Today I shared COVID-19 May Impair Men's Sexual Performance on r/news. Shamefully I admit, I knew its title would make my post popular, just as I knew that many users, in their eagerness to view lascivious content, wouldn't look down the post to the 'soft-pay portal' warning just under the link, then vociferously complain about the deception to which they'd been so unduly subjected. Most of the complaints were vulgar and deleted. Even with the soft-pay portal, the link got 1,000 upvotes/hour, making that link an order of magnitude more valuable than any PhD from my local university. Thousands of people even upvoted what I write a few decades ago. Now, people find me too long-winded. Being a third-generation writer who's had to endure the worst format transitions in history, I've some things to say about how the Internet has caused a cataclysmic decline in writing quality. So far Ive enjoyed a few dozen comments in response. None of them were about the format transition this post actually discusses.
95% of current social-media users can't suspend judgment for more than one paragraph. Many can't even read at all after seeing one link.
In the far past, transitions to new formats were overwhelmingly positive: from scrolls, to bound books, to printed books, to newspapers, each transition enabled wider and more thorough communications. The downturn started with the introduction of paperbacks and tabloids.
Originally, cutting paper and folding it was expensive, so books and newspapers had big pages. In the 1960s, newspapers starting halving the page size. When people turn a page, they see the right-hand page first. Hence, ads on the odd pages could be sold for more money than on the even pages. Newspapers could significantly increase revenue for short illustrated stories by reducing the page size. Thus the tabloid format became popular in the 'low brow' market.
Similarly, paperbacks could fit in handbags for beach reading. So people wanted more beach reading. Leonard Nimoy's remark in his movie 'Star Trek IV' about Jacqueline Susan and Harold Robbins springs to mind: 'Aaah! The Greats!' Even William Shatner had trouble keeping a straight face.
While it might be too easy to salubriously sneer at 'low brow' literature, the impact of the Internet on reading habits has been totally devastating. We are approaching the far end of the transition to an Internet-driven world, and no media transition has ever had a more disastrous effect on human culture. The crisis emerged from private journalism's need to make its early offerings free, in order to acquire an online audience after the 2000 Internet boom. Lost revenue caused a catastrophic decline in quality. Many publications went out of business. Bookshops virtually disappeared. Newspapers lost all but a tiny sliver of their classified ads, which were not only their main source of revenue, but also, and most importantly, a primary justification for editorial to be more neutral.
In what remaining newsrooms there are, staffs have been slashed by at least 60% across the board, and the journalists have to serve larger computer screens, smaller phones, and print formatting, reducing their ability to concentrate on quality reporting. News media has also had to adapt to the current audience, which since the advent of smartphones has had little interest in long news analysis or even long stories.
The typical story read by current audiences has to be written for grade 8 reading level and is ~75 words, averaging 8 sentences with 9.4 words per sentence.
For longer topics, the same subject is repeated 'reverse pyramid' style, with more detail in incremental blocks of about the same size between ads. Personally, I find the insertion of ads every 6-8 sentences a vivid annoyance, and I find myself in the top 1% percentile, as a person who actually finishes reading a news story before commenting on it.
'imprint' studies inform publishers that the 75-word format is their best hope for raising money, because that's as much content as easily fits on a phone. Anything more would require swiping it. Tapping takes less energy, and as observed at this post's beginning, people will tap a link before reading anything below it. Hence, with the reduction in staff, ALL news media has now collapsed into the same minimal format, with links to click instead of more text to learn from.
The move to computer screens, then phones, has caused an even greater reduction of quality, far faster, then any other transition in the prestention of the written word. For political topics, the alternative viewpoint is never presented, and there is no discussion of relative merit between opposing views due to extreme prejudices across the partisan divide. People blame the media, but the media is simply responding to the audience. Writers should not be blamed for writing what people actually will read.
The result is a self-reinforcing cycle of dumbness that has driven American intelligence into the dirt. We can only hope for a change in public expectations, attitudes, and business models to reverse the trend. But a reversal is nowhere near in sight. Instead, Google is promoting new literature formats, for people to write short stories and put a picture behind them. That's what people want to read. That's what technology is now supplying. Society needs to reinvent itself again. It reinvented itself for the Internet. The boom is over. The bust has started. A new enlightenment must recharge our frayed intelligence, or the social divisions created by minimization of thought to fit on a phone will incrementally destroy all the other progress society has made.