One of the main reasons I bought Litecoin was my (incorrect) belief that Charlie, /u/coblee ,had good relationships with the Chinese miners or understood the Chinese culture. https://www.reddit.com/r/litecoin/comments/63drtj/why_litecoin_is_a_buy_right_now/
Based on the latest open letter by Jiangzhuoer, the largest non-signalling mining pool operator, http://news.8btc.com/why-i-am-still-not-voting-for-segwit-an-open-letter-from-jiangzhuoer , it is very clear to me Charlie Lee does not understand business relations, the Chinese culture, or is any good with negotiations. This isn't an attack on Charlie, but just an observation. I have mentioned in a previous thread how important reputation and "saving face" here: https://www.reddit.com/r/litecoin/comments/65btxn/the_chinese_care_most_about_saving_face_please/?utm_content=title&utm_medium=user&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=frontpage . I knew how important voting was despite people saying he is a troll (and he is), but it turns out he acted exactly on what the poll said. Would he have done so otherwise? Who knows. I have had plenty of business interactions with Chinese people and anyone who has also knows its all about relationships. Do not try to fight fire with fire. The only way to get what you want is to give mutual respect. They are willing to be on the sucker end of a deal if you say the right words. Charlie did not. Now I am not saying he has to bow down and do as he is told, this isn't what this is about.
The article released in the letter by LTC1BTC pool owner Jiangzhuoer linked above explains the reason why they are not signalling segwit. It's basically saying Charlie (Charlie + unknown) demanded segwit and threatened UASF. Then Charlie was discussing the possibility of UASF with Bitcoin developers. That is not negotiation. I can understand why the miners, who imo DOES want segwit, are not signalling. I have always knew they wanted segwit as the correlation between price and segwit signalling is obvious. People claim they are blocking segwit because of Bitcoin. This is unlikely to be true and doesn't make sense. They can activate segwit on Litecoin and still block it on Bitcoin and make more money. They want segwit on Litecoin, but not any of the politics or bullshit that can be linked to Bitcoin. For whatever reason, they don't want it on Bitcoin. That is not our problem/battle/fight. This subreddit is /r/litecoin. We should keep it seperate. It is also why they questionned Charlie's ability and team to code segwit. They don't want Bitcoin's team over at Litecoin. It is obvious Litecoin with segwit = higher price = more profits to miners. There was never any proof or evidence they did not want segwit but the conspiracy theories piled on. https://www.reddit.com/r/litecoin/comments/64bvqn/has_ltc1btc_and_antpool_actually_said_no_to_segwit/?utm_content=title&utm_medium=user&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=frontpage
This is one of the biggest problem with this community. We have a US vs THEM mentality. They, the miners, are evil, greedy, selfish, disrespectful. We, the good guys, are logical, good, not greedy, respectful, patient, and so forth. But whenever anything short of signalling segwit is mentioned, even with prohashing, we come up with some theories to support our belief they are evil. Anything that is worthy of discussion is labelled fud and downvoted immediately. Personal attacks and conspiracy theories beyond my imaginations on pool operators are plentiful. How are we expected for them to work with us if we attack them so quickly. How would you react if you were them? /r/litecoin is as toxic as it has ever been and I can understand why.
It does not get any more clear than this. Charlie should stop discussing UASF for now and try to work with miners. UASF is basically a middle finger to the miners. Even Wang Chun who wants segwit will be forced to oppose it. My speculation is Wang Chun wants segwit. He's on our side. But as a Chinese, he understands Jihan and crew. He knows pissing them off wont get anything done. I have said this before https://www.reddit.com/r/litecoin/comments/6682zg/unpopular_opinion_here_i_think_charlie_should/?ref=share&ref_source=link and this isn't some conspiracy by miners who want to delay something. The miners WANT SEGWIT. They really fucking do. I want segwit. We all want segwit! It doesnt get any more simple than this. https://twitter.com/f2pool_wangchun/status/854547475486490624 But some Chinese people care more about respect, "face", reputation, ego just as much as potential profits. Like it or not thats the way it is. If we can let them feel like they won, they will happily activate segwit.
I hope Charlie Lee can successfuly discuss with the pool owners in China in the coming months with this in mind.
Recommended reading: How to win friends and influence people.