While there are many things I love about The Last Jedi, what impressed me the most was the character work that Johnson did and how he developed each character not only separately but tied that character's development into others so that there was an overlapping theme carried throughout. And that theme was that failure is a lesson and all but one character learned from that lesson and every character but for that one was in a better place by the film's end. (One guess as to which character didn't figure out the lesson.)
Let's start with the much-maligned supposed non-existent character arc for Finn. In The Force Awakens, he learned how to care about another person (Rey) beyond his upbringing as a Stormtrooper. In TLJ, he saw beyond that. He saw the bigger picture and realized that it wasn’t just about saving the few people you care about (Rey and Poe), but it was about working to save the galaxy; it was about the goals of the Resistance. He found a resolve that wasn’t wrapped up in Rey but rather was about his own purpose. He truly would now be one of the leaders at the forefront of the Resistance (as Rose thought he was when she first met him) because of his experiences throughout the film. That is what his arc was about.
As for the (again), *supposedly* pointless entire Canto Bight, let's dive in. Firstly, it was about Finn joining the Resistance fully to become THE BIG DAMN HERO. It was about him deciding to fight for the Resistance instead of just him and Rey. TFA began with Finn fighting for himself only. It ended with Finn fighting for himself and Rey only. TLJ began with Finn fighting for himself and Rey only. TLJ ended with Finn fighting for the entire galaxy. That's fantastic development! And it wouldn't have happened without Canto Bight. As Yoda told Luke, 'failure is one of our greatest teachers.' The failure of Canto Bight and what ensued taught Finn where he belonged, who he truly was... who Rose thought he was when she first met him: he did become THE FINN, one of THE leaders of the Resistance.
That was a lot of development, and the beauty of Johnson's writing is that it wasn’t shoved in your face. It wasn’t presented in clunky, simple writing. It was nuanced, and it was written through his interactions with Rose, with Poe, with DJ, with Phasma, through his non-interaction with Rey, through his failures even… because he learned from them. Again it was as Yoda said: You learn from your failures as much as you do from your successes.
And the same was true for Poe. In the beginning of the film, he was the same as he was in TFA. He was a hothead, he disobeyed orders from the leader of the Resistance, and in doing so, he got most of their bombers killed because he had to take a risk and do things his way even though they were outgunned and outmanned. And it was a pointless victory. So what if they took out a dreadnought? The First Order has so many of them while the Resistance had a much more limited number of bombers and people and the cost of one dreadnought compared to what they lost was so very minuscule. And Poe simply did not look at the bigger picture. He messed up.
So he was demoted (rightfully so) and because he was demoted he lost his place in the inner circle of command and that is why he wasn’t let in on the plans that were underway because he had shown that he couldn't be trusted to follow orders. HE put himself in that position. Had he not done that, perhaps the mission that Rose/Finn went on could have been brought to Holdo, been aided by her, been completed faster, maybe been done in time had he not disobeyed, thus not been demoted therefore been part of command decisions. Perhaps their mission could have been called off sooner when it looked like things were failing to get the pods ready. Again, had he been part of the command team, he would have been a part of that, but he had been taken out of that team by *his own actions.*
However, through his failures, he learned and by the end of the film, he was once more put back onto the command team. And the audience actually *saw* Poe learn and grow through his failure and the loss of life partially through his actions, his inability to listen, to learn to understand that he's not the only one that knows the right thing to do, has all the answers. Had he realized that after his first failure at the beginning of the film the Resistance likely would have gotten away. Had Poe learned his place, had Poe learned to listen, had Poe learned that he's not always right and sometimes other people actually DO know what they're doing, care as much about the Resistance as he does, many more people would have lived to survive another day on Crait. But he wasn't there yet. Leia demoted him for a reason. He was no longer a commander, thus no longer in a command position, thus no longer privy to command decisions. *That* is why Holdo didn't tell him what she was planning.
And she was right not to because Poe proved by his secret mission activity that he hadn't learned anything from what happened with the dreadnought versus the bombers/Resistance fighters. It wasn't until once again his hot-headedness, his 'I know better than anyone else'-ness cost a bunch of Resistance fighters their lives that he got it. Had Canto Bight not happened and failed, Poe would have kept making hot-headed, 'I know better than anyone else's decisions and it would have kept getting people killed. Had Canto Bight succeeded, Poe would have kept going on his merry way doing whatever he wanted, he wouldn't have learned anything. He would have continued his reckless ways and in the bigger picture, greater lives very well may have been lost over a period of time because he didn't think of consequences.
The failure of Canto Bight finally opened his eyes to the bigger picture and the consequences of failure. Because of what happened, he finally understood and so what happened on Crait? He stopped the gunners... he realized that taking out that canon blaster would just get more of their very few remaining fighters/pilots killed and it would be no loss for the First Order. It wasn't worth the risk. He weighed the cost and the risks and made the right choice. Failure was his teacher. (For those who question why Finn didn't get that... it's because Finn is now where Poe was already in The Force Awakens, fighting for the Resistance full-throttle, for the galaxy. Finn still needs to learn the lesson that Poe has just learned.)
Then we get to Kylo/Ben whose failure was symbolized by the destruction of his mask. Kylo without the mask was him no longer in Vader's shadow. The mask was about him being the scared, little boy, hiding who he was, hiding from the Light, trying to embrace the Dark. At the end of The Last Jedi, he supposedly got everything he wanted. He no longer needed to hide. By destroying the mask, he was doing his best to let go of the past. He let go of Snoke, let go of Vader. He had everything he wanted and yet he had nothing that mattered. He may have succeeded in becoming the Supreme Leader, but he failed in walking the Dark Path fully, as evidenced by the light shining down upon him, and his position at the end of the film, kneeling, a form of supplication while looking up at Rey with remorse and desolation on his face.
I mentioned above that every character learned the lesson of failure except one. If you guessed that Kylo/Ben was that character who failed the lesson, you were right. He kept telling Rey to let go of the past, but he was the one who couldn't do it. By clinging to his hatred of Luke, his desire to finish what Darth Vader started--and we all know that what he believes his grandfather wanted is not what he thinks--he was still holding onto too many parts of his past. He was getting there, but he was still unable to admit his failure was in truly committing to the Dark Side. That is what his failure was, but he couldn't, wouldn't admit that is not who he is. He's not ready.
This brings us to Rey and her failure which was two-fold. It was in saving Ben, but also in finding happy answers about her parents. Both of those things pushed her forward to her path to adulthood. Prior to the events of this film, she was stuck in a state of arrested childhood, clinging to the memory of the child she was, subconsciously believing that if she stayed that girl that last saw her parents they would still find her. That is why she kept that hairstyle, those three buns. However, once she realized--as she did in the cave, even if she didn't admit it fully to herself until Kylo called her on it--that her parents weren't coming back, she let go of that hairstyle. Why? Because that hairstyle is the only way she could figure that her parents would still recognize her. It's the hairstyle she had when she last saw her parents. By letting her hair down and not putting it back up, she let go of the fantasy that they were coming back.
As for saving Ben, in TFA when hearing about Luke Skywalker and the Force she believed that it was a myth, some mystical higher power that "could move rocks." As the film progressed, she began to understand the Force better and feel her place in the universe in connection with it. However, she still failed to understand its full power and how it wasn't just about her connection, but the connection of every single entity and their choice to do or not to do with it (Luke or Ben/Kylo). She learned that twice over when she left Luke on the island because he wasn't coming with her, and when she failed to save Ben: By not taking his hand, by not killing him when she had the chance--when he was unconscious and she left to rejoin the Resistance--it was Rey realizing, learning that she was trying to force the Force's hand. She learned from her failure that she couldn't save Ben. Ben had to save himself. What would be would be. She could only save herself. She showed him a path... the rest was up to him.
Also, this ties into the failure aspect of the overriding arc, but is also just about how well Rian Johnson wrote the characters and made them REAL. Specifically with regards to Rey. I did feel that she came across as too perfect in TFA, she was just so damn good at everything, I found it a bit eye-roll worthy. She did not do so for me TLJ. Let me explain why.
In the former, she was good at EVERYTHING, but in TLJ, she was totally human, she made mistakes. She, you know, failed. She was impetuous, she rushed into things, she rushed into judgement like a young, naive girl who didn't know any better would. Her hero worship of Han translated to hero worship of Luke and it clouded her judgment. She was confused, she was lost and trying to find her way. And, yes, she didn't have all of the answers. Furthermore, the answers she did have made sense based on her upbringing. Oh, yeah, and girl done made mistakes. She didn't know what the Force was. She didn't know how to properly use a Lightsaber. She messed up the Fish Nun's workload and village left and right. (And it was hilarious!) She needed Chewie's help to carry out her plan in both getting to Ben Solo (when she believed she could turn him) and getting away from Kylo Ren (when she realized he wasn't ready to turn).
She was so refreshingly earnest and young and naive and stupid and brilliant and beautiful and courageous! She was real.
Finally, my favorite character arc in the film. I loved Luke more than I ever have in any other Star Wars movie. The evolution from a grumpy old man who had closed himself off to the Force--a dangling thread that JJ Abrahms left ambiguous in The Force Awakens ( *why* would Luke Skywalker have isolated him off from everyone and everything he loved?)--to an enlightened believer once more. He came out of hiding, saved the Resistance, and spread hope into the galaxy once more. And we saw that through his interaction with Rey, and his telling and re-telling of his interactions with a young Ben. We saw it in his conversation with his master, Yoda, that he still had to learn a hard lesson. (Which MADE SENSE since Luke never actually finished training with Yoda or any other master. He never had traditional Jedi training.) Sometimes you have to fail, you have to lose to learn, to win. Yoda knows this. And Yoda was letting this lesson sink into Luke in typical, awesomely Yoda fashion.
And Luke got it, and he used that lesson to send a message to the Resistance, the entire galaxy, and to teach his nephew one final lesson. Ben's failure to let go of his past--his father, the light from which he came--will ultimately be what will free him. It just wasn't a lesson that Kylo was ready to learn.
There were so many highlights of Luke and his important emotional beats from the Original Trilogy that were hit throughout this film. (Seriously, so many... it was wonderful and beautiful. Thinking about it gives me chills!):
Rian Johnson was able to give us so many highlights of the Original Trilogy through Luke in this one film and show an entire journey from (1) a hermit to (2) the young man to the (3) assured, (4) Jedi warrior to (5) the Jedi fighting for what he loves to (6) the Jedi Master at one with the Force. Just amazing. That's what I call character development, and Mark Hamil gave his finest performance as Luke Skywalker.
A New Hope
(1) Luke the hermit (shades of Ben Kenobi) in scenes with Rey while telling her of the history of the Jedi.
(6) The Jedi Master at one with the Force (again, like Obi-Wan).
The Empire Strikes Back
(2) A frustrated, wanting to learn, soaking up knowledge young Luke when talking to Yoda.
Return of the Jedi
(3) The confident *and* sassy Luke opposite Jabba while bargaining and then making good on his promise, in moments with Rey, and with Kylo.
(5) An understanding, forgiving Luke opposite Vader/Anakin with Kylo (interspersed with some sass).
(4) The Jedi fighting for what he loves, Luke fighting for the Resistance, the galaxy, even without landing an actual blow was reminiscent of Luke battling the Emperor, doing what was right.
I love this film for so many reasons, but the writing for the characters is one of the top reasons.
NOTE: Obviously a lot of this wasn't followed through on in The Rise of Skywalker. *sigh*