r/merlinbbc • • Feb 10 '26

Discussion What if the show incorporated Merlin being the son of Satan as in the original legends?

1 Upvotes

It always irks me that adaptations forget that.


r/merlinbbc • • Jul 09 '26

Discussion I don't like the show but live fandom?

4 Upvotes

I have read a bunch of fics and watching the show for the first time, now s2e1, and i just can't watch it's so frustrating.

I really don't like many plot points. And how they treat Morgana. And Merlin&Arthur, because what is happening usually is unfair to both of them and to their relationship. And how grey themes and grey characters are shown as fairytale good or bad.

But i love actors' performance, and i want more and more and more of it. And i love many scenes, often separately from the episode plot.

I just love it and want to watch but it's hard and i can't wow


r/merlinbbc • • Nov 29 '12

Keep the BBC Merlin TV Series going after series 5

Thumbnail
thepetitionsite.com
0 Upvotes

r/merlinbbc • • Dec 25 '25

Discussion Merlin is absolutely annoying and borderline insufferable (imo) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I’m new to the series and just finished season 2. So far from what I’ve seen Merlin seems to cause almost all of the problems that’s taken place either by not listening or by solely thinking of Arthur. I wanna first start with him going against Gaius and sending Morgana to the druids only to chase after her to come back so Uther wouldn’t kill ppl who had connections with Druids which led to Druids being killed bc he was followed by the knights. All of which increased Uthers belief that the Druids are bad ppl and Morgana was kidnapped which nether was true. Also, I don’t understand this narrative that Morgana is evils bc she doesn’t agree with Uther killing innocent people.

Another careless thing he did was go to Nimueh to save Arthur by trading his life only for his mom to almost die and while he was sad he didn’t do any immediate action to try and help her he just kind of accepted it (but if it was Arthur…) prompting Gaius to sacrifice himself for MERLINS MOTHER. Of course everything worked out at the end but it seems he only cares about Arthur all bc of an alleged destiny the dragon told him. Which leads me to my next thing.

It was an episode about a crystal that could show the future and when Merlin looked at the crystal he saw the dragon biting down Camelot. A couple of episodes later he made a deal to free the dragon for the information of how to wake the kingdom up (which was killing Morgana) even though he had saw the future of the dragon biting down the kingdom. Also, I want to point out that Morgause’s goal was only to get rid of king Uther to stop the paranoid bloodshed and legalize magic. Which they did go about it wrong even Gaius said it would’ve been understandable Merlin just let them do what they were gonna do. Anyways he freed the dragon after all of that and was shocked that the dragon wanted to rage on Camelot as if he didn’t know that was gonna happen.

Merlin also tends to blame a lot of his doings on other people.

It’s also annoying how he villainizes everyone who has the thought of revenge but proudly serve and protect a kingdom that kills innocent people in the name of principle. He becomes the moral police when you’re not royalty.

Another situation he caused was the witch hunter coming to Camelot bc he was playing with magic in the forest which led to Gaius being tortured and himself and Morgana almost being exposed as magicians and he just acted as if everything was unprovoked when it was all his fault.

I could go on but I think it’s clear that he’s just an annoying character all around. I could be more understanding if him and Arthur were in a gay relationship or maybe he was from Camelot but neither of those are the case. He’s putting everyone else at risk to protect a prince and kingdom that won’t even accept him being a wizard


r/merlinbbc • • Jul 03 '25

Discussion i wish they'd been willing and able to explore the romantic relationship between arthur and morgana Spoiler

5 Upvotes

in the first season especially, the showrunners HUGELY play on the fact that arthur and morgana have a strong mutual attraction to one another, and more or less accept that they'll end up together. arthur gets jealous when morgana looks at other men, and she does so because she's a bit of a rebel and doesn't like to be too predictable.

the year was 2008, three years before GoT started airing. and why does this matter? because i feel that GoT """normalised""" incest on screen, and i think the biggest take away from that acceptance is that audiences were far less disgusted than they were expected to be. it's fiction after all, but even in real life royal families have often married cousins together.

i feel like this is semi relevant to merlin, because whilst it was a family friendly show, if they'd known it wouldn't be met with outrage and outcry, the merlin showrunners might have had the freedom to explore arthur and morgana's relationship more faithfully.

personally i would have loved to have seen a juxtaposition of gwen's affair with lancelot - in the form of arthur and morgana - their forbidden, fated love, and the consequences of it (mordred being their son in the arthurian legends). i feel like the entire storyline would have carried so much more weight if mordred had been portrayed as arthur's child, rather than a random druid who goes astray.


r/merlinbbc • • Jul 01 '26

Question ❓ What's the time gap kinda between Merlin and Game of Thrones?

4 Upvotes

I don't mean like a gap of when they aired, but like what time period and how far away they would be. Cause when you look it up it seems like GoT happens almost a hundred years later. But they both have castles, and carriages, and peseants, and dragons. Like idk


r/merlinbbc • • Aug 24 '21

(For Merthur shippers) What should Merlin and Arthur be called if they were to have kids together?

4 Upvotes

In my head I always thought that if Merthur were to have a child together that Merlin would be Papa and Arthur would be Dad, but I've seen quite a number of fics where it's the other way round so I was wondering what you guys think!

147 votes, Aug 27 '21
88 Papa Merlin/Daddy Arthur
59 Daddy Merlin/Papa Arthur

r/merlinbbc • • Jun 01 '23

DISCUSSIONS I will never understand Merlin fans' obsession with Taylor Swift. I know the songs are good but you know there are other good songs too😑

0 Upvotes

r/merlinbbc • • Apr 22 '24

Discussion This entire show is just gaslighting the victims of abuse

71 Upvotes

Your boss overworks you, insults you, and physically abuses you? Well it's your "destiny" to put up with it because one day they might change.

Your dad murders everyone like you and will do the same to you if he ever discovers your identity? Well if you dare to stand up to him, you deserve to be poisoned and killed.

Your government is persecuting and exterminating minorities? Well you just have to collaborate for the time being because the next leader will be so much nicer, we promise.


r/merlinbbc • • Jun 06 '23

DISCUSSIONS i feel like merlin mother hated him like why send him to camelot it was more dangrous then the eldor

0 Upvotes

r/merlinbbc • • Dec 01 '21

DISCUSSIONS Merlin and Arthur...

1 Upvotes

So I hear so many things of queerbaiting and queer coding, how they were secretly in love and all that... but I think the issue is a bit more nuisance than that.

I think, and this is just a theory, that they are not Gay or even written to be attracted to each other at all. I think it is a mixture of fantastic chemistry and literal decades of being inspired by Queer coding without knowing the consequences and reality of it. Those writing the series just followed patterns they knew were successful, which happen to fall under Queer coding if done intentionally. It is not like teen wolf, which intentionally played that card like jerks.

However, since LGBT people are a hell of a lot more common than people realize I am sure there are Gay characters in the series. For example, I always saw Lancelot as Bisexual with a thing for Merlin, though Merlin is totally undeserving of any love interests in my book since he really is as bad as Uther but I digress...

I think the discussion needs to be less bashing and freaking out and just appreciating the series for what it was... a semi decent series that refused to change up the status quo, that was a product of it's times in a lot of ways.

That will be all... if you have your own thoughts, be nice, but please share them.


r/merlinbbc • • Dec 24 '24 I’ll Drink to That Hehehe

Gifs 🎞️ Forget Merthur...All hail Utherus! Spoiler

9 Upvotes

r/merlinbbc • • Jul 02 '26

Fanfiction 🖋️ Arthur X OC Fanfic?

0 Upvotes

Hiiii!

Do you have any favorite Arthur x Original Character fanfictions you could recommend to me?

I don’t mind the platform they’re on (FF.net, AO3, Wattpad, or anywhere else…?)
I especially enjoy stories where the OC is actually a princess (ik ,…. cliché 😅). I’m usually not that interested in stories where she is Merlin’s sister, but I’m happy to be proven wrong if there’s a good one

Thanks ! ❤️


r/merlinbbc • • Jan 18 '23

FANFICTION Looking for Beta/Co-author from trans community for a !transmerlin Merthur fanfic.

0 Upvotes

Looking for a Beta or Co-Author from the trans community to help with a fic I plan to write for AO3.

The fic is a oneshot for the Merlin BBC fandom, the ship is Merthur but in this story Merlin is a trans man who ran away from his own royal family because they wouldn't accept him, and is about to be found out cause his birth fam showed up in Camelot for reasons I won't divulge here.

it is heavily inspired by this fic: https://archiveofourown.org/works/26950681

However while I am not cisgender, I am not trans either. Nor have I had to deal with the struggles people from the trans community deal with.

As such I am looking for either a beta or coauthor from the transgender community to help me make sure that I accurately portray the struggles that Merlin has to deal with. Must have gmail as I use google drive to write my fics and one-shots and will need to share the document with you.

As I am writing this there is no draft or work text for the fic. Only a detailed plot outline.

If you are interested send me a DM on insta. Username styxhuntress. Please include the following in your message.

Whether you want to co author or simply beta the one-shot

If you want to co author the fic please provide a link to your ao3 profile, assuming you do post your own fics. If you do not post fanfics I would appreciate a small writing sample as I want to find someone who's writing style goes well with my own.

How much experience you have as a beta (if you plan to purely beta read the fic.)


r/merlinbbc • • Feb 05 '24

Discussion Arthur is a failure because he is a simp with daddy issues despite knowing how horrible Uther is

0 Upvotes

One of the greatest disappointments of the series was Arthur’s obsession to get Uther’s approval even though Uther consistently abused and humiliated him, threatened the people he claims to love, betrays his mother (the lie surrounding his birth, Uther’s affair with Vivienne and hiding from Arthur that Morgana is his sister), and conducting genocide which seems not to phase Arthur at all (seriously, where are his own set of ethics). It makes me wonder if Arthur even has a sense of who he is as a person or does he merely react to circumstances and people.


r/merlinbbc • • Jul 12 '24

Discussion Are we agreed that Guinevere was Arthur’s mistress from season 2 but they couldn’t say that because it’s a family show?

6 Upvotes

Idk why it’s taken me until my like 7th watch to realise. Their relationship kinda doesn’t make sense otherwise


r/merlinbbc • • Jan 12 '24

Article/ News 📰 Jewish perspective on bbcm

7 Upvotes

https://www.heyalma.com/the-jewish-reality-behind-bbcs-merlin/

I think this is a good read and was able to unveil some perspective I would otherwise not have known of since I am not Jewish. I do think some folks would benefit from reading this too.


r/merlinbbc • • Dec 13 '12

I don't always drink beer, but

Thumbnail
imgur.com
2 Upvotes

r/merlinbbc • • Oct 27 '14

Seriously?

0 Upvotes

So I started watching merlin a while ago and I made it till season 2 episode 8 sins of the father and I was got annoyed that merlin lied to arthur about what uther had done and allowed athur to continue thinking magic is evi, after almost 3 season's merlin still hadn't revealed his magic to anyone and it was starting to annoy me so I looked up when merlin finally reveals his secret and he doesn't till the finale wtf seriously and then arthur dies right after that wtf! Thank fuck I looked it up when I did and didn't continue wasting my time further Im just lost for words.


r/merlinbbc • • Dec 06 '22

DISCUSSIONS Is it me, or are Arthur and Merlin really in love with each other?

9 Upvotes

I'm positively surprised because they behave a lot like a shy couple that's at the earlier stages of their relationship. When a relationship is at its infancy, sometimes people are very shy around each other and don't quite dare to admit their feelings to each other, or even to themselves.

I feel like they have this masculine thing of "we've been taught not to share our feelings, but somehow around each other, we just can't help it".

There's something to how incredibly devoted Merlin is, and how much he believes in him, also the way he's somehow tasked with guiding him towards his destiny is incredibly personal, imo. It's also visible that Arthur is a lot more touched by that than he lets on, and he keeps covering it up with this bro/I'm the king vibe.

I just feel like the way they behave around each other, is very soft and romantic somehow, underneath all the banter.


r/merlinbbc • • Oct 31 '25

Discussion Should I stop at season 3 or 4? can I watch the final without watching season 5? Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I just started watching, and now I can’t stop!

I already knew a bit about the Arthurian legend and had seen a few clips online (the big part of the ending’s kinda spoiled for me). I’ve read some of the discussions about it, but I still can’t decide.

Should I stop at season 3 or 4? Can I watch a few episodes of season 5, including the ending without watching that season?

Any good fanfic recommendations?


r/merlinbbc • • Aug 29 '23

DISCUSSIONS Am I?

5 Upvotes

Am I the only one who DID NOT like the use of a French Château for the setting of Camelot? Nothing against France, just why not a castle jn the British Isles? It is Arthurian Legend.


r/merlinbbc • • Mar 13 '24

Discussion I might get attacked for this opinion but...

14 Upvotes

This show is so awsome but omg, the acting, the special effects, are so freaking bad! I mean so laughably awful. Im sure its all on purpose because some of the actors werent so cheesy in other things. Im on my 3rd rewatch I love it so much. The episodes with the troll takes the cake but the goblin one is a close second. 🤣🤣🤣


r/merlinbbc • • Sep 11 '21

DISCUSSIONS Me and my friend made a list of what we think all the characters sexualities are. What are you're guys' opinions? Pardon my shit spelling of all the names.

Post image
14 Upvotes