r/learnjavascript • u/SlaimeLannister • Sep 03 '20
"JavaScript: The Definitive Guide" by David Flanagan is so damn good
The 7th edition just came out last month. He is so systematic about his explanations and terminology, and the way he builds the reader's understanding of Javascript from the ground up. Highly recommended reading. I understand the language so much better since I started reading this book.
2
u/Key-Object-4657 Dec 29 '21
1 year later. I wanted to ask you if is this book recommended for beginners. I'm doing the freecodecamp course and i'd like to complement it with this book. Thanks.
4
u/SlaimeLannister Dec 30 '21
I think so. Think of the book as a complete map of JavaScript. I read it cover to cover, and then returned to particular sections over time. Even if you don’t read it all the way through, it’s helpful to read the section that is relevant to what you’re learning in freecodecamp.
If you want something light that covers the basics, this book might be overkill
1
6
u/agnarrarendelle Sep 03 '20
Is his book better than those video tutorials on YouTube/Udemy? I have been thinking about switching to books after having gone through several tutorials
8
u/BeefaloRancher Sep 03 '20
Not related to JS but I did this with C#. I find books take the time to explain everything in a lot of depth compared to tutorials which try to find the easiest way to explain things. Obviously every person is different, so if books aren't your thing it's not the end of the world. Books are just a good way to better understand the finer details tutorials often miss.
5
Sep 03 '20
You've gotta check out the beta edition. It's such a trip that I had to buy a new copy when I lost my original in a move.
5
u/snailiens Sep 03 '20
Can you elaborate on this? What do you find special about the beta edition?
I hadn't heard of this and would certainly pick up a copy if you recommend it.
4
Sep 04 '20
I was sort of kidding, but also not. I was referring to the first edition of the Definitive Guide to Javascript (1996).
It's wild to look through to see how much Javascript has changed (and how much hasn't). And also how little it was understood. I haven't read most of it in well over 20 years, but I'm pretty sure closure is never discussed, definitely not by name.
Don't read it to learn Javascript, because it's not good for that anymore. But it's a fun thing to flip through if you're a huge nerd. 😜
Just look at this thing, it says "Netscape 2.0" on the cover. It's awesome!
1
u/snailiens Sep 04 '20
Gotcha, I had a feeling this is what you meant. I would probably really enjoy that. There's a book I read recently called "Racing the Beam" that goes into all the insane challenges developers had writing software for the Atari 2600. The history of pretty much all tech stuff is so fascinating.
I'll definitely pick up that book—thanks for the pointer!
4
4
u/nick17india Sep 03 '20
hey thanks. was waiting for this edition on ES6. Eloquent JS is also good.
18
u/nofapnot Sep 03 '20
I cannot for the life of me understand anything after first few chapters in Eloquent JS.
7
u/Enough-Nerve Sep 03 '20 edited Sep 06 '20
I agree. Eloquent JS is a very difficult book. The difficulty level ramps up from the WereSquirrel chapter.
5
u/kevinmrr Sep 03 '20
Yeah, I don't recommend Eloquent JS anymore.
EJS's quality has gone down significantly as editions progressed. The author got too clever. He confuses his readers by adding complexity into his elaborate examples, where the complexity doesn't serve any pedagogical value.
1
Jan 17 '21
lmao this is awesome...finally some people i can relate to i thought i was dumb or something
3
Sep 03 '20
I'm glad I'm not alone in this. I felt like maybe I was just an idiot because more than a few people recommended the book to me as a beginner book and I struggled to understand what he was talking about after the first few chapters. I'll probably give it another shot though here in a few weeks because it's been months since I stopped reading it and since then I've been following udemy courses and reading mdn to learn js, so at the very least I'll have some foundation to understand and not get as lost when reading it.
2
1
u/waldganger644 Sep 04 '20
Thanks for that relatable comment. I am having quite a hard time with the robot thing.
1
u/AlexRostyagai Dec 06 '23
is it helpful for beginners?
1
u/SlaimeLannister Dec 06 '23
Yes, it’ll give you strong familiarity with the language so that you can stop having to think about what the syntax means and focus on the logic of your applications
3
Sep 03 '20
Hi, I am from South America (Argentina) and buying this book it's pretty hard for me because two thirds of my salary goes to paying University. Does someone have a digital version of the first or two chapters or a demo to check out if its worth buying? Paying U$35 it's a pretty big investment for me so I have to make sure it's worth.
16
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/OCCDD Mar 09 '24
Yes, the book is really good, but it is tough to read. But still worth the efforts.
1
u/Mohitpal2621 Apr 14 '23
Yes, but there were times when it was difficult to follow. Like in the Classes chapter they kept using RegExs even though they hadn't introduced Regexs yet.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
How does it to compare to You Don’t Know JS Yet by Kyle Simpson?