r/lrcast • • Oct 31 '23

Discussion Hot Take, but I don't think Marshall and Luis shouldn't do Common and Uncommon set reviews anymore.

0 Upvotes

The commons and uncommons set review is their biggest and longest show of a set. I imagine it takes the most time for them to record, and I would like them to dedicate that time to the podcast in other, more useful ways for them and the listeners.

I understand that set reviews are a bedrock of LR. As far as I know, Marshall and Ryan were the first to do a card-by-card review of the set, and I imagine they hold a dear place in Marshall's heart. But they just aren't worth it anymore in my experience.

First, given the formulaic methodology by which Wizards makes new sets (as Marshall referenced in the WOE sunset show), a lot of the grades and evaluations are already effectively locked in. The 1W instant that deals 3 or 4 damage to an attacking or blocking creature will be a C+ in controlling decks and will drop off as your deck becomes more aggressive. The 1B spell that gives -3/-3 will be a B-/B and will be one of black's two best commons. The 1G or 2G fight spell with small upside will be a C/C-, but make sure you aren't casting it into open mana too often! Wizards occasionally tinkers with the mana costs and effects that makes them vary by a fraction of a letter grade, but anyone who has listened to a few set reviews or has played a few sets of Magic knows approximately what grades these cards will get.

Second, the boys are wrong too often. I get it, no one is going to be perfect, but in my experience, being wrong about a card is worse than not rating it at all. Ostensibly, the set review is most important to newer players, but these players are also the most vulnerable to bad reviews. For example, when discussing [[Ashiok's Reaper]] in Episode 714, Luis says "Playing this and trying to load up on roles and turn them into cantrips seems pretty awesome. It's also just good naturally as the game progresses." The guys ended up giving it a build around B. By their own grading scale, that means that this should actively draw you into playing black and prioritizing roles (or other enchantments like [[Hopeless Nightmare]]). In their final crack-a-pack, the card was mentioned, but they expressed how there was no way it was worth taking. If you're a new player listening to the set review, that build around B grade is leading you into a trap. And I agree with Marshall when he says "it should have" worked; I would have graded it similarly. But the set review doesn't account for failed archetypes, and the guys ended up missing on this one (and others) as a result. Similarly, Luis said of [[Immodane's Recruiter]] that he doesn't feel quite as bad when a card they said would be great turns out to be awesome, but I think that's also a miss. They said "this looks like a B for red white," which to me says "If you are red and white, this will be a solid performer in your deck. If you are open, this is a good reason to try to play red white." As it turns out, it's an A level card, and the guys admitted they would splash it a GB deck. That's 'be willing to warp your mana to play this card' level, and it's really important to know (accurately) which cards are and are not worth that type of investment. I've got a friend who just can't seem to go infinite in Arena drafting, and one of his biggest issues is that he'll treat D's like C's (as far as willingness to play them). Being a whole letter grade off on card evaluation for even a few commons and uncommons is enough to handicap a player for an entire format. Again, I don't want to rag on the guys. I've tried set reviews, and I missed a lot. Everyone does. But if a set review is only 80% on target and 20% off target, and you can't tell which cards are graded correctly a priori, how useful is it really? Which leads to my third point:

Third, we have playtested, aggregated, more accurate information about the set within a week of release! After every new set, we have countless posts detailing some of the 17lands data trends regarding which cards and archetypes are performing surprisingly well or poorly. This first week of data is, in my opinion, the de facto set review. Yes, sometimes archetypes shift in power as people discover them sometimes secret archetypes emerge later in formats (think RG spells in MID), and that initial data doesn't capture them. But rarely does the set review, either. I trust the first week of data from 17lands more than the set review grades and commentary at this point - not just from LR, but from any podcast trying to grade cards before they are played.

Fourth, given the number of games played nowadays with the advent of Arena and the rise of data-driven limited analysis, formats mature substantially faster than in the past. The guys usually release the Commons and Uncommons review right before or during the prerelease weekend and the Rares review about a week later. The following week comes the First Impressions episode. But, as Marshall has joked previously, by two weeks into the format, first impressions have long come and gone. I would wager that over 50% of a format's maturation and discovery nowadays happens in the first week, and the information in the commons and uncommons set review is effectively obliviated by that point.

Why spend 4+ hours on something that is of mixed usefulness for roughly one week? I would much rather see the guys skip the commons and uncommons review (or do an abridged version for newer players regarding the relative usefulness of the effects that are always present in sets nowadays), prioritize completing the Rare, Mythic, and bonus sheet review when they would normally do the commons/uncommons, release a first impressions show (including commentary on which commons and uncommons are over- and under-performing based on what we would historically expect from their effects) when the rare/mythic review would normally be released, then start some deep dives when the first impressions show would normally be released (e.g. roughly the second week of the format). I think it would save them a bunch of time and provide more useful and relevant information to the listeners when it is most useful and relevant. Plus, it frees up an episode each cycle for some fun topics (e.g. vintage cube reviews that don't eat into the current sets analysis, genius or grifter episodes on rotation, guest appearances, old set reviews with TBS, or whatever the guys want to do).

Finally, I will mention that I do think the Rare/Mythic/Bonus sheet reviews are useful. Those effects are less standardized, and the guys' insights on their novelty have proven useful for me very often. Plus, the average drafter will see less of those, so the information the guys present 1) feels relevant more often until people have enough experience to build their own impressions and 2) is lower stakes, since missing on a card you'll open only a few times in a format has much lower consequences than missing on a card you'll see almost every draft.

I know I've said a lot, but I also know this topic might be contentious, and I wanted to give a reasonable explanation for my thoughts. I don't mean to harp on the Marshall and Luis; I think the issues I've presented herein are inevitable for any set review nowadays. I'm certain I would do no better were I in their positions. Thanks for reading, and I look forward to your comments.


r/lrcast • • May 02 '26

It seems to me that everyone has drafted the perfect soup deck

1 Upvotes
  1. turn 2 environmental scientist 100%

  2. turn 3 potioners trove

  3. perfect mana base at turn 5 with 5 colours

  4. turn 6 snarl song

  5. big payoff with transcedend archaic or sundering archaic

This has happened for more than 15 games to me and its starting to get annoying and repetitive. I am honestly wondering how easy is it to draft this deck with such consistent quality, especially at this point in the format.

Based on my experience, the soup deck is not open for more than 80% of drafts.


r/lrcast • • Sep 13 '25

Discussion Marshall and Luis were too harsh on EoE

29 Upvotes

Luis gave it a C, Marshall a C+. This feels disrespectful to the set. I thought EoE had really fun gameplay and I'm happy that no color pair was unplayable. IMO it deserved a minimum B. I think they underrated it because they were mourning FFN still


r/lrcast • • Nov 19 '25

Hot Take - There are too many busted rares in this format for limited to remain fun.

0 Upvotes

So I'm about 10 drafts deep, which admittedly isn't a massive sample size. I've averaged 3-3 over those drafts and the majority of the games I'm either winning or losing are the result of somebody untapping with a busted rare or mythic in play. That's part of limited and I'm ok with this most of the time, but it seems like this set has way more of that level of bomb in it than other recent sets. I've also anecdotally noticed that there seem to be more rares in packs than usual, which further exacerbates the issue. I think this takes away alot from what could have otherwise been a tactically deep format and will damage the longevity. What are other peoples experiences with the general bombiness of this format so far?


r/lrcast • • Sep 18 '23

Nitpick: Can we please stop calling Imodane's Recruiter "Imodane"?

0 Upvotes

Imodane is literally its own card. If you can't spare the few seconds to type both words, I really recommend going with "Recruiter." There's a whole other word in that there card name, and that one has the advantage of not sharing a name with a different card


r/lrcast • • Sep 15 '21

Genius or Grifter?

0 Upvotes

Spending years building your self up as someone who cares about ethics, only to sign a marketing deal with a NFT company and shill stocks to your fans?


r/lrcast • • Jun 14 '25

Discussion Final Fantasy is...good?

0 Upvotes

Draft has been in a pretty rough spot since Duskmourn rotated out with a mediocre Core Set and two all-time stinkers in a row, but Final Fantasy looks to have reversed this trend, with a lot of things to like.

Color and archetype balance is, with the exception of G/R, solid with no huge outliers in winrate nor general playability; it feels as though every color pair could be conceivably supported to one drafter in any given pod as opposed to some formats wherein an open X/Y seat could still produce a trashpile of a deck. Red is very shallow past the extremely good cards and Blue seems criminally underdrafted for how strong it's roster is, but there's nothing like Aethershit White, where 70%+ of the (un)commons were D to F tier, versus Green, which was insanely deep.

I'm not certain whether or not this is more of a card quality or synergy format...which is probably a good thing and indicates a depper format. Yes, there are some backbreaking bombs, but a lot of the synergy payoffs are excellent and can make decks more than the sum of their parts. A good example are the U/R signposts -- Shantotto doesn't fit in every deck but is absurd when you're curving into some 4 mana spell and has amazing grindout potential. Something like Blazing Bomb, in a vacuum, looks like complete drizzling dogshit, but can be a decent synergy piece in the right deck that you can count of wheeling. Contra Tarkir Shitstorm where cards were just plain good or bad, leading to soupy messes, and seeing the same cards match after match.

The tempo versus value axis doesn't feel too skewed towards one side of another. Aggro can be quite good, empirically borne out by the high winrate of cards like Samurai's Katana, but there exists more than adequate defensive speed in cards like the 1/4 Scorpion or Sahaugin.

Another point in FF's favor is that there's variation in play patterns among the archetypes. R/B Black Mages plays out somewhat differently from U/R Big Spells which in turn both are very different U/B control,, B/G graveyard value, U/G/x ramp, or U/W Artifacts-Tempo, or W/R/G aggro variants. You're not going to be playing the same matches ad nauseam a la Tarkir Shitstorm; which is one of the biggest selling points of Limited.

It's not all Sun Titans and Lotuses, as many of the structural flaws in contemporary limited still rear their ugly heads.

Power creep in general makes for more lopsided non-games especially with all the cards pushed for Constructed that snowball mercilessly in Limited. Jecht, Odin, and Vincent Valentine are all great examples pretty much offer a one turn window to deal with them or face serious disadvantage. The number of people I've already punked with Absolute Virtue is heinous; protection from players is a dirty keyword that should never have been conceived (screw you True Name Nemesis, even if you've been power-crept into irrelevance).

The breakneck pace of set release means that fine balancing is imperfect, even with labor-saving methods like spreadsheet design, so there are still a dozen or so garbage commons that have to face off against all-star bombs, mythic uncommons, and a slew of B-level commons (figuratively speaking; no competent players are going to run these in 99% of situations rendering them newbie traps like the bad parts of old-school drafting).

Play Boosters make cross-pod play more of a shitshow than it already is, and WotC's choice of making the bonus sheet only appearing one in every x packs only adds more to the variance in pod pool strength just to squeeze additional $$$$$$$$$ out of collectors.

But despite all this, Final Fantasy is still pretty fun so far and I'm cautiously optimistic the format has some legs going forward. What are your thoughts? Am I off my rocker? Is everything going to come crashing down once the turbo-spikes optimize the fun out of the format? Or is this actually a decent set?


r/lrcast • • Mar 01 '22

In light of recent event in Ukraine, a reminder that the fine sponsors of Limited Resources are profiting greatly from money being laundered out of Russia right now

Thumbnail
ft.com
26 Upvotes

r/lrcast • • Feb 07 '22

I am boycotting LR as long as they’re sponsored by FTX

55 Upvotes

I’m really sad today. The new set review is out and normally I’d be listening to it and eagerly anticipating the new cards gathering the hot takes ready for the prerelease. Instead I’m googling how to create a reddit account and canceling my Patreon subscription for a show I’ve spent nearly a decade listening to.

I don’t want this whole thing to become an argument about the efficacy of crypto; there’s a lot of passionate, genuine people on both sides of that, but also a lot of toxicity and bad faith that bogs down discussion. Suffice to say there were enough questions to make me skeptical, the show kept telling me to do my own research and the more research I did the more discontented I was.

My opinion is that crypto is bad. But more importantly, my opinion is that I shouldn’t have to spend hours forming an opinion on brand new technology in order to judge the morality of a strategy gaming podcast.

I really wanted to give the hosts the benefit of the doubt on this one. But it seems this decision was made more out of an interest in the shows bottom line, than in the values it has always claimed to be at its core.

So I’m doing the only thing I can do, I am voting with my wallet, and my attention and my downloads. I’d encourage listeners who feel similarly to do the same.

I am really sad today.


r/lrcast • • Nov 08 '24

Image It was really important to me that I beat this jerk because of their username

Post image
15 Upvotes

I felt the pressure as soon as we were matched and I read their name. Got nervous because I didn't like my opening hand, and felt like any victories they experience on Arena validate their crappy world view. My experience of bullies in elementary school lit a fire under my ass. I really needed this win.

I frequently use the emotes "Hello!" and "Nice!" in good sportsmanship, but the only communication this douche canoe got out of me was an "oops" as their life total went to zero. FOH with that.


r/lrcast • • Mar 05 '24

Discussion Has K.E.T.O become obsolete?

0 Upvotes

Way back in the earlier days of drafting, when everything was more laid back, the B.R.E.A.D method made sense.  Creatures were not as cracked, most commons and uncommons didn't do 20 different things when you cast them and the mechanics were a lot simpler.  Basically anyone with a pulse could sit down at a table and pull off a functional, competitive draft deck as long as you followed the B.R.E.A.D mantra.

Magic progressed however, and as the mechanics and cards grew in complexity, it quickly started to out grow the B.R.E.A.D way of thinking.  Thankfully, Marshall and co-resourcer  Brian Wong got together and gave us episode 184 of Limited Resources, Card Evaluation which was the birth of Quandrant Theory.  The theory proved viable, and a new generation of Limited players emerged with a new way to look at each set past and present.  We can all agree it was a valuable practice to use, that was until we entered the "Modern Era" of sets and drafting.

As many of us noticed, when Thrones of Eldraine dropped, the game once again changed.  What we knew or did in the past no longer worked, as cards had once again changed and the whole evaluation system we used once again had to be re-evaluated itself.  Thankfully the boys wasted no time and gave us episode 611 :  K.E.T.O is the new B.R.E.A.D.  Not only was it an impressive word play on the abbreviations, it was also a fresh and flawless way to look at drafting in limited again.  Those of use who listened to the pod saw our win rates skyrocket, while those that didn't continued to struggle and adapt to the new way of drafting.  The only question everyone had was "how long will this ideology last?"  Well unfortunately the Arena Open proved we once again have to re-design how we draft.

Every creature is now a bomb that does 10 things, every colour seems to have 7 different cards at least that provide some form of efficient removal.  Two drops and who is on the play with said two drops have become what determines who wins or who loses.  How many reviews have the boys done now where we hear about so many cards that back in the day would have been absolute bangers, but when it comes time to draft, you can never make them work because 2 drops have already steamrolled you and snowballed out of control.  We are long past the days of needing removal for the few bombs opponent may have because now every creature is a bomb.  If you don't have 13 bombs of your own then go home, because you don't have a chance.

My question is what do prioritize going into a drafts in current day MTG, and is there a way we can abbreviate for newer drafters so they can have a chance?  The closest I've come up with is:

T - Two drops:  Prioritize any 2 drop above anything else.

U - Ultimate Bombs:  Any card that if opponent can't deal with that turn ends the game.

R - Removal:  There's tons of it, make sure you grab some.

D - Don't Bother:  If you didn't get 13 playable 2 drops don't waste your time, concede and draft again.

Tl;Dr: With the formats being quicker and the cards becoming more busted, is there a new mindset to have when figuring out what to prioritize while drafting?  


r/lrcast • • Oct 19 '25

I absolutely hate this guy

Post image
0 Upvotes

Cephalid was the 6th land. And of course he played the frog on 2, pumped it into open mana and I didn't have shit.

Drives me nuts how you can be so bad and still win in this bs game.


r/lrcast • • Feb 21 '24

Rate My Draft I enjoy the MKM draft experience, 13 drafts plat 4 to Mythic #424

0 Upvotes

Played MKM Quick Drafts for about a week since it was available.

Overall Records

Games: 68 - 27 (71.6% win rate)

Total Events: 13 (6 Trophies)

One of the MKM Quick Draft trophy leaders right now, up there on win % and trophy %.

I like the format. It fits well into my draft strategy (rare drafting) and then build a deck around those. I am getting about 6 rares&mythics per draft.

Format is fast, but I also had a few long games, so I think there is sufficiently versatile gaming.

Here a link to the 17lands data with decks etc in case anybody is interested.


r/lrcast • • Dec 18 '24

Okay, I recognize that board wipes are not fun to play against...

0 Upvotes

...which is why I feel I must publicly apologize for drafting Day of Judgment FOUR DRAFTS IN A ROW!

I really expected UW to be overdrafted at this stage, but I just keep taking what I feel are the best cards, and I somehow keep pulling this card every draft. 😅 Apologies to whoever I face against. You deserve better, more skilled opponents than this stupid chucklefuck (me) who slams a board wipe whenever things get dicey.


r/lrcast • • Oct 31 '25

Hasbro is draining gems by the bucketload with powered cube

2 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/kGknlEWjxZc?si=qaT5I9WQhB_5c1Wp

NSFW language

Meanwhile the guy who coded all the cards in his spare time is still in the basement at wotc trying to make splice onto arcane happen.


r/lrcast • • Apr 13 '24

I think im gonna hate OTJ draft...

0 Upvotes

I see way too many bombs deciding matches. I liked MKM because i felt you could win consistently with a solid deck without bombs. This looks even worse than LCI in that respect, just lose to a degenerate deck that has a couple mega bombs and no deckbuilding or ingame skill saving you from it.

i already see myself cursing at a t3 OKO on the play....


r/lrcast • • Oct 08 '26

Apologies if i played against anyone here

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Second arena direct win. This one was significantly easier than the other lol. Absolutely insane pool


r/lrcast • • Sep 02 '25

Discussion Discussing a card shouldn't require "ratings"

8 Upvotes

I wish this subreddit would be more open to discussing a cards potential pros and cons without just dissolving to what rank are you what's your win percentage.

For example:

Person makes posts about card they think might be better than people give it credit for (maybe with rage bait title)

Person provides reasons why they like said card, maybe some things people overlook

Person provides examples of decks using said card to help people visualize

People comment agreements and disagreements with their own reasons that aren't just

  • DATA SAY THIS!!!

  • WHAT RANK ARE YOU?!

  • I CANNOT TRUST OPINION OF MORE THAN 3 PEOPLE WITH 67% WR IN MYTHIC

Just some food for thought


r/lrcast • • Nov 20 '23

Discussion The more I play LCI, the more I vehemently dislike it.

10 Upvotes

I know it's still relatively early and it's a little bit hyperbolic but I think this is the worst draft set since AFR, if not worse. I typically don't want to be overly negative since there is so much negativity in the magic community but I needed an outlet to vent about how frustrated I am with how this format plays out.

It's not just because of the speed or the (really bad) color imbalance that makes me mad. We've had a lot of that in the past year and while that constant problem is getting old quick, most sets were able to offset it for one reason or the other. MOM had a lot of splashy spells that were interesting and Battles offered an interesting wrinkle. LTR just had great flavor that helped it. WOE was miserable but there was a 5 color/soup deck that allowed for some experimentation and offset the struggle for the aggro cards.

There's nothing like that here. It's a similar problem to WOE where half of the set doesn't work but this time there isn't a silver lining. In WOE, despite whole archetypes and color pairs not working, the color fixing was good enough to string enough non-aggro cards together that offered a different playstyle.

This set has nothing like that and is, quite frankly, fucking terrible. Descend doesn't work. Caves doesn't work. UG, is, surprise surprise, unplayable. The whole trinket-y type of playstyle that was in BRO and Luis was hoping this set would deliver, in my opinion, is a complete failure. All of those 1 and 2 mana cards are so good that you just put them together and don't worry about the payoffs or anything interesting. The one mana fliers are so busted that you just jam them all together and win.

And that's sort of what I think is the big issue at play. The cards that are really good are typically much cheaper and there's a huge gulf between the best cards in the format and the "C" level cards which are closer to D+ here. It's been a long long time since I remember a set that once you get to pick four or five, there's just complete chaff and garbage left. Half of the set really pales in comparison to the other half. I don't remember anything quite like this in a long time. In magic, typically the more expensive cards are just better and more powerful than the cheaper ones. That is not true anymore, I get it, but this set feels like an extreme exaggeration of it.

Caves is part of the reason this set falls flat too. Calamitous Cave-In is incredible but if you do not have that card, you just can't play the deck. And if someone else is drafting it, both of you just knocked each other out. Most of the enablers for that deck being uncommon makes it incredibly hard to draft. I did trophy with a caves deck but it really was just a solid RW deck that had two cave-ins.

Everything about this format is so miserable for me. I'm counting down the days until Khans comes out.

This is just my opinion and I know others enjoy this set but I just had to get this off my chest. I hate this format so much.


r/lrcast • • Dec 17 '25

FIN is a good draft format, but overrated.

19 Upvotes

I am someone who really enjoys FIN, both Final Fantasy the property and the draft format. I played to Mythic the last two times it has been on Arena. However, this most recent occurrence has made me re-evaluate my opinion of the format. Basically, I think the viable archetypes are too narrow, especially in the established Arena drafting crowd who is hip to 17lands, podcasts, content, etc. I feel like if you aren't in URx spells, 4/5x green piles, or a very streamlined equipment aggro deck, the other archetypes are just a total mess. GB graveyard used to be my offramp but not it seems there is less of that as more people try to force Gx decks. I just feel like the shine is coming off the format the more it gets "solved" and I feel like there is not as much openness in the draft. If I draft good B/W uncommons, rares, and commons, I feel like I will just lose to the tier1/2 archetypes even if they have an average deck. Playskill doesn't really matter if your opponent goes extremely over the top or kills every creature you play. Just my two cents.


r/lrcast • • Feb 03 '26

Trophy to finish this format for me, I'm not a fan

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I find this format extremely frustrating more often than fun. I lost my first two games then went 7 wins in a row. Shout out to personify which put me too far ahead at multiple inflection points in games. Kinscar sentry is an amazing card but I only got value of it once as it's just a removal magnet on curve.


r/lrcast • • Apr 10 '25

Help Interesting format so far

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/lrcast • • May 04 '24

I Lost 20k Gems in OTJ

0 Upvotes

From 50% winrate in OTJ drafting (historically 60%+ over 3 years) getting no removal, no bomb mythics (opened Pitiless Carnage P1P1 5 times), and conceding to bombs like t3 oko + t4 oko, and from a similar fate just now going 1-3 in Arena Open, I have lost 20k gems in total thanks to OTJ.

Where do I go from here? I don't even play Constructed or Brawl. Do I grind the precon format for the next year? How do I hold all these tears...


r/lrcast • • Oct 13 '26

Unpopular opinion? FRA games take way too long

16 Upvotes

Enjoyed the format for the first week or so but feeling burnt out after about 15 drafts. A lot of the games one player gets way ahead and then it takes 5+ turns to actually end the game.

It feels awful when you’re losing/even on board and OP is drawing 2+ cards per turn. On the flip side it feels bad to be ahead and drawing 2+ cards per turn and have your opponent tank every turn trying to fight back deciding where to put dog counters that ultimately won’t matter.

About once per draft you’ll have an epic match where both players are doing the Jace thing and it’s a real arms race that feels amazing to play, but the rest of the games I’m left chasing that high.

HOB was too fast for me but FRA is too long. I didn’t think it was possible to have too many game actions but this feels like it.

Edit: I was curious to see how others were feeling about the long turns and frequent decking. Sounds like most of you are enjoying it because there are lots of meaningful decisions to be made and I think most of the time this is true. I don’t hate the set, I think it’s average. I think I’ve lost interest in the set faster than others due to the above average number of 20+ minute games. To those of you who say I’m bad - I’ve had a 64% win rate in the format, I don’t think winning is the issue. Thanks for all the input.