TL;DR for the other posts: A former admin, who was banned from just about everything related to these servers, circumvented his ban to post here and pretended to be a starry-eyed mod-wannabe in order to stir the shit and be a troll. Let's start this discussion from scratch.
I encourage everyone to be as specific as possible with their reasoning. Vague, flimsy arguments just make you seem like you don't know what you're talking about. If you want people to listen to you, then develop your argument and present it in a way that's easy to follow and understand.
Openness
People seem to be up in arms over how open the server is and how open they think it should be. The whole "who watches the watchers" sort of thinking is what is at heart of the issue. There is obviously some distrust of mods and admins, who are in a position of power, and that will never change, even if every single action and word that ever could be logged was logged and open for anyone to view. That said, it does not mean that the sentiment should be disregarded in its entirety.
There are many things that could be made available for public view. Let's split this discussion up into the various topics of what that could apply to.
A. Ban Process
From my observation of these discussions, players are not really concerned with how public the appeals process is. After all, it's already publicly available on the forums. What people are more worried about is bans in general. They want to see some sort of log of who is banned, when, and for what, available regardless of whether or not someone appealed. They also want to see as much detail as possible.
That said, people can check out the MCBouncer log, though the last time I checked, it lists all bans from the server as bans from C. Perhaps there is a way to tidy this up? It also may just be that people had no clue this existed already.
There was a closely related issue that people wanted more details regarding a ban. Some bans are extremely straightforward (short bans for crop griefing on P, for example) and need no additional details. There's been consistent complaints about the grey area bans, especially concerning repeat offenders who are then banned for either a long period of time or permabanned. Anyone who's read through the ban appeals on the forums can see that admins are often tapped to decide on those cases, and they often link to a lot of evidence regarding those decisions. I will not link examples of this, as the players involved are already controversial topics; they are easily found on the ban appeals forums.
The harsh truth is that there are indeed some people who will never be satisfied with a mod or admin's reasoning for a ban. There's also so many bans that it would be unreasonable to expect mods and admins to elaborate on all of them for the MCBouncer log, especially when many of them never get appealed. The current system of elaborating only on the appeals forum, which is open for anyone to view, seems like a good balance of those concerns.
There was also mention that perhaps players should be the tie-breakers of sorts for more controversial bans. How can this be implemented in a way that is not easily exploited by the banned player or trolls?
What are people's thoughts on how bans and the records are handled? How exactly can this be improved?
B. Input on who becomes a mod, admin, and head admin
This seems to be a far more contentious issue among players as they get more involved. The reasoning for wanting to have a say is obvious: players want a say in who is running the show. How much of a say they have and whether or not there should be oversight is what makes this such a complicated topic.
For any new players who are unsure what all this is:
A mod is a moderator. They are given access to the ModMode plugin, which is similar to creative mode, in order to complete mod requests, enforce the rules through warnings and bans, and try to troubleshoot general issues on the server. They are prohibited from using any of their mod capabilities for their own gain, and it is grounds for being de-modded and banned. They generally are the people in the team that players will interact with most.
An admin is a sort of elevated mod. They are responsible for a particular server, so there are P, C, and S admins. There are also tech admins who focus specifically on the software of the servers. Admins have more say in the direction the server is going, not because they have an opinion-crushing veto, but because they are the ones who prioritize what will be focused on. Admins often still do mod work, but they have added responsibilities.
A head admin is an admin who now helps run everything. They are often called to be the final decision-makers for contentious issues, whether it is a ban, changes in server infrastructure, or new things to test out. They do not focus on only one server or one type of problem; they're expected to be on top of everything.
Currently, mods are nominated and voted in by the mod and admin team only. While the nominations and selections for mods are generally public, even if not voted on by the players, admins and head admins choices are often kept behind the scenes entirely until the decision is made and the nominee accepts the position. Back when the server was small and Minecraft was less well known, the player base had a more direct impact by being able to vote for these nominees.
The arguments for open and direct voting are simple and easily supported:
However, there are less obvious and equally concerning reasons that player voting should not be the end-all way to choose mods and admins:
Voting en masse can be exploited by knowledgeable and malicious people, whether they are players or not. Barneygale's exploitation of server security and circumventing his ban on the server, subreddit, and forums shows that this is far from hyperbole and that it is in no way a hypothetical.
Mods and admins are not just popular players. This server has never had, and never should it have, a ranking system. Allowing popularity to be a strong factor in determining who becomes part of the team threatens to change that aspect of this server.
Most players on these servers, at any given time, have not been on the servers for more than 1 or 2 revisions. This is especially true for P. New players are very rarely keen enough to determine who could be or should be trusted with mod and admin powers.
Obviously, there should be some balance between the concerns of an oligarchy and the concerns of exploitation inherent in democratic voting. What suggestions do people have?
C. Public Logs
This is where people are not directly effected and it is more how records that already exist are handled. There are chat logs, change logs, forum and subreddit moderation logs, admin logs, etc.
Some people have voiced that all these logs should be public. Others have expressed that they think they should be closed. Still others think they should be screened and censored for sensitive information.
Since it's such a broad and encompassing topic, there's not much specific to any one type of log. The primary concerns for having them publicly available are (1) the availability of sensitive, personal information on players, and (2) security and preventing hacking, DDOS attacks, etc.
If you speak up on this topic, explain what logs you are specifying! The issues vary in importance depending on the one you reference.
D. Mods having more say in how the server is run
As the server has grown, so has the number of mods, while the number of head admins has shrunk. While we do have a new head admin (Barlimore!), that's one less C admin.
As stated before, mods tend to do more of day-to-day server maintenance and PR rather than be directly involved in decision-making. Often, large decisions are left to the admins or head admins, and mods chime in with no substantial power to influence the decision.
That said, this is something that is also very much behind the scenes. We don't have records of the countless mumble discussions between them, nor do we have a sophisticated and searchable chat log to find exactly when X and Y discussed some server topic. To say they have no influence at all is unreasonable.
This also is a subject where mods and admins would have more qualified opinions. They know how things are actually going, who is influential, which admins listen to them, and whether or not they are simply brushed aside.
Discussion of this topic should be done with care. After all, it was first brought up by someone who hasn't been part of this community for nearly a year. For all the players know, he was talking out of his ass and the mods don't feel this way in the least.
In the end, this is a similar discussion to what has already been posted. However, this is also posted by someone who is indifferent to the changes proposed. I am not a mod or admin who stands to benefit or lose with this argument, nor am I a player who feels strongly either way. I just don't like these discussions centering around trolls who have nothing better to do than harass a community they haven't been a part of for months.
Also, keep in mind that we are moving on to a new revision for all three servers. Undoubtedly, that transition will take priority over all other topics brought up here. This isn't meant to whine at anyone for taking time to fix a problem; this is to, hopefully, flesh out the discussion beyond the whole us vs. them tone that was rampant in the original post.