r/mdphd • • Mar 03 '24

It’s finally over

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/mdphd • • Mar 08 '24

we did it joe

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/mdphd • • Apr 25 '25

MD/PhD was the best thing I've ever done

776 Upvotes

I'm a MSTP grad and associate professor in medicine. My classmates and I are all now in our 40s and have various jobs in industry, academia, and private practice. We were just reminiscing on the good ole days and came to conclude that the MD/PhD program was the best thing we ever did. All the career benefits aside, we all got to delay adulthood for an incredibly fun 6-8 years of science and shenanigans. Yes, we were relatively poor in a big city but we made the best of it. It's really the best situation that any non-wealthy person would ever have. You are guaranteed to have at least a 6-figure income for the rest of your life and almost nothing you do (within reason) will affect your future for better or worse. Congrats to everyone entering this beautiful pathway. I know morale is low but trust the process.


r/mdphd • • Mar 20 '24

MD/PhD First-time Cycle Results...all it takes is one

Post image
752 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • Mar 16 '26

lor request denied, help

Post image
533 Upvotes

Hi So I asked a professor for a LOR, and she was probably the one i talked to the most, asked questions after class etc. But she sent back the following email (attached).

Should I leave it at that and say thankyou for replying i understand OR tell her I do need the letter to describe how I am academically? I dont know what to do.

Another prof I asked also denied saying they have a strict deadline of March1, which I understand.

But now I'm left with professors who I havent really interacted with I'm not sure if I should email them in a generic way like:

Dear Prof,

I took your class xYZ in fall 20xx, , i really liked it, especially topic Xyz , the knowledge i gained from the class - helpful.

Im preparing for mdphd application, wondering if you'd write a lor for me, speaking of my work in your class, academic performance...

Attached documents, Can meet in person or over zoom if needed.

OR should I somehow include that they prob dont remember me?

mention how I am aware you might not remember me among so many students so I attached the documents and am willing to meet to talk about me, my achievements, academic interests etc, so it could help

TLDR; PLEASE help me frame the email I can send to professors who barely know me!


r/mdphd • • Mar 10 '24

I hate being a student

437 Upvotes

I just need to vent somewhere. I talked about wanting to be a “lifelong learner” in all my MD/PhD essays, but as a G3 now, I really hate being a student. I hate moving away from my friends and family for school. I hate making friends with my medical school classmates only for them to move away for residency. I hate when my grad school friends graduate and get jobs on the other side of the country. I hate that I found new friends through local groups but I’m just going to leave them in 2 years when I match who knows where for residency. I just hate all the instability. I don’t have a partner, and my MSTP cohort never really bonded because of COVID. Part of me really wants to just find an industry job after graduating so that I can live in one place and put down some roots and build my community without constantly restarting. I know I have people that love and support me in other cities, but it’s just not the same as having people who are a regular part of your daily life. I’ve been running this rat race for so long though and part of me does want to be the academic physician-scientist and pursue my intellectual interests, but I feel like my personal life is suffering at this expense. This all just really hit me after I found out my room mate is moving away after graduation in May and I hate saying goodbye to people. Thanks for coming to my pity party Ted talk.


r/mdphd • • Mar 21 '26 Regret

My Sankey + Giving Back to the Community :)

Post image
381 Upvotes

WAR IS OVER!!! I went into this cycle prepping for both MD-PhD and PhD applications because I was truly convinced I wouldn’t get into a single MSTP. Looking back, that sounds a bit ridiculous, and I am so thankful for my friends, mentors, and family for convincing me I have what it takes to become a physician scientist :,)

If it wasn’t for someone I reached out to on this sub after seeing their Sankey and relating to their research interests, I am 100% certain I would not have had the cycle that I did. The #1 thing I learned from them is how crucial writing is in your application. Your voice is what humanizes you. Tie your experiences into a cohesive theme, it makes it easier for people to remember you when they present your file to the admissions committee if you have a strong narrative (I was told several times during my interviews that my writing is what made my application stand out)! Because of my experience on this sub, I want to give back to this community as much as I can. Here is my Notion MD-PhD Application Tracker that got me through the past year, it includes:

  • Quick Links to AAMC login, a full list of MD-PhD programs, and an MD-PhD Admissions Guide

  • Information on application timeline

  • MD-PhD career info including youtube videos, podcasts, and articles that helped me decide whether or not this career path was right for me

  • A list of the AAMC core competencies with space to brainstorm examples of how you fit them

  • A school list tracker including space to jot notes about faculty that interest you at each school, portal logins, and whatever other info you want to remember

  • Resources from Reddit, Podcasts, and MSTP directors on the primary application

  • Secondary application progress tracker and resources from current trainees

  • LOR contact info table, info packet template, and request template

  • Interview prep resources from Reddit, Podcasts, and APSA webinars

  • Let me know if you'd like it to include anything else!!

Happy to answer any questions, and would love to hear thoughts on which program to pick as I am split between Stanford, Penn, UW Seattle, Sinai, UCSD, and UMich at the moment (+ holding onto UCLA waitlist). Research interests are molecular cardiology + functional genomics (disease modeling, regenerative medicine, inherited cardiovascular conditions) :)


r/mdphd • • Feb 08 '25

Are we screwed?

Post image
312 Upvotes

What does this mean? Is this going to impact T32s? If so, how will this impact current MSTP students and admissions for this and next few cycles?


r/mdphd • • Sep 17 '22

Why You Should Consider the MD/PhD Career Path

280 Upvotes

Disclaimer: all views are my own and are separate from my affiliation with the University of Wisconsin-Madison MSTP and School of Medicine and Public Health.

Part 2: Why you should consider the MD/PhD career path.

As a first-generation student, I didn’t know about the existence of MD/PhD programs until late in college. My premed advising office lacked experience to prepare me adequately to be a competitive applicant. I relied on independent research and summer research programs to acquire the resources and skills needed to apply competitively. The more I learned about the career path, the more certain I became that it was the best path forward for me. I am biased, and I will make a compelling case that the MD/PhD path is a high value, underappreciated alternative to medical school and graduate school alone.

  • A caveat: While I believe the 5 reasons below are compelling reasons to pursue MD/PhD training, these are not what I advise you state in the MD/PhD application or interview. There is indeed an element of gaming to the admissions process, and it would serve you well to learn the rules. I will do my best to teach you how to play the game based on my successes and failures in the process. I will cover the “correct” answers to the Why MD/PhD question in another post, which focuses on becoming an academic physician-scientist whose clinical work informs laboratory work, and vice versa, and provides a synergy that cannot be realized through either training path alone. Since this is a rather cookie-cutter response, you must convey these elements through the lens of your unique story and life experiences, which I can help you develop and deliver with authenticity.

Value

It's no longer noteworthy that college is expensive, and that higher education is over-saturated. Fortunately, a medical degree continues to have great earning potential. However, if you, like myself – even with Pell grants and working jobs – had to accumulate debt during college, the prospect of acquiring an additional ~$200,000 in student loans for medical school tuition, not including living expenses, is a heavy burden. You might ignore this burden with the prospect of earning enough money to pay it off as a physician, but it will be paid slowly, over the course of 5-20 years, with interest accruing, pushing you to work more to pay off your debts sooner. Assume that $250K in student loans were taken between college and medical school at an interest rate of 6%, resulting in $15,000 of added interest per year, incentivizing you to work more for the next decade to pay it off quickly. I’m sure there are financial tricks to reduce this burden, but I’m making a general case. Now that you have acquired a pile of student debt from medical training, an element of sunk cost fallacy might also emerge: “I’ve spent so many years training and have all this debt I must pay, I must continue being a physician to pay off the debt”. Even if being a physician is causing you to burn out?

  • It’s important to remember that what we think we want to do for the rest of our lives at age 22 is likely to differ greatly from what we want to be doing at age 50…investing in career mobility and independence of your future self is, I think, is the best financial decision one can make.

While the MD/PhD path is not one to pursue for financial reasons alone, the ROI on the dual degree path is enticing: medical school and graduate school tuition are free (to you), you receive a pre-tax stipend of $30-45k (depending on location), you graduate with knowledge that can be applied across science and medicine, and you have long-term career mobility across academia, industry, government, and clinical practice. Many people might balk at this idea that the ROI of MD/PhD exceeds MD alone, claiming: “In 4 years of working as a physician, the salary and benefits that I would earn far exceeds the value of a PhD.” Maybe, if money was your sole career motivation, but what I’m talking about is value. Most people want a fulfilling career that they can drop and switch to something new if they’re no longer fulfilled. It’s possible to do this with an MD degree, but I would argue it’s more challenging and less common compared to the person with an MD/PhD.

Quick math on ROI:

  • cost of medical school 4 years at $50K/year = $200k

  • cost of graduate school 4 years at $30k/year = $120k

  • stipend for 8 years at $32k/year = 256k

  • Conferences and travel 4 years = 10k.

  • $200k + $120k + $256k + $10k = $586k, which, over 8 years, comes out to ~73k/year while earning both an MD and a PhD (using UW-Madison’s MSTP, as a stipend example), without accruing interest from medical school debt when you begin your career.

  • At 73k/year, this is approximately the salary of both a postdoctoral scientist with ~4 years of experience, and a PhD graduate who goes directly to industry.

As an MD/PhD, not only do you know how to provide medical care to people (practical skills), but you also have savvy with modern science, technical communication, big data, signal vs noise, and a clear sense of what each the MDs and PhDs, alone, lack. You will be sought after for employment, competitive for residency programs, and able to move laterally and vertically with less resistance through career discovery. The ROI on MD/PhDs, for me, is strikingly favorable.

Opportunity

“But the MD/PhD path is more competitive… I don’t have the grades. My MCAT isn’t high enough. It’s too long.” These excuses are signs of an opportunity. Here are 5 considerations to keep in mind:

  1. The MD/PhD application is designed to provide a more holistic view of applicants and thus the numbers bear less weight. I would argue, subjectively, that the MD path is more competitive than the MD/PhD path—though, objectively, the overall matriculation rates are similar (35.9% for MD/PhD, 36.2% for MD in 2021-2022 cycle). Medical schools in the 2021-2022 cycle received nearly 1.1 million applications from 62,443 students, whereas MD/PhD programs received almost 33,300 applications from 2091 students – it’s no wonder that the MCAT score and GPA serve as an essential weed-out mechanism to sift through the massive application pool for medical school admissions. I argue that students should not be deterred from MD/PhD because they perceive it to be more competitive than MD. If you put in the time to obtain quality research experiences and work hard to evaluate Why MD/PhD, the MCAT score and GPA diminishes in relative importance. At some schools certainly, and at many other programs, too, I presume, the MD/PhD committees have a strong influence on whether a student is accepted, so long as minimum requirements are met for medical school admissions. There is more to being an effective physician-scientist than scores, and the greater depth of the MD/PhD application offers ample opportunity to assess non-numerical qualities, such as science communication skills and character traits.

  2. The prerequisites for being a competitive applicant to MD/PhD programs are not extraordinary. I had 2 years of research during college and one 3rd author publication. However, I had a great relationship with my research mentors, I focused on deeply understanding the scientific method, and I pursued quality experiences over quantity. Critically, my story and vision were engaging to the admissions committee, and I learned to communicate my why effectively with broad audiences. I graduated with honors, my grades were good (3.72), and my MCAT score was around the average (510). I still interviewed at several excellent programs and matriculated into a top-notch MSTP. The point is, there’s more to this game than numbers, don’t count yourself out prematurely.

  3. As a MD/PhD graduate, you will be a competitive applicant for residency. As is evidenced by the Pass/Fail nature of medical school grades, and now also the USMLE STEP1, there is an evident shift from selecting for high exam scores to the more well-rounded characteristics that cannot be identified through multiple-choice exams. MD/PhD training is a foot in the door to interview at most residency programs, providing the applicant with greater decision-making power for where they might end up for the next phase of their training. I acknowledge the low probability of being able to select where exactly you want to go, but anecdotal evidence from the past several graduating MD/PhD cohorts at UW-Madison shows that a majority match into programs among their top choices. The research experience and maturity that is developed from 3-4 years of learning from failed experimentation and gaining deep knowledge of a subject are attractive qualities for residency programs as well as for institutions that conduct cutting-edge research. Even for those more clinically oriented residency programs, the ubiquity of clinical research initiatives at such programs still make the research skills gained during a PhD a valuable asset.

  4. You can apply broadly across the U.S. with a greater likelihood of acceptance to an out-of-state program. If I had done the MD only path, I would have been incentivized financially to remain in-state. If you live in California, for example, you might want to stay in-state, but considering how competitive the California medical school system is and the high volume of applicants that also want a sunny and 75 experience, you better have the grades, MCAT score, research and clinical experience, and stand out. If instead you apply out-of-state, the cost of tuition tends to increase for most state schools and there is a reduced likelihood of acceptance relative to your in-state peers. From my experience, it seems that MSTPs select for out-of-state students (UW-Madison MSTP 2021-2022: 100% out-of-state, and on average, across all MD/PhD programs, 75% of matriculants are out-of-state students). In contrast, MD programs at public universities select for in-state students, which is largely due to the funding support provided to keep doctors at home (AAMC).

  5. As science and medicine becomes more tech-enabled, the demand for PhDs in industry will likely diminish, and given the exodus of young PhDs away from academia (this deserves its own post), there is a growing supply and demand problem. The inherent value of a PhD in science and engineering, however, remains the same and is critically important for the development of our future society. The MD/PhD path provides a practical value (direct service to people) that the PhD alone lacks. I acknowledge that teaching students does provide direct value to people, yet the internet is increasingly reducing the value of this service relative to what physicians provide. However, perhaps a similar argument can be made that the value of the MD will also diminish over time, given AI-assisted diagnostics and the excess of MD graduates relative to available residency positions (Figure 1), but overall, the roles of a clinician are too nuanced, and the demand for eldercare is growing too fast to be supplanted anytime soon. If you want a PhD because you desire a deep dive into a topic of interest, and you also recognize the diminishing lifestyle flexibility of a post-PhD career, the MD further credentials you to apply scientific acumen to serve people directly. Plus, if you do choose a career like pathology, then you could work from home on your iPad reviewing high-resolution images with diagnostic hints from AI and devoting yourself to whatever you really want to be doing with a nice salary and autonomy. I’m only partially joking.

Time

Time is another key feature of why the MD/PhD career path is worthy of consideration. As of writing, I am in my 5th year of MD/PhD training, currently in my laboratory planning to do an experiment after writing this section. One of my friends, who I started medical school with in 2018 and who graduated in summer 2022, is meanwhile quite busy in their first year of residency training. Given all the boxes that one needs to check during medical school, 4 years is not much time to decide confidently on which residency to pursue. This decision will largely influence your work-life balance and working environment for life, so it should not be made lightly. If you know what area of medicine you want to pursue after exploring specialties through clinical rotations for a couple of years, then great! If you are uncertain, for example, whether you like radiology or internal medicine more, you might feel pressured to decide before you are ready or have the experience needed to make a fully informed decision, which might not come until you’ve finished your first year of residency with an uncomfortable feeling of dissatisfaction. No worries, though, you can take a year off, do a research year or two, and reapply for a different program. Had there been more time to explore and gain experience, then this crucial decision might have been made correctly the first time. If instead, you had pursued the MD/PhD path from the start, you would have had this extra time and experience, with the addition of a PhD’s worth of knowledge and publications, to make a more informed decision.

Having the time to think more deeply about what it is that you want to pursue is a blessing and one of the reasons I am most content with my decision to take a longer training path. Some people might retort: “Yeah, MD/PhDs love to procrastinate making life decisions…”, to which I say, yep, what’s the hurry? I’m getting paid to experiment in a lab to my heart’s content and then go home without needing to study for exams and prepare for clinic. I can rotate through different specialties, work closely with choice physicians, build relationships, and gain a more comprehensive, accurate view of what a life working in a particular specialty might entail. You also have time for hobbies, learning new skills, and maturing as a person. For example, I want to develop more computational skills, so I spend time tinkering with small projects, watching Youtube, using Coursera, building a website and MD/PhD advising business (coming soon!), and applying data science tools to my research projects. I also like to garden and cook, and now I cook the produce of my garden after long days in lab. In contrast, the MD path can be a whirlwind. You will have some time to do hobbies in medical school, but you have limited time to get the scores, do clinical research, obtain letters, develop experience, and distinguish yourself. This is difficult when, for the first 2 years of medical school, you’re constantly studying or memorizing information that, frequently, turns out to be clinically irrelevant minutiae. Then, during the first clinical year, you’re running around the hospital rotating in different specialties trying to orient yourself, and by the time you do, it’s time for a new specialty. That leaves your final year to pinpoint a field of interest and make an important decision about your life course. I’m anxious even writing about it.

In addition, there’s another angle to the value of time in MD/PhD training. When I talk with some ambitious applicants, I hear statements like: “I want to make world-changing discoveries that lands my name in textbooks,” and “I want to write the book on modern cancer treatment”. The MD/PhD path is also for those who are centrally focused on becoming the best of the best in science and medicine. You want to cure cancer, cure Alzheimer’s, cure aging! Ambitious and naïve, yes, but it’s the type of energy and passion needed to spend the long hours in lab and clinic, honing your craft, and becoming the world’s expert in your niche. If I were to pursue my current path to its fullest academic extent, I would become 1 of maybe 10 people in the world who is a retinal surgeon, structural biologist, and cellular neurophysiologist.

Mindset

Next, I want to compare the distinct mindsets of medicine and research. I have been a medical student, and I am currently a graduate student. I have experienced both fields and have been fully immersed in their cultures. How can two fields be so complementary and yet so at odds intellectually? The PhDs think the MDs are expensive fools, and the MDs think the PhDs are esoteric fools. I guess that makes me an expensive, esoteric fool. Jokes aside, the box-checking operating system of medical training can make the pre-clinical years feel robotic. As students move from lecture halls into the hospital, the hierarchy of medicine is an added hindrance for students to break out of this mode and think for themselves. Speak up at the wrong place and wrong time, you might get a hasty comment on your evaluations (subjective grades are used to determine competitiveness for residency)—at least, this is the fear of many students, and whether this is perceived or real makes little difference when it modifies the behavior of the student. On the positive side, MDs learn to manage the tremendous responsibility of caring for the health and wellbeing of vulnerable people; the decisions must be made decisively considering multiple perspectives, with analyses of risk, and focused on harm reduction in a team-based model of care. It is not trivial, and each patient presents a wholly new set of conditions to consider. You are unlikely to learn this degree of empathy, decisiveness, and teamwork as a graduate student in a research lab.

While PhDs are also subjected to the rules of hierarchy, the research training nonetheless incentivizes independent, critical thinking. The nature of research affords graduate students more freedom to trial and error. The mindset of an experimentalist encourages creativity and allows one to follow lines of inquiry to the end of curiosity. Aside from meeting with a thesis committee, there’s few boxes to check. You learn by doing and doing often results in failed experiments. The troubleshooting that follows is far more instructive than many courses you will take. This open-ended process is also part of the reason why PhDs can take 6 years and postdocs 8 years to complete their projects at the upper bound.

In terms of coursework in medical school, it is notoriously known for being like “drinking water from a fire hose”. It’s a deluge of mnemonics, books, flashcards, videos, and writing information that spans microscopic to macroscopic topics. In contrast, depending on the graduate program, the significant overlap between medical school and graduate school coursework can lead to waiving of course requirements during graduate school, freeing up more time to focus on creative experimentation and taking the courses you want to take. For example, in my Cellular & Molecular Biology PhD program, I only have a single course requirement. Therefore, I can take courses like Machine Learning and Statistics or Computational Neuroscience.

Lifestyle

Given the above 4 reasons why you should consider the MD/PhD career, lifestyle goals are clearly a big part of this decision. Generally, I believe that people are poor judges of what their future selves might specifically desire; however, it is probably safe to assume that people desire freedom to decide for themselves how they will spend their time: with family, with friends, on hobbies, traveling, starting businesses, etc. Personally, I like variety and context-switching. Therefore, I select for paths that will equip me with the skills and flexibility to pivot and follow my curiosity and passions. I want to be immune to the notion of a sunk cost fallacy. I believe the MD/PhD path integrates the best components of each solo degree while leaving the negative attributes as an option, instead of as a tradeoff.

I get bored if I do one thing for too long – and coming from a person who is pursuing the academic path with the most schooling, this is a measured statement. A little bit of this, a little bit of that, and the capacity to adapt across disciplines is highly attractive to me. Traditionally, for MD/PhDs, this would mean you have a clinical practice and run a laboratory. Ambitiously, you might also engage with industry. BUT, you might interject, you won’t be as good of a doctor or scientist if you split your time between them. I think these interjectors underestimate the bandwidth of the human potential. If Jiro dreamed of more than sushi, who knows what he could have accomplished. Seriously, although there is merit to becoming more skilled if you focus on one task rather than on two tasks, especially if that task is working as a surgeon, I believe that engaging in duality, particularly the dialectical variety, opens a door to a perspective that neither task alone could have provided. This cross-disciplinary perspective is far more valuable and generally practical, in my mind, than the progressive iterations on perfection that occur at the margins of singular talent.

How do you want to be spending your time in your 50s? Will it be driven by the same career goals and ambitions that you have in your late 20s? Considering how my personal goals have shifted from college to now, I suspect that I have no accurate idea. I’m preparing for this uncertainty throughout MD/PhD training and shooting for the stars along the way.

If you like (or dislike) this long-form info, let me know. If you want to read Part 1: What is the MD/PhD Career Path and Part 3: How to get into MD/PhD, you can do so at: https://jakekhoussine.medium.com/

Reach out if you have questions, either in the comments or at [email protected]

-khous


r/mdphd • • Jan 02 '25

nyu md phd program

279 Upvotes

Got an email from NYU’s MD PhD program saying that they paused admissions and all acceptances are now MD only acceptances. Anybody know anything?

Edit: Also wtf happens to their NIH funding now?


r/mdphd • • Aug 05 '22

M1 is going swimmingly so far

Post image
263 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • Aug 17 '24

Saw this exchange on twitter and freaking out a bit

Post image
249 Upvotes

Do we think that this is true ?


r/mdphd • • Mar 12 '26

Its back to clinic for this frog!

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • Mar 29 '26

late sankey 2024-25 (all it takes is one!)

Post image
241 Upvotes

now that it’s waitlist season again i just wanted to share another classic “all it takes is one” sankey. i remember in march/april scouring this subreddit for these kinds of stories and it brought me a little bit of hope, so i wanted to do my part by putting mine out there.

———————————————

stats:

21F, URM (hispanic/latino)

BS neuro BA art history MS global medicine (in 4yrs), honors theses in neuro and art history

520 mcat/3.9x gpa

T20 undergrad

0 gap years

3000 hrs research, no pubs (!), 3 posters

arguably none clinical experience

60 hrs shadowing

700 hrs volunteering (clinical adjacent but i entered it as non-clinical in case of controversy)

500 hrs leadership

some random research awards from my uni/conferences

———————————————

deferred for fulbright (got it after boston u acceptance, told my other 3 WL this in update letters but it didn’t change anything). currently having an AMAZING time abroad before i start in august!

got my acceptance call on may 2nd :)

my advice to future applicants is that you should NOT make the mistake of overlooking the importance of your school list. in retrospect mine is honestly probably one of the worst school lists i’ve ever seen, especially since my stats were nothing extraordinary. of course it’s holistic and i think i had a pretty good story/overarching narrative (my stuff was pretty cohesive). but still, i probably could’ve saved myself a lot of stress and despair if i applied to a more balanced assortment of schools.


r/mdphd • • Mar 09 '26

2025/26 Sankey + Experiences

Post image
241 Upvotes

I have utilized this forum as a resource throughout my application cycle for 2025/26 and wanted to offer my results in case it is helpful to others.

I am very fortunate and grateful for the results of this admissions cycle. I‘m sharing my experiences as I hope they may be helpful, particularly for those from highly disadvantaged backgrounds planning to pursue a career as a physician-scientist.

Personal Background:

I believe that I had good results in-part due to my personal story that I could contextualize my achievements within. Without providing identifying information, I am from a socioeconomically-disadvantaged background. I grew up in poverty in rural America and my parents were often on drugs or incarcerated.

I then went to a T5 for undergrad and got two bachelors degrees: one in biology/engineering and the other in the social sciences. I had 5 publications in bio (1 second author, 3 accepted into high-impact journals, 2 submitted with preprint) and one thesis in my social sciences degree. I volunteered in the clinic and out throughout undergrad. I continued my clinical and non-clinical volunteering during my gap years and worked as a RA in biotech.

Writing and Submissions:

As some of my earliest experiences caregiving came about due to early trauma, I chose to include it in my personal statement and MD/PhD essays. It was imperative to me to strike a tone that balanced honesty and authenticity without making a woe-is-me tone or trauma porn narrative. In order to do this, as others have encouraged, I had friends in the field read over my essays and provide feedback. Additionally, I‘d say always lean into authenticity and leverage your story - privileged or disadvantaged - we all have a story to tell. The trick is making it cohesive between the big three - does your mission come to life and is there logical coherence in your narrative? I truly believe by finding your voice, your uniqueness will shine through and help make you a memorable candidate.

I went through many rounds of editing over a period of several months. With that said, I submitted my primaries in late June, prioritizing quality over speed. I do not regret that decision. However, I do suggest that you start pre-writing your big three essays by looking at the previous years as the format/questions do not change, especially if you are employed. I did not do this and was very stressed as a result.

Additionally, I was extremely selective with where I decided to apply. I looked at each MD/PhD program and asked myself if I‘d really want to be here for the next 8+ years? Is their research well-aligned with my interests and strengths? Do they have the kind of community and support I need to succeed? So I only sent primaries to 10 schools. If you have the time and money to submit many more apps as I have seen done, power to you; I am truly in awe at the sheer volume of apps people have been able to submit.

For secondaries, I became more selective. I withdrew from programs I was only toying with in my mind but couldn‘t see myself truly being happy in. This was in-part due to geography, where my life-partner is located, and research alignment. I highly recommend doing this. Not only will it save you considerable time, but it will also save you from unnecessary feelings of rejection. Admissions committees will sense a lack of eagerness and will toss out applicants who aren‘t a strong fit. If you are, let‘s say, interested in X, but a program has institutional priorities outlined in its strategic plan and a community mainly focused on Y, then the fit will be hard to justify. That‘s not to say you can‘t change your interests, but there really needs to be a throughline that makes reasonable sense based on your past work and future aspirations. Additionally, it should read deeply individualized to that school - have you informed yourself of their institutional priorities, mission statement, kind of community they are trying to put together, and their values? If not, it will be hard for the committee to take your desire to join their program as seriously as someone who made the effort to know the school. It‘s even better when you can demonstrate alignment through past experiences - show, don‘t tell!

Lastly, I‘ll say do not make the same mistake I did. I waited last minute for many of my applications, in-part due to work, but also because of fear of failing. Some schools didn‘t seem to care that I wasn‘t an early bird, and others were very strict. I‘d encourage everyone to submit several weeks before the deadline for secondaries at the latest and be particularly attentive to the deadlines sent in emails as they may be different from the ones posted on the program‘s website.

Interviews:

I was very nervous, personally. I have never thought of myself as a powerful speaker and I often get overwhelmed in these contexts. I truly believe, as others have remarked, that practice is key! If you are like me and don‘t think in a linear fashion, you‘ll want to figure out how to answer the common questions with a friend or colleague in a mock interview, such that you have a succinct and clear response. The goal isn‘t to highlight every accomplishment you have or throw in every buzzword you can think of. I truly got the sense throughout my interviews that faculty were really just keen to get to know me personally. There is bias here because I only interviewed at a few programs, so take it with a grain of salt, but some of my interviewers didn‘t even ask me anything about science or the clinic. When they did, I got the sense they just wanted to hear you say what you did in your apps but live.

Of course, you want to remain calm, polite, and respectful, but do not forget about authenticity! I know we all show up in these spaces with our carefully constructed personas to meet our own and others expectations, but in my experience whenever I allowed myself to crack a joke, push back against an interviewers conclusions I didn‘t agree with, or be candid about my nervousness, it really shifted the atmosphere in a positive way. I will say, however, there were moments after interviews that I felt I must‘ve done awful because some people were monotone and expressionless. That‘s just how some people interview. I read too much into it initially and caused myself unnecessary stress. What was key, I think, is I didn‘t react to it in the moment during the interview.

Final Thoughts:

I said a whole lot, mainly reiterating the excellent advice our peers have already mentioned in previous posts. Of course, I can only speak to my experiences and I encourage you all planning on applying to cast a wide net in your resources.

With that said, I am happy to answer any questions and would be especially be happy to give advice to any socioeconomically disadvantaged applicants.

Wishing everyone the best of luck who is still waiting for positive outcomes this cycle and others who are gearing up for 2026/27!


r/mdphd • • Mar 07 '25

Trump cancels $400 million to Columbia (including possibly the MSTP?)

235 Upvotes

Per the NYT, Trump just cancelled $400 million in federal funding for Columbia... This is breaking and it's unclear if it includes the MSTP, but it very well could...


r/mdphd • • Feb 13 '26

Sankey All Done!

Post image
229 Upvotes

Assuming if I haven't heard back, it's a no. Excited for the next steps!


r/mdphd • • Apr 21 '21

I made a spreadsheet listing whether certain schools will consider you for MD only during your MD/PhD application and at what point. I also added applicant MD/PhD stats for that school, which I stole from another post a while back, and links to the school's MD/PhD website.

229 Upvotes

I made this last cycle. As you will notice, it is not comprehensive and may not be entirely accurate - it's just what I could find at the time. I hope it can save you some time.

If you recognize any errors and you would like for me to change them, drop them in the comments and I will update it. Alternatively, if you want me to add some schools and you provide the information, I can do that too.

Much love,

Basil

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1jakSaJTcW3QCULa6pcd6drQgnUGG82GN5PIo4K5T7-Y/edit?usp=sharing

Edit: Here is the list that breaks down the programs by MSTP or MD/PhD and also includes rank/stats/website. This is the list that I originally stole from - I wish I could find who posted it so that I could credit them.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1qKOxaVpYVkgRCK2AwRVsWe3k1jgCRUv0cOlSiDhaurQ/edit?usp=sharing


r/mdphd • • Mar 12 '25

$800 million cut from Hopkins

228 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • Feb 06 '25

NIH Postbac Officially Paused

Post image
225 Upvotes

:(


r/mdphd • • Mar 25 '26

Just another data point

Post image
224 Upvotes

This one's really for the future straight-from-college applicants: I was scared to apply this cycle. Programs will account for the limited amount of time that you've had to accrue experiences. Work hard. It is absolutely possible to be successful without being some magical wonderkind.


r/mdphd • • May 18 '20

A Comprehensive Guide to MD-PhD Admissions by Current Students

217 Upvotes

Hello All!

We are two MD-PhD students at the University of Virginia School of Medicine MSTP. We wrote a comprehensive FAQ to address common questions and hints/tips that we wished we knew when we applied! It is really long so we ended up putting it on Medium. We hope this guide will help future and current applicants.

This guide covers: general questions about the MD-PhD admissions process, making up for low GPA/MCAT, application competitiveness, how to perfect your essays and AMCAS application, gap year, interviewing tips and more!

Click Here: A Comprehensive Guide to MD-PhD Admissions by Current Students

If you have additional questions you would like answered or have suggestions, please feel free to send us a message or email us at [email protected]. Special thanks to u/chiturtle. We will do our best to keep this post updated from now on. Good luck everyone!


r/mdphd • • Apr 09 '25

$1 billion cut from Cornell and $800 million from Northwestern

210 Upvotes

Yikes per the NYT. Does anyone know if the MSTP grants in particular have been affected?...


r/mdphd • • 25d ago

2025–2026 MD-PhD Application Cycle Results

Post image
200 Upvotes

I know it's a little late, but I found these posts really helpful when I was applying, so I figured I'd share my results and some quick takeaways from my cycle! (No Gap Years)

A few takeaways:

I benefited a lot from having a PI I was close with who was also very flexible and okay with me taking time off work on applications. I also took the minimum number of courses needed during my senior year, so I had very little schoolwork. Since I was applying straight through (no gap years), I also didn't have to worry about my senior year grades during the application cycle.

I felt like the schools where I had the strongest research fit were ultimately the ones where I had the most success (e.g., where there were PIs who could really appreciate and understand my research).

I think choosing PIs for interviews is a great opportunity to really advertise yourself and your research. People outside your field might not fully understand your research or be able to advocate for you as effectively, so finding faculty who can understand your work and have a good conversation with you is important.

I spent a lot of time choosing PIs for my interviews. I basically went through every faculty member in the relevant departments, looked into their research, and crossed people off one by one until I had a list of people I thought would be a good fit.

Lastly, my limited clinical and nonclinical volunteering experience ended up being enough to get me through the cycle, but it also made writing secondaries much more difficult.

I often had to draw on experiences from high school, which ended up being okay, but having more experiences to write about would have made secondaries a lot easier. This was something I hadn't really considered before applying.

Best of luck to everyone applying! Please feel free to ask any questions in the comments!