r/MawInstallation • • Dec 24 '20

Please stop wishing for Mace Windu to come back.

6.0k Upvotes

Here’s the thing, Mace Windu was a cool character. But he was also a character with a purpose. And he finalized that purpose with his death, and retconning his death would ruin the whole thing.

During the prequel era, the Jedi order was at the height of its power, and pride. And Mace Windu was the poster boy of the pride of the Jedi. He was a symbol for everything that was wrong with the Order.

The Jedi had become too focused on rules and regulations. They wanted to dictate the will of the Force, rather than be dictated by it. Even when the literal Chosen One was brought before them, the Council initially refused to train him out of arbitrary rules about age. Mace Windu was the poster boy for this, and even though the Council approved Anakin’s training, Mace never respected him and often butted heads (“Take a seat, young Skywalker”).

And yet despite Windu’s insistence on following rules, he was a massive hypocrite (again, a symbol for the Jedi Order as a whole). He says that Jedi are keepers of the peace and not soldiers. And yet he wholeheartedly becomes a general and joins in the war with the rest of the Jedi. He upholds the rules of the Jedi, but decides to override those rules when he chose to execute Palpatine rather than arrest him.

All this goes to show that Windu’s death wasn’t just the death of a cool character. It was symbolic of the death of the Jedi order. They had been blind to the darkness in Palpatine. And just like Anakin was the overlooked wild card that led to Windu’s demise, he was also the wild card that led to the demise of the Jedi. How much more symbolic can you get? Anakin cuts off his hand and then Palpatine delivers the death blow. He literally falls out a window, a metaphor for the inevitable fall of the Jedi.

Yeah, Mace is a badass with a purple lightsaber, but his survival would be a big kick in the balls to the symbolism that the prequel movies established. Not to mention that the more deaths Star Wars retcons, the stupider it’s gonna get. Bringing back Darth Maul was great and fleshed out an underdeveloped character. The same will hopefully happen for Boba Fett. But if they keep this up it’s gonna get ridiculous. Both those instances just took characters who were plot devices and gave them depth. But Windu was already a character with depth. What’s left for Windu to accomplish? He served his thematic purpose in the story. And bringing him back at the expense of undoing that theme isn’t worth it.


r/MawInstallation • • May 05 '16

The Empire was Always Doomed: The Logistics of Galactic-scale Counterinsurgency

3.7k Upvotes

A persistent issue with the late, lamented Legends canon was that its assertions of the vast scale of Star Wars civilisation rarely meshed well with what we see in the films. In no area was this more clear than in the conflict between Expanded Universe descriptions of the Imperial Military and what was seen in the Original Trilogy. According to the Imperial Sourcebook, the Empire's fleet of Imperial-class Star Destroyers peaked at over 25,000 vessels. Nor even was this the Galactic Empire's most numerous warship, for it possessed millions more smaller ships and support vessels. A fleet for a single sector was said to consist of 24 Star Destroyers and 1,600 smaller warships. Combine this with the well-established figure of the galaxy having 1,024 regional sectors, and we get an Imperial Navy that was 1,638,400 ships strong.

How was the Rebel Alliance supposed to combat this? More to the point, how are we supposed to reconcile this with what we see onscreen? Vader's task force in The Empire Strikes Back, supposedly the main force for hunting down the Rebel base, is only six ships strong. The Imperial fleet at Endor, supposedly the decisive battle of the Galactic Civil War, is only about thirty Star Destroyers in size, when if the Legends figures are correct, Admiral Piett could have sacrificed a Star Destroyer ramming each of Ackbar's ships and still not have appreciably dented the Navy's size.

Perhaps though, a solution can be found when we consider the sheer size of space. Let us keep in mind the words of Douglas Adams:

Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space.

According to Attack of the Clones: Incredible Cross Sections, Naboo's sector, the Chommell sector, contained thirty-six worlds that were sufficiently populated to merit representation in the Galactic Republic, but also contained 40,000 settled dependencies, and it was considered a sparsely-settled sector.

Think on this for a moment: assuming the Chommell sector's fleet was at full strength, this would mean that each ship, from the largest Star Destroyer to the tiniest patrol boat, would be responsible for policing twenty-four worlds. They could not possibly cover each world all at once: when a ship leaves a system to go to the next one on its patrol route, that system is open to Rebel attack. Sure, they could leave behind a starfighter squadron and an Army garrison, but without a rapid reaction force nearby, they're effectively leaving those guys behind for the Rebels to defeat in detail by bringing overwhelming force to bear on that single system. Furthermore, the Chommell sector had an additional 300,000,000 barren, unsettled stars. Any one of those stars could support a small Rebel base in its debris belt ready to strike out across the whole sector, and it would be utterly beyond the sector group's capacity to scout them all.

We see then, that the Imperial Navy faced a terrible strategic conundrum: to reinforce one system only opened another to Rebel attack. It was therefore forced to choose its garrisons. The key worlds of a sector - the capital, the major manufacturing worlds - were probably great concentrations of fleet power, with squadron after squadron of Star Destroyers sitting proudly in orbit. But they were paper tigers, for they could not move without uncovering the system, and to release too many to hunt down the local Rebels would invite the nightmare scenario of the Alliance Fleet arriving in force to destroy what remained. Defeat above a sector capital world to the Rebel fleet would be a shattering blow to Imperial prestige, so for the most part the Star Destroyers just sat in orbit, while the sector group's lighter forces ran themselves ragged in search-and-destroy missions, desperate attempts to chase down the Rebels, who could always choose their battles, strike those systems that were left unguarded, or raid those convoys that had to be sent unescorted. The Chommell sector was difficult enough to police, and this was in the Mid Rim, a relatively-civilized, well-mapped part of the galaxy. Consider how difficult policing the Outer Rim sectors would be, where government authority is basically theoretical beyond the major trade routes.

This is why we see so few Imperial ships in the films. The mere threat of the Alliance Fleet scoring a victory when they were deployed elsewhere kept them rooted to the major systems. Only a handful could ever be spared at one time. In this way, the Empire was always doomed. It effectively had to concede control of the space outside the major systems to the Alliance. Any number of modern counterinsurgency operations will confirm the impossibility of victory in such a situation: during the Soviet War in Afghanistan, the Soviet Army was effectively bottled up in the cities by the Mujahideen, such that just sending troops between two towns required massive planning, escort, and clearance operations, all of which came at appalling cost in blood and treasure. Even dictatorships cannot sustain such losses for long. Oh, the Empire managed to hang on for a while by resorting to terror: the Death Stars were designed to present the threat of retribution so terrifying that no planet would ever consider giving the Rebels safe harbour, but they were destroyed, and when Palpatine died at Endor, the Empire lost heart. It could no longer afford such costly search-and-destroy missions, not with its Emperor dead and its already-shaky legitimacy under full attack by the New Republic. So it retreated. It abandoned the Outer Rim but for a few key worlds at hyperspace junctions, and as it did that, local commanders and forces thought only of the safety of their homes and refused to follow the Empire back to the Core. Some declared themselves warlords, others declared neutrality, and some threw their lot in with the New Republic and only increased its forces.

Palpatine's death at Endor killed the Empire, but it was already dying, the victim of an internal rot. It was unwilling to reform but was unable to coerce. It tried to terrorise the galaxy into submission, but its mighty fleets were mere window dressing and its greatest terror weapons mere targets. Had it still had Palpatine's single-minded tyranny to guide it, the Empire might have survived a few more decades, but its end was always coming.


r/MawInstallation • • Jan 03 '21

They should have kept this deleted scene from AOTC in!

3.7k Upvotes

For those who don’t know, there is this deleted scene from the Geonosian arena fight, where Ki Adi Mundi and Plo Koon lead a team of Jedi aboard the droid control ship to try and deactivate the droids in the arena. They do this, but soon realise that the droids can now operate independent of the main control frame. This scene should have been kept in for a multitude of reasons:

  1. It shows the Jedi had an actual plan and didn’t arrogantly run in to the arena thinking they could take on thousands of battle droids

  2. It shows how Mundi and Plo Koon were captured

  3. It creates continuity with TPM - it shows the Jedi are using past knowledge to win their current battles

  4. it shows that the confederacy has improved and removed one of their glaring weaknesses in their army

  5. makes us care more about Ki Adi Mundi, who basically is the Council’s third in command behind Mace and Yoda

Thoughts?


r/MawInstallation • • Jun 01 '21

Count Dooku brandishing a red lightsaber on Geonosis during Attack of the Clones should/could have been a much more dramatic moment of revelation.

3.5k Upvotes

For the entire movie, we’re told that even though Count Dooku was indeed a former Jedi Master, nowadays he’s simply a political figurehead. Mace Windu even goes so far as to say that being a murderer is not in Dooku’s character.

In a deleted scene for Episode 2, Obi-Wan and Jocasta Nu reflect on a statue of Dooku’s face that was made to commemorate the Lost Twenty. Jocasta comes off as mournful that Dooku left but neither of them give any indication that they’re worried about who/where he is now, so clearly, they don’t suspect anything has gone wrong with him.

We know from The Clone Wars TV show that it takes years before the Jedi ever associate the name that Jango gave to Obi-Wan (“Tyranus”) with Dooku, and given Obi-Wan’s surprise when that’s finally revealed, it’s clear that during Episode 2, the Jedi hadn’t even begun to think that Tyranus might have been Dooku.

Furthermore, when Dooku holds Obi-Wan captive, Dooku pleads with Obi-Wan to join him so that they could “destroy the Sith”.

Now, whether or not that was Dooku’s actual intention when he said that to Obi-Wan is irrelevant, because the point is:

From Obi-Wan’s perspective, Dooku can’t possibly be a Sith. The story that he just gave him about how Darth Sidious betrayed the Trade Federation 10 years ago and then the Federation came to Dooku for help frames the story as though Dooku is squarely against the Sith.

Obi-Wan does refer to Dooku as a “traitor”, in that same scene, but I think it’s clear that what he’s referring to is the fact that Dooku is a traitor to the Republic, since Obi-Wan witnessed Dooku making deals with the Separatist Council to build up an army that would challenge the Republic, essentially declaring war.

So, this means that during the Battle of Geonosis, the Jedi are not automatically assuming that Dooku is a Sith Lord. Why would they? If it weren’t for the fact that he actually was a Sith Lord, all the evidence presented above^ seems to indicate that at most, Dooku is a former Jedi who’s willing to wage war against the Republic, but not for the sake of the Dark Side or for the sake of the Sith, but rather for the sake of his political ideals and his wish for an alternative form of government.

This makes Dooku moderately less of a severe threat to the Order itself, though still a threat nonetheless that needs to be apprehended.

But then we come to the duel between Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Dooku in his secret hangar on Geonosis.

Dooku opens up the conflict by blasting Anakin with Force Lightning, a definitively Sith technique, which should have immediately come as a surprise to at least Obi-Wan, in my opinion.

But if that wasn’t enough, in the very next moment, he draws a red lightsaber from his belt. But what is Obi-Wan’s reaction? Practically nothing, the two just immediately start fighting.

I feel like this moment could have been a lot more dramatic of a reveal. That Dooku has actually been a Sith Lord this whole time! I mean yeah it’s not the biggest twist, but in terms of in-universe context, that should have been a big moment.

Here’s how I have reimagined the encounter to really drive the point home:

———

Anakin and Obi-Wan rush into the hangar to stop Dooku. They have their lightsaber hilts in their hands but they’ve not yet activated them.

They intend to stop Dooku by force, if necessary, but because Dooku is a Jedi Exile, they are uncertain if he still has a lightsaber or not. Meaning, it’s possible that he will come quietly, if he is unarmed.

Anakin, blinded by his anger over Padme falling out of the gunship earlier, is impatient and wants the capture of Dooku to be over and done with already so he can get back to Padme and make sure she’s alright. Thus, he rushes forward foolishly, activating his lightsaber.

Dooku extends a hand calmly, not yet using Force Lightning, but instead calling on the Force to simply shove Anakin forcefully into the nearby wall, dazing him for a time.

Dooku has now proven that he still holds sway over the Force, and is willing to use it in self-defense, but he hasn’t yet shown a lightsaber.

More importantly, he has not yet displayed that he knows the ways of the Dark Side.

Obi-Wan steels himself in case Dooku directs a Force attack towards him, but he still keeps his lightsaber deactivated, speaking to Dooku and trying to negotiate him into surrendering peacefully.

Dooku tells Obi-Wan that surrender is not possible, and then, the camera focuses on a surprise reveal— Tucked within the folds of his cape lies a distinctively curved lightsaber hilt! He draws it, and a red blade ignites, the camera lingering on the spectacle for a few moments. Dooku has just revealed that he is in fact a Sith Lord! A wicked grin starts to grow on his face, and his eyes are slowly turning a light shade of yellow.

Obi-Wan allows a look of surprise to flash across his face, but it doesn’t stop him in his tracks completely— After all, this wouldn’t be the first time he’s faced a Sith.

So instinctively, Obi-Wan ignites his own weapon and the two combatants clash, Obi-Wan now making it a point to accuse Dooku of being a traitor during the fight, asking him questions such as, “How could you turn your back on the Jedi?”, or, “Don’t you see that Sidious has corrupted you?”

The two fight almost to a stalemate, Obi-Wan’s bladework proving to be too defensive for Dooku to penetrate.

So in response, Dooku finally unleashes Sith Lightning for the first time in this whole encounter, surprising Obi-Wan, who’s never faced such a powerful Dark Side technique before. Not knowing he could block it with the blade of his lightsaber, he’s hit hard by the attack and is knocked on his back.

From here, the fight continues as it did in the movie, Obi-Wan tossing a recovered Anakin his lightsaber, so on and so forth.

And the fight with Yoda remains the same, but now giving more weight to the fact that Yoda can block lightning with his hands, demonstrating how much more of a Jedi Master Yoda is compared to Obi-Wan at this point in time, who’s still young, and wasn’t prepared to face such advanced Force techniques in his first encounter with Dooku.

Yoda would be less surprised at Dooku’s red blade than Obi-Wan was, because of the opening exchange Dooku and Yoda have when he shows up: “Powerful you have become Dooku... the Dark Side, I sense in you.”

This would imply that Dooku was masking his Dark aura, up until the moment he revealed that he was a Sith Lord to Obi-Wan, further explaining Obi-Wan’s own shock. And this would give further indication to the audience, that it’s indeed possible for any Sith to potentially mask their presence in the Force... foreshadowing Palpatine’s own secret identity.


r/MawInstallation • • May 18 '25

Man, Galen Erso went all-out on the Death Star

3.4k Upvotes

Galen Erso was really passive-aggressively doing absolutely, absolutely everything he could, to make the Death Star as dangerous to the Empire as he could. No guardrails? Check. Giant pits in random places? Check. Absolute ant's nest of corridors so Stormtroopers had to follow mouse droids to not get lost? Check.

Slow door openings so that hurrying stormptroopers get bonked on the head? You betcha!

Just saying, if the Rebels hadn't fired those proton torpedoes up the ol' tailpipe, what other lunatic design "features" would have popped up?

The reactor flaw was his big present to the alliance, but i'm telling you, he was absolutely loading the Death Star with enough health and safety violations to give Dolores from HR a migraine!


r/MawInstallation • • May 15 '25

[CANON] Andor puts Tarkin’s decision to stay on the Death Star into focus

3.1k Upvotes

For the longest time, we have interpreted Tarkin’s decision to stay on board the Death Star even when he was informed that the rebels were deliberately targeting a vulnerability as a sign of blind confidence. But as the fates of Dedra Meera and Major Partagaz show, mistakes are punished severely. There’s always someone around to scapegoat you, and the Emperor feeds off of competition among his underlings.

Tarkin poured all his professional energies into the Death Star. Its existence personified his ideology—rule by fear alone, no democratic pretext needed. Its destruction not only cost the Empire an expensive asset but it undermined Tarkin’s—and the Empire’s—political philosophy as well.

Tarkin staked his entire reputation on the invincibility of the Death Star. If Tarkin had fled the battle station and learned of its destruction from the safety of his shuttle he probably would have committed seppuku Partagaz style. Blind confidence was the only option for him, professionally.


r/MawInstallation • • Oct 02 '20

Is Obi-Wan an alcoholic?

3.1k Upvotes

At every opportunity, even in urgent situations. When he and Anakin chase Zam into a bar in EPII, what does he do? Does a shot. Not even Senatoral assination attempts can stop the flow of booze. What does he do when he visits Dex? Gets some Jawa Juice. Keep in mind, this is like in the early morning, Obi-Wan has long since replaced caffeine with some good ol' ethanol. Training Anakin was too much stress for the old Stewjonian, and the bottle was the only solution. And that's just in one movie.

In The Clone Wars, Obi-Wan is constantly drinking. I have a pet theory that in "Dooku Captured", he and Anakin got pissed wasted and blacked out, but they don't want to admit it, so they both pretend they were drugged. Whenever he's in a political meeting, he always has a Martini/wine glass in hand (I especially noticed this in Season 3). Remember in Labyrinth of Evil when he and Anakin go bar hopping? That's just every Friday night for him. In ANH, how does he know the location of the Most Eisly Cantina? Because he's a regular, there to drink away his memories of Anakin and Satine. That's how he aged so much in 19 years.


r/MawInstallation • • Jan 06 '21

Is Bo-Katan a horrible person?

2.8k Upvotes

I have actually convinced my grandma to watch the Clone Wars and the prequel movies recently. She came to the conclusion Bo-Katan is a bad woman and when I asked why, I wasn't sure how to really refute it:

  1. The act of participating in enslaving and massacring a village of innocents for practically no reason than to demonstrate you can because you're strong is horrifying and downright evil

  2. Joining a psychopathic terrorist that planned to overthrow and publicly execute her own sister and has already tried to murder her several times. Even if its to stir nationalistic agendas that might fit Bo's vision for Mandalore better, that's still pretty awful.

  3. Not serving the man (Maul) that honored the very traditions she joined a psychopath for because of literal racism, making her an insane hypocrite. She then starts a civil war that tears apart Mandalore. If there are any doubts to the reasons she didn't join with Maul, she first and foremost called to the fact he's a Zabrak. Also if she genuinely loved Pre Viszla that much over his ideals to be so upset with his death in fair combat (which he accepted gracefully), I think that does say something about her considering what kind of man Viszla is. He's probably almost as evil as Maul but not ambitious. There is no moral reason here.

  4. Claiming she knows the pain of some individuals like Ahsoka and Obi-Wan because she lost her sister. That is absolutely rich considering everything. It's difficult to tell if she's sincere or feigning humanity to gain manpower to help in overthrowing Maul. Either way not a good outlook.

In Rebels, she's mellowed down a lot but after being ousted by the Empire in the Purge, she's back to being a racist hypocrite that looks down on others and regresses into barbaric traditions seeing how she won't accept the Darksaber without a fight compared to how she agreed to take it from Sabine peacefully.

Overall, I don't see anything good about this character and I can't refute it in any way. It's difficult to call her evil now but she still seems awful as a person.


r/MawInstallation • • Jun 03 '21

Why so Many Crew on a Star Destroyer? Paperwork.

2.7k Upvotes

The lore surrounding Star Destroyers has all kinds of issues. My conundrum for today is the crew. Why so many? What do they all do every day? What would that many stormtroopers even be good for?

The crew of an ISD is usually listed as roughly 28,000 enlisted, 9,000 officers, and 9,700 Stormtroopers. What do you get with 50k people?

A good point of comparison is contemporary-ish navies. A single Star Destroyer fills multiple roles so it we many have to mix, match, and multiply.

A Nimitz-class aircraft carrier has a naval crew of 3,500 and an air wing crew of 2,500.

Those 2,500 air crew cover roughly 90-100 craft and, depending on estimates, Star Destroyers have 72 TIEs and as many shuttles and support craft. So many take 150% of a Nimitz and you’ve covered the TIE side of things.

An Iowa-class battleship in WW2 had 150 officers and 2,600 enlisted. An Iowa brought three triple turrets of some of the largest guns ever put to sea. The Iowa class would be repurposed for a few roles over the decades but the essence of a battleship is to take the biggest gun feasible and move it in range of an enemy.

How many ‘big guns’ of an Iowa is equivalent to the ‘big guns’ of an ISD? Glad you asked because we’re going off course for a few minutes.

A single turbo laser is probably not a good equivalent to a 16” gun. Having more than 9 or 12 of the “big guns” like 14-inch or larger wasn’t feasible for a variety of reasons. The technical problems likely could have been solved but aircraft and missile technology put the focus in other directions. The WW2 theming in Star Wars, since it’s the last time navies made a big deal out of big guns, is possibly why we talk about turbo lasers and not hyper-speed Exocet-type space missiles. But that’s a digression within a digression.

The trouble in comparing turbolasers to naval guns is that there is little differentiation between one turbolaser and another but naval guns are constantly divided up. The Iowa has 16 inch guns. An Arleigh Burke class destroyer has a single 5 inch gun with a bunch of missiles etc. An ISD-II has 60 turbolasers and another 60 ion cannons. A Raider-class corvette, which is nearly the same length as a contemporary destroyer and has some overlapping functions, has four twin ‘light’ turbolasers. As contemporary naval vessels have moved away from traditional gun fights they’ve gotten harder and harder to compare to Star Wars. Sim is ilarly, fighters have changed significantly and watching a modern pilot in a dog fight (do we even still have those?) or a guy in an air conditioned tent flying a drone wouldn’t stir the same feelings as Luke screaming down the Death Star Trench with Vader on his tail.

All this is to argue that an accurate equivalent is nearly impossible and I present you with my total crapshoot equivalent: an Iowa has three of the biggest turrets available. An ISD has 8 of the biggest turrets available. So an Iowa is 3/8 of an ISD for crew comparison concerns.

Apart from the fighters and guns, an ISD also had a whole pile of troopers, which is why we’re all actually reading this. How much does it take to support troopers?

This brings us to the Wasp-class multipurpose amphibious assault ship. If you are in an exotic locale and marines are knocking on your door then it’s quite likely a Wasp brought them there. A Wasp can transport and sustain an embarked complement of 1,700 marines and needs 1,100 crew to do so.

So to bring that all together for an ISD-II...

The flight complement is 1 and 1/2 Nimitz Carriers (3,750 ship crew and 5,250 air crew) The gun armament is 2 and 2/3 Iowa Battleships (7,300 crew) And the embarked stormtroopers are 5 and 3/4 Wasp assault ships. (9,700 Stormtroopers and 6,300 ship crew)

That all gets us to 22,600 crew (apart from our Stormtroopers). We’re only half way there! If the level of labour and automation are equivalent to contemporary naval ships then there are roughly 15,000 people unaccounted for. Since the Hyperdrive isn’t powered by 15,000 exercise bikes there is a gap here to be addressed.

There are three questions at this point: What are 15,000 random people doing? Why is the officer ratio 1:4 rather than 1:15 in other navies? And since the stormtroopers and stormtrooper adjacent crew is 16,000 people, why is almost exactly a third of the complement just land forces?

The detail that unlocks all of these questions is that a Star Destroyer isn’t really a front line warship. It’s an oversized troop ship meant to put down local insurgencies. It has too few fighters and, honestly, too few guns for it’s size because it’s just an obnoxiously over powered troop transport. Not even that, it’s a flying administration office.

There are far more planets and problems than Star Destroyers so they’re always showing up once a planet is burning hot enough to have made it to the top of the priority list. By that point an insurgency has probably been digging in and expecting them for weeks. An over-sized trooper complement may well be just the appropriate size of response when you arrive to a hot spot three weeks late. You’re not dousing a few flames, it’s one forest fire and then the next.

If they arrived promptly they could likely solve a problem before it gets out of hand but since they have an endless list of problems, the Star Destroyer always arrives late enough that there’s no option but to break everything, root it all out, get things slightly rolling in the right direction, and then off to the next world to repeat.

All the extra crew? Teams to rebuild local bureaucracy and government. Engineers to start the repairs of infrastructure. Gaggles of officers for local intelligence, interpreters of all types, and the types of detail-heavy work involved in counter-insurgency. Imagine the current Afghanistan war but needing to get and out within three weeks. Completely bombard the entire place with turbolasers, troops, credits, teachers, whatever, anything, everything. Achieve compliance and get on your way. Even the harshest regimes keep a carrot beside the stick.

Trying to shatter and rebuild a nation simultaneously and on a prompt schedule. The Empire isn’t going around in a goodwill tour but they want to leave behind some propaganda and get the rebuilding process underway enough that resources will resume flowing shortly. From a strictly utilitarian, imperialist, exploitative viewpoint, it makes sense for a Star Destroyer to have massive repair teams to get resource infrastructure and defensive installations functional again before they leave.

In that light, your typical Star Destroyer is a lot more like an asshole-edition Starship Enterprise than a slick warship and the average captain is probably a Thrawn wannabe stuck on Picard duty. They’d have an endless list of things currently-on-fire and things potentially-on-fire and just roll from one crisis to the next. That also might be why they seem incompetent at times: most have only ever done coast guard duty and the equivalent of paperwork in space. It’s a floating office building full of bureaucrats working at empire-management and all the fighters, guns, and troopers are just empire-management resources.


r/MawInstallation • • May 25 '21

The real reason Uncle Owen wouldn’t let Luke leave

2.6k Upvotes

Maybe this is obvious, but for some reason I only recently caught the fact that Luke wanted to go to the imperial academy which would have placed him right into the hands of the empire. Obi Wan absolutely would not have allowed this to happen, and I’m sure Owen and Beru also knew that they needed to keep Luke away from the empire at all costs even if they didn’t know the full story or trust Obi Wan much.

With that in mind, I now think that the reason Owen insists on Luke staying on another season isn’t really because they need him for the harvest - it’s because Owen is putting off having a difficult conversation for as long as he possibly can. Notice that when Beru defends Luke, she doesn’t say anything about whether they actually need him for the harvest (since that’s not actually the issue at hand) and Owen says that he will make it up to Luke next year, not that he’ll let him go to the academy next year.

This makes Owen a much more sympathetic character in my opinion. He’s not holding Luke back for selfish reasons - he just wants to protect Luke from a painful truth.


r/MawInstallation • • Jan 14 '21

Cody shouldn't turn "good" in the Bad Batch

2.5k Upvotes

There's been a lot of posts on here about how Star Wars brings too many characters back to life. I think another overused trope is the villain redemption arc. It was good for Darth Vader, but now we have Agent Kallus and Kylo Ren as primary villains who eventually switch sides, and a host of secondary characters who defect from the bad guys (Finn, Jannah, Wedge, Mayfeld) along with bad guys who end up helping our protagonists (Commander Grey in the Kanan comics, General Hux, Boba Fett).

Commander Cody is the first clone who executes Order 66 on screen, and he's supposed to symbolize the tragedy of the clones, controlled by genetic engineering (and later mind control chips) to mindlessly serve an evil cause. Every single clone who goes against his programming and resists Order 66 weakens this narrative. It's already kind of a joke right now, with Fives, Rex, Wolffe, Gregor, Grey, and now the Bad Batch themselves turning against the Empire. A Cody redemption arc would strip so much meaning from the poignant scene in RoTS when he becomes the first clone to execute Order 66. So I think he should stay loyal to the Empire in the Bad Batch.


r/MawInstallation • • May 27 '21

Bo Katan has no right to Mandalore.

2.3k Upvotes

This discussion has been going on for a while on here, but Star Wars Explained made a video about it today and I wanted to share my opinion.

Bo Katan is a villain. She has not been redeemed at all at this point.

I think the real world ethics should apply in serialized storytelling, because there is more space for development then in the movies.

Even then Vader died to redeem himself, he didn't just take over the empire and tell everyone he was good now. But also I don't think she is even on the first step to redemption.

Everything is her fault.

She threw away her privilege and betrayed her family to join a racist, fascist, violent terrorist group. She brought a civil war to Mandalore and overthrew a pacifistic government for an ethno fascist one.

She then betrayed that faction when a non human came to power to start her own faction. Against Vizla's wishes. She did not leave because of Satine, she left because she did not think Maul had the right to rule, even though he had.

Then she brought a second civil war and the empire to Mandalore, by going against her sisters wish for neutrality and bringing an army to defeat Maul. When the Republic turned into the Empire she betrayed them again and started a rebellion, with the sole purpose to get power. She did not fight for freedom for the Mandalorian Civilians who loved Satine. Those people don't give a damn about the darksaber. She united extremists for a coup.

Then the Empire committed a genocide as retaliation for her actions.

She brought three wars to Mandalore and still lost. And still feels entitled to the throne and is willing to do it again. She is still very conservative about her views on true Mandalorians, as she is a dick to Fett.

She is a straight up villain in my book and I hope the story treats her this way.

There is no happy end anymore for Mandalore. The good guys on this planet are dead. Those where the people who did not wear armour.

All we got now is a bunch of far right terrorists who want to reclaim the home they helped destroy from the empire.


r/MawInstallation • • Jan 04 '21

Why the Empire HAD to phase out Clone Wars equipment: the ergonomics nightmare of a Clone Army

2.3k Upvotes

The Empire's almost total scrapping of Clone Wars equipment is often discussed, and is often complained about. Much of Imperial equipment is considered inferior to it's clone wars counterparts - with hindsight the Venator is a much more effective tool against the fighter-based rebels (though the turbolaser juggernaut that is the ISD would've ended the clone wars in months), and the DC-15 is far superior to the jam-magnet that was the E-10 and the wildly inaccurate E-11. It is often believed that the Empire made a foolish mistake in switching out their equipment regardless of the quality of the replacement, and they'd have been better off to sticking with the stuff they already had. However, there is one key problem with every single piece of Clone Wars equipment that is almost always overlooked: Ergonomics.

IRL everything from toasters to door handles is ergonomically designed for 95% of people to use as comfortably and efficiently as possible and it's reasonable to assume this applies to the star wars universe; especially designs for human use in a human-dominated military force. This does not apply to equipment from the Clone Wars for one key reason - almost every single user has exactly the same body type from finger length to the distance between the eyes. This means that every single piece of clone wars equipment was perfectly designed for the body of Jango Fett and no-one else. The chairs on the Venator's bridge would have perfect lumbar support for the clones, buttons and screens would be in ideal locations to minimise strain injury and the DC-15 would have its grip moulded perfectly to Jango Fett's hands. The Empire, with it's rapid military expansion, had no choice but to abandon the clones due to a host of economic, military, and political reasons - and the sheer amount of parts requiring ergonomic redesign and refit in every piece of clone wars equipment would end up making it easier to design and manufacture entirely different replacements than perform a complete refit.

In short, the Galactic Empire had no choice but to totally replace their preexisting Clone Wars equipment with new designs because the Clone Wars equipment literally wasn't designed for normal human use


r/MawInstallation • • Nov 23 '20

Star Wars has given up on stormtroopers

2.2k Upvotes

1977: “And these blast points, too accurate for Sand People. Only Imperial stormtroopers are so precise.”

2020: “And they couldn’t hit the side of a bantha.”

In the original Star Wars, stormtroopers were treated as a very serious threat. The opening scene shows them easily defeat the Rebels on the Tantive IV, Obi-Wan speaks highly of their precision, and the characters always try to hide and escape from stormtroopers instead of defeat them. It was clear that stormtroopers were the elite backbone of the Empire.

They do miss the main characters, but as Princess Leia stated, “They let us go, it’s the only explanation for the ease of our escape.” The Empire didn’t want to kill them, they wanted to track them back to the Rebel base. (We also see C-3PO and R2-D2 casually walk past stormtrooper fire, but the stormtroopers were never aiming for them. If anything that’s a point in favor of their accuracy.)

In The Empire Strikes Back stormtroopers are still treated very seriously. They easily defeat the Rebels on Hoth, and the heroes narrowly escape from Hoth and later Bespin. The goal was always to escape from the stormtroopers, they were never under any delusions that they could defeat them in battle. It’s not until Return of the Jedi that stormtroopers are defeated in battle, and only through guerrilla tactics.

The idea that a few heroes could just shoot their way through dozens of stormtroopers without any casualties was ridiculous, until video game characters like Kyle Katarn started doing it. Keep in mind that Kyle was very strong in the Force, and also that those games are no longer considered canon.

When Disney purchased Lucasfilm and started making new content, they could have made stormtroopers just as intimidating as they were in 1977, but instead they’ve made them into a joke. In Rogue One, The Mandalorian, and especially Rebels, we see stormtroopers treated like a joke. A few characters can easily take out dozens of stormtroopers with minimal or even zero casualties.

If A New Hope were made like some of the new shows, there would be no reason for Luke, Leia, Han, and Chewbacca to hide in the trash compactor, or even try to escape at all. How about this, using Disney logic, Obi-Wan can keep Vader busy while the other characters take out every single stormtrooper on the Death Star with zero casualties. Really, why would they keep running and hiding from such useless enemies?

Also, why was Lando so afraid of Vader leaving a garrison on Bespin? If stormtroopers are this incompetent then who cares? I was always under the impression that the Rebels were up against overwhelming odds, but maybe not. In Season 4 of Rebels, the entire garrison on Lothal is easily defeated by a few people, who only suffer one casualty. Their only real obstacle was Thrawn, but then space whales or whatever. And then the Empire just left Lothal alone. If it’s that easy to beat the Empire, then I’m shocked that the Rebels took 23 years to get the upper hand.

In Chapter 11 of The Mandalorian, a character explicitly contradicts the quote from Obi-Wan by saying that stormtroopers “couldn’t hit the side of a bantha”. So, that’s it, after 43 years Star Wars has just completely given up on stormtroopers. Instead of rationalizing why stormtroopers miss, we now have to rationalize why Obi-Wan was so wrong. Imperial propaganda got to him? Or maybe he just meant that they were more accurate than Sand People, which makes sense considering that he described blasters as clumsy and random. Personally, I would much rather have villains who pose a threat.


r/MawInstallation • • Dec 05 '20

[Spoilers] Finally the endless argument of Jango Fett's inheritance is put to rest Spoiler

2.1k Upvotes

I always hated the whole "Jango Fett is not a Mandalorian" position. Personally, I felt that wiping Jango Fett of his Mandalorian status always felt disrespectful to the character's EU legacy, and I was so glad they finally canonized not only his Mandalorian inheritance, but the fact that he fought in the Mandalorian Civil War! (No confirmation on his Mand'alor status yet, but a man can hope).

I also felt that this landed Boba Fett's status in a really nice middle ground for people who felt he should just be a bounty hunter and those who still saw him as the OG Mandalorian. While not a Mandalorian in perhaps Din's sense, what's more Mandalorian then one raised by and taught as a Mando?

All in all, really happy with how they handled Boba Fett and Jango's legacy in this episode. Now is a great time for anyone to read up Jango Fett: Open Seasons if they want more of that sweet, sweet Mandolorian bloodshed.


r/MawInstallation • • May 21 '25

[CANON] I’m actually okay with a decent amount of Jedi surviving Order 66.

2.1k Upvotes

It’s a popular idea that the amount of Jedi that survived order 66 is way too big and the group of Jedi is big enough for people to think that Order 66 wasn’t successful.

I’m not trying to make the points that have been made already where people say “Palpatine wanted power over the senate so it was a success” or “200 out of 20,000” is 1%. But in Disney canon it works better that some Jedi survived Order 66 because of the existence of the inquisitors.

In the 19 year span between ROTS and ANH there was at least a dozen inquisitors out in the galaxy killing Jedi, still basically continuing Order 66. Even if let’s say around 150 Jedi survived the initial purge, with the idea of the Inquisitors by the time the Battle of Yavin roles around it fits in the canon of the Movies that they were eventually killed off by a brother or sister in that time span.


r/MawInstallation • • Jan 09 '21

I.... Don't think Mace Windu should come back..

2.1k Upvotes

I know this will generate debate.. but seeing all this hype, nay, ASSURANCE.. that Windu is returning in some future series leaves me with.. conflicting feelings. I have to know if ANYBODY shares my feelings about this..

I love Mace Windu. I really do. I want him to stay dead.

Windu is the living representation of everything corrupt and blind in the Jedi Order by the end of the Clone War. His death has a lot of meaning, as he was almost the face of the old order even more than Yoda was. His elimination meant a change in the galaxy.

He was also an unbelievably powerful Jedi - and a hard one to excuse not making a SINGLE MOVE against the Empire this ENTIRE time. He also doesn't seem like the type to exist in a quiet peaceful exile due to his warrior nature. And him being in contact with Obi Wan seems to... I dunno... lessen Obi Wan's isolation as now he has someone from the old world to talk to.

But most importantly - what would his return be for? Because he HAS to die to preserve the timeline - why bring him on just to kill him again? So Boba can have his revenge? He seems to be over it, honestly. And Windu certainly never cared to pursue that rivalry. And I mean... all the conflict he created within Vader serves Vader better unresolved. The ongoing hate I think serves more power to a Sith than a resolved one. Besides.. technically.. Vader ALREADY killed Windu.

I dunno... I like Windu as much as the next guy, but this character truly seems built for the Clone Wars environment, and I have a really hard time imagining him living in a post-66 universe. But SO, SO many people seem to be hyping his return like it's a given... and I just... I dunno... it's a hard sell for me.

Some characters should stay dead no matter how much we like them.  Let's give Windu is much needed development in his own series, maybe. Bring Sam L back for his own 4 episode mini series during the Clone Wars. That would feel much more appropriate, in my opinion..


r/MawInstallation • • Nov 27 '20

(Mando S2 E5 spoilers) The Clone Wars is never finished Spoiler

2.0k Upvotes

I was prepared to have some feelings about this episode, but I was not prepared for the sheer sadness I felt.

Ahsoka is not the bubbly little girl we first met. She is a beast of a warrior, she is ruthless! And why shouldn't she be?

But what this episode really did that hurt was to remind me that while the clones are mostly dead, the Republic as it was is gone, the CIS is scrapped, that the Clone Wars is still a lingering thing.

The evil warlord lady Morgan might be evil and cruel, but like Ahsoka and Dinn, she lost everything because of the Clone Wars.

Dinn is the Mandalorian because of the war, while poor little Grogu went through who knows what because of Order 66.

And poor Ahsoka. Sure, it was amazing to see her fight, but remember, she is only so amazing at deflecting and dodging blaster fire because of her experience in the war.


r/MawInstallation • • Dec 28 '20

Of course the Empire had "baby shackles"...

1.9k Upvotes

...because they're not actually baby shackles.

The Empire would need them for any number of species who were resisting imperial rule. Off the top of my head kowakian monkey lizards, Kaminoans, and Geonosians all have itty bitty wrists even for adults.

On second thought the Empire wouldn't need them for the Geonosians :|


r/MawInstallation • • Jul 11 '21

Why the AT-AT was GREAT

1.9k Upvotes

I hear a lot of people talk about the issues with imperial vehicles and especially the big elephant of doom, the AT-AT. “Oh they were just meant to be scary” “oh the design is so bad” wrong!

First let’s consider its role: it was NOT meant to be a main line vehicle, as its speed and maneuvers weren’t exactly the fastest, however I’d argue it’s meant to be a breakthrough vehicle. Sort of a bunker buster, where you have static defenses that are too strong to be penetrated by regular forces. The AT AT can push through a kill zone, laying into defenses and keep going to drop its trooper compliment to clear out the area.

In this context alot of its design starts to make sense. Speed isn’t necessary when assaulting stationary spots, and it’s height is perfect for waltzing through minefields like nothing and taking out entrenched positions like their made out of tissue paper

In addition the AT AT is one of the most well armored and armed in the galaxy, there isn’t a whole lot on the ground that can take one out, and if you see several just run now. In fact in many battles just the sight of one of these guys can cause a route because of the sheer power of the thing.

So basically this thing excels in its intended role, it’s only when forced into alternate roles that it starts to falter. Did it have flaws? Of course, but I feel like it gets an overly bad rep by the community


r/MawInstallation • • Apr 27 '21

Not sure if this is the right place, but all I want is a Star Wars Drama that’s basically the Nuremberg Trials for former Imperial Officers.

1.9k Upvotes

I know Disney is afraid to touch politics in Star Wars but I really feel like this is a missing puzzle piece to the overall story.

The Empire wouldn’t just vanish, nor would they simply just go underground as suggested by The Mandalorian. There’d be a whole entire process of capturing and putting to trial the former officers of the Empire for their war crimes.

Something like this could also help us see just what the New Republic ends up being like. So far we haven’t really seen government at this scale since the prequels, and I’m dying to see more of it.

If something like this already exists please let me know! I’ve been dying to read/watch some Star Wars that’s a bit more grounded in reality/gritty.


r/MawInstallation • • Dec 27 '20

25,000 Star Destroyers was absolutely enough to "police" the galaxy

1.8k Upvotes

A common argument I've seen on this subreddit was that the Imperial Navy, despite its raw power, was inefficient or outright horrible at "policing" the galaxy, and used the Galactic Civil War as their prime example. I think these arguments are misinformed for the following reasons.

  1. The Imperial Navy had 25,000 Imperial-class Star Destroyers at its height. The galactic map was divided into 1,024 sectors with a few thousand inhabited star systems in each. That means the Empire could effectively place about 24 ISDs in each sector with about a dozen to spare for inter-sector operations. A single ISD can bring almost 100 starfighters/bombers and almost 10,000 soldiers to the field, which alone can probably beat the vast majority of Separatist holdouts/rebel cells/small crime syndicates in the galaxy, in addition to a turbolaser loadout that can literally destroy an entire unshielded city in minutes.

    1. The vast majority of inhabited planets/moons/asteroids in the galaxy were small-time colonies. A few hundred to a few thousand inhabitants in cities dedicated to a single industry such as mining, manufacturing, or farming. Each sector usually only had one or two planets that could really put up a fight; the Empire could pacify most other planets in the span of a few hours with a single Star Destroyer's worth of firepower and manpower.

  2. Besides the 25,000 ISDs, there were many other SD models in use by the Empire: the Victory-class, the Gladiator-class, the Interdictor-class, the Secutor-class, the Onager-class, and a few others. This is even more power, especially considering most of these ships are always accompanied by support capital ships such as Acclamator-class assault ships, Arquitens-class light cruisers, and Lancer-class frigates.

  3. The Empire lost because of the Rebel's luck. The Galactic Civil War was absolutely by no means a display of the Empire's power. In fact it was; it showed that the Empire was indomitable in that the Rebels had to use guerrilla tactics despite having the backing of some of the galaxy's wealthiest planets. The Rebels won because of the Empire's logistical incompetence when it came to the Death Stars: they effectively created a single heart of the Empire that, when destroyed, immediately set them in a downward spiral. Then they were foolish enough to make a second one. The Empire was so powerful, so indomitable, that only their own mistakes could've ever defeated them.

  4. It's been established that most Imperial citizens, at least on advanced worlds, enjoyed the peace brought by the new regime. The pirates, terrorists, criminals, and such didn't just decide to stop when the Empire came around; it was purely because of the Empire's military might that such peace and security could be brought about. This alone is pretty much proof that the Imperial Navy was doing its job, and doing it very good.

Had the Empire never made the Death Stars, possibly redirecting those resources to several thousand more ISDs, they not only would have never lost the Galactic Civil War but may as well have securely controlled the galaxy for millennia.


r/MawInstallation • • Jun 02 '25

I'll die on the hill that the "brain chip" retcon was one of the worst ideias of the franchise

1.8k Upvotes

I'm 32 years old and like many other millenials SW fans the year of 2005 was magical. We had both the release of ROTS in theaters and the OG Battlefront 2. Both of those cemented in our heads that the clones were just loyal to the Republic/Chancellor above all else, and that no amount of battlefield camaradarie would change that. These clones were literally bred to kill and follow orders.

And the 2005 Battlefront 2 campaign added an interesting layer to it all. Through a 501st trooper's journal we could analyze the thinking behind it all. Despite following Order 66 to the letter, the clones' thoughts were nuanced. They gladly were waiting to off Ki-Adi Mundi, as they viewed him as a typical pompous master, but were extremely conflicted about executing Aayla Secura, since she gained their respect on Felucia. But at the day orders are orders, and they were carried out.

But then TWC came out and for some context I didn't watch the whole show until like 2020, as I was really turned off by the first season (hated how catered to kids it was), and put if off in favor of having that other Clone Wars show written by the Samurai Jack creator as my head canon for a long time. Well, I inevitably ended up coming around to TCW after it matured throughout the seasons, falling in love with the Umbara arc and some notable others.

But the damn brain chip retcon, man. I still can't wrap my head around it. I don't if it's a mental block from being used to the original plot when I was a teen watching ROTS and playing Battlefront 2, Maybe it's that, but I can't shake the feeling that whenever Star Wars got too dark and gritty, George Lucas always was like: "Whoa, guys. Let's back that off a bit. Remember this is a kid's movie" and starts simplifying his work as to not alienate this target audience. This urks me because I'm such a big fan of "serious" Star Wars. For reference, KOTOR 2 is my favorite Star Wars media of all time, and Andor and Rogue One are my favorite of the more "recent" productions. All more serious and somber pieces. So I end up equating the original Clone arc to the more serious Star Wars and the brain chip retcon to the silly kid friendly Star Wars.

I'm curious as to what you guys think.


r/MawInstallation • • Jun 14 '21

Lando should be the supreme chancellor after TROS

1.7k Upvotes

Objectively, I suggest that Lando Calrissian should be the head of the New Republic after the events of TROS.

  1. He is a beloved war hero from both the battle of DSII, and the fight at Exegol (also the Battle of Tanaab, etc.). He has a long-standing respected pedigree.

  2. He was the person who united the universe-wide militia who directly took on the First/Final Order in the final fight. People would unite behind him.*

  3. He is an experienced administrator.

  4. He was a general in the Rebellion, which means he is capable of leading many others in complicated logistics.

  5. He has off-the-charts, god-tier charisma.

  6. He is a good person, and is known to do right by those he serves. (This is obvious, but relevant data, so I added it.)

  7. He would likely accept the charge out of loyalty to Leia and his friends of the OT.

Perhaps in a few years, he'd get bored or mired in a scandal (somewhat benign, but involving complicated business deals). But he could provide leadership and uniting stability in the very delicate first couple of years as the New Republic reorganizes.

Thus, Landonis Balthazar Calrissian would be the ideal choice to lead the New Republic, at least for the initial years of reorganization.

*Imagine if you were in some galactic hub in the midst of the anti-First Order foment of ROS, and you heard an APB, "This is Lando Calrissian, former General of the Rebellion and current member of the galactic Resistance. I am leading our final assault on the First Order and require any and all available ships to join me immediately." And you fly into battle behind the Millennium fucking Falcon, to ultimate victory. I honestly get chills thinking about it.