r/learnjavascript • • Jun 27 '20

Gatekeeping programming

Post image
431 Upvotes

139 comments sorted by

View all comments

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '20 edited Jun 27 '20

Job interviews for a programming position IS gatekeeping . I don't see that as an issue in this specific context.

EDIT: For those downvoting would you be able to explain why? As an interviewer (not for software developers) I often ask the same questions as in the screenshot. Seeing the discussion so far I keep seeing the words exploitation and corruption, but I don't see how.

The position is for advertising and using Google's web software.

  1. What makes you passionate about advertising?

  2. (If worked in previous marketing agency) What did you to develop those skills when not at work or working on a ticket?

  3. Have you ever ran an ad campaign for personal use or for a friend, what did you learn from it?

The intent of this question is to see if someone has actual interest in the industry, and see if those people follow industry news, engage in the industry discussion etc. Am I making a mistake with these questions?

4

u/myevillaugh Jun 27 '20

For 2 and 3, yes. If one has a demanding job and family, they don't have time to do extra work for "fun". Why not ask them about an ad campaign that went poorly?

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '20

Usually we don't expect people to say they do extra work for fun because chances are it's a lie that is pandering to us. But various answers that we've heard before that we've liked was subscribed to industry news, follow google's blogs, following the facebook/slack group for our industry (extra points when they mention that because I'm on both), r/adops etc. Also I'm not expecting them to do only that in their off hours but if even if they mentioned that they browse those during the commute is enough for me.

For 3, if they answer know it's not a knock against them if they answer "No" but it can demonstrate if they can wear multiple hats.

Why not ask them about an ad campaign that went poorly?

We often ask this question along other questions questions like " outline in detail approaches you took to fix x .

2

u/myevillaugh Jun 27 '20

Well, if asked #2, I would assume the company doesn't train their own employees. If asked #3, I'd assume the company expects me to take on "+1's" for them.