r/linux • • Sep 23 '18

Linux developers threaten to pull “kill switch”

https://lulz.com/linux-devs-threaten-killswitch-coc-controversy-1252/
4 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

25

u/Visticous Sep 23 '18

No it doesn't. The GPL is not revokable.

35

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

As Stallman said, just because you revoke your license doesn't mean that anyone else has to delete your code from their copies of the software.

Revoking the license is a useless formality. If it weren't, FOSS as we know it would be destroyed. It would be way more harmful than any shitty CoC.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

Just because it isn't mentioned doesn't mean you can just revoke the license any time you want. Any code released under the GPL 2 would still be covered by that license. At most all you can do is relicense your project to make any future releases covered by a new license.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

The FUD campaign is in full swing I see. It's almost like we're back in the 90s again.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

What was the outrage du jour of the 90's?

8

u/kcrmson Sep 23 '18

Sexual harrassment.

19

u/doctor_whomst Sep 23 '18

I have no idea how legal it would be to revoke code like that, but I understand that reasoning. If things ever get bad enough that people will get booted for being "yikes, so problematic and unsafe" or some other similar cultspeak argument, it's understandable that they don't want their code to be aiding an actual creepy cult.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

Any creepy cult can come along and make use of GPL licensed code. Ever heard of Red Star Linux?

And anyone who opposes said creepy cult can as well.

Retroactively revoking the license is not possible. It would completely destroy the concept of FOSS. It's disturbing to me how many supposed Linux users are ok with that, as long as it's in the name of their irrelevant politics.

6

u/audioen Sep 23 '18

IIRC, there is already precedent for code having been removed from kernel despite ostensibly being licensed under GPL because its author wished it removed from the kernel. Unfortunately, I don't remember what particular thing was removed, because it's some time ago and was something pretty minor.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

It was removed because Linus agreed to remove it, not because they revoked the license. No court would allow somebody to retroactively remove the license from code that was released under GPL 2, that would simply be insane.

8

u/Shrimpf Sep 23 '18 edited Sep 23 '18

This whole debacle is insane, how can a CoC like this be implemented that affects 80% of 2.5 billion smartphone users, not to mention millions of linux desktop users. Wouldn't you be more careful with those numbers, this is essentially one of the biggest form of influence a feminist movement has had since voting/working rights, shouldn't you ensure that it is a positive one?

22

u/MrAlagos Sep 23 '18

The vast majority of Linux contributors are paid by companies, work in a corporate environment, and if they are assholes or let their own (or colleagues') life get in the way of the work they'd get fired well before anyone complains of CoC violations.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

Linux is where it's at because politics can't affect shit about code that is already GPL. Even if the worst case scenario of these alarmist and paranoid crazies would happen, it would still only mean forking. Now stop spreading FUD.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

Git clone,

drop the CoC,

Include code from banished devs,

Tendies and Dew are safe.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

It doesn’t effect smartphone users. It effects far-right developers who can’t get along with human beings.

6

u/ypnos Sep 23 '18

Is there really any harm in the CoC by-itself? Using the CoC from these people doesn't mean the kernel developers/community have to further listen to them, or even consider their stupid suggestions at banning developers etc. Has there been any serious discussion in the kernel community to ban any single developer yet?

11

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

There's nothing wrong with having laws against raping people, on the other hand, people get criminalized on false accusations sometimes. This is what many fear regarding the CoC. You want to get someone out? Accuse them with something. Even if they get redeemed eventually, it takes time, during which work is lost, and reputation is ruined at the very least.

0

u/Matt07211 Sep 23 '18

Yea a CoC should be what can get you kicked out and not what you need to do to just stay in. I like Open source code collaborations because it's based on the person's technical skill and a total indifference to anything else, meaning that we honestly don't care what you identify as, your sexual preferences or any other shit other then your technical ability

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

[deleted]

-5

u/ypnos Sep 23 '18

So what? They have no merit and they will just be ignored.

•

u/Kruug Sep 23 '18

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion** - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite.

-4

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

What a shit fit. I really think this whole situation is being overblown, and I'm tired of this self victimizing nonsense by devs who ultimately will be fine. The CoC will not be used to persecute people for "having the wrong opinions". At most, it will be used to diminish or remove people from the community who actively make it more difficult for others in the community due to their assholery. And if it actually really goes all to shit, and I'm completely wrong, it's open source. Fork it. The community will survive if the CoC is the right thing to do with a more positive, inclusive environment, and it will survive if it's the wrong thing to do having learned a lesson along the way. People threatening to pull the kill switch are blowing the CoC WAY out of proportion and potentially damaging Linux as a whole more than any CoC related measure ever could.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

No they're not

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

[deleted]

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

There is a massive leap between "looking at bigotry in the Linux community with a more critical lens and taking action where appropriate" and spying on people on mass as a "preventative measure". They have no equivalency.

16

u/BaconCatBug Sep 23 '18

Except this is literally what the CoC is doing. I am surprised someone who actually knows what Linux is would be such a moronic SJW.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Kruug Sep 23 '18

This post has been removed for violating Reddiquette., trolling users, or otherwise poor discussion** - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended.

Rule:

Reddiquette, trolling, or poor discussion - r/Linux asks all users follow Reddiquette. Reddiquette is ever changing, so a revisit once in awhile is recommended. Top violations of this rule are trolling, starting a flamewar, or not "Remembering the human" aka being hostile or incredibly impolite.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '18

..how in the hell is that trolling?

5

u/Kruug Sep 23 '18

poor discussion