r/mechwarrior • • Apr 30 '26

General My humble opinion about how mecha look in BattleTech.

0 Upvotes

For many years (decades? since MechCommander 2), something about mechas in BattleTech bothered me, but I couldn’t quite put my finger on what. Now I think I know: some mechs look off, silly - like enlarged humans, without any reasonable or believable reason.

Some mechs look awesome, like machines, especially the earlier ones in the early missions. They are great, giving off a realistic military vibe one can believe in. It creates the impression of a quasi-realistic simulation and strong immersion - kind of like a modern tank with different locomotion, something the military could possibly implement under certain conditions.

But some mechs, especially later ones, look like enlarged humans… just goofy. It’s basically impossible to believe that anything like that would even be considered a viable option in the real world. It harms immersion.

But it just my opinion.

cheers


r/mechwarrior • • Sep 24 '26

MechWarrior 2 Vibe Coded level viewer MW2

9 Upvotes

For a bit of fun, I vibe-coded a level viewer for my favourite childhood game: Mechwarrior 2. I just opened the `MECH2` folder in claude code and let it loose. Was surprised how much the AI was able to figure out just by looking at the binaries..

Not really planning to do anything with this. Just wanted to share because I thought the results are pretty cool.


r/mechwarrior • • Jul 25 '19

PGI + EGS PGI appreciation & what they've done for Mechwarrior & Battletech

0 Upvotes

I saw this being shared on Twitter and thought it is important for people to keep in perspective when talking about PGI's role for Mechwarrior. I know that some people here aren't the biggest fans, but I think it's undeniable what they've done and it would be good to keep in mind - maybe even tell the team how much we appreciate what they've done over the years? Here's the full text version of the series of tweets:

In the run-up to the release of Mechwarrior 5: Mercenaries we should give appreciation for what everyone at Piranha Games have done for Mechwarrior & Battletech. Not enough credit is given to the amazing folks who put their hearts, blood, sweat, & tears into this franchise.

Back in 2009, PGI plus Smith & Tinker wanted to resurrect Mechwarrior from the catacombs of Microsoft. Yet no publishers wanted to fund the development of MW:3015, even after going public with a visual slice trailer on IGN. This didn’t deter PGI as  they still went on to lay the groundwork for Mechwarrior Online with the help of crowdfunding and minor publishing from IGP.

In 2012 not only did the people at PGI manage to put out a F2P multiplayer Mechwarrior in CryEngine in 2012, it also re-launched a lot of the iconic mechs by hiring the amazingly talented Art God known as Alex Iglesias aka Flying Debris. For the first time in history, PGI established an annual MechCon in 2016 that gathered all the active branches of the Battletech and Mechwarrior universe under one roof in Vancouver to come together and celebrate.

In 2017 Harmony Gold used their copyright trolling to once again damage and extort all of the Battletech and Mechwarrior artists at Catalyst Game Labs, Harebrained Schemes, and Piranha Games for their redesigned Unseen mechs. Here, PGI took a stand and saved everybody’s asses (especially those that had defaulted the case) and basically ensured that the Unseen are back for good. If not for PGI, we would never have gotten the Marauder and Warhammer back!

In 2019, PGI is putting all their energy and funds into making the first singleplayer Mechwarrior in SEVENTEEN years. No longer hidden away by Microsoft’s disregard for Mechwarrior, we are getting a singleplayer Mechwarrior game developed in the state-of-the-art Unreal Engine 4 in 2019. All in all, it cannot be overstated how important PGI have been for the Mechwarrior & Battletech overall. It is simply astounding how they have helped bring about a new Golden Age for Mechwarrior & Battletech after 15 years of twilight and everybody thinking it was dead.

Huge love & thanks to everyone at Piranha, Catalyst, and Harebrained for making this time to be alive so incredibly special. You are appreciated!

So it is incredible that a medium-sized company like PGI single-handledly runs an annual convention that is also live streamed; an online F2P game getting support for over 7 years now; a beefy singleplayer game in a state-of-the-art graphics engine; fighting back against Harmony Gold's copyright trolling; and bringing all the Battletech creatives under one roof; and finally excavating a classic legacy series after Microsoft buried Mechwarrior deep for over a decade.


r/mechwarrior • • Aug 25 '13

The topic they won't allow on the MW:O Forums: What has the gameplay team done for the past six-nine months?

0 Upvotes

The PGI Team has made it clear that the Map team, the Mech team and the Networking team are separate entities and employees, working towards those ends. And in those areas, I will say that content and progress has been made, and will not criticize this aspect.

Now, to the gameplay team.

The last major update the gameplay did was the addition of ECM and Consumables. Of the consumables, only one was ever made useful, with the rest outright abandon past that point.

Since then, we have gotten a long stretch without so much as anyone editing an XML file, only to have them "return" this close to launch to jam in Ghost Heat (a feature most people hate) and 3PV (a feature most people hate with a passion) and little else. Both of these features are insanely simple to code in, and require a bare minimum of effort.

One of their programmers did produce the movement system. However instead of helping lights and mediums out flank heavies on hills, they went with "weight =/= size lol" logic and made mediums perform the same as a Stalker. It was never repaired.

So -what have they been doing- for the past six months?

Last I heard UI 2.0 was in the "mockup" stage a couple months back. This was SUPPOSED TO BE IN WEEKS AFTER CLOSED BETA. Community Warfare is also in a nebulous mock up stage. Balance has been improving slowly in some areas, still floundering in others, but I really don't think months of waiting can warrant a claim of doing much work. I absolutely guarantee you that anyone reading this post, with about 15 minutes of looking at the XML file, could do the same. It is practically plain text.

So my theory? Every core designer on this game got to closed beta, got their paycheck, and went on an extended uncaring vacation and left the interns programming dumb systems. This would mesh perfectly with their claims thus far.

Now that they are back, they can't undo the ONLY "progress" they've made in the past several months without being hung for it - and thus why they aren't letting go of these stupid ideas with a death grip. They were likely the scribblings on a napkin left behind. Even the time they spent in the offices I suspect was very much "checked out."

I think it's inexcusable and as more and more facts come to light, this is precisely what it's looking to be. They got their paycheck and ran with it. Operation Phoenix is pretty much Operation Paid Vacation II.

It'd be interesting to compare the patch notes to the staff credits and see who isn't doing any freaking work whatsoever.


r/mechwarrior • • Nov 27 '12

How I felt playing Mechwarrior 4 for the first time.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Nov 27 '19

Media/Video Mechwarrior 5 Mercs 5 - My First Look at MW5 Mercs Beta... before it crashes again

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Dec 14 '19

MechWarrior 5 Mechwarrior 5 review: 5/10 (from metacritic)

1 Upvotes

this is the review I posted on metacritic for those who haven't bought the game and wonder if they should. PS anyone know if there is a official forum for the game?

First off if your just reading the first part of the review ill spell it out, The game is playable but has some major flaws. Good news is that they are fixable with patches or mods so there is hope yet.Now for the long version; and im not gonna mince words, for a game delayed for a year and a half it is disappointing. I have given it a good shot and put some 20+ hours into the game before making a judgement. I was really hoping this game would offer more than it did but sadly no. so lets break it down.

Gameplay: The gameplay is surprisingly solid, from a combat standpoint, if you liked MWO style combat you will feel right at home. Combat feels good though there is some balancing that would be nice. However I don't like the lack of environmental effects on your mech this has been a core of the Mechwarrior franchise and it seems to be lacking. If it does exist its not marked anywhere and I have played on lava and ice planets and not noticed enough to want to make me change my load-out. Lastly there is the issue of the A.I. IT SUCKS, I ream really sucks, enemy units running into each other, and walls and off cliffs, you get the idea. Your allies are not any better, in missions like base defense they usually cause more damage than the enemy. The fact that the lance commands are essentially the same as MW3 from 1997 should be a big clue. I would have loved more detailed commands such as hold position but keep firing or form a battleline. Thankfully the environmental factors is a easy fix, and the A.I. while more tricky should be possible (and it really is needed).

Campaign:Most of the basics of the campaign are really good they took most of what Battletech PC did and that's a good thing, Open world, reputation and the ability to negotiate contracts are all great. However it is telling that the areas where they differ from Battletech is where the game falls short. The repair system is one big issue given how its implemented. Any battle damage you have to pay for, including armor, this drags the game way down and would have been much better if ti had been just structure/weapons like in Battletech. Also the game has a steep learning curve, you are really dropped to the wolves right from the start. The game hurts you for mistakes(badly) All of this is exacerbated the major flaw; the game has no difficulty settings, at all. For a modern single player game this is a mortal sin. Another problem is the lack of depth in the missions. There are hints of good ideas in some of the story missions that would really have been nice to see in "random" missions (turret generators and mobile field bases im looking at you). the Shitty AI doesn't help. Lastly the characters themselves are completely one dimensional if that you see no real emotion and develop no bonding with any of the characters (including your own).

Graphics: While a relatively minor issue the fact that the graphics are not drastically better than MWO which came out in 2012(and not with cutting edge graphics for its time either) which puts the graphics 10 years out of date.


r/mechwarrior • • May 08 '18

MechWarrior 5: Mercenaries, No commanding a Lance?

0 Upvotes

So I've been watching any video I can find of MW 5 single-player, and for some reason none of the videos show the player commanding a Lance of mechs. All you see is the players running the missions solo. Has the franchise seriously been watered down to this status now? Please tell me they didn't hand the license over to a bunch of lazy underachievers who have betrayed the spirit of the game. Even the first MechWarrior in 8 bit graphics had you build and command a Lance. MechWarrior without the ability to build up and command a Lance in combat is nothing more than a cheaply made first person shooter. So what's the deal with this?


r/mechwarrior • • Jul 29 '19

PGI + EGS When MW5: Mercenaries launches...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Jul 28 '19

PGI + EGS It's okay if you're upset about the EGS deal, just get a refund, but don't harass, insult, or even threaten PGI and Russ

0 Upvotes

The last two days have been so bad and show some really ugly sides of Mechwarrior fans. There is so much hate sent towards PGI and Russ Bullock. And I just cannot understand it at all.

If you are really uspet about a time-limited change in which software launcher to use, that's cool. Just go request a refund and wait 365 days for the Steam release or don't ever buy it. You even get to keep your MWO content and you can always just play the game on Steam later. But do not take out your frustration by harassing and insulting the people who are working their asses off to make the best Mechwarrior game as possible for you. Right now PGI and Russ are receiving so much bullshit on social media because of a temporary change in a software distribution platform! I am seeing insults, "fuck yous", calling him a liar, hoping PGI goes bankrupt, mistreating the IP, harassment, bullying, and even death threats! Even some people are advocating piracy from a small studio whose livelihood depends on the success of this game. All of this over a videogame

And if you are a YouTuber or have a platform where lots of people listen to you, don’t use it to spread hate or provoke harassment and inflaming the situation by misrepresenting and simplifying a complex decision. Instead, use your platform to dissect and analyze the decision and make people come together. This goes especially for Sid Alpha whose viral video accompanies much of the resentment I am seeing online.

PGI does not exist to please you at all times, neither do they exist to be your servants who will always tell you everything they think, do, or decide upon, so of course they are going to make the decision that results in the best game possible with the highest chance of success. All game developers do this! And even if you feel you were lied to, that does not warrant harassment or insults or death threats. And don’t take these Youtubers at their word when they call PGI "dirty devs" or "liars" - they are in it for the clicks and the money by manufacturing outrage, and if there’s one thing some of these Angry Gamer Youtubers love, it’s chasing gamer resentment and generating revenue. Truth and compassion are much further down their list of priorities when they do these videos.

If you want to see the positive side of the EGS decision, this was a good read:

  1. The extra money gives PGI the opportunity to hire more developers, give a much stronger marketing push, and we get German, French, Russian localization at launch

  2. It enables PGI to delay MW5 away from Gears of War 5 and Borderlands which would’ve crushed the potential sales of MW5

  3. By being on the EGS store, the recoup point for MW5 is much, much smaller. 12% cut on EGS versus 35% on Steam? Only a fool would go with the latter. We are talking ¾ of sales on EGS being as significant as on Steam

  4. If you don’t like to install another software launcher, ask for a refund and you still get to keep all your MWO content for free!

  5. Wait and see how the game is when it releases in December. No one is forcing you to preorder now. If you can't wait, get the game on EGS and add the exe to your Steam client!

  6. Mechwarrior 5: Mercs will still come out on Steam and GOG next year and at that point will be even better thanks to patches and the awesome modding community.

  7. This is the first singleplayer Mechwarrior game in 17 years and you want to quit because you can’t be bothered by installing another launcher? Come on  

This deal gives us a better overall and polished game, lessens the financial risks, gets the game bigger marketing, a higher chance of success and thereby more Mechwarrior games in the future, and finally you can get  your money back and wait, and it’ll still be on Steam and GOG later. How are people this upset that they harass and bully the developers making this game?


r/mechwarrior • • Apr 25 '21

MechWarrior Online Sirant Presents: How I Suck @ Mechwarrior Online – Hunting with the Huntsman!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Nov 28 '12

Take a Ride

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • 13d ago

General Mods need to ban all AI slop coded stuff from this sub.

148 Upvotes

So sick of seeing a bunch of posts about "oh I made MW2-4 better" and it's all Claude assisted trash.


r/mechwarrior • • May 01 '18

Anyone interested playing some PROTO MECHS?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Sep 17 '17

MechWarrior 5: Mercenaries Pre-Alpha Footage (Mech_Con 2016)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Jan 29 '14

B.A.D - Battle Armor Division - mechs landing on DESURA -

0 Upvotes

We are happy to announce the release of patch 1.2.9 for B.A.D Battle Armor Division. http://www.criansoft.com/eng/Download.html We have also updated the demo to reflect all of the new patches and changes! So, if you haven't decided to buy B.A.D yet, and would like to take a second look, check here. http://www.criansoft.com/eng/BADdownload.html B.A.D will be also available on Desura very soon. http://www.desura.com/games/bad-battle-armor-division


r/mechwarrior • • Dec 18 '19

MechWarrior 5 Tonnage Limit Must Be Gone.

9 Upvotes

why would you NOT be allowed to use your full power on any mission?

Who makes the rules? The client? Do they NOT want me to succeed?

This is one of the things that stop the game from getting fun.

We should be allowed to wipe the battlefield with our opponents' face if we have the resource.

Something like a 'recommended minimum tonnage' would be okay, but this is a bad feature. Who's with me?


r/mechwarrior • • Apr 06 '14

How you know you've been making poor in-game decisions...

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Dec 15 '19

MechWarrior 5 PGI don't fix 100% of the spawn problem, leave 10% for drama. Ambush scenario.

3 Upvotes

Here me out. If they fixed the stupid aircraft and tanks that just automagically appear on top of you, but left a few mech scenarios, they could easily put a voice over from your drop ship, calling it an ambush with powered down mechs, who will take a second to power up.

Turn a flaw into gameplay by selling it correctly.


r/mechwarrior • • May 02 '19

What's a MechWarrior's Favorite Dance? 💃

1 Upvotes

The Twist


r/mechwarrior • • Jun 10 '21

Battletech Game BATTLETECH Advanced 3062 Ep 49 - Season 2 - Arano Restoration - Defense ... Spoiler

Thumbnail self.battletechgame
1 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Jul 31 '12

Closed Beta Update #6 Notes

Thumbnail mwomercs.com
0 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Jun 20 '22

MechWarrior 5 MechWarrior 5: Mercenaries - Ep 34 - Blast From The Past

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/mechwarrior • • Oct 11 '12

My thoughts as a long time Mechwarrior/Battletech fan.

0 Upvotes

So I got in the closed beta finally and I have been giving it a honest go for a little bit, while I love the overall feel of the mech's, the great visuals and the overall gameplay, I always walk away a bit depressed.

First off, I have no idea what is going on with the menu systems, I have no idea why it is not full screen and I still have not really figured out how all this currency is supposed to work, I mean, I don't even know how to buy new mechs!

I get the feeling that this is going to be a typical "ftp" money sink, they are gonna nickle and dime you for basic things like mechbay slots and other "luxury items" while telling you that you can play without spending a thing, sure, it is free, but you will pay dearly to have a somewhat complete experience.

The next issue is that I cannot choose the maps I like to play on, if I have to play on caustic valley one more fucking time, well, I will be angry some more but nothing will really happen I suppose, the game finder cares not about my desires. This again is a issue with making it a mmo, having a traditional Mechwarrior title would have allowed us to choose our experiences finely and allow us to have fun on our terms.

I don't really get why this had to be a MMO, I am not expecting a sweeping single player game but I would have liked it if I could just have the whole game and not a small part of it, I would gladly pay $60 for this if I could have even a quick mission option where I can test mech's and builds without having to grind for parts.

I am really trying to like this but it seems the days of a good ole' Mechwarrior game are gone and if this fails, we will never see another title in the franchise again, all because they wanted to gamble on yet another MMO.

The same thing is happening with Silent Hunter online but that is another story entirely.