r/litverve • • Mar 31 '14

a beautiful fragment from John Fowles(Daniel Martin)

1 Upvotes

"Love is so strange, so conducted, since time began, under the illusion that it brings the lovers closer together; which it does, of course, in all sorts of physical and psychological ways. But it is also based on some profoundly blind assumptions, the prime fantasy being that the nature of the loved one during the first passionate phase is the everlasting true nature. But that phase is an infinitely delicate balance of reciprocal illusion, a meshing of wheels so finely cogged that the slightest atom of dust—the intrusion of hitherto unrecognized desires, tastes, twists of character, any new information thrust into the idyll—can wreck the movement. I knew this, I had learned to watch for it as one learns to watch for signs of familiar disease in certain plants."

  • John Fowles, Daniel Martin


r/litverve • • May 20 '14

Novel Ayn Rand on sexual attraction, from Atlas Shrugged

5 Upvotes

Love is blind, they say; sex is impervious to reason and mocks the power of all philosophers. But, in fact, a person's sexual choice is the result and sum of their fundamental convictions. Tell me what a person finds sexually attractive and I will tell you their entire philosophy of life. Show me the person they sleep with and I will tell you their valuation of themselves. No matter what corruption they're taught about the virtue of selflessness, sex is the most profoundly selfish of all acts, an act which they cannot perform for any motive but their own enjoyment - just try to think of performing it in a spirit of selfless charity! - an act which is not possible in self-abasement, only in self-exultation, only on the confidence of being desired and being worthy of desire. It is an act that forces them to stand naked in spirit, as well as in body, and accept their real ego as their standard of value. They will always be attracted to the person who reflects their deepest vision of themselves.

I, too, think the world would be a better place if people stopped quoting -- stopped reading -- Ayn Rand. But this quote captures an important truth, and Rand says something about human nature that I've never seen anyone else say.

She's right about this. People are attracted to those who are reflections of their self-conception. Consider a man who makes great money and has all the trappings of success, but knows himself to be a cheat and a fraud. You will always find that kind of man with a cheap money-grubbing woman, someone whose self-esteem is as lacking as his.

As a stylist, Rand's great strength is her sense of conviction. She speaks directly and without equivocation, and there is a stark clarity to her prose. There's no beauty in it, and the writing in her novels is often laughably bad. (Her tin ear for dialog is legendary.) But I think this snippet is memorable for what it says, if not necessarily for how she says it.

P.S. This is a milestone day for /r/litverve. No subreddit is actually legitimate until it contains a reference to Ayn Rand. Oh, one more thing: Here's a cute kitten. Shout it from the rooftops. /r/litverve has arrived!


r/litverve • • May 07 '14

Novel The opening lines of Samuel Delany's virtuosic Dhalgren

5 Upvotes

to wound the autumnal city.

So howled out for the world to give him a name.

The in-dark answered with wind.

All you know I know: careening astronauts and bank clerks glancing at the clock before lunch; actresses cowling at light-ringed mirrors and freight elevator operators grinding a thumbful of grease on a steel handle; student riots; know that dark women in bodegas shook their heads last week because in six months prices have risen outlandishly; how coffee tastes after you've held it in your mouth, cold, a whole minute.

A whole minute he squatted, pebbles clutched with his left foot (the bare one), listening to his breath sound tumble down the ledges.

Beyond a leafy arras, moonlight flittered.

He rubbed his palms against denim. Where he was, was still. Somewhere else, wind whined.


r/litverve • • May 11 '14

Essay Franz Kafka points about the elusiveness of writing, how writing fails to gain an impression, from Diaries

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/litverve • • May 16 '14

Novel A Quote, some Musings from *Delores Claiborne*

3 Upvotes

Vera Donovan: Sometimes, Dolores... sometimes, you have to be a high-riding bitch to survive. Sometimes, being a bitch is all a woman has to hang onto.

This is from Delores Claiborne, Stephen King's book, later a movie, as well.

I think I have stolen this quote about a hundred times, conservatively estimating.

I have been this person and I have surely met a few-about ninety-nine, I guess.

My humble take on what King was saying is that when first all the conceits, then maybe values, and finally a woman's humanity are stripped from her, all she's got left is that uniquely female ability to be a bitch, with the unerring ability to inflict all of that upon whomever should come onto her radar.

Delores never really loses hers, it just goes into deep hiding.

The line where she tells the detective, played by Christopher Glover that she is sure that he has not, "been this broke up since ya string broke on yer pet dime at the pay toilet" is another favorite of mine. Her humanity, that she tries so valiantly to subvert, contrasts with the utter absence of any in the detective Glover plays. And of course, she bests him in the end.

Delores' humanity comes once again to the fore with the arrival of her daughter, the sarcastic, derisive focus of all of her prior efforts, of her life. In "saving" her daughter, she is herself renewed.

King does a fine day's work with these characters and the confounding ways they all interact and there is the satisfaction in the end that Delores is not sent to Shawshank Prison simply for being a bitch, as Glover's character intends.

It would be nice to believe that everyone who is ever pushed to the point of saddling up and becoming her own version of a high riding bitch has this shot at redemption, but that would be naive.

I hope this makes a lick of sense.


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Poem delightful Penny Ashton in "The Shall I have sex or write a poem poem"

1 Upvotes

So shall I have sex or write a poem

The situation’s tense

If I give in to lasciviousness, then my muse and I will be spent

If I throw away my quill to jump under a feather quilt

Then once I’ve come and gone and come, I’ll be wracked with guilt

Aren’t poets supposed to be miserable, lovesick, forlorn

Not happily banging out a meter to the strains of porn

Shouldn’t I simply be masturbating all alone

Then turning my angst and finger cramp into a wretched poem

“Oh, where are you, and who is he, that lingers in the mist

The chariots of Helios still deny your kiss

My soul is turgid, torn tumescent tingling and true

But black satin sheets of wet desire boil a pheromone stew.”

Such oral epics I could produce on the back of restraint

Or of course I could get on my back, and oral till you faint

BUT no instead I’ll alliterate and show off my assonance

Write by flickering candlelight and bid farewell to finance

I’ll eat bread and mouldy cheese and move away to Paris

Catch a fashionable disease and dream about your phallus

Which I’ll compare to a summer’s day as it’s newly shook in June

Resplendent like a daffodil to make a Bath Wife swoon

A satanic mill never stood so tall and yours is a road that

I’d gladly take till your jabberwock finds my bandersnatch

For foreplay on your nipples I will lyrically wax

Till a Nobel Prize for literature becomes my shuddering climax

So shall I have sex or write a poem about having sex

Scheme with rhymes AA, BB or just XY plus XX

Will fame and fortune come my way if I come all alone

Or will my efforts come to nothing, a has been talent free zone

So shall I have sex or write a poem

The situation’s tense

It’s time to throw my leg over, stop straddling the fence

Sex, poem, sex, poem, clamped knees or bed spread

Screw it, screw me, poetic fame comes only when you’re dead.


r/litverve • • May 13 '14

Novel Mark Z. Danielewski on killing time, from House of Leaves

3 Upvotes

Who has never killed an hour? Not casually or without thought, but carefully: a premeditated murder of minutes. The violence comes from a combination of giving up, not caring, and a resignation that getting past it is all you can hope to accomplish. So you kill the hour. You do not work, you do not read, you do not daydream. If you sleep it is not because you need to sleep. And when at last it is over, there is no evidence: no weapon, no blood, and no body. The only clue might be the shadows beneath your eyes or a terribly thin line near the corner of your mouth indicating something has been suffered, that in the privacy of your life you have lost something and the loss is too empty to share.


r/litverve • • May 11 '14

Poem John Yau, from "Borrowed Love Poems"

3 Upvotes

What can I do, all the years that we talked

and I was afraid to want more

What can I do, now that these hours

belong to neither you nor me

Lost as I am in the sky

What can I do, now that I cannot find

the words I need

when your hair is mine

now that there is no time to sleep

now that your name is not enough


r/litverve • • May 07 '14

Non-fiction Robert Nozick, on studying and writing philosophy

5 Upvotes

I, too, seek an unreadable book: urgent thoughts to grapple with in agitation and excitement, revelations to be transformed by or to transform, a book incapable of being read straight through, a book, even, to bring reading to a stop. I have not found that book, or attempted it. Still, I wrote and thought in awareness of it, in the hope this book would bask in its light. That hope would be arrogant if it weren't self-fulfilling -- to face toward the light, even from a great distance, is to be warmed. (Is it sufficient, though, when light is absent, to face in the direction it would emanate from?)

Familiar questions impel this essay: Does life have meaning? Are there objective ethical truths? Do we have free will? What is the nature of our identity as selves? Must our knowledge and understanding stay within fixed limits? These questions moved me, and others, to enter the study of philosophy. I care what their answers are. While such other philosophical intricacies as whether sets or numbers exist can be fun for a time, they do not make me tremble.


r/litverve • • May 11 '14

Drama Aeschylus on Wisdom

4 Upvotes

He who learns must suffer, and, even in our sleep, pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God.

Aeschylus Greek tragic dramatist (525 BC - 456 BC)

edit for spelling


r/litverve • • May 09 '14

Poem Pablo Neruda's perfect, crystalline "If You Forget Me"

5 Upvotes

I want you to know
one thing.

You know how this is:
if I look
at the crystal moon, at the red branch
of the slow autumn at my window,
if I touch
near the fire
the impalpable ash
or the wrinkled body of the log,
everything carries me to you,
as if everything that exists,
aromas, light, metals,
were little boats
that sail
toward those isles of yours that wait for me.

Well, now,
if little by little you stop loving me
I shall stop loving you little by little.

If suddenly
you forget me
do not look for me,
for I shall already have forgotten you.

If you think it long and mad,
the wind of banners
that passes through my life,
and you decide
to leave me at the shore
of the heart where I have roots,
remember
that on that day,
at that hour,
I shall lift my arms
and my roots will set off
to seek another land.

But
if each day,
each hour,
you feel that you are destined for me
with implacable sweetness,
if each day a flower
climbs up to your lips to seek me,
ah my love, ah my own,
in me all that fire is repeated,
in me nothing is extinguished or forgotten,
my love feeds on your love, beloved,
and as long as you live it will be in your arms
without leaving mine.


r/litverve • • May 11 '14

Novel Franz Kafka's irresistible opening to The Metamorphosis

4 Upvotes

One morning, when Gregor Samsa woke from troubled dreams, he found himself transformed in his bed into a horrible vermin. He lay on his armor-like back, and if he lifted his head a little he could see his brown belly, slightly domed and divided by arches into stiff sections. The bedding was hardly able to cover it and seemed ready to slide off any moment. His many legs, pitifully thin compared with the size of the rest of him, waved about helplessly as he looked.

"What's happened to me?" he thought. It wasn't a dream. His room, a proper human room although a little too small, lay peacefully between its four familiar walls. A collection of textile samples lay spread out on the table -- Samsa was a travelling salesman -- and above it there hung a picture that he had recently cut out of an illustrated magazine and housed in a nice, gilded frame. It showed a lady fitted out with a fur hat and fur boa who sat upright, raising a heavy fur muff that covered the whole of her lower arm towards the viewer.

Gregor then turned to look out the window at the dull weather. Drops of rain could be heard hitting the pane, which made him feel quite sad. "How about if I sleep a little bit longer and forget all this nonsense," he thought, but that was something he was unable to do because he was used to sleeping on his right, and in his present state couldn't get into that position. However hard he threw himself onto his right, he always rolled back to where he was. He must have tried it a hundred times, shut his eyes so that he wouldn't have to look at the floundering legs, and only stopped when he began to feel a mild, dull pain there that he had never felt before.


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Essay Exchange of Letters by Wendy Cope

1 Upvotes

‘Man who is a serious novel would like to hear from a woman who is a poem’ (classified advertisement, New York Review of Books)

//

Dear Serious Novel,

I am a terse assured lyric with impeccable rhythmic flow, some apt and original metaphors, and a music that is all my own. Some people say I am beautiful.

My vital statistics are eighteen lines, divided into three-line stanzas, with an average of four words per line.

My first husband was a cheap romance; the second was Wisden’s Cricketers’ Almanac. Most of the men I meet nowadays are autobiographies, but a substantial minority are books about photography or trains.

I have always hoped for a relationship with an upmarket work of fiction. Please write and tell me more about yourself.

Yours intensely,

Song of the First Snowdrop

//

Dear Song of the First Snowdrop,

Many thanks for your letter. You sound like just the kind of poem I am hoping to find. I’ve always preferred short, lyrical women to the kind who go on for page after page.

I am an important 150,000 word comment on the dreams and dilemmas of twentieth-century Man. It took six years to attain my present weight and stature but all the twenty-seven publishers I have so far approached have failed to understand me. I have my share of sex and violence and a very good joke in chapter nine, but to no avail. I am sustained by the belief that I am ahead of my time.

Let’s meet as soon as possible. I am longing for you to read me from cover to cover and get to know my every word.

Yours impatiently,

Death of the Zeitgeist


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Essay On the fortuitous nature of relationships(and for that matter, love)

1 Upvotes

"[...]human relationships, even the most unforgettable ones, are only a matter of fortuitous performances—and perhaps not so much by human beings as by chance or fate itself."

~Rey Chow, "Sentimental Returns: On the Uses of the Everyday in the Recent Films of Zhang Yimou and Wong Kar-Wai"

//

“Love is a form of prejudice. You love what you need, you love what makes you feel good, you love what is convenient. How can you say you love one person when there are ten thousand people in the world that you would love more if you ever met them? But you'll never meet them. All right, so we do the best we can. Granted. But we must still realize that love is just the result of a chance encounter. Most people make too much of it."

~Charles Bukowski, "Hot Water Music"


r/litverve • • May 09 '14

Novel A meditation on loneliness from The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

5 Upvotes

It's hard being left behind. I wait for Henry, not knowing where he is, wondering if he's okay. It's hard to be the one who stays.

I keep myself busy. Time goes faster that way.

I go to sleep alone, and wake up alone. I take walks. I work until I'm tired. I watch the wind play with the trash that's been under the snow all winter. Everything seems simple until you think about it. Why is love intensified by absence?

Long ago, men went to sea, and women waited for them, standing on the edge of the water, scanning the horizon for the tiny ship. Now I wait for Henry. He vanishes unwillingly, without warning. I wait for him. Each moment that I wait feels like a year, an eternity. Each moment is as slow and transparent as glass. Through each moment I can see infinite moments lined up, waiting. Why has he gone where I cannot follow?


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Non-fiction from an interview with Haruki Murakami published in The Guardian

1 Upvotes

He[Haruki Murakami] has written about the metaphorical importance of his running; that to complete an action every day sets a kind of karmic example for his writing. “Yes,” he says. “Mmmmm.” He makes a long contemplative sound. “I need strength because I have to open the door.” He mimes heaving open a door. “Every day I go to my study and sit at my desk and put the computer on. At that moment, I have to open the door. It’s a big, heavy door. You have to go into the Other Room. Metaphorically, of course. And you have to come back to this side of the room. And you have to shut the door. So it’s literally physical strength to open and shut the door. So if I lose that strength, I cannot write a novel any more. I can write some short stories, but not a novel.


r/litverve • • May 21 '14

Essay Philosopher Walter Benjamin on the catastrophe of history

4 Upvotes

A Klee painting named Angelus Novus shows an angel looking as though he is about to move away from something he is fixedly contemplating.

His eyes are staring, his mouth is open, his wings are spread.

This is how one pictures the angel of history.

His face is turned toward the past.

Where we perceive a chain of events, he sees one single catastrophe which keeps piling wreckage upon wreckage and hurls it in front of his feet. The angel would like to stay, awaken the dead, and make whole what has been smashed. But a storm is blowing from Paradise; it has got caught in his wings with such violence that the angel can no longer close them. The storm irresistibly propels him into the future to which his back is turned, while the pile of debris before him grows skyward.

This storm is what we call progress.

This evocative parable comes from Walter Benjamin's influential 1940 essay, "Theses on the Philosophy of History." The Klee painting described in the text is a real one. Benjamin owned it. The painting is here.

Stylistically, this fragment reminds me of Nietzsche. Benjamin is making a subtle point here about the way we impose order on the past, imbue it with meaning and call it history. But instead of merely saying so, he offers us a painting and a metaphor.

The strength of this approach is the it wrenches the reader out of the passivity of reading. If you are at all interested in knowing what Benjamin means -- and given the loveliness of the images and the sentences, you have probably succumbed to curiosity -- then you've got to stop and figure it out.

Some of our greatest writers, including many philosophers, used parables and metaphor for this very reason. Philosophy is meant to be read slowly. There is no value in skimming it. You must fit every word into place in the context of the words that came before, and you must not move ahead to the next sentence until you have milked this one of all its meaning. That's the only way to receive the full value, the full benefit of complex thought.

This parable, then, is intended to bring reading to a stop. Benjamin requires us to stop reading and appreciate the image. We must stop reading and think.


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Essay Giacomo Leopardi, from Zibaldone

1 Upvotes

Everything is evil. That is to say everything that is, is evil; that each thing exists is an evil; each thing exists only for an evil end; existence is an evil and made for evil; the end of the universe is evil; the order and the state, the laws, the natural development of the universe are nothing but evil, and they are directed to nothing but evil. There is no other good except nonbeing; there is nothing good except what is not; things that are not things: all things are bad. All existence; the complex of so many worlds that exist; the universe; is only a spot, a speck in metaphysics. Existence, by its nature and essence and generally, is an imperfection, an irregularity, a monstrosity. But this imperfection is a tiny thing, literally a spot, because all the worlds that exist, however many and however extensive they are, since they are certainly not infinite in number or in size, are consequently infinitely small in comparison with the size the universe might be if it were infinite, and the whole of existence is infinitely small in comparison with the true infinity, so to speak, of nonexistence, of nothing.


r/litverve • • May 22 '14

Novel Cormac McCarthy on the Permanence of Memory

4 Upvotes

..."he knew that those things we most desire to hold in our hearts are taken from us while that which we would put away seems often by that very wish to become endowed with unsuspected powers of endurance. He knew how frail is the memory of loved ones...how we long to hear their voices...those memories grow faint and faint until what was flesh and blood is no more than echo and shadow. In the end, perhaps not even that.

He knew that our enemies by contrast seem always with us. The greater our hatred the more persistent the memory of them so that a truly terrible enemy becomes deathless. So that a man who has done you great injury or injustice makes himself a guest in your house forever. Perhaps only forgiveness can dislodge him". From Cities on the Plain.

Cormac McCarthy disturbs me no small amount. His observations so keen, expressed so simply; profundities juxtaposed with violence and suffering conveyed in that same spare and thoughtful way.


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Poem Lovely poetry from Galway Kinnell

3 Upvotes

Wait, for now.

Distrust everything, if you have to.

But trust the hours. Haven’t they

carried you everywhere, up to now?

Personal events will become interesting again.

Hair will become interesting.

Pain will become interesting.

Buds that open out of season will become lovely again.

Second-hand gloves will become lovely again,

their memories are what give them

the need for other hands. And the desolation

of lovers is the same: that enormous emptiness

carved out of such tiny beings as we are

asks to be filled; the need

for the new love is faithfulness to the old.

Wait.

Don’t go too early.

You’re tired. But everyone’s tired.

But no one is tired enough.

Only wait a while and listen.

Music of hair,

Music of pain,

music of looms weaving all our loves again.

Be there to hear it, it will be the only time,

most of all to hear,

the flute of your whole existence,

rehearsed by the sorrows, play itself into total exhaustion.


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Essay seductively beautiful Virginia Woolf from "A Sketch of the Past”

1 Upvotes

I only know that many of these exceptional moments brought with them a peculiar horror and a physical collapse; they seemed dominant; myself passive. This suggests that as one gets older one has a greater power through reason to provide an explanation; and that this explanation blunts the sledge-hammer force of the blow. I think this is true, because though I still have the peculiarity that I receive these sudden shocks, they are now always welcome; after the first surprise, I always feel instantly that they are particularly valuable. And so I go on to suppose that the shock-receiving capacity is what makes me a writer. I hazard the explanation that a shock is at once in my case followed by the desire to explain it. I feel that I have had a blow; but it is not, as I thought as a child, simply a blow from an enemy hidden behind the cotton wool of daily life; it is or will become a revelation of some order; it is a token of some real thing behind appearances; and I make it real by putting it into words. It is only by putting it into words that I make it whole; this wholeness means that it has lost its power to hurt me; it gives me, perhaps because by doing so I take away the pain, a great delight to put the severed parts together. Perhaps this is the strongest pleasure known to me. It is the rapture I get when in writing I seem to be discovering what belongs to what; making a scene come right; making a character come together. From this I reach what I might call a philosophy; at any rate it is a constant idea of mine; that behind the cotton wool is hidden a pattern; that we – I mean all human beings – are connected with this; that the whole world is a work of art; that we are parts of the work of art. Hamlet or a Beethoven quartet is the truth about this vast mass that we call the world. But there is no Shakespeare, there is no Beethoven; certainly and emphatically there is no God; we are the words; we are the music; we are the thing itself. And I see this when I have a shock.


r/litverve • • May 28 '14

Correspondence this is delectable. (John Wieners to James Schuyler)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/litverve • • May 15 '14

Novel Paul Bowles reflects on the brevity of life in The Sheltering Sky

4 Upvotes

Death is always on the way, but the fact that you don't know when it will arrive seems to take away from the finiteness of life. It's that terrible precision that we hate so much. But because we don't know, we get to think of life as an inexhaustible well. Yet everything happens a certain number of times, and a very small number, really. How many more times will you remember a certain afternoon of your childhood, some afternoon that's so deeply a part of your being that you can't even conceive of your life without it? Perhaps four or five times more. Perhaps not even. How many more times will you watch the full moon rise? Perhaps twenty. And yet it all seems limitless.

This is not a style of writing I enjoy. It's mushy, flabby, and not musical.

Look at the first sentence. Bowles says "is always on the way." "Is" is the cheapest, least evocative verb in English. When I'm editing, I always try to replace it. Why not "death stalks us" or "death calls us" or "death pursues us" or "we spend our lives pursuing death"? Any action verb would have been preferable to "is."

And then we get "the fact that." Padding. Those words make the sentence longer without adding to its savor, without contributing to the meaning.

And "seems to." Why soften the statement with that equivocal qualification?

The whole first sentence is a flabby mess and I'd be too embarrassed to allow it out the door under my byline. the rest of the piece is little better.

And yet. This paragraph has real impact and it's unforgettable because of Bowles's observation. "Perhaps four or five times more." "Perhaps twenty." I never thought of that, and now in a way I'll never stop thinking of it. What a marvelous, direct, tangible way Bowles has of illustrating how finite life is.

I would have preferred to gain this insight from a stylist whose aesthetics more closely match my own. But I'll take it from Bowles because of the terrible precision of his vision.


r/litverve • • May 14 '14

Novel Salman Rushdie on universality, from Midnight's Children

4 Upvotes

I am the sum total of everything that went before me, of all I have been seen done, of everything done-to-me. I am everyone everything whose being-in-the-world affected was affected by mine. I am anything that happens after I've gone which would not have happened if I had not come. Nor am I particularly exceptional in this matter; each "I," every one of the now-six-hundred-million-plus of us, contains a similar multitude. I repeat for the last time: to understand me, you'll have to swallow a world.

Rushdie's writing is as addictive as popcorn. In this paragraph he does two things well. First, he makes the philosophical point that each of us is the sum of our experiences -- a common enough insight, but he explains it in tangible terms and he uses this perspective as a plot point later. Second, he uses language effectively to help us understand the narrator. His over-the-top, larger-than-life, oddly hyphenated and punctuated rush of words helps place him as a braggart. "To understand me, you'll have to swallow a world." It's hard to make a character sympathetic when he's saying such a thing. But Rushdie makes him a bit comical in addition to the braggadocio. It's the kind of subtlety most readers don't notice and most writers don't attempt.


r/litverve • • May 08 '14

Essay "The Opinion of the Ram," a fable based on the biblical story of the binding of Isaac by poet Alicia Susan Ostriker

4 Upvotes

In Talmud it is said that he who humiliates another before the world shall lose his portion of paradise. Yet God humiliated Abraham before Isaac. And that was only the beginning. Think of the generations of pious Jews who trusted in God to rescue them from their enemies. Therefore, in my opinion, His only escape, and the reason He continues to reign in the world to come, is that Isaac forces himself to laugh, making light of this betrayal. Yes, Isaac knows that his father has been fooled and humiliated. But if he laughs at the entire world, treating it as absurdity top to bottom, including God, then God won't be punished, won't lose sovereignty. And if for a moment Isaac should cease to laugh, in that moment the universe would be annihilated.