?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I see a lot of tier lists (and the eyerolling) but what about something the community votes on? I've made a grid* we can fill out to see the best of the best, one a week so its nice and spaced out.

So, first up: What's the Best Retro Metroidvania game?

To vote: comment or upvote a comment with the game/games you support.

*Let me know what folks think about the awards - happy to change them up!


r/metroidvania • • Jan 02 '24

Discussion Guacamelee is meh

21 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel disappointed by Guacamelee? I’ve played both games and found them extremely lacking as metroidvanias. To begin, progression is very linear. The map always shows the way forward and there is not much in the way of exploration. Secondly, the world design feels extremely stiff and unimaginative. It’s just a constant loop of platforming rooms and mob fights. This is made worse by the fact that enemy variety is painfully low, amounting to barely over ten unique enemies throughout the entire game. Finally, the most egregious part of the game is the colored blocks sprinkled throughout the game. Instead of finding a clever way to roadblock players, Guacamelee opts to use huge colored blocks that indicate which specific power you need. This completely broke my immersion and seeing it anytime killed what little enjoyment I was having. All in all, it’s a fine game and I can see why people enjoy it but it’s a really bad metroidvania in my opinion.


r/metroidvania • • Jul 26 '26

Discussion Playing Nine Sols after Silksong is so refreshing

3 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong i really liked Silksong comparing these games shows how much quality of life nine sols has over silksong

Combat is hands down amazing with parrying attacks and NO F***ING IMPACT DAMAGE which made Silksong such a chore

Bosses are amazing in both games but in terms of enemies overall i prefer nine sols. Silksong has way more pain points in certain areas.

Mini bosses are better in all ways and don't get me started on gauntlets.

So yeah overall i really like Silksong but Nine Sols shows me what i miss in this MV.

Hope i didn't sound too harsh but some points strike me immediately:)


r/metroidvania • • May 26 '25

Our New Metroidvania: Isekai Saintess, Demonic Arm, and an Ugly Truth – would u play it?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

After wrapping up METAL SUITS: Counter-attack, we're diving into our next Metroidvania project—and we'd love to hear your thoughts.

The concept:

A girl is summoned to an Isekai world and chosen as a saintess... but her right arm is corrupted by a demonic sword.

As she fights for the world’s salvation, she begins to uncover an ugly truth behind the summoning, the gods, and even herself.

We're aiming to blend fast-paced combat with an emphasis on precise parrying, ability-based progression, and a layered, emotional narrative.

Would this premise appeal to you as a Metroidvania fan? What kinds of mechanics, themes, or visual styles would you hope to see in a game like this?

Any feedback—conceptual, mechanical, or just gut feeling—is super appreciated!


r/metroidvania • • Mar 22 '26

Discussion Silk Song - Anyone else actually like the run backs and the boss rush rooms?

2 Upvotes

I get it, they can be annoying - especially the never ending boss rush rooms.

But there’s something awesome about them. They put you into this Hypnotic trance where you lock in and just fly through it, bouncing off enemies, dodging the ones you don’t need to worry about, parkour-ing through the gauntlet. After you do it a couple dozen times and finally beat the boss, it turns you into a beast. It’s the ultimate leveling up.

It’s the best feeling when you return to earlier zones and just tear through enemies that originally gave you a hard time.


r/metroidvania • • Oct 23 '25

Image Help me w my MV. Would you play one that looked like this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just need you to help me with all the graphics, movement upgrades and abilities, and cool boss fights.


r/metroidvania • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion Tried Blasphemous and didn't like it so far

1 Upvotes

I've only played for around an hour, but I just couldn't really find it in me to continue.

The movement feels very slow and stiff.

You can't move at all while slashing so you can't chase after enemies.

Sparse checkpoints.

Instant deaths that sends you all the way back to a checkpoint that is multiple rooms away.

Corpse running ruins the fun for me since I really couldn't give a damn to return to the last location I died in since those locations are usually the tedious ones filled with annoying enemies.

No clear indication in which way to go first, causing me to repeatedly meet dead ends, having to back track all the way to a different route, meet another dead end, rinse and repeat. At this point I'm so bored of having to return to a different location in the map.

I wouldn't mind constant back tracking if the movement is fast, agile and satisfying like Silksong's movement. But this one feels very slow and sluggish to me. Everytime I have to go from point A to point B and seeing how far away those points are, I already groan because that means I have to slowly move my stiff character all the way there and a single mistakes cause me to restart 10 rooms away where the checkpoint was.

I don't understand why I feel this way because I heard a lot of people say Blasphemous is very good and the review of this game is good. I'm wondering if I'm missing something or if I play the game wrong? So far I've played Hollow Knight, Silksong, Nine sols, Ori games, Ender Lilies, and Constance, and I finished them all with no issue. Silksong and Nine sols has currently become my absolute favorite of this genre because of how fun they are. But I'm just currently not feeling it with Blasphemous.

Anyone has any tips of what I'm missing? Did I do anything wrong? Was I supposed to do something first? Like, I just need an explanation lol.


r/metroidvania • • Apr 02 '26

Discussion Grime II reviews... wtf is wrong with people? How does Steam even allow this?

Post image
54 Upvotes

I mean, what your political/racist/antisemit opinions have to do with actual game quality? Do you really expect from game creators to leave their homeland before releasing the game? How is it their fault, they didnt choose where to be born.

12 people that found this recent review helpful is what dreads me the most.


r/metroidvania • • Jun 10 '25

Discussion Is this sub becoming nothing but ads?

0 Upvotes

Why does it seem like literally EVERY post in this sub lately is just, "We're making a hollow knigh-like!"

"Our new game has a demo!"

"Come check out my kickstarter for the game im making!"

I mean, i juat wanna see people talk about cool games, not people selling stuff at me 😭


r/metroidvania • • Oct 11 '25

Image As if this sub needs more Hollow Knight glazing. Sorry everyone, it's just how I feel.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I feel I probably need to justify some of these so I'll elaborate in the replies


r/metroidvania • • Feb 06 '26

Discussion Whoever said the Silksong community was toxic...was right sadly

0 Upvotes

Ever since Silksong came out and Silksong players have been hating on and making fun of other players who are bad at the game or new at it. Which is sad to see because I'm a Silksong fan. Apparently they also only like their game. If you mention another game that's not Silksong, they literally go insane.