The PGI Team has made it clear that the Map team, the Mech team and the Networking team are separate entities and employees, working towards those ends. And in those areas, I will say that content and progress has been made, and will not criticize this aspect.
Now, to the gameplay team.
The last major update the gameplay did was the addition of ECM and Consumables. Of the consumables, only one was ever made useful, with the rest outright abandon past that point.
Since then, we have gotten a long stretch without so much as anyone editing an XML file, only to have them "return" this close to launch to jam in Ghost Heat (a feature most people hate) and 3PV (a feature most people hate with a passion) and little else. Both of these features are insanely simple to code in, and require a bare minimum of effort.
One of their programmers did produce the movement system. However instead of helping lights and mediums out flank heavies on hills, they went with "weight =/= size lol" logic and made mediums perform the same as a Stalker. It was never repaired.
So -what have they been doing- for the past six months?
Last I heard UI 2.0 was in the "mockup" stage a couple months back. This was SUPPOSED TO BE IN WEEKS AFTER CLOSED BETA. Community Warfare is also in a nebulous mock up stage. Balance has been improving slowly in some areas, still floundering in others, but I really don't think months of waiting can warrant a claim of doing much work. I absolutely guarantee you that anyone reading this post, with about 15 minutes of looking at the XML file, could do the same. It is practically plain text.
So my theory? Every core designer on this game got to closed beta, got their paycheck, and went on an extended uncaring vacation and left the interns programming dumb systems. This would mesh perfectly with their claims thus far.
Now that they are back, they can't undo the ONLY "progress" they've made in the past several months without being hung for it - and thus why they aren't letting go of these stupid ideas with a death grip. They were likely the scribblings on a napkin left behind. Even the time they spent in the offices I suspect was very much "checked out."
I think it's inexcusable and as more and more facts come to light, this is precisely what it's looking to be. They got their paycheck and ran with it. Operation Phoenix is pretty much Operation Paid Vacation II.
It'd be interesting to compare the patch notes to the staff credits and see who isn't doing any freaking work whatsoever.