r/learnpython • u/CryptographerEven268 • Sep 05 '23
1. Should I learn programming in 2023+?
Should I learn programming in 2023+?
Im just wondering if its worth to learn it and do some projects, I dont have tech uni and since chatgpt was released you ask it for stuff and it shows you code and even tell you where you have a mistake in code which is big turn off for me, so I want to ask some pros if its really worth start learning it if I would possibly want to get a job somewhere
7
u/SagattariusAStar Sep 05 '23
AI is nowhere close to be able writing a fully fletched programm with UI and functional output. As said before, it can help for specific tasks or maybe even small outputs, but still you should know what it is doing to change stuff according to your vision.
So yes, if you can use it personally (to optimize recurring tasks, just having fun with game development, writing own apps for personal use) go for it.
But from starting programming to getting a job? That's a huge jump. Maybe just start first, see if you like it, train your skills and then you can think about getting a job.
-6
u/CryptographerEven268 Sep 05 '23
thank you for your comment, I am currently learning https://programming-22.mooc.fi/part-2/3-combining-conditions and I was shocked CHATGPT was able to write me code and even tell me wheres mistake so i was wondering if its worth to learn, I have lot of time rn so I would like to finish this one and move to something different. What do you think should be the next step? I was thinking of doing this course, where they made it into career path: https://www.codecademy.com/learn/paths/bi-data-analyst
2
u/SagattariusAStar Sep 05 '23
It depends what you want. Programming is such a wide field, if you are interested in Data Analysis, go for it, otherwise i would say check out what else can be done with programming by starting small projects on your own. Maybe you will find your passion elsewhere.
0
Sep 05 '23
[deleted]
1
u/SagattariusAStar Sep 05 '23
I just use ChatGPT for concept reasearch and less for code generation and there it was quite reliable.
There are some videos which purely used AI to make small games, it is possible though, but the same stuff could have been archived by someone with a week of programming experience and two weeks of time.
7
u/KingsmanVince Google YOUR questions and errors first Sep 05 '23 edited Sep 05 '23
since chatgpt was released you ask it for stuff and it shows you code and even tell you where you have a mistake in code which is big turn off for me
since cars or any kind of transportations were released, you use them to travel from point A to point B and even have GPS to make sure you go in right way, which is big turn off me (people who love walking).
If we recommend you not to learn programming because of chatgpt, you won't see people being active in this sub.
-8
u/CryptographerEven268 Sep 05 '23
thank you for your comment, I am currently learning https://programming-22.mooc.fi/part-2/3-combining-conditions and I was shocked CHATGPT was able to write me code and even tell me wheres mistake so i was wondering if its worth to learn, I have lot of time rn so I would like to finish this one and move to something different. What do you think should be the next step? I was thinking of doing this course, where they made it into career path: https://www.codecademy.com/learn/paths/bi-data-analyst
7
u/mitchthebaker Sep 05 '23
I’d start learning how to program but it takes a while to go from novice to job ready. I’d ease into it, learn over the next few months to a year and really get a good grasp of what field you’d like to break into. Keep your current job but keep this as a goal in mind and keep working towards it if you’re serious. There’s definitely demand for programmers if you’re good.
Btw results from chatGPT are more often than not confidently naive. It gives an answer to any prompt you enter but the answers are almost always invalid. It becomes useless when you’re working in a large codebase with complex functionality.
-7
u/CryptographerEven268 Sep 05 '23
thank you for your comment, I am currently learning https://programming-22.mooc.fi/part-2/3-combining-conditions and I was shocked CHATGPT was able to write me code and even tell me wheres mistake so i was wondering if its worth to learn, I have lot of time rn so I would like to finish this one and move to something different. What do you think should be the next step? I was thinking of doing this course, where they made it into career path: https://www.codecademy.com/learn/paths/bi-data-analyst
7
u/Diapolo10 I write code for a living -- https://github.com/Diapolo10 Sep 05 '23
The short answer is, yes, absolutely. Especially if you are genuinely interested in programming.
Large language models, like GPT, can be used to generate simple programs in popular languages, but they're unable to do that for anything slightly complex. But let's assume you're right, and they can some day write whatever programs we desire - someone still needs to write the prompts, and if you want the end result to be something specific you have to be very specific with your prompt.
Here's the kicker; that prompt is essentially just you treating the LLM as a transpiler, and you're programming it with the prompt. In other words programmers would still be needed, even if their job was delegated to writing prompts.
It's worth noting that personally I'm not really buying into this AI hype in the first place. I don't expect my job to change drastically in the next two decades, other than from writing increasingly more Rust code.
3
u/Alternative_Driver60 Sep 05 '23
Sure, but only if you like it. You cannot learn and be good in anything that is not fun. Programming can be great fun!
1
u/AdDowntown6609 Sep 05 '23
And that generated code would have plenty of errors check that yourself someday
1
u/Erik_Kalkoken Sep 05 '23
Generative AI can only help with already solved problems, but it can not solve new problems or deal with new technologies. (e.g. it has to be trained on existing answers from Stack Overflow for those solutions).
If you ask it about a topic it does not know about, it will make up a solution that looks right, but does not work.
So until humanity invents AGI we will still need human software developers and a lot of them.
1
u/Fawzee815 Sep 05 '23
No, all of our jobs are going to be phased out by AI very soon. Straight up no point. /s
1
1
u/Initial_Awareness_15 Sep 05 '23
Python will soon be coming to Excel, I think even getting a general understanding of the language and the potential use cases could serve very well even for non coding specific jobs.
1
u/oida__ Sep 05 '23
in the last decade, programmers have constantly joked about how programming is mostly googling. now it's turning to becoming mostly chatgpt-ing.
also, learning to code will actually help you get better at writing better prompts for chatgpt so it can actually do exactly what you want it to create.
1
u/dogfish182 Sep 05 '23
I use ChatGPT all the time for coding, i just write more code faster now and can have it quickly explain boiler plate stuff (or generate it).
It’s confidently wrong all the time and works mostly as a good rubber duck, you can’t actually just turn in work
1
1
u/brotocarioca Sep 06 '23
Chat gpt only works if you already know what to do with it.
2
u/tonsvz Sep 06 '23
Yeah, but most people who are saying "Bruh, dont learn to code" are the ones that thinks that chat gpt works like "Hey gpt, make me an awesome website to impress my bosses and bitches."
1
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Nov 19 '23
Nope. AI can't build projects. As others say, it's a tool for real developers to use. It can make them better and faster. One person will be able to work 10x faster. Unfortunately that means for each person, 9 others aren't going to be needed anymore. Not worth it.
1
u/goodbalance Sep 05 '23
you must be passionate about it. programming is not something you learn once and use until you retire or die, like operating a forklift or something. more so, you can't really learn programming, you can just get a bit ahead of others, and there is no "end". comparing programming with human history, I'd say we, the developers, are on the level of rock painting.
to answer your question directly: no, you should not. indeed, you can make a buck, but you won't get far and it will annoy you sooner or later. you will notice you're doing something you're not interested in and it will eat you from inside, to the point where you will abandon your shitty job and will cry about wasted years. just like with anything else you are not passionate about.
3
Sep 05 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/CryptographerEven268 Sep 05 '23
thank you for your comment, I am currently learning https://programming-22.mooc.fi/part-2/3-combining-conditions and I was shocked CHATGPT was able to write me code and even tell me wheres mistake so i was wondering if its worth to learn, I have lot of time rn so I would like to finish this one and move to something different. What do you think should be the next step? I was thinking of doing this course, where they made it into career path: https://www.codecademy.com/learn/paths/bi-data-analyst
45
u/shiftybyte Sep 05 '23
Current generative AI isn't reliable enough to do code without a professional checking output.
So you can treat it just like another tool in the programmer's tool belt.
Programmers are still needed for their reasoning, problem solving, and creativity, and the ability to deal with code longer than 3 functions...