A few months ago I crafted this proposed legislation with the help of LLM tools.
Proposed United States Digital Legacy and Account Preservation Act (DAPA)
A Bill to Protect Digital Legacies, Prevent Arbitrary Deletion of User Accounts and Content, Establish User Control Over Post-Mortem Data, and Promote the Preservation of Personal and Cultural Digital Archives
Section 1. Short Title and Findings
(a) Short Title. — This Act may be cited as the “Digital Legacy and Account Preservation Act” or “DAPA.”
(b) Congressional Findings. —Social media platforms, major email services, and related digital accounts have become integral archives of personal memories, family histories, cultural moments, creative works, and historical records.
— Arbitrary or automatic deletion of inactive or deceased users’ accounts risks irreparable loss to families, historians, researchers, and future generations, including potential facilitation of “historic context attacks” through fabrication of records in the absence of authentic primary sources.
— Users expect permanence and control over their digital lives, not invisible timers or corporate defaults that erase data without explicit consent.
— Platforms should prioritize user autonomy, strong security, tiered storage, and memorialization options over blanket deletion policies.
— Major platforms function as de facto public utilities for digital expression and memory and warrant targeted regulatory oversight to ensure continuity of access.
Section 2. Definitions
Covered Platform: An online service, regardless of user count, that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), in consultation with the Department of Commerce and the Department of Justice, designates as having strategic status based on one or more of the following factors:
Provides essential communication, authentication, or identity services relied upon by other critical infrastructure (e.g., email services used for two-factor authentication, banking, government services, or cryptocurrency wallets);
Hosts significant volumes of irreplaceable personal, family, cultural, historical, or scientific archives;
Holds substantial market power in a particular digital ecosystem or serves as a primary repository for user-generated content with long-term societal value;
Presents elevated national security, public safety, or systemic risk concerns if user data were subject to mass deletion or loss.
Digital Legacy: All data, accounts, posts, media, messages, and associated metadata belonging to a user, whether active, inactive, or post-mortem.
Thanatosensitive Settings: User-configurable preferences for what happens to an account and its data upon prolonged inactivity or death (e.g., memorialization/preservation, transfer, or deletion).
Memorialized Account: An account placed in a read-only or limited-access state for remembrance, with content preserved but new activity restricted.
Designated Beneficiary: A person or entity designated by the user (via will, platform settings, or court order) to inherit or manage the account.
Section 3. Prohibition on Automatic Deletion Policies
(a) General Rule.—No covered platform may implement or enforce a policy that automatically deletes, purges, or renders permanently inaccessible a user account and/or its content solely based on inactivity periods of fewer than five (5) years, absent explicit user consent or a clear and documented security threat (e.g., confirmed compromise with no recovery possible).
(b) Non-covered platforms. — Inactivity-based deletions in non-covered platforms may occur only after: Robust, multi-channel notification attempts (email, SMS, app notifications, and secondary contacts) over at least 30 days. Opportunity for the user or authorized representative to respond, export data, or update activity.
(c) Tiered Storage Mandate.— Covered platforms must move long-inactive data to secure, encrypted cold storage with reduced visibility while maintaining accessibility upon valid request.
Section 4. User Control and Thanatosensitive Features
(a) Mandatory Settings.—Covered platforms shall provide prominent, easy-to-use Thanatosensitive Settings allowing users to designate:
(b) Implementation.—These settings must be configurable at account creation and easily accessible thereafter, with one-click data export tools in standard formats. Platforms shall honor valid wills, court orders, or successor-in-interest requests for access or transfer.
(c) Post-Mortem Access.—Upon verified death (via death certificate or court order), platforms shall:
Notify designated beneficiaries or next-of-kin.
Provide options for memorialization, data export, or managed transfer.
Preserve public or shared historical content of cultural value unless deletion is explicitly requested.
Section 5. Security, Privacy, and Utility Obligations
(a) Security Enhancements.—Platforms must apply automatic security upgrades (e.g., modern password hashing, anomaly monitoring) to dormant accounts and allow users to “freeze” accounts.
(b) Utility Designation.—Major covered platforms (as determined by the FTC, considering market dominance and societal role) shall be treated analogously to essential utilities. The federal government may provide targeted grants, tax incentives, or shared infrastructure support to offset reasonable costs of long-term data preservation, ensuring that maintenance of user digital legacies is not treated solely as a corporate liability.
(c) Transparency.—Annual public reports on retention practices, deletion requests, breach statistics (differentiated by account activity), and data use for AI training are required. Clear opt-out mechanisms for non-consensual uses (e.g., AI training) must be provided.
(d) Username and Address Management.—Platforms are encouraged to implement technical solutions such as third-level domains or sub-accounts to address namespace exhaustion without forced deletions.
Section 6. Enforcement and Private Right of Action
The FTC and state attorneys general shall enforce this Act. Violations may result in civil penalties up to $50,000 per affected user (adjusted for inflation), injunctive relief, and attorney fees.
Private Right of Action: Affected users, estates, or beneficiaries may sue for damages, including emotional distress and loss of irreplaceable data, in federal or state court.
Safe Harbor: Platforms acting in good faith to honor user settings, provide notifications, and implement security measures receive a defense against certain liability.
Section 7. Relation to Other Laws
This Act supplements (and does not preempt) state digital asset inheritance laws (e.g., Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act) and federal privacy laws. Nothing in this Act limits valid law enforcement requests, national security needs, or a user’s “right to be forgotten” upon explicit request. Preemption of conflicting state laws that mandate aggressive deletion timelines.
Section 8. Effective Date and Rulemaking
This Act takes effect 18 months after enactment. The FTC shall issue implementing regulations within 12 months, including guidelines for verification of death/inactivity.