r/marsone • • Mar 16 '15

Dr. Joseph Roche, an assistant professor at Trinity College’s School of Education in Dublin, with a Ph.D. in physics and astrophysics Quits MarsOne With a Detailed Explanation Why

Thumbnail
medium.com
38 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Feb 16 '15

Mars One Announces the 100 round three astronaut candidates

Thumbnail
mars-one.com
26 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Jun 10 '15

Every Mars One deadline shifts exactly two years every year [OC] (x-post /r/space) — source in comments

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Feb 19 '15

Sorry, but those Mars volunteers are never getting off the ground [x-post (r/redplanet)]

Thumbnail
qz.com
20 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Aug 28 '14

Any Mars One astronauts on Reddit?

17 Upvotes

I just wondering if anyone who made it through the first round is on Reddit. What's your experience been like so far?


r/marsone • • Mar 21 '15

How Expensive is the Mars One Plan? A Cost Estimate from an Unaffiliated NASA Engineer

16 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am a propulsion engineer who works at the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory. I am currently working on the M2020 program which is a Mars rover mission similar to Curiosity launching in 2020. I am not an affiliate, backer, or applicant for Mars One, but I think on paper they do have a solid baseline from an engineering standpoint. As to whether they can actually raise the money they need, I won't comment on since I don't know much of anything about fund-raising at this scale.

Below is a cost estimate based on a comment I made here during an argument with one of the many /r/space redditors who seem determined to think Mars One is a scam with malicious intentions. Maybe this will help you out the next time someone claims such a mission would cost "hundreds of billions to a trillion dollars or more".

When I first heard of Mars One in the summer of 2012, I read their plan and was pleasantly surprised it was very close to how I would recommend getting to Mars as cheaply as possible. One problem I did have was with the cost estimate of $6B. Instead, off the top of my head, I guessed they would need roughly triple that ($18B) for the first crew, and the costs would come back down closer to their original estimate ($6B) for each subsequent crew. After doing this analysis I was pleasantly surprised to see how close that guess was to this more refined estimate.

Basis of Estimate:

To estimate the cost of the combined robotic and manned missions to Mars, I propose we use Apollo as the basis of estimate for the technology development and operations of the manned mission, since that is the only manned mission with a similar scale ever done. This will mean we'll need to account for the differences between flying to the Moon versus Mars, as well as the advances in technology in the past half-century. For the robotic missions we have much more modern examples of Mars landers, orbiters, and rovers to use.

So as I stated above, in order to use Apollo numbers, we need to account for the difference in difficulty between landing on the surface of Mars versus landing on the Moon. As well as the difference between landing on either over 40 years ago versus now. To both at once, let's look at something we did on the Moon in the Apollo days, and something we did on Mars very recently. The entire Surveyor Program cost $469 million in 1966-68. In 2015 dollars that's about $3.2 billion for seven spacecraft or about $457 million per lander. These are basic robotic lander missions made by JPL as Apollo precursor missions. For a modern equivalent, also made by JPL, the Phoenix mission was a Mars lander that launched in 2007 and cost $386 million ($435 million in 2015 dollars) including the launch vehicle.

So, even when not accounting for the economies of scale that the Surveyor program benefited from, we sent an even more capable lander to surface of Mars for less money ($457M vs $435M). Based on this, I would say increased difficulties of traveling to Mars, communicating with an object at Mars, and landing at Mars, are less significant than the technological advances and improvements in efficiency made since the days of Apollo. Good to know we've gotten a little better at this in nearly half a century. Another benefit of this example is that almost the entire Phoenix lander was built by Lockheed Martin, the same contractor Mars One is supposedly working with now (which explains why all the lander images on their website look so much like Phoenix).

Although the above example estimates that it might actually be cheaper to go to Mars today than it was to go to the Moon in the days of Apollo, I'll call it even.

Manned Mission Cost Estimate:

Now, to get back to Apollo. The breakdown I see from the Apollo wikipedia article is this:

  • Apollo spacecraft: $7,945.0 million

  • Saturn I launch vehicles: $767.1 million

  • Saturn IB launch vehicles: $1,131.2 million

  • Saturn V launch vehicles: $6,871.1 million

  • Launch vehicle engine development: $854.2 million

  • Mission support: $1,432.3 million

  • Tracking and data acquisition: $664.1 million

  • Ground facilities: $1,830.3 million

  • Operation of installations: $2,420.6 million.

This adds up to about $23.9 billion, but one important thing to note is that the entire development cost for the Saturn launch vehicle, including the engines, is included here. The invention of the F-1 engine is possibly one of the greatest engineering feats in human history and the constant destruction of test articles is where rocket science got it's infamous reputation from. It would be ridiculous for the sake of this comparison to include the cost of developing these engines, as well as an entire class of launch vehicles, into the cost of the mission. Instead these costs should be replaced with the launch costs associated with launching on a commercial launch vehicle, which Apollo did not have the luxury of.

Subtracting the $9.6B for the launch vehicle development from the total leaves us with $14.3B which in 2015 dollars is about $91.1B for 17 missions, 11 of which were manned. Now as a compromise I would roughly say we should divide by 13 here since that's the number of missions that included a lunar module (which is a large part of the non-launch cost), which leaves us with $7.0B per mission in 2015 dollars. Now let's add the launch costs back in.

Now based on my reading of the Mars One roadmap they plan to first launch six supply missions for the first crew, which will likely all require heavy launches. For the heavy launches to be conservative I'm going to assume we're using something similar to a Delta IV Heavy, which comes in at the hefty, monopolistic price of $375 million per launch. If the Falcon Heavy is ready anytime soon, Musk claims it will be a third that price, but that's not something I would bet on being ready anytime soon. Lastly the actual crew vehicle will be assembled in-space requiring by my estimation three heavy launches and two standard manned launches, for which we'll just use a Falcon 9 since it's probably safe to assume it will be man-rated by then. The Falcon 9 has a nice competitive price tag of just $61 million. Here's a summary of launch costs for the manned mission:

  • Cargo missions 1-6, Delta IV Heavy ($375Mx6 = $2250M)

  • Mars Transit Vehicle (MTV) Piece 1: Transit Habitat, Delta IV Heavy ($375M)

  • MTV Piece 2, Mars Lander Capsule w/Assembly Crew, Falcon 9 ($61M)

  • MTV Pieces 3 and 4, Propulsion Modules, Delta IV Heavy ($375Mx2 = $750M)

  • Flight Crew to swap with Assembly Crew, Falcon 9 ($61M)

Manned Launch Cost Total: $3497M ~= $3.5B

Robotic Mission Cost Estimate:

Now let's estimate the costs of the robotic precursor missions. On the Mars One roadmap they plan to have one Mars lander, one Mars orbiter, one Mars rover, and one deep-space orbiter around the L5 Lagrange point. For the lander we can use the Phoenix lander mentioned above ($435 million). For the rover, it makes the most sense to use the Mars Exploration Rovers rather than Curiosity since the rovers Mars One uses will surely be solar-powered rather than powered by RTG, and also will likely not need to be as big as Curiosity is. The two MER rovers (Spirit and Opportunity) cost a combined $924 million for all of their development, launches, and operations. Although we're losing some cost of scale we'll estimate the cost of one rover as simple half of this as $462 million in 2003 which would be about $587 million in 2015. For the orbiters I'll use Mars Odyssey as a baseline since that was also made by Lockheed Martin. Odyssey was $297 million in 2001 which is about $392 million in 2015. One thing to remember is that all of these costs for the robotic missions include the launches as well. As a summary:

  • Mars Lander (based on Phoenix): $435M

  • Mars Orbiter (based on Odyssey): $392M

  • Mars Rover (based on MER): $587M

  • L5 Orbiter (based on Odyssey): $392M

Robotic mission total (including launch costs): $1805M ~= $1.8B

Total Cost Estimate:

So to add up what is needed for the first crew:

  • Development, construction, operation, and launches of robotic missions: $1.8B

  • Development, construction, and operation of manned mission: $7.0B

  • Launches for manned mission: $3.5B

Total without margin for crew one: $12.3B

Conclusion:

I'm going to leave the estimate as it is here, but some other things to consider would be how much margin is needed in addition to this value (typical values range from 10-30%, likely 10% for the robotic missions, and 30% for the manned mission). Another thing to consider however is that the entire estimate above is based off of missions which were managed by NASA. Missions managed by NASA are always significantly more expensive due to the extremely low risk-tolerance NASA has. When you become more risk-tolerant, the numbers can start to look very different. For instance the Mars Orbiter Mission launched last year by India was only $73 million, a fraction of the cost of a NASA Mars orbiter. Another large cost factor that Mars One could avoid is the tremendous suite of scientific instruments usually attached to NASA missions, which can sometimes account for as much as a third of all development and operational costs. It is likely that Mars One came to their sporty estimate of $6B by squeezing cost-savings out of the mission in a combination of the above methods, with possibly a healthy dash of optimism as well. So in conclusion, based on the above I would rate the probability of Mars One overrunning its $6B budget as high.

Any corrections or criticism is welcome. Do keep in mind this is clearly a rough first-order analysis, meant to show that Mars One likely has the correct order of magnitude in their cost estimate.


r/marsone • • Dec 30 '13

Congratulations on making the first cut.

16 Upvotes

You and only 1057 other aspiring astronauts around the globe have been pre-selected as potential candidates to launch the dawn of a new era – human life on Mars. Congratulations. You have made it to the next round.

Round 1 down. Three more to go. History, here I come!

Edit: Help crowd-source the project, dear Homo Astronauts ----> http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/mars-one-first-private-mars-mission-in-2018


r/marsone • • Dec 04 '12

Mars One is now a Dutch not-for-profit Foundation.

Thumbnail
mars-one.com
16 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Feb 14 '15

Mars One to soon announce names of 100 Shortlisted Applicants

Thumbnail
newsmaine.net
15 Upvotes

r/marsone • • May 05 '14

705 potential Mars settlers remain in Mars One’s astronaut selection process

Thumbnail
mars-one.com
15 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Dec 03 '13

Mars One to hold press conference with Lockheed Martin and Surrey Satellite Systems about first robotic mission to Mars on December 10th

Thumbnail
spaceref.com
15 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Apr 22 '13

I'm a little disappointed by the turnout of this press conference.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
15 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Mar 19 '15

Mars One CEO Bas Lansdorp answers questions about mission feasibility

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Feb 10 '15

If I die on Mars | A kind of weird Guardian documentary on Mars One candidate finalists

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Mar 22 '15

Mars One Fires Back

Thumbnail
innerspace.net
13 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Mar 18 '15

Mars Won

Thumbnail
darthcontinent.com
13 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Jul 29 '14

Mars One has launched a new community homepage

Thumbnail
community.mars-one.com
13 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Jun 02 '14

Mars One Teams with Endemol for Worldwide TV Event

Thumbnail
mars-one.com
13 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Dec 13 '16

Mars One receives €6 million investment

Thumbnail
mars-one.com
12 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Oct 10 '13

Dr. Robert Zubrin joined the Mars One advisory board.

Thumbnail
mars-one.com
12 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Nov 09 '12

What is everyones opinion on Mars One thus far?

12 Upvotes

Personally I think its a pretty crazy, and pretty awesome idea. I dont think it will really catch on though until they show some real technological progress. I havnt been keeping up with it lately, but is there any other information other than how they want it to be a big media event and them trying to get sponsors? Will they really be ready to even send a satellite there in 3 years?

what do you guys think


r/marsone • • Apr 29 '18

MarsOne - no money, no plan, no technology nothing

Thumbnail
inverse.com
11 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Jun 03 '15

Mars One Reveals True Number of Applicants: Just over 4,000

Thumbnail
medium.com
11 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Mar 22 '15

Finally, talking sense: We’re not going to Mars anytime soon, says this astronaut

Thumbnail
cantechletter.com
11 Upvotes

r/marsone • • Mar 19 '15

Mars One boots Joseph Roche from Mars programme for breaching confidentiality

Thumbnail
siliconrepublic.com
11 Upvotes