So some background. We have a solo that begins and ends our second song. Originally, the solo was written for French horn, so it was given to our mello section leaders. The issue? Its pretty difficult rhythm wise and it goes a bit high for the horn. For the past couple of weeks, the horn hasn't been able to get the rhythm, hes not coming in at the right times, and he's been reaching for the high notes. I should note that he is literally the only one playing, like not even drumline is playing so when he messes up, EVERYONE gets messed up. My director transposed the music for a saxophone and has been working with one of our sax section leaders to take the horns spot. I've listened to both because they asked for mt suggestions and honestly the sax is much better. Even after just 2 days he is playing on tempo, coming in at the right times, and hitting all the notes (all of which the horn struggles with). Today is the first day we were going to perform our second song and the director said the horn was playing the solo. He cited a bunch of logistical reasons but im so worried for our show tonight. I want to tell him that the sax should be given the solo but my director has a unique talent to make you feel bad for asking then running off to do something else without deciding anything. Any tips? TL;DR I don't agree with my directors soloist choice and it's messing with the band, what do I do?
Edit: alot of people don't seem to realize im the field commander. I have had members come up and complain about how the soloist is messing them up. Ive never gotten involved with any soloist choice before (because i trust my director) but also ive never had a bunch of people come complain to me. Part of my job description is liaison between the band and the director and I wanna fulfill that. I really get not involving my self, and I will follow that advice I just want you all to understand why I even want to intervene in the first place