r/marxism_101 • • Jul 13 '25

"liberals with always collaborate will fascists to fight against socialists"

496 Upvotes

I hear this phrase or phrases similar quite a lot but don't understand the absolutism. Like the pause during the Chinese civil war where the Kuomintang and ccp collaborated against the imperial japanese is a clear counterargument. Castro's Cuba and Franco's Spain were trade partners (albeit a collaboration between socialism and fascism, not liberalism). I mean world war 2 was literally all about an alliance between liberals and socialists against fascists.

I assume it's meant more intranationally than internationally but idk.

Edit: I'm not saying liberals don't collaborate with fascists, or even that they don't usually collaborate with them. It was more generally a question of why people say things of this nature even though there's big exceptions. It led to a better discussion on why the socialists sometimes collaborate with liberals. The best answer for said question I've seen is that it's more about the preservation of capital and in rare cases it's more oppurtunistic to side with socialists for this. (albeit only temporarily.)


r/marxism_101 • • Aug 05 '25

Anti-intellectualism in some corners of Marxism

77 Upvotes

tl;dr at the bottom, but:

A number of times, on a separate reddit account, I've tried to express an interest in the application of dialectical materialism beyond political economy and class society, ie nature. It doesn't seem unreasonable to me that this philosophy can be applicable beyond the development of social relations to property. We are, after all, products of nature not separate from it and attempts to explain DM regularly use examples from the non-human world such as how DM can be seen in the fits and bursts of evolutionary biology, rather than the older belief of it being a steady, even crawl. But whenever I attempt to discuss it, I am only ever confronted with dismissal because such thoughts apparently don't help overthrow capitalism or something.

This attitude of promoting intellectual poverty (at least until a revolution, if not generally) seems to me parallel with the erroneous view that socialists should practice material poverty, and that anything other than going to work in a factory all day to then go home to your wife and children, eat sleep and repeat in a boiler suit is somehow bourgeois. Why is this, when Marx was first and foremost a philosopher? And is there a space suitable for Marxist philosophers to challenge not just interpretations of society but of the world around us, so that we might better understand it? If we can also interpret the natural world with DM, might this not help us better innovate for a communist future, since we will be better equipped to find solutions to problems we currently struggle with? Or even it may improve the arts if we understand the world differently, not just the human world?

---

tl;dr: why are so many online Marxists anti-intellectual and look down on using DM to understand more than just class society, viewing such attempts to interpret the natural world as unproductive just because they don't ignite a proletarian revolution, and is there a space where the value of philosophising is recognised?


r/marxism_101 • • Jul 28 '19

Are there any good Marxist analysis of mental illness in capitalist society?

62 Upvotes

I got diagnosed with Borderline Personality Disorder. One of the key features of the illness is a “markedly impoverished” self image. This reminded me of Marx’s theory of alienation, and how the worker is alienated from themselves while they’re at work.

I am not trying to suggest that BPD and alienation are synonymous. My sense of self is impaired 24/7, not just while I am on the clock. But there’s probably a relationship there that’s worth exploring.

If any of you know about any Marxist analysis of mental illness in capitalist society I would love some recommendations.


r/marxism_101 • • Dec 05 '25

How to get into Marx's sociology

59 Upvotes

While Marx is a highly controversial figure in modern economics, I have heard that he is almost universally regarded as one of the most important thinkers for sociology. What should I read if I am primarily interested in the ways that Marx influences modern sociology?


r/marxism_101 • • Jun 16 '25

On “Socialism in one country”

48 Upvotes

Now I first want to make clear that I do not believe that socialism can be achieved in one country (not only does Engels, Lenin, and even young Stalin attest to this, but it is evidenced by every “AES” state and is just illogical in general). But with that being said, what is to be done when world revolution doesn’t happen?

Was “socialism in one country” an inevitable outcome after the failure of the German Revolution? And what should a nation that has undergone a revolution do when they are left isolated like Cuba, Vietnam, etc. (using them as examples, I’m sure there are many views on their revolutions here)?

Can the lower phase of communism be achieved without world revolution? Was Stalin just wrong in his implementation, or is the idea completely nonsensical? And if it truly isn’t possible, what should these states do? I know LeftComs don’t agree with Trotsky’s degenerated worker’s state theory.

TLDR, what should the USSR have done after the failure of Germany’s revolution, and could socialism (abolishing of commodity production etc) have been achieved in the one nation?


r/marxism_101 • • Mar 16 '25

Are retail workers Proletariat?

46 Upvotes

Hey so this might be a dumb question but I’m really new to leftist theory.

So I work a retail job do I and other retail workers fall into being apart of the Proletariate?

We don’t technically make anything but we do provide the labor for our bosses.

I’m not trying to be condescending or anything I’m genuinely curious.


r/marxism_101 • • Apr 01 '20

Why does Marx take on the label of "materialism"?

44 Upvotes

In the Paris Manuscripts Marx while commenting on Feuerbach says this about materialism:

Here we see how consistent naturalism or humanism is distinct from both idealism and materialism, and constitutes at the same time the unifying truth of both. We see also how only naturalism is capable of comprehending the action of world history.

It seems that at this point Marx does not like the label materialist and instead prefers "naturalism" or "humanism," and it seems to me that humanism is the perfect label for his thought since he is analysing human activity.

In the Theses on Feuerbach Marx now takes on the label of materialism:

The standpoint of the old materialism is civil society; the standpoint of the new is human society, or social humanity.

Marx is now calling himself a "new" materialist while maintaining that his work is from standpoint of social humanity.

Next in The German Ideology, Marx begins formulating his "materialist conception of history." Now it seems to me that he is using this to describe a method, when traditionally "materialism" is an ontology.

When I think of materialism I think of Epicurus, Democritus, Spinoza, etc. All these thinkers are metaphysicians. Marx is not a metaphysician, he is not making ontological claims, in fact, he makes it pretty clear that he is working off empirical claims:

the premises from which we begin are not arbitrary ones, not dogmas, but real premises from which abstraction can only be made in the imagination. They are the real individuals, their activity and the material conditions under which they live, both those which they find already existing and those produced by their activity. These premises can thus be verified in a purely empirical way. [emphasis mine]

Why does Marx take on this label if he is trying to distance himself from philosophers? I know he wrote his thesis on Epicurus and Democritus, so it is clear he had in interest in materialist philosophy. Is he just using it as a fancy term for atheism to distance himself from the more religious Hegelians?


r/marxism_101 • • Feb 27 '20

What are some good Marxist books apart from the classics

43 Upvotes

Can someone recommend some modern marxist works, works on current social and political situations etc.


r/marxism_101 • • May 01 '21

For Marx, sociological phenomena like bigotry were products of a society’s material conditions, and so to abolish bigotry necessarily means to abolish capitalism, so why is “class reductionism” wrong?

42 Upvotes

I am very confused by the epithet class reductionist, it seems in a sense anti-Marxist. From what I understand it is used against people who want to center the class struggle over other struggles like racism or sexism; the natural conclusion to draw from this is that these people believe racism and sexism and homophobia or anti-Semitism etc are entities distinct and independent from class and capitalism, that it is possible to successfully struggle against sexism or racism or anti-Semitism, that is to say defeat and totally abolish it, without having abolished capitalism and class society.

From an orthodox Marxist analysis as far as I am aware, bigotry is not just some “thing”, a cold that you catch or something, they like all other social and sociological phenomena come forth from material conditions, and so bigotry will not be defeated until the material conditions change in such a way that doesn’t produce the phenomenon, to say that bigotry of any sort can be abolished separately from the abolition of capitalism, that through discussion, education, consciousness, protest etc within the framework of a superstructure that is unchanged in material terms on it’s own can effect social relations is anti-materialist and materialism is the core of Marxism.

Basically what I am trying to express is that it seems to me that not centering class struggle and treating racism and the like as something separate rather than as a function of class society is like a doctor who has a patient with a brain tumour deciding that the first priority is to try and relieve the pain of the terrible headaches that the tumour causes, as opposed to destroying the actual tumour; in that scenario what the patient gets is at best is temporary reprieve from the suffering.

That doesn’t mean that it’s wrong to fight against bigotry and try to make life as pleasant as it can be within the context of current material conditions, just as any socialist wouldn’t oppose raising the minimum wage even though wage labor is exploitative and basically theft by nature and should be abolished, because in the mean time a few more dollars in peoples’ hands at the end of the day will make their lives a bit better. However it seems to me that Marxist praxis necessitates centering the class struggle and I am having difficulty trying to think of a justification within dialectical materialism for conceiving of bigotry of any sort as being independent from material conditions and social relations under capitalism and thus as a problem that can be solved on it’s own, without having solved (that is, overthrew) the problem of capitalism — if there is please tell me I’m quite curious.

I want it to be made very clear that I have no desire to argue with, insult or offend anyone. I’m just interested.


r/marxism_101 • • Mar 14 '20

What do Marxists mean when they say Bourgeois morality?

42 Upvotes

I've heard the term thrown around and I can't seem to find any works or things that talk about it, so I anyone who has a good definition what does it mean? Thank you in advance for anyone who answers!


r/marxism_101 • • Feb 21 '19

Why do many Left Communists and Marxists reject electoralism when Marx said revolution could be achieved through democracy?

42 Upvotes

"Someday the worker must seize political power in order to build up the new organization of labor; he must overthrow the old politics which sustain the old institutions, if he is not to lose Heaven on Earth, like the old Christians who neglected and despised politics.

But we have not asserted that the ways to achieve that goal are everywhere the same.

You know that the institutions, mores, and traditions of various countries must be taken into consideration, and we do not deny that there are countries -- such as America, England, and if I were more familiar with your institutions, I would perhaps also add Holland -- where the workers can attain their goal by peaceful means. This being the case, we must also recognize the fact that in most countries on the Continent the lever of our revolution must be force; it is force to which we must some day appeal in order to erect the rule of labor."

La Liberte Speech, 1872


r/marxism_101 • • Dec 24 '19

How has capitalism changed since Das Kapital was written?

40 Upvotes

r/marxism_101 • • Mar 16 '23

Why feminism needs to be materialistic

38 Upvotes

Hello comrades.

I am a student who will hold a presentation, answering the question "why a materialist worldview is the foundation for the emancipation of women" (I am paraphrasing this, English is not my first language, and I will present it in german, so sorry for any grammatical mistakes.) But you get the idea.. It is supposed to be a plaidoyer for a materialist feminism and should uncover why liberal feminism is not actually feminist, since it only benefits privileged women. I have worked a lot on the presentation, since my teacher is anti-marxist, it needs to be "perfect", so she can`t touch me. I have collected some arguments and data, but maybe I am missing something... How would you argue this point? Any great sources that could support my cause? I would be immensely grateful for any kind of help. Thank you in advance, and solidaric regards!


r/marxism_101 • • Jul 31 '21

What marxist literature covers pre-capitalist modes of production?

37 Upvotes

r/marxism_101 • • Feb 05 '20

Who were the German thinkers Marx and Engels criticised in chapter 3 of the Communist Manifesto?

36 Upvotes

I'm just asking out of curiosity. Its clear the work they did actively harmed the bourgeois revolution that would have eventually pushed the proletariat towards their own revolution eventually, but I want to know who these people were.


r/marxism_101 • • Jun 12 '21

From a materialist standpoint, how did nationalism as an idea/concept came to be?

34 Upvotes

Nationalism affects our understanding of history almost retroactively. What were the material conditions that caused or aided the development of nationalism?


r/marxism_101 • • May 02 '19

Books about contemporary economic issues from a Marxist perspective?

34 Upvotes

I am hoping some people here can recommend books similar to "Business as Usual: The Economic Crisis and the Failure of Capitalism"by Paul Mattick which deal with contemporary economic issues from a Marxist perspective. A lot of the books I come across are more progressive moral critiques rather than the type of analysis in Mattick's work.

Special topics of interest to me: the stock market (venture capital, stock buybacks), real estate bubble, automation and technology, negative interest rates, consumer debt, pensions, birth rates and immigration, the future availability of jobs, generational wealth differences (the dismal millennial prospects). But anything from a materialist perspective covering topics I see in the news everyday would be great. Thank you!

EDIT: I just heard of these:
The Writing on the Wall: On the Decomposition of Capitalism and Its Critics by Anselm Jappe
World in Crisis: Marxist Perspectives on Crash & Crisis by Guiglelmo Carchedi
The Long Depression: Marxism and the Global Crisis of Capitalism by Michael Roberts


r/marxism_101 • • Dec 03 '25

I'm trying to understand the fundamentals of Marxism yet I find it hard to comprehend. Can you give me an easy introduction into Marxism?

33 Upvotes

r/marxism_101 • • Apr 03 '20

Reactionary Behavior of Trade Unions

33 Upvotes

In The Fundamentals of Revolutionary Communism, Bordiga writes:

History has taught us the unhappy truth that the ex-worker who leaves his job to work in the trade-union bureaucracy is generally more likely to betray his class than somebody originating from the non-proletarian classes. Examples? We could provide thousands of them.

I don't doubt the veracity of this statement, but I'd like to hear some examples of reactionary trade union behavior to build my understanding.


r/marxism_101 • • Jan 29 '20

Good Marxist historiographies on Chinese civil war?

33 Upvotes

r/marxism_101 • • Aug 09 '19

How does one contribute towards a Communist cause?

33 Upvotes

Up until I recently began reading theory, I was an ardent Anarchism. During that time, there was a consensus among Anarchists that if enough people began squatting, stealing, and forming workers' co-ops, capitalism would somehow collapse and communism would flourish. This is obviously nonsense.

I was wondering what Marxists would recommend as a sort of communist 'praxis'. Should I perhaps join an organization of some kind? I was thinking of organizing with my co-workers to directly advance our interests (in the form of a traditional labor union), but it seems like that would be some sort of reformism.

I know that there has to be more to Marxism than the 'armchair socialist lmao' meme that other tendencies seem to push, but it would be nice to have a theoretical basis for organizing rather than simply kicking over trash cans until the revolution comes.


r/marxism_101 • • May 05 '19

What's a good guide to Das Kapital that isn't David Harvey?

33 Upvotes

I'd prefer it to be in video form, but a book or other sort of text is also fine. I've seen tons of people criticise Harvey for a bunch of reasons, and the number of guides is huge, so I don't know which I should use.


r/marxism_101 • • Jul 14 '22

What did Karl Marx mean when he said, "Christian Socialism is but the holy water with which the priest consecrates the heart-burnings of the aristocrat."

31 Upvotes

My question isn't meant to be religious in any kind of way. I just need to understand what he meant by it - I'm thinking he was making an association, that maybe his words were an analogy - so what do you think he was trying to say? I appreciate any insight!


r/marxism_101 • • Nov 04 '19

Was Marx wrong regarding the working day?

31 Upvotes

Hello everyone, while reading chapter 10 of Capital “the working day” I did a quick google search and I came across this paper, which sets out to show that since Marx argued a uniform rate of surplus value, the hours of work would also have to be uniform. In which the the author attempts to show this as false. Thus refuting the idea that labor produces value. My understanding of Marx is still quite rudimentary, so I was wondering if anyone else had any thoughts, or refutations regarding the paper. Thank you


r/marxism_101 • • Jul 04 '21

When Marx says that proletarians through the State should impose "Equal liability of all to labor"

30 Upvotes

8. Equal liability of all to labor. Establishment of industrial armies, especially for agriculture

(The Communist Manifesto)

Does he want that labor to be mandatory for everyone? Like with punishment for those who don't work?