r/maths • • Jul 15 '23

Solve the problem 5

Post image
0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

18

u/SebtheSongYT Jul 15 '23

This a very easy problem that shouldn't be an issue if u have had any precalc class or trig overall. Thus is the Pythagorean trig identity, sin2 x + cos2 x = 1

Since this equals 1, we are just taking the derivative of a constant, which is 0.

I suggest you brush up on your precalc and trigonometry skills, as this is the first real identity you learn.

-27

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

I think your tone is unnecessary and also you're clearly incorrect.

As d/dx(f(x) + g(x)) = d/dx(f(x)) + d/dx(g(x))

So we have to differentiate both of them separately and the sum of their derivatives is not clearly 0.

Maybe you should brush up on your differentiation theorems and stop giving incorrect answers.

15

u/DenXV Jul 15 '23

You didn't read what he said properly, there is no need to differentiate them separately because sin²x + cos²x = 1 so you can just use that trig identity to simplify the problem an then just differentiate 1 which is 0.

9

u/SebtheSongYT Jul 15 '23 edited Jul 15 '23

d/dx sin2 x + cos2 x

= d/dx sin2 x + d/dx cos2 x

Using chain rule: d/dx sin2 x = 2sin x cos x d/dx cos2 x = -2sin x cos x

Summing together = 0

No incorrect answers here

Sorry is my tone came off as kinda condescending. It's late where I am

-9

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

Yep, just did it. Definitely checks out. But it was totally not called for right?

5

u/chairman-me0w Jul 15 '23

Go away. How’s that for tone.

6

u/LingonberryNeat8642 Jul 15 '23

I agree on the tone thing but ma dude is completely correct. If you prefer you can also differentiate both terms separately and if you use the chain rule correctly you realize that they cancel out to 0.

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

Yeah I just did it and saw it canceled out.

6

u/UnforeseenDerailment Jul 15 '23

m-... maybe you should brush up on your precalc? 😇

4

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

Yeah, that's fair.

3

u/iamtabestderes Jul 15 '23

How about you watch your own tone 🤡

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

I said what I said. Idgaf.

It was a simple question, somebody was looking for help, and there's no need to be an ass about it.

It's unfortunate he was right but I have no qualms calling him out for his tone.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

I lied, I did the math. He's right.

1

u/LukeLJS123 Jul 15 '23

if a=b, then b=a

sin2 (x) + cos2 (x) = 1, so you can use them interchangeably

-1

u/Free_Dingo_6901 Jul 15 '23

I did that and the answer was cos2-sin2

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

Yeah, I think where you may be going wrong perhaps the application of the chain rule.

So you have d/dx(cos2 x), I forgot how they usually show it but let u = cos x

Then you have d/du(u2) = 2u × d/du(u) by the chain rule.

I would usually just skip this step and write it down like so.

2 cos x × d/dx ( cos x ) by chain rule.

Then you get -2 cos x × sin x

That will be your first half.

If you do both of them, you'll get -2 cos x × sin x + 2 cos x × sin x.

They will both cancel out and you will get 0 as he said.

Which... does make sense.

1

u/Free_Dingo_6901 Jul 15 '23

The problem is time here. Didn't get enough time to practice.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23

It's all good, I think although his comment may have come off a bit snarky he does have a point in terms of memorizing trig identities.

Not all of us go to schools where those are taught to us but if you know them then they could save you a lot of time during a test or an exam.

1

u/BEAST_WORK6969 Jul 15 '23

konsi book hai bhai?

3

u/Impossible_Fuel2130 Jul 15 '23

-2sinx cosx + 2cosx sinx = 0 (or just the derivative of 1 is 0)

2

u/Ari45Harris Jul 15 '23

0 due to pythag identity

2

u/benfok Jul 15 '23

People are missing the problem that 0 is not a choice for problem 5.

1

u/chaos_redefined Jul 18 '23

I am hoping there is an option d not caught by the camera. None of the answers shown are correct.

1

u/BruhMonkey100 Jul 15 '23

Sinx2 + cosx2 = 1 , I’m pretty sure your given that as a standard trigonometric identitiy , furthermore when you take the derivative of the any constant you’re given f(x)’=0