r/mathematics • u/8bitjam • Oct 08 '26
Solving a mathematical problem needs someone’s permission?
“Mathematicians did not ask for this work to be done.”
r/mathematics • u/8bitjam • Oct 08 '26
“Mathematicians did not ask for this work to be done.”
r/mathematics • u/itzshyam1 • Mar 28 '25
My Maths teacher, in his intro class (my first day btw), pulled out an example as follows
0 = 0
x2 - x2 = x2 - x2
(x + x)(x - x) = x(x - x)
By cancelling/dividing out (x - x) on both sides,
x + x = x
2x = x
this leads us to an incorrect fact of 2 equal to 1.
according to my math teacher, this contradiction has arisen because we divided out the (x - x), and hence we cant cancel variables at any cost (which I know is wrong)
how can I disprove his conclusion? thanks!
r/mathematics • u/Educational-Hour5755 • Oct 16 '24
I really mean this, do not go into mathematics if you want to have a job, you will be passed on opportunities by people with business degrees and certifications. That is what employers want, if you want a job, you are wasting your time and effort on these courses.
I am a moron for panicking and choosing to study math after completing my bachelors in biology, because, for some reason I thought mathematicians had a good job outlook.
it’s impossible to find jobs that value problem solving and critical thinking over some basic certification in SQL or a trendy programming language.
The system is broken. Companies care more about ticking off tool certifications than recognizing the ability to understand and model complex systems
if you're thinking math will open doors to a fulfilling career, consider what the job market truly values first. Certifications > Degree,
EDIT: since some of yall mfers dont believe me, check out this job posting: https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1g5djxm/i_work_in_customer_service_there_are_people_on_my/
r/mathematics • u/Will_Tomos_Edwards • Oct 29 '23
Not a rigorous proof but a visual I came up with to hopefully clarify intuitively how block matrix multiplication works
r/mathematics • u/Orderi • Aug 19 '26
Honestly I don't really care whether statement is true or not, what I want to know is the reasoning, the inspiration, the trials and errors. I think Lean is cool but if the futur of math is unintelligible code written by AI, what's the point ?
(Sorry for my english)
r/mathematics • u/Federal-Edge6099 • 7d ago
We have an inverse for e^x, we have an inverse for xe^x, but what about other functions?
I just think some equations would be way easier if we added inverses for functions like e^x±x and e^x±e^-x. If they do exist, I will be glad to be informed so. If they don't, here it is:
Since the inverse of xe^x is W(x) the inverse of e^x+x is U(x) and the inverse of e^x-x is V(x). I don't care if they're not useful, I want them to exist because that would give excuses for buttons to add to calculators. Speaking of which, they should add the lambert W function to calculators.
the inverse of e^x+e^-x should be defined using the hyperbolic trig functions, but I don't see how you could do that so I'm just calling the inverse S(x) and T(x) (T(x) is for e^x-e^-x) for now.
Edit: TBH I realized it was a dumb idea, so just ignore everything I said.
r/mathematics • u/[deleted] • Jul 06 '24
9 multiplied by anything is basically 9?
Watch.
9 x 150,256 = 1,352,304
BUT THAT’S NOT 9 right?
Wait.
1 + 3 + 5 + 2 + 3 + 0 + 4 = 18
1 + 8 = 9
Now let’s check another number
9 x 99,256,234 = 893,306,106
8 + 9 + 3 + 3 + 0 + 6 + 1 + 0 + 6 = 36
3 + 6 = 9
No matter what number you multiply by 9 if you follow this step by step adding each individual place together and keep doing it until it’s a single digit answer it will always be 9.
I just thought this was very interesting because I think 9 is the only number 1-9 that has this specific phenomenon occur. Even if it’s a simplistic phenomenon.
r/mathematics • u/MathTutorAndCook • Nov 16 '25
Obviously Theres a broad range considering every person and series of courses is different depending on a lot of factors. However, I finished with a 3.5 gpa in math related courses, in 2018, from CSU Sacramento
What could I consider myself in the 1% of? Since it's not the same as Engineering or CS or more applicable maths
r/mathematics • u/Ok-Editor-665 • 22d ago
Imagine a Quidditch match in which the Golden Snitch is completely invisible.
You know exactly the initial distance, but not the direction. You move faster than the Snitch, which moves at constant speed and always chooses the direction that takes it as far away from you as possible.
Is there a trajectory that allows you to catch the Snitch?
I made a video exploring the problem, the geometry, the differential equations, and a possible strategy. The proof is partially incomplete (but simulations work), so I'd genuinely love to hear your ideas, objections, or alternative approaches.
Video link: https://youtu.be/0xVusHRQePQ
r/mathematics • u/[deleted] • Jan 02 '25
Like seriously. Why can we not say 1/0= [any random symbol will do] @ (let)
AND I KNOW I'M GOING TO MAKE A FOOL OF MYSELF SINCE I'M NOT A MATHEMATICIAN WHO CAN DO THIS BUT I JUST WANT THIS TO BE A THEORETICAL IDEA THAT OTHERS CAN REFINE INTO SOMETHING FUNCTIONAL, OR TELL ME WHY WHAT I'M SAYING JUST CANNOT BE TRUE NO MATTER WHAT
And then assign some properties to it like
there is a third set of numbers outside the domain of real or complex numbers, for my theoretical case let's call them hyper numbers since we're just having fun right now. A hyper number is defined as c@, where c is any number.
@ⁿ=@ n € R; n≠0
n/@ = 0 n € R
And a number having a real, an imaginary and a hyper element is considered a true number. Represented as a + ib + @c
And some more properties I'm too dumb/too lazy to think of. But this is only meant as a question about why we let √-1 exist but not 1/0. Why do we not say 1/0 has singular solution that is just out of our universe similarly to how we deal with i. Why is that?
Edit: okay thanks for all your answers, I get it now, it's both not very useful and leads to contradictions. Y'all can stop commenting for me. I got my answer.
r/mathematics • u/DasEdgy • May 02 '23
r/mathematics • u/Confident_Salt_8108 • Mar 16 '26
A Polish mathematician’s research-level problem, which took 20 years to develop, was solved by GPT-5.4 in just one week. After several attempts, the model produced a 13-page proof that demonstrated a level of reasoning the creator previously thought impossible for AI. This milestone marks a shift from AI as a basic assistant to a legitimate collaborator in high-level scientific discovery.
r/mathematics • u/ReSpekMyAuthoriitaaa • Oct 29 '23
r/mathematics • u/AlbuStark • Apr 21 '26
I've seen several videos online, even from respected accounts who should know more than me, say something along the lines of "you can fill Gabriel's Horn with paint, but you can't paint it." But the problem is, they are comparing volume to area. ANY finite volume could be theoretically spread infinitely thin to get an infinite area. Using the π litres of paint that is in Gabriel's Horn, we could theoretically spread it until it has a thickness of 0 and an area of infinity.
Let me know what you guys think of my reasoning, and if I made any mistakes.
r/mathematics • u/ZengaZoff • Mar 12 '25
I'm a professional mathematician and a faculty member at a US university. I hate pi day. This bs trivializes mathematics and just serves to support the false stereotypes the public has about it. Case in point: We were contacted by the university's social media team to record videos to see how many digits of pi we know. I'm low key insulted. It's like meeting a poet and the only question you ask her is how many words she knows that rhyme with "garbage".
Update on (omg) PI DAY: Wow, I'm really surprised how much this blew up and how much vitriol people have based on this little thought. (Right now, +187 upvotes with 54% upvote rate makes more than 2300 votes and 293K views.) It turns out that I'm actually neither pretentious nor particularly arrogant IRL. Everyone chill out and eat some pie today, but for god's sake DON't MEMORIZE ANY DIGITS OF PI!! Please!
r/mathematics • u/SpatiaCaeli • Jun 16 '26
I didn't learn that there was more than one math until I was an adult. In hindsight, it seems obvious that there would be. Why don't they just teach that from the start? "We're teaching you the mainstream math but there are many others."
Edit: clarification. It's a question about curriculum, not my teachers. I loved them.
r/mathematics • u/utoytargaryen • Dec 27 '19
Please help me and explain. Thanks!
r/mathematics • u/pretzlchaotl_ • Sep 21 '26
After many, many months of trial and error, I've made a symbolic expression and rewrite system 10x faster than sympy (specifically at constructing an arbitrary sequence of expressions; the rewriting is probably about as fast, but I'm not familiar enough with sympy to say for sure). It allows the construction of any expression that can be written in python, with the string representation of said expression being totally accurate in terms of python's evaluation order rules via parentheses. As for the rewrite algorithm, anything that can be expressed as pairs of expressions (<pattern>: <replacement>) in a dictionary can be applied. The only glitch I've encountered turned out to be user error when I tried getting it to apply two competing distributivity laws simultaneously. All that's left to do is format and add some documentation, and it will be ready to be applied to whatever algebraic problem users can concieve of (within scope, obviously). I'd be happy to demo anything you'd like, it will just have to be shared as copy-pasted screenshots for my lack of social media skills.
The pictures are:
Successful test of canonical forms for lattice operations [pattern || expression ==> rewritten || expected] Why are there colons prefixing some of the variables? They're not colons, just bindable unicode symbols that look exactly like colons.
Time test of various prototypes constructing expressions from scratch. Two red dots indicate the current version vs. Sympy. Yes, there's one version slightly faster, but it doesn't have nearly as many features. The blue stuff at the bottom is debris from a separate test.
r/mathematics • u/Big_Presentation_894 • Jun 28 '26
Addition and subtraction feel like primitive operations—you perform an action, and a result comes out. Since multiplication is just repeated addition, it shares the same “executable” quality.
But division seems categorically different. When calculating 20 ÷ 5, we aren’t actually “doing” anything; we’re asking a question: “How many times does 5 fit into 20?” This question requires a termination condition—that is, we must ask whether the remainder is smaller than the divisor. This resembles a logical expression more than an arithmetic operation.
This distinction seems to be reflected in formal mathematics as well. Division is not among the primitive operations of Peano arithmetic; it is defined later. Moreover, while addition and multiplication are total functions, division is a partial function—that is, it is not defined for every input.
My question is: Is division viewed as a genuine arithmetic operation in elementary mathematics, or is it more of a derived logical expression? Is there an established position on this matter?
r/mathematics • u/[deleted] • Feb 28 '24
I don't mean problems, I mean like algebra, calculus, etc.
r/mathematics • u/[deleted] • Aug 31 '25
Imagine explaining stokes' generalization to a 4 dimensional manifold or the thermodynamic definition of temperature after he just burnt his hand.
r/mathematics • u/CharlesorMr_Pickle • Feb 17 '25
I've always found it to be a misleading acronym, as multiplication and division can be flipped around, and addition and subtraction can be flipped around.
pe(md)(as) feels more accurate, or just visualizing division as multiplying by the reciprocal and subtraction as adding a negative number.