r/malta • u/Poet-Adept • 5h ago
Marble window sills do not match the sample provided
Hi all,
First time posting on reddit as i am not one to post usually but i need some advice on whether I am justified in thinking that this company (which i won’t name for the time being) is trying to scam me.
Me and my partner are finishing up our future home and have gotten to the point where we needed window sills. We went to this company on the 30th of October and found something we liked and that matched the tiles we ordered.
I went ahead and paid the deposit for the order on the 3rd of November to confirm the order. 2 days later on the 5th of November in the morning i was bombarded with phone calls and messages from a worker there to confirm sizes and finishing specs so the pieces can be cut that same morning (one size was even measured incorrectly).
That same day i receive a text from this same person recommending delivery the following Thursday. I was working that day so suggested Friday which they agreed to.
I applied for all the necessary permits and got everything ready on my side by removing the old apertures and sills.
Friday the 13th (lol) came around and the van parked in front of my property and began offloading the pieces. The pieces looked very different (much darker) than the sample ever looked. I showed them to my partner who agreed they looked totally different and did not like them at all. I then called the person i was dealing with and explained that they looked very different from what was agreed. His response was that this is a natural product and there can be some natural variation. There was a lot of back and forth until eventually we agreed to stop the installation and meet at the factory. The unfortunate part is they left the pieces there and had already managed to fit one sill (of which the rounded cut did not even match at all so would have had to be removed anyway).
I picked up my partner and headed over. The second we got there we were met with hostility from the employees who kept arguing with us that it is the same product that we were given when i showed them both the original sample and a piece that was meant for my place. They basically just kept repeating the same natural variation argument. At points the confrontation even got a bit aggressive from their end. At no point did they try help us find a solution for a way forward. I was the one who had to suggest that we try find a slab that we could agree on and then discuss pricing after.
We went outside and again they kept showing us the dark slab which our pieces were cut from however we did not like it. We went along the line of the slabs they had and eventually came across a slab with the name of the product we ordered written on it’s side. When we compared the sample to it the match was almost perfect. It was obvious that was where our sample came from. I asked if our pieces could be cut from this to which he went inside to check and came back telling us they are reserved for another project.
This is when they started getting more angry with us and at points even borderline threatening us. We could not find any slabs which we liked so we decided to leave.
The employee then messages me making it seem as though we were being unreasonable and that as mentioned many time it is just natural variation of the stone. The only compromise they would accept is to cancel the order and pick up the pieces but keep the €450 deposit we paid. He basically also confirmed that it was not possible to give us pieces that matched the original sample which in my books means he cannot uphold his side of the deal.
I asked a family member to go and ask for samples of this same product we ordered. They were given a sample which was the same as the one we were given but the salesperson told them to wait because the new batch looks nothing like the old batch and had to freshly cut a new sample piece for them from the new batch.
Am i justified in trying to keep insisting i get my full deposit back or should i accept losing it?
The square piece in the images is the sample that was provided to us on the 30th of October while the other more refined pieces are the items they cut. The last 2 images are the slabs we believe our sample was taken from that we saw at the factory.
TL:DR: Company provided a window sill sample which was completely different from the product they cut from in looks and they are insisting it is natural variation while withholding my deposit.
Edit: They are also arguing that i did not take up the opportunity to go check the slab before they cut it but with how fast it was cut i didn’t even have time to go at any point and they never even suggested going to check it or that there is a significant variation between the slab and the sample that was provided.
