I've seen some interesting Tier Lists lately, so as my deadlines loom ever closer, I've decided to make my own instead of opening a word document and crying over a blank page.
So, tiers, their explanation, and short recs.
S (So good I support it on Patreon) - as with most of my tiers, this is self explanatory. Here are stories I enjoyed so much I was willing to part with my money each month to support the author. There were many across the years, but Wandering Inn and DotF are the two I have subscribed to for many years without a break.
Wandering Inn - my all time favorite, even if the beginning can be rough and Erin can be annoying protagonist at the start. I love the worldbuilding and the minimalistic system. The best part is that Paba can make any character feel like they are a protagonist of their own story instead of existing as a support for the MC.
Defiance of the Fall - excellent slop. Just exquisite. One of my earliest reads and while I can acknowledge that it's not overly deep or emotional story, it's perfectly hits my two most favorite genres: xianxia and litrpg. Bonus that it feels like it's improving as it progresses further.
A (Amazing) - stories that stuck with me for long and I remember them fondly.
Mother of Learning - award for best time-loop story from me. Excellent worldbuilding and protagonist. It perfectly paces the mystery, progression, and plot, without making Zorian feel too OP at any given moment. Although it felt like the ending was a bit rushed. Still, 10/10.
Beware of Chicken - best xianxia slice-of-life I've read, but it too slow sometimes. I love the feeling it gives, especially in the first part, but it slowed down a bit too much later for my liking. Still, I enjoyed it very much.
Forge of Destiny - similar to BoC, but with more focus on progression and cultivation. The best western xianxia for me, even if it suffers from it's quest origins at times. Love Ling Qi and her themes, but sometimes they are repeated too many times.
Sky Pride - classic well done xianxia in western edition. It's extremely well written, and that elevates it from B tier, as it feels too much on the nose at times, with tropes played straight and painful in retrospect.
B (Better than average) - stories that I enjoyed for what they are, but didn't make me think deeply.
Azarinth Healer - good 'ol punch 'em litrpg. Fun to read, and Ilea doesn't burden the plot with heavy 'feelings', just goes around doing whatever she wants without being an insufferable asshole. Got too strong too fast.
Supper Supportive - amazing start and equally amazingly slow pacing later. Love the MC, the prose, and the worldbuilding, but it slows down waaaaaay too much after the first arc.
My Life as a Max Level Archmage - fun power fantasy. Gets a bit old after the same reactions to MC OP status after a while.
The Hundred Reigns - excellent so far, but I start to dislike the MC in later chapters. I know it's 'character building' and all, but I dislike when MC doesn't think things through. And the world feels small for some reason.
The Years of Apocalypse - feels like Mother of Learning rip-off at the start, but quickly grows into its own, and I enjoy the worldbuilding and MC a lot. But it still takes quite a bit before that point.
The Undying Immortal System - despite being generally a xianxia system slop at the surface, I enjoyed the story a lot. It has a good progression pacing, where MC never feels too strong for the current arc.
C (Can read without strong feelings) - not much to explain. Stories I've read and enjoyed at the moment, but they also evaporated from my mind not long after. Sometimes I still return to them when I notice a new chapter or book, but it doesn't feel me with too much excitement. There are waaay more of stories in this tier than I've put in the tier-list, but those are the ones that popped into the auto-fill box when I was making the list, or I saw them on RR recently. No explanation for them here.
D (Didn't like) - stories I didn't like for one reason or another.
Cinnamon Bun - too scatterbrained MC and dragged on too much. Felt like the story didn't move forwards after reading dozens of chapters.
The Calamitous Bob - good worldbuilding, didn't like the MC. She just wasn't enjoyable to read about for me. Felt like a Mary Sue without any obvious reason.
Paranoid Mage - good prose, tiny world. Seriously, the entire world felt like a series of rooms the MC moves through. Interesting magic system, but MC spent too much lime running away from the plot.
Critical Roleplay - felt like the Max Level Archmage rip-off. Didn't like the magic system and overly-complex systems.
The Menocht Loop - enjoyed the first part, but fell off dramatically later. Felt like the MC turned into a different person.
Cultivation Nerd - despite the title, he is not a nerd at all. Cultivation or otherwise. Quickly turned into a generic xianxia story almost identical to hundreds other, throwing away the initial premise.
Vigor Mortis - enjoyed the first part, but later it felt like the author wanted to make his MC suffer for 'the plot' without any good in-story reason.
F (F*cking trash) - stories that I actively dislike, felt betrayed by, or just plain evil MC.
Beneath the Dragoneye Moons - dislike. It was decent at the start, but the MC constantly makes decisions counterproductive to her own survival, feels like a Mary Sue, and later throws away entire plotlines at a whim. Felt like the author constantly found new amazing ideas and made the MC forget her entire past and motivations to hand out with her new cool friends.
Reborn as a Demonic Tree - just plain evil MC. This story represents many other similar I've unfortunately read, all with MC doing abhorrent shit to standing ovations of the brainless NPC's surrounding him. I don't even remember well what I disliked about this one specifically, beyond the vague feeling of disgust at the MC actions.
Hive Minds Give Good Hugs - betrayed. Wasn't too enthusiastic about the story but it was nonetheless enjoyable at the beginning. The later parts, however, made it feel like a rugpull. Incredibly annoying plot-twists.
G (Garbage, pure garbage) - stories that still make me angry when I think about them. Mostly because they were good at the beginning.
The Primal Hunter - holy shit, the MC is annoying. I get it, he is a 'hunter' who doesn't care about anything but 'the hunt', but Jesus, he feels like the biggest Gary Stu ever while being an absolute dickbag. And that would be still fine, if he didn't fuck off to hide in a cave for dozens of chapters to pontificate about his skills, points, or whatever, for tens of thousands of words.
Tori Transmigrated - loved it for a long time. I do enjoy myself a nice Otome Isekai from time to time. But lady, please, don't tell me she is 'not like the other Mary Sues' while writing her as the biggest Mary Sue in the genre ever. Everything the MC does is 'correct' and 'perfect', her enemies are all 'evil idiots' or 'redeemed' into loving her. She can do no wrong and the world constantly bends to please her while the author continues to assure me she is not, in fact, a Mary Sue. Not to mention the romance baiting. Garbage.
H (Holy shit, it's bad!) - one story made me love and hate if in equal measure.
Ben's Damn Adventure - amazing writing and characters, absolute dogshit plot and pacing. Just... I just can't. How can someone be so good at writing prose and characters, and at the same time so bad at plotting the story and the worldbuilding. I just can't.
I (I feel like I wasted hours of my life reading this, hours I can never recover and it makes me feel empty now) - there were three occasions where I felt like this. One was a Worm/KanColle fanfic that made me stare into the ceiling after spending a saturday afternoon reading it, only to almost cry as I realized I wasted precious hours on my life that I could've used to read another story. Even a garbage one. The two other occasions I successfully purged from my memories. Only a vague imprint that it happened at all remains.
J (Jason Asano) - Jason Asano.
He Who Fights With Monsters - specifically, the MC. I burn with a potent hatred for him, a fire of ten thousand suns of pure malice wishing that abomination in human skin will combust if he exists somewhere there in the multiverse. The story itself was enjoyable. Even the MC at the time (I was younger then), and the worldbuilding was nice, as was the magic system. But then he returned to Earth, and I comprehended how Obi-Wan felt while looking at the burning Anakin.
There are probably many other stories I've forgotten or can't recall at this moment despite loving them at the time, but this list should still show my preferences, and if it matches your own, you can find a story you will enjoy too. I also tried to put only stories from RR on this list.
Edit: forgot tier H.