r/learnpython • • Feb 27 '20

Thank you šŸ™ r/learnpython members

I just wanted to say a big thank you to everyone on here that takes the time to teach newbies like me how to code properly.

My journey into programming has been eye opening, especially when I need help understanding how to complete my course assignments.

This has been my experience so far:

StackOverflow - don’t ever ask questions until you are an expert or you’ll get verbally slapped. It’s like you are not worth their time.

Python Discord - people on the help channels seem like they know what they are talking about but don’t help much. Sometimes just like those on SO. In the recent past I asked the same question about 4 separate times and got nothing but dead air.

I’ve tried getting a tutor from Kijiji but all they want to do is complete your assignment for you and charge you $hundreds. I’m not going to learn that way.

This subreddit seems to be the only place I have found that gives me respect as a beginner and the help I need by providing suggestions. I don’t think I’ve ever felt degraded or dismissed.

So again, thank you to everyone who takes the time to help new programmers. šŸ»

534 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

56

u/kiwiboy94 Feb 27 '20

Stackoverflow teaches you how to ask a question properly. In college we are used to bombing questions without taking the initiative to solve it ourselves first. We expect the teaching assistant to spoonfeed us answers. We then carry over this self-entited mindset into our workplace and realise how inadequate we are.

If you look into those stackoverflow posts that got downvoted you will see common patterns.

  1. They asked a question that was asked before.

  2. They take no initiative to solve it themselves first before asking.

  3. They failed to describe their problems with a code example.

If we learn how to overcome all these issues, I do find stackoverflow to be a great site to ask questions. There are people willing to help us if we help ourselves first.

19

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

Yup this is so true. I do get annoyed when people ask me questions IRL when they’ve clearly put zero effort towards trying to solve it first. I can see how with anonymity on SO, the abuse just flies haha

13

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

I usually only ask questions after spending hours or days scrolling the internet. So when someone tells me I should google it first, my reaction at that point is to say F right off (although I bite my tongue).
I do realize that a lot of people don’t put in the time but I don’t think everyone should be lumped into the same bucket just because of the type/skill level of the questions.

Learning how and what to ask is something that comes after years of experience. I hope that happens to me.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20

I usually only ask questions after spending hours or days scrolling the internet.

Nobody knows you actually did that though, even if you mention it they might be skeptical. You also have to realize, taking the time to figure out someone else's problem can be time consuming. I agree a comment like "google it first" does not offer anything though. But just because one person makes a comment like that, doesn't mean you should lump them into the same bucket, just like you are asking to not be lumped into the same bucket of people not even trying to solve their own problem first.

And I'm not sure I'd agree with learning how and what to ask is something that comes after years of experience. If you can't grasp the problem you are having or how to properly explain the problem, then that problem isn't your biggest problem. People don't know what you are working on, if you want them to figure out what your issue is with just a few lines in a post, it also takes a lot more time for them to figure it out. Everyone should value the time others put in into helping them, so make it as easy as possible for them.

5

u/drewatjuniper Feb 27 '20

There have been times that by thinking about how to ask my question, I actually ended up solving my problem. It is true that you need to understand the actual problem you are facing if you want a good answer.

4

u/jdnewmil Feb 27 '20

This.

Turn about is informative. Try answering some poorly worded questions and you will learn what it is like to answer something the OP didn't think they were asking but their question was unclear and you get slapped for not being helpful. You start wanting to see a record of all those things the OP did first so you can diagnose the issue correctly, and grumpy when they spring it on you later.

4

u/kiwiboy94 Feb 27 '20

Yes, don't get discouraged by what people say. People are often so scared to ask questions because they are worried of getting criticised. How I deal with it is to categorise them into constructive criticism (feedback that guide you to the right path) and destructive criticism ("Oh you should just quit", "maybe you should pay more attention in class and stop posting your homework question here"). You do see a mixture of both in any post and the most important thing is to not get affected by those unhelpful comments. I have been through that but I was lucky enough to encounter a long time user that come by to answer my question and encourage me to participate. That regains my lost faith about that site and ever since I have been repaying that favor to those in need.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

When asking, be sure to state clearly what you’ve tried, what didn’t work and steps you took to remedy it.

6

u/sky_badger Feb 27 '20

This is exactly right. With no reflection at all on OP, queries on SO fall into two broad categories:

  1. I'm stuck (and often late with an assignment!), can you do this for me?

  2. I'm stuck. I've done some research and tried A, B, and C. I think I'm on the right track with X, but my code doesn't work -- here's the code:

Only one of these approaches is going to get a positive response!

2

u/vixfew vixfwis Feb 27 '20

Heh. I once asked a question on SO, answer to which could be 1 word: downcasting. But I put a complete code example with explanation what I expect to get. Someone answered that and I felt really dumb about the question ą² _ą²  but no downvotes or anything. Maybe I got lucky, but I want to believe ĀÆ_(惄)_/ĀÆ

2

u/ElllGeeEmm Feb 27 '20

No, you asked the question properly, and so you got a response. 99% of the complaints about stack overflow are due to people not understanding how the platform is intended to be used.

4

u/Vortetty Feb 27 '20

I’ve tried getting a tutor from Kijiji but all they want to do is complete your assignment for you and charge you $hundreds. I’m not going to learn that way.

that is how a lot of tutors are, they just want to get it over with.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

Ya that’s not tutoring.

2

u/Vortetty Feb 27 '20

But in my experience that is what happens

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

Lol I know. Every person I was in contact with offered the same thing. No thanks. I’ll never learn that way.

3

u/WhatDaHellBobbyKaty Feb 27 '20

I have never asked anything on Stack Overflow. Most of my questions have already been asked. I do see a lot of snippy asshole responses to some questions. On the other hand, I see people that want a whole project done for them or things that can be found in a search. I am also interested in Raspbery Pi projects and you get the same thing there. I actually have a folder of bookmarks for all the places I can find answers for Python. One site that I find good info when I have questions and thats RealPython.com. They have tons of info and forums. Some is behind a pay wall but lots of it is not. I actually really like their Pythonista Cafe.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20

Thank you so much for this recommendation. I signed up for RealPython and already got tremendous help.

2

u/WhatDaHellBobbyKaty Feb 28 '20

I'm really happy to hear that. The guy that runs it, Dan Bader, is very cool. When I first found the site, I had an issue about the sectioning of the site or osmething like that and he emailed and chatted wiht me personally til it was sorted out. I like his tutorials and videos. I think I need to jfollow his stuff more and cut back a little on other sources. Take care. May the Py Be With You.

3

u/WhatDaHellBobbyKaty Feb 27 '20

I forgot to say that I really really love this forum. On top of great Python advice, you have truly been encouraging. I have wanted to give up several times and there was a time 2yrs ago that I didn't even look at it. I had to have a major surgery which scarred me for life physically and mentally. The medications affected my memory and cognitive skills for many months and I felt like I'd never want or get to start over again. I'm so glad to have found this sub and heard y'all's stories and lessons. Thank You.

81

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

StackOverflow: pay the price and learn how to ask/answer. I have a top 15% rating and I still get abused.

23

u/Legorooj Feb 27 '20

Yup. I'm in the top 10% best answers 2019, and well... Stackoverflow needs more people who know stuff. It's running out.

16

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

Stack Overflow is a highway, it's where you go to get from A to B fast. It's not the parking lot where you learn how to drive stick shift. Once you get a little better at framing questions, demonstrating the actions you've taken leading up to where you got stuck, people will be more helpful. I remember my first SO question, felt like I rolled down my window on the highway in a traffic jam, asking for directions. Everyone and their mom hurled hate handgrenades at my face.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

I have a colleague who got banned for 3 days for not asking a question properly.

20

u/AS1272 Feb 27 '20

reddit subs have been the most helpful place in my experience as well. big thanks to all the participants here!

16

u/pmacking Feb 27 '20

Agreed, kudos noble strange nerds

1

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

I ask some really obvious questions on stack overflow but never have gotten any sass or negativity.

They've been super helpful over there, just like here.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

You’re either not a beginner, great at asking questions or just plain lucky. Whatever it is I’m glad you’ve had a better experience.

3

u/125RAILGUN Epic noob at programming Feb 27 '20

Stack Overflow: First become a master at python, then get huge amounts of reputation, they you can ask the question you wanted to ask 20 years ago.

1

u/rmpr_uname_is_taken Mar 03 '20

And get ignored because you have too much reputation, so it must be a too serious issue.

2

u/angyts Feb 27 '20

Actually. Learning how to ask questions should be a class module by itself.

From the style of writing to the styling of the text and giving all the relevant information. And sometimes by the time you do that you probably figured out the problem. So yeah. Which is why you get RTFM as a response most of the time.

2

u/sgthoppy sgtlaggy Feb 27 '20

Often when I see people get no replies, it's because helpers or others who may know about the topic aren't around at the time (I see you've experienced that here as well), or may not know how to answer the question with the information given.

Looking at your posts about your CSV issue, a couple things could help you receive better help in the future.

Along with code, include the expected behavior and current behavior. For example, you would note the expected behavior being the CSV file is edited with the selected row modified, while the current behavior is the file not being edited at all.

Ask more specific questions, though this may be difficult for beginners, as you may not know where the issue actually lies. For example, instead of "How to update a row in a csv file using user input," maybe ask, "How to update a row in a csv file."

2

u/UnavailableUsername_ Feb 27 '20

StackOverflow - don’t ever ask questions until you are an expert or you’ll get verbally slapped. It’s like you are not worth their time.

Seriously?

My experience is the opposite.

As long as i format my post like they require, i only get helpful, polity replies.

1

u/UnicornWithTits Feb 27 '20

People abuse on StackOverflow ! omg.

(I have never asked question there, most of the time my problems already been asked, I am a beginner too)

And yeah, this is the best community on reddit <3

1

u/oblivion-age Feb 27 '20

I've just learned to not be reliant upon others in life in general. Everyone is self-serving whether they want to think so or not. Even so, I am willing to help anyone in any way I can and answer any question I can (I'm new to this so I can't yet), but anything else I have experience in I won't disregard a question.

You learn by asking, and I understand you need to supply proper info in the question, but one can just request that instead of being a prick about it y'know. Once you ask, need to supply more info, then you SHOULD be prepared next time you ask, if you learn from that error.

1

u/lolslim šŸTelegramšŸ¤– Feb 28 '20

This is how I felt with arduino stuff, if I went to their forum I felt like im wasting their time, they always slapped me with "that sounds illegal, get out of here criminal" (it was to read amiibo's NFC)

1

u/jorvaor Mar 09 '20

wait, that's illegal.

/jk

1

u/lolslim šŸTelegramšŸ¤– Mar 09 '20

I never continued on the project

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

[deleted]

1

u/sentientoverlord Feb 27 '20

It's hackerrank a valuable source for knowledge

0

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20

I try to do so since explaining things also helps me solidify my understanding

This. Also, even think you are correct but when it turns out you aren't, someone else might chip in and correct you, helping your understanding in the process.