Thanks to everyone who engaged with my original post, https://www.reddit.com/r/lichess/s/c5gooVKA3L, including the skeptical comments. The post had initially gained some traction but after a few comments questioned my credibility, it was downvoted. I am making this post because I believe my issue is genuine, and even if I remain banned from Lichess, I am fully supportive of FOSS and it deserves to improve and be better. Please check out the previous post before reading this one, or at least the summary given below. I don't reply on these posts because I assume the initial comments will simply be accusations and ragebait and going on comment wars will simply be a waste of my time and energy. In case I feel any genuine arguments are raised I will respond in due time.
It is still depressing though that the most upvoted comment on the last post was "Just stop cheating". Everyone may agree Kramnik is crazy for his baseless accusations and fully in support of his victims but how many of the same people will the benefit of doubt to a random person making their case? Sure everyday people make similar posts but at least read through it once and you will see this post stands out.
u/Informal_Degree_3205 Asked for my chess com account. At the time I thought my arguments were enough but now I agree there should be something for credibility. But I cannot share my main chess com account. Chess is all I have and I am already banned from Lichess. If I get somehow get mass reported if this post goes viral and I'm banned on chess com too, I don't think I can survive that. What I can share is a secondary account: https://www.chess.com/member/jvolj
To be clear about what it is:
It is not my main account.
It's an account I made long ago for some reason but forgot about, whose ratings I recently built up by playing it a lot. I believe at least for rapid and blitz it is close to but still below my current strength.
It shows I'm a genuine ~2300-level player and the account age shows I have been involved with chess for a very long time. It does not prove I didn't cheat on Lichess, and I'm not claiming it does. This is simply for credibility.
I'm sure though some talented Redditors could still somehow find my main chess com account with the info I have given so far. But I hope it is difficult enough that they aren't motivated to do so. And I am still willing to share the main account personally to a Lichess mod, on the condition that they remove the flag on my account.s
u/International_Bug955 also suggested the chess com account "ValjeanChess" is mine because it was created around the same time as my Lichess account with the same username. It isn't mine. I can't prove a negative, but its ratings are far below mine, and I haven't check its games but I'm sure it is very different than mine.
Summary of the original post
I'm rated around 2300 on chess com and use Lichess sparingly, mostly for college events. I created a second Lichess account, ValjeanChess, to keep my opening prep away from friends who knew my old account, j34n_v4lj34n (created 2020, 355 games, rapid ~2290, 188 wins / 20 draws / 147 losses). Lichess's terms list hiding opening preparation as an acceptable reason for a second account. I used both accounts in the same period. Both appeal pages cite engine use as the reason, not multi-accounting.
ValjeanChess was flagged after 6 games. The two games I think triggered it had single-digit centipawn loss:
Both were quiet, strategic positions with little tactical danger. The evaluation stayed within about half a pawn until my opponent made one late error (Kg3 on move 48 in the first game, Nxe3 on move 29 in the second), and they resigned within a move or two. That pattern produces low centipawn loss without any assistance.
I deny using any assistance on either account. The appeal for ValjeanChess was denied as final, and Lichess says it won't discuss it further.
My issues with the process
A flag after 6 games of ordinary play. Low centipawn loss in quiet positions is expected, and a short ending is what a resignation after a blunder produces.
The old account was marked right after I linked it. Its appeal page says engine/computer assistance, not multiple accounts. It kept pairing with unmarked opponents until Oct 30 (7 games that day, all unmarked), and its next game, on Nov 2, was against a marked account. I can't see their evidence, but the sequence suggests the mark followed from my linking it in the appeal. If honesty about a second account gets your main account banned too, nobody has a reason to disclose.
A generic reply after a week. The denial was a template that mentioned nothing I wrote: not the games I linked and not my explanation. I can't tell whether they were looked at or whether the decision rested on the flag alone.
A lack of transparency. I understand detection methods have to stay secret. But with no explanation, an appeal looks the same whether it was reviewed carefully or not at all. A short note saying what was reviewed (not how) would help cheaters not at all and let people trust the process.
Lichess's contact page says that if an appeal is legitimate, they will lift the ban. I couldn't find a single verifiable public example of that, only secondhand claims. Moderation is volunteer-run with limited resources, which makes a transparent process more important, not less. Even an aggregate figure, such as how many engine-mark appeals are lifted each year, would reveal nothing about detection and would show whether appeals are genuinely reconsidered.
What I'm asking and my plan
Please look at both accounts for anything that looks off: https://lichess.org/@/J34N_V4LJ34N and https://lichess.org/@/ValjeanChess. If you think the evidence points the other way, tell me why. Specifics help more than "just stop cheating."
I won't create any more accounts, since I know that can count as ban evasion. I'm happy on chess.com and just wanted to give a FOSS platform a chance. I don't expect this to resolve anything. I'm posting it as a record, in the hope that someone eventually sees it and recognizes that the process needs improving.