r/learnjavascript • • Feb 06 '18

Draft of Eloquent JavaScript's 3rd edition is out

http://eloquentjavascript.net/3rd_edition/
62 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

15

u/SOLUNAR Feb 06 '18

This is the book that turned me off Js for a few months before finding better resources. Not kidding

7

u/Strongfatguy Feb 06 '18

The weresquirrel got another one!

1

u/Darknessflowers Feb 06 '18

This is how I feel. What were the better resources you used?

1

u/j00pY Feb 07 '18

Headfirst Javascript was a great book for a complete beginner in programming. It was the book that got me started on my way. Eloquent JS just killed me when I tried to understand it.

1

u/Cowgoesmo Feb 06 '18

Why is that?

10

u/theadammorganshow Feb 06 '18

Just from personal experience, I think people completely misrepresent the difficulty level of this book. It's not uncommon for me to see it recommended to beginners and that's just....wrong. It's a difficult book and I definitely wouldn't expect a beginner to be able to work through the problems on their own without any guidance.

I'm surprised it's recommended as often as it is. I'm not saying that it isn't a good book but there should be some expectations set upfront.

2

u/Cowgoesmo Feb 06 '18

Well I have to say I agree with you on this one. I to read multiple times that it's a good book for beginners but I kinda got stuck on 6th chapter (the one with objects and tables). The good thing is that I finished twitch project on FCC and I am now continuing with their exercises.

2

u/WolfofAnarchy Feb 07 '18

Jesus, are there no good beginner's books then? First people said You Don't know JS is a good one. Then people say no, it's too difficult, use Eloquent. And now you say this. Which books should I learn, then?

3

u/PrincessSmaug Feb 07 '18

Head First JavaScript was the catalyst for my learning. I had been trying to teach myself OOP for quite some time and every resource I used was too advanced for me to really understand what I was doing. I can't recommend HF JS enough for beginners. My fiance is a senior front end dev and I was able to teach him a few things after reading this! Everything is explained in conversational English with a ton of diagrams to aid understanding. It does not read like a textbook like most other resources.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18

Eloquent is good, so is YDKJS.

Here are the problems you will run into with them, as a beginner:

EJS's style is to go from topic to topic and ensuring you have a very solid understanding to continue. That's why it's hard. If you don't run every single code example through the console to make sure you really understand what is happening, it's going to be doubly hard.

YDKJS aims to give a reasonably deep understanding of a lot of things. That's great if you've been exposed to the language for a while so you're deepening or solidifying understanding of these things. Its wide exposure is great for a beginner, too, but it's also going to mean that not a lot of it sticks and at best you'll be using a vague memory of something you've read as a reference later.

The overwhelming majority of resources you encounter as a beginner will be absolute shit. At least half the time I spent studying when I started out was from resources I now hold contempt for and regret using. These two don't belong anywhere near that category. Of the two, YDKJS is going to be better for most people.

1

u/Simbaxo Feb 07 '18

is there any beginner book you would recommend?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18

Go with YDKJS. It's still exceptional.

1

u/wingraptor Feb 07 '18

I'd also interested to know what you'd recommend.

3

u/Cowgoesmo Feb 06 '18

I'm going through 2nd edition right now, I'll be happy to check this out.