I am very confused by the epithet class reductionist, it seems in a sense anti-Marxist. From what I understand it is used against people who want to center the class struggle over other struggles like racism or sexism; the natural conclusion to draw from this is that these people believe racism and sexism and homophobia or anti-Semitism etc are entities distinct and independent from class and capitalism, that it is possible to successfully struggle against sexism or racism or anti-Semitism, that is to say defeat and totally abolish it, without having abolished capitalism and class society.
From an orthodox Marxist analysis as far as I am aware, bigotry is not just some “thing”, a cold that you catch or something, they like all other social and sociological phenomena come forth from material conditions, and so bigotry will not be defeated until the material conditions change in such a way that doesn’t produce the phenomenon, to say that bigotry of any sort can be abolished separately from the abolition of capitalism, that through discussion, education, consciousness, protest etc within the framework of a superstructure that is unchanged in material terms on it’s own can effect social relations is anti-materialist and materialism is the core of Marxism.
Basically what I am trying to express is that it seems to me that not centering class struggle and treating racism and the like as something separate rather than as a function of class society is like a doctor who has a patient with a brain tumour deciding that the first priority is to try and relieve the pain of the terrible headaches that the tumour causes, as opposed to destroying the actual tumour; in that scenario what the patient gets is at best is temporary reprieve from the suffering.
That doesn’t mean that it’s wrong to fight against bigotry and try to make life as pleasant as it can be within the context of current material conditions, just as any socialist wouldn’t oppose raising the minimum wage even though wage labor is exploitative and basically theft by nature and should be abolished, because in the mean time a few more dollars in peoples’ hands at the end of the day will make their lives a bit better. However it seems to me that Marxist praxis necessitates centering the class struggle and I am having difficulty trying to think of a justification within dialectical materialism for conceiving of bigotry of any sort as being independent from material conditions and social relations under capitalism and thus as a problem that can be solved on it’s own, without having solved (that is, overthrew) the problem of capitalism — if there is please tell me I’m quite curious.
I want it to be made very clear that I have no desire to argue with, insult or offend anyone. I’m just interested.