r/ludology • u/[deleted] • Feb 09 '12
Player decision-making in video games
Since I've been reading reviews and commentary on Kingdoms of Generic: Reckoning, I've been forced to consider the sort of bizarre self-deceptive thinking necessary to enjoy the paradigm of western RPGs.
This starts from the k^n problem: if you give players actual flexibility in decision-making, and the average number of choices per decision point is k, and there are n total decision points, then there are k^n expected plot threads. To put some perspective on this equation, if you get to choose between 3 options each time you make a choice, and there are 10 opportunities to make choices (an extremely low number for modern video games!), then there are 59,049 possible outcomes.
We all know what happens as an alternative to designing millions of possible endings: at best there's two or three choices that have any impact on the plot, they're clustered at the end, and all they do is select some variations on the ending sequence. (Games that allege to offer massive player choice instead offer irrelevant player choice, but change some lines of dialogue in unimportant ways.)
The question is why this is viewed as preferable. A game presents a choice, often in the form of a forced moral dilemma, and then once you've made it and the associated cutscene ends, the choice no longer exists.
Even the choice of killing one of the two other human party members in Mass Effect is only made meaningful if you for some reason use both in your party, since neither of them have enough narrative heft to really imprint, and of course BioWare isn't going to completely bifrucate the game at that point. Compare to the railroad ride of Final Fantasy VII, where Jenova murdering Aeris still causes mental anguish for a lot of players. (Then there's the "decision-making" of the last level of Mass Effect 2, where the logical connections are so obscured that the game turns into Reservoir Dogs. If they wanted to make a postmodern commentary on movies about organized crime, then at least they succeeded on that front...)
Despite that, "player choice" in RPGs is still seen as a good thing, and I just can't see how. Choice in games is basically the deterministic choose-your-own-adventure book, but with a much higher budget, and an apparent lack of self-awareness on the part of either the developer or the player.
So, now that I've probably offended 80% of the people reading this... thoughts?