r/mahler • • Sep 03 '26

Posters for Mahler's Symphonies

Thumbnail
gallery
261 Upvotes

I'm a music professor, not a graphic designer, but I've long been interested in the clean lines and abstract geometry of the Swiss/International Typographic Style. I designed a poster for each of Mahler's completed symphonies, using a restricted visual vocabulary: geometric forms, sans-serif typography, grids, flat color, and no representational imagery.

See what you think: which was the strongest? which needs more work? which do you think captured some of the "essence" of its symphony?


r/mahler • • Jan 02 '25

My wife’s shirt gifting game is UNMATCHED!

Post image
148 Upvotes

She has been hyping this gift up to me since mid-December, and it did not disappoint. I guessed it was Mahler-related, but I was not expecting this. My wife is really awesome, by the way.


r/mahler • • Dec 05 '24

Am I cooked

Post image
119 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Dec 29 '25

More photos of his composing hut by Altersee

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

Folks seemed to like the other photo of Mahler's composing hut by Attersee, so I found a couple more of his composing hut. The piano inside was not his, but it's nice to sit there and plunk out some of his tunes in the space. I think he had two other composing huts, one I think in western Austria and one in northern Italy. This one was about 1 to 1 1/2 hours outside of Linz. The lake is probably very pretty during nice weather (it was cloudy and glum when we were there) and there are hiking trails on the surrounding hills.

If you're a Mahler geek, I'd recommend visiting one of his composing huts. It's sort of like visiting the composer apartments and homes in Vienna, but with the bonus of a beautiful setting. We stayed overnight in a Gasthaus a block or so away (we'd spent the day driving to hiking in a nearby park and driving to the hut) that had a very personable cat.


r/mahler • • Dec 28 '25

Composing hut at Altersee

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

He worked on #2 and #3 here. The location is Attersee, I messed up on title.


r/mahler • • Feb 22 '26

Mahlers First Symphony with Andris Nelsons and the Vienna Philharmonic last Friday

Post image
66 Upvotes

It was quite perfect I would say. One of my best Mahler experiences.


r/mahler • • May 07 '24

Listening to Mahler’s Symphony 2 for the first time tonight. 👂

Post image
63 Upvotes

A first listen is a big deal to me. You only have a first once!

I’ve listen to symphony 1 and 5, but before giving a first listen to any other, I like to prepare myself beforehand for greater enjoyment and understanding.

After reading a biographic book of Mahler, I now feel ready to listen to Symphony 2 for the first time.

This is my recording of choice. ✨


r/mahler • • Nov 20 '23

So I really like Mahler...

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/mahler • • May 19 '25

Just now realizing how insane the orchestration of the sixth is

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

(you may have to tap on the image to see it fully)


r/mahler • • 14d ago

M8 rehearsal showing Mahler’s preferred instrument placement in Munich 1910

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

Today I realise I've hit the age for needing a magnifying glass


r/mahler • • Apr 09 '20

Editing Mahler Scores

56 Upvotes

This is a random post but I thought I'd share that I'm currently in the middle of a project which is editing all of the first edition Mahler scores for every orchestral score he published so that they match a late Urtext edition and I can log what he changed and why. This sounds like the most stupid and boring thing in the world but it's probably enriched my knowledge of conducting, orchestration and general musical skills more than almost any other exercise or study I've done. Mahler wasn't just a genius but also a perfectionist who constantly laboured to make sure his scores could not possibly be misinterpreted and it's genuinely so impressive (and annoying when I have to edit 50 piano markings to pianissimo on a page because he's a control freak).

When the project is finished I'll post all my findings on each piece and some screenshots of the worst pages that are filled with scribblings everywhere. Currently I'm on the 4th Symphony as I just finished the 3rd after a 6 hour marathon doing movements 3-6.

My findings so far is that the 1st Symphony despite taking 10 years or so to even get published, is filled with SO MANY CHANGES EVERYWHERE between first editions and republications. He deletes more brass bars in that symphony than I could possibly have imagined. And that huge climax of the 2nd theme in movement 4 (just before the inferno themes return for the last time) used to be ENTIRELY PPP?! I was so shocked he changed a whole page from ppp to fff. It seems unthinkable Mahler would change his mind that much but he did so there you go.

Symphony No. 2 has surprisingly little changes. Just light editing and occasional reorchestration. There's more changes towards the end (probably because movements 1 and 3 were based on previous pieces so less material needed to be edited). Nothing that exciting besides some interesting footnotes and more instruments in the choral section as a backup to keep them in tune.

Symphony No. 3 has massive metrical changes, dynamic changes and reorchestration throughout the whole symphony sparing only the last movement. One particularly strange marking is him adding "bisbigliando" to the harp which I believe is a whispering tremolo? I'm a pianist so I couldn't get solid info on it but it must be a mistake as he wrote it on a very fast scale that is played glissando on every recording. Besides that oddity, he reworked just about everything he could get his hands on. Only edit I personally dislike is axing all the percussion in the string scales section of the first movement where the percussion does insane and starts smashing everything. Some recordings like Haitink's still have the old percussion while newer recordings like Abbado's Lucerne Festival have the slimmed down percussion section. I think it is a tad bit excessive and I get why he cut it down but I think he cut way too much off and was probably afraid of being ridiculed for his very "modern" percussion choices at the time. Maybe he changed this around the time everyone was laughing about the hammer, cow bell and motor horn?

I own the Kaplan book on Mahler's Concerts and I'm starting to sense a pattern. The more he conducted a piece, the more he changed it. This explains why 1 and 3 have such huge changes but 2 doesn't. While 2 was popular in his time, he didn't conduct it personally as much as 1 and 3 which he did 16 and 15 times respectively (can't be bothered getting the book out so this is from memory and I might be slightly wrong). This makes complete sense and isn't a new revelation or anything but interesting to think about nonetheless. I might do a huge post in the future explaining my whole Mahler story and obsession but that's for when I finish editing all the scores! Wish me luck on the next symphonies. 4 will probably be easy but the book for 5 and 6 is monstrously long and I know 5 has a history of changes so God knows how I will survive that one. Keep up the Mahler worship!!!


r/mahler • • Oct 05 '26

Why the hammer should be considered a character

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/mahler • • 13d ago

Yes, Mahler wrote all the music for the unfinished 10th

53 Upvotes

I love the 10th Symphony, particularly the Kurt Sanderling recording with Berlin. It's big, powerful, full of love and loss, heartbreak and triumph, ending with that great musical sigh, Mahler's final total affirmation of life through all its suffering.

Recently a fellow Mahler fan insisted to me that Mahler only wrote the first movement. It makes me wonder how in the 21st Century there's still confusion among Mahler listeners over how much or how little of the symphony he wrote.

Mahler composed all five movements of music. The work could be performed from beginning to end on piano using Mahler's short score (the un-orchestrated draft). In fact, I wish someone would! (As it is, someone did do the 4th movement, and it's interesting to compare it to the Cooke version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wq1dHz8jUvc )

Mahler also orchestrated more than just the first movement.

From Gustav Mahler: The Symphonies by Constantine Floros,

"Of the five movements, the first two are complete or almost complete in the score sketch. The third movement (Purgatory) is written on three loose sheets as a short score; moreover the first 30 measures are also written out in the score sketch. The two final movements exist as a short score on four staves, with sparse indications of the instrumentation. Mahler's manuscript consists of seventy-two pages of a fully written-out draft and ninety-three pages of a short score."

Deryck Cooke goes into greater detail about what he had to work with to orchestrate the parts Mahler hadn't already done in his little book, Gustav Mahler: An Introduction to His Music - but I can't quote from it as I gave my only copy away in a moment of temporary insanity.

I totally understand if someone doesn't want to listen to the 10th because Mahler didn't finish the orchestration. What I don't get is people saying Mahler didn't *write* it. That would be like claiming the Ravel orchestration of Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition wasn't written by Mussorgsky - even if part of the orchestration had actually been made by Mussorgsky himself.

Thoughts? Favorite recordings?


r/mahler • • Jan 15 '25

Beautiful, sublime passage for brass

51 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Aug 12 '24

Is it even legal to write a line this luscious and rich?

51 Upvotes

r/mahler • • 4d ago

Why Did Gustave Mahler Wear Two Monocles?

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Sep 19 '26

I am building a website where you can search classical music concerts with music of Gustav Mahler (currently 1600+ future concerts globally)

46 Upvotes

Hi,

I am building a database of classical music concerts. It's helpful especially if you're looking for a specific composer, case in point, here are 1600 future concerts with music of Mahler:

https://classicalbot.com/?composers=Gustav+Mahler

Of course, all other composers are covered :)


r/mahler • • Jun 21 '24

What is your favorite Mahler symphony

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Aug 24 '26

GTA VI leak reveals a classical radio station playing Mahler's 6th Symphony

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Oct 26 '25

Little sketch I made of Mahler

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Mar 27 '26

Mahler Puppet Philharmonic

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Hi, a Mahlerian that's new at reddit here.

I wasn’t sure if I should post this here, but I’ve decided to take the risk. I will delete it if it's not allowed. I am creating something to honor Mahler, and I’m looking for "my" people - it’s not easy to find those who share this specific kind of terminal passion. I try on a lot of communities dedicated to classical music, so I came here too!

​I am building a 1:6 scale doll orchestra. A complete ensemble capable of performing Mahler’s Second Symphony in a physical world. I would be honored if you would join me on this journey.

​About three years ago, I heard the "Resurrection" Symphony live for the first time (Silesian Philharmonic under the baton of Yaroslav Shemet). Nothing had ever sounded more intense. Nothing had ever stayed with me so long after leaving the concert hall. It sparked a fascination with a man who could enclose the entire world within a single piece of music. He did it in a way that made me feel alone with the orchestra in an empty hall. A ton of brass, steel, and wood was crashing down on me, but he was right there, telling stories of summers in Maiernigg, of Alma, of Putzi, or whatever literary work fascinated him at the moment.

​I read everything i could find, looked at every photo - I wanted to know it all. I even made a "pilgrimage" to the Grinzing cemetery by train; the entire trip was planned solely for that purpose. I started hunting for concerts, mostly nearby, but often traveling across Poland. I spent sums on tickets that could have fed me for a month. I heard all his symphonies live, fulfilling my original goal. I thought I’d "stop" then, but I was wrong. The obsession continues. I still dream of hearing him in Berlin, Vienna, New York, or at the Concertgebouw.

​Somewhere on the wave of this respect and the need to contribute something of my own to this "cult" of Mahler, an idea was born - I called it my idée fixe. I don’t play an instrument myself, so I had to find another way. As an amateur dollmaker, it felt like a natural step to create an orchestra out of my dolls. But a real one. Not just a collection of random instruments in random places, but an orchestra specifically equipped to play Mahler’s Second.

​I sculpt anatomically correct dolls from polymer clay and scratch. I study how musicians hold their instruments, how they sit, how they move. I buy front-row seats (even against acoustic logic) or balcony spots just to observe. I ask my musician friends questions, though I don’t always find what I’m looking for. Sometimes I hit a wall and have to rely on intuition for the details.

​This stopped being just an artistic challenge or a way to impress others. It became about respect. Deep admiration for the musicians who lend their voices to Mahler in those dark philharmonic halls. It’s not about aesthetics; it’s about credibility. Mahler isn't always "beautiful." Sometimes he is a ton of brass, wood, and horsehair thrown with sheer force. But he is honest. I am trying to be honest on that project, too.

​I started with the strings. I build exact 1:6 replicas (violins are about 5-6 cm long) where the tailpiece isn't just glued on - they have a soundpost inside, and the strings can actually be tuned with the pegs. The bows have synthetic hair, a frog, and a tip. For the woodwinds and brass, I sculpt every valve, pipe, and finger rest. I’m planning a 1:6 scale organ and even transport crates. For the harp, I used surgical forceps to tie 47 strings just 2-5 mm apart. The pedals work. I’m also working on the score—I’ve reprinted the actual sheet music, not a single page is missing. I will do the same for every orher musician.

​I am doing this all alone and I'm still a med student, so it might take decades. I might never finish. But it is still worth to try. For Mahler, it is always worth it.

If you’d like to see the progress of my orchestra or follow this journey, you can find me here:

https://www.instagram.com/mahler_puppet_phil?igsh=bzc3NW9qdDd3NGt1


r/mahler • • Dec 28 '24

Will be going to my first classical concerts in the beginning of 2025: Mahler Symphony 5 in January and Mahler's Symphony 2 in February!

41 Upvotes

Recently been very into classical music and I'm especially obsessed with Gustav Mahler. His work touches me like no other composer can. I just bought tickets for my first classical concerts. In January, Ivan Fischer and the Budapest Festival Orchestra performing Mahler 5 in De Singel (Antwerp) and in February Mahler 2 performed by Gergely Madaras and the Orchestre Philharmonique Royal de Liège (In Liège). I'm very much looking forward to this! Mahler 2 might be my favorite of his symphonies, but now I'm especially looking forward to seeing Fischer and the Budapest Festival Orchestra playing the fifth. It's a very good thing that all the venues give huge reductions for people younger than 26. Without that reduction, I probably wouldn't be able to go, as I've only recently graduated from uni and I'm still looking for a job. Anyways, just wanted to share my excitement on here.


r/mahler • • Jan 29 '23

I could still listen to his works for hours

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/mahler • • Mar 27 '20

Just recolorized some photos of Mahler. Here is one of them: (Hope you'll like it)

41 Upvotes

r/mahler • • May 25 '26

Hans Rott

39 Upvotes

I've only been able to find one mention of Rott in this subreddit, so I wanted to give him the credit he's due for the influence he had on Mahler's development into the composer we all love.

Rott attended the Vienna Conservatory (tuition free) at the same time as Mahler, and they even roomed together for a bit. We have few compositions of Rott's because he died young at 25. When he was 20, he submitted the first movement of his First Symphony for evaluation at the Conservatory, and other than Bruckner, the faculty ridiculed his work. Two years later, he presented the completed Symphony to Brahms in the hopes of having it performed. Brahms, the conservative that he was in the War of the Romantics, told Rott that he had no talent whatsoever and should give up music. Rott began to experience delusions that culminated in his threatening to shoot someone on a train because he believed Brahms had rigged the train with dynamite. He was committed to a mental hospital and died of tuberculosis in 1884, four years after completing the Symphony that Brahms had deemed meritless.

Of his death, Mahler said:

  • "[A] musician of genius . . . who died unrecognized and in want on the very threshold of his career. . . . What music has lost in him cannot be estimated. Such is the height to which his genius soars in . . . [his] Symphony [in E major], which he wrote as 20-year-old youth and makes him . . . the Founder of the New Symphony as I see it. To be sure, what he wanted is not quite what he achieved. . . . But I know where he aims. Indeed, he is so near to my inmost self that he and I seem to me like two fruits from the same tree which the same soil has produced and the same air nourished. He could have meant infinitely much to me and perhaps the two of us would have well-nigh exhausted the content of new time which was breaking out for music."

Mahler didn't write his First Symphony until he was 28. Rott had given Mahler the idea for what the symphony as an art form could and even should be when he was eight years younger. And just like Mahler, Rott was faced with intense vitriol for his compositions (the only prominent person at the time who supported Rott was Bruckner, but Bruckner's influence angered Brahms, which made Brahms's backlash even greater than it normally would have been).

There aren't many recordings of Rott's works. But I encourage you to listen to the handful that exist of his First Symphony and the couple that exist of his string quartet. You can hear what sounds like (how you'd assume) a young Mahler would sound. There is also an album of performances of fragments of his works that is both wonderful in that you get to hear more of Rott's music and sad in that the music is always cut short.

Mahler opens his Third Symphony with an alteration of the main theme of Brahms One movement four, which itself is an alteration of the main theme of Beethoven Nine movement four (the "Ode to Joy"). It's quite audacious! But Rott did it first in the fourth movement of his First Symphony. Both Rott and Mahler were advocating for "the New Symphony" referenced above, and both asserted the validity of that "New Symphony" by writing music that unmistakably argued that it was "what comes next" in Romanticism. Indeed, it argued that they were "what comes next." The difference is that Rott made this assertion at 22. Mahler waited until he was 36. (And Brahms took 21 years to write his First Symphony; he didnt enter the symphonic lineage with his variation on the "Ode to Joy" until he was 43.)

Around the 4 minute mark of the fourth movement of Rott's First Symphony, the flute has a half note trill followed by two grace notes (the first a half-step below, the second back to the half note's same pitch) and a leap. Mahler's Second Symphony uses this same form of flute call in the Flute 3/Piccolo 1 part in the fifth movement. I don't believe this is a coincidence, especially because the second movement of Mahler's Second Symphony is about remembering the happy times you've had with those who have died.

That flute call comes back at the end of the first movement of Mahler's Ninth Symphony, right after the oboe quotes a line from the second movement of Brahms's First Symphony. I believe there's much to say about that choice, which could be it's own post, but the point is that Rott was on Mahler's mind throughout his compositional career.

Another example of this is the fourth movement of Mahler Five, the Adagietto. Yes, it's a love letter to Alma. But it also references and quotes the second movement of Rott's C minor String Quartet. Mahler cared deeply for Rott, and Rott impacted him greatly.

Rott is rarely discussed or performed, but he's a crucial link in the chain of music history, both at the macro level of music's overall progression (his musical philosophy influenced Mahler's boundary pushing late-Romanticism, which then expanded musical possibilities into atonality and the Modernism of the 20th Century) and the micro level (we're all here because we love Mahler, and Mahler as we know him would not exist without Rott).