r/lrcast • u/Dont_be_thatotherguy • Oct 31 '23
Discussion Hot Take, but I don't think Marshall and Luis shouldn't do Common and Uncommon set reviews anymore.
The commons and uncommons set review is their biggest and longest show of a set. I imagine it takes the most time for them to record, and I would like them to dedicate that time to the podcast in other, more useful ways for them and the listeners.
I understand that set reviews are a bedrock of LR. As far as I know, Marshall and Ryan were the first to do a card-by-card review of the set, and I imagine they hold a dear place in Marshall's heart. But they just aren't worth it anymore in my experience.
First, given the formulaic methodology by which Wizards makes new sets (as Marshall referenced in the WOE sunset show), a lot of the grades and evaluations are already effectively locked in. The 1W instant that deals 3 or 4 damage to an attacking or blocking creature will be a C+ in controlling decks and will drop off as your deck becomes more aggressive. The 1B spell that gives -3/-3 will be a B-/B and will be one of black's two best commons. The 1G or 2G fight spell with small upside will be a C/C-, but make sure you aren't casting it into open mana too often! Wizards occasionally tinkers with the mana costs and effects that makes them vary by a fraction of a letter grade, but anyone who has listened to a few set reviews or has played a few sets of Magic knows approximately what grades these cards will get.
Second, the boys are wrong too often. I get it, no one is going to be perfect, but in my experience, being wrong about a card is worse than not rating it at all. Ostensibly, the set review is most important to newer players, but these players are also the most vulnerable to bad reviews. For example, when discussing [[Ashiok's Reaper]] in Episode 714, Luis says "Playing this and trying to load up on roles and turn them into cantrips seems pretty awesome. It's also just good naturally as the game progresses." The guys ended up giving it a build around B. By their own grading scale, that means that this should actively draw you into playing black and prioritizing roles (or other enchantments like [[Hopeless Nightmare]]). In their final crack-a-pack, the card was mentioned, but they expressed how there was no way it was worth taking. If you're a new player listening to the set review, that build around B grade is leading you into a trap. And I agree with Marshall when he says "it should have" worked; I would have graded it similarly. But the set review doesn't account for failed archetypes, and the guys ended up missing on this one (and others) as a result. Similarly, Luis said of [[Immodane's Recruiter]] that he doesn't feel quite as bad when a card they said would be great turns out to be awesome, but I think that's also a miss. They said "this looks like a B for red white," which to me says "If you are red and white, this will be a solid performer in your deck. If you are open, this is a good reason to try to play red white." As it turns out, it's an A level card, and the guys admitted they would splash it a GB deck. That's 'be willing to warp your mana to play this card' level, and it's really important to know (accurately) which cards are and are not worth that type of investment. I've got a friend who just can't seem to go infinite in Arena drafting, and one of his biggest issues is that he'll treat D's like C's (as far as willingness to play them). Being a whole letter grade off on card evaluation for even a few commons and uncommons is enough to handicap a player for an entire format. Again, I don't want to rag on the guys. I've tried set reviews, and I missed a lot. Everyone does. But if a set review is only 80% on target and 20% off target, and you can't tell which cards are graded correctly a priori, how useful is it really? Which leads to my third point:
Third, we have playtested, aggregated, more accurate information about the set within a week of release! After every new set, we have countless posts detailing some of the 17lands data trends regarding which cards and archetypes are performing surprisingly well or poorly. This first week of data is, in my opinion, the de facto set review. Yes, sometimes archetypes shift in power as people discover them sometimes secret archetypes emerge later in formats (think RG spells in MID), and that initial data doesn't capture them. But rarely does the set review, either. I trust the first week of data from 17lands more than the set review grades and commentary at this point - not just from LR, but from any podcast trying to grade cards before they are played.
Fourth, given the number of games played nowadays with the advent of Arena and the rise of data-driven limited analysis, formats mature substantially faster than in the past. The guys usually release the Commons and Uncommons review right before or during the prerelease weekend and the Rares review about a week later. The following week comes the First Impressions episode. But, as Marshall has joked previously, by two weeks into the format, first impressions have long come and gone. I would wager that over 50% of a format's maturation and discovery nowadays happens in the first week, and the information in the commons and uncommons set review is effectively obliviated by that point.
Why spend 4+ hours on something that is of mixed usefulness for roughly one week? I would much rather see the guys skip the commons and uncommons review (or do an abridged version for newer players regarding the relative usefulness of the effects that are always present in sets nowadays), prioritize completing the Rare, Mythic, and bonus sheet review when they would normally do the commons/uncommons, release a first impressions show (including commentary on which commons and uncommons are over- and under-performing based on what we would historically expect from their effects) when the rare/mythic review would normally be released, then start some deep dives when the first impressions show would normally be released (e.g. roughly the second week of the format). I think it would save them a bunch of time and provide more useful and relevant information to the listeners when it is most useful and relevant. Plus, it frees up an episode each cycle for some fun topics (e.g. vintage cube reviews that don't eat into the current sets analysis, genius or grifter episodes on rotation, guest appearances, old set reviews with TBS, or whatever the guys want to do).
Finally, I will mention that I do think the Rare/Mythic/Bonus sheet reviews are useful. Those effects are less standardized, and the guys' insights on their novelty have proven useful for me very often. Plus, the average drafter will see less of those, so the information the guys present 1) feels relevant more often until people have enough experience to build their own impressions and 2) is lower stakes, since missing on a card you'll open only a few times in a format has much lower consequences than missing on a card you'll see almost every draft.
I know I've said a lot, but I also know this topic might be contentious, and I wanted to give a reasonable explanation for my thoughts. I don't mean to harp on the Marshall and Luis; I think the issues I've presented herein are inevitable for any set review nowadays. I'm certain I would do no better were I in their positions. Thanks for reading, and I look forward to your comments.
