r/mathbiceps • • Oct 16 '26

Misc Found this problem.

Post image

Hey there. Loved your content and the way you explore and explain the fastest solution (even if it might be present in the polar opposite of the domain of that problem). Here is a question that I found doomscrolling. I want to know the proper textbook approach to solve such NOT SO IIT problems. I hope someone in the comments will come up with an answer.

114 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

8

u/Nomadic_General Oct 16 '26

It’s easy no?

(x^2,x) are the points on y=x^2

If you rotate them by 1 degree
(x^2 cos 1 +x sin 1, -x^2 sin 1 + x cos 1)

Let the x component = x’
For this x’ there will be two solutions of x as the equation is quadratic.

The same solutions when put in the y component will give two different y

1

u/Omigod_7 Oct 16 '26

Yeahh. I am just looking for if any more methods could solve this! It's a great place for that right?

1

u/Nomadic_General Oct 16 '26

Idk lmao. I don’t even follow this sub.

3

u/DrJaneIPresume Oct 16 '26

Even easier: show that the slope of the regular parabola decreases without bound on the left. Thus there's some point where the slope of the tangent line is 1º off the vertical. The second derivative is always positive, so the curve is strictly above the tangent line.

Now rotate by 1º clockwise. The 1º tangent line is now a vertical line, with the curve strictly to the right of it, meaning there are two nearby points on the same vertical line, so the rotated curve fails the VLT.

1

u/98nissansentra Oct 20 '26

This is the most intuitive proof on here, I think.

2

u/OmegaCookieMonster Oct 16 '26

You're right, but it's (x,x2) I feel I should mention

1

u/Downtown_Finance_661 Oct 16 '26

Is there  angle small enough for the rotated curve stay a function?

2

u/DrJaneIPresume Oct 16 '26

No! For a line of any negative slope, no matter how big (slope = tangent of angle the line makes with the vertical), there is some point on the parabola that has a tangent line with that slope, and which it stays strictly to one side of. Rotate to make that tangent line vertical, and you now have two nearby points on the same vertical line.

1

u/localizeatp Oct 19 '26

Yes. Zero degrees.

1

u/Remarkable_Fee4136 Oct 16 '26

At low enough x, y=x² will have a slope lower than -cot1°, so then the rotated curve would loop back on itself and be multivalued.

1

u/BadJimo Oct 16 '26

1

u/Im_a_hamburger Oct 18 '26

You can use rotation matrices now instead of having to decompose them by the way.

1

u/Cryptographer-Bubbly Oct 16 '26

Point originally at x = a= - tan(pi/180) , y= a^2 gets rotated to lie on the vertical at (0, a^2 +a^4) . The point at 0,0 gets mapped to 0,0

So the resulting curve has multiple y coordinates for same x=0 - not a function

1

u/royalebot9000 Oct 16 '26

The answers here are correct, but i definitely find it more intuitive to think of the line x = 0 in the above graph, and then rotate everything BACK -1 degrees. Then its just y=x^2 and a line y = tan(-89)x, which certainly intersect twice.

1

u/WE_THINK_IS_COOL Oct 17 '26

That made it click for me. That’s crazy tho, if you were standing in the middle of an actual infinite parabola and you could see infinitely far it would appear to curve overhead and almost connect with itself. Not what I would have expected.

1

u/MathManiac5772 Oct 17 '26

This is how I did it too. What I like about this approach is that you don’t even need to solve for the slopes if you don’t want to. Just call the line y=mx for some m < 0. Then mx = x^2 has two solutions, namely x = 0 and x = m.

1

u/Slow_Comfortable_128 Oct 16 '26

x^2. the further out you go, the steeper it gets. at some point the steepness gets really steep. if you rotate really steep by a small amount, it goes past vertical. QED.

1

u/Elspaddy Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

ycos(a) - xsin(a) = (xcos(a) + ysin(a))**2 where a = -pi/180

1

u/ZackoBear Oct 17 '26

Just geometrically. The slope is 2x. Which with larger x values eventually passes less than one degree from vertical. Rotating makes that one degree makes it verticle which fails the vertical line test.

1

u/wannabemedico23 Oct 17 '26

therlaaa

but i guess minimise the the graph,

draw line parallel to y axis

it will intersect two coordinate ie two y value for a single x value

so it is not a function

:)))))))

1

u/wannabemedico23 Oct 17 '26

and i guess the y values will be the solutions of that quadratic equation as my fellow redditor mentioned

1

u/Reasonable_Medium_53 Oct 17 '26

Here are many answers but I can't see any question?

1

u/Desmond_Ojisan Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 18 '26

Simple. A line of 1 degree as a finite calculable slope, lets call it 'a'. The slope for the function is 2x, meaning when you go negative enough you will surely reach a negative slope steaper than the 'a' (only negative), so by rotating the function 1 degree what was a steep down slope tilts past being completely vertical, meaning there is more than 1 y result per x value.

1

u/Arcanite_Cartel Oct 18 '26

It is a function if you rotate the coordinate system.

1

u/MathTutorAndCook Oct 18 '26

It's easier to rotate it in polar coordinates

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

well think about how the function would turn around its linear direction. The slope of x^2 would equal 2x, meaning the limit of the slope in such direction would equal negative infinity. Having this slope turned 1 degree will have it turned around past being vertical by some point compared to the X axis. This turnaround would make the curve fail the horizontal line test, hence making it not work out.

1

u/Personal-Peace-9947 Oct 20 '26

You can prove that the y-axis meets this curve at 2 points. Rotate the curve back 1 degree so the curve becomes y=x2.

Let the y-axis line (before) be y=mx. So solving for the 2 points: mx=x2 , x=0 and x=m.

Hence a vertical line (in original graph) means a curve in 2 points, hence not a function.

1

u/Jazzlike_Platypus430 Oct 16 '26

A curve can hardly be a function, if we stick to strict formulation which is encouraged in math.

If you insist of "... is NOT a graph of a function" (using a and knowing its meaning), that's false too. Any curve can be described parametrically, by two functions of one variable, say (x(t), y(t)) on R^2. In this case it is sufficient to say that (x, y) are related to standard coordinates (x', y') by a 1 deg rotation, and the parabola is given by x' linear in t and y' quadratic in t.

It's true though this parabola is not a graph of any function y(x) (these coordinates are barely visible on your picture).

Moral of the story - think before you write.

2

u/Wild-Store321 Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

If we stick to strict formulation (which is highly encouraged in math!!) a function is defined as a relation with extra properties. A relation is a subset of a product set. This curve is a subset of RxR, hence a relation. So you can ask: is this relation a function?

Moral of the story - think before you write

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER

1

u/Sigma2718 Oct 17 '26

A wikipedia article on maths that starts intuitive and ramps up the rigor via formal definitions after understanding has been built? Surely I must be dreaming!

0

u/camilo16 Oct 20 '26

Consider the vector [-x, x2]. And now consider its normalized version (divide by sqrt(x4 + x2))

as x goes to infinity the x4 term will dominate, I will same myself some l'hoptial shennanigans and just jump straigth to

[-x / x2, x2 / x2]

Which converges to [0, 1]

A vertical asymptote. If you rotate that by any non zero angle, then there will exist some real number x for which you would have produced two points with the same x coordinate.

The more rigorous way to do it is to start with [-x, x2], them multiply by the rotation matrix of 1 degree and then show that the resulting vector curve has at least two points with the same x and different y (but I don;t want to do the algebra right now).

1

u/old_cheesecake_67893 Oct 21 '26

Chat gpt 🤣🫱

0

u/camilo16 Oct 21 '26

I typed it.

You can see the more rigorous version in a comment by someone else.