r/linuxquestions • u/Ralstonnn • Nov 13 '21
Does Linux desktop have a future ?
Hey guys, I know it's a controversial topic but lately, with Bryan Lunduke's video and other videos and articles, the question of desktop Linux coming to its end started to bother me a little.
Just wanna see your thoughts on the topic.
Because I've tried Linux and liked it but the noise that Linux gonna die makes me question - is it worth it switching to Linux now?
58
u/lijmlaag Nov 13 '21
Linux on the desktop is better than it has ever been.
But also, yes, there is room for lots of improvements.
29
Nov 13 '21
No of course not. that's rubbish.
The beautiful thing about Linux (and Open Source in general) is that as long as there are people that want it to exist, it'll exist. It's created, backed and supported by a completely different ethos than some corporate software. With something like Adobe Photoshop for example, if everyone stopped buying it, the company would say "well, that's not financially viable anymore, let's take it off the market." It would be gone. It would cease to exist.
Gimp meanwhile, even if most of the user base moved on to something else, as long as at least some passionate fans still exist, it will continue to exist because open source isn't driven by money, it's driven by the passion to create something useful and share it with the world regardless of how many people may or may not share that enthusiasm.
That doesn't just go away in a project as big as Linux. There will always be people who want it to exist.
Don't listen to Bryan Lunduke. He's a middle aged edgelord that new Linux users get introduced to because of his smart-ass "Linux Sucks" series, and then as they learn more about Linux themselves they realize he's just a douche who's not worthy of their youtube views.
14
24
17
8
Nov 13 '21
It's dying so hard that it's gained like 50% more marketshare on Steam since 2018, outpacing the growth of the market. Don't even listen to people like Bryan Lunduke. Their job is to get clicks and views, not provide good content.
6
u/Engrais Nov 13 '21
So, what are the arguments in favor of Linux dying ??
0
u/Motor-Lab-406 Nov 14 '21
I didn't watch the vid, but linux on the desktop is not for the common user. That also means me - a 20+ year veteran in tech, codes in several languages including c and two assemblers, and is an engineer who builds all kinds of compute, storage, network and software solutions for large global customers.
No native vendor tools run on linux. Any time there's some kind of an issue, it's a bitch to fix. Library dependencies. Ridiculously subpar software available. Yes, it's cheaper/free, but my laptop has 50k of vendor software and VMs on it, and cost over 7k (dell precision). Those are a rounding error. I want to do my work on it, I don't want to OS to get in the way. Windows mostly doesn't. With Linux, a ridiculous amount of time is spent managing the OS. Professionals don't care about the OS - we need something to get our work done. Linux ain't it.
Now, windblows gets in the way too, especially lately. I got two laptops, every time I update office it keeps popping up ads for its features - over and over and over. I had to close the little ad bar in outlook about 10 times before it understood that it doesn't need to let me know there's an outlook app for my phone. Most other ads and telemetry are not in the corporate image, so literally just a couple of annoyances. Fixing stuff is much easier and faster than on linux, and the community you google up for the fixes is not a bunch of useless assholes being purposely dense or dragging on conversations to purposely miss the point while being technically correct but missing the obvious question.
Linux is not a thing for the destop. It's a thing for cheap servers that aren't too important (BSD/AIX/etc are for important stuff). It's a thing for virtual appliances that aren't mission-critical. It's a thing for routers and such. It's not dead, but for desktop use beyond playing around with it? It's an inferior product to get work done.
10
5
u/Born-Process-9848 Nov 13 '21
For the gaming market sure. That's how I look at windows just my gaming pc. I'm a dev and been on linux/unix since 1997. Nothing's better imho than a linux pc for personal, privacy conscious user. I have macbook pros and dell windows from work which I use for teams and emails but for serious projects I use linux.
9
u/brimston3- Nov 13 '21
Linux gaming is better than ever these days. I'm not sure where you've been but valve has been doing a heavy push on proton to get huge swaths of the library working. It's easily 70+% of games without anticheat. Even the notoriously incompatible jrpgs are playable now.
2
u/Born-Process-9848 Nov 13 '21
That's good news. I only have a few steam games in Linux. Yeah it's smooth. Hopefully videocard makers and big game studioa support linux more.
5
4
4
u/Linux4ever_Leo Nov 13 '21
LMAO! Linux isn't going anywhere. It has been growing steadily since it was initially released and basically runs the backbone of the Internet as well as on countless business and enterprise servers. It's also, of course on a lot of enthusiasts' desktops. By all means make the switch.
4
7
u/hate_commenter Nov 13 '21
Is it about a "Linus sucks" video? If so, don't take it seriously. He like to do the mental exercise of why Linux might sucks or die. He doesn't even believe it. Also, you should always question the opinion of people on the internet (yes, even mine).
9
u/vacri Nov 13 '21
Lunduke has gone off the rails recently and has been trolling but calling it 'satire'.
5
Nov 13 '21
Hate people like that “oh, it’s just a joke, bro” “relax it’s just satire, I don’t actually believe it” ugh
3
5
Nov 13 '21
I wonder what will happen when Windows 10 reaches end of support. Lots of old hardware can run it well but doesn't meet Windows 11 requirements. Will Microsoft change the requirements or will a lot of people switch to Linux?
Other than that I don't expect much change of popularity of the Linux desktop.
6
u/captainstormy Nov 13 '21
The same thing that happens when every version of windows hits EOL. Lots of people will keep using it anyway.
2
Nov 13 '21
The jump now seems bigger and less appropriate, maybe because computer performance and performance requirements haven't been rising as much as before. I'm writing this comment on a laptop that's over 10 years old, and can run Windows 10 fine. Earlier computers became unusably slow much more quickly.
5
u/captainstormy Nov 13 '21
People in mass aren't going to switch to Linux because a new version of windows comes out. I've been hearing this since the 90s every single time.
99+% of current windows 10 users are going to do one of three things when windows 10 hits EOL.
Upgrade their PC to Windows 11.
Keep using an out of date Windows 10.
Buy a new PC that has windows 11 on it.
4
u/Se7enLC Nov 13 '21
It's called "clickbait". Of course Linux isn't going away any time soon. But if you say it is you get more clicks.
2
Nov 13 '21
Not sure what Bryan Lunduke said, I quit following him a while back when he clearly went insane. He used to be one of the best sources of Linux news, but those days are unfortunately over. I hope he gets better as he was excellent when he was in good form.
1
3
u/justme424269 Nov 13 '21
Everyone is used to how Windows works and they start spouting off when Linux works differently. Yet they don't expect Apple to be the same as Microsoft. You couldn't pay me enough to use Windows anymore. I'll happily stay on sane side with my Linux desktop.
3
u/CleoMenemezis Nov 13 '21
Linux Desktop is already present. It's nestled, but that's not really a problem.
3
3
2
u/warpedspockclone Nov 13 '21
Linux desktop has the brightest future. Windows is bloatware, MacOS is ransomware masquerading as an OS.
The only thing keeping Windows alive is its monopolistic behavior. The only thing keeping Mac OS alive is that it isn't Windows and has a big app ecosystem.
1
u/Left-Leopard-1266 Nov 13 '21
My humble thoughts: Windows 11 refuses to be installed on millions of desktops (that includes laptops). Microsoft also has an end of life for Win 10.
With that in mind, i don’t think people will simply throw away their laptops. Hackintosh isn’t everyone’s cup of tea/ liking. Solution? Good old trusted Linux 😀
1
Nov 13 '21
I think the notion Linux Desktop is dying comes from our corporate environment today where constant growth is expected.
There Linux Desktop doesn't really grow when it comes to market share, it has remained constant for a long period of time. So to some, that means dying because it isn't growing. To others it's just a stable alternative that has kept it's niche in the desktop space.
1
u/ICantPCGood Nov 13 '21
I don't see it going anywhere. It's been around since the 90s. It's niche (on the desktop), always been niche, and i believe it will continue to be a niche OS primarily for enthusiasts with its own quirks, but it's not likely to go anywhere. If it meets your needs use it.
1
1
u/Seref15 Nov 13 '21
I've maintained for years that in order for Linux to capture significant desktop market share, there will have to be an Android-like distro--a commercially developed and supported GUI running on Linux.
Also I think the kernel maintainers don't particularly care about desktop. Damn near the whole world's servers run on Linux and that's far more meaningful.
1
1
1
u/Schievel1 Nov 13 '21
If anything it has been dying since the beginning. :D at least that’s what it feels like
1
1
Nov 16 '21
Protip - Lundukes "predictions" have been wrong for... well about a decade at least. They are more often than not fuelled by his personal one sided beefs with different groups - and a preference to do the "Nah just talking, lol" route when ever confronted with his tbh nonsensical garbage.
So this is what have worked for me, if I see something he's said that I kinda agree with - I tend to read up on it more because that dude would call the sky purple, and up down if he could get a buck out of it. So just take it him for what he is, a panicking song and dance man who's been found out and now does anything to stay slightly relevant, including clickbait.
1
Dec 03 '21
Sidenote: considering Lundukes well documented lies, his preference for pedophilia and support for neonazi movements blaming "the jews" (while he is one)... lets not bother with him.
He and his wife was even flung out of conservative circles for being too weird.
0
Nov 13 '21
He's been saying "linux sucks" for years, and linux has been getting and better by the year. I know he brings up some valid criticism sometimes, but doesn't ever mean that linux is "dying". I always give him the benefit of the doubt and say "he criticizes linux because he wants it to get better". You know, we, humans, tend to criticize the things we care about the most.
0
-9
0
Nov 13 '21
[deleted]
7
5
u/mistahspecs Nov 13 '21
Clickbait and controversy-stirring podcaster.
Was relevant a decade ago, but burned a ton of bridges, and lost the respect of many folks.
-2
u/Duranture Nov 13 '21
YouTuber who's content is mostly about Linux.
17
u/Born-Process-9848 Nov 13 '21
This explains everything. You know how youtubers use controversial titles like "you're doing this wrong" and "why you should stop doing this"... 100% that's the reason for his video that OP fell for.
17
u/Duranture Nov 13 '21
It's not just that, Lunduke long ago was a very interesting and informative Linux YouTuber, but at some point he turned really bitter. That or he adopted this persona as a YouTube character to get views. I'm not sure since I stopped watching him years ago.
1
0
Nov 13 '21
[deleted]
1
u/raggedyman2822 Nov 15 '21
It would help if Bryan belived the pandemic is real. His Twitter got really right-wing in the last few years.
77
u/MoobyTheGoldenSock Nov 13 '21
There is no sign that desktop linux is dying.