I just need to rant here because I’m really getting irritated with how many mail clubs are popping up using AI (and yes, when you see enough of it, you notice details that don’t make sense and can easily clock when it’s AI).
If you’re thinking about starting a mail club with AI-generated art or written stories using chatgpt, please re-consider how much harm you’re doing to the environment and to other artists and creatives.
Yes, there are people willing to buy AI art as long as they like the design. Yes, you’re free to do what you want. But you dont need to start a mail club. The entire idea of a mail club is that it promotes slow living (hence the snail mail aspect of it…) and it’s a cost-effective way for artists and writers to get their art out there.
It makes no sense to start a monthly subscription to something you didn’t actually draw or write yourself.
This is also a side tangent but, I get that mail clubs are trendy right now but it is not some get rich quick scheme. It’s already difficult for real artists to sell their work as is. Mail clubs are a great incentive for artists to create consistent work every month. We don’t need more AI slop as is but esp not in our mailboxes every month.
At the end of the day, if you want to create and sell AI stuff, that’s your prerogative and no one is going to stop you. But please don’t convolute something as beautiful and as niche as snail mail clubs to do it.
And also, please read the room! People generally do not like AI art and can usually tell when it is. And for those of you who are pro-AI, let me ask you this. If you’re so proud of what you generated, why do you guys never state that you used AI? Why not proudly label your work as AI instead of trying to pass it off as something you created by hand? Because you know if people saw that they wouldn’t actually support you.
Know the audience.
The niche of mail clubs are that it’s a community of mostly creative people! The people who join mail clubs are generally artists themselves or enjoy supporting small artists, or are into creative hobbies. So when you’re making an AI mail club it’s like if Amazon tried to sell their best sellers at an Art Market… it literally does not belong.
/rant
[edit] just an fyi — there was a specific artist who people here thought i was specifically targeting. although they did trigger a reaction from me because i thought their work was AI i was chatted with this person and they are not using AI. so i stand corrected. that being said, my point about AI mail clubs still stands.