TL;DR Ignore all the negativity that people are posting, and give it a shot! It’s a great game!
So I’ve never written a review for a game before, but Magic Duels seems to be getting so much heat lately that I thought I might chime in on the subject with my own personal opinions.
Let me start, though, with a disclaimer that I am super new to playing Magic in any form. I only started about a month ago with Magic 2015: Duels of the Planeswalkers and have since picked up some paper cards to start playing as well. I’ve also played a bit of MTGO, but don’t really see the point in sinking money into digital cards. That being said, it’s safe to say I’m a newbie to MTG, but I’ve got decades of experience with other games.
With that disclaimer out of the way, I have to say that people are being far too harsh and whining way too much. First, keep in mind it’s a free game. It’s not like we had to pay to preorder or anything, so a lot of people need to relax a little. Is the game perfect? Nope. Have I been able to indulge a few hours for free? Absolutely! Have I enjoyed those hours? Absolutely! You know the old addage "You get what you pay for"? Well, in this case, you don't have to pay anything, and you get a lot of fun!
I’ll begin with what have been a lot of the negative points first. When I first installed, my computer shut off twice during the download phase through Steam. Not even the installation, the download. Super weird, I thought, * but I don’t see how the game could have caused that*. Naturally, I thought it would be something hardware related, so I discounted the download. When I downloaded and installed, I kept getting Fatal Errors. I followed some of the suggestions others posted, but nothing worked. So I figured I would try it on my other computer, and sure enough it worked. So I figured it must have been my graphics card. I swapped the two graphics cards, loaded the game and…. Fatal Errors!
Two different graphics cards, one Nvidia, one AMD, both with completely updated drivers, and it worked fine on one computer, but not on the other (and tested both computers with both cards). Super weird! So I figured I would just give up and wait for an update for it to be playable on my gaming rig, swapped the cards out again and figured I would give it one more shot. So I uninstalled and reinstalled… And then my computer shut down not twice but three times during the download. Super sketchy, but the only time my computer has randomly shut off in the past year or more was during the download of Magic Duels. And not once, but a total of five times! So say what you want, but I don’t see how it could have been related to anything but the download. Keep in mind, it wasn’t even the install, it was just the download. I even downloaded another game from Steam to test it, and it downloaded fine. So I uninstalled and tried to download again. This time, I paused the download every thirty seconds or so and it downloaded without an issue.
I reinstalled, launched the game… and success!
After having eagerly awaited launch for the past few weeks and suffering a really rough first impression, I quickly jumped in.
Some people reported having weird graphics issues, but I didn’t. Everything looks pretty sharp. And I am so happy that they changed the UI from Magic 2015. Having to click “continue” or “next” or whatever the button is on the left side of the screen seemed very backwards in Magic 2015 and I’m very happy to see it moved to the right side. A minor thing, but one I very much appreciate! And the menus are much better! People whined endlessly about the menus in Magic 2015 and while they were definitely annoying, they definitely weren’t the end of the world. I’m glad to see both of these improvements! They make it seem a bit more polished and enjoyable.
So far, I’ve played for about 20 hours and haven’t had a single crash. Yes, I’ve had a few matches where I lost sync with the server and either had to replay it to proceed with the campaign or lost out on a few coins, but ultimately, hardly the end of the world. Definitely not worth the insane amount of posts claiming the game is "absolute crap" or people condemning WotC as one of the Worst Companies Evert. To all those people who rant and rave: seriously? You have to replay a match from time to time? It's not like it's every match that needs to be replayed. So far, I've encountered it maybe one out of fifteen or twenty games.
I think it’s safe to assume that they’ll stabilize the servers over the next few days or weeks. They've announced that there's an issue and they're working to resolve it. Again, it's definitely not the end of the world.
The tutorial is also a bit annoying, but thankfully you don’t have to play it more than once (unless you lose sync, of course) and it rewards you pretty nicely for playing along. Not knowing which cards are in your deck can be a bit like playing Russian roulette and some of the matches felt insanely difficult (here’s looking at you Liliana’s angel match and Chandra’s artifact match!), but with a little luck (and a few time outs for wanting to smash my keyboard!) they are definitely doable. Most matches I beat on my first attempt, so it wasn’t too bad.
The skill tests were a bit annoying too. Even for myself, a super Magic newbie, I felt they were a waste of time. Thankfully they are super short and also give a few coins for completing them. So with the story mode finished, I used the deck builder and made a deck. I proceeded to get thrashed by the AI time after time after time, even on easy mode! So I figured, maybe it’s supposed to be ramping difficulty and as I unlock new cards and my decks get better, I’ll stand more of a chance. So I struggled through them, bought a few boosters and created my own custom deck. And now I’m doing much better! But those built decks seem atrocious! I tried about 6 or 8 of them and really didn’t enjoy them. (Note: it was my first time ever building my own deck ever, so that’s got to say something about the deck builder!)
With my own custom deck, I’ve really been enjoying it. I’ve been playing on Normal difficulty and the AI often puts up a fight and wins frequently. That’s a positive point though: I love a good challenge! One strange thing about the AI though is that it almost always plays its cards on the second main phase, even if playing it on the first would have pumped or buffed their baddies while they were attacking. Often I see something gain +X/+X, but just for the turn… after they’ve already attacked. Seems silly! Overall, is it a perfect game? Nope. Is it worth it? Absolutely! Oh wait.. it’s free! I didn’t even have to spend a dime to play it and I’ve already gotten several hours of entertainment out of it! So instead of whining about how terrible of a game it is, I’d like to say **Thank You WotC and Stainless! ** It’s a definite improvement over Magic 2015 and I can’t wait to see how the game evolves over the next few months and years!