r/mcgill • • Nov 10 '23

Why is this subreddit so blatantly anti palestinian

20 Upvotes

Title . Idc if I get downvoted. Why is it that I have seen NOTHING on any of the protests & unity happening in the past two weeks here, and yet there are unfiltered posts every other day commenting on SPHR or critiquing the CAQ for something or another. Why aren’t people allowed to post [edit: why are there no] critiques of mcgill’s recent emails? Or anything pro-Palestine related? This sub has such a homogenous viewpoint.

Edit: holy guys. I’m saying that out of the posts that have been getting traction since October 7th, a concerning amount contain bias against, or neutral positions for, what is happening in Gaza. This is the context in which I was critiquing this sub. I’m not saying that I can’t post about it myself, I’m saying that the lack of traction of pro-sphr protests here (more, traction of posts against them), are telling that this sub has a sizeable population of people I would consider complacent in this genocide.

I’ll admit, I’ve worded things MUCH better. However, it does not make my point unworthy to the extent that some comments are claiming it to be. I apologize to the mods for using the word “allowed” in my original statement.


r/mcgill • • Mar 29 '22

How about staying at home if you're sick?

0 Upvotes

Why the fuck is this so hard to understand? I'm sitting in class today, and every 30 seconds:

someone: *cough-co- coughhhhhhhhhh*

someone else: *coughing up phlegm*

yet another person:*cough-cooooooough-sniffle-sneeze*

some mf: *chokes on phlegm*

me: *my skin is literally crawling, and i cannot concentrate in class because someone behind me is coughing on my hair*

How inconsiderate, selfish and irresponsible do you have to be to show up to class if you're clearly sick and symptomatic? I understand that this class essentially has mandatory attendance. But do you realize that it's mandatory for every student in this class??! Even for students who aren't sick and don't want to get sick and for those who cannot afford to get sick?!?!

How about staying the fuck home, and letting one of your healthy friends come in for you and sending you their notes?

Or how come there isn't a program like OSD note taking, but for COVID/sick students to enroll in temporarily? I mean, if you're sick, I'd even offer to share my notes with you, but if I'll have to keep sitting in a crowd of sick people, I will stop going to lectures from now on.

But for those of you who are sick, and showing up to class, consider this: exam season is approaching. This is not a time when responsible students who take precautions and who are COVID negative can afford to get sick. I'm sorry that you are, and I hope that you get better soon. But in the meantime, you can be a considerate student in the McGill community, and respectfully, stay the fuck home.


r/mcgill • • Sep 02 '23

Wear a mask bastards

68 Upvotes

Basically the title. I was sitting in one class this week and half of the class was coughing their lungs out. As a result I’m feeling off right now. Somebody recently posted about people getting sick at frosh so I guess that’s were it’s coming from 🤷‍♂️. Sorry if it comes off as rude, but seriously if you are sick, if you decide to come, at least wear a mask. 😷


r/mcgill • • Oct 31 '22

Je suis dans une drôle de situation et je ne sais pas quoi faire

0 Upvotes

J'ai récemment rejoint l'école d'Éducation Permanente à McGill et je me suis rendu compte que la grande majorité des élèves de l'école viennent de France - comme moi. McGill fait pas mal de pub pour attirer des étudiants français, alors c'est pas trop surprenant qu'on soit si nombreux. Malheur, notre prof nous a mis sur un travail d'équipe il y a quelques semaines et on est tombé sur l'un des seuls anglophones du lot, ultra relou qui plus est. On parle tous anglais bien sûr, mais c'est pas naturel de se parler en anglais entre francophones, alors on s'est dit qu'il pourrait faire un petit effort pour parler en français ou à tout le moins nous laisser parler en français. Il est dans une ville francophone après tout... Mais non, il a commencé à nous saouler et à nous dire qu'on devrait tous parler en anglais, parce que son français est pas bon. De bonne foi, on a essayé, mais naturellement, on repasse au français. Normal, non?

Si le type avait décidé d'aller à une université en Ontario ou aux États-Unis, il n'aurait pas eu à "gérer" une autre langue que l'anglais, mais bon, il décide d'étudier à Montréal ou la langue principale est le français. C'est le genre de chose à laquelle on doit s'attendre, il me semble.

J'apprécierais tout conseil de votre part. Merci!


r/mcgill • • Jun 25 '21

**UNPOPULAR OPINION**

25 Upvotes

I’m sick of all these coco berry (or whatever this albino squirrel’s name is) pictures. Like why is it so popular on this sub? I mean, thank u we know what it looks like, what next 🐿


r/mcgill • • Nov 22 '23

McGill’s SSMU is the worst most divisive student union.

159 Upvotes

Instead of fostering unity, they meddle in politics overseas that insults or harms their very own students that they were elected to represent.

More McGill students need to VOTE and be very cautious when electing our reps.

I have zero trust in them, and clearly our justice system doesn’t either.


r/mcgill • • Dec 06 '23

Call for Ceasefire @ City Hall

0 Upvotes

Not sure if I should post but it would be better to get the word out on this forum too

Call for a Ceasefire protest at 5:00 pm on Thursday, Dec. 7, 2023 @ 275 Notre-Dame St E. - demand an end to the violence !!


r/mcgill • • Dec 26 '18

It is your favourite McGill Dad over here. Happy Christmas! I have a message for everyone worried and anguished during your holiday.

7 Upvotes

My daughter, whom spends many late hours trolling about this online abode, came home from McGill for the holidays. As I imagine many of you are, she was crushed by some grades. It has not been her most successful few semesters, and she's of the conviction her life is coming apart. I told her over Christmas dinner what I saw as my duty to tell you all. More people need to tell the younger generation the following:

This does not matter.

Don't get me wrong. School is important. I learned a lot in college. What they teach you in college is fundamentally important, and it will make your mindset systematic and teach you the bare bones framework of thinking. But the first thing my first boss told me was, "forget what you learned and *do not remember it*." After that job, by the way, no one nary asked what school I finished, let alone my GPA. I managed to, nevertheless, become a very successful businessman in a niche market (export and shipping). Friends I had who took college far too seriously are grubbing between dusty book covers and can't take a vacation further than the coast.

It will seem almost impossible to realize this right now, but your professors aren't the smartest people in the world. They're not even very smart, full stop. They have dedicated their lives to living in learning, instead of living in doing. And if you want to make money, you have to do. You have to produce, not memorize books and produce hackneyed papers that peddle your dogmatic views. I know it is hard to truly grasp it right now, but you will remember me when you come to understand that your professors were false idols, and that college was an entire cult of polytheistic false idols.

Work on people skills. Work on your network. Grow your capabilities. College does not matter. Have more fun and go out more. Take it from me, you are far more likely to meet a lifelong business connection partying than you are to work for that added +.01 GPA point.

Be merry, be mirthy, and take life easy. I wish you all more relaxation, focus, and remember to laugh once in a while.

Yours truly,

MD


r/mcgill • • Sep 05 '21

SSMU Activities Night event in-person at Muzique

1 Upvotes

Am I the only one who is confused as to how there is an in-person "activities night" event organized by SSMU at Muzique when the SSMU is strongly advocating for increased mask use, vaccination passports, and a "safe campus" generally? How does McGill react to seeing this after being criticized for not doing enough?

The vaccine only reduces your chances of catching it and it makes you less sick, but going to a club is sooo much worse than sitting in a classroom or doing extracurricular activities or sports

Is the purpose of getting a "safer campus" for having no covid spread on campus? If so, isn't that event completely absurd?

As the semester gets underway there will likely be a lot more of these in-person events with "close contacts" and so I'd love to hear thoughts on this


r/mcgill • • Oct 24 '23

WALK-OUT FOR PALESTINE TOMORROW AT 1:30PM

Post image
0 Upvotes

Organizations and student groups across Canada are planning a national student walkout tomorrow at 6:30pm in solidarity with the people of Palestine. Some of the calls to action include divesting from corporations complicit in the genocidal violence against Palestinians, such as arms companies.

McGill’s administration has a long history of attacking those who speak out against the oppression of Palestinians, threatening the club status of the Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights Club in 2022 and this past month. Other campuses across Canada and the world have threatened pro-Palestine activists, echoing the actions of employers and state officials to silence and remove anyone who defends Palestinians. Western imperialists have been quick to “Stand with Israel” at a time when Israel is bombing hospitals and schools, shutting off water and electricity and dropping thousands of bombs on Gazans, whose average age is 18.

Student and workers must take a stand against the brutal oppression of Palestinians, and this starts at home - against Canada’s politicians, corporations and university bureaucrats and Board members. Please walk out of your classes tomorrow at 1:30pm for a rally at the Y-intersection in defence of Palestine! Viva viva Intifada!


r/mcgill • • Oct 07 '25

What did you think of the Israeli sided anti war protest, vigil for the dead today?

Post image
1 Upvotes

In before post is locked award is mine buddy.

I wish there would be some nice anti war protests with both Israeli & Palestinian flags but I might have to wait a while for that.


r/mcgill • • Jan 20 '22

Seriously, why does McGill want us back to campus? ELI5 plz!

0 Upvotes

Edit: I’m not advocating one over the other. I’m just saying, some people hate online classes and some people hate online classes but still don’t want to go back because the situation of this pandemic and variants is still unclear.

Original: What’s the hurry? Also not only McGill but other uni like UoT also. People from UoT are also complaining about going back to in person lectures. But seriously why? It surely can’t be because then cafeteria would make more money…?

———————————-

To people saying “because the traditional way of teaching is in-person”: yes I KNoW. I also enjoy in person lectures. But with the petition going around and SSMU sending out emails and open about their concern going back to campus, clearly a lot of people do not want to go back because of the pandemic.


r/mcgill • • May 09 '24

This is time !!! New encampement please...

0 Upvotes

why no body speak about sudan????


r/mcgill • • Apr 02 '24

Remove Christopher Manfredi from Provost Position - change.org x Queer McGill

Thumbnail
chng.it
0 Upvotes

r/mcgill • • Oct 11 '23

SPHR McGill literally celebrated a Hamas terrorist attack on civilians

149 Upvotes

Hamas raped and killed civilians who were at and around a music festival.

This is what SPHR McGill did the next day:

«🚨MONTREAL: ALL OUT FOR PALESTINE🚨 Last night, the resistance in Gaza led a heroic attack against the occupation and has taken over 30 hostages including Brigadier General Nimrom Aloni. Their march toward liberation is as monumental as their rockets - the resistance will free the prisoners who have been facing a fascist attack by the occupation and liberate our land from the fangs of the enemy. The resistance has set a new precedent for the Palestinian struggle - our right to resist the occupation, to defend the land, and to free our prisoners are the utmost priorities. We call on our people in Montreal and in the far diaspora to celebrate the resistance’s success, to uplift their calls, and to march this Sunday Oct 8 at 2pm at Dorchester Square 🇵🇸»

It is not an act of resistance to behead babies in their crib, nor to parade the naked body of a victim like a trophy.

As a recent-ish alumni, I am profoundly disgusted at SPHR and at the fact that no one is calling them out.


r/mcgill • • Apr 17 '24

what gender for housing do i put down

0 Upvotes

Hello, I’m a incoming trans girl (mtf) and haven’t started hrt. What freaking gender do I put down for Mcgill housing? I don’t know anymore >~<


r/mcgill • • Mar 22 '23

Does anyone feel like McGill is lacking in school spirit

0 Upvotes

I feel like most people from other schools are way more proud of their school than we are. From price gouging for food, to incredibly expensive merch, to soul draining semesters with little breaks, to transphobes being invited to talk, and lots of other problems, it feels so hard to be happy about going here. It feels like the administration wants to make us NOT be proud about McGill 😭. Any thoughts on this? I want to like McGill but there’s so many problems.


r/mcgill • • Sep 21 '23

depressed about the protests

190 Upvotes

I didn't think it would affect me as much as it has, but I can't stop thinking about the protestors. I've had it in my head for so long that these people only exist on the internet, if I turn off my phone I can go back to the real world and forget about it. Guess not. I'm having a hard time even getting myself to go to campus. Is anybody else having a hard time with this?

edit: probably should have made it more clear that i'm against the protests, proud member of the lgbtq+ community

another edit: I knew this might be controversial but wow lol, it's encouraging to see how many of you have been so kind and supportive, our community is strong and our allies are very much appreciated <3


r/mcgill • • Mar 19 '13

Bang.ne.sia

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/mcgill • • May 17 '21

Petition to the McGill Administration to Divest from all Israeli Companies and to Update Discrimination and Racism Policy

16 Upvotes

Apartheid and Colonialism is unacceptable today and always. We must speak up.

This is about human rights, International Law, and NOT antisemitism - don’t get it twisted.

Peacefully protesting the current Israeli government is the most efficient path to peace in Palestine.

SIGN HERE :

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScIyiZ5nFQZWyp5Y9ZKVYvV8sGUh7ke1IWIyBWJ3nfIquwekg/viewform

FULL STATEMENT:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qe4bIwWd0dNPxoEsf755CNf7aL3yDi6vU1tsneEqnR8/mobilebasic


r/mcgill • • Feb 27 '26

Political Stop Scribbling in the Burnside Bathrooms

0 Upvotes

Whoever keeps scribbling this dogshit pro-Palestine nonsense in the bathroom stalls, you need to stop. I don't understand what you think you're accomplishing, you're just fighting with the janitors at this point.

You've been doing this shit for months on end. Surely, you have better things to do with your time.

Instead of writing meaningless drivel in the bathrooms, why don't you actually do something worthwhile? Why not organize a protest instead of being a worthless waste of oxygen?


r/mcgill • • Sep 16 '24

Political SSMU’s email is a total disgrace

70 Upvotes

The SSMU being split on delisting SPHR is ridiculous. The behaviour displayed by SPHR was absolutely abhorrent and the decision to delist them should have been made swiftly and easily.

This is a group that very openly praised a terrorist attack, and the rape and murder of people at a music festival.

Everyone is entitled to whatever opinions they want on the situation in the Middle East, but if you think what happened on Oct 7th should be praised, you are deranged and in need of mental counselling.

The calls to violence by SPHR were a clear reason to remove them from SSMU club status.


r/mcgill • • Jun 23 '21

Do any international students regret coming to McGill?

10 Upvotes

This question is meant mostly for international students, other than those from the US.

I am an international student from Europe (not France or the UK) and I often look back on my decision to come to McGill. There are not many people from my home country at McGill, and my friendships/networks formed in Canada do not transfer back to my home country. It makes me feel lonely and isolated in a specific social bubble of each country. I feel that I am just wasting my life at McGill, because I plan to come back home after graduation (I understood that Canada is not for me), and I am essentially "absent from social life" in my home country from September to April. Career-wise, I also cannot participate in most of the part-time internship programs because they require me to be in the country during the year. And neither do I enjoy McGill that much- I think that it is a hostile and competitive environment. And Montreal is...alright.

Simultaneously, I feel that I am gradually becoming more distant with my old friends from my country. I also don't belong to North American partying culture- it seems immature and dumb. And socializing with Canadians/Americans is weird. In general- I grew to dislike Canada and Quebec a lot. I think that it is a country that has nothing to offer to the world-it is boring and dull. Of course what I am saying here is a bit of an oversimplification and exaggeration, but my statement nevertheless holds true. Additionally, toxic SJW-like campus politics is off-putting because it literally ignores the existence of my distinct culture, language and identity- it clumps me into the generic "white American" culture. I find it offensive.

Why did I exclude American students from my question? This is because I view the US as culturally similar to Canada, and because there are many American students at McGill, so it is a different situation regarding maintaining friendships across the border. Many Americans also come to McGill for the cheap tuition and it is good value for money for them, which is opposite for me.

So I just wanted to ask other international students if they find themselves in this situation? How do you go about it?

What are your thoughts?


r/mcgill • • Jul 25 '24

These military checkpoints are dehumanizing.

61 Upvotes

I had to show my ID card to someone about five times today so they can pull back a temporary metal fence so I can enter the DMZ that has become McGill's lower campus.

I got stopped entering a building "too quickly" because we all had to scan our ID cards that I just had to show someone before entering a building.

This has got to stop. McGill has gone absolutely scorched earth on its students and employees for about a year. TAs, professors, students, all on strike at some point or another, the entire time negotiating in bad faith. The worst part of it is that they get away with it because of the Eternal September.

It's time to organize a tuition strike or something because there is a consistant and total disregard for the treatment of students and staff at McGill.