r/magicduels • • Oct 06 '15

general discussion Where does all this butthurt over Duels come from?

0 Upvotes

I'm serious. I hear there are severe problems with the iOS version, and if it's true how dysfunctional that platform is I can understand the vigor with which people are posting their displeasure, but that's it.

I play on the Xbox One version and it's pretty stable. For a game that costs us nothing if we don't wish to spend anything, I've been pretty happy. Yes, I have complaints:

  • BFZ not being released and no update from wizards until the day it was supposed to come out is pretty weak.

  • The matchmaking could be better as it often will freeze on the 'waiting for players to join' screen.

Those are my only major complaints. There are occasional minor bugs, achievements that didn't unlock when they should have, etc. but overall it's been an enjoyable experience. If there wasn't the possibility for patches it'd be a different story, but we haven't been in the age of cartridge-based games since the 90s xD and for a free experience, this game is awesome and I hope to see the support continue.

Again, I don't play on the iOS, so if that's the major reason for the constant flaming I can understand, but I wanted to put this thread out as a bellwether. Are there other people who are still grateful/optimistic and don't really understand the bitterness directed at the game/wizards/stainless? Also please post what platform you're on if you reply, thanks!


r/magicduels • • Aug 30 '15

general discussion Thank you for Making Duels!

0 Upvotes

Just wanted to say thanks to Wizards for all the effort you guys are putting into Duels! It is a great game - destined to get only better with new expansions and updates. Realizing that a game as complex as this, will not be "water tight" upon initial release is something that a lot seem to do not understand. If things are not "perfect" at the beginning the " thumbs down - throw it in the trash - start over " mentality starts wreaking havoc on the message boards. And more often than not, those are the loudest voices. Coming from a long time magic player with tournament experience, I love the game and format of Duels. The smaller card pool, the ranking and matchmaking, the streamlined interface, not seeing a mythic rare played every other card, etc... are all things that, although will be improved upon with time, are such a breath of fresh air. It pushes a player to focus more on skill and deck building. Its a great time to be a magic player!


r/magicduels • • Aug 03 '15

general discussion You don't deserve the win if you can't beat the AI

0 Upvotes

Not a popular opinion by any means, but I just want to vent this.
If you lost to the AI because your opponent left, you probably would lose anyway, unless your opponent was very bad. In any case, if you can't beat the bad AI they have for this game, you don't deserve the win.
[EDIT] After a lot of downvotes, I can say that this community is going to be much more spoiled than any other gaming community. I mean, geez, they feel entitled to win just because the other guy left(even if it was because internet connection lost, crash or any other thing).
Seriously, if you really think you deserve the win just because the guy left, so finishing off the match is no problem for you. The people complaining must be so bad at this game that they can't even beat this AI...
Do you really think you earn 20 gold and a rank point because your opponent mulliganed to 3 and left? And you couldn't even beat the AI with 3 cards in hand? Please, quit this game.


r/magicduels • • Jul 16 '15

general discussion Why are wizards so good at fucking it all up?

1 Upvotes

I know this is all around the sub at the moment, but I just had to vent somewhere. No release dates, which every other company does weeks and months in advance. Ignoring people with ultra-vague answers on their Facebook. That in itself is so frustrating, but to not even think through the basic concepts of the game like cross-platform capabilities, no chat in a team game and no rewards (for 2hd) is just stupid.

And for years of years the games have been chocked full of bugs. When I heard about this release I thought well at least it explains the buggy years as they surely must of been making this great. How does wizards even think this is acceptable? This is clearly released to counter hearthstone (which is rubbish compared to magic gameplay) but blizzard will destroy the market purely because they know how to please their customers and actually seem to understand what is wanted in a game. I guess I'm just cynical from the previous releases and unfortunately this just seems to be confirming my fears. I wanted it to be good as I honestly think it would be so popular, but I can't see it happening soon.

Sorry for the rant.


r/magicduels • • Feb 16 '16

There are two types of people out there...

0 Upvotes

People who play a turn four Mwon-Vuli Acid Moss and people who aren't assholes.


r/magicduels • • Apr 20 '16

community event 1-2 weeks per pach(hotfix) - is all we need!

3 Upvotes

If you agreed + for this message!

p.s patch*


r/magicduels • • Aug 02 '15

general discussion I'm actually done.

10 Upvotes

If you're going to have always-on DRM, you could have the good graces to let me drop my game when your servers poop the bed. But preferably your servers shouldn't be a tire fire.

Or you could be like your nearest competitor and allow the winnings of one offline match to be recorded when connection is lost.

I just fought through a half-hour game to earn the last bit of gold for a pack. Was greeted with the offline message immediately upon winning. No gold for me!

Uninstalled.


r/magicduels • • Jul 23 '17

rumor I heard a rumor about the next product.

0 Upvotes

I feel the need to write this due to the fact that otherwise others may not hear about what the new product will be when September comes. Do note this isn't guaranteed because this is a rumor that a friend over heard because he lives near the Wizards office in Washington. He told me that it's supposed to be a product similar to magic duels but with support mainly directed at mobile platforms. I also heard they are planning on having it update much more frequently than magic duels did as far as it goes for bug fixes. If I hear anything additional from my friend I will update my post but I sincerely hope this doesn't mean it won't be on steam.


r/magicduels • • Aug 07 '15

general discussion Where's all the positivity?

9 Upvotes

Seriously though, this game isn't even that bad. I played Hearthstone for a week and couldn't get into it. The game was just too simple and the voice acting ticked me off.

I just finished the Story mode, and haven't run into a single glitch. I am hesitant about purchasing cards right now as I would like to see where the game goes before doing so.

But seriously. The expectations I had going into this was low, and the game ended up being much better than I thought. This game is doing exactly what the DotP franchise has been doing from the start, a gateway drug to the franchise, and aimed towards casual Magic players. I'm starting to think that maybe this game was never meant to compete with Hearthstone, and I feel it should stop being compared to it.

Can it be better? Sure! Only time will tell though, but don't forget, the game has only been out for a week and everyone is acting like its the end of the world.


r/magicduels • • Oct 01 '16

question Is there a Draft mode yet?

0 Upvotes

Hey I have been away pretty much since launch. Steam just reminded me this game exists! Is there a Draft mode yet? ... I like Drafting if taht wasn't clear from the question :D


r/magicduels • • Jul 24 '15

general discussion Getting tired of all that "bad for new players" thing.

0 Upvotes

tittle says, I'm getting so annoyed with this game and all that "bad for new players". I was a new player too, and there are new players in paper magic too and they can live with full sets, 4x any card no matter rarity and can even learn to tap their own mana or set blockers themselves, assign damage and play stuff in upkeep if necessary.

seems like every game mechanic change is excused with "for the new players". But those new players will eventually not be, and will they be OK with this "dumbed down" magic? and what is more, are the old time magic players OK with this?

sometimes I wonder what their target audience really is or if kids this days are so "not-smart" to play a game with its full rules I learned when I was 12 with my friends.

A little rant that was burning in my soul and just exploded when having a conversation with a friend, wanted to know your opinion! Maybe the community is OK and it's only me becoming an old fart. :)


r/magicduels • • Jun 02 '16

general discussion This game is just frustrating.

1 Upvotes

Hi guys

Some rant but i need to get this off my chest.

I Am level 25 right now and this game is just frustrating.
The higher i get, the more i play against the same deck with the same gamestructure. It's always "destroy this, exile that, remove this etc."

I play a creature? He just destroys it. And then wins the game with planeswalkers or some other shit. I always lose to the same kind of decks, where my opponents has many cards which can destroy or exile and then wins with some planeswalkers or some big creatures.

There's nothing i can do, since i dont have that many cards.
To be honest, i regret spending 20 Euro on this shit.

Thx for reading, regards.


r/magicduels • • Mar 05 '16

general discussion All I want is some sort of in-game tracking for achievements- is this really too much to ask?

0 Upvotes

It's bad enough that there's an achievement for completing 500 daily quests.

It's bad enough that I only get a new daily quest about 75% of the time and that a couple of days every week I get no daily reset or new daily quest.

All I have left to complete in this game (from an achievement perspective) is 500 daily quests. I complete them daily and never let them build up beyond two (which is rare if I miss a day), so I never miss out on any in that capacity.

It took me 118 days from the day I started playing to get the "Complete 100 daily quests" achievement because I don't get one daily like I should. Whatever. It is what it is.

But literally every other game in the world tracks achievement progress within the game. Magic 2015 tracked progress towards 100 online wins so you knew how far along you were. With this dumb game, I have to manually track my progress towards a year and a half's worth of daily quests, worsened by the fact that I don't get one every day. Why the hell isn't this tracked for me so I know where I am?

It should also track your solo and online versus wins, but I don' t really give a shit since I have those achievements done (100/500 solo and 100/500 online versus).

Hello? Help?


r/magicduels • • Aug 01 '15

general discussion Not nearly as bad as they make it sound!

0 Upvotes

TL;DR Ignore all the negativity that people are posting, and give it a shot! It’s a great game!

So I’ve never written a review for a game before, but Magic Duels seems to be getting so much heat lately that I thought I might chime in on the subject with my own personal opinions.

Let me start, though, with a disclaimer that I am super new to playing Magic in any form. I only started about a month ago with Magic 2015: Duels of the Planeswalkers and have since picked up some paper cards to start playing as well. I’ve also played a bit of MTGO, but don’t really see the point in sinking money into digital cards. That being said, it’s safe to say I’m a newbie to MTG, but I’ve got decades of experience with other games.

With that disclaimer out of the way, I have to say that people are being far too harsh and whining way too much. First, keep in mind it’s a free game. It’s not like we had to pay to preorder or anything, so a lot of people need to relax a little. Is the game perfect? Nope. Have I been able to indulge a few hours for free? Absolutely! Have I enjoyed those hours? Absolutely! You know the old addage "You get what you pay for"? Well, in this case, you don't have to pay anything, and you get a lot of fun!

I’ll begin with what have been a lot of the negative points first. When I first installed, my computer shut off twice during the download phase through Steam. Not even the installation, the download. Super weird, I thought, * but I don’t see how the game could have caused that*. Naturally, I thought it would be something hardware related, so I discounted the download. When I downloaded and installed, I kept getting Fatal Errors. I followed some of the suggestions others posted, but nothing worked. So I figured I would try it on my other computer, and sure enough it worked. So I figured it must have been my graphics card. I swapped the two graphics cards, loaded the game and…. Fatal Errors!

Two different graphics cards, one Nvidia, one AMD, both with completely updated drivers, and it worked fine on one computer, but not on the other (and tested both computers with both cards). Super weird! So I figured I would just give up and wait for an update for it to be playable on my gaming rig, swapped the cards out again and figured I would give it one more shot. So I uninstalled and reinstalled… And then my computer shut down not twice but three times during the download. Super sketchy, but the only time my computer has randomly shut off in the past year or more was during the download of Magic Duels. And not once, but a total of five times! So say what you want, but I don’t see how it could have been related to anything but the download. Keep in mind, it wasn’t even the install, it was just the download. I even downloaded another game from Steam to test it, and it downloaded fine. So I uninstalled and tried to download again. This time, I paused the download every thirty seconds or so and it downloaded without an issue.

I reinstalled, launched the game… and success!

After having eagerly awaited launch for the past few weeks and suffering a really rough first impression, I quickly jumped in.

Some people reported having weird graphics issues, but I didn’t. Everything looks pretty sharp. And I am so happy that they changed the UI from Magic 2015. Having to click “continue” or “next” or whatever the button is on the left side of the screen seemed very backwards in Magic 2015 and I’m very happy to see it moved to the right side. A minor thing, but one I very much appreciate! And the menus are much better! People whined endlessly about the menus in Magic 2015 and while they were definitely annoying, they definitely weren’t the end of the world. I’m glad to see both of these improvements! They make it seem a bit more polished and enjoyable.

So far, I’ve played for about 20 hours and haven’t had a single crash. Yes, I’ve had a few matches where I lost sync with the server and either had to replay it to proceed with the campaign or lost out on a few coins, but ultimately, hardly the end of the world. Definitely not worth the insane amount of posts claiming the game is "absolute crap" or people condemning WotC as one of the Worst Companies Evert. To all those people who rant and rave: seriously? You have to replay a match from time to time? It's not like it's every match that needs to be replayed. So far, I've encountered it maybe one out of fifteen or twenty games.

I think it’s safe to assume that they’ll stabilize the servers over the next few days or weeks. They've announced that there's an issue and they're working to resolve it. Again, it's definitely not the end of the world.

The tutorial is also a bit annoying, but thankfully you don’t have to play it more than once (unless you lose sync, of course) and it rewards you pretty nicely for playing along. Not knowing which cards are in your deck can be a bit like playing Russian roulette and some of the matches felt insanely difficult (here’s looking at you Liliana’s angel match and Chandra’s artifact match!), but with a little luck (and a few time outs for wanting to smash my keyboard!) they are definitely doable. Most matches I beat on my first attempt, so it wasn’t too bad.

The skill tests were a bit annoying too. Even for myself, a super Magic newbie, I felt they were a waste of time. Thankfully they are super short and also give a few coins for completing them. So with the story mode finished, I used the deck builder and made a deck. I proceeded to get thrashed by the AI time after time after time, even on easy mode! So I figured, maybe it’s supposed to be ramping difficulty and as I unlock new cards and my decks get better, I’ll stand more of a chance. So I struggled through them, bought a few boosters and created my own custom deck. And now I’m doing much better! But those built decks seem atrocious! I tried about 6 or 8 of them and really didn’t enjoy them. (Note: it was my first time ever building my own deck ever, so that’s got to say something about the deck builder!)

With my own custom deck, I’ve really been enjoying it. I’ve been playing on Normal difficulty and the AI often puts up a fight and wins frequently. That’s a positive point though: I love a good challenge! One strange thing about the AI though is that it almost always plays its cards on the second main phase, even if playing it on the first would have pumped or buffed their baddies while they were attacking. Often I see something gain +X/+X, but just for the turn… after they’ve already attacked. Seems silly! Overall, is it a perfect game? Nope. Is it worth it? Absolutely! Oh wait.. it’s free! I didn’t even have to spend a dime to play it and I’ve already gotten several hours of entertainment out of it! So instead of whining about how terrible of a game it is, I’d like to say **Thank You WotC and Stainless! ** It’s a definite improvement over Magic 2015 and I can’t wait to see how the game evolves over the next few months and years!


r/magicduels • • Oct 01 '16

general discussion why we need anti planewalker cards

0 Upvotes

here is 2hg game i played and my partner had a super friends deck and it went out of control

out of control super friends

my opponents had only starter cards and had no answer to the army of planewalkers ,and they might be discouraged to continue playing magic duels after this one sided match

so i propose the following cards to be included in the starter box

[[Dreadbore]]

[[Fated Retribution]]

[[Silumgar's Command]]

[[In Garruk's Wake]]

[[Ruinous Path]]

as the number of powerfull planewalker cards are growing i wonder why has wizards not addressed this issue ??


r/magicduels • • Feb 07 '16

general discussion So basically every deck is Land Destruction or Red Decks?

0 Upvotes

Every single deck I play against, the same fucking thing.... I guess there are only 2 decks in the format.


r/magicduels • • Feb 22 '16

information Main Issue with Magic Duels future

0 Upvotes

HI community, I`m former mtg player (started playing during Tempest and retired during Onslaught). I have returned few years ago only to play Duels. I liked the most Duels from 2012 and 2013. I was surprised, when they announced new way of doing Duels - one client for Duels and only to add stuff and at first I liked the idea. But then I realized that there is one big flaw for a new players in the future.

Each new player will be put before bigger and bigger pile of cards to grind, while players already playing will have significant advantage. This will be even worse after few more years. I think there should be some rotating out or something, bc, community is already small after all outages and bugs, and new players will soon be intimidated to even join. After April, possible new player will be put before 4 sets to grind! and at the end of 2016, even more sets will be needed to grind. It will be most like in HS, where new player is w/o chance unless they spend a LOT of money or time. My concern is, after few years there will probably wont be any new players, or only few without important cards from past sets. What do you think, should cards rotate out after few cycles?


r/magicduels • • Aug 03 '15

general discussion Just a note

1 Upvotes

Our community manager, /u/Wizards_Chris took the weekend off. The weekend that came 3 days after launch of the game he's supposed to be CM for.

Now I'm not saying Chris is bad for taking the weekend, if you're off the clock, you're off the clock. However, I think it's very telling what WotC thinks of this game and those playing it that they have the CM take the weekend after launch off without having some other CM cover.

Run for the hills boys, I hear Hex is pretty nice.


r/magicduels • • Jul 01 '16

general discussion This game is prohibitively expensive: the unreasonable pay/grind wall

0 Upvotes

Currently, if you want to skip the grind, you have to drop $240 to buy enough coins to get all the cards. With EMN on the horizon, that number will be closer to $300. Even if you were willing to pay $40, a somewhat high price for a game, that would not even be enough coins to finish a single set.

If you want to grind instead of paying, it currently takes 3-4 months of capping every day while maximizing quests, after which a NEW set will have come out, adding more to the grind. You will have no time to enjoy playing the game before new cards are introduced that will reshape the meta and render many of the cards you just acquired and decks you created to be obsolete.

How are new players expected to be okay with this? I tried introducing Magic Duels to a few friends who were nostalgic about playing Magic as a kid, and after doing the math for them, we all had a good laugh. Meanwhile, because I started playing from Origins, I have enough coins stocked up to buy the next set already. I know there are other players who have enough coins to buy the next 4 sets even if they stopped playing today.

It's time to remove the gold cap. It's time to reevaluate the monetary model. It's time to make old sets much cheaper, or decrease the price of gold. It's time to add gold sinks in the game to encourage people to spend (and to play). It's time to do something about this problem that I predicted months ago. Is there at least going to be an acknowledgment of this issue or are we just going to continue to shrink in size as a community as this "Free2Play" game becomes increasingly Pay2Win and loses all appeal for new players? Is anybody at Wizards even thinking about this problem, let alone working on it?

edit: I don't play Hearthstone. My friend's don't play Hearthstone. Stop bringing it up because it is a moot point. We just want to play Magic, and I only know about the models in Duels/MTGO. Comparing it to another game is meaningless to us, and doesn't make the grind in Duels any less unreasonable. If anything, it makes it more unreasonable as Magic Duels really does not compare with Hearthstone in worldwide popularity or developer support. Hearthstone is a Blizzard product, and you can expect top notch service, bug fixes, and balance decisions. From what I have seen from Stainless/WOTC over the past year in Magic Duels, comparing the two products is an absolute insult. From what I understand, Hearthstone's meta does not revolve so heavily around extremely rare cards, and there are systems to mitigate luck to enable you to still play competitively (disenchanting cards, playing Arena if you're skilled). The online playerbase for Magic Duels is less than 4,000 players out of 1.5mil people who have it installed. It does not even BEGIN to compare with Hearthstone. If Duels' system is so newbie friendly and generous, then where are the players? If Duels wants to succeed in the shadow of Hearthstone, it needs to do things much differently.

http://steamcharts.com/app/316010

http://steamspy.com/app/316010

Our system is deeply flawed, and downvoting this discussion will only send the message to Wizards that everything is okay. I think its abhorrent that people seem to be okay with a $300 price tag to play this poorly supported game.

Lots of people are obviously not even reading the post before they reply. I own all the cards. I have enough coins to buy the new set without playing or paying, and I have not spent a dime on this game to date nor will I ever (That is another flaw in the system to be addressed). The current model doesn't prevent me from playing or enjoying the game. The point is that potential new players have no reason to join in, and the problem only gets worse as new sets come out. Every single person that I have tried to introduce Duels to has laughed at the idea of spending 3 months grinding for cards or spending $200-300 to own all the cards. If you want to play a specific deck, you need to own all the cards, and most competitive decks run multiple rares/mythics (ie, the most popular deck in the current meta is Superfriends).

DOTA2, TF2, Path of Exile...those are the games I think of when I think of Free to Play. These games are successful because they allow you to start on an even playing field, without the need to play the game religiously for 3 months straight or to spend $300 just to catch up with everyone else.


r/magicduels • • Sep 07 '15

question So...they're just done patching the game? There are STILL some of us who can't launch.

5 Upvotes

It really seems that way. We haven't heard shit regarding further patches or whatever. I still can't launch the game. I'm in the "unknown error" camp. I can run DOTP 2015 just fine.

I'm just extremely pissed because I was looking forward to this game and it looks like I won't be able to play until I can afford another computer, which isn't going to happen for a while. It sounds like the first patch cleared up 90% of the launching problems, which apparently is good enough for WOTC. I'll just be left here in the dust. Thanks.


r/magicduels • • Dec 01 '15

general discussion Acid Moss is Limiting Deck Diversity

3 Upvotes

In short, I believe [[Mwonvuli Acid-Moss]] is limiting the possible deck diversity within duels by both countering interesting new multi-colour decks and by generally being too strong in the format.

As we all know, ramp (and in general G/X/x decks) are running rampant on duels and are likely THE deck to beat at this point. I believe that this is in large part due to Acid Moss being way too strong.

First, it directly counters 4/5 colour decks, which is something BFZ is encouraging with converge cards as well as better dual lands, by being able to destroy the specific lands the deck is short on. Acid moss being so common makes it almost impossible to try and innovate with new muti-colour decks and having any success (on top of being extremely frustrating). It also directly counters new deck types like an awaken or manland focused deck.

Second, Acid Moss is just completely overpowered in the duels meta. It's a two lands swing in favour of the person playing Acid Moss, which is something that is extremely hard to come back from without ramp of your own. This is exacerbated by the myriad of strong creatures G got to ramp into, making Acid Moss difficult to counter without an Acid Moss of your own (or an actual counterspell). This incentivizes everyone to play the already strong ramp archetype. There is a reason WotC has been pulling back on strong land destruction in more recent cards, they consider it to be an unfun mechanic when its this strong.


r/magicduels • • Dec 22 '15

community event TibaltTown95 V.S Hakeem928 and other "Good" magic players.

0 Upvotes

hey there i am tibalttown95. i am a comedian and a magic player. sadly i am better at magic than at making people laugh. I am a twitch streamer and it has come to my attention via my followers that there are people out there who also have a following with this game on youtube. I thought what better way to get into the youtube crowd then to beat its "Good" players for my first video. if you are a fan of these youtubers/twitch people let them know about this post and that i would love to play them. you can find my deviod ;) youtube channel by clicking the link on my twitch page.

Hugs and kisses - TibaltTown

P.s if this is against policy, my bad.


r/magicduels • • Apr 13 '16

We need a patch.

0 Upvotes

Look at this tonns of bugs Stainless! Fix them!


r/magicduels • • Apr 20 '16

general discussion Wait for Magic Next?

0 Upvotes

So like a lot of people I am pretty frustrated with the bugs I have experienced in Duels. I'm just wondering how much is known about Magic Next, and if its worth just giving up on Duels and waiting for Next to arrive. I was pretty excited about Duels taking the format it did, being that it was not getting replaced with a new yearly version. Now I guess I'm thinking that WotC might just invest their resources in Next, and it isn't worth investing money or effort into Duels.


r/magicduels • • Aug 05 '16

pvp The beauty of Esper Control

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes