r/manufacturing • • 1h ago

How to manufacture my product? Manufacturing Companies Solutions and Discussions

0 Upvotes

Is your markup high but your bank balance low? Many manufacturers focus on identified costs, but forget the hidden leaks in their operations.


r/manufacturing • • 13h ago

Other Is outsourcing CAD work practical for a small or mid-sized manufacturer?

7 Upvotes

We're a 35-person job shop that does a lot of fixtures and weld assemblies.

And right now, I'm trying to figure out if sending CAD out would save us time or just add review work.

Fixture drawings and small revisions seem easy to hand off. Anything with a tricky tolerance stack does not.

My plan is to give them our drawing template, standard tolerances, and weld and finish notes. I’d also mark the key features and include a few drawings we’ve approved.

Is that enough to start? And how do you know if the checking and redline time is low enough to make it worth it?


r/manufacturing • • 1d ago

Other Factory and commercial facility professionals: how do you monitor electricity use and equipment operation? (4-minute student survey)

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m Devansh, a 16-year-old school student from Uttar Pradesh. I’m researching how factories and commercial facilities track electricity use and equipment operation for an early-stage startup competition project.

If you’re a factory owner, facility or operations manager, energy or maintenance professional, or have relevant experience, I’d appreciate your input in this short survey:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSea9JIktVqRvtIHmof9PVp0YiyhhAxBh9iDXAuMOeaov0aiLA/viewform?usp=publish-editor

It takes about four minutes. Participation is voluntary. The form does not ask for your name, company name, or exact electricity bill. Please don’t include confidential business or production information.

I’m trying to understand current practices and challenges; this is research, not a product offer. Thank you for considering it.


r/manufacturing • • 1d ago

How to manufacture my product? Building a Manufacturing Community

Thumbnail chat.whatsapp.com
2 Upvotes

r/manufacturing • • 2d ago

News Automated Instant-Quote Platforms vs. Direct Engineering-Led Shops: An honest breakdown for EVT/DVT runs (from the factory side)

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone — full transparency up front: I help run an ISO 9001:2015 certified prototyping & low-volume shop in China (datumrapid.com). Since we constantly see hardware teams switching back and forth between big automated platforms (like Xometry, Protolabs, or RapidDirect) and smaller direct shops, I wanted to share an honest comparison of where each actually makes sense.

**Where big automated platforms win:**

- **Instant ballpark pricing:** If you need a budget number in 30 seconds for an internal slide deck, automated CAD parsers are unbeatable.

- **One-click convenience:** Great for simple 3-axis brackets where you don't need much back-and-forth.

**Where automated platforms struggle (and where direct engineering-led shops like ours fit better):**

  1. **Zero-context pricing on tight tolerances:** Automated parsers often penalize ±0.01 mm callouts blindly—or worse, route your job to an unknown subcontractor who misses a critical mating bore. With a direct shop, an actual manufacturing engineer reviews your STEP + 2D PDF first and tells you *where* you can relax tolerances to save 30% without hurting function.

  2. **Bridge Tooling & Urethane Casting (10–1,000 units):** Platforms treat every part like a commodity. For DVT enclosures, silicone vacuum casting or 7075 aluminum bridge molds require real human judgment on parting lines, draft angles, and Pantone/RAL surface finishes—plus direct feedback when you inevitably do an ECO revision.

  3. **Accountability & SOPs:** Instead of wondering which random shop got assigned your order, working directly with an ISO 9001:2015 audited shop means you see the actual shop-floor setup, CMM inspection data, and pre-shipment photos before parts board the plane to North America or Europe.

**The trade-off with us:**

We don't have an instant 10-second AI price widget on our site—you email your specs or drawings to an engineer ([email protected]) and get a real DFM review + quote within 24 hours.

Happy to answer any questions about sourcing CNC, urethane casting, or bridge tooling overseas—or feel free to roast our site (`datumrapid.com`) if you have feedback on what engineers want to see!


r/manufacturing • • 2d ago

Other To all the production supervisors/managers - hit me like a truck

7 Upvotes

26m. Been in manufacturing as an operator for 6 years ( left 7 months ago & unemployed ). BS in Management. Green lean six sigma ( Don't remember much on this since it was just exams & not projects ). OSHA 10. I did help coordinate work for a few associates in one of my previous role, not a lead role.

I'm trying to land my first production supervisor role and not hearing anything back. I know I don't have the lead or supervisor title but I know I can do it. I'm currently tweaking my resume right now

I'd love for a production supervisor/manager to review my resume or give me advice on how to get this first role. I'd go for a lead as well.

I think with a better resume or better way to explain my experience and my capability, surely someone will take a chance on me. I believe manufacturing management is the right career for me


r/manufacturing • • 2d ago

Quality Best setup for Quality Manuals when more and more clients are sending their own quality requirement list.

9 Upvotes

I've been noticing that with a lot of our recent projects, our customers are submitting their own list of items that need to be included in the Quality Manual that we provide. Some of these requirements contradict with other projects, while others line up...so i've been essentially creating a new quality manual for every new project. The issue is - now we have 7+ manuals and if we make any changes to our internal processes, I have to update 7 documents. I see this only getting worse.

How do your companies manage quality manuals on a project level? My best idea right now is to create an internal quality manual that is specific for us. When a client submits a requirement list, I create an addendum that says anything in this section supersedes what's in the base manual. Are there any better ways?


r/manufacturing • • 2d ago

Machine help Need help with diamond knurling with automatic axial feed

2 Upvotes

My dad has a thread rolling machine and wants to knurl a 5/8" long bar with diamond knurls (60-120-60-120 degs with 12 diamonds (counter along the periphery) and long edge along the axis) and the pattern is quite long
Since the pattern in long, automatic axial feed is desired.

We have reached out to a couple of suppliers, but so far no one has been able to design dies which gives the correct pattern and also provides axial feed.
If someone can help with the die dimensions (angle of helix on the die and tilt in die) it would be of great help...

As of now, one side impressions are correct, but the other doesn't overlap (if no tilt is given, the the impressions are correct, but there is no auto axial feed)


r/manufacturing • • 2d ago

How to manufacture my product? Inventing a product need manufacturing advice

1 Upvotes

I’m creating a product for general consumer use, I don’t want to go into too much detail because I’m still in the early stages of designing. But the product needs to fit these requirements:

Structural plastic that can handle repeated moderate uplift load on the midspan.

The product is a rectangular extrusion 1 span is hollow(4’) the other is telescoping (4’-7’) and each end will need to be able to interlock with fixed points.

The spans will be roughly 1/2” wide and 2”-3” tall the wall width is negotiable but the thinner the better.

Ai has generated some leads and I’ve looked at a dozen or so manufacturers and no one has quite what I’m looking for. Basically it’s an either or situation. They do telescoping extrusion but my dimensions are too small or they’re tooled for the right size but they don’t have telescoping capability. Also having a shop that could do some machining would be helpful.

What plastics do you recommend and other that push pins what are some other methods of semi permanent interlocking these parts? Could you recommend resources for research on developing plastic products and/or recommend a manufacturer who could meet my product requirements?


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

How to manufacture my product? t-slot hardware and fasteners for repeated quick assembly/disassembly?

3 Upvotes

I'm looking to build a frame out of some extruded aluminum 20x20 mm t-slot. The majority of the frame would need to be regularly assembled and disassembled, and I was hoping to get some guidance on how to do it as easily and quickly as possible.

I chose t-slot extruded aluminum because it's far cheaper than any other option I can come up with (while still potentially being easy to assemble/disassemble) and it's well supported by hardware and other options. I can get 2020 t-slot for around $0.16 per inch. I'm willing to consider other options if it's at most around $0.40 an inch or so and would be otherwise easier to assemble or possess other advantages over 2020 t-slot. The main function of the frame is just to provide a general structure, and to mount a small amount of hardware onto it. It'd need to support 30-40 pounds at one point, and I can surely reinforce this section if needed with a few extra rails/extrusions.

I've seen "quick frame connectors" but I'm not sure they'd be quicker from all I'm gathering.


I'd need to connect square frames to straight pieces repeatedly. In other words: I would have a 2D square in the X and Y dimensions, and I'd want to connect a straight line in the Z dimension at each edge/corner of the square. Then, I'd have another square frame on the other side of the Z dimension lines, to create a box. The actual design is slightly more involved than this, but that's the basic idea (just repeated a bit).

A small amount of connections could be hinged, but I don't know of an easy way to make a solid box (with additional things mounted along the t-slot rails of the frame) fold flat without some disassembly. The hinges I do have in mind would be somewhat atypical, more on that below.

I'm estimating around 30 connection points which need to be disassembled and reassembled each time, so anything I can do to make this process easier would be super great.


Connecting hardware

What should I look for in connecting hardware? My plan was to use open gusseted corner brackets for every corner (eg: https://www.mcmaster.com/5537T518/), and maybe some surface brackets for straight extensions (eg: https://www.mcmaster.com/5537T948/). Anything else I should look for which might be quicker? My idea was that if I just keep one side of the hardware attached to the rail, and on the other, I just remove the bolts, it should be as simple as lining things up and hitting it with an impact driver (if the t-nuts are fixed in place, see below).


Spring T-nuts

I know there's some spring loaded t-nuts on McMaster which attempt to hold the t-nut in place, but I'm not sure if they'd be the best choice or if they'd work well enough. If they hold the t-nut VERY firmly in place where they'd very rarely need any placement adjustments, then that may work well enough. But the McMaster options here are all "drop-in" meaning they could come out of the rail, so I'm not fond of that if they're easy to lose, get knocked out, etc.


Other ways to keep t-nuts in place

If spring loaded t-nuts don't work super great, I was loosely considering jb-welding (or another similar material) standard t-nuts in place along the rails, but I'm slightly concerned about getting this to line up perfectly for repeated assembly and disassembly. It seems like it might be an easy thing to screw up, or it might be easy to get the bolts jb-welded into the t-nuts while I'm waiting for the t-nuts and jb-weld to dry (causing a big mess).

I don't really need the jb-weld to be structural exactly, I just want it to hold the t-nuts in place. Maybe I could just put jb-weld around where the t-nut should sit, so that the t-nut can't slide out of the section of the rail where it should be? If I try to jb-weld the nuts fully to the rail, then the jb-weld would be subjected to the stress of that portion of the frame (thus making it structural at that point). Is there an easier way to fully keep the t-nuts in place, if the springs nor the jb-weld are super appropriate? Again, the whole idea is just to make it easier to disassemble/reassemble this.


Flat panels

I need to mount flat panels along the t-slot frames (think the sides of the "box"). My plan is to find brackets something like this: https://www.mcmaster.com/5537T305/ Which holds the panel mostly flush with the outmost edge of the t-slot frame, as opposed to holding it inline with the groove of the t-slot itself. Open to other ideas if there's an easier way to put side panels on. These panels would not need to be disassembled frequently.


Hinge

Is there a good way to hinge two t-slot extrusions inline with each other? Eg: [---] + (hinge) + [---] = [---][---] I've found hinges for t-slot, but they seem to be designed for putting two t-slots side by side, not two straight inline with each other. I'm not sure if it would work the other way or not.


Torx bolts

Is there any t-slot hardware made for a torx drive? I figure that if I'm disassembling and reassembling a bunch, it'd be good to get torx over hex, since it has better hardware lifespan (designed to wear the bit out, not the fastener head). I'm sure I could just buy separate bolts instead, but was wondering if this was common. Looks like most 2020 t-slot nuts are M5, so I'm sure I can just get any torx M5 bolt at appropriate length from McMaster and call it a day.


Recap:

  • Any other materials beside t-slot which would work better without being way more expensive? T-slot is sturdy, cheap, accessible, and modifiable.

  • Any better connecting hardware which I should be considering over the choices above?

  • Do spring loaded t-nuts work well at holding the t-nuts exactly in place?

  • Would jb-welding t-nuts in place work well, or am I just asking for trouble?

  • Inline hinge of two t-slot pieces?

  • Torx hardware?

  • Is the panel mounting approach valid, or is there something else I should consider for adding side panels?

  • Any other general advice?

Thank you very much! I really appreciate the assistance greatly.


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Other CS students looking for real shop-floor problems: what's still done by eye, on paper, or caught too late?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

We're computer science students (AI / intelligent systems) in Egypt working on our graduation project. We'd rather solve a real problem from the people who live it than invent one.

For those working in [manufacturing / maintenance / controls / lean / industrial engineering]:

  1. What's a task on your line or in your plant that is still done manually, by eye, or on paper? (quality inspection, logging failures, inventory counts, reporting, etc.)

  2. What breaks or gets delayed, and you only find out late?

  3. How do you handle equipment failures today: after they happen, or with scheduled maintenance? What does that cost you (downtime, scrap, time)?

  4. Have you tried any tools or systems for this? What was missing?

We're not selling anything. Everything we build will be open source, and we'll share a summary of the findings back here. We also don't need any confidential company data, only descriptions of the problems.

Even short answers are really valuable. Thanks!


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Other Every product have an ingredient list

5 Upvotes

I always thought product packaging( skinn care) had certain standard requirements, including listing the components. But I've come across skincare products that don't seem to have an components list at all

How are consumers supposed to know what they're buying or what goes into the products they're using?

Isn't ingredients ( or components) labelling supposed to be a basic packaging requirement? What factors leads to such a out product?


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Other Where do I go from the regular controls, automation and process engineering?

1 Upvotes

Context: I am a manufacturing engineer that has been working on design, automation, control systems, commissioning, SCADA work and OT/IT infrastructure for about 2.5 years.

I finished my masters last year from UofM in Manufacturing, during that I learned a lot while working as a Co-Op, basically taught myself control systems, robotics and automation design in a year while solving a broad range of problems for the battery manufacturing line.

I am an electronics undergrad so control logic, automation logic, electrical and electronics diagrams are like back of the palm, intuitive for me. Problems that senior engineers find complex are pretty easy for me to digest because I think in code and electronic logic.

In the last year and a half I worked for THK as an automation engineer, where I did everything that was thrown at me from setting up OT infrastructure for data logging, jigs and fixture design, firefighting controls issues, safety changes for preventing mishaps, planning and designing an AMR fleet operation, rigging, welding carts, programming robots, the whole 4 corners of the field. Then I moved to JnJ as a manufacturing engineer to work on their SCADA systems to configure, data logging, monitoring, alarming, BI capabilities, networking old hardware, designing databases, doing process characterization for new manufacturing processes, electrical changes, controls design for new processes, learned a lot of Injection Molding nuances, worked on a new line commissioning for cells, a lot of compliance learning (OSHA, NFPA/NEC standards, IEC), spares strategy, managing budget, coordinating vendors, creating BOMs, spare parts strategy, work instructions.

After doing all this, and doing it pretty well I feel like I am stuck in an industry where unless you have 5-8 years of experience, or are a people leader, you don't really get to drive larger manufacturing changes or initiatives.
Most of the time that I spend working, it's mostly basic knowledge coordination, my brain is only working at like a 10-15% of the capacity that it could otherwise. I have had more complex engineering challenges trying to figure out air intake issues on my car than a million-dollar manufacturing line. I've solved better manufacturing problems for my friend's job shop in a 3rd world country.

The question is, is a jack of all trades, 26 year old, feels like he could solve a lot more complex problems is just overthinking or are there actual manufacturing positions that exist, that require broad cascading problem solving skill sets, for if not complex at least financially significant projects?


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Quality Two 6063-T5 billets, same cert, 1.5 ΔE apart on the same black dye bath — how do you specify recyclate content?

0 Upvotes

I run extrusion and anodising in the same plant, so the failure mode I keep running into is not a process one, it is a purchasing-spec one. The billet spec that reaches the extruder says 6063-T5 and nothing else. Two heats can both certify to that and still behave differently in the tank.

The numbers I am working with: sulphuric anodising, 12 µm target, black dye at fixed concentration and temperature, same rack, same 6063 die. Billet A is primary metal, Fe around 0.20. Billet B carries roughly 35% post-consumer recyclate, Fe closer to 0.35, Si slightly up as well. Both pass incoming spectro against the 6063 window because the window is wide. Dyed black, the two lots land about 1.5 ΔE apart, which is visible side by side and invisible on a single part.

Before I write this into a purchase spec I would like to know how other people handle it, because there are three places to put the control and they cost different amounts:

  1. Cap the recyclate fraction in the billet spec (say 20%) and accept that the supplier's certified chemistry still tells you nothing about it.

  2. Require a spectro per heat with tighter internal limits than the alloy standard, and reject on Fe rather than on alloy.

  3. Stop controlling the metal and control the output: dye to a physical colour panel per lot, and eat the scrap when a lot misses.

Option 3 is what most anodising shops actually do and it is why the same colour code shows up different in two shipments. Option 2 is the only one that catches the cause, but I have not seen a customer write Fe limits into an extrusion PO.

The part I am least sure about: does the Fe difference actually shift the dye, or is it the film growth rate changing with the intermetallics and therefore the pore structure? If it is the second, capping Fe does not buy much and the answer is bath control plus a colour panel.

Anyone here specify recyclate content or Fe limits on 6063 billet for cosmetic anodised parts? And if you did, what did it do to the price per kg versus just accepting the colour variation and sorting?


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Quality Need Advice as a QA Manager

17 Upvotes

To start, I work in a CNC machining company. I got our company AS9100D certification from a (completely faked) ISO 9001 certification. The annual audits from a registrar were remote to tell you how serious they were. Quality was non-existent at this company. They had a quality manager who faked audits, management reviews, inspections, everything. I implemented numerous quality initiatives that were lacking. FAI, receiving inspection, and contract review, to name a few.

My problem is, our CEO does not know what the role of Quality Assurance is. For example, I am reviewing inspection reports, CofC's, purchase orders, incoming purchase orders, work travellers for the production floor, and outgoing shipments. He believes QA is simply inspection and verification. When i bring it up, he says "i thought you liked quality".

None of our department managers are forced to own their departments failures. For example, I write a CAR on how we do not have control of CNC programs on the production floor. I stated i can help get us where we need to be; I can help with the procedure, the document to control, etc, The manager of that department gets upset and leaves, doesnt agree to any of the CAR bullets, and the CEO says I piled this on to an already stressed manager. I have audited, and written up the lack of program control since 2019. If a correction involves another department, it will not happen. No other department has formal procedures, WI's, processes, nothing.

I have also been stuck with implementing a safety program and implementing an ERP from scratch, while maintaining my department. This is because we do not have any operational management, just department managers.

I do love quality assurance. I enjoy risk management, CAPA, etc. It's definitely my career of choice. I am just beginning to think its not worth continuing this fight with no support from above.


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Other How do you find buyers when you have inventory ready to sell?

0 Upvotes

I’m curious about how smaller manufacturing businesses handle sales, particularly those producing industrial machinery, equipment, or specialized components.
If you have machines or equipment ready for sale, how do you usually find potential buyers?

Do you rely mainly on distributors and dealers?
Do you have an in house sales team reaching out to businesses?
Do you get most inquiries through trade portals, referrals, or existing customers?
What happens when you have inventory but aren’t getting enough serious inquiries?

I’m exploring ways to help manufacturers connect with potential buyers and distributors, so I’d like to understand how this actually works in the industry.
Would be interested in hearing from owners or people directly involved in industrial sales.


r/manufacturing • • 3d ago

Other Industrial Maintenance: Technician Experience and Knowledge Sharing (Managers, Technicians , Supervisors, Engineers, Working professionals)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/manufacturing • • 4d ago

Supplier search Offering help on RFQs for Plastic Parts

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/manufacturing • • 4d ago

Other I had a terrible experience with AMARAL FACTORY, despite choosing Portugal for their premium services.

3 Upvotes

Today I wanted to share the terrible experience I have experienced with a Portugese manufacture, AMARAL FACTORY.

It all started back in Februrary of this year, when I got CRAZY traction on social media (+50K followers in a month) with my 3D characters video wearing a cool outfit I designed myself. After seeing hundred of messages of people asking where they could buy its outfit, I decided to make them reality and started looking for a manufacture.
I first wanted to aim for China, as I know they can provide good quality, but after discussing about it with my family, they all recommended me to aim for Portugal instead.

That's how I came across the AMARAL FACTORY profile on Suplify. I checked their website, modern and clean, contact on whatsapp, they well pretty much all around my age (I was 23, they were around 26) and the vibe was cool. I started with 100 hoodies, 100 pants and 50 t-shirts.

I was told everything would be ready a month and a half later. Long story short: it took 8 MONTHS to finally receive everything. Here is a list of all the issues I ran into with them:

- Constantly delayed deadlines and misleading progress updates: I was always told “hopefully before next week” or “by the end of the month”.

- Legal threats from the owner when I complained about my experience on a small private Discord server. I was also called an “annoying customer” and told I knew nothing about this industry when I complained about the situation (4 months without any progress).

- They only sent me progress on the final sample (before bulk production) after I complained to Suplify’s platform support and explained the situation.

- When I first received the final sample updates (after 4 months of waiting), it was unsewn. When I asked to see the sewn version, they told me it would take two more weeks and that it wasn’t necessary because “everything has been done according to the techpack”. Three weeks later, the sample was sewn and the hood pattern of the hoodie was completely in the wrong direction. If I had never asked for this sewn sample, I would have ended up with 100 hoodies made with the wrong design.

- After seeing the final sample and how bad it was, I asked for a refund. They kept ignoring my message and answered as if I had given them the green light to proceed to final production. The hood pattern was completely in the wrong direction and some pattern placement measurements were off.

- I found out my t-shirts were done by watching their Instagram story. I had asked them several times not to use my clothes in their videos to promote their factory (saying how fast and good they were), and they kept ignoring me. At some point their Instagram account got taken down, and the owner accused me of asking “small groups of people on Discord” to report it.

- Despite telling them I needed screenprinting, I discovered on the final sample board that it was DTG. I had to “negotiate” with them to get back to full screenprinting, because they had charged me for too few screenprinting boards on the first invoice.

- Despite asking them beforehand whether the composition would be shown on every label, the composition labels were basically a big QR code to their website, with no composition at all. I had to order new ones and replace all 250 labels by hand.

- They did NOT apply the changes I asked for on the samples (pants waist size, additional stitches on the hoodie pocket) despite saying they would.

- Even though I paid for 500 custom labels, I only received 250 (the ones sewn on the clothes). The owner never answered my messages about them.

It’s safe to say I do not recommend working with them. There is probably a lot more I forgot, but at this point I just want to move on. This situation put me in a very bad mental and financial state and destroyed my clothing brand momentum. After contacting several clients they had worked with in the past, I learned they all had terrible experiences too.


r/manufacturing • • 4d ago

Machine help how do you keep tools from not disappearing

12 Upvotes

So we have 7 or 8 rooms. Each room has its toolbox. Tools say for this room only - stuff like wrenches, allen keys, screw drivers

Can't keep tool boxes loaded for more than 2-3 weeks before they all disappear and some rooms have lots of tools and others have none. Of course the machine you're at and need to adjust something has nothing of what you need at this point.

How the hell do you keep tools in their designated equipment room?


r/manufacturing • • 4d ago

Other packaging business idea

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/manufacturing • • 4d ago

How to manufacture my product? Hollow die or semi-hollow plus a machining op? Where do you draw the line on a finned box?

2 Upvotes

I quote the same enclosure two ways and the two answers keep crossing, so I would like to hear how other people decide this.

The part: 190 x 120 x 45 mm aluminium box, wall 1.5 mm, six fins on the top face at 8 mm tall with 2 mm between them, one internal shelf at mid height that the PCB screws down to, and a 3 mm window in the front that gets machined after extrusion. 6063, anodised after machining. Quantities I see are 300 to 3,000 a year, in batches of a few hundred.

Route A is a hollow die: the shelf and the cavity come out of the press, so the bar is close to finished and the CNC only does the window, the ends and the screw holes. The die costs more and takes longer, and the mandrel limits how thin I can run the wall and how tight I can put the internal corners. On a 1.5 mm wall with a shelf, the internal radius is not going to be what the drawing asks for.

Route B is semi-hollow, or even a solid-ish profile with the cavity milled out afterwards. Cheaper die, faster to first sample, but now I am removing a lot of metal from the inside of a 45 mm deep pocket with a 1.5 mm wall, which is exactly the geometry that moves when you unclamp it. I have been holding wall to plus or minus 0.02 mm on the outside and then watching the inside pocket pull the wall in after the last pass.

What I cannot work out is where the crossover actually sits. My instinct says hollow wins above roughly 1,500 pieces a year because the die amortises, but the internal corner radius forces a design change that the customer then has to accept, and that conversation has killed two projects. At 300 pieces the die is obviously wrong, but so is fixturing a 1.5 mm wall for a deep pocket.

So: for those of you running extrusion and machining under one roof, do you pick the route on quantity, on the internal geometry, or on how much wall thickness the customer will give you? And when you go semi-hollow, do you machine the pocket before or after the window, because I have been doing the window first and I am not sure that is right.

Numbers if it helps: presses here are 700 t and 1,800 t, 220 mm circumscribed circle, 6 m bars, 4 kg/m max section, and the CNC side holds plus or minus 0.04 mm on inside and outside diameter.


r/manufacturing • • 4d ago

Productivity I asked if anyone's ERP matches the floor. Here's what I took away

0 Upvotes

Last week I asked if you'd trust your ERP enough to schedule tomorrow without asking anyone. Over 40 of you joined in across r/manufacturing and r/LeanManufacturing.

  • Plenty of you do trust your ERP. The replies explaining how kept coming back to having someone responsible for keeping the data right, long after go-live.

  • Leaving some things outside the ERP can make sense. The trouble starts when something the plan doesn't cover, like tooling or consumables, stops production.

  • Finding an error doesn't mean it gets fixed. Floor feedback can get lost on its way through the office, so people carry on working around the same problem.

  • Even data that was right at setup needs checking. The process changes, but the BOMs, routings and run times don't always get updated with it.