Silksong! It's a good game. I know, it's shocking to find someone with this view, but bear with me. Now, I've previously expressed the thought that the original Hollow Knight is somewhat overrated, and I still believe that. It's a really great game, sure, but I think many people essentially put it in god tier, far higher than any mere mortal videogame. And this has essentially caused a bit of a revolution in the MV genre, hasn't it? We had the dim dark past of MV's before Hollow Knight, and now we have the glorious present where nearly every MV is inspired by Hollow Knight in some way. Because HK was so beloved, people naturally asked why. The answer was obvious: the movement, the combat, the openness, the charms, the map, the bosses, the bread-crumb lore, the platforming, the art style, etc. So on came games taking these elements directly from Hollow Knight. You play Super Metroid, for example, and you have a big character with a beam gun and a very floaty jump, but in Hollow Knight you're small, with a very quick melée weapon, and very tight jump controls, which enable dance-like very hard bosses and pogo-heavy platforming gauntlets. So, games have made small characters with quick melée attacks and easy air control, and they've made very hard bosses and pogo-heavy platforming gauntlets. Even the art style has been copied, even specific boss attacks, even the appearance of the character (I can name several MV's with some very HK-like avatars). All of this, I think, is meant to capture the magic of Hollow Knight.
But that obvious answer to what makes HK so great was, well, wrong. What makes it great is the quality of the experience. The mechanics are fine, and yeah, HK has some Souls-like ideas that made for some very fairly challenging bosses in a way not really seen before in MV's, which have more often been DPS races than elegant dances, but this comes with excellent storytelling, excellent music, excellent art, an excellent setting, excellent gameplay tuning, excellent atmosphere, and so on. You can't just take those elements, copy them, and say hey look, my game is great because it shares these elements with Hollow Knight! That's just not where greatness comes from. Team Cherry understood what makes a game great, and they made that happen with the set of mechanics they wanted to use; if they had wanted different mechanics, it probably would have turned out just as good (if not better) because the mechanics aren't why the game is so great.
Enter Silksong. Silksong kinda destroys what Hollow Knight built, in a sense. Hornet? Not as small. The pogo, not there by default and you have the option to not even have it at all. That precise air control now comes with running momentum. The charm system is replaced by Tools, which work very differently -- I mean, you have a whole ranged arsenal now! Gone is the super-quick horizontal dash that was so important for HK. If Hollow Knight spawned the HK-like subgenre, the actual sequel Silksong is not a Hollow-Knight-like. That's pretty crazy to think about, isn't it? I mean, obviously there are still many similarities, but many of the specific elements that were repeatedly imitated with "homages" (yeah, right) to Hollow Knight are not part of the game. And the stuff people complained about? Corpse runs, the fact that you have to buy maps and equip the Compass and that it only updates at benches, the insane difficulty? All still there. It's like Team Cherry listened to what everyone was saying and just... Captain America-ed out, "no, we don't think we will".
So I think Silksong, in being a really great game, exposes that lie, that what made Hollow Knight great was the mechanics. Silksong is great for the same reasons Hollow Knight was great, the fact that the developers are really good at what they do. You can't copy Silksong. There's nothing there to copy. There's nothing so special about the mechanics of Silksong that hasn't been done dozens of times in other games already. If you want to make a game like Silksong, then you need tons and tons of quality. And it's not just that. Team Cherry spent seven long years working on this, and it shows. There'll be no such thing as a "Silksong-like". Instead, I think we may see more of an understanding about the amount of effort and hard work (and talent) that it takes to make a game of this scale and quality (because Silksong, in addition to being a really great game, is MASSIVELY HUGE). Hopefully devs are fully aware that they're not going to make the next Hollow Knight by copying mechanics, and that actually making something like this is really, really hard. I personally also enjoy playing smaller games that didn't take 7 years to make, so I hope that devs can realize their dreams of making great games that fit their desired scope, whether small or large. But my real hope here is that the era of HK ripoffs is done for good, because ripping off Silksong would be pointless without the massive amounts of quality behind it.
Anyway, that's all I have to say about that. Feel free to agree or disagree!