r/legalphilosophy • u/[deleted] • Jan 28 '14
General Was Nazi Law ...law? | Between Law and Morals: The Hart-Fuller debate, 1958
From Wikipedia:
The Hart–Fuller debate was an exchange between Lon Fuller and H. L. A. Hart published in the Harvard Law Review in 1958 on morality and law, which demonstrated the divide between the positivist and natural law philosophy. (...) Hart took the positivist view in arguing that morality and law were separate. Fuller's reply argued for morality as the source of law's binding power.
It will be recalled that one of the issues at stake in the Hart-Fuller debate was how the post-Nazi German legal system should respond to heinous acts committed during the Nazi period and purportedly authorized by Nazi law. Hart argued that because these acts, however reprehensible, were lawful at the time they were committed, the only way that their perpetrators could be lawfully punished was through retrospective criminal legislation.
Fuller, by contrast, argued that Hart had too quickly conceded that the heinous acts in question were lawful. (...) Fuller’s contention ties into his general theory of law, according to which legal systems are not constituted by the mere existence of officials who share an internal perspective on what counts as a valid set of laws, but rather by an orientation —shared by officials and legal subjects alike— towards governing their interactions with one another in a manner that displays fidelity to the principles of legality, or, as Fuller sometimes called it, to the internal morality of law.
H. L. A. Hart, Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals (PDF)
Lon L. Fuller, Positivism and Fidelity to Law — A Reply to Professor Hart (PDF)
Nicola Lacey, Philosophy, Political Morality and History: Explaining the Enduring Resonance of the Hart-Fuller Debate (doc)
H. L. A. Hart also inspired the Hart-Dworkin debate, which was also "organized around one of the most profound issues in the philosophy of law, namely, the relation between legality and morality." The quote is from:
Scott J. Shapiro, The "Hart-Dworkin" Debate: A Short Guide for the Perplexed (PDF)
Also relevant:
Brian Leiter, Beyond the Hart/Dworkin Debate: The Methodology Problem in Jurisprudence (PDF)
Lon L. Fuller is also known for The Case of the Speluncean Explorers, a hypothetical legal case described as
"a microcosm of [the 20th] century's debates" in legal philosophy, as it allowed a contrast to be drawn between different judicial approaches to resolving controversies of law, including natural law and legal positivism.
Originally posted to /r/HistoryofIdeas.