r/literature • • May 18 '24

Discussion Are there any right-wing books that would be considered classics?

12 Upvotes

I can think of a lot of books criticizing capitalism or in support of feminism, for example, but not many classics that are written from a right-wing perspective. Some of Orwell's work could be interpreted as criticizing the far-left, but he was a democratic socialist.

I've heard complaints from the right that literary critics are usually left-leaning and biased, and I've heard people on the left say that right-wing people just can't write good literature. To know whether either of these have any merit, I'd need to know if there really are that few classics with right-leaning messages.


r/literature • • May 07 '25

Publishing & Literature News Louis CK is publishing a novel

56 Upvotes

The comedian Louis CK is publishing a novel called "Ingram", out in November.

I had no idea he wrote fiction, but apparently he does.

(edit: Original description was from an email newsletter)

Publisher's description of the novel:

An odyssey through rural America follows a young drifter’s coming of age in an indifferent world.

When Ingram is forced by overwhelming poverty and spiritual exhaustion to walk away from his home, he leaves behind a neglectful childhood on a dirt farm on a dead-end road. With no family, no resources, and no practical understanding of the world, Ingram’s only compass is the daily fight to survive and the narrow dream of one day owning a truck.

A picaresque novel set against the backdrop of working-class Texas, Ingram invites readers to see the world through the eyes of a child who drifts through a tough American landscape of corn farms and oil fields, guided by diner waitresses, migrant workers, and criminals, trying to make sense of a world that doesn’t care about him anymore than a jungle or desert does for the creatures that toil to survive within them.


r/literature • • May 24 '24

Discussion Opinion: I HATE modern references and technology use in contemporary literature. Just me??

0 Upvotes

As I’m typing this I do have to call attention to the fact that I am using a phone myself to criticize contemporary literature…It’s just that every time I read a book and an email or text message materializes, I become enraged. It really takes me out of the plot and changes the direction of the particular scene. It’s comparable to breaking the fourth wall, but in the very worst way. I’m also particularly sensitive to how some authors even go as far as to change the text or attempt to mimic a chat box. Phone calls in novels can be done will in my opinion and don’t detract the same way. In terms of modern references…referring to Instagram or influencers or some abstract culture reference makes me have to stop reading and roll my eyes before continuing again.

I understand these devices are necessary when creating stories set in modern times, but there’s just something about it that is bothersome! Perhaps this anger comes from wanting to escape the world I live in by reading and then being reminded of it just throws me off. Or maybe since I grew up reading books when the internet was really just starting to take off has permanently caused me to just assume devices such as these are not typically included in literary works.

I’ve brought this up in creative writing classes before, but it did not seem like that many people felt the same way.


r/literature • • Sep 15 '25

Discussion Can we talk about the statutory rape scene in Everything Is Illuminated?

7 Upvotes

Jonathan Safran Foer's first novel was met with a great deal of literary acclaim and a smattering of awards when it came out, so I thought I'd give it a whirl. It's engagingly odd and, maybe a quarter of the way in, I was broadly enjoying it until I came to this scene with the character Brod, on the night of the festival.

Brod, for those unaware, is a 12-year old girl. At this point the author has already spent quite a lot of text telling us how beautiful she is and how she's desired by every man in the village. She is dressed as a mermaid for the festival by her adoptive father, Yankel.

... he had seen the men grope at her (he was not blind), but helping her pull up her mermaid suit, having to tie the straps around her bony shoulders, made everything else seem easy (he was only human).

...

Yankel! she called, pulling her skinny legs from the mermaid's tail, revealing her tightly wound pubic hair, which was still new enough to trace out a sharp triangle.

...

Yankel! Are you home? she called, walking naked from room to room, her nipples hard and purple from the cold

[at this point, a stranger arrives at her home, leering at her through the window and demands to be let in. Initially, she says no, and that she'd rather kill herself, but he refuses to leave. Foer also includes a passage about how people making love "glow".]

Brod let her arms brush down her skin to her sides and turned to face my great great great great great grandfather.

Then you must do something for me, she said.

Her belly lit up like a firefly's bulb - brighter than a hundred thousand virgins making love for the first time.

So let's be generous and imagine that Foer wants us to understand that this is rape: that the stranger is refusing to leave and Brod is simply accepting the inevtiability of her fate. She's had a propheric dream that she would be raped, so that's possible. Even given that interpretation, why on earth would he include such semi-pornographic language describing her getting dressed - how even her adoptive father struggles to control himself seeing her nakedness - and wandering around the house? To describe a 12 year old girl?!

And let's also consider the less generous interpretation: that Foer is implying 12 year old girls are able to meaningfully "consent" to having sex?

I was so appalled by this this I almost stopped reading. I have continued, but I'm still revolted enough that I'm struggling to read more without remembering this description. But I presume all the award juries and critics read this too and still saw fit to shower it with praise. Maybe they saw something in this scene, or in later scenes that I have missed? How are we supposed to get beyond what reads, to me, like a wish-fulfillment fantasy involving statutory rape?


r/literature • • Nov 25 '23

Literary Theory Lovecraftian horror is for the rich whereas Kafkaesque horror is for the not rich

0 Upvotes

I’ve always thought that Lovecraft’s works are in tandem with the fears experienced by the wealthy; something unknown like climate change, the ever changing nature of modern society, death and so on. Basically things they can’t change no matter how rich and powerful they are.

As for Kafka, the horrors feels closer and act as anxiety for the person experiencing them. The anxiety narrows their view and creates a new individual horror experience. For example, the trial. The horror he experiences can be the same horror as a minority facing a cop. You never know if it’s your lucky or unlucky day whereas in metamorphosis feels like a story of a simple guy from an Asian household. Strict ass lifestyle lol.

Lovecraftian horror renders the individual helpless against the impossible and forgetful about the miracle of man whereas Kafkaesque horror narrow’s one’s view(anxiety).

Anyway I didn’t mean to make it about race but after remembering about Phillip’s white superiority tendencies, I thought race was an appropriate analogy but 🤷‍♂️

PS: correct me if I’m wrong since it’s been years since I’ve read Call of Cthulhu, metamorphosis, Nameless City and the Trial


r/literature • • Jul 10 '25

Discussion Relating more to male literature than female - despite the sexism and my calling myself a feminist

18 Upvotes

Edit: I am a 16 year old female, currently in high school and German.

I am a big reader of mid century American literature. I really enjoy JD Salinger and Phillip Roth. Though, something that I realize, especially about Roth, is the fact that women are used as nothing but props in his most famous novels, for example one of my favourite books, Portnoys Complaint. Salinger has a similar issue, in that all the women he writes are largely the same ascetic thin archetype. I feel comfortable reading these stories despite the frequent sexualization and reduction of women, and even feel more uncomfortable when I read lit about women and sex, since I feel like many times sex "interested" women in literary fiction are shown as totally detached and traumatized. I relate more to the male authors in general, and it makes me feel weird since I'd call myself a feminist but feel so detached from female sensibilities especially in literature.

I read a lot of female authors, along with many, and more often that not I feel more understood by men that by women. Which, makes me fear: Am I a "Pick-Me"? Does anyone else experience this?


r/literature • • Feb 18 '26

Discussion A Long-Ass Rant by an English Major In Account Of Wuthering Heights (2026)

8 Upvotes

Being a huge aficionado of literature and cinema, I have never rebuked a filmmaker whenever he or she has tried to change or reinvent concepts while he or she is tasked to make a film adaptation of a book that has been an integral part of the classical literature. Nevertheless, after watching Wuthering Heights (2026), I take back my words.

I know, I shouldn't have watched that movie, but I had to, for academic purposes (fyi I'm studying English Honours). Since I am just 19 years old, my parents did not allow to watch the movie during Valentine's Day, since it is rated R, but four days after the day of its release, I said, "Fuck it!" Please convince me that whatever I witnessed yesterday was but a fever dream, not a reality. The movie literally started with production logo of Warner Bros flashing, while the sounds of a bed creaking and a man (supposedly, Heathcliff) groaning in pleasure pierced my eardrums. I first thought that someone was pranking me in the theatre, since my home country is filled with perverted men, but then I realized that those sounds were coming from the movie itself. And then came that scene where the Victorian people (even little children included) were rejoicing at the hanging of a man. Why? Because that corpse had erection in his pants!? What a sickening adaptation of a novel which was meant to be a critique on classism and racism!

The worst part is that Heathcliff and Catherine are depicted as doomed lovers here. They have no chemistry whatsoever; the third act of the movie is entirely fraught with scenes of them fucking and tongue-kissing each other. Heathcliff is picturized not as a victim of oppression but a six-feet tall daddy-material that every woman daydreams about. There is this "Christian Grey" angle to his character. When we read the book and we listened to Emily Brontë saying that Heathcliff was a "sadist", we saw him as a boy who turned into a loathsome man because of a long history of oppression. However, Emerald Fennell, the director of this movie, saw him as a "sexual sadist". The bruises on his back are shown as if they are the "sexiest" part about Heathcliff. Catherine is also sexualised; we see her touching herself in the moors, and her dissatisfaction with her s*x life with Edgar Linton. Joseph is not that oh-so-evil devout Christian anymore; he is shown doing pony-play with a servant named Zillah. Nelly has no major role throughout the movie; she just appears to be a mere servile woman who follows the orders of Catherine. Isabella is reduced to a fatuous girl who knows nothing other than playing with dolls and crawling on the floor like a dog, while in the book, she's one of, if not, the strongest and boldest female characters, who witnesses a notable evolution in her character. She was never weak; she was just reserved and had a moral demeanor.

It all looks so offensive. Emily Brontë definitely did not want this while she died of tuberculosis 177 years ago.


r/literature • • Dec 14 '23

Discussion Which historically significant, popular modern author (had been alive in your lifetime) has the least literary value?

0 Upvotes

Like, trend-setter, mover and shaker, but you could Thanos snap their books out of existence and you wouldn’t miss them.

For me it’s Rowling. Like, the literary world would not be the same without her legacy in a lot of ways (negative and positive) but her prose is so vapid and her creative choices are lazy.


r/literature • • Jan 11 '24

Discussion Why are people hell bent on spoiling classic books?

9 Upvotes

Tldr: in-book annotations, chapter summaries etc should have spoiler warnings for content that occurs in later chapters.

I read all sorts of books for fun. Recently I have read Frankenstein, and I am currently reading "crime and punishment"

Old books, especially those translated from other languages, often have cultural context that you will miss if you are not from the culture in questions. An action that is normal today may seem deliberately scandalous and insulting in the time and place the book is written.

One example of this: a character in crime and punishment is upset because his daughter "has a yellow ticket". This is slang for being a prostitute, but I would not know that without looking it up.

Fortunately, you can understand the story better if you get a annotated copy. The copy can contain annotations that explains the cultural nuances of things that are occurring.

Unfortunately, these annotations contain active spoilers 😡. They often times point out where a character's death is foreshadowed, reveal plot twists before hand, or reveal that an unassuming character is a villain. This completely ruins the enjoyment of the book for me.

I try looking at spark notes or cliff notes chapter summaries, and they have the same issue.

I really wish these spoilers where clearly marked. This has been the practice for video games and tvs for decades, why not books?


r/literature • • Jul 18 '15

Other Western Lit, shot to death by ‘trigger warnings’

Thumbnail
politico.eu
9 Upvotes

r/literature • • Sep 03 '24

Discussion Most overrated classic?

0 Upvotes

What classic can you just not understand the appeal of? Whether you think it’s poorly written, boring, or trite - shit on a classic.

Personally, the Alchemist is my least favorite book I’ve ever read. I found the message extremely annoying (universe conspiring for my success) and heavy handed. Trust the audience to figure it out and quit shoving the message down my throat. The writing was also meh.

Not a classic, I literally did a double take when I saw the Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo on a “literary fiction” list. It read like a long-form BuzzFeed article. Just painful to read. Couldn’t finish it.


r/literature • • Apr 05 '24

Discussion If an author didn't mean it that way ...

1 Upvotes

What are people's thoughts on this.

If a critic analyses a work/ story and gets some deep meaning/ interpretation out of it, but the author themselves had zero intention for that meaning, then does that even rlly 'count'? And what would the meta for this phenomenon? That the author subconsciously projected that meaning, from the collective unconscious, into her work for example?

For context, I had this thought when I heard Jordan Peterson analysing how Harry Potter went underground, through the bathroom, to fight the Basilisk. It's supposedly a symbol of confronting your inner chaos, at where you least want to look, because what you most want to find is in the place you least want to look. I was thinking, that's kinda a stretch, and if JKR never even intended that, does that count?

I think there's 2 answers to this question, what are people's thoughts:

  1. If it's just a fun imaginative story or novel etc e.g., LOTR, then of course, every interpretation counts. That's the fun in it.

  2. But if it's an instructive text, where the author had the intention to convey instruction, e.g., religious or philosophical texts - then it's important to rlly know what the author had in mind and not twist meaning.

Edit: Thanks guys! I've nvr posted here b4 but I didn't expect to get so many very good responses in less than an hour. Awesome.


r/literature • • Mar 08 '26

Discussion 11/22/63 was… terrible?

0 Upvotes

I tried reading this because I see people on Reddit universally praise it like it’s the bible. It was SO boring. I made it like 800 pages in and absolutely nothing has happened. I hate to DNF something after getting that far, but it is such a frustrating read. He’s spent the last 400 pages just talking about his sex life like a 15 year old and listening to pointless wiretaps about nothing?? The whole thing feels like it was written by a self-indulging teenager.

I’ve read war and peace, infinite jest, brothers Karamazov… I don’t mind a long slow burn. I also read a lot of non-classic literature and don’t need everything to have some profound meaning. I loved Dark Matter for example. I’ve even enjoyed some other Stephen King books.

But this book just felt like the worst of both worlds. It has absolutely no purpose or deeper meaning, but is also just a complete slog with nothing happening. ugh. I’m so confused why people love it so much. Potentially one of my least favorite books ever.

I’m also not normally one to rant or complain about books. I’ve read a lot of books I didn’t like that I set aside and thought “that just wasn’t for me”. There is a lot of subjectivity in any literature. But i’ve never felt such a disconnect between the praise I’ve seen for something on here versus the actual quality of the book. Just… so bad


r/literature • • Dec 03 '15

When Women’s Literary Tastes Are Deemed Less Worthy

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
0 Upvotes

r/literature • • Jul 28 '24

Discussion What is your literary Barbenheimer?

0 Upvotes

I'm currently reading both Generation Kill by Evan Wright and a collection of short stories by the peerless Claire Keegan, and they weirdly match really well.

Whenever the ultra macho, toxic world of the Marine Corps you're plunged into by Wright's gonzo journalism gets too much, I can read a few short stories from Keegan that are dark, intricate, sensitive and arresting.

Whenever a series of short stories get too profound, raw, emotional and sensitive to carry on, I can take a break for a few hours to jump back into the all action, shoot first ask questions later book that is GK's examination of war and masculinity in 21st century America.

What random, seemingly incongruous book pairs have you found to be strangely complimentary?


r/literature • • Dec 03 '25

Discussion [meta] Can we ban the “what are you reading posts”

38 Upvotes

Edit:

It seems like it’s just me that isn’t super into those threads but most people like them. So I’ll just ignore them. I do appreciate the insights.

I am a curmudgeon but rarely on Reddit. And yes I know I can just skip those posts. But is anyone else kinda tired of these?

They don’t seem to ever lead to much discussion and just end up a giant list of 4 word posts. The last one I saw from 3 days ago was from an account that has only posted that question over and over again for weeks.

Short of an outright ban, maybe just have a weekly “what are you reading” mod post for people that still want these.

Ideally for that, we could also require people to respond with at least say 500 characters to make sure people are sharing something interesting about what they are reading.

Internet, am I alone?


r/literature • • Sep 07 '24

Discussion What is a genre that you totally don't fuck with and why?

0 Upvotes

I can't with fantasy and all, ever, but is just that I appreciate more realistic stuff and have enough unreal dystopian bullshit in my mind


r/literature • • Nov 04 '25

Author Interview Kate Clanchy: I was cancelled. It made me contemplate suicide

Thumbnail thetimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/literature • • Mar 29 '24

Discussion Can’t read through Nietzsche

0 Upvotes

I have been reading through ‘thus spoke zarathustra’ for like a year and have gotten to a halfway point. And hate everything about it.

Unfortunately every line sounds like it was written by someone who beats themselves with a dictionary if they fail to wake up an hour before the alarm rings.

He is trying to separate himself and his followers from the human race. But personally it doesn’t feel inspiring at all, it’s too arrogant at times and as someone who believes perfect balance is everything, and his concept of the ‘superhuman’ comes off as an equivalent to worker ants. I can’t seem to read more than 5 pages per week.

I was expecting to find new things and ways through this book, and not hate every line of it.

I think that I perfectly understand what was written but is there any other perspective to look at it from? Or should I just stop reading this author (after I painstakingly finish this work).

I will give it to him that he has predicted correctly the rise of atheism and the world has evolved partly as he envisioned. But it hasn’t changed extremely in one way to completely align with his beliefs.


r/literature • • Jan 11 '24

Discussion What books are better abridged?

1 Upvotes

I know this question’s been asked a few years ago, but I’d love to hear some new answers. Les Miserables was easily the most common answer, and I know from experience that most English translations the Four Great Novels of China (which all have longer word counts than the Stormlight Archive in their OG language) are cut to remove what most modern Westerners would consider repetitious prose, needlessly descriptive detail, and uneventful chapters. What other books (especially classics) are better abridged in your opinion?

If you say The Stand, I’ll judge you forever.


r/literature • • Dec 04 '25

Discussion Fanfiction Has Destroyed Writing (And Everything Else)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Hi! I am new here. I wanted to create a discussion around this video essay and see what you thought of it. Here's what I commented on the video summarizing my views on the topic (it's directed to the youtuber):

I agree with some of your points and disagree with others.

You expressed very eloquently how fanfiction has shaped the sensibilities of today's readers, and it is something I personally have a crusade with. To my understanding, art should expand your borders, make you unconfortable, teach you other points of view, and make you question yours.

I am the president of my public library's book club. The older members are accustomed to being challenged by literature, while the newer ones are just... lazy? Or maybe even afraid? We started reading "Las Niñas del Naranjel", which in English is translated as "We Are Green and Trembling", by Gabriela Cabezón Cámara. This is a novel based on a famous nun from the XVII century who ran away from a convent in Spain and came to the colonies disguised as a male soldier. The techquine, rhythm, form, pacing, or whatever you want to call it, is extremely poetic. I loved it. The newer club members, though, wanted to quit reading it immediately because it was too hard, convoluted, confusing, or boring.

It actually frustrated me, and I explained that they should be open to doing things that are hard and to have to pay close attention, or even look words up in the dictionary. I read a chapter aloud to show how the rhythm works, but nothing. Nonetheless, I won't compromise my views and curricula just because they got bored. I gave them another book to read in parallel, and that was that.

With all this preamble, I mean to say I agree with your thoughts on the harms of this type of self-gratifying consumption of media.

The idea that what an author writes reflects the author's points of view is ridiculous. This is really sad and shows how much education has declined nowadays. With my already mentioned book club, we like to organize literary events. While marketing our event on Gothic literature, we were accused of being satanic and told to find God by our neighbors. I can't be responsible for them not knowing the difference between reality and fiction. I just feel sad for them. Similarly, I see this happening every day online with authors. Even authors from different centuries.

On the other hand, there were some remarks I found misogynistic in this video. Saying that this is the fault of women, or that women are shielded from being persecuted for their fantasies regarding illegal acts, unlike men, is crazy to me. Unless you have hard data backing up the assumption that all of these entries are made and read only by women, this has no solid base.

I do not like those fantasies (inc*st), but they are the least common tags in fanfiction spaces, even in places as deranged as AO3. Most women, as you've mentioned, look for eroticism or for emotional masturb*tion more than hardcore smut. However, I do not support shaming people's kinks or their exploration of their sexuality (within reason, and as long as they are not harming anyone or acting on said fantasies).

Men partake in more dangerous, harmful, and disgusting habits to satiate their "hunger". Even when they commit crimes against women, they are released with a slap on the wrist. What's up with that? So men can r\*ape a piacere, and women shouldn't invent little stories in their heads to have a good time?

Again, I understand that the transpolation of fanfiction rules into traditional publishing has generated profound harm to the form, content, and message of contemporary literature. I do not condone that. I believe fanfiction belongs to AO3 just like my diary entries belong in my diary. I just didn't like how you framed it every now and then as this being women-sex-bad.


r/literature • • May 20 '26

Discussion “This first person character is an unreliable narrator”

9 Upvotes

Every time I see someone call Percy Jackson and Katniss Everdeen an “unreliable narrator”, I *immediately* get irritated- and yes those are the examples I’m using because this is what I see the most often

Correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t an unreliable narrator a character/voice in a story that either outright lies, lies by omission, and or paints the narrative in a dishonest way to *intentionally* mislead the reader ?

I keep seeing people call these first person characters “unreliable” simply for being biased or not knowing the whole truth- but a character being biased doesn’t make that character unreliable, it just means they’re not objective/omniscient, which is practically EVERY first person character, isn’t it ??

It really fucking confounds me, a character being insecure and us reading them having those thoughts doesn’t make them “unreliable” because they’re “not telling the truth”, they’re not trying to mislead the audience, they just have low self esteem- “Percy Jackson is an unreliable narrator because he thinks he’s a loser when he’s actually not”- that’s not what an unreliable narrator is 🫩

It’s even more aggravating in the case of Katniss when the whole og trilogy has a constant theme of propaganda- and clearly shows that every character, INCLUDING KATNISS, has their biases BECAUSE of the environment they live in -no Katniss isn’t “unreliable” because she’s “a better archer than she says she is” or because “she doesn’t realize she’s in love with Peeta”- that’s not what an unreliable narrator is 🫩, these characters have their biases/perspectives BECAUSE of who they are/what they’re going through, not because they’re trying to mislead the audience

It makes me confused as to what people mean/what people want- Is an unreliable narrator really just a character that “doesn’t tell the truth unequivocally no matter what” to some people ? Do people want characters that are more “objective”? Why ? That would make books significantly less fun to read, right ?? 😭

I dunno, I feel like in general I’m seeing people misuse literary terms on social media all the fucking time and it’s genuinely starting to irk me 💀 like if you aren’t sure what it means just look it up ? I’m getting really tired of people not understanding what words mean 😭

EDIT: For some reason, I literally cannot see the comments, idk why and it’s a shame but 🤷🏾‍♀️ I mean shit, idk what to do about it

anyways, I see (some) of what people are saying about intent, so I double checked my definitions, and it’s seems like more of a sliding scale then an exact descriptor- and atp I might be being pedantic, but the reason why I say they’re “biased” but not “unreliable” -despite the fact that being non objective by definition can make a character unreliable, is because I feel like calling any character that has any amount of bias or doesn’t know the whole truth (yet- or ever) -makes practically every first person character an unreliable narrator ?

Because then it would seem like the only way to have a “truly reliable narrator”, is if they knew everything right off the bat, were right all the time, and were completely non objective, and I really can’t think of any characters like that ? I can’t even think of a way for a character to be a “truly reliable narrator” and still have an arc, dramatic irony, etc etc.- so maybe they don’t have to be aware of the fact that they’re not as “true” as they believe themselves to be-

but I still feel like calling characters having moments of insecurity, or being dense-examples of them being unreliable narrators is a stretch, because if that’s all it takes, then any character with any minor flaw is unreliable, and I just don’t believe that to be the case 🤷🏾‍♀️

Edit 2: nvm I can see the comments now ! Don’t know wtf happened but they’re back lmao


r/literature • • Sep 25 '21

Discussion The Internet has caused a cataclysmic decline in literature

0 Upvotes

Today I shared COVID-19 May Impair Men's Sexual Performance on r/news. Shamefully I admit, I knew its title would make my post popular, just as I knew that many users, in their eagerness to view lascivious content, wouldn't look down the post to the 'soft-pay portal' warning just under the link, then vociferously complain about the deception to which they'd been so unduly subjected. Most of the complaints were vulgar and deleted. Even with the soft-pay portal, the link got 1,000 upvotes/hour, making that link an order of magnitude more valuable than any PhD from my local university. Thousands of people even upvoted what I write a few decades ago. Now, people find me too long-winded. Being a third-generation writer who's had to endure the worst format transitions in history, I've some things to say about how the Internet has caused a cataclysmic decline in writing quality. So far Ive enjoyed a few dozen comments in response. None of them were about the format transition this post actually discusses.

95% of current social-media users can't suspend judgment for more than one paragraph. Many can't even read at all after seeing one link.

In the far past, transitions to new formats were overwhelmingly positive: from scrolls, to bound books, to printed books, to newspapers, each transition enabled wider and more thorough communications. The downturn started with the introduction of paperbacks and tabloids.

Originally, cutting paper and folding it was expensive, so books and newspapers had big pages. In the 1960s, newspapers starting halving the page size. When people turn a page, they see the right-hand page first. Hence, ads on the odd pages could be sold for more money than on the even pages. Newspapers could significantly increase revenue for short illustrated stories by reducing the page size. Thus the tabloid format became popular in the 'low brow' market.

Similarly, paperbacks could fit in handbags for beach reading. So people wanted more beach reading. Leonard Nimoy's remark in his movie 'Star Trek IV' about Jacqueline Susan and Harold Robbins springs to mind: 'Aaah! The Greats!' Even William Shatner had trouble keeping a straight face.

While it might be too easy to salubriously sneer at 'low brow' literature, the impact of the Internet on reading habits has been totally devastating. We are approaching the far end of the transition to an Internet-driven world, and no media transition has ever had a more disastrous effect on human culture. The crisis emerged from private journalism's need to make its early offerings free, in order to acquire an online audience after the 2000 Internet boom. Lost revenue caused a catastrophic decline in quality. Many publications went out of business. Bookshops virtually disappeared. Newspapers lost all but a tiny sliver of their classified ads, which were not only their main source of revenue, but also, and most importantly, a primary justification for editorial to be more neutral.

In what remaining newsrooms there are, staffs have been slashed by at least 60% across the board, and the journalists have to serve larger computer screens, smaller phones, and print formatting, reducing their ability to concentrate on quality reporting. News media has also had to adapt to the current audience, which since the advent of smartphones has had little interest in long news analysis or even long stories.

The typical story read by current audiences has to be written for grade 8 reading level and is ~75 words, averaging 8 sentences with 9.4 words per sentence.

For longer topics, the same subject is repeated 'reverse pyramid' style, with more detail in incremental blocks of about the same size between ads. Personally, I find the insertion of ads every 6-8 sentences a vivid annoyance, and I find myself in the top 1% percentile, as a person who actually finishes reading a news story before commenting on it.

'imprint' studies inform publishers that the 75-word format is their best hope for raising money, because that's as much content as easily fits on a phone. Anything more would require swiping it. Tapping takes less energy, and as observed at this post's beginning, people will tap a link before reading anything below it. Hence, with the reduction in staff, ALL news media has now collapsed into the same minimal format, with links to click instead of more text to learn from.

The move to computer screens, then phones, has caused an even greater reduction of quality, far faster, then any other transition in the prestention of the written word. For political topics, the alternative viewpoint is never presented, and there is no discussion of relative merit between opposing views due to extreme prejudices across the partisan divide. People blame the media, but the media is simply responding to the audience. Writers should not be blamed for writing what people actually will read.

The result is a self-reinforcing cycle of dumbness that has driven American intelligence into the dirt. We can only hope for a change in public expectations, attitudes, and business models to reverse the trend. But a reversal is nowhere near in sight. Instead, Google is promoting new literature formats, for people to write short stories and put a picture behind them. That's what people want to read. That's what technology is now supplying. Society needs to reinvent itself again. It reinvented itself for the Internet. The boom is over. The bust has started. A new enlightenment must recharge our frayed intelligence, or the social divisions created by minimization of thought to fit on a phone will incrementally destroy all the other progress society has made.


r/literature • • Aug 16 '25

Discussion Bret Easton Ellis' novels are like magazines that were turned into novels, and feel miserable to read

4 Upvotes

I do understand that it is his style. A focus on pop culture and vapid consumerism, and the creation of equally shallow and terrible characters to highlight it.

However, in my opinion, it doesn't work.

Not because he isn't a great writer, but because he lacks the essential thing that is necessary when writing novels like this, which is highlighting his humanity in his work.

Instead, he focuses on creating a pop sensational feeling, using and highlighting violence to enforce his point. This isn't bad, and it's not something that only he has done. Hunter S thompson also did this when he wrote fear and loathing. The only difference in my opinion is that Hunter S thompson was able to write and express the humanity, or lack thereof, of his characters , which was genuine and truly worth reading. Perhaps because I find his work seems to have some compassion for the world which is essential for creating something to connect to.

Ellis' novels feel cheap and boring, and just as empty as the world he comments on.


r/literature • • Oct 18 '23

Discussion I Changed My Mind about Reading Problematic Male Authors | I came of age loving the works of Milan Kundera and Derek Walcott. Now, as a professor of literature, I have to ask tough questions

Thumbnail
thewalrus.ca
7 Upvotes