r/linux • • Jan 12 '20

Make. It. Simple. Linux Desktop Usability — Part 1

https://medium.com/@probonopd/make-it-simple-linux-desktop-usability-part-1-5fa0fb369b42
476 Upvotes

390 comments sorted by

31

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

21

u/WickedFlick Jan 12 '20

This was a genuinely excellent look into what makes good UI design. Highly recommend it to anyone thinking about getting involved in one of the DE's, or for people interested in customizing their DE heavily (like on r/Unixporn).

Also, encapsulating those links with the [text](link) format can help make it look a bit nicer, and a bit easier to differentiate. :)

Make it Simple Series:

19

u/babulej Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

These are all really good articles! I want this guy to design a desktop environment, I'd totally use it.

edit: there are some stuff I disagree with here, like the part about keyboards and languages. Not all keyboards have specific languages. I live in Poland, we use totally standard QWERTY keyboards, and input Polish letters by pressing the right alt+letter.

And the ability to quickly change the keyboard language can be useful for people who use more than one language that needs its own keyboard layout. For example, English and Polish can be typed with the same keyboard layout (when it's set to Polish). But English and Japanese need two different keyboard layouts, so if someone uses both languages, he or she needs a quick way to switch between them.

edit 2: The author suggested that if someone types in more languages, they should physically plug and unplug keyboards made for that language. I'm not sure I want him to design a DE anymore.

edit 3: So, I've read all of these articles. They are full of great stuff, except for that language and keyboard brain fart. I'd still use a DE designed by this guy, but hope that the keyboard settings are saner than the article.

1

u/Kapibada Jan 13 '20

And the whole thing with accidentally pressing ctrl/alt+shift - Well, yeah, we've lived with it for years on Windows, because it would always set up three keyboard layouts by default… Until Windows 8. Finally, on fresh Windows installs, we only have our one usual keyboard layout by default and can add others as needed. Default keyboard layouts should reflect common usage in the given locale.

26

u/VenditatioDelendaEst Jan 12 '20

For the most part, anything I don't mention, I agree with.

Part 1

Hamburger menu is correct for web browsers, because you should pretty much never need anything in it except for the developer tools. The top edge is used for the much more important tab bar (with horizontal tabs) or Back/Forward/URL/Search (with vertical tabs). All of those actions are way more frequent than creating new windows, zooming, changing preferences, or using the web developer tools.

Global bar is worse than per-window menu bar, because it is incompatible with focus-follows-mouse. And even in click-to-focus environments, it makes accessing a different window's menus a 2-step operation.

Who on earth wakes up one morning and says, let me see what happens if I press “/” in a Linux application? I wonder who comes up with those hidden easter eggs.

Anyone who has used less or vim. It also works in Firefox.

Part 2

Changes should be effective immediately, without the user having to click “apply” first. In the case of dangerous actions, the user should be warned by a dialog box with “Cancel” being the default. Configuration changes should be easy to be reset to the defaults.

Apply does 3 things

  1. You can get ready to look at the effect of the change.

  2. You can change multiple settings at once.

  3. Some configuration changes are expensive to apply, such that they cannot be switched willy-nilly in real time.

To see why Apply is good, just imagine trying to configure your monitor's video mode (screen resolution and refresh rate) without an Apply button.

By now the dock should be an established user experience concept

"The Dock" is cargo-cult Apple-chasing UI design. The Correct window-switching UI is the taskbar.

Or take the pulsating Aqua default buttons in Mac OS X 10.0 (around 2000).

Barely visible waste of CPU time and battery life. Animated UI makes it appear that it is doing something (c.f. animated progress bars), when it is actually waiting for user input. Objectively awful.

But not even the most basic aspects of desktop UX seem to be sacrosanct anymore.

Ah! Ahahaha! Some of us remember Nautilus' spatial window mode By default, it would open a new window every.single.time. you tried to descend into a folder.

Part 3

Here is the control panel from the Mac in 1984.

Okay but that's completely incomprehensible. The volume control is clear, and maybe the tortoise/hare things is keyboard repeat rate?

Linux distributions should pick a standard for how to set the hardware clock (e.g., UTC — check what Windows and macOS do), and then stick to it.

This is, as far as I know, already the standard. Windows is (was?) the odd one out that sets the hardware clock to local time. (Which is stupid. WTF are you supposed to do if the machine is turned on during a daylight-savings-time switching hour?)

Someone should come up with a scheme for storing basic per-machine settings in EFI NVRAM, and get it standardized for all operating systems to implement — so that these basics “just work” as they did on the original Macintosh in 1984.

This is, in general, a terrible idea.

It requires cooperation from all the OS vendors to support. It makes it difficult to backup configuration because it's stored outside the normal filesystem. And all you get in exchange is slightly improved UX for multiboot.

Part 4

Printing

Oh no.

... is what I said when I saw that heading, because I hate printers so fucking much. I agree with everything in that section, but even if it were fixed, the printers themselves would still be awful.

2

u/american_spacey Jan 13 '20

Hamburger menu is correct for web browsers, because you should pretty much never need anything in it except for the developer tools.

Things I use at least once a week in Firefox's menu bar: File -> Quit, File -> Print, File -> New Tab (I use the keyboard shortcut), File -> Private Window (keyboard shortcut), Cut, Copy, Paste (all keyboard shortcuts), History -> Show All History, Tools -> Dev Tools (keyboard shortcut), Tools -> Page Info, Help -> About Firefox (to check the version).

Sure, for me about half of the menu bar functions I use are effectively replaced with the equivalent keyboard shortcut. But good UI design does not assume that people already know about and use all the keyboard shortcuts (see this author's points about discoverability). But for the other stuff, I'd have to deal with a single hamburger menu to get to the functions I use, assuming they're all buried in there somewhere.

3

u/VenditatioDelendaEst Jan 13 '20

Things I use at least once a week in Firefox's menu bar

But the tab bar and/or back button is used once a minute.

File -> Quit

Ctrl-Q

Sure, for me about half of the menu bar functions I use are effectively replaced with the equivalent keyboard shortcut.

Not just for you. The web browser is so central to modern computer usage that practically every user will spend years in its UI. Everyone becomes a power user of the web browser eventually, so the UI should be optimized for 1) being efficient for power users and 2) turning people into power users as fast as possible. The goal of the menu, however it's shown and laid out, should be to teach people the keyboard shortcuts and then get out of the way. (Firefox, for instance, fails at this for cut/copy/paste and zoom functions.)

→ More replies (1)

25

u/tsadecoy Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

So I'm reading through and his rant in part 3 about the quick keyboard language switching options is pretty idiotic. Plenty of people use english keyboards with some other language stickered on top so quick switching is essential for the user experience.

A coworker of mine uses that feature so that he can write stuff for work in english but talk to his family overseas in arabic.

Not a fan of part 3. Seems to be missing the forest for the trees.

EDIT: Part 4 also has issues where he does something in the worst way possible. Ubuntu pretty explicitly lets you enable proprietary and "legally questionable" codecs on install. Deepin and to a point other Ubuntu derivative works can also do what they want because they don't have a corporate presence to worry about. I get the whole legality be damned point of view but Canonical used to actually sell codec packs to be super legal and nobody wanted any part of that.

21

u/Headpuncher Jan 12 '20

Yeah, Pt3 is waaaaay off the mark. I use Norwegian keyboards and English keyboards on usually English language OS. Of course on laptops, that means a non-exchangable norwegian kb on english OS.

When an OS or even a website *assumes my language* based on some other setting it honestly drives me insane.

iOS/Apple are a worst offender at this. Set your iOS device to localization: UK and language: UK and go into any app like podcasts and it serves data based on location. That is 100% stupid.

The author also doesn't appear to know the difference between input sources and languages. Which is odd.

And all this ranting about gnome and KDE is kinda funny from the POV of an XFCE user. Author sets his focus where it is easy to avoid talking about DEs on which it is easy to set the KB language. On XFCE with the Whisker menu installed it's about 4 clicks away, and that's if you don't search the setting which would bring it down to 2 clicks.

14

u/Maoschanz Jan 12 '20

90% of his rants are idiotic, but since he hates things commonly hated on r/linux he's posted here every month

→ More replies (2)

26

u/LvS Jan 12 '20

Holy cow, that's some bullshit. I mean, it sounds nice if you have no clue about the topics he touches - who doesn't agree with "This should be easy!!!!111eleven" - but in every case I know about, he fails to understand why it isn't easy.

There's one case where he does it in the article, when he says "just use the keyboard's hardcoded language" and then a reader has to inform them that keyboard manufacturers don't set that tag, so it's unsupported in 99% of cases and wrong otherwise.

Want some more?

Why didn't CentOS install MP4 support? Patents.
Why aren't icons part of the binaries? Because you'd need multiple formats and sizes and users also need (translated) application names to find their application and that's why we have .desktop files.
Why don't desktops just run random binaries? Because we all know what happened on Windows when users and .exe files.
Why don't desktops just run random binaries in a sandbox? Because no sandbox exists that is both secure and full-featured to run random binaries.
Why is adjusting the volume so hard? Because sometimes people want to only adjust their music volume but not their call (or vice versa).
Why are control panels more complex than in 1984? Because stuff is no longer hardcoded using hardware switches but is configurable at runtime.
Why do keyboards have so many options with dead keys and whatnot? Because not only does every device maker invent their own keyboard layout (without using new USB IDs), but users also want to use the same layout with differently labeled keyboards.

And I suppose all of his arguments are that thin and not researched, but sometimes I don't know the details either.

Holy hell, this series is stupid.

7

u/american_spacey Jan 13 '20

Why is adjusting the volume so hard? Because sometimes people want to only adjust their music volume but not their call (or vice versa).

I think he makes quite a lot of good points that you're not giving him credit for. But you're 100% right about this one especially. It's not at all confusing that you might have multiple audio outputs and want to control them independently. The macOS way that he praises here seems to assume you want to only output sound on one device at a time, which is just 100% wrong.

5

u/gnumdk Jan 13 '20

He is Appimage author, so, not surprised about the "make Linux virus ready" bullshit.

1

u/loop_42 Jan 13 '20

Superb post. I don't fully agree with everything in your links, but the vast majority is spot on. Especially the unnecessary visibility of the complexity of the Linux filesystem.

1

u/cloveistaken Jan 12 '20

Why the heck does the Elementary gif in part 2 behave like that ??

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

[deleted]

7

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

The inconsistencies and complexities definitely makes it tough for the average joe to use Linux.

It's not ideal, but I wouldn't say that modern Linux desktops are any worse than Windows 10 when it comes to inconsistency and complexity.

4

u/Democrab Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

People forget how much of the UI comes down to the user themselves.

You'd never expect that my Mum (Mid to late 60s, no real IT training, former accountant and dressmaker) would prefer LibreOffice to MS Office but she does simply because she learnt on Office 97 and guess which has the most similar UI to Office 97 out of LibreOffice or Office365?

Likewise with KDE, she had to get used to it still after coming from 10 with a 7 style UI from ClassicShell (She tried to adapt to 10 but found it terribly confusing and I eventually installed classicshell because I was sick of having to show her how to do things every day) but took to it like a duck to water because the concepts it follows for design style are ones the software she uses typically followed too so she was able to figure things out for herself. Stuff like KDE Connect gave her a good reason to want to get used to it, too. (She uses her PC to have movies playing while she sits away from it, but in the room to do sewing and the like. Handy to have a control on her phone to pause and the like)

44

u/EternityForest Jan 12 '20

I agree with most of this, but I can't stand global menus. It's one of the reasons I didn't even bother learning mac.

Associating the menu with the window is way more important than fractional second efficiency gains on items that aren't used that often.

Windows 7 got usability right in almost every way. The dev experience and performance sucked, but the UI was near perfect.

A lot of design seems to think people are having multiple apps onscreen at once, and non devs don't do that as much as devs. So I'm not a fan of anything optimized for tiled windows at the expensive of fullscreen plus taskbar switching.

28

u/american_spacey Jan 13 '20

I can't stand global menus

The problem with global menus is that they force you to use a desktop metaphor with a global state, i.e. where it makes sense to say that one application is "active" and all others are not. For anyone who uses more than one application at a time, you end up with a situation where you can't just use each application independently, you have to do something to "switch" the global state from one application to the other before it becomes usable.

The other problem with global menus is that they mean you can't dispense with the dock by putting the application icons in the taskbar. You're basically forced into having two bars or a bar and a dock.

1

u/ragnese Jan 13 '20

The problem with global menus is that they force you to use a desktop metaphor with a global state,

But every desktop metaphor that I'm aware of does exactly that anyway. On Windows you have to click or alt-tab to switch which window (which is nearly 1-to-1 with application) is active. On Linux, some DE's allow you to just move your mouse over a window to activate it without clicking, but it's basically the same.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Reasonable people can disagree. I love the global menu and think taskbars are an abomination. I ran windows from 3.0 to XP, when I got my first mac it took like an hour to get used to the global menu bar, after a day or two it was old hat. Orienting to the global menu bar is just not a big deal, and it's better. Task bars are an eyesore, when they're sparsely populated they look goofy and a densely populated task bar is a hot mess.

2

u/ragnese Jan 13 '20

The benefit of global menu, though, is that you don't have to have a window open to interact with the application. Look at your typical UX for word processors. On Windows and Linux, I can't close all of my open documents and then open a new document without the application fully quitting and restarting. That's the wrong model, IMO. In macOS windows are separate from the application itself. So you can close all of your documents, and still go to the application menu to open a new blank document.

Not only does it fix the brokenness I stated above, but it also fixes the "need" for Windows and Linux DEs to have system trays where applications can hide themselves. That's craziness. Just keep the application running, but with no open windows.

1

u/davidnotcoulthard Jan 13 '20

On Windows and Linux, I can't close all of my open documents and then open a new document without the application fully quitting and restarting

I'm sure there are a good number of programmes that make examples of what you're saying here, but MS Word IIRC isn't one of them

EDIT: neither is Libreoffice, in fact

→ More replies (10)

1

u/acdcfanbill Jan 13 '20

I agree with most of this, but I can't stand global menus

Yea, it seems like Global Menu's are the compromise between having nothing at all, and having a traditional desktop
:(

1

u/Anaptyso Jan 13 '20

Another problem with global menus is when you are using a large screen. The menu can end up a long way from the application window, which can get quite annoying.

159

u/Linux4ever_Leo Jan 12 '20

I agree with the sentiments in this article for the most part. What was so wrong with the File, Edit, View, etc. menu bars? I use Global Menus in KDE Plasma and it works great. The menu changes to whichever application has focus and it displays the program name and it's icon to the extreme left in the same manner as macOS so that you know which program you're in. The menu is always where you expect it. Simple, elegant and it works.

52

u/VenditatioDelendaEst Jan 12 '20

I agree that this image is pretty darn funny, but to be fair, actually needing anything behind the hamburger button is extremely rare, so moving the menu items in there frees up the Fitts' Law Friendly top edge for the tab bar, which is far more frequently accessed.

63

u/hexydes Jan 12 '20 edited Feb 23 '26

The across nature today quiet simple dot bank honest where dot day yesterday!

10

u/Victorino__ Jan 13 '20

Also, at least in Firefox, pressing Alt reveals the top bar with options like File, etc.

6

u/betam4x Jan 13 '20

The hamburger menu has been abused constantly by every project I am aware of. There is an argument to be had for simplicity, but I find it often gets taken too far.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

[deleted]

8

u/mcilrain Jan 13 '20

They didn't save any screen space, they just made finding the menu option you're looking for more difficult.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jhasse Jan 13 '20

If your menus are in a wide top bar, saving space isn't necessary.

Because the space is always wasted ...

1

u/iindigo Jan 13 '20

Well, assuming that your browser windows are maximized. At 2560x1440 and higher real estate resolutions, they’re very frequently not. In that situation global menubars start making more sense.

69

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I completely agree with everything you're saying. Unfortunately the GNOME devs would rather stick to poor design decisions.

73

u/Linux4ever_Leo Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

I tried out Gnome 3.3x on my laptop for a few weeks after my MATE became corrupted. It was in a word...HORRIBLE! They've oversimplified the desktop into utter uselessness. You can't minimize windows by default, there are no right-click options in the file explorer; no copy or paste in the menu items. The dash and window overview is clunky and overbearing. One has to add dozens of extensions or use Gnome Tweak just to get things to a workable state. I realize that Gnome 3.3x has a lot of fans but it does absolutely nothing for me. I prefer classic desktop paradigms like KDE, MATE or Cinnamon.

85

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

I just wish the GNOME Devs would take this kind of criticism seriously instead of just saying "well you're using it wrong." They hardly do any UX testing anyway.

Like... Are we making systems that fit people or are we making people that fit systems..?

EDIT: I have to say that you are wrong about the contextual menus and the dash. But my point still stands.

27

u/sanderd17 Jan 12 '20

I used to ba a gnome fan, back in the 2.x days. Then Gnome 3 came along. It lacked features, but I understood how cleaning up the code could make it easier to add new features, and get a more stable and uniform DE. So I still believed in the gnome project. But update after update, features got removed instead of added. I ended up being so disappointed

7

u/Y1ff Jan 13 '20

MATE is what you want if you liked GNOME 2, it's a fork of the old GNOME.

21

u/dirtbagdh Jan 12 '20

I was cautiously optimistic early on too. Quickly became apparent that they had VERY different ideas about what the DE is supposed to be. Not for me.

23

u/Barafu Jan 13 '20

You are not the target audience of Gnome 3. It is supposed to be used on a touchscreen by a trained gorilla.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/TheMadcapLlama Jan 12 '20

For real though, the fact is that we have KDE, Mate, Cinnamon, XFCE and others to satisfy the needs of a "classic desktop paradigm". The way Gnome is might not please you or a lot of the vocal members in this community, but there are a lot of people that love it (me included) and loathe having to use something else. If all DEs had the same paradigm and workflow why would we need many of them?

I understand for a lot of people the main issue is that Gnome is the default for most distros, but that's something that should be complained to the distros themselves, not to Gnome devs. Even if you don't like their vision, I think their commitment to it is awesome and I applaud them for that. The same way that I applaud the KDE team for their lightweight feature-filled vision and execution, even if I dislike using Plasma.

16

u/Barafu Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

Look, our problem is not with what Gnome do. Our problem is that Gnome is the default on many distros. New people try it first and get the impression that the whole Linux world is that limited and buggy.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

29

u/Linux4ever_Leo Jan 12 '20

Right. Compare MATE to Gnome 3.3x (bearing in mind that MATE was forked from the old Gnome 2.x desktop.) MATE has many more features and utility than Gnome 3.x. How is it that Gnome 3.3x devs have moved so far backwards with regards to simple workflows, intuitive discoverability and basic desktop features like right-click menues? Heck Windows 95 is more advanced in that regard than Gnome 3.3x.

34

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

Hmm. Honestly I'm kind of torn about GNOME. It has a lot of really nice things. I just don't agree with how they don't have certain things that are considered standard. The worst part, for me, is that they call those things "out-dated" and "legacy" while literally every other DE (incl. macOS and Windows) has those things. That's just not a good way to go about it IMO.

They say they care about usability but let's be real. If that was true, how come they tell people to use something else or refuse any criticism about usability? In my view, that's the direct opposite of focusing on usability. If you care about usability then feedback is the highest priority.

They say that since GNOME is popular, then they must be right. But do they consider how many of the GNOME users are using extensions that enable things like Desktop Icons, Minimize+Maximize and Top Icons? I don't think they take that into consideration when they make those statements. I don't even think they are able to measure that correctly.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/NightOfTheLivingHam Jan 12 '20

because the devs are arrogant and think end users are stupid.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/babulej Jan 12 '20

I think the main problem with Gnome is that it tries to be many things at once. According to this screenshot I found Gnome devs don't want to use menus, because they would be hard to use on a touchscreen. So instead of being an experience that's optimized for a typical mouse-and-keyboard usage, or being an experience optimized for a touchscreen, it's something in between. Not really optimized for either, but usable with both.

8

u/nintendiator2 Jan 13 '20

Not really optimized for either, but a mess with both.

FTFY

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I like gnome

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (56)

9

u/duffil Jan 12 '20

I sort of agree with your sentiment, in that you can install the tweak tool to get those minimize/maximize buttons, but they should be on by default.

19

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

or at least incorporate the GNOME tweaks app into GNOME settings.

That would be awesome.

I actually really like GNOME, but I always turn on the minimize and maximize buttons, as well as dash-to-dock. Those are essential for me. And they should be default options and not hidden away in a secondary app you have to install.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

As an i3-wm user there is nothing wrong with not being able to minimize windows.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

My only guess is they are designing it for touch screens, which are the quote unquote "future".

I mean if ARM processors actually take off some time in the future they will have been right. Its really their best chance of breaking Microsoft.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

Then it would come out of the box working on the Pi and it doesn't.

Not saying pi team should focus on making it the desktop, theirs works - but installing and running gnome 3 isn't a few clicks.

11

u/babulej Jan 12 '20

I don't really think touch screen computers will ever be the future. Constantly waving your hand in front of the screen can be tiring. Can you imagine, for example, working for 8 hours like that? It looks cool in sci-fi movies, but it would be horrible in real life.

Mobile devices have touchscreens not because it's such a great input method, but because they're meant to be used on the go, where you can't really use anything better, like a mouse and keyboard.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ikidd Jan 12 '20

So long-press works in Gnome?

→ More replies (6)

13

u/SutekhThrowingSuckIt Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

a few weeks

Did you though? Most of these complaints seem to conflict with that:

You can't minimize windows

Yes you can, the minimize button is off by default and hidden in tweaks which is stupid but you can still do it if you need to by right clicking and there’s a keyboard shortcut like everything else (Super+h for “hide” ). That said I notice that I don’t tend to ever minimize thigs anyway because workspaces are a better approach for my work flow and switching workspaces/focused windows is as easy as in the tiling wm I also use.

there is no right-click in the file browser; no copy or paste

These are just plain incorrect and I don’t know how you managed to think this.

The dash overview is clunky and overbearing.

This is subjective so I won’t argue but it’s a lot smoother with the fixed animations. I find it useful for seeing what I have open on each workspace. The focus on workspace integration like this is why I like the DE overall.

One has to add dozens of extensions just to get things to a workable state

Not at all. If you are running the DE with dozens of extensions that might explain the clunky and broken experience you are having.

I still like the classic desktops like Cinnamon which I also use and gnome is not for everyone since it’s different but this is mostly misinformation.

edit: to anyone reading this later /u/Linux4ever_Leo modified the comment a lot after I had responded but didn't note their edits

Anyway here's a screenshot from right now showing that the minimize option is there in a menu by default and there as a button when enabled: https://imgur.com/gDFQkLb

and here's a screenshot showing that the right menu to copy, cut, paste etc. is alive and well: https://imgur.com/qWDIaXC

13

u/BolognaTugboat Jan 12 '20

Min-max buttons should be on by default, not the other way around. It's little usability features like that which give people headaches after setting up PC's for non-technical users.

We can adjust these settings to get the OS we need -- but the default OS on a major distro like this should have usability of the average user in mind.

8

u/SutekhThrowingSuckIt Jan 12 '20

I agree that having the buttons off is not a sensible default. They should be on by default. However, the comment I responded to said that it was not possible to minimize at all. It was later edited.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DDFoster96 Jan 13 '20

after my MATE became corrupted

I'm sorry for your loss

4

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I use KDE on my main deskop and laptop. Gnome's the only DE that's usable on a tablet though - none of the others have simple things like proper font scaling for high res, screen autorotate, on screen keyboard, screen edge swiping etc as nicely integrated.

→ More replies (22)

15

u/NightOfTheLivingHam Jan 12 '20

what's annoying is when you call the gnome devs out on this shit, instead of defending their position they just shit on you for it. Bad enough gnome became its own operating system after Miguel De Icaza sent it that direction because he had a hard-on for microsoft.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

Exactly. And the worst part about that is that it shifts the discussion away from improving the product.

12

u/NightOfTheLivingHam Jan 12 '20

there's a reason KDE is slowly becoming the choice desktop for linux distros, why MATE exists, and why unity and other interfaces have spawned off gnome.

Gnome has a lot of sway because it's gtk 100%, and back in the 2000's when KDE looked ugly, its future was in question because of the QT opensource issue, and gnome was rolled into the freedesktop group, everyone built for GTK. (though tbh wxwindows would have been a better idea so apps wouldnt be ingrained in gnome)

Bothers me that the closest enterprise grade mail client for linux is evolution, which is ridiculously tied into gnome so much that you practically need to install the entire gnome environment to run it.

These devs know so much of what makes desktop linux is gnome, and that's why they disregard criticisms and user input for their own half-baked ideas of what people like.

It's sheer arrogance from the gnome devs.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

I just think it's really sad. Gnome could be so freaking good. Somehow they managed to get so close while still being so far from delivering a really good product.

I haven't followed KDE much but it seems that it is really making a lot of progress. It still looks overly cluttered but it's way better than what it used to be.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

27

u/LvS Jan 12 '20

What was so wrong with the File, Edit, View, etc. menu bars?

That depends on the application.

In the browser case, the stuff in the menu just isn't used, so it takes up screen space for no reason at all. I don't need part of my monitor to read "File Edit View" all the time.

In the office application case, there are just too many options and you never find them. The Gimp docs document over 250 different menu items, but that doesn't cover the large submenus (like all the filters). So I suppose it's reasonable easy to get to 1,000 menuitems. And finding the one thing you want in a nested tree with 1,000 items just doesn't work.

And last but not least, menus only show buttons - so if you want to show more complex UIs, you need to reorganize things. Which is precisely what's happening with hamburger menus, Gnome's popovers or the ribbon.

17

u/Maoschanz Jan 12 '20

That depends on the application.

Yes and you could have mentionned that these menus "standard" labels often don't make any sense in all contexts where the app isn't oriented towards files editing

8

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

What's the point of a HIG then? Just have a completely unique UI for each application.

The menubar is no ideal, but it does solve a UI problem for the general case. Other solutions are possible, but Gnome isn't interested in solving for the general case.

12

u/ImSoCabbage Jan 12 '20

Exactly, menus aren't simple, they're just things you know. It's obvious when you consider the request for "File, Edit..." when a large amount of applications have nothing to do with these things. What should Firefox place in there, or a terminal emulator? Or what about a text editor, should it just cram every feature it has inside the Edit menu?

I hated the ms office ribbon in 2007 till I tried using it. Then I realised how much simpler it was to find things I didn't know existed.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I thought so too, until I looked at the hamburger menus of Chrome and Firefox. I've never gotten used to navigating them.

2

u/Hrothen Jan 12 '20

In the browser case, the stuff in the menu just isn't used, so it takes up screen space for no reason at all.

Firefox just hides them, they're still there. The hamburger menu is actually taking up extra space.

1

u/h0twheels Jan 13 '20

heh, I use them in my browser all the time

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

What was so wrong with the File, Edit, View, etc. menu bars? I use Global Menus in KDE Plasma and it works great.

If you make the kinds of apps Gnome and Elementary does, you don't need a menubar. The problem is they never stop to think about the requirements of other applications, or what happens if someone wants to create something more sophisticated for Gnome.

Maybe if they had done that, they'd come up with a general replacement for the menubar that could suit simple and complex applications alike. But of course they don't recognize anything outside their little platform, so what their users end up with is a totally incoherent desktop where your recipes app follows the Gnome style but all the software you actually need totally violates it.

6

u/Barafu Jan 13 '20

The problem is they never stop to think about the requirements of other applications

GTK devs stated many times that they don't care whether other apps work or not. The problem is that other apps choose to use UI library that is by definition unsupported for them. If someone decides to use Motif in 2020, they will get many raised brows. But using GTK is OK and recommended despite that the situation is almost the same.

7

u/perkited Jan 12 '20

It appears hamburger menus are preferred by sausage finger users, which is all UX/UI devs seem to care about these days.

14

u/SutekhThrowingSuckIt Jan 12 '20

all this talk of hamburgers and sausages is making me hungry

hungry for coherent design

3

u/yetanother-1 Jan 12 '20

I would love to see a screenshot of your desktop with global menus, and maybe a link to how to set them up.

Thanks!

5

u/dreamer_ Jan 12 '20

What was wrong? Simple - Chrome removed them and started to claim superiority because of increased vertical space for webpages. And other browsers started to follow because USERS WOULDN'T SHUT UP ABOUT IT. It was requested over, and over, and over again. And tech press was giving it a boost by comparing "how much Chrome is better at managing screen space".

2

u/sonay Jan 30 '20

And other browsers started to follow because USERS WOULDN'T SHUT UP ABOUT IT.

And if that is not a good reason to go for it, what is?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Nobody is catching this part. Although people are reluctant to change habits (which is what this discussion is really about, "Gnome changed everything and I don't like it"), I will say that generic non-programmer users with low computer literacy like screen area. At least in the local set of like 5 people I have provided linux to.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/JanP3000 Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

How did you get the KDE Global Menu to display the application name and icon, like macOS?

I only see the other menus like File, Edit etc.

Edit: Thanks for all the answers. Since Active Window Control seems to be abandoned, I'm now using Window Title Applet and Window Buttons Applet alongside plasma's native Global Menu

2

u/LinuxFurryTranslator Jan 13 '20

Likely Latte Dock + applet-window-buttons + applet-window-title + applet-window-appmenu.

2

u/emilsedgh Jan 13 '20

There's a widget called _Active Window Control_ for that purpose.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jojo_la_truite2 Jan 13 '20

There also is :

But I do not use those last 2. I found latte dock to be buggy (slow to refresh) when switching workspace from an electron based app (so I stick with defaults panels), and the globalmenu plugin available by default also seemed to work better than the one I linked. (I use Kubuntu 18.04)

1

u/betam4x Jan 13 '20

I 'expect' the menu to be in the window that owns it. Note that KDE does this. The author of this article has clearly never used a modern version of KDE. With KDE you have the option of:

  • A hamburger menu

  • A menubar

  • A top level global menu bar ala OS-X.

You can easily set up the environment to use any of those options.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/chic_luke Jan 12 '20

The author makes a lot of good points, but I don't subscribe to the general tendency that appears in various places throughout the series of taking older versions of Mac and as a design gold standard and copying that on Linux.

  • For example, I am not convinced by the innate superiority of a dock + top bar with a global menu and system tray. I personally find that an utter waste of space, and purely an annoyance to users who don't pin their applications and always open them via they keyboard: for this kind of user, the taskbar paradigm saves space and it's generally better. i don't agree on the global menu being the best option universally either - it's without a doubt the best option if you have gone with a dock to try and reclaim some of the pixels you lost already, but it can get very confusing when you have a lot of windows open since you have to check if you are focusing the correct one before using the menu. It also makes the menu less reachable if you're using a windowed program. It's entirely up to debate whether it is a good idea or not.

  • I agree with the argument about hamburger menus wholeheartedly. No question. This is a mobile / touch computing paradigm that should have never seen the light of the day on traditional desktop systems. Cannot object.

25

u/Arnas_Z Jan 12 '20

I totally agree with you. I absolutely hate global menus and docks, they are such a useless waste of space. Im not against menu bars, but they should be in the app, not sitting at the top. Also the dock is just huge and also an eyesore. The only place I actually like having a hamburger menu is in my browser, since that way the top bar is smaller (and it's not like I really use the menu on browsers anyway)

4

u/chic_luke Jan 13 '20

The only place I actually like having a hamburger menu is in my browser, since that way the top bar is smaller

True that, I should have mentioned that exception..in browsers it allows to reclaim a lot of screen space, also because browsers are not traditional productivity-oriented products. But if I'm, like, using a text editor or a PDF viewer with an hamburger menu, I start to legitimately question where are the things I need to click on

9

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

Quite frankly, any normal person who cares about these things just hides the dock.

To me, macOS with a hidden dock is the sweet spot, I love the menu bar in the top panel (and I love KDE because it let me replicate this)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

But then how do you click a button at the bottom of a window without bringing up the dock? How do you fund stuff quickly when you can't even see the dock before moving your mouse? If you're going to hide the window switcher, why limit yourself to the dock UI at all?

6

u/Arnas_Z Jan 13 '20

You just listed the exact reasons why I don't use a dock. I find it inconvenient

4

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I think Gnome overview is definitely an advance in desktop interfaces. My only problem is that it's hard to tell windows and desktops apart without app icons and text labels (and maybe smart grouping). Definitely a solvable problem but Gnome doesn't seem to want to fix it since that would mean admitting their desktop design is less than perfect.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I just cmd-tab, much more convenient. The lack of a dock is one the things that Gnome 3 got right IMHO

5

u/Democrab Jan 13 '20

purely an annoyance to users who don't pin their applications and always open them via they keyboard

They're annoying to those of us who pin applications anyway. I prefer to keep my pinned applications off the main task bar unless I'm actually using them because if I'm say, modding Skyrim (Or anything else that involves a bunch of separate, open windows) and I've got umpteen windows open, I do not want shortcuts (uselessly) taking up that space. I'll just pin only the ones I have open nearly all the time on the taskbar (So...My web browser) and anything else I want on the start menu where I can easily hit the Windows key while moving the mouse over there. (Or just type the first few letters and hit enter if I've got both hands on the keyboard)

65

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

The criticism about the hamburger menu is spot on. The hamburger menu is a fad that plagues responsive web design that GNOME seems to have adopted since their design seems mobile (tablet) first oriented. Unfortunately, people cargo cult it because others do it (i.e, major frameworks like Bootstrap) even though many people agree that it's bad design.

39

u/Headpuncher Jan 12 '20

Hamburger menu is for small screens. The problem is when it used on for example firefox desktop browser. Why am i looking at a stupid little icon when I am on a 17" 2K screen?

Its original purpose was good, the purpose of hiding an actual menu behind an icon on screen sizes where the menu was over-large. Then it got used everywhere as a lazy fix-all for everything.

So it's not bad design when used as originally intended, but it has been abused horribly.

35

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

It is used for small screens yes, but that doesn't mean it's good design for small screens. See Are there alternatives to hamburger + drawer menus? for criticisms/alternatives to it.

7

u/Headpuncher Jan 12 '20

good link, thanks. Mobile design is still a train-wreck of competing styles and ideas. And in 2020 it seems to be getting worse. Especially on iOS.

24

u/LvS Jan 12 '20

Why would I want to waste my screen space with toolbars or menus that I rarely need?

I'd rather see the website I'm on.

6

u/progrethth Jan 13 '20

A solution i prefer is Firefox's press alt to display the menu. It is not very discoverable but I find it faster to navigate than the hamburger menu and it does not use any space.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/mcilrain Jan 12 '20

I prefer a menu bar in an IDE or image editor but a hamburger in a web browser.

It's all about using the right tool for the job, which is something you can't do if you use a global menu like the article proposes because now you have wasted space if you use anything else.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Democrab Jan 13 '20

I don't mind the hamburger menu for certain programs that simply don't need a huge amount of options and I hate the whitespace in modern UI design with a passion.

Some stuff should have it at least as an option (eg. I think something like Office should have the Ribbon and a Traditional style UI, because some people will always simply prefer one to the other) but there's a few cases where you see the typical menu with so few items in each part that it could easily just be the one, larger menu. Difference is that I want that extra space filled with more useful content and not just some whitespace or padding as it all too often is.

7

u/thunderbird32 Jan 12 '20

As others have said, it's possible that the hamburger menu is more intuitive for those who have grown up in Android/iOS land. My first OS was Windows 3.1 so that's not me, but I can imagine it being true.

4

u/FifteenthPen Jan 12 '20

It's perfectly intuitive to me and my first computer was an Apple IIe. I don't want my UI cluttered with crap I rarely if ever use, no matter how big my screen is. I've been wanting something like the hamburger menu for decades, and I'm happy it's here.

1

u/Vindve Jan 13 '20

Hamburger menu is not bad by itself. On Bootstrap documentation, every example of usage makes this menu appear only on smaller screens, with a responsive design, which is good.

32

u/linuxlover81 Jan 12 '20

simple? i do hate a global menu bar. with a passion. so.. which version should be implemented? the global bar is not the problem wit desktop usability

15

u/KugelKurt Jan 12 '20

i do hate a global menu bar. with a passion.

It's hard to like them when you ever used them on screens above 20 inch. At that point moving the cursor over that large distances is more trouble than just clicking on an in-window menu bar.

1

u/iindigo Jan 13 '20

I’m the exact opposite, finding more value in global menu bars on larger screens. Why? Because very few windows on a 27” 2560x1440 display are going to be maximized, and I don’t like chasing something as important as menus around the screen. With a global menu bar and my trackball on high sensitivity accessing a menu takes little more than a finger flick that’s been deeply encoded into muscle memory for years now.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/_ahrs Jan 12 '20

The Unity HUD. That thing was way ahead of its time even if it did require awful hacks to GTK to make it work right.

3

u/tsadecoy Jan 12 '20

Unity was really good. I kinda hope that in a few years maybe Canonical has the funds to pay for it to be developed properly.

1

u/Mordiken Jan 13 '20

Why do you say they where awful? GTK applications used to work wonderfully on Ubuntu with Unity, same as Qt applications. Hell, even Java applications worked flawlessly with Unity's Global Menu implementation!

Just because Gnome never accepted Canonical's GTK patches that enabled applications to work with a Global Menu, it doesn't mean the patches where bad... They worked flawlessly on Unity for years, after all.

2

u/_ahrs Jan 13 '20

My memories fuzzy but I'm pretty sure they messed with GTK internals a lot behind applications back which wasn't ideal. I'd love to see first class support for global menus and/or huds in GTK but sadly I doubt that'd ever happen (I'd be really happy if it did though). Right now global menus live on in MATE and KDE Plasma but they rely on a GTK plugin (plugins are going away in GTK 4 iirc so this is not sustainable) and don't work in Wayland.

22

u/mcilrain Jan 12 '20

Global menu bar doesn't work well on large monitors or multiple monitors, it takes up unnecessary space and requires the user to look around the screen more. It's great for small, single-monitor, non-touchscreen setups but this is no longer ubiquitous.

2

u/vahtos Jan 13 '20

I have two 27" monitors and the global menu bar on KDE works great. You just don't repeat it across monitors as it isn't necessary to do so. I know my menu is always at the top left of my left monitor. I can move my mouse there blindfolded, and quickly peruse the menu.

The global menu bar works just fine.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

The monitors have to be really big and your mouse has to be really slow. And you can't reach the global menu, how are you going to reach a tiny hamburger that's not even in the fitts area?

Global menu doesn't take up any space if you already have a panel at the top, like Gnome does.

I agree that a global menubar isn't ideal. I'd prefer a "Menu" button in each application, that when pressed would bring up a searchable and clickable command/tool palette, a single compact entry-point from which to explore the functionality of the entire application.

A locally integrated menu in the titlebar is also a solution, Unity already did it.

But given the choice between a global menu and a traditional client-side one, I definitely prefer global.

> It's great for small, single-monitor

It's possible to have separate menubars per monitor. Latte dock already does this on KDE.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I came to linux from mac so the global menu bar is home and, to me, task bars are an abomination.

The KDE Plasma global menu widget is a fair solution, but you have to know to add a spacer correctly to get menus to left justify and the tray to right justify. It doesn't handle the desktop focus like mac, so if you click the desktop the current app looses focus but it's menu remains, and if you switch to a new workspace that doesn't have an open app to take focus, you have a menu bar from an app on a previous workspace.

Anyway, I think this author was reaching a bit with some of his justifications but he raises some good points. Drop down menus are utilitarian, but appliance-style UIs abstract too much and function too little.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I say search bar everything. Have one in focus at the top of every context menu. Use it to filter options in said context menu. How you would set that up though, in regards to meta data, I don't know. But if properly standardized you could potentially get to any screen with just a search in your favourite launcher (plasma is sort of getting there with krunner... but eh). Here's looking at XDG.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

That kind of search would be nice, but it only helps if you know what kind of operations you want to do. When i was first learning computer programs, i didn't yet know the kinds of things I could do, but the menus gave me some idea.

It kinda makes me think we need to have a separate concepts introduction for folks rather than make every program carry the same baggage.

4

u/PegasusIsWeird Jan 12 '20

Interesting article. I have never used global menus and am always confused by the Mac os in the rare cases that I use it. Maybe I should give it a try on my plasma workspace but why exactly is the concept superior to per window menues? With global menues you have an issue with focus on multi head systems, haven't you? Which can make it confusing.

Agreed on the discoverability and some of the other critique in the article.

39

u/galgalesh Jan 12 '20

The series contains some good criticism like the keyboard layout settings and the autohiding dock.

However, I think the author is completely wrong about the File/Edit/.. menu's. I think the reason why people like this is not because it's a good design but simply because it's what you are used to. Any interface that you've used for 20+ years will be ingrained in you. However, the goal of moving away from these menus is to optimise for the people who have not been using computers for 20 years.

Time and time again, I see that the ribbon interface is a lot easier for people who are less familiar with computers. User research shows it helps people discover features and remember the location of features better. Moreover, some research suggests that even very experienced users work more efficient with a well-designed ribbon interface.

I think it's unfortunate that the series starts with an eulogy of the File/.. menu because it gives the impression that this is another "you should make X perfect for ME!", even though the rest of the series is better than that.

32

u/HighStakesThumbWar Jan 12 '20

User research shows

Serious question: Where can I find such research? Are there any RCTs to speak of?

32

u/galgalesh Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

Good question!

  • Microsoft themselves did research about the Office UI/UX during the development of the ribbon interface. source (@20 mins and 51 minutes he specifically talks about the research)

  • "First, the users profit from easiness and memorizability of the ribbon interface. On the other hand, some users have of course doubts when it comes to fundamental changes in UX." source

  • "further analysis showed that the RUI is received quite well by users, except experienced and frequent users of word processing applications with a classical WIMP interface." source

  • Ribbon UI efficiency based on number of clicks required to execute a certain task. This also compares different iterations of the ribbon UI. source

  • A study showing no statistical difference between time needed to do something in ribbon vs non-ribbon office. This is interesting because all participants were familiar with non-ribbon office, but only a few of them had used the ribbon before. source

  • More studies done by Microsoft themselves source

6

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
  • Ribbon UI efficiency based on number of clicks required to execute a certain task. This also compares different iterations of the ribbon UI. source

Number of clicks are a terrible metric to determine the efficiency of an UI. By that logic the most efficient UI would be a wall of buttons covering each and every possible action of the application. Then you can do everything in just one click which is as good as it gets and more than twice as "efficient" than any of the ribbon UIs tested in your link.

8

u/v6ak Jan 12 '20

I partially agree. All metrics are imperfect. Virtually any metric becomes useless when people try to focus only on that metric, as it leads to situations like the one you have mentioned. However, metrics can show you some insights. Needing less clicks for an operation is good property on its own. It does not mean there is nothing bad about Ribbon. There are probably both good and bad properties of Ribbon (number of clicks for some operations is one of them), and the final vertict depends on all of them…

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

It IS "you should make X perfect for me".

Which is fine. He doesn't claim to know UX or design or be the King of UX or anything, he have found links and quotes that back up his claims - but he is basically writing things down. These are the writers preferences, whether you agree with them or not is another matter (I agree with some, I think others are sort of just odd...).

8

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I actually doubt that visually parsing a two dimensional grid of items of varying sizes (the layout of almost all ribbon UIs) is more effective than a one dimensional list or 2d grid of uniform items. Do you have links to papers that show that such UIs are more efficient?

14

u/galgalesh Jan 12 '20

See my reply to the other comment for research around the ribbon UI specifically.

In almost all cases, people perceive pictures quicker than words. Although the research on the ribbon UI also showed that the best combination was actually icons + words. Users used the icons to find the right button and used the word to get confirmation that this was the correct button.

As for the size, this is based on how much a button is used. Our brain attention gets drawn to the big things first, which is good in this UI because those are the most common functions.

Moreover, since the UI is tabbed and automatically shows you the tab related to what you're doing, the interface actually hides a lot of the stuff that's not relevant to the user; giving you less stuff to parse.

5

u/TopdeckIsSkill Jan 13 '20

I'm young, when I started to use office MSO 2007 was already out. At that time I hated Open Office (or MS2003) because I couldn't find any option, while on MSO 2007 I could find everything easily. Big icons divided in simple groups was the reason.

Recently I had to use LO for nearly two years, until a few months ago I got fed up and went for MSO 2019. Even after two years I couldn't get used to the old menu style. Simply put: what on MSO took me 1 second to find, on LO took 10.

8

u/YTP_Mama_Luigi Jan 13 '20

Yep, that's what a lot of people seem to miss.

For simple programs, the traditional "file, edit..." menu works well. But when your "simple" Edit menu has 30+ items, you end up spending far too much time just picking out the one you need.

Same thing goes for toolbar buttons and the like.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/iindigo Jan 13 '20

The variable size thing is what bothers me the most about ribbons. I know it’s trying to optimize for most used functions, but half the time what The things they choose to enlarge are things I never touch (or use keyboard shortcuts for).

If it were a simple/dumb tabbed toolbar with uniform button sizes and niche functions weeded out it’d be much better.

1

u/aziztcf Jan 15 '20 edited Jan 15 '20

Why on earth would I ever want to switch to a “wrong” (that is, non-matching) keyboard language?

Terminal usage, coding and other use cases where you need a lot of special characters are always designed around enUS layout. I don't want to reach for three different keys just to find a char that's not easily available in my native layout.

I also don't get the audio volume issue he's having. Scroll on volume icon to change master volume. Routing apps to diffent devices takes only a few clicks, all from the pulsewidget

E: >We should agree on a filesystem hierarchy that humans can understand intuitively. GoboLinux is leading here.

Now this is an idea I like.

1

u/RedSquirrelFtw Jan 13 '20

If everyone is used to a certain way and that certain way works, then why change it? Steering wheels are so old school maybe we need to change them to a rotary encoder since it takes up less space on the dash of a car! I hate when they make UI changes just for sake of it. Ms started all this by wanting to get rid of the start menu in Windows 8, or messing around with the menus in Office (which I STILL hate). Stop changing stuff that works!

→ More replies (11)

9

u/aksdb Jan 12 '20

For me personally the worst thing is constant "change", that Microsoft introduced around Office 2000 and "perfected" with the ribbons that change depending on context.

The old school menus where more or less static. Parts may have been disabled (or in the worst case hidden), but usually they were static. So once I half-way remember a click-path I can pretty easily find a functionality. I only need to know that it was "roughly around here" and can spot it.

With ribbons however, depending on if I'm inside a table, or an image, or a paragraph or whatever some items show up bigger or smaller, in different locations, etc. So it gets incredibly hard for me to remember where functions are that I don't need regularly, where I usually just remember vague hints. Since this does not work due to the seemingly random nature, I often have to click through layers of ribbons (since there are also very small drop downs in some of them) until I finally find what I was looking for. Horrible.

One of the best UX achievements - IMHO - was Sublime Text's (I think that was the first to implement it on a broader scale?) Command Palette, that is now also part of Atom, VS Code, IntelliJ (kinda) etc. Searching for stuff with a quick hotkey is just amazing.

But still ... to discover functionality in a "new program", a well structured menu is still the best start IMHO. My perfect world would consist of optional structured menus (that can be hidden) combined with a command palette.

6

u/Jeven_ Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

The command pallet is the pinnacle for me. It provides instant visual feedback, while presenting an opportunity to on board specific hot keys. The implementation needs to be robust though so that "view", "zoom", etc, for example, both list the options for adjusting text size.

I agree though, static menu + command pallet + listed individual hot keys in both would be ideal.

Edit: Like all good Redditers I commented before reading the article, but Plotinus looks really cool.

3

u/masteryod Jan 12 '20

One of the best UX achievements - IMHO - was Sublime Text's (I think that was the first to implement it on a broader scale?) Command Palette

This kind of command search is nothing new. I remember using it in Blender 2.5 10 years ago.

3

u/U5efull Jan 13 '20

every part where he talks about the UI regression in gnome I agree with. I don't get it. Why does everyone want to remove the simplest of functionality? it confuses everyone who is new

3

u/captainofallthings Jan 13 '20

I hard disagree about much of what was said about "global menus". While the stuff about flipping through them is nice, the ribbon menus give much more space, which lets you include things like images. I really like ribbon menus because of this, makes it easier to get a feel for a new program.

Hamburger menus are pretty terrible, though.

10

u/svelle Jan 12 '20

Why is he so mad about the missing copy and paste entries in the menus? Does he not know he can right click inside of windows to copy and paste content?

6

u/WickedFlick Jan 12 '20

I believe his main complaint for them not being in the hamburger menu is that it means discoverability of the keyboard shortcuts for those commands is diminished or eliminated.

I haven't used gnome in a long time, so I'm not sure if the right-click menu has the keyboard shotcuts listed next to the command.

15

u/mcilrain Jan 12 '20

Given the strong Mac bias he's probably never seen a mouse with more than one button.

11

u/EternityForest Jan 12 '20

That's one of the worst things Mac has done to computing...

→ More replies (2)

4

u/YourBobsUncle Jan 13 '20

Judging on all the screenshots he uses, he probably hasn't even used a Mac since 2004. Why does he care so much about what Apple does?

3

u/svelle Jan 12 '20

WHY ISN'T THERE A GLOBAL MENU BAR????

5

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I think I have never ever used the Copy / Paste options from within a menu. This article doesn't really speak to me, tbh.

1

u/Brillegeit Jan 13 '20

My mom is super nervous about right and left mouse button (she's only had a computer for a few years), but she's a pro about the Edit menu, select all, copy, paste etc. For a right click paste the additional information is that you need to right click on the context of the cursor, so if you're one of those that move the cursor "out of the way" while typing they have to ensure they move it back to the edit context before right clicking. For these people the edit button is consistent and great.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/babulej Jan 12 '20

That was a good article, I think it made me appreciate good menu bars more. Since I'm using KDE Plasma, I think I'll try enabling a global menu bar to see what happens, and how many apps work well with it.

13

u/klesus Jan 12 '20

There are some good points he brings up, but the obvious bias makes him less credible as an experienced UX designer. Like, saying that ribbon menus are a big step backwards, basically only because he has more difficulty finding things, without mentioning anything positive about ribbons at all. Or making blanket statements that every desktop app should have traditional menu bars. One can only infer why he'd think that, but there is little to no actual reasoning why traditional menu bars are better because he makes no attempt to do a fair comparison to the alternatives. The negative examples stops at being just that, and he seems unable to see any reason for why such UX designs were introduced. So if he can't see any point in alternative designs, then it doesn't seem like he knows shit.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Like, saying that ribbon menus are a big step backwards, basically only because he has more difficulty finding things

Which is the entire point of the ribbon [in Office]. The ribbon was designed to bring the most-used functionality forth. Office, if you can remember to Office 2003 and prior (especially Word and Excel) was a terrible mess of menus and submenus and Advanced... to get even more options.

The applications had so many capabilities and features that the traditional menu system was no longer workable.

4

u/TopdeckIsSkill Jan 13 '20

You don't have to remember how bad MSO2003 was: LO still use classic menu and their new "ribbon" is still a mess.

2

u/Niarbeht Jan 12 '20

If there's one thing that I like about ribbon menus it's that you can switch between applications, and as long as the glyphs/icons/whatever are similar, you can figure things out, instead of spending ten goddamn minutes looking through menus just to resort to Google.

11

u/plawwell Jan 12 '20

Hacking the GUI is what you do when you've run out of other ideas. The Mac is lucky in that it has a global menubar so you will always see sane menus as you expect them. It's a crap shoot in Windows 10 but some apps show a menu bar when you hit the alt key. It's really terrible to try to force paradigms from tablets for finger pointing onto computers with mouse pointers.

As for the Ribbon effect, that's just so wrong and should die immediately.

4

u/Headpuncher Jan 12 '20

Right, I thought the ribbons in MS Office where the Nr1 reason people hated MS office. Give me a menu bar, please.

2

u/iindigo Jan 13 '20

That’s one of the things I love about macOS: the menu bar is always there no matter what, which reduces dev impulses to squirrel everything away in a stupid hamburger menu. It also means that each app’s menus are standardized, making them searchable, scriptable, and compatible with the system’s universal shortcut control panel.

1

u/plawwell Jan 13 '20

Although you can hide it.

9

u/fear_the_future Jan 12 '20

I had to stop reading after the stupid comment about hamburger menus in browsers, with the fucking Wikipedia article for fitt's law opened, which the author obviously doesn't understand. Hamburger menu is exactly the right choice for browsers: When do you ever need anything from that menu? When does anyone ever access the "about" menu? Exiling those menu items to the hamburger menu in order to maximize screen space is obviously the right choice. If you add a traditional menu bar above the tabs then you make it significantly slower to change tabs with the mouse due to Fitt's law, for no apparent benefit.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

It's mind-boggling to me that so many distros are shipping with GNOME by default despite its glaring flaws. I know many people who've been turned off of Linux immediately because of the bad default UX they run into with major distros like Ubuntu

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

The biggest thing I like about GNOME is the "overview" menu that you get when pressing SUPER. It is really useful when using full screen applications like video games.

In windows it was always annoying to switch out of full screen games. the delay took so long. In GNOME is is speedy.

Also I dont think I care about the minimize button espeically with this overview menu,

2

u/RedSquirrelFtw Jan 13 '20

Yeah I hate that Gnome is often default, even if you can get the KDE version, when trying to google for stuff because you're having a problem or whatever, half the time it's assuming you are using the "standard" version. That and the other versions are usually an after thought so you're more likely to run into weird issues like certain apps that don't play nice or whatever.

1

u/HCrikki Jan 14 '20

Many popular apps are developped against Gnome or GTK libraries, so unless you want your install to download half gnome the simplest solution is to make gnome your default desktop. It was a huge issue with KDE before they decoupled many of their apps to be rebased on QT libs instead.

5

u/Vorthas Jan 12 '20

I honestly agree with the vast majority of his points, especially the decline of the standard Menu bar and the rise of Ribbon interfaces and Hamburger buttons. These are DESKTOPS not mobile phones/tablets we're using after all.

Honestly he touches on the very reasons why I prefer to use XFCE over GNOME or even KDE (though KDE is my second choice after XFCE): XFCE at least preserves a lot of the traditional desktop design choices. GNOME does away with them entirely.

2

u/xzer Jan 13 '20

While i've been enjoying Gnome... I don't disagree.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

clap

I love Linux, but not the desktop; in my wanting to be efficient with my time, I stick to the more conventional UX stuff. I'm tired of having to deal with backend stuff just so I can watch a movie or edit a file, or manage my files. Keeping it simple and intuitive doesn't mean hide stuff behind obscure terminology and UI. Makes the UX horrid.

2

u/gustoreddit51 Jan 13 '20

I think this is one reason why a lot of people migrated from Ubuntu Unity to Linux Mint (cinnamon & mate). For many, like myself, Ubuntu was fixing/redesigning something that people were familiar with that didn't need it for desktop users. Many liked it but for me, I just wanted to continue in a GUI environment I was familiar with.

2

u/ragnese Jan 13 '20

I find this amusing:

Why is there this unsettling tendency to kill the beloved “File, Edit,…” menus that also date back to the Lisa user interface design and have been engraved into our brain muscles for the last 40 years?

And then...

After the initial publication of this article, I was shocked to find out that the Xerox Star had the hamburger menu in 1981 (before the Lisa and the Macintosh) [...] So, essentially Firefox, GNOME 3 & Co. have thrown out the Lisa/Macintosh improvements to the GUI and have reverted to the Xerox GUI from 1981.

So, first, we're supposed to think menu bars are great because they're really old. But then we find out that the "horrible" hamburger menu is actually even older! But now older isn't better all of a sudden because it argues against my conclusion!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Thoroughly enjoyed the series. This shows us how much developers need to learn about UX and the impact that has in our apps.

2

u/malucious81 Jan 14 '20

I've seen this article before. It has good points but at the end of the day it comes down to the individual. For me a perfect DE would contain elements from the gnome,xfce, and maybe something tiling. Individually they all have shortcomings IMO. I use gnome mostly because it's good enough, and works best on my distro of choice. Is it a little weird? Yes. But I find it fun.

4

u/lproven Jan 12 '20

It's a good piece -- you'll see a left a length comment in it, back in July.

Sadly, while GNOME 2 was the desktop that lured me into Ubuntu in 2004, GNOME 3 is, IMHO, an incoherent mess and it is driving me away again.

Currently, in my Linux-centric $DAYJOB, I use Xfce. It's the only modern desktop I really like, although Deepin looks promising.

4

u/osugisakae Jan 12 '20

Only read part one so far, but I agree with most of what the author says. A few thoughts:

I believe he is talking specifically about Desktop Environments, so not about window managers such as fluxbox and i3. Desktop environments are expected to be consistent, well thought out, and good for new users. If you are using Fluxbox, I think it is fair to assume you know how to deal with config files and read man pages. KDE and Gnome should not make these assumptions about their users.

I mention this because a lot of the criticisms in part 1 were about things that DEs did poorly - things that they should do well. Discoverability is important in DEs. Recent Gnome DEs have been disappointing. Does anyone really think that copy and paste should be missing from the application menus? Or that having the keyboard shortcuts in the menu is a bad thing? I recently booted into a default Gnome environment (Ubuntu live CD, iirc), and was shocked at how hard it was to figure out how to do anything. Opened a menu and found only like 3 items? What? Where is everything?

Similarly, phone UX should not be shoehorned into desktop software. One button to open a big menu makes sense on a small screen. It doesn't make sense on a desktop or even laptop computer. How is it better?

In the end, I think that is the question to be asking - how is the new way better? Different just to be "newer" is not better. As the article mentions, there is decades of research on computer interface usability and the such, and recent changes seem to pretty much go against time-tested, research-based best practices.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

Designs and aesthetic preferences change over time. I think there are some valid criticisms, but I think this is a lot of someone who doesn't like current design trends.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Gnome devs have left the chat

5

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I would leave the chat too if it only contained angry nerds insulting me and my intelligence for the volunteer work that I do.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Most of the comments aren't blind anger nor insulting.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Someone [at GNOME] needs to be fired lul

They [GNOME] seem like the kind of project where they do UX testing once a year and call it a day.

Unfortunately the GNOME devs would rather stick to poor design decisions.

Sometimes they outright insult users upon feedback but the worst part is that they don't even value it. No matter who that feedback comes from. No matter how it is given.

That is never the case with GNOME. They are always saying "well you're using it wrong" or some rude variation thereof.

/u/johnlarshorde

Do some reflection dude. You have >10 comments in this thread shitting on GNOME. And the only argument you repeatedly bring up is that GNOME devs don't listen to you.

But they don't just not listen to you because of your vitriol. They don't listen to you because you're wrong. I'm going to make a couple of assertions:

  • You don't have an account on GNOME's bug tracker.

  • You have never done UX design for a wide non-technical target audience.

  • You have no idea how to solve GNOME's problems other than repeating the mantras of "CSD bad", "negative space bad", "menu bar good", "hamburger bad", "removal of features bad", and so forth.

  • When you make any design suggestion, you never once think about any use case for people with a disability, people who don't speak English, or people who aren't all that good with computers.

  • Of all the options and features that GNOME has removed, no more than one or two of those removals actually affect you negatively other than making you adopt a different workflow.

  • You consider Word 2003 the pinnacle of good design and hate the ribbon interface.

  • You probably use some weird obscure Arch+i3 (or whatever) setup that requires a lot of configuration that no layperson could ever use, or would ever want to use.

  • In your response to this message, you're going to nitpick all the assertions that I got wrong, and ignore the grander scope: GNOME devs are tired as fuck of vitriolic nerds who think they know better than them.

GNOME has the following design principles: Focus, minimal complexity, prioritisation of content, minimal interruptions, and prioritisation of good defaults over extensive configuration.. That list fails to mention it, but accessibility tops those priorities. And for what it attempts to be, GNOME is excellent.

Obviously, if you disagree with the stated design principles, don't use GNOME?

2

u/rahen Jan 13 '20

Unfortunately your post is at the bottom of this topic. It should be at the top.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20 edited Jan 14 '20

First of all, I thought a lot about your comment and this is going to be a long comment but I promise you that it's not random trolling or meant to piss you off. You might even take some of it and have a laugh about me with your colleagues.

Second of all, if the GNOME team thinks everyone that writes a comment is a vitriolic nerd that needs to be ignored, then my opinion is that they have a lot to learn. The first lesson being: If someone criticises your product it doesn't mean they criticise you, personally, as a dev. It does not surprise me that you put it in those words, though, because I see it happen all the time. Those, that you call vitriolic nerds, are actually the users of your product (surprise). What you guys don't seem to understand, is that these people actually want GNOME to be good just as much as the GNOME team (I assume) wants it to be. They aren't looking to pick a fight or to complain. There might be angertards in this community, and I can certainly point to a few in the comments, but that doesn't mean that every single comment that doesn't praise GNOME is one. In my view, it's a minority. I would even go as far as saying that some of the GNOME representatives, here, are a touch too vitriolic themselves. Don't you think there might be a reason that the GNOME team is constantly criticised for its arrogance?

Also, might I just point out that my position, in this comment section, has been that I find it paradoxical that the GNOME team is constantly reacting negatively to anyone who writes about their negative experiences with using GNOME? I also never said that GNOME sucks or that it's unusable. If GNOME wants to build a product that people want to use, then why don't they take these negative experiences seriously? These are the same users that want to be used as a resource to make the desktop better. I cannot, for the life of me, understand why that is not regarded as some kind of opportunity in one form or another. It happens, very often, that a user wants to reach out to the GNOME team and more often than not, that user is regarded as a "vitriloic nerd", as you put it.

Third of all. You completely missed the target about me.

Currently on my bookshelf, I have a wide array of books related to human computer interaction, experimental systems development, pervasive/ubiquitus computing, shape changing interfaces, graphical user interfaces, physical computing, interactive design, participatory design, physical design, contextual design, ideation, design processes, prototyping, rapid prototyping, IT-product development, compendiums about designing IT-systems for human interaction and interviews, in print, of designers who were a part of creating digital products that are recognizable in, and shaped, our daily lives.

I have spent hours and hours working with designing applications and even slept in HCI design labs filled with various electronics, laser cutters, 3d printers, cardboard, arduino kits, raspberry pi's, pink and blue foam, soldering irons, post it notes, glue and you name it.

I actually could have several ideas for what the GNOME team can do to solve its problems. Nobody can tell GNOME to just put whatever button here and give the desktop X functionality and it'll be done. Designing software is a continuous process that requires a lot of back and forth just to identify the problems alone. Coming up with solutions is the same story. Once you have an idea for a solution you still need to evaluate if it actually is received and used by the user as intended by the designer. This is exactly where I suspect that the GNOME team could better themselves dramatically, by the way. I also know that the cases where good ideas appear by happenstance or occur as a random shower thoughts are incredibly rare and that it's a stupid bet to count on it. It is a creative, iterative, and, in my opinion, a somewhat social process to arrive at a good idea. I am very well aware that it's a long road to go from initial idea to a final product. I know that the final product most likely wont ever arrive.

Nonetheless, that process involves the user and not just as an afterthought.

When I have made design suggestions, hell... when anyone makes design suggestions, it's part of a quite comprehensive process of generating ideas that involves a lot of participants, post-its, white boards, prototypes - even when designing graphical interfaces. Nobody can reliably go solo trying to come up with an idea on his own. That's also why it's a red herring to suggest that the commenters should "jUsT cOmE uP wItH tHeIr OwN iDeAs iF tHeY hAvE sO mUcH tO sAy". In my opinion that's a huge dick move from the GNOME team because you're giving them no choice but to fuck right off.

Lastly, I actually do have an account on bugzilla. I actually follow GNOME quite closely and have been doing so for a very long time. I even remember when GNOME went from the ugly close-window-button to the pretty one - whenever that was (around 3.10 ?). That is quite a lot of years and I was already following the development for quite a while back then. I also don't really think the ribbon interface sucks. I don't a strong opinion about it actually, but it looks nice and I suppose it has very good discoverability. I use several machines but my daily driver, at home, is stock Ubuntu 19.10 with the Dash-to-Panel extension. That is my only linux machine.

Honestly, I have to say that I do stand by what I wrote in my comments. I do think that GNOME has made some poor design decisions but it's nothing that can't be solved. I just think it's a huge shame that the GNOME team regards their users as "vitriolic" nerds whose input is worthless. Because it isn't. In my view it's a gold mine.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/not-enough-failures Jan 12 '20

This post contains screenshots from ancient versions of software, and reads like a Mac circlejerk central. If you cannot fathom how to copy/paste something because there isn't a COPY and PASTE button in the title bar, you're just incompetent. If you cannot comprehend why people want multiple volume sliders or multiple keyboard layouts, then you're just ingrained in the Apple "you're holding it wrong" philosophy, which Linux is not about.

It's ridiculous that the kind of people who whine about new design trends want every single function to be present in a bloated Win98-like interface. Are you not tech savvy enough to remember a keyboard shortcut ?

GNOME is meant to be used with keyboard shortcuts, that's why everything is hidden away. If you don't like that, install Windows 10.

-1

u/Nnarol Jan 12 '20

GNOME is not meant to be used with keyboard shortcuts, it's meant to be used while tripping. It has exactly the same Mac-like mentality you described. You don't like it? Well, you just can't comprehend our awesome sense of design!

→ More replies (6)

2

u/natermer Jan 12 '20 edited Aug 16 '22

...

1

u/pagwin Jan 12 '20

Who on earth wakes up one morning and says, let me see what happens if I press “/” in a Linux application?

me(but that was because of regexs)... I did it in vim and was pleasantly surprised to find myself searching through text lol but I get the point

1

u/d3pd Jan 13 '20

Would have been nice if people actually supported Unity, because its ergonomics are still some of the best and most respectful of decades of research. Menu search functionality. Search text in all windows at once. Switch between global menus and window menus as you please. Efficient use of space by merging window title bars as needed. And window buttons at the top corners of the displays to avoid fiddly clicking by mouse.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

I have always been excited to try new operating systems (and thus distros with different DEs too) because of its looks.

However, I don't think it's GNOME's madness to optimize their GUI for smartphone orientated users or the dislike from Xfce and WM users to adopt new style user interactions.

What the Linux desktop overall is lacking is a smarter use of design element rules and adoption of how to treat software.

Like when I run a gtk program in Plasma devs shouldn't expect me to adopt the GNOME shortcut layout but rather make their software adopt my preferences. Same with the way of how global menubars are treated by especially third party software i.E. Firefox, Chrome, Discord or Spotify.

What works somewhat good already is client side decoration but it still depends on the user to optimize looks for different toolkits to make things actually feel native.

If those issues are ever going to be solved with software written in qt, gtk and in something like Electron, the desktop experience should work a lot better.

Especially since there are by now actually different favor of UX.

1

u/perplexedm Jan 13 '20

Lumina desktop is written in qt? Looks fine.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Wasn't that exclusive to some BSD? At least for a while?

Because it fell under my radar.

2

u/perplexedm Jan 13 '20

Debian, Gentoo, Arch, are listed on their home page.

Fedora used to support earlier, don't know now.

qt5/c++, very low memory footprint, interesting.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20

Now that you say it, there are Debian (probably Ubuntu deb as well) packages listed but I can't find anything in the official repos for either Stable, Testing, backports, Ubuntu LTS or 19.10.

It'd be indeed interesting to test that environement on some of my older and thus weaker PCs, one being an Atom machine from 2010 and the other being the X60t.

1

u/Lawnmover_Man Jan 13 '20

“hamburger menus” may be a suitable compromise for crammed mobile phones but not for today’s desktop systems with Full HD or 4K screens.

Resolution is not a solution for this problem. It's not like 4K screens are 4 times bigger.

1

u/betam4x Jan 13 '20

TIL GNOME has usability problems, but KDE does not.

1

u/NOOBMASTER Jan 13 '20

AFAIK you can use mousewheel to quickly scroll through the ribbon menus, and even the open tabs in your browser (just hold mouse pointer on a tab + scroll mouse3).

1

u/ManinaPanina Jan 14 '20

I prefer "Logical" and "Organized" than "Simple" and it's sacrifices.

And these people love to talk about Apple OSes, but the few times I got to use them it was an "experience"... an traumatic one. I'll never forget that one time at work (it was free time) with an iPad Mini, it gave me arrhythmia.

1

u/EasyMrB Jan 13 '20

This post is So. Damn. Good.

I am so sick of "UI Innovations" that make things cramped, unusable, and difficult to discover.

UI designers have been idiots since everyone decided to pick up the Microsoft Ribbon. It's disgusting.

1

u/ShlomiRex Jan 12 '20

If you follow the Windows look and feel it would solve most of the problems

1

u/pagwin Jan 13 '20

from part 4

I really couldn’t believe that this was the end of it, so I cheated a bit and entered on the Terminal:

sudo apt-get update

this doesn't update packages this just updates what apt will look for when trying to install or upgrade packages

0

u/balr Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

I really have no problem with "hamburger menus" at all, so long as there is no dumbing down of the general interface (which Gnome3 and ElementaryOS are blatanlty doing these days).

Global menu is a bad idea, since many people do not use a full desktop environment like KDE, XFCE, Cinnnamon etc. Usually there is no global menu in tiling window manager alone like i3, Awesome, dwm. So for those who prefer to use a window manager only, this will not work.

0

u/bobbyfiend Jan 13 '20

The world: Hey, this works! I like it!

Profit-driven industry: We must distinguish our new product!

The world: We don't need this.

Profit-driven industry: Then we will make you need it.

-3

u/BoutTreeFittee Jan 12 '20

YES YES YES hell yes. I almost down-voted this on its title alone, then realized what it was really about.

So, essentially Firefox, GNOME 3 & Co. have thrown out the Lisa/Macintosh improvements to the GUI and have reverted to the Xerox GUI from 1981.

lol amen, preach on. So much goodness in this article.

XFCE gets the basics right — using menus and menu shortcuts. I would never have expected this to become something that needs to be specifically mentioned, but the GNOME example above shows that apparently we can’t take the basics for granted anymore

Of course MS and Apple have headed down that road too, although sometimes backtracking. There are unfortunately a lot of people (most people?) that want interfaces that slow them down to a crawl, making them much less productive. Seems like most of the younger crowd prefers this. They want the interface to be constantly obscured, overly visually simple, overly-layered, most useful functions hidden, slowing them down. What once took two clicks now takes four, and it took you a lot longer to ever find what you were looking for to begin with.

1

u/moonbatlord Jan 13 '20 edited Jan 13 '20

Much of that instinct comes out of fear — the ribbon was invented because people were afraid to make choices that might be wrong, and UI designers had to come up with something that might entice users to try more than the simplest actions. They can do the same thing (make a wrong choice) from the ribbon, of course, but it feels different, since they're clicking on an icon instead of making a menu choice that will do who knows what? It's pretty sad.

-1

u/Y1ff Jan 13 '20

I think this dude is just a Mac fan.

Not that there's anything wrong with that sort of design. It's just not for me. I like the Windows 9x desktop layout, honestly. That's why I'm using KDE currently :)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

My Plasma layout is actually a mix of Win10, Unity and macOS looks, so I like to say I love the customization aspect of it.

It's not to deny however that initial impressions matter the most and that's something the Linux desktop is still a little wonky with.