Alternative To The "200 Lines Kernel Patch That Does Wonders" Which You Can Use Right Away
http://www.webupd8.org/2010/11/alternative-to-200-lines-kernel-patch.html28
Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
Can someone explain the idea behind this? What exactly do those commands do to make the system snappier?
10
u/f0nd004u Nov 18 '10
Please, someone correct me if I'm wrong, but from what I understand this patch is telling the kernel to multitask by splitting up tasks into different groups by TTY. This is supposed to make desktop computing snappier in real-time.
15
u/Timmmmbob Nov 18 '10
But I still don't understand how this would work. Aren't all desktop apps part of the same TTY?
Edit: If I understand the article correctly, the tasks get set in your .bashrc, so if you never open a terminal this will have no effect.
It seems to be a "make Linus's desktop faster" patch, rather than "make everyone's desktop faster", because he does a lot of compiling stuff from the command line.
9
u/placatedmayhem Nov 18 '10
If I understand the article correctly, the tasks get set in your .bashrc, so if you never open a terminal this will have no effect.
You are partially correct.
The file /etc/gdm/Xsession is run immediately after you authenticate at the GDM prompt to set up your environment.
At the top of the Xsession file, your ~/.profile is sourced if it exists.
With the default .profile (the same as the one at /etc/skel/.profile), .bashrc gets sourced from there as well.
So, through some roundabout jumps, yes, your .bashrc does in fact get sourced so the cgroup does get set up for the graphical login session. Honestly, relying on a user's dotfiles for a system-wide policy isn't exactly ideal, but I digress.
Now, it is quite a different topic of whether it helps end users. For my workstation at work, where I run a handful of KVM virtual machines in the background all the time, cgroups help a lot. They will also help a very finite amount for the average joe user that has a bunch of processes that they don't necessarily know about but might occasionally take up lots of the CPU (cupsd, for instance, while processing a job). It's also worth noting that the X server runs as root, outside of the context of the graphical login session. The implications of this are pretty deep -- rendering, then, is done in one cgroup, while the applications running graphically are making the rendering calls from another cgroup.
I think what I'm trying to say is cgroups are no silver bullet, but they definitely have great potential.
(Also note that the info I've provided is about Ubuntu -- I make no claims that the above is how any of it works on any other flavor.)
[Edit: formatting]
2
u/tso Nov 18 '10
Do xorg still run as root? I thought that issue had been taken care of some time ago.
2
u/placatedmayhem Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 19 '10
Appears so...
$ ps -ef | grep X root 4181 4179 0 17:27 tty8 00:00:23 /usr/bin/X :0 -br -verbose -auth /var/run/gdm/auth-for-gdm-u3uoId/database -nolisten tcp[Edit: Sanitized output to protect the innocent.]
[Edit 2: I've just verified on another, just-installed 10.10 box and a Linux Mint julia box that this is the case.]2
u/JAPH Nov 19 '10 edited Nov 19 '10
it depends on the setup, and who starts X. X will almost always be run as root. X can be made to run by a normal user though.
edit: now with less herp derp.
1
1
u/SEMW Nov 19 '10
The first step, moving modesetting into the kernel, has now been completed, but there are still hurdles to be passed before X can run not as root. See this LWN article from September.
1
Nov 19 '10
Does the recommended 'if then' for .bashrc stop X from running in it's own cgroup?
3
u/placatedmayhem Nov 19 '10
Nope. The if/then is testing for a non-zero-length $PS1. Glossing over some shell scripting nuances, this is an easy way to test for an interactive shell (like in a terminal window) versus a non-interactive shell (such as when bash is working as a script interpreter).
3
Nov 19 '10
I am using the hack and only see the PIDs for the gnome-terminals I currently have open (not X's PID) in /dev/cgroup/cpu/user/.
Thus my thoughts that the profile sourcing you outlined was done from a non-interactive shell perspective.
1
u/placatedmayhem Nov 19 '10 edited Nov 19 '10
Assuming things are set up properly, one of the PIDs in that folder should be for gnome-session along with your bash processes.
If you logged out and logged back in at your X session, check to make sure your .profile is sourcing your .bashrc; if not, at the bottom of your .profile, you can add this:
# if running bash if [ -n "$BASH_VERSION" ]; then # include .bashrc if it exists if [ -f "$HOME/.bashrc" ]; then . "$HOME/.bashrc" fi fi[Edit] WAIT WAIT! There's a problem. See my comment in this same thread (here). Let me know if that doesn't fix your problem.
1
Nov 19 '10
Thanks for the fix, but I am going to stay w/ the solution that's been tested on lkml.
If X isnt being run in it's own cgroup w/ the hack outlined by Lennart, I and everyone else reporting increased X responsiveness could be a placebo effect (assuming others are observing normal use case and not running intensive commands from terminal). Perhaps someone could run some app or X benchmarks to see if the improvement is real or not.
8
u/ObligatoryResponse Nov 18 '10
I just closed my tab, but the mailing list has some good comments. Focus on Linus and Lennart and what was said immediately before and after them.
Basically, Lennart argues that you are correct. The entire desktop runs in 1 tty. Each terminal emulator (or tab in a term em) you run gets its own pty. So if you open a term and launch your CPU intensive app, the patch (or the userspace method as written) will help.
The userspace method has a few advantages, primarily (imho) that it can be altered after the fact. In the commands, $$ is the PID of the shell, so each bash session is a group and the rest of X11 is a group by default. This is the same behavior as the patch (one bash per tty/pty, generally), but with the patch there's no fiddling. With userspace, you can move firefox to another group even if it wasn't started from a shell.
1
u/qrios Nov 19 '10
So does the user need to manually move things into certain groups?
2
u/ObligatoryResponse Nov 19 '10
If you setup bashrc (or equiv) as shown, no, as a group is created everytime bash runs and all children live in that group. This is roughly equivilant to the tty patch, except it will also group things that run on their own bash but not a tty (shell scripts launched by cron). You CAN manually group if you want though.
0
u/f0nd004u Nov 19 '10
There are terminals running behind X.
1
u/ObligatoryResponse Nov 19 '10
There's a tty behind X. ~/.bashrc is sourced by the login manager if you graphically log in. Not sure your statment is technically correct, but the result is the same.
2
u/ObligatoryResponse Nov 18 '10
That's what the patch does, and we either have to wait for OS updates to support it or patch our own kernels. Nightcoder is asking about the alternative to the patch (series of commands) which can be used immediately.
1
11
u/spif Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
EDIT: never mind, the Ubuntu instructions added to the article work for me, at least with the cgroup-bin package left installed. One thing I added was to do:
chmod a+x /dev/cgroup/
So you don't get a permissions error from df.
3
Nov 18 '10
Any links to an actual step-by-step for that? I think I follow but I'd like to be sure.
3
Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
Someone named Lsh e-mailed the author a howto for Ubuntu users and has been added to the end of the blog post.
2
Nov 19 '10 edited Nov 19 '10
Followed the steps, rebooted, not sure I see much difference yet. I'm hoping it helps with VMware Player and an XP guest I usually have running in the background. Seemed to have helped at first, but, now I'm not so sure. Oh well, it's definitely not worse (that I can see).
3
u/colinnwn Nov 18 '10
I don't know if this is a change from when you read it, but they are no longer suggesting /sys/fs/cgroup/ for Ubuntu, and they didn't change it to /mnt/cgroups/. Instead for Ubuntu, they are using /dev/cgroup/cpu/
Do you know which one would be better to use?
/dev/cgroup/cpu/
or
/mnt/cgroups/
Thanks.
6
u/nephros Nov 18 '10
Hmm, I'm not a fan of semi-random pseudo-filesystems mounted into /sys but still /mnt/cgroups feels just wrong.
2
u/tj111 Nov 18 '10
Is this in addition to the comments in the article about using in Ubuntu, or was that part added after this comment?
7
27
u/ericje Nov 18 '10
finally, restart the computer.
no
3
u/ascii Nov 18 '10
Heh. I just sourced the rc.local. Works just fine. I guess telling somebody to reboot is easier, by like five key strokes or something.
2
u/flukshun Nov 18 '10
i think you'll want to restart gnome or whatever you use at least, or at least the apps you/terminal you already had running
2
u/placatedmayhem Nov 19 '10
Yup, run the /etc/rc.local then log out and log back in.
1
u/ascii Nov 19 '10
Does gdm bind a tty to every session? If not, I fail to see what the difference it would make to log out and in instead of just closing the old terminals.
1
u/placatedmayhem Nov 19 '10 edited Nov 19 '10
It is supposed to work... in practice, I'm seeing something else with the default dot files. I'm looking at the problem right now.
[Edit] Yup, there's totally a problem. See my comment in this same thread (here).
10
u/smithzc Nov 18 '10
I'll just leave this here... http://imgur.com/SHAHe
8
u/williadc Nov 18 '10
So you're running a webserver with 3 years of kernel vulnerabilities?
7
u/smithzc Nov 18 '10
This just happens to be a spare server used for monitoring, and it's on a private network. Our client's are in charge of the upkeep on this... i just found it interesting that the uptime was so high.
0
Nov 18 '10
[deleted]
4
u/smithzc Nov 18 '10
Lol, I was expecting an article... But hey if they're willing to drive to upstate New York and break into the facility to get at this server... go at it.
1
u/Edman274 Nov 18 '10
"Hackers don't give a fuck that you're running your browser as root"
Uh, what? Is it because they can get root when you're running it not as root, or because...? whatever
4
u/tedivm Nov 19 '10
Reload or refresh the page- it spits out random crap, so it wasn't meant to be a direct reference to this discussion.
2
u/Edman274 Nov 19 '10
I know, but it's funny to note in general. I know what it is, there are a lot of websites with this meme (what the fuck is my security strategy, what the fuck is my mission statement) and it's funny that someone would write that particular line
19
2
u/coned88 Nov 18 '10
can I ask what you get out of that? I see so many people flauting their uptime as if it is something to be proud of. I restart my computers and production servers every chance I get.
6
u/smithzc Nov 18 '10
Uptime is nice for SLA's, especially when you're dealing with a medical application used in the ER... downtime has to be scheduled at odd hours. And this particular server is used for monitoring, so it doesn't get touched much.
1
1
3
u/superwinner Nov 18 '10
Works good, things seem a little snappier. I had a very snappy system before so its tough to notice, mostly it makes opening folders quicker and scrolling long web pages (like reddit) faster/smoother.
Now if I can only get some of my games working I can get off windows at home totally. Am I think only one who cannot get a single newer game running in Wine?
4
Nov 18 '10
I at least got Starcraft 2 working wonderfully in Wine...
2
u/ajayrockrock Nov 18 '10
Oh crap, say it's crappy please. Otherwise I'll get nothing done.
1
Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
Haha, well its not PERFECT. I think on my friends PC it played on Ultra in Windows and something like High in wine. But I don't think I had his linux nvidia drivers up to date so that could be different. Otherwise, it runs with no problems.
All I did was install it and then:To get sound, start winecfg, go to DLL overrides, add "mmdevapi" and set it to "disabled".
For more info, if you need it, check this relevant wine appDB link
1
u/authorblues Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
ive got the opposite problem. i have a hard time finding games that WONT work in Wine. which games are you having a hard time with? appdb.winehq.org covers most of the gotchas, if you arent in the mood to figure it out yourself.
E: fixed the link
5
u/russdot Nov 18 '10
Do you mean appdb.winehq.org?
1
u/authorblues Nov 19 '10
yes. i opted not not check that url. it was totally just a guess. i knew the page was called appdb. thats enough, right?
2
u/superwinner Nov 18 '10
Like out of the box, or you have to do a bunch of reg editing and tweaks? Incidentally I have an ATI 4870 card, not sure if thats the problem.
1
u/authorblues Nov 19 '10
actually, almost no tweaks necessary for anything. a tiny number of regedit tweaks for a few games to fix some mouse issues, and i use PlayOnLinux to handle wineprefixes (i HIGHLY encourage wineprefixes), but most stuff is just standard Wine.
ill admit that sometimes i have to monitor what version of wine i am using for some programs, because older versions will work better than newer releases. this is a bigger problem in archlinux, where rolling release mandates that i might get some less stable versions.
2
u/sawu Nov 18 '10
Football Manager 2011 has been killing me for the past few days. Though my computer seems to be in the minority and most people can get it working.
1
u/authorblues Nov 19 '10
ive had some inconsistencies between what i am able to do and what appdb suggests sometimes. general rule, however, is that if its possible to run it at ALL in wine, itll be on appdb, and i trust their ratings.
1
Nov 19 '10
I wish I could get Continuum and ReVolt running in Wine... I can't even get ReVolt running in Vista. I think newer games are probably easier to get running in Wine than older ones.
1
3
u/hbalagtas Nov 18 '10
I followed the steps here http://blog.glock.co.za/cgroup-user-space-speed-patch and tried it on Ubuntu 10.04 and 10.10 and the steps worked ok.
It does seem to have made my desktop snappier... it could just be the placebo effect kicking in.
3
u/Croooow Nov 18 '10
I wonder whether libpam-cgroup would be a more elegant solution than the shell configuration hackery.
2
u/placatedmayhem Nov 19 '10
I've looked at this a little and it looks promising but the documentation for it sucks out loud. Maybe if I get motivated over the weekend, I'll figure this out and write some up.
2
u/dhavalgiani Nov 19 '10
I would much appreciate it if you would take some time to update the documentation and send the patch to us.
1
Nov 18 '10
me too
2
Nov 19 '10
"Control Groups provide a mechanism for aggregating/partitioning sets of tasks, and all their future children, into hierarchical groups with specialized behaviour. . This PAM module will move a user session into an existing cgroup by attempting to match uid and gid against the defined cgroup rules configuration."
I think it does... o_O
2
u/Tobblo Nov 18 '10
I can't see any difference on my system.
1
u/flukshun Nov 19 '10
my rough test was to start up a couple terminals running
top -d .001have those terminals in view along with a browser and an extra terminal.
then the scientific part: "draw" a bunch of crap on your screen by frantically moving the terminal all over the place. also, visit a "heavy" website with firefox and do some rapid scrolling up/down by dragging the scrolling.
you should get some easily noticeable "ghosting" from the window dragging and pauses with scrolling firefox.
try the same with using separate cgroups and you should see a difference in responsiveness, particularly with firefox.
im sure there's better tests but this was pretty convincing at least on my setup.
for "normal" stuff i doubt you notice much, except maybe if you're multitasking with some youtube videos open.
2
Nov 19 '10
you should get some easily noticeable "ghosting" from the window dragging
That depends on not running a compositor. It won't happen with one due to the way redrawing the screen works.
1
2
u/ferk Nov 19 '10
Running Archlinux, I get these errors: mkdir: cannot create directory /sys/fs/cgroup/cpu/user/20474': No such file or directory bash: /sys/fs/cgroup/cpu/user/20474/tasks: No such file or directory mount: mount point /sys/fs/cgroup/cpu does not exist mkdir: cannot create directory/sys/fs/cgroup/cpu/user': No such file or directory I do have a "/sys/fs" directory but there's no "cgroup" folder there. Running "locate cgroup" only returns some kernel source .h files.
2
u/formode Nov 19 '10
Also happens in gentoo.
1
u/nephros Nov 19 '10
doesn't work for
/sys/fsbut you can create a mount point (e.g./cgroups) and then do a mount -t cgroup cgroup /cgroupand it will work.
1
2
Nov 19 '10
For people getting an error in their terminal along the lines of:
mkdir: cannot create directory `/dev/cgroup/cpu/user/3249': No such file or directory
bash: /dev/cgroup/cpu/user/3249/tasks: No such file or directory 2
u/formode Nov 19 '10 edited Nov 19 '10
Psst. Your link doesn't work. :(
Nevermind! Adblock ate it.
1
Nov 19 '10
just clicked it and it worked. you have to wait for the page to completely load before it jumps to the right comment
1
2
2
Nov 19 '10
Didn't work on my Arch 64-bit system, there is no cgroup directory in /sys/fs
1
u/nalf38 Nov 19 '10
Same for me in Opensuse 11.3, but I suspect it's because I run my own custom slimmed-down kernel. I've never had a use for cgroups before, so I didn't compiled that option into my kernel. I'm curious enough that I'm going to recompile.
2
Nov 19 '10
I just use the stock kernel package, so I guess that Arch doesn't enable cgroups in their build.
2
u/placatedmayhem Nov 19 '10
There is a problem with the recommendation that this article makes with respect to the addition to the .bashrc. At the top of .bashrc (the default one on Ubuntu 10.10, at least), there is this line:
[ -z "$PS1" ] && returnThis line causes the rest of the .bashrc to not get processed. So, at gdm login, the graphical session doesn't get added to the cgroup. The following is a hacked version of the article's .bashrc section which should fix the issues with respect to graphical logins, but it MUST come before the aforementioned return line in your .bashrc:
if [ "$PS1" -o "$0" = '/etc/gdm/Xsession' ] ; then
mkdir -m 0700 /dev/cgroup/cpu/user/$$
echo $$ > /dev/cgroup/cpu/user/$$/tasks
echo 1 > /dev/cgroup/cpu/user/$$/notify_on_release
fi3
u/jbus Nov 18 '10
I installed this on Ubuntu 10.10 following the instructions for Ubuntu in the article and my laptop is much more responsive.
3
2
Nov 18 '10
interesting. would this have any benefit on a rooted android mobile phone with updated kernel?
10
1
1
u/nephros Nov 18 '10
Do cgroups do any good on single-core systems?
3
u/ascii Nov 18 '10
Yes. They're used by the scheduler to make sure that each group of processes get a fair slice of the CPU. This helps in cases where you have e.g. a build job consisting of dozens of processes competing for CPU with a single process trying to e.g. play some video or render a web site.
1
u/johnaman Nov 18 '10
What effect would this have on a real time kernel like puredyne, an Ubuntu Karmic derivative? My debian partition is currently broken for internet access over hacked wifi (only option right now). I don't want to try it if it will break something on my only (easy to work with) working wireless partition.
3
u/johnaman Nov 18 '10
is this just a stupid question then?
1
u/exlevan Nov 19 '10
I suspect that realtime scheduler doesn't support cgroups, so this must have no effect. However, I didn't find any evidence that kernel is realtime on puredyne site. Are you sure it is? Because all I see is "realtime audio and video processing" and "low latency kernel", and low latency doesn't imply realtime.
Anyway, the patch and this alternative only change latency of the system, not the way it works. I don't see any scenario for breaking your system this way (except some unexpected kernel bug, which I think is unlikely).
2
1
u/johnaman Nov 19 '10
Thanks, I will give it a shot and report back here. And yes, it uses the realtime kernel although it sometimes seems to "hang" badly. % uname -a Linux jamon-laptop 2.6.31-9-rt #152-Ubuntu SMP PREEMPT RT Thu Oct 15 05:01:14 UTC 2009 i686 GNU/Linux
1
1
1
u/geocar Nov 19 '10
This seemed to be great at first, but it broke resume on my Dell Mini 9 (Atom) so I reverted.
If you use this, check everything to make sure you didn't make something subtly worse.
1
1
Nov 19 '10
But before doing that, read the whole thread. They test that the patch works by doing the bash thing itself and then added to the kernel.
1
1
1
Nov 19 '10
Has anyone tested this on Ubuntu 10.10 x64 running the 2.6.36 kernel instead of .35? Does the kernel version matter, or will this patch work on either kernel, regardless?
1
u/thedoge Nov 19 '10
For the first time, since I've installed the OS, Ubuntu is reading my battery life properly! I'm a noob to this kind of stuff, but I think this kernel patch fixed it somehow.
1
1
1
1
-2
u/icemaze Nov 18 '10 edited Dec 31 '15
EDIT: I removed all my comments and submissions in response to Jan 1, 2016 privacy policy update. I'm moving to that other site that rhymes with goat.
23
u/HopeThisNameFi Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
This patch is about a week old I think. The distros will definitely pick this up, but it will take some more time since the patch is against 2.6.37-rc2 (i.e. release candidate), and it won't hit the kernel until 2.6.38 since the 2.6.37 merge window is already closed. Some might backport it to 2.6.37 and 2.6.36 as well.
You can wait until your distro picks it up or do this manually if you don't want to wait.
2
u/superwinner Nov 18 '10
So once this is in the kernel, do I have to remove this patch?
12
u/mackstann Nov 18 '10
I'm confused. This is not a patch... this is an alternative to the recently-posted patch.
2
u/superwinner Nov 18 '10
So once the patch is in the kernel, will this alternative do anything? Should it be removed at that point?
1
u/exlevan Nov 18 '10
It will have no effect at that point and can be removed.
0
Nov 18 '10
Are you certain it will not have any ill effects if you have this alternative and the kernel patch?
1
u/exlevan Nov 18 '10
There will be almost no effect. In fact, you'll have two identical cpu groups for each terminal, which means you will have a bit worse, while still good, latency while you compile your kernel in 64 threads. (You can read what cpu groups are and how they can improve latency here.)
Of course, it's better to keep your system clean and to remove unneeded code at the point it becames, well, unneeded.
1
1
u/icemaze Nov 18 '10 edited Dec 31 '15
EDIT: I removed all my comments and submissions in response to Jan 1, 2016 privacy policy update. I'm moving to that other site that rhymes with goat.
7
2
Nov 18 '10
Probably because things get done when they are discovered, not before? This will eventually make it into new kernels. Plus, this alt 'fix' takes less than a minute.
2
u/adrianmonk Nov 19 '10
Because nobody needs to do this. It's a tweak that makes the kernel perform better in certain rare circumstances.
-6
u/inmatarian Nov 18 '10 edited Nov 18 '10
Con Kolivas recommends just doing this when you build, to get the same net effect as the Kernel Patch.
nice -19 make -j64Edit: I always get the signs wrong. On CK's blog, he might have also, or maybe I misinterpreted what he was trying to do.
3
u/pemboa Nov 18 '10
Doesn't really help with anything besides that singular command.
5
u/iamjack Nov 18 '10
And misses the point that the kernel build is supposed to simulate heavy load of normal processes not be an actual use case...
6
Nov 18 '10
Imagine a ridiculous fantasy world where you have a web browser that runs each tab as a separate process, and each plugin on a page as a separate process, and the plugins are horribly bloated and pegging the CPU each. CK's BFS kernel patchset would let you have a smooth desktop even under this hypothetical scenario.
0
Nov 18 '10
Yeah... i'd like to see some measurements of that; ever measurement i've seen BFS has been beaten, hands down. Just sayin'
-4
u/inmatarian Nov 18 '10
Right, just like the Kernel patch!
3
u/pemboa Nov 18 '10
I believe the kernel patch is for heavy IO in general.
2
u/inmatarian Nov 18 '10
My understanding is that it splits I/O loads according to TTY, preventing one from wrecking havoc on the others. Which is great on multi-users systems, or for developers. Casual desktop users only use a single TTY (which X.org takes control of), so there's limited benefit to them.
I'm not sure how daemons are treated under the new patch.
2
u/f0nd004u Nov 18 '10
No, Kolivas reccomends not using the patch at all with BFS because he sees it as unnecessary. He wrote the patch already, but doesn't wanna scale it.
1
1
u/m1ss1ontomars2k4 Nov 19 '10
All that does is parallelize the job when you're compiling the kernel and renice it...I fail to see how this affects the performance of the kernel when you're using it, after it's compiled.
1
u/inmatarian Nov 19 '10
the nice command is the focus, not the make -j64 part. See, linus used make -j64 to demonstrate a severe i/o load, and the nice command tells the load to not be a dick about scheduling.
1
Nov 19 '10
nice -19tells the kernel "fuck you, my make job is more important than everything". You probably meant +19.1
u/inmatarian Nov 19 '10
Right, on Con Kolivas' blog, he uses -19, so I think he was demonstrating his script, not demonstrating niceness. But in either case, nice is still a good way to stop a process from stealing too much cpu time.
0
Nov 18 '10
[deleted]
4
u/ascii Nov 18 '10
You can very easily test that the correct cgroups have been created (theoretical test below), but actually checking if it makes a difference is a bit more involved (practical test below). Happy hacking.
Theoretical test:
Start up a few bash shells.
Type echo $$ in each of them. This will print out the process id of each bash instance.
Type «ls /dev/cgroup/cpu/user/» in one of the shells.
Make sure that for each PID in step 2, there is a corresponding directory in the directory listing in step 3.
Practical test:
Disable all your changes and reboot.
Download Linux kernel sourcecode.
Run «make -j 50»
From a separate terminal, start up your favorite movie in mplayer and check the FPS.
Enable all your changes and reboot,
Repeat steps 2-4. If the FPS is significantly higher, things seem to be working.
1
0
Nov 19 '10
[deleted]
3
u/throwaway-o Nov 19 '10
I don't get it. If you followed these instructions, then Rhythmbox and Dropbox and the Alt+F2 run box all are on the SAME cgroup, yielding you NO NET GAIN. So how can you make those claims?
0
Nov 18 '10
[deleted]
2
u/uh-hum Nov 19 '10
Fedora 8? Didn't Fedora 8 support end at the beginning of 2009?
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Time_based_release_schedule#Maintenance_Schedule
You should do a clean install of Fedora 13 or 14 - you're probably having some serious security issues that you are not aware of.
0
Nov 19 '10
[deleted]
3
u/uh-hum Nov 19 '10
Fedora dropped the term "core" from Fedora releases by 2007. The last Fedora core was in '06 (Fedora Core 6). Fedora support cycles last for 13 months. Given that Fedora core ended in '06 and Fedora 8 was released in 2009, how could you have an up to date system? Are you updating everything by yourself?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fedora_%28operating_system%29 http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Releases/Names
1
u/throwaway-o Nov 19 '10
No, it's not. The most up to date is Fedora 14. Do you perchance drive a DeLorean DMC?
1
25
u/mlk Nov 18 '10
I wonder if this isn't a study on placebo effect.