r/mcpublic • • Feb 18 '12

Petition to keep PVE r6 up until MC 1.2 is released.

0 Upvotes

There's a chat going on right now in the PVE server where a number of us are outraged at the timing of this map reset. With 1.2 looming and this revision in an amazing state with much left to be explored, why can't we leave it until 1.2 is released?

I think Appleanche sums it up perfectly in his comment on the reset thread

This is the longest PvE because of the lack of updates breaking it. That is something worth noting. This isn't an rev that's being lost due to updates, it's being reset because some people are bored.

A week wait wouldn't be lame duck, it would allow people to say "Ok, look we've got a week to finish this project" it would have allowed FISA to plan a quick playoffs and play them out. It would allow planning and discussion of next map.

Also, as if 24 hours isn't enough time to grief your own stuff, that's such a non factor it's not even worth talking about. PVE is about community, it's about builds, towns, cities, etc. It's not like surival where you have to reset to allow newbies a fair chance vs the diamond armored/sword'd people. It's not creative where the map is literally full of bullshit.

It really is just icing on the dog shit cake that they'd rather not just wait for 1.2 and force what's sure to be a weird and ugly mix when 1.2 comes out.


r/mcpublic • • Aug 21 '11

The Reddit Chaos Server is the Biggest Waste of time I have experienced yet!

0 Upvotes

I hid chests where I had to draw a map to find them. No fracking way a player without cheats could just happen to stumble upon all 4 of my hidden fracking chests. I hate cheating scumbags!


r/mcpublic • • Dec 16 '14

Notice Please welcome our newest Survival admin!

Thumbnail
nerd.nu
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Apr 18 '13

PvE Looking at my build in the carto

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Feb 14 '12

How I see the Reddit Servers

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Feb 04 '15

Survival Is it worth keeping S?

3 Upvotes

Here's to hoping there's a rational discussion about it instead of this getting shut down.

As far as I can see it, S consumes practically all of the drama around nerd.nu, and most of it is caused by the same dozen or so players. S-admins are replaced every few months, and the server seems practically ungovernable, despite even trying Civcraft, something the players really wanted. Why not just drop S and redirect resources to C, P, or other games? Maybe a corner of the PvE map where PvP still works, or they can move to/create a different server curated by their own. As for dropping the server, there is precedent for this - the Chaos server was dropped a long time ago when activity fell, why not for S?


r/mcpublic • • Apr 15 '13

PvE Tom Plays... MCPublic PvE Server - Part 3 - Hats

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Mar 31 '13

Survival Making My Leave from MC Public Official

7 Upvotes

I have been on these servers for 2 years now, and they have been fairly enjoyable. However the time has come to say goodbye. I have seen many admins come and go, and they always do go. Many of the old players have left as well. Now it is my turn to leave. The old MC Public is gone. It is no longer enjoyable. Because of this, and because of my ban, I won't be returning. I know many of you will be glad to see this post, but to the people who aren't, I bid you farewell.

Edit: No more hello kitty statues :( Edit 2: I also realize this will be down voted into oblivion. But for those who see it, just tell rcub and them I said bye.


r/mcpublic • • Apr 05 '13

PvE Welp, I guess this will be happening tommorrow.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Feb 02 '12

Happy Birthday Nat!!!!!!!!

0 Upvotes

Oh glorious leader, please accept our birthday wishes! Hope its a good one!


r/mcpublic • • Nov 12 '13

PvE It'll make sense eventually...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Feb 12 '12

Survival Cake Shop Now Closed Till Further Notice

0 Upvotes

http://nerd.nu/forum/index.php?p=/discussion/11102/cake-shop-closed

This is my resignation as a moderator and from the community. It is quite long and such but I assure you there was no shorter way to put it. It's been fun, be safe. Much love.

-LadyRavenOwl


r/mcpublic • • Feb 24 '13

Creative MCPublic Harlem Shake

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Oct 30 '12

PvE Melonville is coming back! REV 10 Planning

2 Upvotes

I am going to be bringing back Melonville this rev so if you wanna help out with the town, build a house and something or want to be in a spleef team then come to Melonville! WE hope to be near spawn or flatland. The new rev will most likely go up evening american time which means about midnight for european people.

For the spleef team, me and someone else will hold a tournament soon after the spleef arena has been built. (I need a good builder, a good designer and a good redstoner to wire up buttons and levers.) In the tournament each person will play 5 games. If you win a game you will get 3pts, if you lose you get 0pts. The top four players will get a place in then team. The tournament will be held before we have to sign-up for the spleef season. More players will be added if they are active and got at least 6 pts in the tournament. I will then pick two active players to be managers of the spleef team.

Every 3 weeks I will hold a treasure hunt. There will be clues around the town and there will be a prize chest at the end. Donations for the prize chest will be welcome.

Some people can build a tall house in their plot that would look like a skyscraper. That will be 1 district. Another district will consist of smaller two storey cuboid shaped houses with a long balcony on the 2nd storey at the front. All the small houses must be made of wood. The third district will be everything that isn't houses. It will include: Business companies, shops, spleef stadium, town hall, farms, bank, post office etc.

If you want to make a shop or company then let a mayor know and they will make a plot for your whatever. If you want a wage then tell at least one mayor and at least one bank worker. Me and 2 other mayors will each have our own office in the town hall. We can decorate out offices to what suits us. The town rules will be on the bottom floor and news and info that you need to know. The mayors' offices will be on the 2nd and 3rd floors. The bank will have wages for every 7 days you work. There will be no taxes on your wages like irl.

I would like the spleef stadium and some other buildings to have melon blocks in each plot. This will be a symbol to show we are Melonvile. If someone (like thelethalkind or Ooer) wants to build Molon Jnkshun then please speak to me or another mayor about getting space to make it.

There will be a donation chest outside every empty plot. You will not be able to break it as it will have a protection open to everyone. Please don't steal contents of the chests and be a dick. Feel free to leave some stuff for new people in a chest outside their plot.

At least 10 people must be living in the town to start the spleef tournament.

Some rules: Spawn rules apply No derp buildings (except in molon jnkshun if there is one) Keep the melon blocks neat on your plot. Don't go mad when placing them.

Come and join us in rev10!! You won't regret it. We will need to all pitch in and either get somewhere near spawn or get a portal or get some flatland.

teds

EDIT: READ THE JOBS PARAGRAPH AGAIN. I CHANGED SOME THINGS AROUND. AND THOSE WHO ARE DOWNVOTING THEY ARE ASSHOLES AS PAUL13NOV SAID.


r/mcpublic • • Jul 28 '13

An alternative to the drama-fest recently started by Barneygale.

2 Upvotes

TL;DR for the other posts: A former admin, who was banned from just about everything related to these servers, circumvented his ban to post here and pretended to be a starry-eyed mod-wannabe in order to stir the shit and be a troll. Let's start this discussion from scratch.

I encourage everyone to be as specific as possible with their reasoning. Vague, flimsy arguments just make you seem like you don't know what you're talking about. If you want people to listen to you, then develop your argument and present it in a way that's easy to follow and understand.


Openness

People seem to be up in arms over how open the server is and how open they think it should be. The whole "who watches the watchers" sort of thinking is what is at heart of the issue. There is obviously some distrust of mods and admins, who are in a position of power, and that will never change, even if every single action and word that ever could be logged was logged and open for anyone to view. That said, it does not mean that the sentiment should be disregarded in its entirety.

There are many things that could be made available for public view. Let's split this discussion up into the various topics of what that could apply to.

A. Ban Process

From my observation of these discussions, players are not really concerned with how public the appeals process is. After all, it's already publicly available on the forums. What people are more worried about is bans in general. They want to see some sort of log of who is banned, when, and for what, available regardless of whether or not someone appealed. They also want to see as much detail as possible.

That said, people can check out the MCBouncer log, though the last time I checked, it lists all bans from the server as bans from C. Perhaps there is a way to tidy this up? It also may just be that people had no clue this existed already.

There was a closely related issue that people wanted more details regarding a ban. Some bans are extremely straightforward (short bans for crop griefing on P, for example) and need no additional details. There's been consistent complaints about the grey area bans, especially concerning repeat offenders who are then banned for either a long period of time or permabanned. Anyone who's read through the ban appeals on the forums can see that admins are often tapped to decide on those cases, and they often link to a lot of evidence regarding those decisions. I will not link examples of this, as the players involved are already controversial topics; they are easily found on the ban appeals forums.

The harsh truth is that there are indeed some people who will never be satisfied with a mod or admin's reasoning for a ban. There's also so many bans that it would be unreasonable to expect mods and admins to elaborate on all of them for the MCBouncer log, especially when many of them never get appealed. The current system of elaborating only on the appeals forum, which is open for anyone to view, seems like a good balance of those concerns.

There was also mention that perhaps players should be the tie-breakers of sorts for more controversial bans. How can this be implemented in a way that is not easily exploited by the banned player or trolls?

What are people's thoughts on how bans and the records are handled? How exactly can this be improved?

B. Input on who becomes a mod, admin, and head admin

This seems to be a far more contentious issue among players as they get more involved. The reasoning for wanting to have a say is obvious: players want a say in who is running the show. How much of a say they have and whether or not there should be oversight is what makes this such a complicated topic.

For any new players who are unsure what all this is:

A mod is a moderator. They are given access to the ModMode plugin, which is similar to creative mode, in order to complete mod requests, enforce the rules through warnings and bans, and try to troubleshoot general issues on the server. They are prohibited from using any of their mod capabilities for their own gain, and it is grounds for being de-modded and banned. They generally are the people in the team that players will interact with most.

An admin is a sort of elevated mod. They are responsible for a particular server, so there are P, C, and S admins. There are also tech admins who focus specifically on the software of the servers. Admins have more say in the direction the server is going, not because they have an opinion-crushing veto, but because they are the ones who prioritize what will be focused on. Admins often still do mod work, but they have added responsibilities.

A head admin is an admin who now helps run everything. They are often called to be the final decision-makers for contentious issues, whether it is a ban, changes in server infrastructure, or new things to test out. They do not focus on only one server or one type of problem; they're expected to be on top of everything.

Currently, mods are nominated and voted in by the mod and admin team only. While the nominations and selections for mods are generally public, even if not voted on by the players, admins and head admins choices are often kept behind the scenes entirely until the decision is made and the nominee accepts the position. Back when the server was small and Minecraft was less well known, the player base had a more direct impact by being able to vote for these nominees.

The arguments for open and direct voting are simple and easily supported:

  • Players should have a choice in how the server is run and who is doing the work.

  • Players should have an opportunity to speak out against nominees when they feel that they are unfit for the position.

However, there are less obvious and equally concerning reasons that player voting should not be the end-all way to choose mods and admins:

  • Voting en masse can be exploited by knowledgeable and malicious people, whether they are players or not. Barneygale's exploitation of server security and circumventing his ban on the server, subreddit, and forums shows that this is far from hyperbole and that it is in no way a hypothetical.

  • Mods and admins are not just popular players. This server has never had, and never should it have, a ranking system. Allowing popularity to be a strong factor in determining who becomes part of the team threatens to change that aspect of this server.

  • Most players on these servers, at any given time, have not been on the servers for more than 1 or 2 revisions. This is especially true for P. New players are very rarely keen enough to determine who could be or should be trusted with mod and admin powers.

Obviously, there should be some balance between the concerns of an oligarchy and the concerns of exploitation inherent in democratic voting. What suggestions do people have?

C. Public Logs

This is where people are not directly effected and it is more how records that already exist are handled. There are chat logs, change logs, forum and subreddit moderation logs, admin logs, etc.

Some people have voiced that all these logs should be public. Others have expressed that they think they should be closed. Still others think they should be screened and censored for sensitive information.

Since it's such a broad and encompassing topic, there's not much specific to any one type of log. The primary concerns for having them publicly available are (1) the availability of sensitive, personal information on players, and (2) security and preventing hacking, DDOS attacks, etc.

If you speak up on this topic, explain what logs you are specifying! The issues vary in importance depending on the one you reference.

D. Mods having more say in how the server is run

As the server has grown, so has the number of mods, while the number of head admins has shrunk. While we do have a new head admin (Barlimore!), that's one less C admin.

As stated before, mods tend to do more of day-to-day server maintenance and PR rather than be directly involved in decision-making. Often, large decisions are left to the admins or head admins, and mods chime in with no substantial power to influence the decision.

That said, this is something that is also very much behind the scenes. We don't have records of the countless mumble discussions between them, nor do we have a sophisticated and searchable chat log to find exactly when X and Y discussed some server topic. To say they have no influence at all is unreasonable.

This also is a subject where mods and admins would have more qualified opinions. They know how things are actually going, who is influential, which admins listen to them, and whether or not they are simply brushed aside.

Discussion of this topic should be done with care. After all, it was first brought up by someone who hasn't been part of this community for nearly a year. For all the players know, he was talking out of his ass and the mods don't feel this way in the least.


In the end, this is a similar discussion to what has already been posted. However, this is also posted by someone who is indifferent to the changes proposed. I am not a mod or admin who stands to benefit or lose with this argument, nor am I a player who feels strongly either way. I just don't like these discussions centering around trolls who have nothing better to do than harass a community they haven't been a part of for months.

Also, keep in mind that we are moving on to a new revision for all three servers. Undoubtedly, that transition will take priority over all other topics brought up here. This isn't meant to whine at anyone for taking time to fix a problem; this is to, hopefully, flesh out the discussion beyond the whole us vs. them tone that was rampant in the original post.


r/mcpublic • • Nov 24 '11

Mods censoring PvE: I thought being a mod was not a promotion, guys...

12 Upvotes

Eh, i am out now. I said all i need to say. Thanks everyone who replied and a big fuck you to everyone who flooded my account with meaningless downvotes in old comments i made on other threads.

Also, to the people sending my fiance (reddit name ryusko) hostility: he is not the droid you're looking for. I'm the stubborn bitch here, not him, my reddit and game names are seperate.

Today, Thanksgiving, at bout 12, some users were talking about politics/trees on the in-game chat. I was not really part of the discussion but the mods on at the time (KedNys and thelethalkind) put forth a broadcast threatening to ban anyone who talked politics.

Seriously, what the holy fuck was that, mods? People were not getting out of hand, and no one was really saying anything offensive except for a few pizza being a vegetable jokes. As far as I know less than five minutes of political speech is not a ban worthy offense.

Reddit is a diverse community with diverse users. Although I would hate to think anyone got alienated, this is STILL a Reddit server and no one talks politics more than us.

Truthfully it seems like mod abuse. It was arbitrary and senseless. I feel good about reporting it and look forward to a resolution.

Edit: Well, so far everyone seems split. I still say it was rude and uncouth to broadcast "people who talk politics will be banned" and call it spam, especially since people have gotten away with a lot worse discussions in-game for a lot longer. It's not the end of the world but I hold my ground.

A lot of others (and mods) think differently, eh. World still turns.

Lovingly, Ryusko

Wow, this got popular I guess :)

Some people think calling this issue out was me being disrespectful. I don't think so. Quite a few very ignorant PMs later, I disagree.

I should have known I'd get shit from both sides though.

It seems like some people think this is about spam. It's not. If you think it is, you are misinformed.

15:16:24 [INFO] [Broadcast] ok enough politics. This is a direct order, failure to comply will result in a ban.

The aformentioned phrase was the only one I had a problem with. Notice how it doesn't mention the "spam"? That's because it really wasn't about the spam at all, was it? Because, if it WAS about spam, which I don't think anyone here is stupid enough to believe it actually was, that would indicate it was one person and not many users having fun and talking. That's all they were doing.

And you know what? If it was only about spam, everyone would not have shut up and changed the topic right away and begged the mods not to get banned for talking about pot.

That message was an in-game STFU from a mod because he didn't like what people were talking about (there, I said it).

" Failure to comply?" Forgot that part. I don't even need to comment on that, it's so litigious in and of itself. It's a phrase usually reserved for high school decorum codes, not what constitutes congress as morons and how much pot people smoke.

But why is this discussion still going on? I guess what this has come down to is, add an extra rule at spawn that says "no politics" or let users know they can talk shop in game as long as they are not being jerks to each other. Mods are awesome people but they are not admins and should not make up ban offenses just to scare people into staying on topic. Like the admins say in the forums, becoming a mod is not a promotion so they shouldn't act like they can dictate or censor topics they don't like.


r/mcpublic • • May 27 '13

Survival Survival is Having a Player "Crisis"

0 Upvotes

Let's face it. Survival is having a player "crisis," if you will. We need to brainstorm ideas to advertise without costing the server's money, and bringing in too many bad players. We really need to start off by clearing our reputation that AVO created, etc. Then we need to brainstorm ideas that involve the community and will make players want to help, while still helping the server in a positive way. I have an idea:

-Post our server on a voting site + set up a voting module. We can set it up so the "top-voter" gets a reward that doesn't change gameplay signifigantly, but still drives the player to want to vote, etc. Some possible rewards could be a prefix in game that says "Top-Voter" or "Dedicated Player," etc. Or, it could be an item such as a skull. Maybe there could be an implementation that it lets you run /skull <Player> once, giving you a player head of your choosing. You could also have custom subreddit flairs, which still don't go over the line of ranks and stuff like that.

All I'm sayin' is we need to start "working together" to get more players and make Survival more popular. I do realize we have spikes in players, such as today we had 30/150 on, but still, it shouldn't be a spike-it should be most all of the time.

Please leave ideas down below, and try to keep the criticism constructive.


r/mcpublic • • May 23 '12

Survival The fellowship of the egg!!!

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • May 08 '12

Survival On Ender Pearl glitching

0 Upvotes

In the last few days, Nerdia has been raided several times, most of the raids due to people using enderpearls to glitch through blocks. This section of the rules: (No use of bugs or exploits to gain an advantage over other players (eg: item duping).) states that no exploits or bugs can be used to gain an advantage over players. I would argue that enderpearling through blocks with some creative use in game calculations should be disallowed by this rule.

Through the use of enderpearls to teleport through blocks by abusing the game's flawed code for calculating where a teleported player ends up, certain players are abusing pearls to gain unfair advantages over over players by passing through blocks.

I would like some clarification as to the breadth of the rule I mentioned and what is and isn't allowed in terms of glitching through blocks with enderpearls.


r/mcpublic • • Jul 28 '14

Survival Some recommendations from a long-term Civcraft player

4 Upvotes

Hi there! I'm Sanwi, from the Discharge clan.

Discharge is made up of a bunch of people from the Civcraft server, as well as a few random people who've joined along the way. We decided to check this server out when we heard that you guys were implementing some of our plugins. Our previous experience with these plugins has given us a huge advantage, but we're hoping that more players will catch on and be able to compete.

We have been very aggressive, because this server seems to be more pvp-oriented than Civcraft. Unfortunately, this seems to have damaged the server population a bit.

I'm going to explain how to make a successful clan, and hopefully people will be able to gear themselves up and fight us. Personally, I would see this as a success if the people on this server were able to destroy our clan. That would demonstrate the resilience, cooperation, and determination required to form a successful playerbase on any server.

We want you to beat us.

Here's how to do it:

  1. Get some friends to work with. You cannot do this alone. A group of people will go much further than the same people playing alone.

  2. Get yourself some gear. Currently, animal farms are the best way to get xp. Breed the animals, then kill the babies for xp. Use the xp to enchant books, combine the books until you have protection 4, then put it on some diamond armor. Potions are extremely important as well, but that is better explained by the Minecraft wiki.

  3. Practice PVP There are a lot of servers dedicated to pvp practice. I don't want to post any of them here, as to not violate subreddit rules, but you can look them up online.

  4. Protect your town Build it far away from anywhere that people might wander. Being well-hidden is your best protection until you can defend it. Be sure to make use of the Citadel plugin to protect everything. Every block you place should be at least reinforced with stone. I recommend building most of it underground, with obsidian tunnels and iron doors. This will save your life if your town is raided, and give you time to regroup and get ready to fight.

  5. Assume everyone is hostile Carry speed potions at all times if you can. If you see someone with better gear than you, assume that they intend to kill you, and run away. If you need to travel, I highly recommend riding a horse. They're much faster than players, and will allow you to easily escape even the most geared enemies. You can protect your horse with /corral, so it can't be killed.

I hope this helps. So far, we've really enjoyed your server, and hope to continue playing. I will try to convince people to be a little nicer until you guys can get some gear :)


r/mcpublic • • Aug 17 '14

Notice Public vote: Should staff members be voted on by the whole community?

Thumbnail
nerd.nu
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Aug 06 '14

Survival Survival Fun!

0 Upvotes

So I just want to take a minute to express how much I'm enjoying this survival revision (hint, its a lot). I've only recently gotten back to S for a couple revs (I did play around rev 2-3 or so and since was more of a PvE player) but in my opinion the new plugins give so much more depth to the game-play. Previously, everyone would just mine/enchant as fast as possible, get tons of gear and go randomly PvP, for the only purpose of killing someone else and to me, that just wasn't enough. Now, there are resources at stake: land and chests.

It is up to the player to decide how secure they want their build. You can absolutely protect your chest enough so no one will take the time to get to it, it just takes time and effort and designing the protections is really something that I'm enjoying.

I've so far had 2 bases raided. The first one was because we were too close to a big bulls eye, Discharge. The second because I/we were careless and left paths back to the base. Neither base am I upset for losing because in the end, both were my fault. I've learned some new tricks and will build a better, new base.

I have had to learn some new commands for the new plugins (even I didn't know fully how to utilize them and am still learning new commands even today) but it literally requires maybe 30 minutes of reading through a few pages. The plugins are really fairly simple, just take the little effort to knowledge up and you can effectively counter most grief. If you want any help on the plugins, ask and at the very least I'll direct you to the correct doc for what you are trying to do and most likely I will actually help you more thoroughly.

So, in summary. Yay survival!


r/mcpublic • • Mar 05 '13

Survival Unce vs. Our most valued player, the almighty Randomdoor

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/mcpublic • • Mar 10 '12

Remove NOCHEAT from Survival

0 Upvotes

PVP is patently unfair because 9/10 times sword hits just don't count at all on a a person. It is entirely luck now. A stone sword zerger can take out an armored person without taking a hit.

This is not an isolated incident. This is not picky. This is downright dumb.

At the VERY least remove(or alter) everything that protects against forcefields and autoclicks and range hacks.

This server's excuse for pvp is just a roulette game where your odds are 1:100 where you can hit someone.


r/mcpublic • • Dec 14 '13

He griefed our chaos base... So we burned him in effigy!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes