r/MawInstallation • • Jun 08 '23

[META] Hot take: “Somehow Palpatine returned” is not a bad line

3 Upvotes

I’ve heard many people say that “somehow Palpatine returned” is the worst line in all of Star Wars. They also do not elaborate on why they think it’s a bad line because it is generally accepted in the fandom that it was bad.

If they were to elaborate, they would probably say that it’s bad because the movie didn’t explain how Palpatine returned and just left it at “somehow”. In the context of the movie, it makes perfect sense that Poe would say that. Why would a Resistance pilot have any idea or be able to explain how a Dark Lord of the Sith was able to return from the dead after, as far as the galaxy is concerned, blowing up on the Death Star?

Not to mention, Dominic Monaghan’s character immediately gives an explanation for how Palpatine returned. Using all of the information we have from Mandalorian, Bad Batch, and the Rise of Skywalker novelization, we now know that Palpatine returned by using cloning technology to clone himself and transfer his essence from his original body to his clone body.

The movie literally explains all of this, just in more subtle ways. The movie begins by showing you the cloning technology being prepared on a planet that’s very clearly thriving with the dark side. Monaghan’s character says Palpatine returned with “dark science, cloning, secrets only the Sith knew”. And Palpatine’s entire plan in the movie is to transfer his essence from his clone body to either Ben or Rey.

It’s all laid out very clearly in the movie, but a majority of the fanbase loves to be intentionally ignorant of these things. “Somehow Palpatine returned” was never intended to be the only explanation.

EDIT: Some of you need to relax. I’m not saying Rise of Skywalker is the most well written piece of fiction ever made. Just that this particular line being said by this particular person is not as big of a deal as people make it out to be, and that they give you enough hints throughout the movie to explain how Palpatine returned.


r/MawInstallation • • Jan 01 '24

[CANON] Why do people hate the Holdo Maneuver so much?

0 Upvotes

The first movie established hyperspace was dangerous and you had to be extremely careful, later material showed it wasn’t faster than light travel but closer to wormholes in that it decreases the distance traveled (so no relativitistic stuff happening, not that Star Wars has ever considered relativity). All of this combined is all we need to believe that hyperspace collisions are very possible and extremely dangerous, but ramming is also difficult and not worth the risk if you have any other options.

If we’re going to be mad about how hyperspace is treated in the sequels, “Light Skipping” is so astronomically worse that I don’t understand why the Holdo Maneuver is the target of so much hate.


r/MawInstallation • • Aug 16 '21

Do you think Dave Filoni is good for Star Wars?

18 Upvotes

I always loved him as a person, because he is the type of guy I can have great conversations and go full on Geek mode. He understands you as a fan, because he is one himself and is from what I can tell a really genuine and cool dude.

That being said, he is also the type of guy I would constantly disagree with 90% of the time. He seems to have taken all the bad George Lucas could teach him. Things like:

- Introduce characters that you know fans will hate and eventually if you shove it down their throats enough they may or may not like/love the character

- If the fans are critical of what you are doing in this specific point, double down on it

- If something is too stupid/slapstick or childish excuse it for being made for children

- Thinks that children are dumb and have no taste and eat low quality stuff as long as it's flashy

I still had hope for him, despite Resistance and Rebels being Mediocre/low tier shows, but Bad Batch just made me realize I cannot enjoy his work.

Although I am not a big fan of The Clone Wars, it at least had more suspense and characters could die at any moment. There was at least some actual threat, despite his tendencies to make villains incompetent.

All project that he is involved with have a group of main characters that are nearly invincible for 90% of the time and enemies are simply pathetic. He also has an obsession for his own creations to not die no matter what and is overly attached to them.

A while ago I read this in a comment: "I think Filoni is a very good fan fiction writer for all the connotations that holds. I’m not really a fan. " which is something I 100% agree with.

Undoubtedly though he has his fans and I am curious if you guys think overall if he is good for the future of Star Wars


r/MawInstallation • • Oct 26 '21

[META] 'The Last Jedi' isn't a failure; it's about failure

256 Upvotes

While there are many things I love about The Last Jedi, what impressed me the most was the character work that Johnson did and how he developed each character not only separately but tied that character's development into others so that there was an overlapping theme carried throughout. And that theme was that failure is a lesson and all but one character learned from that lesson and every character but for that one was in a better place by the film's end. (One guess as to which character didn't figure out the lesson.)

Let's start with the much-maligned supposed non-existent character arc for Finn. In The Force Awakens, he learned how to care about another person (Rey) beyond his upbringing as a Stormtrooper. In TLJ, he saw beyond that. He saw the bigger picture and realized that it wasn’t just about saving the few people you care about (Rey and Poe), but it was about working to save the galaxy; it was about the goals of the Resistance. He found a resolve that wasn’t wrapped up in Rey but rather was about his own purpose. He truly would now be one of the leaders at the forefront of the Resistance (as Rose thought he was when she first met him) because of his experiences throughout the film. That is what his arc was about.

As for the (again), *supposedly* pointless entire Canto Bight, let's dive in. Firstly, it was about Finn joining the Resistance fully to become THE BIG DAMN HERO. It was about him deciding to fight for the Resistance instead of just him and Rey. TFA began with Finn fighting for himself only. It ended with Finn fighting for himself and Rey only. TLJ began with Finn fighting for himself and Rey only. TLJ ended with Finn fighting for the entire galaxy. That's fantastic development! And it wouldn't have happened without Canto Bight. As Yoda told Luke, 'failure is one of our greatest teachers.' The failure of Canto Bight and what ensued taught Finn where he belonged, who he truly was... who Rose thought he was when she first met him: he did become THE FINN, one of THE leaders of the Resistance.

That was a lot of development, and the beauty of Johnson's writing is that it wasn’t shoved in your face. It wasn’t presented in clunky, simple writing. It was nuanced, and it was written through his interactions with Rose, with Poe, with DJ, with Phasma, through his non-interaction with Rey, through his failures even… because he learned from them. Again it was as Yoda said: You learn from your failures as much as you do from your successes.

And the same was true for Poe. In the beginning of the film, he was the same as he was in TFA. He was a hothead, he disobeyed orders from the leader of the Resistance, and in doing so, he got most of their bombers killed because he had to take a risk and do things his way even though they were outgunned and outmanned. And it was a pointless victory. So what if they took out a dreadnought? The First Order has so many of them while the Resistance had a much more limited number of bombers and people and the cost of one dreadnought compared to what they lost was so very minuscule. And Poe simply did not look at the bigger picture. He messed up.

So he was demoted (rightfully so) and because he was demoted he lost his place in the inner circle of command and that is why he wasn’t let in on the plans that were underway because he had shown that he couldn't be trusted to follow orders. HE put himself in that position. Had he not done that, perhaps the mission that Rose/Finn went on could have been brought to Holdo, been aided by her, been completed faster, maybe been done in time had he not disobeyed, thus not been demoted therefore been part of command decisions. Perhaps their mission could have been called off sooner when it looked like things were failing to get the pods ready. Again, had he been part of the command team, he would have been a part of that, but he had been taken out of that team by *his own actions.*

However, through his failures, he learned and by the end of the film, he was once more put back onto the command team. And the audience actually *saw* Poe learn and grow through his failure and the loss of life partially through his actions, his inability to listen, to learn to understand that he's not the only one that knows the right thing to do, has all the answers. Had he realized that after his first failure at the beginning of the film the Resistance likely would have gotten away. Had Poe learned his place, had Poe learned to listen, had Poe learned that he's not always right and sometimes other people actually DO know what they're doing, care as much about the Resistance as he does, many more people would have lived to survive another day on Crait. But he wasn't there yet. Leia demoted him for a reason. He was no longer a commander, thus no longer in a command position, thus no longer privy to command decisions. *That* is why Holdo didn't tell him what she was planning.

And she was right not to because Poe proved by his secret mission activity that he hadn't learned anything from what happened with the dreadnought versus the bombers/Resistance fighters. It wasn't until once again his hot-headedness, his 'I know better than anyone else'-ness cost a bunch of Resistance fighters their lives that he got it. Had Canto Bight not happened and failed, Poe would have kept making hot-headed, 'I know better than anyone else's decisions and it would have kept getting people killed. Had Canto Bight succeeded, Poe would have kept going on his merry way doing whatever he wanted, he wouldn't have learned anything. He would have continued his reckless ways and in the bigger picture, greater lives very well may have been lost over a period of time because he didn't think of consequences.

The failure of Canto Bight finally opened his eyes to the bigger picture and the consequences of failure. Because of what happened, he finally understood and so what happened on Crait? He stopped the gunners... he realized that taking out that canon blaster would just get more of their very few remaining fighters/pilots killed and it would be no loss for the First Order. It wasn't worth the risk. He weighed the cost and the risks and made the right choice. Failure was his teacher. (For those who question why Finn didn't get that... it's because Finn is now where Poe was already in The Force Awakens, fighting for the Resistance full-throttle, for the galaxy. Finn still needs to learn the lesson that Poe has just learned.)

Then we get to Kylo/Ben whose failure was symbolized by the destruction of his mask. Kylo without the mask was him no longer in Vader's shadow. The mask was about him being the scared, little boy, hiding who he was, hiding from the Light, trying to embrace the Dark. At the end of The Last Jedi, he supposedly got everything he wanted. He no longer needed to hide. By destroying the mask, he was doing his best to let go of the past. He let go of Snoke, let go of Vader. He had everything he wanted and yet he had nothing that mattered. He may have succeeded in becoming the Supreme Leader, but he failed in walking the Dark Path fully, as evidenced by the light shining down upon him, and his position at the end of the film, kneeling, a form of supplication while looking up at Rey with remorse and desolation on his face.

I mentioned above that every character learned the lesson of failure except one. If you guessed that Kylo/Ben was that character who failed the lesson, you were right. He kept telling Rey to let go of the past, but he was the one who couldn't do it. By clinging to his hatred of Luke, his desire to finish what Darth Vader started--and we all know that what he believes his grandfather wanted is not what he thinks--he was still holding onto too many parts of his past. He was getting there, but he was still unable to admit his failure was in truly committing to the Dark Side. That is what his failure was, but he couldn't, wouldn't admit that is not who he is. He's not ready.

This brings us to Rey and her failure which was two-fold. It was in saving Ben, but also in finding happy answers about her parents. Both of those things pushed her forward to her path to adulthood. Prior to the events of this film, she was stuck in a state of arrested childhood, clinging to the memory of the child she was, subconsciously believing that if she stayed that girl that last saw her parents they would still find her. That is why she kept that hairstyle, those three buns. However, once she realized--as she did in the cave, even if she didn't admit it fully to herself until Kylo called her on it--that her parents weren't coming back, she let go of that hairstyle. Why? Because that hairstyle is the only way she could figure that her parents would still recognize her. It's the hairstyle she had when she last saw her parents. By letting her hair down and not putting it back up, she let go of the fantasy that they were coming back.

As for saving Ben, in TFA when hearing about Luke Skywalker and the Force she believed that it was a myth, some mystical higher power that "could move rocks." As the film progressed, she began to understand the Force better and feel her place in the universe in connection with it. However, she still failed to understand its full power and how it wasn't just about her connection, but the connection of every single entity and their choice to do or not to do with it (Luke or Ben/Kylo). She learned that twice over when she left Luke on the island because he wasn't coming with her, and when she failed to save Ben: By not taking his hand, by not killing him when she had the chance--when he was unconscious and she left to rejoin the Resistance--it was Rey realizing, learning that she was trying to force the Force's hand. She learned from her failure that she couldn't save Ben. Ben had to save himself. What would be would be. She could only save herself. She showed him a path... the rest was up to him.

Also, this ties into the failure aspect of the overriding arc, but is also just about how well Rian Johnson wrote the characters and made them REAL. Specifically with regards to Rey. I did feel that she came across as too perfect in TFA, she was just so damn good at everything, I found it a bit eye-roll worthy. She did not do so for me TLJ. Let me explain why.

In the former, she was good at EVERYTHING, but in TLJ, she was totally human, she made mistakes. She, you know, failed. She was impetuous, she rushed into things, she rushed into judgement like a young, naive girl who didn't know any better would. Her hero worship of Han translated to hero worship of Luke and it clouded her judgment. She was confused, she was lost and trying to find her way. And, yes, she didn't have all of the answers. Furthermore, the answers she did have made sense based on her upbringing. Oh, yeah, and girl done made mistakes. She didn't know what the Force was. She didn't know how to properly use a Lightsaber. She messed up the Fish Nun's workload and village left and right. (And it was hilarious!) She needed Chewie's help to carry out her plan in both getting to Ben Solo (when she believed she could turn him) and getting away from Kylo Ren (when she realized he wasn't ready to turn).

She was so refreshingly earnest and young and naive and stupid and brilliant and beautiful and courageous! She was real.

Finally, my favorite character arc in the film. I loved Luke more than I ever have in any other Star Wars movie. The evolution from a grumpy old man who had closed himself off to the Force--a dangling thread that JJ Abrahms left ambiguous in The Force Awakens ( *why* would Luke Skywalker have isolated him off from everyone and everything he loved?)--to an enlightened believer once more. He came out of hiding, saved the Resistance, and spread hope into the galaxy once more. And we saw that through his interaction with Rey, and his telling and re-telling of his interactions with a young Ben. We saw it in his conversation with his master, Yoda, that he still had to learn a hard lesson. (Which MADE SENSE since Luke never actually finished training with Yoda or any other master. He never had traditional Jedi training.) Sometimes you have to fail, you have to lose to learn, to win. Yoda knows this. And Yoda was letting this lesson sink into Luke in typical, awesomely Yoda fashion.

And Luke got it, and he used that lesson to send a message to the Resistance, the entire galaxy, and to teach his nephew one final lesson. Ben's failure to let go of his past--his father, the light from which he came--will ultimately be what will free him. It just wasn't a lesson that Kylo was ready to learn.

There were so many highlights of Luke and his important emotional beats from the Original Trilogy that were hit throughout this film. (Seriously, so many... it was wonderful and beautiful. Thinking about it gives me chills!):

Rian Johnson was able to give us so many highlights of the Original Trilogy through Luke in this one film and show an entire journey from (1) a hermit to (2) the young man to the (3) assured, (4) Jedi warrior to (5) the Jedi fighting for what he loves to (6) the Jedi Master at one with the Force. Just amazing. That's what I call character development, and Mark Hamil gave his finest performance as Luke Skywalker.

A New Hope

(1) Luke the hermit (shades of Ben Kenobi) in scenes with Rey while telling her of the history of the Jedi.

(6) The Jedi Master at one with the Force (again, like Obi-Wan).

The Empire Strikes Back

(2) A frustrated, wanting to learn, soaking up knowledge young Luke when talking to Yoda.

Return of the Jedi

(3) The confident *and* sassy Luke opposite Jabba while bargaining and then making good on his promise, in moments with Rey, and with Kylo.

(5) An understanding, forgiving Luke opposite Vader/Anakin with Kylo (interspersed with some sass).

(4) The Jedi fighting for what he loves, Luke fighting for the Resistance, the galaxy, even without landing an actual blow was reminiscent of Luke battling the Emperor, doing what was right.

I love this film for so many reasons, but the writing for the characters is one of the top reasons.

NOTE: Obviously a lot of this wasn't followed through on in The Rise of Skywalker. *sigh*


r/MawInstallation • • May 10 '25

[CANON] The ST doesn’t make the OT pointless

12 Upvotes

A common complaint I hear about the Sequel Trilogy is that it makes the Original Trilogy pointless, because essentially, the Republic fell and the Empire rose all over again.

Should the Rebels have just… not bothered, then? Just keep Palpatine and the Empire around? It’s gonna come back, so why even try, right?

Wrong. Very wrong. I see two primary reasons why.

The first is that, ultimately, it did buy the galaxy about 30 years of peace, which I don’t think ought to be taken for granted. During this time, the New Republic was able to build up the desire to fight Fascism in the people, which would ultimately prove invaluable. Yes, the demilitarization of the New Republic was, in hindsight, a bad idea. But why was it a bad idea, subtracting the Imperial retreat to the Unknown Regions, which the New Republic didn’t know about? War’s over. The New Republic doesn’t really have an adversary to justify a giant military at the moment. Having a big military worked for the Empire, yes, but as an instrument of oppression. What does the New Republic need one for?

(Also, it wasn’t 100%, they did still have a fleet, if a small one, which was also destroyed during the destruction of the Hosnian system. Just wanted to throw that out there, as it often seems forgotten.)

The second is that, when the First Order did make its appearance, it fell considerably faster. The Empire lasted about 25 years. After its takeover, the First Order lasted one. I also find it very hard to believe the First Order really took over the galaxy that quickly. They might have seemingly been in a position to do so eventually, but again, they lasted a year before being destroyed. This is because Fascism wasn’t allowed to take over the galaxy within again, and it had to try to do so from without. This is much easier to fight off.

TL;DR: The fall of the Empire wasn’t pointless, the demilitarization of the New Republic made sense, and it made the First Order’s attempted takeover harder.


r/MawInstallation • • Apr 15 '23

[META] In defense of The Last Jedi and it’s themes

0 Upvotes

You have to understand that the reality of nature and God and life is that things come and things go. They do not stay in your life, and you have to learn to accept the fact that it is a continuum that you’re just a part of, and that things will be there and then they won’t be there. So enjoy them and love them while they’re there, and then be happy that they’ve gone someplace else.” - Goerge Lucas

Out of all of the Star Wars movies and TV shows released under Disney, I think many will agree with me when I say that The Last Jedi has been by far the most divisive entry into the Star Wars canon. Fans have criticized the movie for everything from its portrayal of Luke Skywalker, to the Canto Bite subplot, and the death of Snoke, as well as the introduction of the Holdo maneuver. Despite this, I will defend The Last Jedi as I believe that the film’s director Rian Johnson was attempting to make a film that deconstructs what we the fans think Star Wars is supposed to be, and in that regard specifically, he succeeded.

Luke isn’t the near morally infallible hero he was in the old EU; he’s an incredibly flawed man. Rey’s parents aren’t somebody special; they were terrible people who sold her for drinking money. Snoke isn’t a mastermind like Palpatine was, as Kylo Ren killed him, and in the process declaring his independence. I don’t think these creative decisions weren’t made solely to “subvert expectations” as some will claim they were, as I believe that these decisions were made to tie into the movie’s theme of letting go of the past. Rey’s parents being nobodies is meant to exp this, as it tells the audience that Star Wars doesn’t have to be about the Skywalkers, and the destruction of the Skywalker lightsaber is symbolic of the movie's message of moving on, just as the Force Sensitive “broom boy” at the end serves to remind the audience that Star Wars does have to be about the Skywalkers. The moral of the story is very much “Let the past die. Kill it if you have to”, just not to the extremes that Kylo Ren suggests, and in a way, this message builds off of the moral of the first six films, which, according to George Lucas, is learning to let go.

“The core issue, ultimately, is greed, possessiveness - the inability to let go. Not only to hold on to material things, which is greed, but to hold on to life, to the people you love - to not accept the reality of life’s passages and changes, which is to say things come, things go. Everything changes. Anakin becomes emotionally attached to things, his mother, his wife. That’s why he falls - because he does not have the ability to let go.” - Goerge Lucas 2005

And that’s why I feel that The Last Jedi is the best film of the sequel trilogy. To me, it feels like the only one with a clearly vision, and it has morals that actually build off those of the first six films, but in doing do it divided the fanbase as some weren’t ready to let go of their fan theories and childhood heroes. I could go into more detail about how Luke’s mental state in the film also loosely tied into the movie’s themes, but I’ll just end this post here as I think I’ve conveyed my point well enough


r/MawInstallation • • May 14 '24

[ALLCONTINUITY] How come "Palpatine returned" get so much criticism when the idea was lifted from Legends?

0 Upvotes

in Dark Empire, a Legends comic, Palpatine returns from the dead and it takes a lot to get rid of him. In TROS, Palpatine returns as well. Why do people have a problem with Palpatine's return as if it hadn't been done before?


r/MawInstallation • • May 01 '25

[CANON] Was Anakin a fascist?

5 Upvotes

I know this is an incredibly dumb question, but do you think Anakin/Vader believed in all the empires beliefs like human superiority, order through military might, the whole kit and caboodle? I mean in canon and the EU he was a child murder but he did end up as a force ghost in ROTJ despite everything which is something not even the most goodest of good guys got to become. I don’t know, what’s your opinion on the matter?


r/MawInstallation • • May 18 '22

[CANON] The Rise of Skywalker doesn't undo Anakin's arc

2 Upvotes

Many claim that Anakin's character arc in Return of the Jedi is dependent on the fact that kills Palpatine. This claim leads into the assertion that The Rise of Skywalker undoes Anakin's character arc by bringing Palpatine back. However, TROS does not undo Anakin's character arc, and let me explain why.

Let me start with something everyone should know: Anakin's character arc is not dependent on Palpatine dying. Anakin's arc is that he saves Luke. You could say that Anakin saves Luke by killing Palpatine, but this is not the case. The exact moment that Darth Vader makes the decision to save Luke is the exact moment that Anakin is back. Not when Palpatine explodes.

What's also important to consider is that Palpatine would have been killed even if Darth Vader decided not to save Luke. The Rebels and the Ewoks were already going to destroy sheild generator, and Palpatine didn't effect either the Space Battle of Endor or the Battle in the Forest. Let's explore these alternate scenarios.

Scenario 1: Luke is killed by Palpatine aboard the Second Death Star. Vader is indifferent to his son, leading to the victory by the Sith. Then the Death Star explodes. Both Vader and Palpatine are dead, (although Palpatine is now on Exegol), and the Rebels win. The empire is doomed, but Anakin doesn't change.

Scenario 2: Luke doesn't go to the Death Star. Sidious just sits on his throne, and nothing really happens until the Second Death Star explodes and now both Vader and Sidious are dead. The rebels are alive, but Anakin still is unchanged by the end of the movie.

One of the genius things about Return of the Jedi is that Luke doesn't have to go to the second Death Star. If Luke just stayed on Endor, the Rebels would have still won the war. But that would not be a satisfying ending. The Returning Jedi is not Luke, it's Anakin.

Palpatine's death doesn't affect the plot of Return of the Jedi because it was a foregone conclusion. What mattered is Anakin's turn to the light.


r/MawInstallation • • Apr 08 '25

So, i just finished "Kenobi"...

0 Upvotes

So, I was a huge Star Wars fan as a kid. I watched all the films from the first two trilogies and really liked The Clone Wars series as a teenager. I stopped following the show after Season 5 ended, and by the time The Force Awakens came out, I had kind of grown out of it (though I did watch the premiere).

A few days ago, I decided to check out the new Kenobi series, and I felt the need to write down all my thoughts and share them with someone—partly because I’ve started getting into cinematography and wanted to. So if you have time to waste, feel free to read on. Keep in mind I haven’t consumed much of the newer Star Wars content, and aside from watching the Episode VII premiere nearly 10 years ago, this is my first real encounter with the Disney-era material.

  1. The acting is honestly pretty bad and unconvincing, and the characters don’t help much either.

Apart from Ewan McGregor, who did the same job like he did in the prequels, no one really grabbed my attention. Though to be fair, maybe the writing is to blame, giving the actors so little to work with. Flea and that Ice Cube’s son felt completely out of place. At one point I caught myself thinking, “How much did Flea have to pay to get into this franchise?”

2. Reva is horrible.

Possibly one of the worst character portrayals I’ve ever seen. Nothing about her fits the story. Besides the fact that I personally think the whole idea of the Inquisitors is dumb, every time she appeared on screen, I got this mild stomach ache like I knew something cringey or just plain bad was about to happen. And how did she end up turning good?!?! Who thought that was good writing? Have these screenwriters ever read a book? Or even a comic? Even Marvel handles character arcs better than this—and yes, I mean Marvel. Also, mind-reading? Really? Since when?

3. The dialogue is a mess.

Lines and phrases often don’t flow naturally, and even the few that hit an emotional note feel totally out of place in the Star Wars universe. The only character interaction I found remotely interesting was between Obi-Wan and that scammer Haja. At this point, I genuinely doubt that anyone involved in writing this show has read anything thicker than a restaurant menu.

4. On the technical side, it’s all pretty mediocre.

The stunts feel amateurish, the costumes are weak, and the special effects are surprisingly underwhelming—especially when trying to de-age Anakin. He still looks like a 40-year-old man. The camera work isn’t great either. I just don’t understand how Disney, with all its money, resources, and talent, managed to produce something worse than what George Lucas did in 1999–2005. He had less money, older technology, and still managed to make something far more convincing. Jar Jar Binks did a better job selling himself as an alien than almost anything in this show.


Now, I know all this probably makes me sound like a bitter old hag, so I’ll admit: there are a few good things here.

The overall concept is solid. Obi-Wan being crushed by the reality of life under the Empire—the atmosphere of fear and hopelessness eroding his desire to help others—is a great direction. At the start of the show, he’s not the same man we knew, and that works.

The portrayal of the Force in combat is also done well. When Vader rips that ship apart or uses the Force to push that massive stone during the final fight—that’s the kind of power I imagine the Force should have during battle.

The final duel between Obi-Wan and Vader is actually quite good. It could’ve been better, sure, but it’s how I imagine a proper lightsaber fight should feel. The Original Trilogy had technical limitations and a lack of clarity what lightsaber combat should look like, while the prequels went overboard with flashy choreography and "sword hitting a sword" fights. This one found a more grounded balance.

That said, some moments felt like lazy callbacks. The reunion between Vader and Obi-Wan uses the same lines from Revenge of the Sith, which was clearly meant as a tribute—but it came off as cheap. Instead of cleverly building something original, the show relies heavily on nostalgia, flashbacks, and recycled emotions (Vader vs. Obi-Wan, youngling slaughter, etc.). With talented filmmakers, this could’ve been done well. But here, it feels like a budget Spanish soap opera.

The whole thing gave me the impression of a fan-made project—something by cosplayers or LARP enthusiasts. At least to me. I don’t want to insult anyone’s taste.

Final thought: Disney is milking the Star Wars brand for easy profit. They don’t care about quality. George Lucas should never have sold his company. Star Wars might have been better off continuing with animation style filmmaking. I think animation suits this kind of sci-fi world far more than these poorly executed live-action attempts.


r/MawInstallation • • Aug 26 '23

Convince me to like Luke

0 Upvotes

So, Luke is my least favourite SW character. I'm really a CW fan girl so my favourites are Ahsoka, Echo, Anakin, Padme. I adore Leia & Han, but Luke just doesn't hit it imo. Luke fans, please tell me why you like him cos I want to as well!


r/MawInstallation • • May 02 '24

[CANON] The one thing I hated about the Bad Batch ending. Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Spoiler warning:

That Scorch died the way he did, like, getting shot off a platform? Scorch deserved way better than that.


r/MawInstallation • • Jun 25 '25

[ALLCONTINUITY] Why does everyone in the galaxy love alcohol?

0 Upvotes

This may seem like a silly question but I've read/watched hundreds of Star Wars stories. It doesn't seem to matter what species you are. What part of the galaxy you're in or what your moral affiliations are-everyone likes to go to their local cantina and have a drink.

Why? What's the in-universe reason

I have a sneaking suspicion that this trend continues because one of the first things SW fans saw was a bunch of aliens drinking in a bar. Since that's what we were drawn in with; authors and other content creators have been obsessed with recreating it. That's the Doylist answer but that never worked for me.


r/MawInstallation • • Jun 07 '24

[CANON] does anyone else like the sequel trilogy?

3 Upvotes

I don't think they are as bad as people say they are, but they aren't masterpieces either, and I think the rise of Skywalker is pretty decent, being my favorite of the three. 


r/MawInstallation • • Mar 20 '23

I don't understand what the problem with Luke's character in The Last Jedi was.

25 Upvotes

It seems to make sense to me. At the TLJ's point in time Luke is not the young man that he was in the original trilogy.

He's grumpy, old, tired, and lost everything that he worked so hard to build. His entire new Jedi order was brutally destroyed by brother-in-law's own son.

Luke's sense of prosperity and hope from the galaxy being finally free of the control of the Sith and the Empire was suddenly smashed into a million pieces by Ben Solo's turn to the dark side.

He probably felt that the galaxy didn't need anymore Jedi to have balance in the force and the tragic loss of his new order was a symptom of that.


r/MawInstallation • • Apr 15 '23

[CANON] Neo-Nazis Weren't What the Sequels Needed

0 Upvotes

One of my big gripes with the Sequel Trilogy is that it's just another rebellion against another empire. This trilogy wasn't a proper sequel. It was more of a soft reboot.

The good guys should have been the New Republic and a revived Jedi Order. And the bad guys should have been a completely new threat that rose in the power vacuum of the Empire's collapse.

I recently did some reading on the Russian Mafia-- their status while the Soviet Union was in power, then the gang wars that followed the USSR's collapse, and their current status in Putin's Russia. Likewise, the oligarchs were businessmen who profited from the privatization of Soviet state assets.

Similarly, the post-Endor Outer Rim can be compared to the Wild West in the post-Civil War era, when a bunch of armed veterans with PTSD moved out to where law enforcement was thin. And when greedy eastern businessmen (oligarchs again) began exploiting the West.

Star Wars has got so much good stuff that just needs rearrangement. The Prequels should have depicted a military of normal recruits fighting enemy clone forces. Save the droid armies and cyborgs and Dark Troopers, and Darth Maul's Shadow Collective, for the Sequel era. They could be like a galactic, high-tech version of Mrs. Cheng's pirate confederation. They've taken over the governments of certain planets across the galaxy, turning them into mafia states and kleptocracies. Then, in a coordinated stroke, they declare their independence, and become extradition-free anchorages for pirate cells. This results in the Droid Wars. The Sequels could have depicted the New Republic fighting to secure peace and stability, law and order, in the galaxy.

Instead, Abrams and Johnson just gave us another guerrilla fight for freedom from fascism, all because Luke and Leia's generation didn't do a thorough enough job killing all the Imperials the first time around.


r/MawInstallation • • Mar 30 '23

[CANON] No: "Somehow Palpatine Returned" doesn't undermine Vader's Redemption...

44 Upvotes

...because Vader's choice to Return to the Light and become Anakin Skywalker again had no bearing on whether Palpatine lived or died.

There's an all-too-common take online that I fundamentally disagree with, and today I am going to address it... WITH TIMESTAMPS!

The take goes something like this:

"The return of Darth Sidious undermines Vader/Anakin's decision to kill him, because now that choice has no consequence."

or, even more extreme:

The rise of the First Order undermines Vader/Anakin's decision to institute the New Republic, because now that choice has no consequence."

There's a problem with these positions, though... they ascribe way more impact to Vader's choice than it ever originally had.

Let's rewind to Return of the Jedi. Luke surrenders to the Empire on Endor for two reasons:

  1. He fears that his presence will lure Vader to the Rebels, and endanger the mission.

  2. He hopes he can convince his Father to defect.

The moment he leaves the Rebel Pathfinder group, he has achieved objective 1.

He has full faith that his friends will down the shield, and destroy the Death Star. HIS DIALOGUE MAKES THIS CLEAR.

After his surrender, the stakes of his actions are PURELY PERSONAL. He might redeem Vader, save his own life, the life of his father, or he might not... but he won't impact the mission. He cannot. Nothing he does from that point until the end of the film has ANY IMPACT on galactic politics. It's all personal stakes. When Vader elects not to take Luke's initial offer, Luke accepts that he will die, his father will die, and that there will be no redemption.

But what about the Emperor himself, I hear you ask?

He'd have died anyway. He makes it 100% clear that he had no intention of leaving, nobody could or would tell him that the situation has changed, and the space station he is standing in was about to turn into rubble.

1 hour, 32: minutes: Luke tells the Emperor, in explicit terms, that both of them will soon be dead.

"Soon, I'll be dead, and you along with me."

The emperor disagrees, citing the legion of troops on Endor, and the operational nature of the Death Star.

Crucially... if he doesn't learn that this is incorrect with enough time to leave, he's going to die. The explosion will kill him.

I'll repeat that.

If the Emperor had not left the Death Star before it exploded, he would have died no matter what Vader did or didn't do.

So, the question then becomes: would he have left?

I argue that he would not have.

As Luke rightly points out (again, this is all EXPLICIT DIALOGUE):

"Your overconfidence is your weakness"

The emperor has absolute faith in his soldiers, his ships, his weapons. He is sure they cannot fail him. So sure, in fact, that he never indicates any plan to leave. So sure that he conducts his attempted conversion of Luke aboard the very structure that is under attack.

1 hour, 55 minutes: the shield generator explodes. Lando IMMEDIATELY realises the shield is down, and so, presumably, does everyone else with functioning sensors. The Emperor? He continues to speak slowly and calmly (albeit with notable contempt), and chooses a very slow and tortuous method to kill the unarmed and defenceless enemy before him.

He either does not know that the shield is down, meaning that his underlings have orders not to disturb him, which is plausible, as he sent even his guards away (technically, it's possible that they could tell him, but refuse to, for fear of his retribution; I think this is possible, given how scared Jerjerrod was of him); or he knows and doesn't care! In either case, there's no indication that he was going to do anything different!

1 hour, 57 minutes: Vader turns on, and kills, his master.

1 hour, 58 minutes: Rebel ships actually enter the superstructure. If ever there was a time to alert the Emperor, it would be now. And yet... no alarms in the Throne room.

1 hour, 59 minutes, 42 seconds: Luke and his dying father have left the throne room. Tie Pilots are scrambling everyone is at battle-stations, but there are still unattended shuttles. This is not a full evacuation. There has not been a call to Abandon Ship, because they are able to have a full conversation before Anakin finally dies... and nobody pushes past them, or tells them to board the shuttle. The Empire is still fighting, the people aboard the Death Star DO NOT EXPECT TO DIE.

Luke -alone- recognises the need to leave, because he has, as the Emperor puts it:

"faith in [his] friends"

Luke believes the Alliance will destroy the Death Star, but nobody else, including (especially?) the Emperor does.

And... that's it.

2 hours, 3 minutes: The explosive shockwave from the Death Star's reactor reaches the surface. Anyone still aboard is dead.

Palpatine was going to die there no matter what. Had Vader allowed him to torture Luke to death, Darth Sidious would have sat in his throne cackling for six minutes until the resulting shockwave turned his bones to splinters and ruptured his stomach.

Vader's last words to his son were purely personal. No "here is how you should run the new Galactic Government", or even "here's how you should run the Jedi Order".

"Balancing the Force" meant redeeming himself and saving his son's life, not killing his master or replacing the Empire with the New Republic, because THOSE THINGS WOULD HAVE OCCURED ANYWAY.

Thanks to Vader, his child lived a full lifespan.

Thanks to Vader, the ideology of the Jedi triumphed, and the prophecy was fulfilled.

Thanks to Vader, sinners found hope of atonement, and the new regime was one built on an ideal of mercy.

None of that was undone by the First Order, or the cloning experiments on Exegol.

But to act as if the events of the sequels undermined Vader's sacrifice is to ascribe to them entirely too much weight!

That story thread in RotJ was a personal and spiritual one. It NEVER had direct astropolitical consequences!


r/MawInstallation • • Apr 08 '25

[ALLCONTINUITY] Anakin Was Never Good

0 Upvotes

He murdered people before, during and after RotS. He moved on incredibly quickly after admitting to killing the women and children of the Tusken Raiders. Pure psychopath material.

He also murdered younglings. He wasn't redeemed in RotJ because his evil acts made him irredeemable.

The council in TPM were right, there was too much emotional baggage involved for him to be trained safely.

The prophecy about the 'chosen one' was a bare faced lie. There were Sith Lords after Sidious. He brought balance to nothing. All he did was get masses of innocent people killed by being a pawn in an evil genius' plan.

Obi Wan's life was also characterised by bad choices and if I'm not mistaken, the original planned ending for RotJ was that Luke would join Palpatine. If this is what would have happened then Obi Wan's failure to make good decisions would be laid bare even more. All those warnings from Yoda to Luke about not being ready would also make more sense.

Star Wars is a tragedy about placing misplaced trust in ancient texts and prophecies.

What was Light Sided about Anakin Skywalker in your opinion?


r/MawInstallation • • Nov 11 '25

I don't believe Anakin Skywalker was "loyal".

12 Upvotes

I don't believe Anakin Skywalker was "loyal".

There is a common notion that comes up anytime Anakin Skywalker is discussed that describes him as extremely loyal to his friends and those he cares about. And it makes perfect sense for people at the time to believe that was true, but I don't believe it actually was a reflection of who he was.

Anakin Skywalker desired above all else to dominate and control everyone. This was a mental process of him that didn't truly come to light except in a few occasions before ROTS, but the events of the movie do make clear that this is who he is.

He's a violent and obsessive mass murderer who will without hesitation attempt in full effort to murder in cold blood absolutely everyone who he cares about the moment they show any signs of not completely adhering to his demands and views.

He claimed to care about the Jedi and the Jedi Order. Without hesitation the moment his interests were threatened he murdered everyone in cold blood.

He claimed to care about his Master and best friend, Obi-Wan Kenobi, the second Obi-Wan doesn't just let him get away with mass murder, he resolves to cut his head off.

He claimed to care about his wife, Padme Amidala, the moment she steps out of line, he accuses her of betrayal, immediately attempts to murder her, and their own child that she is pregnant with.

Years later, his own former Padawan, the closest thing to a daughter he ever had, Ashoka Tano, he gives her a token opportunity to aid him in more murder and the moment she refuses, immediately resolves to cut apart.

Yes, he did one genuinely selfless thing at the end, by not allowing his own son to be tortured to death in front of him. But even still, when it is "Anakin" who comes back to the surface, he isn't sobbing and begging for forgiveness for his endless crimes, the innocents he's tortured and murdered without hesitation. He's insisting to Luke that he was right about him being good. He's buying into the idea that he was truly good deep down, he's not taking it even the slightest accountability for his monstrous actions and when Obi-Wan gives him the chance at eternal life, he doesn't reject it feeling that he doesn't deserve it and that he could never make up for his crimes, he accepts it and allows himself to live on for all eternity.

I view him as a fundamentally selfish monster. You cannot simply wave it away by claiming that the dark side corrupted him. While it DID, there was moment after moment he could have jumped off. He was a fully grown adult man who knew the consequences and effects of all of his actions at every stage. To make any attempt to wave it away removes his complicity and his agency.


r/MawInstallation • • Sep 07 '25

Star Wars should be Controversial

0 Upvotes

Since the Rey Movie has been announced, I've rewatched past video essays, podcasts, and comments from Star Wars fans. I've thought about how controversial the last Jedi was, and how it changed the direction of Disney Story telling. Disney is now playing it safe and I think that it's a disservice to the story and character arcs.

The core of George Lucas's Stars Wars focuses on Philosophy, Politics, Spirituality, and Psychology. All four topics are controversial, but that is what makes Star Wars Stand Out. When you take those core topics away and play it safe, then the story is dead.

When I mention Politics, I am not talking about liberal or Conservative views. I am talking about a story about a War in the Stars caused by leaders who has different ideas which is very reflective of human society.

Stories are controversial because it challenges our own ideas and that is okay. Good stories form good discussions and it's influence can last for centuries.

For example, Frankenstein was written in 1816 and was controversial of its time. Today, the story of Frankenstein is a iconic classic that influenced many other stories that we love today.


r/MawInstallation • • Feb 15 '26

Has there ever been a stupid Sith or Jedi?

0 Upvotes

Title is as it sounds

Do idiot jedi or sith exist? I'm talking anywhere between "dumb and dumber Jar Jar" kind of people to Rainman or Forest Gump level ? Hell throw in down syndrome or mental retardation while we're at it.

Would these kind of people ever be a Jedi or Sith?


r/MawInstallation • • Apr 30 '26

[CANON] Yoda actually passed away at a somewhat young age for his species, here's why

1 Upvotes

Yoda's unknown species are obviously known for living for hundreds of years, however Yoda dying of natural causes at exactly 900 years old is young for his species.

This is because Grogu by the time of Yoda's death, is 45 years old (4 ABY) and resembles the physical and mental development equivalent of a human toddler. By the New Republic era, he is over 50 and appears to be 3 years old in human years.

With this in mind you could make the argument that 16 plus two third years (16.67) aged of Yoda's species is the equivalent of 1 human year. For example for Grogu to be 6 years old in his species' years, he would need to age 100 years (would reach that age in 41 ABY)

Using this logic of examining Grogu's slow aging, this would mean that Yoda's death at the age of 900 is the equivalent of a human dying at the age of 54.

With Yoda being a very powerful force user and feeling the full suffering of Order 66, dying of natural causes before 70s-80s isn't too much of a surprise. Ben Kenobi died at 61 naturally through the force (becoming one with the force is a light-side ability those with not much strength (say less than a few years) left use) and him being able to see and raise Luke from time to time definitely helped him live longer


r/MawInstallation • • Aug 01 '25

[META] [Meta?] Why are the canon Inquisitors so much of a joke in comparison to the Legends Inquisitors?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about the Legends Inquisitors. They're so much stronger, intelligent, and more interesting than the canon ones. Jerec alone was exceedingly stronger than all of his canon peers.

Why was this downgrade done?