So I, like many of you who still browse this subreddit, am a die hard liquid fan. Die-Hard is just how i support my teams across all sports, once i'm your fan you have me for life. However, just because i'm a staunch supporter does not mean I agree with every decision the team makes, and think every player we have is the best in their position. I want to highlight a few things TL has to do if they want to make it to worlds next year.
I am going to split this post into positions so things read a bit more clearly.
TOP: Oh boy, I used to be a huge Quas fan. When the news was announced that he was kicked off the team, with absolutely no explanation other than some vague statement I was pretty salty. I was upset, but then we got lourlo. A relative unknown to the scene Lourlo has big shoes to fill and nobody can blame him for those first few weeks where he seemed to have a hard time winning lane, dealing with the supportive role he was given and adjusting to the LCS. However, I gave him the benefit of the doubt. The ability to develop local talent is one of the most admirable qualities of a team, however in this situation i'm going to be frank: I do not think Lourlo is good enough. Consistently this year Lourlo has failed to produce results on anything other than a couple champions. When on tanks he has been somewhat lackluster, when givent he opportunity to play carries (which he was touted to be amazing on since he was a carry player when he played SoloQ) he failed. I am remembering a few Irelia performances which had me shaking my head the entire time.
Jungle: Well, what can i say that hasn't been said. Dardoch was a great player. His lee inspired me to feed in soloQ so many times is stupid. However I had no great love for him as he constantly showed attitude problem throughout his tenure with the team. If rumors are true and Piglets departure was as a result of Dardoch the management need to take a long look at themselves and ask if they made the right decision to keep Dardoch and move piglet to TLA. If Tl want to advance as a team they need a good jungler, but they need somebody who is a cool head. Personally I would try my best to steal Spirit from FNC, I think he is a great jungler and if you put him on a team with some solid solo laners he would show what he is truly capable of.
Mid: Probably the shortest paragraph here. I like Fenix, I think Fenix is actually really good. He has a couple issues but he puts pressure on the map for TL. Consistently creates cs leads, solid mechanics, good carry performances and the ability to play quite a wide range of champions. Since he has joined the org his English has improved and I think he has the potential to show he is a top 2 midlaner NA next season.
ADC: Bring back piglet! In football (soccer for the Americans here) your substitutes are used tactically. If a player offers something one of your first eleven is lacking you sub him in for a while, but then he returns to the bench unless he can consistently show he is the better player. Fabbbby, is not the better player. I am sorry Fab. Piglet is a world champion, yeah it was 3 years ago and yeah we had a rough start to the split, but man, ashe/jhin every game? our draft was so predictable. Honestly Steve should do everything he can to keep hold of piglet because I do not see a better replacement in the market right now. I am unsure about the NA resident rule and whether piglet and Fenix will qualify next split, if somebody could clarify I would be grateful.
Support: This is the hardest one for me. Matt is not bad. But he is not great, however I want to say that he could be just as good as any other NA support with a bit more experience and teh right team around him. Matt has shown some stand out performances this split as well as some stand out fails. Getting caught multiple times a game, weak showings in lane and some straight up misplays. I like Matt, I think that Tl should keep him because he has potential and he is an NA player.
I think that if tl is smart they wont take a long holiday and instead they should boot camp. Go and let their team see how the best teams in the world operate, I wish the TL roster could spend a few weeks with SKT and see hwo the team train, play, and work together.
That being said, I know I said some harsh things about the members of our team, if anybody from the team reads this just know I still support you 100 percent, if the exact same roster we have now starts next year I will still be there watching every game and cheering when we win. Sorry for the wall of text, there was a lot to say.