2017 Mazda6 Touring with approximately 139k miles. Recently, my mechanic and I noticed some light play on the front passenger side when wiggling the wheel left to right while the car was lifted.
It's not terrible right now, but I'm concerned about it becoming a serious safety issue, especially because of where I'm located, where potholes can be pretty brutal. I do my best to avoid them when driving.
I'm planning to replace the passenger-side control arm, but I'm debating whether OEM Mazda parts are worth the additional cost.
My options:
- OEM Mazda: Dealership replacement would cost at least $1,500+ including parts and labor, with a one-year warranty.
- NAPA aftermarket: My mechanic buddy can do the job for approximately $500 using a NAPA control arm, which comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
The car already had this issue when I purchased it, but I didn't discover it until we inspected the suspension.
My goal is to keep this Mazda6 running well past 200k miles, ideally reaching 250–300k with proper preventative maintenance. (Transmission fluid, brake fluid, oil, coolant, etc. Everything has been changed and documented.)
I'm not necessarily against aftermarket parts, but I'm concerned about their longevity compared to OEM. The original Mazda control arm lasted nearly 140k miles, and I don't know whether a NAPA replacement would offer comparable durability.
My questions:
Has anyone used NAPA control arms on their Mazda6? How have they held up?
Is there a significant difference in build quality and longevity between OEM Mazda and NAPA aftermarket control arms?
Does NAPA's limited lifetime warranty actually make it a better long-term investment, or is OEM still preferable?
Would you spend the extra money on OEM, or go aftermarket given the age and mileage of the vehicle?
I'm trying to balance safety, reliability, and cost without unnecessarily spending $1,000+ more.
Any experiences or recommendations would be appreciated!